METAlliance ON AI’S IMPLICATIONS FOR PRODUCTION MUSIC—PAGE 25 Desert Island Mics
PAGE 27 news
Volume 40 No. 10 www.prosoundnetwork.com October 2018 Recording prosoun 18 Dave Grohl’s STATE OF THE INDUSTRY Epic Play This summer, Foo Fighters frontman Dave Grohl released a 23-minute solo SOUND REINFORCEMENT RECORDING track, “Play,” performing all seven instruments in single, unbroken takes. BY CLIVE YOUNG BY STEVE HARVEY Engineer Darrell Thorp reveals how it all went down. ll industries are dependent on the state of the economy. ast year was the third straight year of growth for the The sound reinforcement business is no different— global record business, with music sales up from 2016 A which means it’s been going full steam ahead this year, L by over 8 percent, to $17.3 billion, according to the powered in part by low unemployment and a public in a spend- annual report released in April by IFP, which represents the thrift mood. recording industry worldwide. Streaming was at the heart of The U.S. Consumer Sentiment Index, tracked by the Uni- those figures, with digital revenues accounting for the first versity of Michigan, hit 96.2 in August, not far from the 101.4 it time for just over half of industry income around the world. reached in March—the highest point it’s hit since 2004. Despite “We’re in a renaissance now,” says Glenn Swan, man- signs of inflation starting to kick in, consumers are feeling good ager and director of music production for Premier Studios in about spending money, citing future income and job stabil- New York City. Premier, which encompasses four rooms, two ity. The university’s chief economist, Richard Curtin, observed, acquired from Quad NYC in 2010, and rents an entire floor “Consumers have not yet judged the current rate of inflation (continued on page 48) The Evil as a significant source of erosion in their living standards or as That Men 38 a cause to reduce their buying plans,” and noted that personal consumption can be expected to grow by 2.6 percent in the year Mix ahead. Rob Zombie and Marilyn Manson All of this directly affects the sound reinforcement commu- teamed this summer for the Twins of (continued on page 48) Evil tour; now Zombie’s tight-knit crew shares how they made bad sound so good.
THE SONICS OF SMITH—UK crooner Sam Smith is circling the globe behind his hit album The Thrill of It All with audio provided by UK-based Capital Sound. A massive d&b audiotechnik P.A., with multiple hangs of 20 J8s each, helps cover sold-out arenas nightly. For more on the tour, see page 36.
soundBUSINESS [ 5 ] Italy’s RCF Group Acquires EAW
BY CLIVE YOUNG ly, the deal comes some 15 years af- sold off this year, following in the ter RCF itself was divested by Loud steps of Ampeg, which was sold to Ya- WHITINSVILLE, MA—Italian pro au- Technologies, an earlier iteration of maha in mid-May, and Martin Audio, dio conglomerate RCF Group has Loud Audio, in December 2003. which was subject to a management acquired Eastern Acoustic Works EAW will remain an independent buyout in July. The remaining brands (EAW) from Loud Audio. Ironical- company, according to RCF Group under Loud Audio are Mackie, Crate, CEO Arturo Vicari. “We can look at Blackheart and Tapco. a bright future together,” he said in a Loud and Transom announced briefs statement. “Being part of our group that with the sale of EAW, they have will provide EAW with the necessary completed their planned divestitures investments and focus for a fast and of brands—a move they say will help Williams Sound, solid growth. We are very proud to the company narrow its focus to its have EAW with us.” remaining pro audio brand, Mackie. Pointmaker Now Headquartered in Reggio Emilia “While I have truly enjoyed work- Williams AV and Bologna, Italy, RCF has subsid- ing with all of the brands in the Loud minneapolis, mn—In the wake iaries in the United States and Eu- legacy, now it’s time for us to turn the of Williams Sound’s acquisition of rope, and operates under the compa- page and focus entirely on building unique partners and customers. I Pointmaker last year, the two com- nies RCF and AEB Industriale (dB the Mackie brand,” said Alex Nelson, look forward to the continued devel- panies have launched a new com- Technologies). Founded in 1949, Mackie’s president. “Our companies opment of Mackie and EAW under RCF has 500 employees and its prod- have long lived in a conglomeration new and more focused ownership.” mon brand and corporate identity as ucts are sold in more than 130 coun- of brands, and I believe going for- In a separate statement, Smith of- Williams AV (www.williamsav.com). tries around the world—an effort that ward all the brands are going to ben- fered, “For those who love EAW, it The overall organization will be called it expects to bolster on an interna- efit from newfound focus, alignment is difficult to imagine a better sce- Williams AV, while its products will tional scale with the acquisition of and investment. This last divestiture nario. From the first moment this be categorized under one of two E AW. marks a particularly exciting time for possibility started to materialize, it major product lines—appropriately, Founded in 1978, EAW was Mackie employees worldwide who has been clear that joining forces with Williams Sound or Pointmaker. The bought by Mackie Designs in Febru- are now about to embark on a jour- RCF Group is a great opportunity for rebranded company offers digital, ary 2000 to complement the latter’s ney of reinvention and revitalization.” EAW. This transaction is a true rec- FM, infrared and induction loop wire- portfolio of brands, which includ- It’s a sentiment that was echoed ognition of what the brand represents less audio, as well as video annota- ed Radio Cine Forniture (RCF) at by Dom Harter, managing director of and its potential, as well as the team tion and presentation systems. the time, acquired in 1998. In order Martin Audio, when he spoke to Pro we have built over recent years. With to differentiate between the Mackie Sound News in August about his com- gratitude to the long list of those who Hal Leonard, brand and its parent company, Mack- pany’s MBO from Loud, noting, “We built EAW over its 40-year history, we Avid Team Up ie Designs was renamed Loud Tech- can now make the decisions wholly look forward to the exciting time in burlington, ma—Avid (www.avid. nologies in 2003—the same year that for the benefit of Martin Audio rather front of us.” com) and music media publisher/ Loud divested RCF. The company than a larger multi-brand organiza- Loud Audio distributor Hal Leonard. (www.hal- was later renamed Loud Audio when tion.” www.loudaudio.com leonard.com) have entered into a Transom Capital Group purchased TJ Smith, president of EAW, five-year agreement to distribute the Loud Technologies and all its related added, “Having grown up with the EAW latter’s creative tools through the for- brands in October 2017. EAW and Mackie brands, I can truly www.EAW.com mer’s network of resellers around the In the wake of Transom’s acquisi- say that this is an exciting moment. globe. The agreement is among Avid’s tion of Loud Audio, the EAW sale Both brands are now in a significant- RCF Group largest distribution deals to date and marks the third Loud brand to be ly stronger position to support their www.rcf-group.it is said to represent a multimillion-dol- lar value to Avid annually, while pro- viding for Hal Leonard’s distribution of professional audio and video prod- ucts through authorized resellers in VER Exits Bankruptcy, Reorganizes the Americas, Australia, New Zealand LAS VEGAS, NV—VER, which provides pany, GSO Capital Partners and and selected countries in EMEA. audio gear and engineering for the PRG Management, under the new Roland Opens in music touring industry as well as corporate structure, PRG chairman equipment to the film and TV indus- and CEO Jere Harris now has roles London try, has emerged from bankruptcy for the combined company, while london, uk—Aiming to reach produc- and been reorganized. Stephan Paridaen is president and ers, engineers, instrumentalists and In April, VER entered into an COO of the combined company and music business professionals, Roland agreement to merge with Production Bob Krakauer is CEO of VER. (www.roland.com) has opened the Resource Group, bringing together As PRG already offers lighting, “We believe that this approach Roland Artist Centre London, located two of the largest event production video, media servers and staging for will bring about innovation, an excit- within Metropolis Studios in West companies in North America, but as tours, it expects to draw on VER’s ing level of service, and even more London. The center will be a hub part of the transaction, VER filed vol- tour audio gear and background in transformative collaboration with our for a variety of activities, including untary petitions for Chapter 11. order to provide complete services partners. It feels historic, not only for product support, social media initia- VER will continue to exist as a for tours, festivals and events. VER’s PRG and VER, but for the entertain- tives, interviews, sessions, streaming traditional business-to-business sub- audio division, VER Tour Sound, ment industry,” said Harris in a state- events, photo shoots, gear demos rental platform, renting to AV staging has provided audio services for such ment. and more. The move comes on the companies and industry profession- productions since it was founded in VER heels of new Roland Artist Centers als. Meanwhile, full-service solutions January 2013. Combined, VER and www.ver.com in Nashville and Los Angeles, which will transition to PRG, and the two PRG will have approximately 70 loca- opened in June and May, respectively. companies will continue to operate tions across five continents. Production Resource Group separately. Controlled by the Jordan Com- www.prg.com
