A Review of Passenger Rail Franchising in Britain: 1996/1997–2011/2012

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

A Review of Passenger Rail Franchising in Britain: 1996/1997–2011/2012 A Review of Passenger Rail Franchising in Britain: 1996/1997–2011/2012 John Preston Workshop on Tendering Transport Services Madrid, 19 May 2014. Outline Update of a paper in Research in Transportation Economics in 2008. • Brief History of Franchising. • Key Trends. • Key Issues: Competition, Objectives, Overoptimistic bids. • Franchising Futures. • Conclusions 2 A Very Brief History of Rail Franchising in Britain • First phase. 1996/7 – c2000. Associated with OPRAF. 25 TOCs franchised. • Second phase. c2001-2004. Associated with SRA. 9 TOCs (re)-franchised. • Third phase. 2005-12. Associated with DfT. 13 TOCs (re)- franchised. 2012. ‘Failure’ of West Coast Franchise and instigation of the Laidlaw Enquiry and Brown Review. • Fourth phase. 2014- 3 Development of the British Rail Franchises Original Franchise Type Development and Franchisees Present/Future Franchise 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 South West Trains Lon Stagecoach Stagecoach ? South Western Island Line Reg Stagecoach MTL was purchased by Arriva in 2000 Merseyrail Electrics Reg MTLArr iva Serco/Abellio Merseyrail 2008: Laing Rail, owner of M40, was purchased by DB Regio. 2011: Re‐organisation to Arriva UK. Chiltern Railways Lon M40 Trains M40 Trains DB Regio Arriva Chiltern Railways Connex South Eastern Lon Connex (Veolia) SRA Govia ? Integrated Kent New name: Northern Spirit MTL was purchased by Arriva in 2000 Franchise Regional Railways North East Reg MTLArr iva Serco/Abellio ? Northern North Western Reg First Serco/Abellio ? TransPennine New name: Wales & Borders Cardiff Railways Reg PrismNational Express Arriva ? Wales and Borders Prism was purchased by National Express in 2000 New name: Wessex Trains Wales & West Reg Prism National Express Great Western IC First First ? Greater Western Thames Trains Lon Go‐Ahead First Midland Main Line IC National Express Stagecoach ? East Midlands Some services to Central Trains Reg National Express New Cross Country New name: West Midlands North London / Silverlink Lon National Express Govia ? London Midland Some services went to ‘London Overground‘ franchise in 2007 New name: New Cross Country Cross Country IC Virgin Arriva ? New Cross Country West Coast Trains IC Virgin ? West Coast Scotrail Reg National Express First ? ScotRail Prism was purchased by National Express in 2000 New name: Essex Thameside LTS Rail Lon Prism National Express / c2c ? c2c/Essex Thameside Great North Eastern IC Sea Containers NEX East Coast ? East Coast GB Railways was purchased by First in 2003 Anglia Reg GB Railways Brand name ‘One’ New name: Greater Anglia Great Eastern Lon First National Express Abellio ? Greater Anglia Prism was purchased by National Express in 2000 West Anglia Great Northern Lon Prism National Express Thameslink, Southern Thameslink Lon Govia First ? and Great Northern Gatwick Express Reg National Express New name: Southern Publicly operated Connex (Veolia) Govia Govia Connex South Central Lon Re‐Negotiation / Cost‐plus contract Regional Long Distance London & South East 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017 2018 2019 2020 2021 Start of franchise contract Source: Schneider, 2013, after DfT 2013, Knowles 2004, Müller 2011, Nash/Smith 2007 British Rail Regulation 1993 ‐ Franchise rounds I II III IV 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2013 2014 OPRAF SRA Department for Transport DfT Franchising Act Act Office of Strategic Rail Passenger Rail Franchising Authority Railways Welsh Assembly Transport Transport for London Government Railways Act 1993 Regulation of fare levels 