Cbi), Rohini, Delhi
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
IN THE COURT OF SPECIAL JUDGE-II (PREVENTION OF CORRUPTION ACT) (CBI), ROHINI, DELHI ID No. 02404R0008692008 CC No. 37/2010 RC No. 3(A)/04/ACU.IX/NEW DELHI CBI Vs 1. Vidya Dhar, IAS S/o Sh. Ram Swarup R/o V & PO Dhabdhani, Tehsil & District Bhiwani, Haryana. 2. Sher Singh Badshami S/o Late Sh. Karta Ram R/o (i) 931, Sector-5, Kurukshetra, Haryan. (ii) 327 Sector-4, M.D. Complex, Panchkula, Haryana. 3. Sanjiv Kumar, IAS S/o Dr. Maheshwar Kumar R/o Flat No. 6360, Sec.-C, Pkt. 6&7 Vasant Kunj, New Delhi-70. 4. Om Prakash Chautala S/o Late Sh. Devi Lal R/o (i) V & PO-Chautala, Tehsil ± Dabwali, Sirsa, Haryana,. (ii) 231-232, Chautala House, Barnala Road, Sirsa, Haryana. (iii) Tejakhera Farm-House Village Tejakhera, Tehsil Dabwali, Sirsa, Haryana. 5. Ajay Singh Chautala S/o Sh. Om Prakash Chautala R/o (i) 231-232 Chautala House, Barnala Road, Sirsa, Haryana. (ii) 18 Janpath, New Delhi. 6. Smt. Prem Bahl W/o Sh. Balbir Kumar Bahl R/o House No. 925, Sec. 7, Urban Estate, Ambala City, Haryana. 7. Smt. Shashi Malhotra W/o Sh. Prabhu Sharan Rai Nayyar R/o H. No. 10, Vikash Vihar, Ambala City, Haryana. 8. Smt. Krishna Gupta W/o Sh. Om Prakash Malhotra R/o H. No. 74, Vijay Nagar, Ambala City, Haryana. 9. Brahma Nand S/o Sh. Chandgi Ram R/o Village Ninar, Post Office Kaunt, Bhiwani, Haryana. 10. Ms Vinod Kumari D/o Sh. Harbans Lal Sharma R/o 100, Ram Nagar, Bhiwani, Haryana. 11. Maman Chand S/o Sh. Pala Ram R/o (i) A-12/ Geeta Colony, Bhbiwani. (ii) Village & Post Office Devasar District Bhiwani, Haryana. 12. Sawan Lal S/o Sh. Gurdayal R/o 50, Kamala Nagar, Bhiwani, Haryana. 13. Smt. Kanta Sharma W/o Sh. Bhim Singh Sharma R/o 3928, Sector 22-D, Chandigarh. 14. Sh. Prabhu Dayal (expired before filing of the charge sheet) S/o Sh. Aud Ram R/o Village & Post Office Khabra Kalan, Bhatukala, District, Fatehabad, Haryana. 15. Smt. Phool Khurana W/o Sh. Bhupinder Pal R/o Old Post Office Street, Bhuna, Fatehabad, Haryana. Present address : H. No. 1386, Village Bhuna, Block-4, Tehsil Fatehabad, District Hissar, Haryana. 16. Harbans Lal S/o Sh. Sadi Lal R/o Village & PO Ramgarh, Near PNB, Ramgarh, District Alwar, Rajashtan. 17. Ram Saran Kukreja S/o Sh. Khem Chand R/o 127, Vijay Colony, Jawahar Nagar, Hissar, Haryana. 18. Udal Prasad Sharma (expired during trial on 05.12.2012) S/o Sh. Badri Prasad Sharma R/o 1398, Parvatia Colony, Faridabad, Haryana. 19. Brij Mohan (discharged on 23.7.2011) S/o Sh. Shri Ram Sharma R/o 365, Near Shradha Nand Park, New Colony, Palwal, Haryana. 20. Chand Singh Verma S/o Sh. Kirpa Ram Verma R/o 591/18, Om Nagar, Khandsa Road, Gurgaon, Haryana. 21. Yogesh Kumar Sharma S/o Sh. B. R. Sharma R/o 860, Sector-7, Extn. Urban Estate, Gurgaon, Haryana. 22. Smt. Abhilash Kaur W/o Sh. Sardar Singh R/o 107, Pratap Nagar, Jail Road, New Delhi. 