[ October 2018 ] [ 6 ] CONTENTS news provol. 40 no. 10soundOctober 2018 SOUNDRECORDING DEPARTMENTS How UK Producers Created Grime..18 Sound Business 5 Grime is one of UK music’s big success stories in recent times, but despite the high accolades and Classifieds 49 equally high sales of today, it was the low-fi, DIY techniques of young producers that first generated Sound People 46 the unique sound. Advertiser Index 48 Studio Showcase: 416 Wabash ...... 20 Indianapolis’ 416 Wabash is a 7,800-square-foot flexible space that combines a well-appointed music studio with an all-purpose event facility— CHARTS and it’s a well thought-out hit. Tracks 22 SOUNDPOST/BROADCAST Centerstage 44 AI’s Implications for Production Music...... 25 Artificial intelligence software is already writing SPECIAL REPORT production music; now AI music platforms may be State of the Industry. . . . 1 [18] impacting composers and their audio partners, too. Pro Sound News’ annual compre- hensive overviews of the record- The Rules and Tools Behind the Mixes of ing and live sound industries, The Darkest Minds ...... 25 looking at how manufacturers, tour sound providers, studios and Working on The Darkest Minds, co-supervising engineers alike are reacting to sound editors Will Files and Warren Hendricks the changing trends around us. were challenged to give the characters’ mind con- trol powers individual sonic signatures with a good or evil twist. COLUMNS SOUNDTECHNOLOGY softwaretech ...... 21 Craig Anderton throws down the The METAlliance Report: Desert Island gauntlet and says, “96 kHz vs. Microphones...... 27 44.1 kHz—let’s settle this!” Multiple Grammy-winning producer/engineer Frank Filipetti pens the inaugural edition of the theahamoment ...... 45 METAlliance’s new column, discussing “desert Former Radial Engineering CEO island microphones.” Peter Janis kicks off his new busi- ness column. Sound Innovations: Meyer Sound’s Bluehorn System ...... 28 viewfromthetop...... 47 [20] Miles Rogers of Meyer Sound recounts the cumula- Jim Dugan, president of Wisycom tive development of the company’s new Bluehorn USA, discusses bringing the System studio monitor. Italian RF company’s products to the U.S. and how that completes Pro Audio Review in PSN . 30, 31, 32, 33 a worldwide picture. Mara Machines MCI JH110C 1/4” Two-Track Recorder; Lynx Aurora(n) Interface; Genelec music,etc...... 50 1032C Studio Monitors; Audio-Technica ATH-M60x Jacques Sonyieux talks with Headphones Chuck Leavell about one rockin’ night in Germany, the genius of SOUNDPRODUCTS Ray Charles and what it’s like to have Clapton and Gilmour ask Studio Products ...... 34 you to join their bands. SR Products ...... 35 SOUNDREINFORCEMENT Bringing Boutique Festivals to the Beach 36 Boutique festivals, serving smaller, niche audienc- es, are a growing trend in Europe, as evidenced by [36] Love International, an annual EDM festival in Tisno, Croatia, that puts stages on beaches, boats and more, all with DJs bringing the beats til sunrise. follow us ONLINE Live Sound Showcase: Rob Zombie..38 subscriptions: online: www.mypsnmag.com www.prosoundnews.com Rob Zombie and Marilyn Manson teamed up this facebook: twitter: summer for the Twins of Evil tour; now Zombie’s www.facebook.com/ www.twitter.com/ tight-knit crew shares how they made bad sound ProSoundNews/ ProSoundNews so good.
[ October 2018 ]
[ 8 ] prosound news fromtheEDITOR vol. 40 no. 10 October 2018 CLIVE YOUNG http://www.prosoundnetwork.com [email protected] FOLLOW US @prosoundnews
an eight-year run that had a strong facebook.com/prosoundnews Facing Festival Fatigue attendance history, selling out all 60,000 tickets just last year. CONTENT n the U.S., we love massive fes- decades. Here in the U.S., however, Why is attendance down? There’s VP/Content Creation Anthony Savona tivals, but Coachella, Bonnaroo, after nearly two decades of growth, no single answer. Music fans who Content Director Clive Young, I Outside Lands and the rest real- we’re only starting to see festivals on a attended the earliest post-2000s festi- [email protected] ly only caught on in the last two downward trend for the first time. vals are now aging out of regular con- Content Manager Katie Makal, decades. In truth, our festival history The U.S. touring industry wel- certgoing, with priorities shifting to- [email protected] pales against that of Europe and the comed the advent of festivals with ward raising families and so on. Most Senior Content Producer Steve Harvey, UK, where such annual blowouts open arms in the early 2000s. With of the biggest festivals are now owned [email protected] have been a summertime staple since the record industry in freefall at the by the same promoters, resulting in a Contributors: Craig Anderton, Russ Long, the 1970s. time, there were fewer new acts being creeping sameness to the lineups, too. Jacques Sonyieux, Rob Tavaglione, Rich Tozzoli There’s generations of music fans minted that could fill sheds and sta- Pitchfork found that Lollapalooza, Managing Design Director Nicole Cobban over there who can’t remember life diums, and the aging Baby Boomer Coachella and Bonnaroo had about Production Manager Fred Vega without festivals—take my cousin acts that were regularly among the a third of their lineups in common ADVERTISING SALES Jemima, who makes a point of hit- highest-grossing live acts every year in 2017. And then there’s the theory VP/Market Expert, AV/Consumer ting three or four a year. While one were getting on. Were live shows go- that millennials’ much-discussed fo- Electronics, Education & Pro Audio happens to be held only a few hun- ing to dry up forever? Then festivals cus on experiences may mean they’re Adam Goldstein, [email protected], dred feet from her backyard (Board- started springing up, providing win- ready to experience…something else. 212-378-0465 masters in Cornwall), Glastonbury wins for all involved—consumers got All industries experience lulls, and remains her all-time favorite, though a good ROI on a ticket, promoters then reinvention comes along. Some SUBSCRIBER CUSTOMER SERVICE she’s been known to travel halfway made money, acts at all levels got ex- suggest the U.S. should embrace the To subscribe, change your address, or check on your current account status, go to around the world to try one out: posure to huge audiences, and sound growing European trend of small, al- www.MyPSNmag.com and click on About Us, email “At Glasto, it normally rains and companies and other production ven- most artisanal festivals, like Croatia’s [email protected], call 888-266- you’re wearing wellies for seven days dors kept working. Love International, profiled on page 5828, or write P.O. Box 234, Lowell, MA 01853. straight, walking around a five-mile- Fast forward to 2018 and the top- 36. Some fests are adopting that for- big festival with blisters and mud— grossing tours are still mostly aging mat here, like Portland, OR’s Pick- ARCHIVES that’s exhausting work. Coachella was baby boomers, but now we’ve started athon, which caps tickets at 3,500 This magazine is available for research and retrieval of select archived articles from leading electronic grass and heat, so I thought I would to experience festival fatigue. Lol- daily and adds a decidedly American database and search services, including ProQuest. give it a go, plus it’s one of the big- lapalooza saw slow ticket sales this twist by turning it into a weekend- For microform availability, contact National Archive gest music festivals in America and year, according to the Chicago Tri- long live music video shoot with an Publishing Company, 800-521-0600, or search the it used to be classed as the American bune, while Bonnaroo had its worst audience on 12 heavily art-directed Serials in Microform listings at napubco.com. Glastonbury. Which it’s not. The fact and third-worst attendances ever in stages, resulting in hundreds of indi- Back issues are available. For more information, you are penned in a certain drinking 2016 and 2017, according to the Ten- vidual clips released throughout the contact www.proquest.com area and can’t drink while watching a nessean. Some long-running main- year online for an additional reve- REPRINTS/PERMISSIONS nue stream. By all reports, this year’s band or DJ or whatever? Don’t know stays like Sasquatch have gone on This magazine may not be reproduced or quoted what that’s about.” hiatus, while others like FYF Fest edition was a smashing success. For in whole or in part by printed or electronic means Since they’re such an ingrained and Lost Lake threw in the towel this years, the sound industry has crowed without written permission from Future. To obtain part of culture over there, festivals— year due to low ticket sales. In Sep- “live music will never die because you permissions, contact Wright’s Media, 877-652-5295. and all their supporting industries, in- tember, St. Louis’ LouFest cancelled can’t download an experience”—but cluding audio vendors—have weath- due to money issues just 48 hours now people want to experience the MANAGEMENT ered ups and downs throughout the before showtime, bringing to an end creation of the live music download. Managing Director/Senior Vice President Christine Shaw Chief Revenue Officer Diane Giannini Chief Content Officer Joe Territo Chief Marketing Officer Wendy Lissau Head of Production US & UK Mark Constance
FUTURE US, INC. 28 East 28th Street, 12th Floor, New York, NY 10016
All contents © 2018 Future US, Inc. or published under licence. All rights reserved. No part of this magazine may be used, stored, transmitted or reproduced in any way without the prior written permission of the publisher. Future Publishing Limited (company number 2008885) is registered in England and Wales. Registered office: Quay House, The Ambury, Bath BA1 1UA. All information contained in this publication is for information only and is, as far as we are aware, correct at the time of going to press. Future cannot accept any responsibility for errors or inaccuracies in such information. You are advised to contact manufacturers and retailers directly with regard to the price of products/services referred to in this publication. Apps and websites mentioned in this publication are not under our control. We are not responsible for their contents or any other changes or updates to them. This magazine is fully independent and not affiliated in any way with the companies mentioned herein.
