Portraits of the Songwriting Process in Elementary Classrooms

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Portraits of the Songwriting Process in Elementary Classrooms Graduate Theses, Dissertations, and Problem Reports 2001 Portraits of the songwriting process in elementary classrooms Sally dhruva Stephenson West Virginia University Follow this and additional works at: https://researchrepository.wvu.edu/etd Recommended Citation Stephenson, Sally dhruva, "Portraits of the songwriting process in elementary classrooms" (2001). Graduate Theses, Dissertations, and Problem Reports. 2373. https://researchrepository.wvu.edu/etd/2373 This Dissertation is protected by copyright and/or related rights. It has been brought to you by the The Research Repository @ WVU with permission from the rights-holder(s). You are free to use this Dissertation in any way that is permitted by the copyright and related rights legislation that applies to your use. For other uses you must obtain permission from the rights-holder(s) directly, unless additional rights are indicated by a Creative Commons license in the record and/ or on the work itself. This Dissertation has been accepted for inclusion in WVU Graduate Theses, Dissertations, and Problem Reports collection by an authorized administrator of The Research Repository @ WVU. For more information, please contact [email protected]. PORTRAITS OF THE SONGWRITING PROCESS IN ELEMENTARY CLASSROOMS by Sally dhruvá Stephenson Dissertation submitted to the College of Human Resources and Education at West Virginia University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Education in Curriculum and Instruction Approved by Joy Faini Saab, Ed.D., Chair Ron Iannone, Ed.D. Ardeth Deay, Ph.D. Janet Robbins, Ph.D. Gail Neary Herman, Ph.D. Department of Educational Theory and Practice Morgantown, West Virginia 2001 Keywords: Creative Writing, Portraiture, Arts in Education, Creativity, Qualitative Research © 2001 S.D. Stephenson Abstract Portaits of the Songwriting Process in Elementary Classrooms by Sally dhruvá Stephenson This study uses the qualitative research technique of portraiture to study the songwriting process in elementary classrooms. In chapter one, the author provides a theoretical framework for incorporating the arts and music in general education, and proposes to provide support for incorporating the creative process of songwriting into the elementary curriculum. Chapter two reviews the research literature on the educational and therapeutic uses of songwriting, and published examples of educational applications of songwriting. In chapter three, the methodology of portraiture is explained and four research settings are described, one each in Virginia, West Virginia, Tennessee, and Maryland. Two of the sites involve visiting songwriters-in-residence, and the other two sites involve regular classroom teachers in educational outreach programs sponsored by professional organizations (Country Music Hall of Fame and Metropolitan Opera Guild). In chapter four, the results of the researcher’s observations, interviews, and review of student products are presented as portraits of the songwriting experiences (one for each site). In the final chapter, the author reflects and integrates the four portraits and draws conclusions regarding the four approaches to the songwriting process observed. Inferences from the data are discussed in sections entitled “Collaboration, Cooperation and Engagement,” “Voices of the Children,” and “Authentic Learning Experiences.” The chapter concludes with reflections on the research with recommendations for further study. The researcher suggests that there is sufficient justification, outlined specifically in national and state educational standards, supported by research literature, and brought to life by the experiences and voices of those in the field, to incorporate songwriting into the regular elementary curriculum. Also included are fourteen excerpts from songs written by elementary students, references, and four appendices: interview questions, summary of songwriting pedagogy by site, song topics grouped by theme, and National Standards for Arts Education relating to the songwriting process. iii Dedication This dissertation is dedicated to my advisor, chair, mentor and colleague, Dr. Joy Faini Saab who patiently walked me through my doctoral program from my first inquiry through my graduation and in memory of my father, Dr. Edward Almand Stephenson, always the consummate teacher and scholar, and mother, Eunice Ruth Stephenson, whose belief in me never waned. iv Table of Contents List of Tables......................................................................................................vi List of Figures ...................................................................................................vii List of Songs ....................................................................................................viii Chapter One Introduction and Purpose ..................................................................................1 Progressivism....................................................................................................3 Bloom’s Taxonomy............................................................................................5 Constructivism...................................................................................................7 Creativity Research ...........................................................................................8 Multiple Intelligences Theory...........................................................................10 Arts in Education .............................................................................................11 Music in the Classroom ...................................................................................16 