2000 Transport Scotland Merseyside PTE 2005 Shadow‐SRA SSRA Regionalised responsibility for some franchises Strategic planning Network Rail Railtrack ‐ Department for Act Public Members Transport facto placed into De Infrastructure manager alisation administration Renation Railways Privatised 1993 Office of Rail Regulation ORR Safety Regulation Rail Safety and Standards Board RSSB (since 2003) at Health and Safety Executive Act etc. and 1974 Work Safety Health Her Majesty's Railway Inspectorate Her Majesty's Railway Inspectorate Safety Inspectorate Act Office of the Rail Regulator Railways Transport Competition Act Monopoly regulation OFT 1993 Office of the International Rail Regulator Safety Commission Railways Office of Fair Trading and OIRR 2003 1994 1995 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2013 2014 ‘Moderation of Competition’ stages Open Access restricted to Open Access restricted to Case‐by‐case approach. Generally origin‐destination‐pairs 20% of a franchisee’s speaking: Open access services have to that constitute less than registered revenue flows demonstrate that they are not primarily 0.2% of a franchisee‘s – unregistered flows open abstractive but generative. It seems as if revenue for competition. the relevant threshold is that not more than 30% of the traffic is abstractive. Source: Schneider, 2013, after Knowles 2004, Müller 2011, Nash/Smith 2007, Nash/Smith 2011, Preston 2008 Trends: Passenger Kms 55 50 45 40 35 30 25 Passenger20 Kms 15 10 5 0 1981 1983 Data from ORR National Rail Tren 1985/6 1987/8 1989/90 1991/2 1993/4 1995/6 1997/8 ds http://dataportal.orr.gov.uk/Year 1999/0 2001/2 Passenger Kms (Billion Kms) 2003/4 2005/6 1995/6 – 00/1 +27% 2007/8 2001/2 – 04/5 +9% 2009/10 2005/6 Total +84% – 11/12 +33% Trends: Train Kms 600 500 s 400 300 Train Km 200 100 0 1981 1984 1987/8 1990/1 1993/4 1996/7 Year 1999/0 2002/3 Train Kms (Millions) 2005/6 2008/9 1995/6 – 00/1 +21% 2000/1 – 04/5 +7% 2005/6 – 11/12 +13% Total +46% Trends: Unit Costs Source: Robins, 2012. Unit costs in £ per train km, 2008 prices. Main growth in Renewals and Enhancements, but also increases in TOC costs since 2000. 9 Trends: Government Support 1995/6 – 00/1 -44% 2001/2 – 04/5 +150% 2005/6 – 11/12 -24% Total +6% 10 Estimated Welfare Effects (£ B) Overall Increase in Net Effect Infrastructure Costs 1995/6 -2.2 +4.6 +2.4 – 2000/1 2001/2 -18.7 +16.9 -1.8 – 2004/5 2005/6 -13.8 +17.0 +3.2 – 2008/9 Total -34.7 +38.5 +3.8 Based on Robins (2012) and Preston and Robins (2013). If each franchise had bidding costs of £22.5M then the net benefits of £3.8B are offset by transaction costs of £1.1B. 11 Issue (I) Level of Competition and the Winning Bid Franchising has been competitive, but competition declining over time: • First phase: 5.4 bids per franchise • Second phase: 4.2 bids per franchise • Third phase: 3.8 bids per franchise. Current pool of 10 active bidders. High bidding costs (£5M per bidder in 2006, £10M in 2012). Are rail franchises a common value or a private value auction? Assuming no uncertainty and/or no risk aversion contracting- out will ensure optimal effort. But where there is uncertainty (e.g. open access) and risk aversion, effort will be sub-optimal.12 Issue (I) Level of Competition and the Winning Bid Only 3 out of 47 franchises have failed. However, 13 franchises re- negotiated after Hatfield 2000. Evidence of the winner’s curse? 