23. Sher Singh S/o Sh. Nand Ram R/o Village & Post Office Mandhan, Tehsil Tosham, District Bhiwani, Haryana. 24. Anar Singh S/o Sh. Neki Ram R/o (i) H. No. C-37, Surya Vihar, Near Sec. 4, Police outpost, Gurgaon, Haryana. (ii) H.No. 1446 ± Huda, Sector-6, Bahadur Garh, Haryana. 25. Smt. Kailash Kaushik W/o Sh. Karna Singh Kaushik R/o H. No. 1132, Housing Board Colony, Jind. 26. Ajit Singh Sangwan S/o Sh. Moji Ram R/o Vidya Nagar, Mehram Road, Bhiwani, Haryana. 27. Smt. Ram Kaur W/o Sh. Om Prakash R/o H. No. 1498, Urban State, Jind, Haryana. 28. Mahavir Singh Lathar S/o Sh. Balraj Singh Lathar R/o Shadipur, Julana, District Jind, Haryana. 29. Narain Singh Ruhil S/o Sh. Preet Singh R/o (Present) H.No. 66, Officers Colony Kunj Pura Road, Karnal, Haryana. (Permanent): Village & PO Beholi, District Panipat, Haryana. 30. Krishan Lal Narang S/o Sh. L. R. Narang R/o H. No. 1973, Sector-13 Urban Estate, Karnal, Haryana. 31. Smt. Usha Rani W/o Sh. Radha Krishan Chanana R/o 847, Sector-13, Urban Estate, Karnal, Haryana. 32. Madan Lal Kalra S/o Sh. Jai Lal Kalra R/o (i) House No. B-4, D.C. Colonyu, Kurukshetra. (ii) House No. 534, Modal Town, Jind Road, Kaithal, Haryana. 33. Veer Bhan Mehta S/o Sh. Thakur Das Mehta R/o Ward No. 6, Village & Post Office, Indri District, Karnal, Haryana. 34. Shashi Bhushan (expired during trial on 12.11.2008) S/o Sh. Atma Ram R/o H. No. 1142, Sec.-13, Urban State, Kurukshetra, Haryana. 35. Dilbag Singh S/o Sh. Lehri Singh R/o House No. 320, Ward No. 1, Charkhi Dadri, District Bhiwani, Haryana. 36. Ram Kumar S/o Sh. Bhana Ram R/o Mandir Wali Gali-6, Patel Nagar, Kaithal, Haryana. 37. Pushkar Mal Verma S/o Sh. Ram Chander Verma R/o H. No. 1360, Mohalla Shiv Colony, Opp. Panchayat Bhawan, Narnaul, District Mahendergarh, Haryana. 38. Durga Dutt Pradhan S/o Sh. Maha Ram Sharma R/o Gali New Sari, Sain Chowk Road, Narnaul, Haryana. 39. Bani Singh S/o Sh. Amar Singh R/o Mohalla Sainipura, Mahendergarh, Haryana. 40. Smt. Daya Saini W/o Sh. B. S. Saini R/o H. No. 396/1, Sector ± 44, Chandigarh. 41. Ram Singh S/o Sh. Surat Singh R/o Village & Post Office Sheikh Pura, District, Karnal, Haryana. 42. Puran Chand (Expired during trial on 03.12.2012) S/o Sh. Lachhaman Das R/o H. No. 301, Ward No. 11, Panipat, Haryana. 43. Sheesh Pal Singh S/o Sh. Hoshiar Singh R/o (i) 1165, Sector-15, Sonepat. (ii) 257, Sarojini Colony, Yamuna Nagar, Haryana. 44. Smt. Rekha Sharma W/o Late Sh. Ravi Dutt Sharma R/o H. No. 438, Sec.-16, Punchkula, Haryana. 45. Smt. Raksha Jindal W/o Sh.R. C. Jindal R/o 1383, Sec.-15, Punchkula, Haryana. 46. Jeet Ram Khokhar S/o Sh. Shobh Ram R/o H. No. 326, Opposite Power House, Modal Town, Rohtak, Haryana. 47. Smt. Nirmal Devi W/o Sh. Dhambir Singh R/o 813/23, DLF Colony, Rohtak, Haryana. 48. Amar Singh S/o Sh. Ram Krishan R/o Village & PO Meham, Mohalla, Kharikuri, District Rohtak, Haryana. 49. Smt. Sudha Sachdeva W/o Sh. R. S. Sachdeva R/o H. No. 72A, Model Town, Near Shravan Jayanti Park, Rewari, Haryana. 