Purpose of this Study ......................................................................................19 Overview of the Chapters................................................................................20 Chapter Two Literature Review ..............................................................................................21 Songwriting in Music Therapy .........................................................................21 Educational Applications of Songwriting..........................................................29 Educational Songwriting in Action ...................................................................37 Chapter Three Methodology: Creating the Portraits..............................................................38 Research Design.............................................................................................38 Selection of Participants..................................................................................41 Description of Sites .........................................................................................42 Data Collection................................................................................................47 Data Analysis ..................................................................................................48 Chapter Four Results: Portraits of the Songwriting Process..............................................52 Site One: On the Train of Creativity................................................................52 In the foothills of Virginia..............................................................................52 Getting the momentum going.......................................................................53 Keeping on track: “When in doubt, sing!”....................................................57 Site Two: The Building Blocks of Songwriting ................................................60 High up in the West Virginia hills. ................................................................60 A framework to go by...................................................................................62 A little bit of recorded history........................................................................70 v Site Three: The Country Music Songwriting Tradition ....................................75 A rich musical environment..........................................................................75 Seeing the pride and glow in their faces. .....................................................77 A toolbox of songwriting skills. .....................................................................79 “The Children Want to Be Heard.” ...............................................................94 Site Four: An Integrated Perspective in a Fragmented World ........................98 On the edge of a multicultural metropolis. ...................................................98 Cooperating to make something “really big” happen. ..................................99 The overwhelming responsibility of writing an opera. ................................101 Telling a story by singing. ..........................................................................105 Weaving the arts into the cloth of the curriculum. ......................................109 Chapter Five Conclusion: Reflections on the Portraits ....................................................113 Collaboration, Cooperation and Engagement ...............................................117 Voices of the Children ...................................................................................122 Authentic Learning Experiences....................................................................125 Reflections on Research ...............................................................................131 References ......................................................................................................135
Recommended publications
  • Teaching the Media with Mouse Woman: Adventures in Imaginative Education
    Teaching the Media with Mouse Woman: Adventures in Imaginative Education by Kymberley Stewart M.A., Simon Fraser University, 2004 Thesis Submitted in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in the Curriculum Theory & Implementation Program Faculty of Education Kymberley Stewart 2014 SIMON FRASER UNIVERSITY Summer 2014 Approval Name: Kymberley Stewart Degree: Doctor of Philosophy (Education) Title: Teaching the Media with Mouse Woman: Adventures in Imaginative Education Examining Committee: Chair: Allan MacKinnon Associate Professor Mark Fettes Senior Supervisor Associate Professor Kieran Egan Supervisor Professor Michael Ling Supervisor Senior Lecturer Lynn Fels Internal/External Examiner Associate Professor Faculty of Education David Jardine External Examiner Professor Faculty of Education University of Calgary Date Defended: August 20, 2014 ii Partial Copyright Licence iii Ethics Statement iv Abstract Concerns have been expressed for decades over the impact of an increasingly media-saturated environment on young children. Media education, however, occupies a somewhat marginal place in compulsory schooling, and its theorists and practitioners have given relatively little attention to the question of how to teach the media to elementary school children. This question is explored through an auto-ethnography and métissage spanning more than twenty years of media use, media studies, and media education. Three shifts in emphasis are particularly central to the thesis. The first is a shift from a protectionist to a more open, albeit critical stance with respect to children‘s media use. The second is a shift from conceiving of media education in terms of a pre-packaged curriculum towards the co-construction of learning experiences with the students, guided by Egan‘s theory of imaginative education.