13 Issue (II) Objectives What is franchising trying to achieve? (i) To harness private sector commercial judgement and innovation to reduce the net cost and increase the value for money achieved from the Government’s overall support for passenger rail services. (ii) To improve passenger services, commensurate with funding available. (iii) To set the level of service needed and to vary specifications to reflect changing market needs and accommodate future passenger growth. (iv) To protect passengers from the power of unregulated monopolies. (v) To maximise the benefits of the network as a whole. (vi) To fit rail within Government’s wider public transport objectives. Maximise net social benefit subject to a budget 14 constraint? Issue (II) Objectives Brown Review: (i) Ensure value for money by competition for the market. (ii) Harness private sector skills and innovation. (iii) Ensure stability of service. (iv) Secure franchisees who will work in partnership. (v) Facilitate further devolution of decision making. (vi) Ensure services are delivered and managed by organisations which are attuned to local market needs. 15 Issue (II) Objectives (continued) Change in: Fares Train Miles Subsidy Welfare Profit Max - +17% -8% -7% -22% 50% variable Constrained -1% +8% 0 0 Welfare Max - 50% variable Unconstrained -93% +71% +521% +86% Welfare Max - 50% variable Profit Max - +24% -47% -89% -35% 100% variable Constrained -36% -30% 0 +25% Welfare Max - 100% variable Unconstrained -88% +12% +374% +53% Welfare Max - 100% variable BCR of revenue support (£1.2 b per year) ≈ 4. BCR of revenue and direct support (£4.6b per year) ≈ 1.1 16 Issue (II) Objectives (cont.) Social v Commercial 2012-13 subsidy per passenger kilometre (pence) source: ORR data portal (northern/tpe adjusted for net subsidy) 15,0 12,0 9,0 6,0 3,0 pence per km 0,0 -3,0 -6,0 Issue (III) Overoptimistic Bids The East Coast Franchise Date Started Expected PVNP PVNP Duration 1st year Final year (£m) (£m) GNER April 1996 7 years 651 0 GNER May 2005 10 years (50) (219) National Dec. 2007 7 ¼ years 7 (311) Comparison of FWC Express (purple) and NXEC (red) PVNP = Present Value of Net Payments. Figures in brackets bids. denote premia paid. Source: Modern 1Out-turn. Railways, 2012. Source: Preston and Root (1999) and www.dft.gov.uk 18 Issue (III) Overoptimistic Bids £200 £100 South Eastern South Western First Greater
Recommended publications
  • Firstgroup Vies with Virgin in West Coast Rail Bidding War | Business | Guardian.Co.Uk Page 1 of 2
    FirstGroup vies with Virgin in west coast rail bidding war | Business | guardian.co.uk Page 1 of 2 Printing sponsored by: FirstGroup vies with Virgin in west coast rail bidding war Aberdeen-based group is frontrunner, along with incumbent, in battle to secure 14-year franchise contract Dan Milmo, industrial editor guardian.co.uk, Sunday 15 July 2012 14.13 BST Virgin, the current holders of the west coast franchise, pay an annual premium of £150m to the government. Photograph: Christopher Thomond for the Guardian FirstGroup has emerged as a frontrunner for the multibillion-pound west coast rail franchise alongside incumbent Virgin Trains, with the contest now a two-horse race between the experienced operators. Aberdeen-based FirstGroup is vying with Virgin despite announcing last year that it is handing back its Great Western rail contract three years ahead of schedule, avoiding more than £800m in payments to the government. The Department for Transport is expected to bank a considerable windfall from the new 14-year west coast contract, with Virgin currently paying an annual premium of about £150m to the state. Both bidders are expected to promise an even bigger number over the life of the new franchise. The winner is expected to be announced next month. It is understood that FirstGroup and Virgin are still in talks with the DfT, but two foreign-owned bidders on the four-strong shortlist are no longer considered likely contenders. They are a joint venture between public transport operator Keolis and SNCF, the French state rail group, and a bid from Abellio, which is controlled by the Dutch national rail operator.
