DOCSLIB.ORG

Elegant Tour De Force

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Elegant Tour De Force HIGHLIGHTS HIGHLIGHT ADVISORS WENDY BICKMORE FUNCTIONAL GENOMICS MRC HUMAN GENETICS UNIT, UK SEAN B. CARROLL UNIVERSITY OF WISCONSIN, Elegant tour de force USA ADAM EYRE-WALKER UNIVERSITY OF SUSSEX, UK When the draft human genome genes, for example, those that JANE GITSCHIER sequence was published it was encode essential components of the UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, referred to as the blueprint. But, as basal cellular machinery. By con- SAN FRANCISCO, USA with any design plan, the challenge trast, most of the genes in the Vpep RALPH J. GREENSPAN is in establishing how the plan is class probably represent animal- THE NEUROSCIENCES executed. This task lies at the heart specific genes, and their products INSTITUTE, CALIFORNIA, USA of functional genomics, and now affect processes such as behaviour YOSHIHIDE HAYASHIZAKI Kamath et al. provide an important or body shape. RIKEN GENOMIC SCIENCES contribution to this field with their A closer look at the genomic dis- CENTER, JAPAN tour de force systematic RNAi tribution of genes in each class PETER KOOPMAN analysis of the Caenorhabditis revealed that genes with similar UNIVERSITY OF QUEENSLAND, AUSTRALIA elegans genome. Not only do they functions tend to be co-localized in LEONID KRUGLYAK uncover the function of scores of large domains of the genome and FRED HUTCHINSON CANCER worm genes, but they also provide are co-transcribed. The size of these RESEARCH CENTER, USA important information on the clusters, however, suggests that any BARBARA MEYER worm genome structure and its large-scale transcriptional co-regu- UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, evolution. lation must be mediated by a mech- BERKELEY, USA To determine RNAi phenotypes anism other than the previously LEE NISWANDER for as many C. elegans genes as pos- described open-looped chromatin. SLOAN-KETTERING INSTITUTE, sible, the authors constructed a Another interesting finding con- NEW YORK, USA library of 16,757 bacterial strains cerns the X chromosome. The fact genes that have mammalian homo- CHRISTOS OUZOUNIS (equivalent to 86% of all currently that Nonv genes are underrepre- logues, some of which have already THE EUROPEAN predicted worm open reading sented on the X chromosome, been implicated in fat metabolism. BIOINFORMATICS INSTITUTE, frames; ORFs), each of which whereas those that encode compo- The worm fat-regulating genes fall UK expressed double-stranded RNA nents of signalling pathways and into three main pathways (insulin, NORIYUKI SATOH (dsRNA) corresponding to a single transcription factors are overrepre- serotonin and tubby) confirming KYOTO UNIVERSITY, JAPAN worm gene. When worms feed on sented, suggests that very different that fat metabolism is conserved in MARC VIDAL these bacteria (Escherichia coli selection pressures operate on genes metazoans and that the worm can DANA-FARBER CANCER is their normal diet) the dsRNA on the sex chromosomes compared be used as a model of human fat INSTITUTE, BOSTON, USA is internalized and mediates with genes on the autosomes. metabolic disorders. VIRGINIA WALBOT sequence-specific knock down of Two other studies, in which the The authors of the second report, STANFORD UNIVERSITY, USA the endogenous gene. One by one, same approach was used to address published in Nature Genetics, sought DETLEF WEIGEL the phenotypes were scored, and more specific biological questions, genes that, when inactivated, MAX PLANCK INSTITUTE FOR 10.3% of the analysed ORFs gave have also been recently published. increased the C. elegans lifespan. Lee DEVELOPMENTAL BIOLOGY, consistent phenotypes, which the Ashrafi et al. used the same RNAi et al. followed up their RNAi screen GERMANY authors grouped into three classes: library to look for genes that regu- with a classic forward genetics screen LEONARD I. ZON nonviable (Nonv), growth defects late fat storage and mobilization. and, together, the results showed that CHILDREN’S HOSPITAL, (Gro) and viable post-embryonic Among the 305 genes that reduce worms with impaired mitochondrial BOSTON, USA phenotypes (Vpep). The first class body fat stores and the 112 that and certain metabolic functions tend ▲ contains many universal eukaryotic increase them, they identified those to be long-lived. NATURE REVIEWS | GENETICS VOLUME 4 | FEBRUARY 2003 | 79 © 2003 Nature Publishing Group HIGHLIGHTS ▲ Apart from the