If you submit material to us, you warrant that you own the material and/or have the necessary rights/permissions to supply the material and you automatically grant Future and its licensees a licence to publish your submission in whole or in part in any/all issues and/or editions of publications, in any format published worldwide and on associated websites, social media channels and associated products. Any material you submit is sent at your own risk and, although every care is taken, neither Future nor its employees, agents, subcontractors or licensees shall be liable for loss or damage. We assume all unsolicited material is for publication unless otherwise stated, and reserve the right to edit, amend, adapt all submissions.
Future plc is a public company quoted Chief executive Zillah Byng-Thorne on the London Stock Exchange Non-executive chairman Peter Allen (symbol: FUTR) Chief financial officer Penny Ladkin-Brand www.futureplc.com Tel +44 (0)1225 442 244
[ October 2018 ]
[ 12 ] soundBUSINESS Live (Sound) from New York, It’s AES Doug JOHNSTALEYPHOTO.COM NEW YORK, NY—The annual Audio Engineering Society Convention is MacCallum, coming up soon. Audio pros from around the industry will come to- gether at the Jacob K. Javits Conven- One Systems tion Center in New York City, Octo- ber 17–20, for four days of everything Co-Founder, audio. One of the benefits of hold- ing the show once again in the Big Apple is the opportunities it affords Dead at 62 to attend workshops and panels at NASHVILLE, TN—Douglas “Doug” which live sound pros working on MacCallum, co-founder and Broadway, live television, tours, inter- president of Nashville-based national events and more share their speaker manufacturer One Sys- insights and experiences. Last year’s AES Convention at New York’s Javits Center was packed. tems, died at his Brentwood, TN, This year’s Sound Reinforcement home in mid-September after a Track will explore dozens of live Stoffo of Radio Active Designs, the and his crew will provide insights yearlong battle with leukemia. and installed sound topics including panel will feature RF engineers and into the show’s Tony Award-winning He was 62. sound system optimization, corporate technicians, manufacturer’s prod- sound design. Born in Pitts- sound, live sound production for TV, uct specialists and government rela- Core technologies will be covered burgh, PA, in the impact of the continuing reallo- tions experts. A second Super Ses- in sessions such as “Understanding 1956 and gradu- cation of the RF spectrum, and best sion, moderated by Peter Erskine of Line Source Behavior for Better Op- ating from Bald- practices in designing wireless inter- Best Audio and discussing wireless timization” and “A Cookbook Ap- win High School com systems. intercom systems, will investigate and proach to Sound System Optimiza- in 1974, Mac- “Sound reinforcement is continu- compare the primary technologies in tion with Bob McCarthy.” “Audio Callum headed ally evolving due to new technologies use today, including associated con- Production for Corporate Events” will to Otterbein Uni- Doug and possibilities, and audience expec- trol platforms. feature a panel of experts addressing versity in Wester- MacCallum in tations. In 2018, sound reinforcement In the “Live Production in a TV topics ranging from fitting the sound ville, OH, where 2002 faces continuing regulatory, financial World” seminar, Jenny Montgom- system to the venue to RF coordina- he earned a bach- and market challenges,” said Henry ery, the lead A2 (audio assist) on tion and music and band support. elor’s degree in business admin- Cohen, AES New York 2018 Sound the recent live broadcast production AES New York Convention Sound istration. Reinforcement Track co-chair. “With of Jesus Christ Superstar, and other Reinforcement Track events, avail- MacCallum began his ca- these challenges come opportunities, members of the production team will able with All-Access registration, reer in 1978 as sales manager of and the AES New York Convention discuss handling the challenges of a run in complement to exhibit floor Cambridge Marketing Group, presents the next chapter in audio one-off live event where there’s no and demo room events including the a manufacturers’ rep firm, fol- engineering evolution.” option but to get it right the first Broadcast Audio Expo, Broadway lowed by a 14-year run of sales AES New York’s “RF Super Ses- time. Getting it right every night is Sound Expo and Live Production management and executive posi- sion” will address attendees’ con- the challenge on Broadway, as will Stage, and the AoIP Technology Pa- tions with Electro-Voice and its cerns about the new RF landscape, be illustrated in the session “Design- vilion. parent company, the Mark IV identify specific issues and offer real- ing for Broadway: The Band’s Visit,” AES Convention Audio Group (the former parent world solutions. Moderated by James where sound designer Kai Harada www.aesshow.com company of EV, Altec Lansing, University Sound, Cetec Vega, Klark Teknik, DDA and Midas). He ended his Mark IV Audio Audio Precision Co-Founder Bob tenure serving as vice president from 1994-96. From there he went on to join Harman-owned Metzler, Dead at 84 AKG as vice president and gen- eral manager of U.S. operations, BEAVERTON, OR—Audio Preci- calling for extensive interna- a position he held for a decade. sion co-founder and former tional travel. It wasn’t uncom- At that time the microphone and president Bob Metzler died mon for him to be gone for headphone manufacturer was at home on August 11, 2018. weeks at a time, visiting numer- based in Nashville. Along with Dr. Richard Cabot, ous countries, and customers, In 2007, MacCallum co- Bruce Hofer and Robert in a single trip. He became the founded loudspeaker manu- Wright, Metzler founded Audio face of AP during those early facturer One Systems, which is Precision in 1984 and served years, engaging thousands of also the United States distribu- as the organization’s president customers across the globe. tion partner for P.Audio’s line until his retirement in 1999. During his time at AP, Met- of sound reinforcement systems. He was 84. zler wrote numerous magazine He served as president of the Born in Plymouth, IN, in articles and application notes, company until his death. 1934, Metzler went to study Bob Metzler edited AP’s newsletter, Audio. MacCallum is survived by his at Manchester College in Indi- TST, and, in 1993, authored the wife Jeanette, stepchildren Chris- ana, where he met his wife, Violet, OR, in the early 1970s to work at Audio Measurement Handbook. tina and Jacob, brother Bob, sis- in 1953; they married in 1954. After Tektronix. Later he gained an MBA He is survived by his wife Violet; ters Heather, Laurie and Tracy, working for various radio stations as degree at the University of Portland. sister Helen; children Mark, Den- and many nephews, nieces, and a DJ/chief engineer, he finished his During his time at AP, in addition nis, Lucinda and Christopher; and 11 great-nephews and nieces. physics degree at the University of to his role as president, Metzler’s grandchildren. One Systems Louisville and worked for General responsibilities included marketing Audio Precision www.onesystems.com Electric before moving to Portland, and sales, with those duties often www.ap.com
[ October 2018 ]
[ 14 ] soundBUSINESS Audio on IP Networks: AES67 and Audinate’s Dante