    [Show full text]
  • View Fleet List (1919-2021)
    FLEET LIST (1919-2021) Fleet Seating Into Fleet Reg No:Chassis: Make & Model Chassis No: Body: Make & Type New Withdrawn Notes No: & Format if used 1 PW 1558 Ford T Economy, Lowestoft B14F -/19 - 11/28 Burnt out 2 CT 6489 Chevrolet 29262 Andrews B14 05/24 - 11/28 Burnt out 3 CT 7421 Lancia 4947 Delaine 26 06/25 - 11/28 Burnt out 4 CT 8216 W&G. L 2553 W&G B26F 06/26 - 09/32 Broken up 01/36 5 CT 9025 W&G 3261 Hall Lewis B26F 05/27 - 06/36 Chassis to shed in yard, Broken Up : Body Broken up 06/39 6 CY 8972 W&G 5001 - 28 -/28 11/28 -/29 On loan from and returned to W&G 7 ? W&G - - 26 ? 11/28 -/29 On loan from operator near Cadnam : To W&G Southampton 8 ? Reo - - 26 ? 11/28 -/29 On loan from CH Skinner, Spalding (Dealer) 18 CT 9869 W&G 2639 Hall Lewis B32F 07/28 - 02/52 Broken up 11/55 9 TL 364 Gilford 166SD 10668 Clarke, Scunthorpe B26F 04/29 - by/40 To Canham, Whittlesey 10 TL 565 Chevrolet LQ 54366 Bracebridge B14F 06/29 - -/30 To Brown, Caister 19 TL 1066 Leyland TS2 60895 Duple C31F 03/30 - 03/55 Rebodied by Holbrook C37F in 1939. Scrapped on site 03/55 17 TL 1316 Reo Pullman 1528 Bracebridge B20F 07/30 - 12/48 To shed in Yard 11 TL 2224 Leyland TS4 202 Burlingham B32F 03/32 - 08/40 Requistioned by War Dept. Bombed in 1943 20 TL 2965 Leyland TS6 2982 Burlingham C37F 07/33 - 06/53 Requistioned by War Dept and returned.
    [Show full text]
  • London and the South East of England: 15 July 2016
    OFFICE OF THE TRAFFIC COMMISSIONER (LONDON AND THE SOUTH EAST OF ENGLAND) NOTICES AND PROCEEDINGS PUBLICATION NUMBER: 2359 PUBLICATION DATE: 15 July 2016 OBJECTION DEADLINE DATE: 05 August 2016 Correspondence should be addressed to: Office of the Traffic Commissioner (London and the South East of England) Hillcrest House 386 Harehills Lane Leeds LS9 6NF Telephone: 0300 123 9000 Fax: 0113 249 8142 Website: www.gov.uk/traffic-commissioners The public counter at the above office is open from 9.30am to 4pm Monday to Friday The next edition of Notices and Proceedings will be published on: 29/07/2016 Publication Price £3.50 (post free) This publication can be viewed by visiting our website at the above address. It is also available, free of charge, via e-mail. To use this service please send an e-mail with your details to: [email protected] Remember to keep your bus registrations up to date - check yours on https://www.gov.uk/manage-commercial-vehicle-operator-licence-online NOTICES AND PROCEEDINGS Important Information All correspondence relating to public inquiries should be sent to: Office of the Traffic Commissioner (London and the South East of England) Ivy House 3 Ivy Terrace Eastbourne BN21 4QT The public counter at the Eastbourne office is open for the receipt of documents between 9.30am and 4pm Monday Friday. There is no facility to make payments of any sort at the counter. General Notes Layout and presentation – Entries in each section (other than in section 5) are listed in alphabetical order. Each entry is prefaced by a reference number, which should be quoted in all correspondence or enquiries.