important bio- more complete picture of individual Caenorhabditis elegans genome using RNAi. IN THE NEWS Nature 421, 231–237 (2003) | Ashrafi K. et al. logical insights, Kamath et al. have biological processes. The hope is Genome-wide RNAi analysis of Caenorhabditis Clone baby? given the community an important that, as RNAi technology improves, elegans fat regulatory genes. Nature 421, Doubts have started to resource — the bacterial RNAi similar systematic screens will also 268–272 (2003) | Lee, S. S. et al. A systematic surface over the truth of library that can be used over and be feasible in mammalian cells. RNAi screen identifies a critical role for claims that the first human mitochondria in C. elegans longevity. Nature over again. Many more reports of Magdalena Skipper Genet. 33, 40–48 (2003) clone has been born, after screens such as those by Ashrafi et al. FURTHER READING Dillin, A. et al. Rates of Clonaid — the company that References and links behavior and aging specified by mitochondrial made the original 27 and Lee et al. are bound to follow, ORIGINAL RESEARCH PAPERS Kamath, R. S. function during development. Science 298, December announcement — the results of which will provide a et al. Systematic functional analysis of the 2398–2401 (2002) backed away from an independent verification by genetic tests. The New York Times EVOLUTIONARY GENOMICS reported that Clonaid’s self- imposed one-week deadline expired with no evidence forthcoming. Clonaid’s chief executive Brigitte Boisselier Compensation or innovation said “The parents told me that they needed 48 hours to decide yes or no — if they Gene duplications are often seen experimental conditions. These to perform a new function. The would do it” (New York Times). as an opportunity to evolve new observations indicated that buffering effect of duplicates is The credibility of the claims functions through the duplicated genes compensate largely caused by their partially took another hit when accumulation of mutations for each other, a conclusion that overlapping function. Axel Meyer Michael Guillen — the leading to functional was supported by the fact that argues for a dual role for duplicate freelance science journalist diversification. But, they can deletions of either gene from a genes, but further whole-genome- organizing the genetic tests also be thought of as a back-up duplicate pair showed similar sequence comparisons and — pointedly distanced or a buffer against loss-of- fitness effects. Furthermore, the functional genetic analyses are himself from Clonaid after the tests did not go ahead. function mutations in one of smaller the divergence between needed before we can really “It’s entirely possible [that] the duplicates. Using yeast as a the duplicates, the better they address this question. Clonaid’s announcement is working example, Gu et al. have compensate for each other. It also Magdalena Skipper part of an elaborate hoax to shown that gene duplications turns out that deleting duplicate References and links bring publicity to the Raelian considerably contribute to genetic genes with higher expression levels ORIGINAL RESEARCH PAPER Gu, Z. et al. movement,” he said robustness against null has a greater effect on fitness than Role of duplicate genes in genetic robustness (The Guardian). mutations. deleting those that are not as against null mutations. Nature 421, 63–22 Claude Vorhilon (aka ‘Rael’), (2003) A previous study of genetic highly expressed. leader of the pseudoscientific FURTHER READING Meyer, A. Duplication, duplication. Nature 421, 31–32 (2003) sect that funds Clonaid, robustness — the ability to These data provide strong suggests that a Florida court withstand null mutations — evidence for the role of gene action aimed at placing the concluded that it was redundant duplication in genetic robustness baby under the court’s metabolic pathways and networks, against null mutations. Whether protection might explain the rather than duplicate genes, that this contribution is more or less company’s reticence. “…to mainly fulfil this function. important than the interactions take away this poor baby However, these conclusions were between unduplicated genes that from a mother, I think this is based only on a few genes, so Gu function in alternative pathways completely crazy, just because she was cloned. et al. revisited this problem — this remains to be seen. The role of So I called Doctor Boisselier, time addressing it on a genome- duplicates in genetic