    [Show full text]
  • 2020 Southern California Young Writers Awards
    presents 2020 Southern California Young Writers Awards Illustration by Maia Tumbokon age 13 The dA Center for the Arts Pomona , CA Inclusive | Accessible | Equitable ARTS for All Introduction We are delighted to announce the results of the 1st Southern California Young Writers' Awards, formally the Mrs. Nelson’s Young Writers’ Awards founded in 1997 by author Q.L. Pearce. We received 23 submissions from students whose ages ranged from 6 to 16. Their stories range in length, topic, style and focus, some ending joyfully, others tragically, and a good many mysteriously. A few students wrote wittily and with passion about the ups and downs and pleasures of everyday life, two wrote clever poems, but a greater number jumped the fence into science fiction, magic, outer space and Vampire territory— stretching their imaginations and their readers’ as well. A box in the attic is opened and a magical story line unrolls; a sip of “Shrink water” and a heroine slips into an unknown world and returns with a husband. Princesses are saved, Aliens conquer, matches are made and lovers are lost. And although all the stories were submitted by the February 2020 deadline, it is striking that so many of them touch on the unpredictability of life, and the unforeseen events that can sweep us into new and unfamiliar worlds. “Listen to the children” has always been a wise advisory, and the stories they write, at whatever level of sophistication, merit our attention and encouragement. Martha Fay is a freelance writer and editor and the author of three works of nonfiction, most recently Out of Line, The Art of Jules Feiffer.
    [Show full text]
  • The Mississippi Mass Choir
    R & B BARGAIN CORNER Bobby “Blue” Bland “Blues You Can Use” CD MCD7444 Get Your Money Where You Spend Your Time/Spending My Life With You/Our First Feelin's/ 24 Hours A Day/I've Got A Problem/Let's Part As Friends/For The Last Time/There's No Easy Way To Say Goodbye James Brown "Golden Hits" CD M6104 Hot Pants/I Got the Feelin'/It's a Man's Man's Man's World/Cold Sweat/I Can't Stand It/Papa's Got A Brand New Bag/Feel Good/Get on the Good Foot/Get Up Offa That Thing/Give It Up or Turn it a Loose Willie Clayton “Gifted” CD MCD7529 Beautiful/Boom,Boom, Boom/Can I Change My Mind/When I Think About Cheating/A LittleBit More/My Lover My Friend/Running Out of Lies/She’s Holding Back/Missing You/Sweet Lady/ Dreams/My Miss America/Trust (featuring Shirley Brown) Dramatics "If You come Back To Me" CD VL3414 Maddy/If You Come Back To Me/Seduction/Scarborough Faire/Lady In Red/For Reality's Sake/Hello Love/ We Haven't Got There Yet/Maddy(revisited) Eddie Floyd "Eddie Loves You So" CD STAX3079 'Til My Back Ain't Got No Bone/Since You Been Gone/Close To You/I Don't Want To Be With Nobody But You/You Don't Know What You Mean To Me/I Will Always Have Faith In You/Head To Toe/Never Get Enough of Your Love/You're So Fine/Consider Me Z. Z.