    [Show full text]
  • Drivers'union
    The train ASLEF drivers’ union >>> Rail Franchise Handbook 2019 ASLEF Introduction Welcome to our new Rail Franchise Handbook. I hope you will find it as interesting, and useful, as I do and a valuable tool for the political and industrial work you do for our union. We put this handbook together to give our reps and decision makers the inside track on who really runs Britain’s railways, how they run our railways, and what they take out from our railway industry every year. Because we believe the facts and figures revealed in these pages show, with crystal clarity, the utter folly of our privatised, and fragmented, franchise system. A structure – set up by John Major, 25 years ago, and continued by Conservative governments ever since – that separates the wheels and steel and is underwritten by an enormous public subsidy from every taxpayer in this country, and sky high passenger fares, while tens of millions of pounds haemorrhage from the system into the pockets of shareholders in the form of profits and dividends, or increasingly due inefficiencies. In fact whilst the system has never worked for passengers or taxpayers, there are now signs that it doesn’t work for operators either. The franchising system has been put on hold for a couple of years now due to a lack of bidders. This means direct awards have been handed out leading to even less competition. So we now have a system that exists to maintain the system itself, not our railway. It isn’t true to say that all the train and freight operating fill the pockets of shareholders; some TOCs and FOCs are owned by public, not private, operators where shareholders do not skim the cream off the top of the milk.
    [Show full text]
  • Retail Market Review
    Retail market review Emerging findings June 2015 Contents Executive Summary 5 Box 1: Summary of proposed remedies 12 1. Introduction 14 Summary 14 Purpose of the retail market review 14 Scope of the Review 15 Box 2: The Retail Market Review and wider interactions 17 Characteristics of the rail retail market 18 Our methodology 19 Purpose of this document 20 Next steps 20 Question for Chapter 1 21 2. Passengers’ experiences of the rail ticketing market 22 Summary 22 Introduction 22 Where passengers buy tickets 22 Box 3: Passengers’ appetite for having a wider range of retailers, including smaller retailers 27 How passengers buy tickets 28 Ticket formats 30 Passengers' choice of tickets 34 Box 4: Passengers’ take-up of inter-available and through fares 36 Passengers' opportunities to find different / cheaper fares 38 Questions for Chapter 2 38 3. The industry regime for TOCs and possible remedies to promote effective competition 39 Summary 39 Introduction 39 TOCs’ ability to offer new fares and products 40 TOCs’ ability to differentiate the ticket buying experience 44 TOCs’ ability to differentiate by sales channels 45 Questions for Chapter 3 47 4. The industry regime for third party retailers and possible remedies to promote effective competition 49 Summary 49 Introduction 49 Third party retailing in ticket selling 49 Incentives on potential third party retailers to enter and to expand in the market for ticket selling 52 Box 5: The level of third party retailers’ commission 57 Scope for third party retailers to compete 60 Box 6: ATOC’s trial to allow third party retailers sell Season tickets 61 Box 7: Retail rail prices in Sweden 64 Questions for Chapter 4 66 5.
    [Show full text]
  • Drucksache 19/27457 19
    Deutscher Bundestag Drucksache 19/27457 19. Wahlperiode 10.03.2021 Antwort der Bundesregierung auf die Kleine Anfrage der Abgeordneten Torsten Herbst, Frank Sitta, Oliver Luksic, weiterer Abgeordneter und der Fraktion der FDP – Drucksache 19/26671 – Entwicklung der wirtschaftlichen Lage der Arriva PLC Vorbemerkung der Fragesteller Im Jahr 2010 hat die Deutsche Bahn AG (DB AG) für rund 2,7 Mrd. Euro in- klusive der Übernahme vorhandener Schulden das britische Unternehmen Ar- riva PLC erworben. Mit Sitz in Sunderland betreibt Arriva in mehreren euro- päischen Ländern Bus- und Bahnverkehre. Zunächst galt das Unternehmen als wirtschaftliche attraktive Akquisition für die DB AG. So erwirtschaftete Arri- va Anfang der 2010er-Jahre mit rund 50 000 Mitarbeitern einen Jahresumsatz von mehr als 5 Mrd. Euro. (https://www.handelsblatt.com/26044118.html) Vor dem Hintergrund der immer weiter steigenden Schuldenlast des DB-Konzerns unternahm der DB-Vorstand im Jahr 2019 zunächst den Versuch, Arriva zu verkaufen. Zu diesem Zeitpunkt beliefen sich die Schulden der DB AG, auch aufgrund neuer Bilanzierungsvorgaben, auf 25 Mrd. Euro. Geplant war zu- nächst, durch den Komplettverkauf bis zu vier Mrd. Euro einzunehmen. Im weiteren Verlauf des Jahres 2019 scheiterte der Verkaufsversuch jedoch. Medienberichten war zu diesem Zeitpunkt zu entnehmen, dass dem DB- Aufsichtsrat die von Investoren genannten Angebote zu niedrig gewesen sei- en. So sollte zumindest der ursprüngliche Kaufpreis von rund 3 Mrd. Euro durch den Verkauf erzielt werden (https://www.spiegel.de/wirtschaft/unterneh men/arriva-und-brexit-deutsche-bahn-blaest-boersengang-bei-britischer-tochte r-ab-a-1292544.html). Da ein solches Angebot nicht vorlag, entschied die DB AG daraufhin, Arriva im Jahr 2020 an die Börse zu bringen.