50. Darshan Dayal Verma S/o Sh. Vasudev Prasad Verma R/o 380, Agarsain Colony, Sirsa, Haryana. 51. Smt. Saroj Sharma W/o Sh. R. B. Dutta R/o H. No. 207, Sec.-7, Gurgaon, Haryana. 52. Tulsi Ram Ram Bihagra S/o Sh. Ram Swaroop R/o 251, Street-7, Gulabi Bagh, Rewari, Haryana. 53. Nathu Ram (expired during trial on 17.01.2012) S/o Sh. Kurara Ram R/o Village Adampur, Post Office Mandi Adampur, District Hissar, Haryana. 54. Om Prakash Tiwari S/o Sh. Mangat Ram Tiwari R/o Nahoria Bazar, Sirsa, Haryana. 55. Bihari Lal S/o Sh. Pat Ram R/o 15/249, Bansal Colony, Sirsa, Haryana. 56. Rajender Singh Dahiya S/o Sh. Hoshiar Singh R/o H. No. 62, 8-Marla, Sonepat, Haryana. 57. Dalip Singh S/o Sh. Chand Ram R/o 245/5/3 Adarsh Nagar, Gohana, District Sonepat, Haryana. 58. Smt. Kamla Devi (expired before filing of the charge sheet) W/o Sh. Ranbir Singh R/o 174 L 9A), Model Town, Sonepat, Haryana. 59. Rajender Pal Singh S/o Sh. Ranbir Singh R/o House No. 3903/D, Sec. 22, Chandigarh. (Permanent Address: 365, Jagat Colony, Bhiwani, Haryana). 60. Sarwan Kumar Chawla S/o Sh. Manohar Lal Chawla R/o 44, Madhu Colony, Behind Madhu Cinema, Yamuna Nagar, Haryana. 61. Smt. Urmil Sharma W/o Late Sh. Ramesh Chander Sharma R/o 72, Krishna Colony, Yamuna Nagar, ITI Road, Haryana. 62. Joginder Lal S/o Sh. Ram Lal R/o 1026, Dwarka Puri, Jagadhari, District Yamuna Nagar, Haryana. O R D E R ON S E N T E N C E 22.01.2013 Most of the convicts are senior citizens and all of them suffer from various ailments. Some of them are seriously ill. Many of them have their spouses, children and parents, who suffer from interminable diseases. Some of the unfortunate convicts have the burden of supporting their minor grand children due to the death of their sons. A few of them are physically challenged. Many of these convicts have been deserted by their children in their old age. In this background, this judgment of conviction, it is argued, has shattered them beyond redemption. 2. Sh. S.K. Saxena, Adv. has prayed fervently for showing leniency in awarding sentence to Om Prakash Chautala due to his old age, physical challenge and various ailments. It is argued that Om Prakash Chautala, Ajay Singh Chautala and Sher Singh Badshami have heavily suffered in terms of their political career because after the registration of this case, their party had lost the power and individually these convicts have lost elections successively. It is further argued that even this conviction is an enough punishment for them because it is difficult for them to show face to the society. 3. Ld. Counsels for convicts have submitted their medical records and the medical records of their family members in support of their submissions. I find no reason not to believe the aforesaid submissions of Ld. Counsels for convicts. However, these aspects are not relevant to the question of the quantum of sentence.