    [Show full text]
  • 2Pac Greatest Hits 01 Keep Ya Head up 02 2 of Amerikaz Most Wanted
    Downloaded from: justpaste.it/yp43 2Pac Greatest Hits 01 Keep ya head up 02 2 Of amerikaz most wanted 03 Temptations 04 God bless the dead 05 Hail Mary 06 Me against the world 07 How do u want it 08 So many tears 09 Unconditional love 10 Trapped 11 Life goes on 12 Hit 'em up 13 Troublesome 96' 14 Brenda's got a baby 15 I ain't mad at cha 16 I get around 17 Changes 18 California love (original version) 19 Picture me rollin' 20 How long will they mourn me 21 Toss it up 22 Dear mama 23 All about you 24 To live & die in L.A. 25 Heartz of men A Teens Greatest Hits (2004) 01 Mamma Mia 02 Upside down 03 Gimme gimme gimme 04 Floorfiller 05 Dancing queen 06 A perfect match 07 To the music 08 Halfway around the world 09 Sugar rush 10 Super trouper 11 Heartbreak lullaby 12 Can't help falling in love 13 Let your heart do all the talking 14 The final cut 15 With or without you 16 I promised myself A Teens Greatest Hits Back A Teens Greatest Hits CD A Teens Greatest Hits A ha Greatest Hits (Ltd.Ed (2CD) 2009 101 a ha foot of the mountain atrium 102 a ha celice atrium 103 a ha summer moved on atrium 104 a ha lifelines atrium 105 a ha the bandstand atrium 106 a ha dont do me any favours atrium 107 a ha minor earth major sky atrium 108 a ha analogue atrium 109 a ha velvet atrium 110 a ha mother nature goes to heaven atrium 111 a ha the sun never shone that day atrium 112 a ha forever not yours atrium 113 a ha you wanted more atrium 114 a ha cosy prisons atrium 115 a ha shadowside atrium 116 a ha thought that it was you atrium 117 a ha little black heart
    [Show full text]
  • Reflections on a Pandemic Thoughts, Considerations, Poems, Philosophies & Understandings
    REFLECTIONS ON A PANDEMIC THOUGHTS, CONSIDERATIONS, POEMS, PHILOSOPHIES & UNDERSTANDINGS NOELLE BIEHLE intin awingI 1 Open with INTRODUCTION The coronavirus pandemic has changed us all. No one could have predicted the ways in which we would become different, in our outlooks, our physical living conditions, and in the ways we connect (or don’t) with each other. Towards the end of April, I sent our seventh graders a collection of questions, created by the organization Facing History and Ourselves. The same organization created an activity called “Toolbox for Care,” in which students we asked to put together a collection of items for both self-care and care for others. What follows is their thoughts and ideas during the time of quarantine. Thank you, Noelle, for your breathtaking art! Frieda Katz At this time where there is a worldwide pandemic spreading fear and anguish across the globe, pain is unavoidable. It can be the mental pain of losing a family member, friends or physical pain where the virus has gotten to you. The pain can also be subtle, such as missing friends who are trapped inside their homes like 2 yourself. This pain is a reflection of how human interaction is vital for people to survive through life. Distress can cause depression or stressing about education, work, sports or health. The corona virus has brought more stress around the world than anything else my generation has seen. The serenity of isolation, Alone on a hill of daisies, As bright as the sun blinding my eyes, Forcing them to close, and eventually relax under the heat, My feet brushing against the grass, Filled with warmth but at the same time, Swaying to the rhythm of the autumn’s breeze, If only this was real, Such peace, No wars or diseases or death, Coming from behind, And grabbing your loved ones from your shaking arms, Not looking back once too see the pain it's brought, To a broken world, Never perfect, Never will be perfect.
    [Show full text]
  • The Experiences of Historically Black College and University Graduates in Pursuit of an Advanced Degree From
    From There to Here: The Experiences of Historically Black College and University Graduates in Pursuit of an Advanced Degree from a Predominately White Research University A dissertation presented to the faculty of The Patton College of Education of Ohio University In partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree Doctor of Philosophy ShaRonda M. Cooper April 2017 © 2017 ShaRonda M. Cooper. All Rights Reserved 2 This dissertation titled From There to Here: The Experiences of Historically Black College and University Graduates in Pursuit of an Advanced Degree from a Predominately White Research University by SHARONDA M. COOPER has been approved for the Department of Counseling and Higher Education and The Patton College of Education by Peter C. Mather Professor of Counseling and Higher Education Renée A. Middleton Dean, The Patton College of Education 3 Abstract COOPER, SHARONDA M., Ph.D., April 2017, Higher Education From There to Here: The Experiences of Historically Black College and University Graduates in Pursuit of an Advanced Degree from a Predominately White Research University Director of Dissertation: Peter C. Mather As defined by the U.S. Commission on Civil Rights (2010) HBCUs are “colleges or universities that existed before 1964 that have a historic and contemporary mission of educating African-Americans” (p.8). These institutions have served a critical role in research, diversification of the professoriate (Allen & Jewell, 2002), educational opportunity, and more importantly the pipeline used by some African Americans to graduate school (Louis, Phillips, Louis, & Smith, 2015). Over the past three decades educational research centering on Black students and/or HBCUs have often centered on the undergraduate level with focus on issues such as retention and academics and less on the impact of student experiences and higher achieving academic pursuits.