BY EKIN BINAL routes in the Dante software solutions that provides the with the business. When purchasing matrix. user with the ability to control, mon- a Dante-enabled product, you are as- Networking is a key com- AES67 is an open itor, discover and transport many sured that all components will work ponent of pro audio these standard developed by audio channels between any com- together seamlessly. days, and much as all the Audio Engineer- pliant audio devices. AES67 cannot As for sound quality, Dante offers professionals have a few ing Society. This suite currently control or monitor assign- user-selectable ranges with capability favorite pieces of gear, of IP-based audio net- ments, and it doesn’t currently have ranging from 48 kHz to 96 kHz and they also have preferences working standards fo- Dante’s ability to allow its users the all the way up to 192 kHz. AES67 about networking solu- cuses on interoperabil- control and management of audio- has currently adopted a media clock tions. AES67 and Audi- ity with standards like over-IP traffic. rate of 48 kHz, technically making it nate’s Dante protocol are Dante or Q-LAN, for Dante has added an additional lower fidelity, but this is still a high among the most popular instance. With AES67 layer of security with Dante Domain sampling rate, especially when you offerings, though they ul- configuration, users are Manager, which provides assigned take into account the fact that it is timately are intended to [opinion] able to make different users with different levels of access. 24-bit and can be up to 32-bit. The accomplish different goals. audio-over-IP plat- Profiles with higher-level access can difference between the sampling rates Here, Ekin Binal, audio solutions tech- forms talk to each other on a net- determine where audio can be sent would not be noticeable to most us- nology manager at Crestron Electronics, work. AES67 ties together different and received. A user must have ad- ers, and 48 kHz has been accepted shares his opinions on the two protocols, networks by allowing a user to send ministrator rights to set and break the across the pro AV industry as a com- exploring considerations such as security, audio from, say, a Dante-enabled audio routes. Without this security, pliant rate. For reference, CD quality cost, sound quality and future-proofing. piece of hardware to a Ravenna-en- someone could enter somebody else’s is 44.1 kHz/16-bit. abled piece of hardware when both network, plug in and route micro- With future-proofing in mind, ante and AES67 are two of the devices are in AES67 mode. phone channels from a conference many manufacturers have waited to most popular ways of trans- While comparing two very preva- room to listen in on a conversation or see whether Dante or AES67 would D mitting audio over IP. Dante lent solutions, it is imperative to dive project. While this is a benefit of the emerge as the dominant audio-over- is a license-based media networking deeper into the conversation and note Dante solution, this type of security IP solution. Dante adoption has technology developed by Audinate, that Dante and AES67 provide enter- is not currently part of the AES67 grown at a rapid pace. Customers a publicly traded Australian com- prise-grade solutions. standard. are becoming more comfortable with pany. With over 300 brands and more A common misconception is With AES67 being an open stan- Dante as it has AES67 built into it, than 1,500 products on the market that AES67 and Dante are compet- dard without licensing costs, there is which provides flexibility to the user. designed to support the Dante audio ing standards. AES67 was created to no upfront cost; rather, it is a com- Meanwhile, if two years from now networking protocol, the company serve as an interoperability solution plete specification that any manu- Dante becomes something else or an- has developed a large presence in the between various audio-over-IP stan- facturer can follow. It defines what other competing platform emerges, industry. Audio solutions that are dards; as such, it does not offer all of developers need to implement, the users can rest assured that AES67 Dante-enabled guarantee interoper- the capabilities that Dante does. For protocols to follow and the underly- mode will maintain interoperability ability. For example, a Crestron DSP- example, Dante provides users the ing architecture. AES67 is attractive with other AES67-compliant gear. 1283 can easily connect to a Dante- functionality of controlling and moni- for manufacturers seeking audio over Dante is currently the best solution enabled Sennheiser microphone, toring audio, while AES67 does not. IP for the lowest initial cost. out there as it provides synchroni- allowing both devices to appear in It is also important to note that Audi- Although Dante is initially more zation, has a high quality of service Dante Controller. Audinate’s Dante nate has adopted AES67 compatibil- expensive, its users can feel confident built into the platform, and it en- Controller software allows the user ity mode in its most recent firmware. they are implementing future-proof sures that all of the audio partners to view all Dante transmitters and Dante is a full-suite solution and industry-supported technology that support Dante can work together receivers, and configure all of the ranging from hardware modules to that is designed to adapt and grow without question.
T-Mobile Continues 600 MHz Push Across U.S.
BY STEVE HARVEY far from the tower and are four times T-Mobile began its rapid 600 MHz better in buildings than mid-band Extended Range LTE rollout. To BELLVUE, WA—Having pushed wireless LTE, providing increased coverage accelerate the process of freeing up mic operators out of the 600 MHz and capacity. The so-called “Un-car- the spectrum for LTE, T-Mobile range, T-Mobile is continuing to lay rier” has already deployed Extended has been working with broadcast- the foundation for nationwide 5G in Range LTE to more than 80 percent ers occupying 600 MHz spectrum 2020 with 5G-ready equipment, and of Americans with 700 MHz (Band to assist them in moving to new has now lit up 600 MHz (Band 71) 12), and rapidly began deploying it frequencies. Extended Range LTE in 1,254 cities with 600 MHz (Band 71) last year to T-Mobile currently offers 14 and towns in 36 states, including the expand coverage and capacity even smartphones capable of operating in island of Puerto Rico. further. the 600 MHz band, and that number As T-Mobile rolls out its Band In April 2017, T-Mobile made continues to grow. The company has 71 infrastructure, licensed and unli- its largest network investment ever, also enabled carrier aggregation for censed wireless audio equipment op- tripling its low-band spectrum 600 MHz Extended Range LTE and erators must vacate frequency spec- holdings by purchasing spectrum mid-band LTE, so customers with trum in the 600 MHz band in the sold in the U.S. government’s 600 capable devices can access the capac- relevant regions. Failure to do so may MHz auction. Those licenses cover ity of both simultaneously, increasing result in a hefty fine. 100 percent of the United States, download speeds. T-Mobile notes that Extended including Puerto Rico. Immedi- T-Mobile T-Mobile has lit up 600 MHz Extended Range Range LTE signals travel twice as ately after receiving the licenses, www.t-mobile.com LTE in 1,254 cities and towns in 36 states.
[ October 2018 ] soundBUSINESS [ 15 ]
• RONAN HILL, CAS, Production Sound Emmy Winners Announced Mixer
BY STEVE HARVEY Best Sound Mixing (Half-Hour Best Sound Mixing (One-Hour Best Sound Mixing (Movie/Mini) Series) Series) Genius: Picasso—“Chapter One” LOSANGELES, CA—In the first of two Barry—“Chapter Seven: Loud, Fast Game of Thrones—“Beyond the Wall” • BOB BRONOW, Re-Recording 2018 Creative Arts Emmy Awards and Keep Going” • ONNALEE BLANK, CAS, Re-Re- Mixer ceremonies honoring outstanding ar- • TODD BECKETT, Re-Recording cording Mixer • MARK HENSLEY, Re-Recording tistic and technical achievement in Mixer • MATHEW WATERS, CAS, Re-Re- Mixer television, the Television Academy • ELMO PONSDOMENECH, Re- cording Mixer • TAMÁS CSABA, Production Mixer awarded many talented artists and Recording Mixer • RICHARD DYER, Production Academy of Television Arts & Sciences craftspeople, including sound mixing • BEN PATRICK, CAS, Production Mixer www.emmys.com and sound editing teams. Mixer The ceremony, which kicked off the 70th Primetime Emmy Awards, honored achievements in the catego- ries of animation and scripted pro- gramming including comedy, drama and limited series and were presented at the Microsoft Theater in Los An- geles.