buffering and I said, ‘If I was you, I wide scale. They made use of a might explain why these genes would not test anything.’” previous study in which almost do not ‘decay’ into pseudogenes (The Washington Times). all of the genes of Saccharomyces as quickly as expected. But, Axel The increasing scepticism cerevisae were knocked out and the Meyer — the author of the of the media has not fitness of the mutants was assessed accompanying News and Views — prevented Clonaid from expanding their claims: under five different conditions suggests that their incorporation according to them a further (see Highlights section in into new networks and pathways three human clones will be September 2002 issue). When the also prevents such decay. So, does born in
Load more

Recommended publications
  • International Arbitrage of Controversial Medical Technologies: an Introduction Hiram E
    Case Western Reserve Journal of International Law Volume 35 | Issue 3 2003 International Arbitrage of Controversial Medical Technologies: An Introduction Hiram E. Chodosh Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarlycommons.law.case.edu/jil Part of the International Law Commons Recommended Citation Hiram E. Chodosh, International Arbitrage of Controversial Medical Technologies: An Introduction, 35 Case W. Res. J. Int'l L. 363 (2003) Available at: https://scholarlycommons.law.case.edu/jil/vol35/iss3/3 This Foreword is brought to you for free and open access by the Student Journals at Case Western Reserve University School of Law Scholarly Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Case Western Reserve Journal of International Law by an authorized administrator of Case Western Reserve University School of Law Scholarly Commons. INTERNATIONAL ARBITRAGE OF CONTROVERSIAL MEDICAL TECHNOLOGIES: AN INTRODUCTION Hiram E. Chodosht James R. Lisher IPt During the 2002-2003 academic year, the Case Western Reserve University Journal of International Law (the "Journal") and the Frederick K. Cox International Law Center (the "Cox Center") invited a series of experts to explore the difficulties in global regulation of new bio-medical technologies. We entitled the symposium International Arbitrage of Controversial Medical Technologies in order to capture the intersection of two significant developments. First, we endeavored to investigate the rapid proliferation of bio- medical technologies that create deep moral and ethical dilemmas for lawmakers, e.g., genetic engineering, germ line gene therapy, somatic cell gene therapy, untested, risky pharmaceuticals for terrible illnesses, and even biological weapons, and the diverse national approaches to regulating such activity.
    [Show full text]
  • Human Cloning and the Raelians in the Spanish Newspaper El País
    Science Communication Volume 30 Number 2 December 2008 236-265 © 2008 Sage Publications Human Cloning and 10.1177/1075547008324429 http://scx.sagepub.com hosted at the Raelians http://online.sagepub.com Media Coverage and the Rhetoric of Science Miguel Alcíbar University of Seville, Spain In this article, the author analyzes the reported coverage on human cloning and the Raelians in the Spanish newspaper El País. On December 27, 2002, Brigitte Boisselier, the director of the biotechnology company Clonaid, part of the International Raelian Movement, announced they had successfully cloned a baby girl. This news report enlivened the controversy on human cloning, which originated in February 1997 with the news of Dolly’s birth. El País constructed the controversy as a fundamental problem of scientific policy. This study sug- gests that El País wants to persuade policy makers to establish limited regula- tions on experimentation with embryo stem cells for therapeutic purposes. To achieve this goal, this newspaper used scientific sources selected ad hoc and a series of well-defined rhetorical strategies. Keywords: human cloning; newspaper coverage; Raelians; El País; actor network theory; framing n December 27, 2002, Brigitte Boisselier, the director of the Obiotechnology company Clonaid, run by the International Raelian Movement (IRM), announced they had successfully cloned a baby girl who they called Eve. The claims of the IRM members not only enlivened the ethical debate surrounding human cloning but also provoked the reaction of the “scientific community,”1 calling for science as the legitimate repository of knowledge and source of future development of research using human embryos (Table 1).