    [Show full text]
  • Vehicles Expected to Attend the PEAK PARK PRESERVED BUS GATHERING 2021 As at 26Th June 2021
    Vehicles expected to attend the PEAK PARK PRESERVED BUS GATHERING 2021 as at 26th June 2021 The list below shows the buses and coaches that have been entered in this year's Peak Park Preserved Bus Gathering so far. Those marked ▲ are expected to assist in operating the free bus services during the day. Additional vehicles are expected to be entered during the next few weeks - if you would like to bring a preserved bus or coach to our event, please download an entry form from our website - www.peakparkrally.wordpress.com Registration New Make Model Body Operator Livery Class A - Half cab & 'Classic' Double-Deckers ▲ WLT 467 1960 AEC Routemaster Park Royal London Transport YNU 351G 1968 Bristol FLF Eastern Coachworks Midland General ▲ OVL 473 1960 Bristol FS6G Eastern Coachworks Lincolnshire Road Car ▲ 225 LRB 1960 Leyland PD2 M.C.W. Chesterfield Transport Class B - Rear Engined Double-Deckers ▲ C253 FRJ 1986 Leyland Olympian Northern Counties Wigan Corporation ▲ P915 RYO 1997 Volvo Olympian Northern Counties London General PUM 149W 1980 Bristol VRT3LS/6LXB Eastern Coachworks West Yorkshire R.C. ▲ S629 MKH 1998 Volvo Olympian Northern Counties East Yorkshire M.S. RNA 236J 1971 Daimler Fleetline Park Royal Selnec PTE ▲ UHA 225H 1969 Daimler Fleetline Alexander Midland Red DEM 779Y 1982 Leyland Atlantean Alexander MTL Southport & Dist ▲ H654 VVV 1990 Leyland Olympian Alexander RL Stagecoach United Counties B741 GCN 1985 Leyland Olympian Eastern Coachworks Go Ahead Northern Class C - Single Deckers pre-suffix registrations (pre, 1964) MHY 765 1950 Leyland Comet Duple Orient Coaches KRR 255 1949 AEC Regal III Weymann Midland General Class D - Single Deck Buses post-suffix registrations (after 1964) ▲ BVP 808V 1980 Leyland National Leyland NBC Midland Red ▲ LED 71P 1976 Bristol RE East Lancs Warrington Transport AXI 2541 1982 Bristol RELL6G Alexander (Belfast) Citybus (Belfast) ▲ AJA 139B 1964 Bedford VAL Strachan North Western ▲ GSO 90V 1979 Leyland Leopard Alexander Y type Alexander Northern PDJ 269L 1972 AEC Swift Marshall St.