Best Sound Editing (Half-Hour Series) Atlanta—“Teddy Perkins” • TREVOR GATES, Supervising Sound Editor • JASON DOTTS, Dialogue/ADR Editor • DAVID BARBEE, Sound Effects Editor • JORDAN MCCLAIN, Foley Editor • GEORDY SINCAVAGE, Foley Edi- tor • MICHAEL HEAD, Foley Editor • TARA BLUME, Foley Artist • MATT SALIB, Foley Artist
Best Sound Editing (One-Hour Series) Stranger Things—“Chapter Eight: The Mind Flayer” • BRADLEY NORTH, Sound Su- pervisor • CRAIG HENIGHAN, Sound De- signer • TIFFANY S. GRIFFITH, Dialogue Editor • JORDAN B. WILBY, Sound Effects Editor • DAVID WERNTZ, Sound Effects Editor • ANTONY ZELLER, Supervising Foley Editor • DAVID KLOTZ, Music Editor • ZANE BRUCE, Foley Artist • LINDSAY PEPPER, Foley Artist
Best Sound Editing (Movie/Mini) Black Mirror—“USS Callister” • KENNY CLARK, Sound Supervi- sor/Sound Effects Editor • MICHAEL MAROUSSAS, Dia- logue Editor • MATTHEW SKELDING, Dia- logue Editor • DILLON BENNETT, Sound Ef- fects Editor • DARIO SWADE, Foley Editor • RICKY BUTT, Foley Artist • OLIVER FERRIS, Foley Artist
[ October 2018 ] [ 16 ] sound INTERNATIONAL
that as the inner ring fired outward, Hill’s Gets Immersive with d&b it supported the Soundscape environ- ment. So if a sound object originated LISBON, PORTUGAL—When it comes in the north position, for example, to a corporate event, the production then as that sound transited the room always keeps the client at the center and the delegates, a loudspeaker of the audience’s attention. Certainly from the inner ring would pick up that was the case recently when U.S. that role, supporting the sound object pet nutrition company Hill’s held an across the 120-foot throw. in-the-round corporate presentation Koan noted, “We used QLab to in Lisbon, but event producer Har- program the sound moves. The video vest Productions aimed to go a step spit out timecode, QLab took that further by immersing the participants and output OSC into the DS100, via d&b audiotechnik’s d&b Sound- then to the matrix, so the whole pro- scape technology. cess became automatic. That func- “We have always done 360, in-the- tionality was already built into QLab. round style presentations for Hill’s,” What it meant was you just needed explained Josh Koan, Harvest’s proj- to drag the path of the audio through ect leader for this event. “And we the listening area, and QLab writes always wanted to create a totally im- the OSC code to make that happen. mersive experience for the delegates This was not a simple ‘snap to a new that places them within the context of position’ audio; this was real-world the content we have created. d&b audiotechnik’s d&b Soundscape created immersive audio for a corporate event in Lisbon. transiting through space from one “For the Hill’s event, we were in location to another, and without any a large ballroom at a hotel in Lisbon, gine, Soundscape includes two dis- south, east and west of an oval shape, need for complex programming to Portugal,” continued Koan. “A central tinct software components: En-Scene, with the loudspeakers spaced evenly achieve that effect.” stage was used for all speech-based a sound object positioning tool, and between them. d&b audiotechnik presentation. The delegates surround- En-Space, an acoustic room emula- The systems worked together so www.dbaudio.com ed the stage, and they in turn were sur- tion tool that provides room rever- rounded by a 360-video panorama.... beration signatures. We then paired that to multitrack re- The event’s system comprised cordings made at the same time so we point-source loudspeakers, mainly could paint an accurate audio portrait, Y10P with some E12-D. An inner Aurus Makes FOH Debut giving all delegates, wherever they sat, “out-firing ring” for speech-based a spatially accurate experience.” presentation from the central stage d&b Soundscape enables two dif- area used all Y10Ps. Meanwhile, there in China’s Cadillac Arena ferent, related forms of sound pro- was also an “in-firing” system of E12- cessing to produce defined enhance- D and Y10P on the video perimeter. BEIJING, CHINA—Zhang ments to the listening environment. Each screen was approximately 4 Hong Guang, one of Based on the d&b DS100 signal en- meters wide and positioned north, China’s most popular composers, filled the Cadillac Arena in Bei- jing in July when his music was performed Back to Analog for for an audience of 18,000 fans. Placed at the house mix position Polosud Records was a Stage Tec Aurus platinum desk, making A Stage Tec Aurus platinum desk mixed the music of Zhang NAPLES, ITALY—Italy’s Polosud Re- a professional studio in 1987 and a its debut as a FOH con- Hong Guang at Cadillac Arena in Beijing in July. cords has returned to analog af- focal point of the Neapolitan music sole in China. ter more than a decade of digital scene. After a “digital switchover” The Aurus platinum was RMDQ DSP units. The microphones operation with the installation of in the late 1990s, which lasted until equipped with 32 faders and inte- were converted to digital signals with- a Rupert Neve Designs 5088 mix- 2017, Pascale says, “The analog is grated into a Nexus network with out analog preamplification directly ing console. Founded in 1981 as finally back.” The 5088 was supplied six Base Devices and a STAR rout- at the Nexus’ mic inputs with 32-bit a rehearsal room and project stu- by Rupert Neve Designs’ Italian dis- er. CCTV, China’s national state resolution using the True Match pro- dio for owner Ninni Pascale’s band tributor, MidiWare. broadcaster, recorded the event, cess. A total of 16 XMIC microphone Walhalla, Polosud Records became Pascale says, “Having been a Ru- which aired on the CCTV-3 music boards with eight channels each (128 pert Neve fan for a long time and and entertainment channel. IFTT in total) were installed in the Nexus already having his equipment in was the technical service provider. Base Devices for the purpose. my studio, I had the chance to talk The 60-piece orchestra, a choir of A second performance in Shen- about the console during a MidiWare 50 singers and a band with 11 musi- zhen is already planned for the end of event—and on that occasion, it was cians, 16 soloists and two presenters the year. Zhang Hong Guang, a com- love at first sight. I have used a lot of required more than 200 mix channels poser of Chinese opera and dance consoles, but the RND 5088 is the and 80 buses, which engineers kept theater, also writes film and television ‘true’ mixer for me.” track of by using the Aurus VCA hi- scores, as well as pop and ethnic mu- Pascale’s console is configured erarchy feature, enabling instruments sic. The Cadillac Arena was opened with a 16-channel penthouse loaded to be grouped. VCAs were mixed in- in 2008 and hosted the Olympic bas- with 14 channels of Shelford 5052 stead of individual channels, com- ketball tournament in the same year. mic preamp/EQ and two Shelford bined with the Aurus spill function. It will serve as the ice hockey venue 5051 EQ/compressor modules. To accommodate the large num- during the Winter Olympics in 2022. Italy’s Polosud Records has a new Rupert Rupert Neve Designs ber of audio channels, the Aurus plat- Stage Tec Neve Designs 5088 mixing console. www.rupertneve.com inum was fully populated with seven www.stagetec.com
[ October 2018 ] soundBUSINESS [ 17 ] RG Jones Joins In at Henley Festival
HENLEY-ON-THAMES, UK—RG Jones Jones’ audio team of Steve Carr and the other three stages equipped by Sound Engineering recently provided Mark Edwards fielded Martin Au- RG Jones, which was the only onsite sound for the annual five-day Henley dio MLA Compact loudspeakers for sound contractor for the festival. Festival in the UK, as it has for the main hangs and outfills. “They more “Rita had the crowd jumping last 36 years. This year, that meant than rise to this challenge and yet and the sound system sounded in- providing audio for the likes of Rita also enable us to keep to the fairly credible—a floating fairytale on the Ora, Chic featuring Nile Rodgers, strict off-site noise limits set by the water,” reported Daria Dee, touring Grace Jones, Curtis Stigers and ENO. [city] council,” Lambert explained. production manager for Rita Ora. The event sports a number of venues, For this year’s edition, held in July, “I’ve been working with RG Jones but none as unique as the festival’s RG Jones added DD12s as arena de- for many years now and it’s always a trademark Floating Stage. lays in the grandstand to replace the relief to see their name on the sheet. Festival technical manager and previously used DD6s. Production The people behind this company are head of sound Jim Lambert said, also used MLA Mini for infill, and very passionate about what they do— “The Floating Stage has always been decided to retain the same curved they are a family-run independent a challenge in that the front-to-back MLX sub-bass arrangement that it business and it really distinguishes of the arena is only approximately 98 had introduced in 2017, resulting in a them. I’ve been to Henley Festival as The Martin Audio MLA Compact P.A. is feet but it is extremely wide, and with smoother response in the far reaches a guest and it’s a truly unique event. splayed wide at the Henley Festival’s Floating the introduction of general admission of the main stage arena, according to Working on it this year was equally Stage in order to cover the shallow but wide tickets outside the arena, we are be- Lambert. fun and refreshing; the festival team audience area. ing asked to cover a width of some- In addition to the Floating Stage, is as wonderful as they are profes- thing like 330 feet.” MLA Minis were used in the Bed- sional, and our crew were well looked Martin Audio