    [Show full text]
  • The BG News September 25, 1992
    Bowling Green State University ScholarWorks@BGSU BG News (Student Newspaper) University Publications 9-25-1992 The BG News September 25, 1992 Bowling Green State University Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.bgsu.edu/bg-news Recommended Citation Bowling Green State University, "The BG News September 25, 1992" (1992). BG News (Student Newspaper). 5417. https://scholarworks.bgsu.edu/bg-news/5417 This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 4.0 License. This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the University Publications at ScholarWorks@BGSU. It has been accepted for inclusion in BG News (Student Newspaper) by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks@BGSU. G The BG News Friday, September 25, 1992 Bowling Green, Ohio Volume 75, Issue 23 Weather Hope of Toledo train stop derailed by Mitch Weiss The Associated Press He is scheduled to leave from The local economy has wor- Columbus and stop in Marysville sened since then. in central Ohio and Arlington and In the past decade, Toledo has TOLEDO - Democrats said Bowling Green in the northwest lost thousands of manufacturing Frazee, Reed residents Thursday that before heading to Michigan. jobs. In the last three years, more President The train will pass through than 15,000 jobs have been elim- Bush's decision Toledo but will not stop, said inated or moved to other cities excited to see president to bypass Thomas Noe, chairman of the with lower labor and utility costs. by Jane Kllgore right here where the action is Toledo during a Lucas County Republican Party.
    [Show full text]
  • Holy Diver. ("0, ( 1983 1\'Arner Bros
    ctP3 _o 88049GRE ENL YMON T OO ARAV MONTY GREENLY htC SM 14011 03 10 S 374 0 EL M UCY' LONG. BE ACH CA 90807 NEWSPAPER I A Billboard Publication The International Newsweekly Of Music & Home Entertainment June 11, 1983 $3 (U.S.) ALBUM VCR Action CONFIGURATIONS MULTIPLY AFM Agrees Spurs Entries Odd Formats Vex Dealers on Royalties By EARL PAIGE John Denver's next album, like its original, but this helps." Even so, In Blank Tape and SAM SUTHERLAND predecessor, to ship in both conven- Spano suspects the public views For Vielclips tional and digitally mastered audio- many limited edition titles and spe- NEW YORK -This week's Con- LOS ANGELES -Valuable mer- phile versions; and fresh activity in cial packages as "gimmick releases." By LAURA FOTI sumer Electronics Show in Chicago chandising hooks or confusing gim- the realm of oversized cassette mer- More critical is Norman Hunter, is scheduled to see some major mar- micks? Retail and one -stop buyers chandising packs. purchasing manager for recorded NEW YORK -The American ket entries in the blank videotape appear divided over the prolifer- A &M, meanwhile, ships its new product at the 149 -unit Record Bar Federation of Musicians (AFM) and field, as well as instances of market- ation of unusial record /tape prod- Police album, "Synchronicity," in 36 of Durham, N.C. They should at label representatives have reached ing redirection and the launch of a uct, price and packaging configura- different cover graphic combina- least have changed the stock num- agreement on royalty payments for full spate of promotional cam- tions.
