Judicial Bench Book on Violence Against Women in Commonwealth
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
JUDICIAL BENCH BOOK ON VIOLENCE AGAINST WOMEN IN COMMONWEALTH EAST AFRICA Judicial Bench Book on Violence Against Women in Commonwealth The judiciary plays a central role in enhancing and protecting women’s rights, as well as the development and East Africa enforcement of formal legal responses to discriminatory and criminal activities, including violence against women (VAW). Commonwealth Secretariat The Judicial Bench Book on Violence Against Women in Commonwealth East Africa situates VAW in four member countries, Kenya, Rwanda, Tanzania and Uganda. By placing VAW within the socio-cultural and legal context of the region, it is hoped that the bench book will enhance the ability of judicial officers to handle cases of VAW, both within a human rights as well as a gender perspective. It is a quick reference for judicial officers, in line with the foundations of the common law system –stare decisis and judicial precedent. Through case law, the book discusses measures to address VAW and the role of the judiciary in ensuring that the state fulfils its obligations. It also includes examples of how a lack of appreciation of the lived realities of women victims of violence can lead to denial of justice. The critique of such cases will expose the injustice arising from failure to interpret the law through a gender lens, thereby offering important lessons to judicial officers. ISBN 978-1-84929-161-3 7818499 291613 P14952_COM_Judicial_Bench_Book_VAW_E_Africa_253x190.indd All Pages 20/12/2016 10:04:42 Judicial Bench Book on Violence Against Women in Commonwealth East Africa Commonwealth Secretariat Commonwealth Secretariat Marlborough House Pall Mall London SW1Y 5HX United Kingdom © Commonwealth Secretariat 2017 All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or otherwise without the permission of the publisher. Published by the Commonwealth Secretariat Edited by Editors4Change Ltd Typeset by NovaTechset Private Limited, Bengaluru & Chennai, India Printed by Views and opinions expressed in this publication are the responsibility of the authors and should in no way be attributed to the institutions to which they are affiliated or to the Commonwealth Secretariat. Wherever possible, the Commonwealth Secretariat uses paper sourced from responsible forests or from sources that minimise a destructive impact on the environment. Copies of this publication may be obtained from Publications Section Commonwealth Secretariat Marlborough House Pall Mall London SW1Y 5HX United Kingdom Tel: +44 (0)20 7747 6500 Email: [email protected] Web: www.thecommonwealth.org/publications A catalogue record for this publication is available from the British Library. ISBN (paperback): 978-1-84929-161-3 ISBN (e-book): 978-1-84859-955-0 iii Contents Foreword vii Acknowledgements ix Acronyms and Abbreviations xi Section I Judicial Principles on Violence Against Women 1 1 Introduction 3 1.1 The judiciary as an actor 3 1.2 Purpose of the bench book 5 2 Definitions of Violence Against Women 7 2.1 Introduction 7 2.2 Definition of VAW under international law Instruments 7 2.3 Definition of VAW under regional human rights instruments 10 2.4 Definition of VAW under national laws 11 2.5 Manifestations of violence against women in East Africa 14 2.6 Statistics of prevalence of VAW in East Africa 17 2.7 Consequences of violence against women 19 Notes 37 3 The Role of the Judiciary in Addressing VAW 40 3.1 Introduction 40 3.2 Direct judicial intervention in addressing VAW 40 3.3 Addressing VAW – The judicial process 42 3.4 Judicial guidelines in dealing with matters involving VAW 50 3.5 Addressing challenges 71 Notes 90 4 International Law Standards and State Obligations 94 4.1 Introduction 94 4.2 The status of international law and norms in the Commonwealth member countries in East Africa 94 4.3 State obligations under regional human rights treaties 124 4.4 Obligations under international criminal law 128 iv Judicial Bench Book on VAW in Commonwealth East Africa 4.5 National legal mechanisms 129 Notes 161 Section II Case Summaries on Violence Against Women 165 5 Domestic/Intimate Partner Violence 167 Case 5.1 Uganda v Jackline Uwera Nsenga 167 Case 5.2 Republic v Francis Paul 169 Case 5.3 Uganda v Lydia Draru Alias Atim 170 Case 5.4 Jackline Vidanya Baraza v Rep. 173 Case 5.5 David Munga Maina v Republic 177 Case 5.6 Prosecutor v Fatirakumutima 180 Case 5.7 Prosecutor v Cyuma Miruho 181 Notes 182 6 Sexual and Other Forms of Violence Against Children 183 Case 6.1 Uganda v Sekajija Asuman 183 Case 6.2 Uganda v Joseph Baluku 185 Case 6.3 Uganda