    [Show full text]
  • View Annual Report
    FirstGroupplc Principal and registered office London office FirstGroup plc FirstGroup plc 395 King Street 50 Eastbourne Terrace Aberdeen AB24 5RP Paddington Keeping people Tel. +44 (0)1224 650100 London W2 6LG Fax. +44 (0)1224 650140 Tel. +44 (0)20 7291 0505 Ann Registered in Scotland Fax. +44 (0)20 7436 3337 ualReport and Accounts 2012 number SC157176 www.firstgroup.com moving and Printed in the UK by Royle Print, a Carbon Neutral printing company, on material made from 100% post consumer waste; the printer and paper communities manufacturing mill are both accredited with ISO 14001 environmental management systems standard and both are Forestry Stewardship Council certified. When you have finished with this report, please dispose of it in your recycled waste stream. prospering www.firstgroup.com Annual Report and Accounts 2012 Overview About us Shareholder profile At 23 May 2012 Number of shareholders % Shares held % Performance By category FirstGroup plc is the leading transport Individuals 37,892 95.0 46,748,910 9.7 operator in the UK and North America. Banks and Nominees 1,695 4.3 427,940,406 88.8 Insurance and assurance 1 – 300 – With revenues of over £6.5 billion per Other companies 114 0.3 1,889,454 0.4 Other institutions 150 0.4 5,488,100 1.1 annum and approximately 124,000 39,852 100.0 482,067,170 100.0 employees we transport more than By size of holding 1-1,000 30,642 76.9 8,011,808 1.7 Governance 2.5 billion passengers every year. 1,001-5,000 7,138 17.9 15,759,366 3.3 5,001-10,000 1,072 2.7 7,428,005 1.5 In our increasingly congested world 10,001-100,000 699 1.7 19,184,334 4.0 we help to keep people moving and Over 100,000 301 0.8 431,683,657 89.5 39,852 100.0 482,067,170 100.0 communities prospering.
    [Show full text]
  • Transport Committee
    Transport Committee Value added? The Transport Committee’s assessment of whether the bus contracts issued by London Buses represent value for money March 2006 The Transport Committee Roger Evans - Chairman (Conservative) Geoff Pope - Deputy Chair (Liberal Democrat) John Biggs - Labour Angie Bray - Conservative Elizabeth Howlett - Conservative Peter Hulme Cross - One London Darren Johnson - Green Murad Qureshi - Labour Graham Tope - Liberal Democrat The Transport Committee’s general terms of reference are to examine and report on transport matters of importance to Greater London and the transport strategies, policies and actions of the Mayor, Transport for London, and the other Functional Bodies where appropriate. In particular, the Transport Committee is also required to examine and report to the Assembly from time to time on the Mayor’s Transport Strategy, in particular its implementation and revision. The terms of reference as agreed by the Transport Committee on 20th October 2005 for the bus contracts scrutiny were: • To examine the value for money secured by the Quality Incentive Contracts issued by London Buses to bus operators. This will include o An examination of the penalty/bonus element to the Quality Incentive Contracts o An examination of operator rate of return and operator market share o An examination of the criteria by which the subsidy’s value for money is judged • To compare all of the above with other contracting arrangements within the UK and other international major cities Please contact Danny Myers on either 020 7983 4394 or on e-mail via [email protected] if you have any comments on this report the Committee would welcome any feedback.
    [Show full text]
  • Alphabetical Index
    Alphabetical Index A & C Black PLC 3 Anglo Nordic Holdings PLC 16 Baynes, Charles, pic 30 A & J Mucklow Group PLC 3 Anglo Pacific Resources PLC 16 B.C.E. Holdings PLC 31 A B Caller & Sons Ltd 3 Ansbacher, Henry, Holdings PLC 16 BDA Holdings PLC 31 A Beckman PLC 3 Antofagasta Holdings PLC 16 B.D.R. (Grain) Ltd 31 A Cohen & Co pic 3 API Group PLC 17 BEA 39 A F Budge (Building) Ltd 3 Apollo Leisure Group PLC 17 Beale, J E, PLC 31 A F Bulgin & Co PLC 3 Apollo Metals pic 17 Beales Hunter PLC 32 A G Barr pic 3 Apollo Watch Products PLC 17 Beattie, James, PLC 32 A H Ball Group PLC 3 Appleby Westward Group pic 17 Beauford PLC 32 A H Marks & Company Ltd 3 Aquascutum Group PLC 18 Beckenham Group pic (The) 32 A R Dennis PLC 3 ARA Services Pic 18 Beckman, A, PLC 33 Abaca Group PLC (formerly Zurich Arcadian International PLC (formerly Becton Dickinson UK Ltd 33 Group