    [Show full text]
  • The Clone Wars: the Growing Debate Over Federal Cloning Legislation
    iBRIEF / Health & Biotechnology Cite as 2001 Duke L. & Tech. Rev. 0022 6/20/2001 THE CLONE WARS: THE GROWING DEBATE OVER FEDERAL CLONING LEGISLATION As readers of science fiction are well aware, the term "clone" refers to asexually produced offspring, that is, offspring produced by a process of cell-division which does not begin with the union of two sex cells. A clone is the genetic twin of the cell donor. Propagation of plants by this method is, of course, commonplace, but mammalian reproduction in this fashion would indeed be a revolutionary accomplishment, with profound and disturbing implications.1 Introduction ¶ 1 As is evident from this footnote from a 1979 District Court opinion, "cloning" is not a novel concept, and in fact, experiments with tadpoles date back as far as the 1950s. However, experiments involving humans have not been attempted to date. In fact, scientists thought human cloning was impossible until February 22, 1997, when a sheep named "Dolly"2 was born at the Roslin Institute in Scotland.3 Dolly's birth shocked the scientific community and led to vigorous debate about whether this technology could or should be applied to humans. ¶ 2 Despite the fact that the cloning controversy has been around for some time, human cloning was not seriously contemplated until Ian Wilmut and his colleagues at the Roslin Institute cloned the first mammal through the use of a novel scientific development called "nuclear transfer technology."4 The production of this clone was accomplished by transferring the udder cell of a six-year-old all-white adult Welsh Mountain sheep into a Scottish Blackface ewe's egg from which the DNA had been removed.5 Scientists facilitated the combination between the udder cell and the enucleated egg using electric charge.
    [Show full text]
  • Recommended Response for Human Cloning Patent Applications
    279 RECOMMENDED RESPONSE FOR HUMAN CLONING PATENT APPLICATIONS * DUANE NASH, M.D., J.D. I. INTRODUCTION The United States Patent and Trademark Office (“USPTO”) should not follow the recent decision of the European Union to invalidate patents pertaining to human cloning technology. First, human cloning inventions are clearly patentable in the United States; not only do these inventions meet the statutory requirements of proper subject matter and utility, but they are also not precluded from satisfying the other requirements of novelty, nonobvious- ness, disclosure and enablement.1 Second, while human cloning technology undoubtedly requires regulation, patent law is not the proper forum or even an adequate one. While patent law is designed to reward inventors of desirable inventions, it is not in the position to regulate or prohibit the undesirable ones. In addition, the patent infringement immunity given to “medical ac- tivit[ies]” by section 616 of the Omnibus Consolidated Appropriations Act of 1996 (“Act”) should not be relied upon to prevent enforcement of human cloning patents.2 First, this legislation has been sharply criticized and should * Dr. Nash is a 1993 graduate of Williams College, a 1997 graduate of Dartmouth Medical School, as well as a 2001 graduate of the University of California at Berkeley School of Law (Boalt Hall) where he concentrated in Law and Technology. He also completed a clinical internship in general surgery at the University of California at San Francisco and is currently an MBA candidate at Corpus Christi College and the Saïd Business School, both of the University of Oxford. Dr. Nash may be reached at: [email protected].