    [Show full text]
  • M:\> Dir /D /S > Listing.Txt Volume in Drive M Is Export Volume
    M:\> dir /D /S > Listing.txt Volume in drive M is Export Volume Serial Number is 34E8-1268 Directory of M:\ [1492 The Conquest Of Paradise] [2 Many DJ's - As Heard On Radio Soulwax - 09] [2004rehearsals] [28 Days Later] [2Fast 2Furious] [A Beautiful Mind] [A Mighty Wind] [AC-DC - High Voltage [ReMaster]] [AC-DC - Highway To Hell [Remaster]] [AC_DC - Back In Black] [aerobitch] [Aerosmith - Pandora's Box] [Alanis Morissette - Out Is Through (CD-Single)] [Alexander OST] [Alice In Chains - Dirt] [Alice In Chains - facelift] [America-JonStewart] [American Idol] [American President] [American Steel - Jagged Thoughts] [Andrew Lloyd Webber] [Angelo Badalamenti - Twin Peaks] [Apocalypse Now] [Arrested Developement - 3 Years, 5 Months & 2 Days in the Life Of] [At Home With The Munsters] [Atomic Kitten] [AuntBeanie's1stPrizeBeets] [Avril Lavigne - Let Go] [Avril Lavigne - Under My Skin] [B.B. King] [Back To The Future Complete Soundtrack Disc 02 of 03] [Band Of Brothers] [Barefoot Adventure - Bud Shank] [Batman - Original TV Soundtrack] [Beastie Boys - To The 5 Buroughs] [Beatles] [Beck - Mellow Gold] [Beck - Odelay] [Beetlejuice Complete] [Best Of John Williams] [Bette Midler - Greatest Hits] [Betty White Selects Music for Cha Cha Cha Dancing] [Beyonce - Dangerously In Love] [Big Bands - Big Band Fever - Volume II] [Big Country - Singles Collection 4 CD5 Fragile Thing] [Big Gun Down] [Big_Easy] [Billy Idol - Storytellers (Live)] [Billy Joel - Greatest Hits Volume 1] [Billy Joel - Greatest Hits Volume II] [Bj”rk - Debut] [Black Flag - Everything
    [Show full text]
  • Newspeak Volume 19, Issue 7, February 26, 1991 the Tudes Nts of Worcester Polytechnic Institute
    Worcester Polytechnic Institute DigitalCommons@WPI Newspeak All Issues Newspeak 2-26-1991 Newspeak Volume 19, Issue 7, February 26, 1991 The tudeS nts of Worcester Polytechnic Institute Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.wpi.edu/newspeak Recommended Citation The tudeS nts of Worcester Polytechnic Institute, "Newspeak Volume 19, Issue 7, February 26, 1991" (1991). Newspeak All Issues. Book 419. http://digitalcommons.wpi.edu/newspeak/419 This Book is brought to you for free and open access by the Newspeak at DigitalCommons@WPI. It has been accepted for inclusion in Newspeak All Issues by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@WPI. Motives behind BVOB policy uncovered by)ot Parbr recruit members through a good IO· Sagma Alpha Ep~ilon (whach hao; a ties to do as much 2!. they possibly can 1. No Common Containers News EdiJor surance policy. fair rcrmo;. and an at­ WPI chapter) implemented a policy do to reduce ri~ks and prevent liabality A) A "common container' is de­ tractive price. The overall APG pro­ samllar to that which the APG pre­ claims." The adoption of the FIPG fined as any alcohol which has unrc­ A almo 1 everyone on campus gram is beller than what a fratemny scribes in 19R6. and·~ clearly a fore­ plan eems to be the answer. tricted public access and or is for the must know by now. on January 22. would be able to obtain on its own." runner to the current FIPG pohey. It Graduates. alumni, and current purpose of mru.~ consumption (i.e. 1991. the Inter Fraternity Council TFCs around the country arc adopc­ state~ "No purchase of alcoholic bev­ members who are used to liberal alco­ kegs, beer balls, barrels of beeT, etc ..
    [Show full text]