v Kakuru Johnson 188 Case 6.4 Uganda v Peter Matovu 190 Case 6.5 Uganda v Tigahwa 192 Case 6.6 Uganda v NA 194 Case 6.7 Uganda v Rwishosha Geoffrey 195 Case 6.8 Prosecutor v Nihimbazwe Samuel 196 Case 6.9 George Hezron Mwakio v Rep 197 Note 200 7 Sexual and Other Forms of Violence Against Adult Women 201 Case 7.1 Leonard Jonathan v Republic 201 Case 7.2 Okeyo v Ogwayi 203 Case 7.3 Mukungu v Republic 204 Case 7.4 Uganda v Hamidu & Others 207 Case 7.5 Ally Hussein Katua v Republic 208 Case 7.6 Seif Mohamed El-Abadan v Rep 211 Case 7.7 Onesphory Materu v Republic 214 Contents v Case 7.8 Foro Yahaya v Uganda 218 Notes 220 8 Female Genital Mutilation 221 Case 8.1 Pauline Robi Ngariba v Rep 221 Case 8.2 SMG & RAM v Republic 224 Case 8.3 Law and Advocacy for Women in Uganda v AG 226 Case 8.4 Joyce Nakacwa v AG and 2 Others 229 Notes 232 9 Sexual Harassment in the Workplace 233 Case 9.1 Vishaka v Rajasthan & Others 233 Notes 235 10 Matrimonial Property 236 Case 10.1 Kivuitu v Kivuitu 236 Case 10.2 Nderitu v Nderitu 237 Case 10.3 Bi Hawa Mohammed v Ally Sefu 239 Case 10.4 Lawrence Mtefu v Germana Mtefu 243 Case 10.5 Gatera Johnson & Kabalisa Teddy v The Supreme Court 246 Notes 248 11 Divorce on Account of Violence 249 Case 11.1 Kirungi Doreen v Mugabe Ronald 249 Notes 251 12 Discrimination 252 Case 12.1 Ndewawiosia v Emanuel 252 Case 12.2 Rono v Rono & Another 254 Case 12.3 Re-Estate of Lerionka Ole Ntutu 257 Case 12.4 Stephen Gitonga M’Murithi v Francis Murithi 259 Case 12.5 JAO v Home Park Caterers 259 Case 12.6 Uganda Association of Women Lawyers & Others v the Attorney General 260 Notes 262 13 Discrimination at the Workplace 263 Case 13.1 George Opiyo and 2 Others v Deputy County Commissioner Gem, & Another (Siaya) 263 vi Judicial Bench Book on VAW in Commonwealth East Africa 14 Sexual Violence and Abuse of Authority/Trust 266 Case 14.1 WJ and LN (Minors Suing through their Guardians, JKM and SCM) v Astariko Henry Amkoah & Others and the Cradle and 3 Others (NBI) 266 Case 14.2 Prosecutor v Munyawera Moustapha 268 Case 14.3 Prosecution v Kazina Lucien 270 Case 14.4 CK (a Child) & 11 Others v the Commissioner of Police/Inspector General of the National Police Service, the Director of Public Prosecutions, Minister for Justice, National Cohesion & Constitutional Affairs and Kenya National Commission of Human Rights … Amicus Curiae 272 Annex 1 Child, Early and Forced Marriages in East Africa: The Role of the Judiciary 284 Annex 2 Additional Materials for Reference 327 vii Foreword The Judicial Bench Book on Violence Against Women in Commonwealth East Africa (Judicial Bench Book) is prepared by judges for use, primarily by judicial officers. The role of a judicial officer in handling a case of violence against women and girls (VAWG) is to ensure a fair trial. To that end, judicial officers need to apply the law, taking cognisance of the socio-cultural and other limitations that impact on the lives of women and girls and guide the actions of perpetrators. Judicial officers need to take leadership outside the courtroom and promote change in their respective societies. The Judicial Bench Book is the realisation of a vision that emanated from the Botswana Judicial Forum of 2013 which considered the review on the Commonwealth case law on VAW and discussed landmark judgements with a view to contributing to a strengthened jurisprudence of equality. The Judicial Bench Book sets out the definition of VAWG in international and regional human rights instruments and national legislation. It discusses the relevant international human rights standards with respect to VAW. These standards have been developed and further advanced by international and regional institutions, global fora and the work of the United Nations Special Rapporteur on Violence against Women, its Causes and Consequences. The Judicial Bench Book discusses the obligation of the State to eliminate VAWG through the exercise of due diligence to prevent and protect women from such violence, prosecute and punish perpetrators of such violence and to provide an effective remedy for victims of such violence. it further discusses, through case law, measures to address VAWG, and the role of the judiciary in realising the obligations of the State. The case law used in the Judicial Bench Book has enriched the final product and brought to the fore evidence of suffering that many women endure; however, through access to courts women can access justice while perpetrators are brought to account. The experience of the judiciary adds value to the contributions of new magistrates or judges on matters relating to courtroom procedure while also applying international human rights standards.