To accomplish that goal, RG ouin Tent and Jazz Garden—two of after.” www.martin-audio.com Solotech Takes On Fame in Montreal MONTREAL, CANADA—The theme song MKE1 lavalier wireless mics with to Fame goes, “I’m gonna live forev- SK 5212 bodypack transmitters were er,” and the theatrical musical based used for the actors, resulting in 40 on the 1980 hit film might do that as wireless inputs, along with more than well. Case in point: it was recently re- 50 wired microphones for the band. vived for a run at the 2,219-seat Saint Serge Rodrigue was hired as the wire- Denis Theatre in Montreal, with au- less technician for the show to ride dio provided by Montreal-based So- herd on all its RF needs. lotech. Solotech Front of house engineer Maxime www.solotech.com Lambert oversaw a Yamaha Rivage PM7 digital audio console nightly for Tackling audio for the Fame revival were (l-r) Maxime Lambert, FOH engineer; Serge Rodrigue, Yamaha the show. “Solotech strongly suggest- wireless technician; and Colin Gagné, sound designer. www.yamahaca.com ed that we take a look at the PM7, as it fulfilled most of our requirements,” said Lambert. “After a moment of reflection, the show’s sound designer, Colin Gagné, and I decided that it could be the right fit for us. We have used many Yamaha mixers before, mostly CL5, QL5 and M7CL, and Solotech provided us a day in their warehouse for training by Yamaha systems application specialist Kevin Kimmel.” Lambert took advantage of the new desk’s multiuser interface: “Hav- ing the possibility for two operators on one control surface at the same time is really useful when you have 100-plus inputs to manage,” said Lambert. “Another great feature is to have the option of choosing the send point of each channel to any mix, which made mixing monitors from front of house a lot easier. We had the Rupert Neve Designs EQ810 and MBC4 multiband compressor on all of our mix buses and mostly used the Yamaha SPX reverb for effects. The Rupert Neve Designs 5045 also came in handy.” A full two dozen Sennheiser
[ October 2018 ] [ 18 ] soundRECORDING
leases the Foo Fighters’ music, was Capturing A Gang of Grohls for Play produced by Grohl and Therapy ROSWELL FILMS Content/Therapy Studios. It was di- rected by Grohl in collaboration with Mark Monroe. The pair previously worked together on the Grammy- winning 2013 documentary Sound City and the Emmy- and Grammy- winning HBO docuseries Sonic High- ways. Grohl’s concept was to film and record each of his parts for the piece, which he wrote in sections on his laptop while touring, in a single, continuous take; one mistake and he started over. “He came in and said, ‘I’ve never played this in its entirety before.’ First he played the drums down, humming the guitar part— and there’s no click,” says Thorp, who also engineered Foo Fighters’ latest album, Concrete and Gold. The finished piece was built on take four, says Thorp. Next came the first guitar part, bass, then two more guitars, including an acoustic. Percus- “Play,” a 23-minute track composed and performed by Foo Fighters leader Dave Grohl, was recorded in single, continuous takes as he performed all seven instruments in the piece. sion and keyboards came last. Grohl performed the drum part BY STEVE HARVEY mentary that includes a 23-minute wood over several days in March, on three kits spread across the studio, track on which he plays seven differ- with multi-Grammy Award-winning with two floor toms placed between, LOS ANGELES, CA—To help inspire new ent instruments, each recorded in a engineer, producer and mixer Darrell enabling transitions. Play was report- generations to learn and play music, single take. The instrumental piece Thorp behind the console. edly inspired by Grohl watching his Foo Fighters’ frontman Dave Grohl was filmed and recorded in Studio Play, from Roswell Films, an off- own kids, who have appeared on recently released Play, a mini-docu- One at EastWest Studios in Holly- shoot of Roswell Records, which re- (continued on page 24) Behind the Beats: How UK MARK SURRIDGE Producers Created Grime
BY EMMA FINAMORE A true DIY genre, many of to- day’s biggest MCs came up as LONDON, UK—Grime is one of UK producers: present-day household music’s big success stories. Thanks names Wiley and Skepta, for ex- to the genre, British rappers are ample, both produced tracks for now being taken seriously across the themselves and others before be- pond by the likes of Kanye West and coming better known for their skills Drake. Ticket sales for grime events on the mic. DJ Target—who helped quadrupled between 2010 and shape grime in its earliest form— 2017, while Spotify grime streams was childhood friends with Wiley, went from 89 million in 2016 to 206 and the two discovered music pro- million in 2017. Between 2016 and duction together before going on 2017, physical and digital album to found garage crew Pay As U Go sales for grime grew by 93 percent, Cartel (who had a Top 20 hit with according to Dr. Joy White in The “Champagne Dance” in 2002) DJ Plastician’s early tools included FruityLoops 2.0 and Cool Edit. Business of Grime. and the grime-establishing group Despite the high accolades and Roll Deep, who enjoyed a string ever hip-hop show, Yo! MTV Raps. Pro with a bunch of MIDI plug-ins equally high sales of today, it was of Number One singles and who “New software enabled us to work was all we needed to get the sound the low-fi, DIY techniques of young count grime stars Dizzee Rascal and entirely from laptops, or from much we wanted,” he adds. producers that first generated the Tinchy Stryder as former members. simpler studio setups, which made it FruityLoops—available on Play- unique sound that would become “I’d analyze the beat, right down possible for many more [people] to Station—was a freeware digital au- one of the UK’s biggest home- to the small sounds in the back- start making music. Even without a dio workstation released in the late grown genres. These early pioneers ground,” remembers DJ Target— laptop or a recording studio, teenag- 1990s and adopted by many bud- used the accessible tools they had— who helped shape grime in its earli- ers were using PlayStation programs ding grime producers. Created by programs found on game consoles est form—in his recently published to create beats,” says Target about Belgium-based Image-Line, which of the late 1990s, cheap technology autobiography, Grime Kids. how he and his peers started creat- specialized in games, FruityLoops plugged into their parents’ PCs—in He describes how, even as teens, ing the sound of grime around the 1.0 was developed as a MIDI-only order to reflect the sounds and at- he and Wiley were analyzing the turn of the millennium. step sequencer inspired by the Ham- mosphere of their environment, at beat of tracks while listening to their “Ninety-five percent of the beats merhead Rhythm Station, an emula- grime’s now infamous 140 bpm. Walkmans or watching MTV’s first we made were on our laptops. Logic (continued on page 23)
[ October 2018 ]
PSN478.recording.indd 18 9/19/18 6:17 PM
[ 20 ] STUDIOshowcase 416 Wabash Aims for Best of Both Worlds WA ASH BY STEVE HARVEY indianapolis, in—After graduating with a bachelor’s degree from Indiana niversity, Chris Wodock decided the -to- life was not for him, so he headed to oston to study music pro- duction and engineering at erklee College of Music. After si years as a touring musician based out of Austin, T , Wodock returned to his hometown of Indianapolis in mid- and put his economics degree to work, initially building the Music arage recording and rehearsal studio and, more recently, Wabash, a music production facility and event space. “When we opened in 2004, re- G Series stereo bus compressor. For The control room for 416 Wabash centers around a SSL XL-Desk and Focal Twin6 Be hearsals were booming,” says the new facility, he purchased Lynx monitors. Wodock, who launched Music Ga- Aurora 24 HD converters for his rage with the goal of building out Pro Tools HD12 rig and a pair of multiple rehearsal rooms in addi- Focal Twin6 Be monitors. A double- tion to a recording studio. “There wide outboard rack houses API, Fo- were rehearsal spaces and studios all cusrite, Universal Audio and other over Austin, so I thought I’d model devices. “Premium converters, good off what I’d seen there. But they’re speakers, nice desk; that was our completely different music scenes, goal,” he says. so we only got to build three re- Wodock built his previous stu- hearsal rooms.” dio from Wes Lachot designs posted Over the following 12 years, he on the internet. Lachot was his first says, it became increasingly difficult choice for the new facility, but the to entice bands into the rehearsal budget wouldn’t quite stretch far rooms. The studio, on the other enough. Instead, he went with India- hand, was doing fine. “I worked with napolis-based Haverstick Designs, a Gucci Mane back in 2007; that gen- company founded by Gavin Haver- erated all kinds of buzz and I got la- stick, who previously worked for lo- beled as the place to go for hip-hop.” cal acoustics company Auralex. With 7,800 square feet to work with, 416 Wabash is both a full-fledged recording studio and When the lease came due for re- “When I saw he’d branched out event space. newal, Wodock decided it was time on his own, I thought, of course I’m for a change. “I found a couple of going to call the hometown guy,” Additionally, the event space is event space. “I can have a front-of- investors who were into my idea says Wodock. “I sat down with available for recording larger bands, house engineer and a studio engi- of creating a recording studio that Gavin and said I wanted it mod- or