    [Show full text]
  • Congressional Record United States Th of America PROCEEDINGS and DEBATES of the 108 CONGRESS, FIRST SESSION
    E PL UR UM IB N U U S Congressional Record United States th of America PROCEEDINGS AND DEBATES OF THE 108 CONGRESS, FIRST SESSION Vol. 149 WASHINGTON, THURSDAY, FEBRUARY 27, 2003 No. 32 House of Representatives The House met at 1 p.m. MESSAGE FROM THE PRESIDENT port the bill to the House with such amend- The Chaplain, the Reverend Daniel P. ments as may have been adopted. The pre- A message in writing from the Presi- vious question shall be considered as ordered Coughlin, offered the following prayer: dent of the United States was commu- Eternal Father of all, You teach by on the bill and amendments thereto to final nicated to the House by Ms. Wanda passage without intervening motion except touching human hearts, which is far Evans, one of his secretaries. one motion to recommit with or without in- beyond simply changing minds or form- structions. f ing new language. The SPEAKER pro tempore (Mr. By converting deepest desires, You ANNOUNCEMENT BY THE SPEAKER SWEENEY). The gentlewoman from shape priorities of true concern and PRO TEMPORE North Carolina (Mrs. MYRICK) is recog- focus attention on lasting ideas that The SPEAKER. One-minute requests nized for 1 hour. have penetrating consequences. will be at the end of business today. Mrs. MYRICK. Mr. Speaker, for the Your presence in our midst is mani- purpose of debate only, I yield the cus- fested by marvelous deeds which con- f tomary 30 minutes to the gentleman sume debatable words. HUMAN CLONING PROHIBITION from Massachusetts (Mr. MCGOVERN), Send now Your spirit upon the Mem- ACT OF 2003 pending which I yield myself such time bers of the House of Representatives, Mrs.
    [Show full text]
  • Descending Masters: a History of the Raëlian Movement
    CHRISTIAN RESEARCH INSTITUTE P.O. Box 8500, Charlotte, NC 28271 Statement: DD807 DESCENDING MASTERS: A HISTORY OF THE RAËLIAN MOVEMENT By Sharon Fish Mooney This article first appeared in the Volume 24 / Number 3 / 2002 issue of the Christian Research Journal. For further information or to subscribe to the Christian Research Journal go to: www.equip.org/cstore SYNOPSIS UFO fascination has been around for centuries, and events that many have said portend the end of civilization such as wars and natural catastrophes frequently fuel it. Moreover, religious beliefs and UFO interest have always walked hand in hand, often interpreting each other. A relatively new religious movement birthed by a supposed UFO encounter is the Raëlian Movement, a.k.a. Raëlian Religion. The Raëlians made national headlines when an affiliated scientist announced that Clonaid, a company developed by Claude Vorilhon Raël, the movement’s founder, was attempting to clone the first human being by December 2001. Raël himself claims that his religion is science, but a careful analysis of his movement indicates that it is a science wrapped in reinterpretations of primary biblical doctrines. Cloning, in fact, is the ultimate eschatological experiment: “Eternal life, thanks to science” is the Raëlian motto. In the earlier years of UFO study, cult figures and founders liberally borrowed from occult literature; for example, the Theosophical teaching of the “ascended masters.” The Raëlians also have their masters, a group of technologically advanced Beings, who descended to earth in spaceships, creating all of life on this planet some 25,000 years ago. As I looked, behold, a stormy wind came out of the north, and a great cloud, with brightness round about it, and fire flashing forth continually, and in the midst of the fire, as it were gleaming bronze.
    [Show full text]
  • S Human Reproductive Cloning
    9/15/2020 Cloning humans is technically possible. It's curious no one has tried - STAT 1 Human reproductive cloning: The curious incident of the dog in the night-time By Henry T. Greely February 21, 2020 Reprints2 Seven-month-old Dolly poses for photographs in 1997 at the University of Edinburgh's Roslin Institute, where she was cloned and raised. Paul Clements/AP Gregory: Is there any other point to which you would wish to draw my attention? Holmes: To the curious incident of the dog in the night-time. Gregory: The dog did nothing in the night-time. Holmes: That was the curious incident. — Arthur Conan Doyle, “The Adventure of Silver Blaze”3 Sometimes what doesn’t happen is as interesting as what does. Cloning human embryos has been possible for nearly seven years. Yet as far as I know, during that time no one has made a cloned baby or, apparently, has tried to make one. And what I find most surprising is that no one has announced they intend to make one. https://www.statnews.com/2020/02/21/human-reproductive-cloning-curious-incident-of-the-dog-in-the-night-time/ 1/7 9/15/2020 Cloning humans is technically possible. It's curious no one has tried - STAT Why is this surprising? Let’s go back almost 23 years to Feb. 23, 1997. On that day, news leaked out that the scientific journal Nature was about to publish a report of the birth of the first mammal cloned from adult cells — a sheep named Dolly4.