PLC) 3 Westminster & Country Properties Bell & Howell Ltd 33 ABB Power Ltd 3 PLC) 18 Belling & Co Ltd 33 ABB Vetco Gray UK Ltd 3 Arco Ltd 18 Bellwinch pic 33 Abbey Panels Investments PLC 3 Arcolectric (Holdings) pic 18 Bemrose Corporation pic 33 Abbey pic 3 Arenson Group PLC 19 Bemrose, Eric, Ltd 34 Abbeycrest PLC 4 Ariston Domestic Appliances Ltd 19 Ben Bailey Construction PLC 34 ABE 22 Arlen PLC 19 Bendix Ltd 34 Aberdeen Steak Houses Group pic 4 Armitage Bros PLC 19 Bennett & Fountain Group pic 34 Aberfoyle Holdings PLC 4 Armour Trust pic 19 Benson Group PLC 34 ABI Leisure Group PLC 4 Arsenal Football Club PLC 20 Bensons Crisps PLC 34 Abrams, Syd, Ltd 5 Arthur Sanderson & Sons Ltd 20
    [Show full text]
  • Printmgr File
    THIS DOCUMENT IS IMPORTANT AND REQUIRES YOUR IMMEDIATE ATTENTION. If you are in any doubt as to the action you should take, you are recommended to seek your own personal financial advice immediately from your stockbroker, bank manager, solicitor, accountant, fund manager or other independent financial adviser authorised under FSMA if you are in the United Kingdom or, if you are not, from another appropriately authorised independent financial adviser. This document comprises a circular and a prospectus relating to FirstGroup and the Rights Issue, prepared in accordance with the Prospectus Rules of the UK Listing Authority made under section 73A of FSMA. This document has been approved by the FCA in accordance with section 85 of FSMA. A copy of this document has been filed with the FCA in accordance with paragraph 3.2.1 of the Prospectus Rules. This document will be made available to the public in accordance with paragraph 3.2.1 of the Prospectus Rules by the same being made available at www.firstgroup.com. This document can also be obtained on request from the Receiving Agent. Subject to the restrictions set out below, if you sell or transfer or have sold or transferred all of your Existing Ordinary Shares (other than ex- rights) held in certificated form before 8.00 a.m. on 11 June 2013 (the “Ex-Rights Date”), please send this document, together with any Provisional Allotment Letter, if and when received, as soon as possible to the purchaser or transferee, or to the stockbroker, bank or other agent through whom the sale or transfer was effected, for onward delivery to the purchaser or transferee.
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Bus Statistics: 2010/11
    Annual Bus Statistics: 2010/11 Notes and Definitions This document provides information about DfT These Notes and Definitions include: bus statistics. 1. Introduction to the statistics Bus statistics are published annually by the 2. Information on data sources and methods Department for Transport, and include figures 3. Information relating to the published tables relating to bus passenger journeys, vehicle miles including key definitions travelled, revenue and costs, fare levels, 4. Sources of further information related to but Government support, vehicles owned by PSV not covered by these statistics operators and number of staff employed. In 5. Background and contextual information addition to the annual publication, estimates of patronage are available on a quarterly basis. Section 1 presents a brief overview of the statistics, covering the following questions: What do these statistics cover? Why are the statistics collected and how are they used? What are the sources of data used to compile the statistics? What methods are used to compile the published information? How reliable are the statistics? What should be considered when using them? How often are these statistics updated? What other information is available on buses and bus travel? Section 2 provides further general information about the main data sources used to compile the statistics, including the methods used to produce figures for publication and data quality issues. Section 3 presents information relevant to specific aspects of the published figures, including definitions of key terms and specific issues relevant to the interpretation of individual tables or sections. Section 4 provides details of further sources of statistics on buses and bus travel which are not covered by these statistics Section 5 provides links to relevant contextual information about the bus industry and bus policy The annexes contain more detailed information as referenced in the appropriate section above.
    [Show full text]