    [Show full text]
  • Creating Clones, Kids & (And) Chimera: Liberal Democratic Compromise at the Crossroads Nathan A
    Notre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics & Public Policy Volume 17 Article 4 Issue 1 Symposium on Bioethics 1-1-2012 Creating Clones, Kids & (and) Chimera: Liberal Democratic Compromise at the Crossroads Nathan A. Adams IV Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarship.law.nd.edu/ndjlepp Recommended Citation Nathan A. Adams IV, Creating Clones, Kids & (and) Chimera: Liberal Democratic Compromise at the Crossroads, 17 Notre Dame J.L. Ethics & Pub. Pol'y 71 (2003). Available at: http://scholarship.law.nd.edu/ndjlepp/vol17/iss1/4 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Notre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics & Public Policy at NDLScholarship. It has been accepted for inclusion in Notre Dame Journal of Law, Ethics & Public Policy by an authorized administrator of NDLScholarship. For more information, please contact [email protected]. CREATING CLONES, KIDS & CHIMERA: LIBERAL DEMOCRATIC COMPROMISE AT THE CROSSROADS NATHAN A. ADAMS, IV* I am thy creature, and I will be even mild and docile to my natural lord and king if thou wilt also perform thy part, that which thou owest me.1 Most agree that biotechnology is leading to a revolution in medicine. Less appreciated is the challenge biotechnology poses to the prevailing liberal democratic consensus pertaining to health and welfare. Biotechnology necessarily impinges upon key health and welfare doctrines at the core of our collective understanding of what it means to advance personal autonomy, self-determination, liberty, and equality within a market economy. Supporters are confident that the biotechnological industry will affirm these values and channel potentially life-saving bio- technological innovations in directions harmless to all but the human embryo.2 They favor essentially a self-regulated industry, where medical professionals decide whether and when to create or modify human clones, kids, and chimera.3 In contrast, oppo- nents of biotechnology fear the natural inclination of the market * Nathan A.
    [Show full text]
  • The Historical Development of Cloning Technology and the Role of Regulation in Ensuring Responsible Applications
    The Historical Development of Cloning Technology and the Role of Regulation in Ensuring Responsible Applications The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters Citation The Historical Development of Cloning Technology and the Role of Regulation in Ensuring Responsible Applications (2003 Third Year Paper) Citable link http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:8852108 Terms of Use This article was downloaded from Harvard University’s DASH repository, and is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Other Posted Material, as set forth at http:// nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of- use#LAA The Historical Development of Cloning Technology and the Role of Regulation in Ensuring Responsible Applications Darcy A. Paul∗ I. Introduction On December 27, 2002 a company called Clonaid announced the birth of a cloned human.1 Clonaid an- nounced the birth of a second child on January 4, 2003.2 Clonaid was founded by the leader of a religious sect known as the Raelians. This individual, a French expatriate named Claude Vorilhon, also goes by the name Rael.3 He and his group are probably the most vociferous and well-known advocates of applying cloning technology to human beings. What motivates the desire to make human clones? Vorilhon, reportedly born out of wedlock, was abandoned by his parents at an early age.4 While cloning may be an attractive option for those in similar situations, aversion to the so-called traditional concept of parentage, where one is reared by biological parents, is not the only reason why people might be interested in cloning as a potential reproductive means.
    [Show full text]
  • Newsweek, Raelians to Clone Humans Jan 13, 2003 P.48
    Newsweek, Raelians to Clone Humans Jan 13, 2003 p.48 Spaced Out: A group that believes life on earth was created by aliens claims to have made the first human clone. Who are the Raelians and where are they hiding 'Eve'? Article by: Jerry Adler. Two thousand years ago a Judean carpenter changed the course of history by offering humanity a path to eternal life. About a week ago a French-born sometime journalist and race-car driver who calls himself Rael tried to do the same thing when his followers announced they had solved the mysteries of human cloning. This was the high point of Rael's second career as a savior, which began when he was taken aboard an alien spaceship and transported to a faraway planet whose inhabitants, the Elohim, had created all life on Earth. For most of the past three decades Rael has been on a mission to replace outmoded religious bunkum with modern, scientific bunkum. "Science is love!" he grandly proclaimed last week in an interview with NEWSWEEK at his Canadian compound--UFOland--near the Vermont border. Soon, he promises, people will be able to make exact genetic copies of themselves, grow them instantaneously to the prime of life and then download all their accumulated memories and traits into the new bodies--the ideal solution for people who want to live forever but find Christianity so... unscientific. In this contest of beliefs, the edge has to go to Christianity, and not just because it numbers 2 billion adherents against 55,000 Raelians. The claims of the former have never been verified by science, but they were meant to be taken on faith in any case.
    [Show full text]
  • Stem Cell Technology: Morality and Immortality in the 21St Century: U.S and World Perspectives
    Stem Cell Technology: Morality and Immortality in the 21st Century: U.S and World Perspectives by Channing Robertson Department of Chemical Engineering Stanford University Stanford, CA 94305 France-Stanford Conference on Risk and Responsibility in Contemporary Engineering and Science: French and U.S. Perspectives Introduction As we enter the 21st century, we face numerous social, technical, scientific and ethical challenges. Of these, research on stem cells looms on the horizon as a particularly difficult issue. It will most likely emerge as one of the great debates of the years ahead, ranking in comparison with the controversies surrounding nuclear arms proliferation, deployment of biological and chemical weapons, in vitro fertilization, contraception, recombinant DNA technologies, and abortion. Research on stem cells aims to provide an understanding about organismic development from a single cell to a complex being, about the repair and replacement mechanisms required to counteract the ravages brought on by damaged cells and tissues, and to provide alternative means for bringing life forth in cases where doing so is not possible through normal procreation. There exists a clear and present moral and ethical divide between those who condone stem cell technology research and the benefits to health care and perhaps even life itself that it might provide and those who consider the harvesting of stem cells from developing embryos to be nothing less than murder. The intersection of religion, belief systems and faith, fundamental values assigned to the human condition, the natural curiosity stoked by unanswered questions about the universe in which we coexist, all conspire to create a tangled network of philosophical chaos, political conflict, legal innuendoes and scientific misinformation.
    [Show full text]
  • CLONING LAWS Egg Cell from Which the Nucleus Has Been Removed
    Attack of the Clones As cloning technology marches forward, state legislatures are faced with some hard decisions. By Alissa Johnson irst, it was sheep. Then, it was “CC,” the cloned house cat. stance the surrounds the nucleus) of the egg cell. FIf a cloned sheep spawned CC’s creator Genetic Savings and Clone, Therapeutic cloning, or cloning for the purpose of research, begins where pet owners can bank Fido’s DNA, then what could spring from in the same way, but development of the organism is typically halted cloned humans? during an early (blastocyst) stage when the original cell has divided Cloning first hit the front page with the birth of Dolly in 1997, a into eight cells. Then, stem cells, which have the unique ability to lamb created using the nucleus of a cell from her mother’s body. Even generate specialized cells, such as liver cells or brain cells, are before then, decision makers were debating the ethics of human extracted for use in scientific research. cloning. In fact, researchers began laying the foundation for cloning technology more than 100 years ago. The clamor of debate, however, FEDERAL REGULATIONS was fueled as never before by an announcement last December that Although the U.S. House of Representatives passed a measure to an obscure religious sect had, indeed, cloned a human being. ban both therapeutic and reproductive cloning in February, the bill is “Cloning a baby is just the first step” toward human immortality, waiting action in the Senate at press time. Several competing bills that said former French journalist Claude Vorihon, who calls himself Rael would prohibit all or some forms of human cloning are also pending and claims to be a direct descendant of extraterrestrials who created in Congress.
    [Show full text]