live performances, he notes. “We neer each doing their own things,” was more of an events/performance eled around an SSL desk and Focal put a 24-input panel with four data he says. space. Why don’t we have bands speakers, and he built exactly what I lines outside the control room facing For a P.A. system, Wodock turned come into the studio and record, asked for.” the event space. I had Jared Stansill to his local dealer. “I usually get my and then do a show to promote their Wodock and his crew con- at Pro Audio LA do all my Mogami equipment through Sweetwater be- EP? I found this space; it had been structed the production facilities to wiring.” cause they’re two hours north of us. empty for four years, so they were Haverstick’s specifications, only us- A freestanding, isolated mez- My Sweetwater sales rep, Jeff Bar- eager to rent it to us.” ing Primacoustic diffusors on the zanine structure above the control nett, recommended a PreSonus ULT 416 Wabash’s 7,800-square-foot back wall for the sake of expediency. room serves as a VIP area. “We system, two mains and two 2,000W flexible space, with a standing ca- “It was way harder than I thought,” might make it a green room,” says subs. It’s plenty loud—it’s 110 dB pacity just short of 600 people, fea- he says. “Putting real lead stone into Wodock, who is keen to keep the en- all day—and crystal clear. We’ve had tures an industrial vibe with mul- the recording booth was a two-day tire space as flexible as possible and great luck with it.” tiple mezzanine levels and VIP areas process that turned into two weeks. cater to the widest possible range of Indeed, with few other business- that can be configured for anything There were points where I’d been events. “I don’t want to be pigeon- es combining a music studio with from a wedding celebration to a cor- working for 14 hours and was ready holed; I try to do it all.” an all-purpose event space to serve porate product launch to a music to give up. Nobody tells you how But music is certainly a focus. as a template, Wodock believes luck concert. “I bought a portable stage difficult it is to hang a 5x3 piece “This weekend we have a four-band has played a part in 416 Wabash’s of 4-foot by 8-foot pieces, so we can of 1-inch glass and how incredibly bill on Friday, a three-band bill on success. “I’d had a studio business tailor the stage for a solo acoustic heavy it is. But we pushed through Saturday, then Sunday is a Latin for almost 18 years, so I had a pret- artist or we can do a 24-foot by 16- it.” dance night,” he reports. One of ty good clientele, and it was a good foot stage for a larger touring act,” Wodock chose to keep the con- Wodock’s goals is to produce a mu- time to add the event space. Now says Wodock. trol room to a workable size while sic show similar to Austin City Lim- I’m adding even more clientele who Shortly before relocating, also including an iso booth that its. “We did a test pilot in April with are interested in not only record- Wodock purchased a 24-input SSL could accommodate several musi- a film company, with seven cameras ing but also having their EP release XL-Desk, which is outfitted with a cians. “It was a fine line between and two really good regional touring here,” he says. variety of 500 Series modules, in- making the event space as usable as acts.” “But I definitely don’t think I’m cluding pairs of Lindell Audio PEX- possible and having enough space The studio control room is linked that smart. I think I just got lucky.” 500 passive EQs and Heritage Au- to make the studio as usable as pos- over Cat 5 via a Focusrite RedNet 3 416 Wabash dio ’73JR mic preamps, plus an SSL sible,” he says. box to a Midas M32 console in the www.416wabash.com
[ October 2018 ]
PSN478.recording.indd 20 9/19/18 6:17 PM SOFTWAREtech [ 21 ]
eration is that the oversampling al- 96 kHz vs. 44.1 kHz: Let’s Settle This gorithms need to work in real time, so recording at a higher “native” BY CRAIG Foldover distortion is usually an ments tend to be power-hungry any- sample rate may be better (although ANDERTON issue with older virtual instruments way, this may limit the number of whether anyone would notice is de- because newer ones often have in- real-time virtual instruments you batable). ver since we’ve ternal oversampling so they can run can run in a project. Fortunately, I’ve also found that even 96 kHz had a choice of at a higher rate than the project. oversampling is usually optional, so isn’t enough to represent some synth E sample rates, However, this, too, has limitations. you can track without it—when low waveforms accurately, and 192 kHz there’s been contro- Oversampling requires more CPU latency matters—and oversample is preferable. At this frequency, versy over whether cycles, and because virtual instru- while mixing. But another consid- (continued on page 24) higher sample rates sound better. Some claim higher sample rates add transparency to music, while others claim (with some justification) that no one can tell the difference if material recorded at 96 kHz plays back at 96 kHz or 44.1 kHz. Which reminds me of being in a studio in Chicago years ago. Two musicians were having a heated de- bate about whether cables made a difference. Musician A said that cables can make an audible, obvi- ous difference. Musician B said it’s about companies trying to sell you things you don’t need, and wire is wire. I asked musician A if he played guitar, and musician B if he played keyboards. They were shocked— how did I know? Easy: Cables can make a difference with guitars, but not so much with keyboards. For the past few years, I’ve been researching the hypothesis that both the pro and con higher-sample-rate advocates are right, because the dif- ference is situational. Although I can’t speak to all possible differenc- es, it turns out there can be a major, obvious difference when working “in-the-box” with some (but not all) virtual instruments and amp sims. Virtual instrument waveforms, like pulse waves, can have har- monics that can extend into, or above, the sample rate. When hard- ware synths feed this type of sig- nal through an audio interface, the higher frequencies aren’t an issue because the interface itself, and the A/D conversion process, filters out these harmonics. However, sounds generated inside the computer do not have these constraints. The same can be true of high-gain amp sims; with massive amounts of dis- tortion and 60 dB of gain, harmon- ics can work their way above the clock frequency. This can create foldover distor- tion—a well-recognized digital au- dio limitation that produces aliasing and a “woolly” sonic character. In workshops, I often demonstrate the sound of an amp sim recorded at 44.1 kHz, 96 kHz and 192 kHz. The difference is so obvious that a common reaction is, “Are you sure it’s not a different preset?”
[ October 2018 ]
PSN478.recording.indd 21 9/19/18 6:17 PM [ 22 ] LOOK AT THE RECORDING SCENE tracks notes
PERSONNEL: Scott Kinsey ARTIST: EOR IA THE Produced by: Phony Ppl Engineered by: Scott Kinsey VINTA E YO TH RT Taps Engineered by: rother Studio: Wishbone Studio ALBUM: REMEM ER RIC TASCAM Rich, Roland Cespedes, (Los Angeles, CA) LANE allen, ok—RT Valine and Elbee Thrie, Matthew yas, Mastered by: Scott Kinsey LABEL: C Z Z RECOR S his band, RT N’ The s, Aja rant, annon ashiwa, at Wishbone Studio PERSONNEL: described as folk noir and Andy Wright, Cole araba EQUIPMENT NOTES: Produced by: “a vintage country band with Mix Engineer: Mo Pleasure Million A - , A , True dark obsessions, started Studios: (two tracks), Ivor Crandon The Cabin at Systems P , eoff Tanner out recording on a TASCAM and eorgia Crandon (two Manhattan Center (New T , ynaudio M A (www.tascam.com) York, NY), theSpacement. monitor, MOT P , tracks) ARTIST: RETA VAN FLEET Portastudio and have since . ( rooklyn, NY), Sparta Ableton Live Engineered by: Neil oody ALBUM: ANTHEM OF THE progressed through the Studios (New York, NY), The Studio: Premises Studios PEACEF L product line to the R- WL Casa ( rooklyn, NY), Studio LABEL: LAVA/REP LIC (London, ) handheld digital recorder, (New York, NY), Flyin’ PERSONNEL: Mastered by: Neil oody at belying a lo-fi ethos that read Studio (Los Angeles, Produced by: Marlon Premises Studios e tends to the use of instru- CA) Young, Al Sutton, Herschel EQUIPMENT NOTES: SSL ments constructed from Mastered by: Chris Athens found materials. oone AWS , ATC monitors, at Chris Athens Masters Engineered by: Al Sutton, (Austin, T ) Avid Pro Tools Focusrite Is assisted by Tanner Peters EQUIPMENT NOTES: ARTIST: and Jason Mott E IE Z in the House TASCAM P- S ALBUM: TO ETHER IN THE Mix Engineers: Al Sutton pa ling, n — aryl Hall’s Portastudio; monitors: VA LT and Marlon Young at longtime audio director Focal Shape and Alpha LABEL: THE PLAYROOM Rustbelt Studios (Royal and engineer Peter Moshay , Yamaha NS and PERSONNEL: Oak, MI) has used a -channel rack HS , Reftones, Tannoy Produced by: Eddie Z Studio: lackbird Studio of Focusrite (pro.focusrite. Reveal Ableton Live . Engineered by: Eddie Z, Nashville, TN com) ISA mic preamps Mark Williams, Eddie ibbs to record every performance Mastered by: Ryan Smith at (assistant) ARTIST: MIKE FARRIS of the Live From Daryl’s Sterling Sound Studio: The Vault at The ALBUM: SILVER STONE House streaming and cable EQUIPMENT NOTES: Playroom (Charlotte, NC) LABEL: TV music show since it began -input API Legacy Plus COMPASS RECOR S Mastered by: ave Harris at Hall’s home in , later mic pre’s and Flying PERSONNEL: at Studio Produced by: Garry West moving to aryl’s House Faders II automation EQUIPMENT NOTES: Restaurant Live Music Club Engineered by: Matt Coles Avid Pro Tools, Steinberg in Pawling, NY. Studio: Compass Sound ARTIST: RACHEL EC ROTH Nuendo, Audio inesis Studio (Nashville, TN) ALBUM: WHEN IT FALLS monitors Putting the Mastered by: LABEL: SELF RELEASE Randy LeRoy Em in PMC PERSONNEL: at Tonal Park (Tacoma Park, london, uk—Producer Emre Produced by: Tim Lefebvre M ) Ramazanoglu, known to his Engineered by: Gary EQUIPMENT NOTES: Avid friends as Em, whose client Novak, Eric Isaacson, riffin C , API and Millennia list is a who’s who of con- ARTIST: RO EN oice (vocal engineer) pre’s, Emotiva Stealth temporary music, has pur- TESTIMONY Mix Engineers: Nic Hard, monitors, Avid Pro Tools chased a pair of PMC (www. ALBUM: HOL IN ON TO Geoff Stanfield ARTIST: AVI MESSIER pmc-speakers.com) twotwo NOTHIN Studio: Kronos Recording ALBUM: TIME OM monitors for his studio at LABEL: THERMAL Studio ( urbank, CA) LABEL: SAME S Y Ho a H , a boutique facility ENTERTAINMENT Mastered by: Ed rooks at PRO CTIONS in London’s West Hampstead PERSONNEL: Resonant Mastering PERSONNEL: that was established by Produced by: Jacob Porter EQUIPMENT NOTES: Produced by: Dave writer/producer Jimmy Engineered by: Hogarth. The PMCs sit beside Jacob Wheatstone TV Console for Madden a Pro Tools H rig and A Porter playback, ynaudio M A Engineered by: Andre ARTIST: interfaces. Studios: Illusions Studios monitors, Avid Pro Tools, Cantave EVON CH RCH (Taylor, SC) Aurora Audio TP- pre’s, Mix Engineer: Chris Shaw ALBUM: WE ARE 80-Fader Mastered by: Illusions Neve pre’s Studio: Same Sky INE TRICA LE Studios Productions (Austin, T ) LABEL: FELTE Desk Lands EQUIPMENT NOTES: Mastered by: Piper Payne PERSONNEL: at MC34 PreSonus FP , Avid Pro at Neato Mastering Produced by: Devon ne ork, n —Manhattan Tools (Oakland, CA) Church Center (www.mc .com) EQUIPMENT NOTES: Engineered by: has renovated its Studio- enelec monitors, Mix Engineer: recording facility, equipping Avid Pro Tools the control room with new Studios: Home studio ARTISTS: JIMMY HASLIP, sound, mi ing and produc- ( rooklyn, NY) SCOTT INSEY, ER tion systems, e panding Mastered by: Rafael Irisarri ORLAI workplaces for producers, ALBUM: ARC TRIO at lack noll Studios and installing a new -fader ARTIST: PHONY PPL LABEL: L E CANOE EQUIPMENT NOTES: IP-based mc production ALBUM: M ’Z I . RECOR S niversal Audio LA- , console from Lawo (www. LABEL: PERSONNEL: Yamaha HS monitors, lawo.com). ENTERTAINMENT Produced by: Jimmy Haslip, Apple Logic Pro
[ October 2018 ]
PSN478.recording.indd 22 9/19/18 6:17 PM soundRECORDING [ 23 ] TIM ORROW Grime old sound of the TS404,” he says. Rude Kid began producing grime (continued from page 18) tracks later than Plastician. Just a teenager when Wiley and DJ Target were releasing their first records, he tion of the TR-909 drum machine, started out in 2007 but quickly made and Rebirth 338. An early software waves and went on to work with synthesizer, FruityLoops was an at- much-loved independent grime label tempt at merging the two into some- No Hats No Hoods, as well as with thing new. At a time when Pro Tools some of the genre’s biggest MCs: Wi- was still seen as an industry standard ley, Skepta, Frisco and Ghetts. His DAW, along with Cubase and Logic, track “One Take”—sampling Dizzee FruityLoops turned out to be an un- Rascal, Section Boyz and Wiley—has complicated DAW for the masses— itself been reworked with freestyles perfect for young people with no pro- by grime MC legends Chip and Stor- duction experience, and an ideal tool mzy. for experimentation. “When I was still in school, I got Known today as FL Studio, the shown a music program that changed software has developed on the Win- my life. A friend of mine played a dows platform for 20 years and finally beat he made and it amazed me, so gained a Mac version this past spring, I asked how he made it,” says Rude. but back in the late 1990s, it was “A few days later, he gave me Fruity- likely FruityLoops’ origins in gaming Loops 3—that’s what it was called that made it so accessible—young at the time—but he never taught me people, accustomed to using game how to actually make beats, so I had programs, took to it intuitively. From humble audio beginnings, Rude Kid has gone on to work with some of the genre’s biggest to figure that out by myself. I used to Grime producer Darq E Freaker, MCs, including Wiley, Skepta, Frisco and Ghetts. spend hours and hours making beats for example, has said in interviews on the internet or cut off of tracks some of my tracks—not often, from morning till night, sometimes that at his school, “everyone had in my CD collection, as I was such though, as I was still trying to keep even forgetting to eat. Since then, I’ve FruityLoops on their computers at an amateur at recording I had no my foot in the grime sound as well. never looked back.” home, and making tunes was more knowledge of synthesis at all. I used That TS404 bass sound became the Accordingly, FruityLoops had just like a game.” Many producers came to trawl the internet for sample packs; most iconic dubstep bass sound from as much an impact on second-wave to the program via video games, hav- we were on such a slow connection around 2002 to 2005.” grime producers as it did the initial ing spent hours on games like Music back then, so everything was pretty Plastician’s experience and devel- pioneers, its simplicity lending itself Creation for the PlayStation in the ear- lo-fi as well.” opment as a producer demonstrates well to young, creative minds. ly 2000s. Image-Line had unwittingly “I never even touched a MIDI how grime’s sound—as well as as- Necessity is, of course, the mother created the perfect tool for a genera- controller until around 2004 when I sociated genres—was directly shaped of invention, and Rude Kid wasn’t tion of beat makers. went to college to do music technol- by the technology readily available to going to let a lack of high-end tech Grime’s instantly recognizable ogy,” says Plastician. “I literally just those making music. get in the way of creating music: “Be- “magic number” of 140 bpm finds used to place WAV samples onto the That sound’s dominance didn’t fore I even knew how to sample or its origins here, too, as the preset drum pad—which was pretty much last, however: “When FruityLoops what programs to use to sample, I tempo in FruityLoops. “Godfather of all FruityLoops was back then, bar- 2.0 upgraded to 3.56, the sound of had a £1 mic connected to my PC Grime” Wiley has said this standard ring a few basic plug-ins—and then the TS404 was completely different and I had Sound Recorder, which tempo in the program meant he cre- used to play them in on the piano and phased out of dubstep produc- came with the computer. I had a little ated most of his earliest tracks at 140 roll. I think the cleverest I would tion pretty quickly because many of CD player and some sample CDs—I bpm, and as one of the genre’s first get outside of Fruity was bouncing us started using 3.56 instead and dis- played them on the CD player, put success stories, other producers fol- loops out and opening them in Cool covered other plug-ins. I remember the mic on the CD player speaker lowed his lead. Edit to add some phase or flange Junglist being a favorite; also Albino and recorded all my stuff. It sounded DJ Plastician is one such pro- effects and then import those back [a synth with 128 waveforms] was rough, but at the time it was the only ducer, who started out making “dark into Fruity. a massive one for me from around way to get other sounds on my com- garage” beats while DJing on south “If you listen to all my old stuff, 2005 onwards. It worked perfectly puter. ‘Are You Ready’—my trade- London pirate radio in the early most of it is on the Plasticman Remas- for me as I was straddling the gap mark sound on every one of my tunes 2000s, “before grime was known as tered album, you can hear it—there’s between grime and dubstep in my till this day—was sampled like this, grime,” he says. “Then I would say hardly any chords, nothing too musi- productions and I felt that plug-in of- and I still use that very same rough around late 2001 I started trying to cal, just stabs and stuff layered on top fered some great sounds with plenty sample.” make stuff that was based around of each other. I guess that was a vibe of bass weight.” Rude still uses FruityLoops to cre- what we now recognize as the very in itself, but it really was just trial and The Junglist plug-in is known for ate beats alongside newly developed first grime records—stuff like ‘Pulse error all the way.” its waveforms with a complex, and skills in Logic, and he embraces EQ X’ and ‘Eskimo’ by Wiley.” His first Part of that trial and error was organic quality, and its low bass type plug-ins like Waves and Ozone: “Us- album, 2007’s Beg to Differ, featured swapping methods and ideas with Bass FX section that creates ultra- ing these few things made my tunes many UK rappers, including grime other DJs and producers, across low basses. The Albino plug-in (now sound much cleaner and louder.” legend Skepta. More recently he’s genres, in the south London and discontinued) was voted number 12 He insists that low-tech doesn’t have worked with East London’s new gen- Croydon area, where the dubstep in a 2011 poll about the best VST to mean low quality. “I always tell eration pirate radio MC, Jammz. scene had been born and was thriv- plug-in synths in the world. The pop- producers it’s not about what you “I was using FruityLoops 2.0 at ing. “Through hanging with Skream ular synth from Rob Papen features a have—it’s about how you use what the time,” Plastician says of his early and Benga [a dubstep DJ duo lauded whopping 128 waveforms. you have.” experiments, developing his “dark ga- by the likes of Radio 1’s Annie Mac] Despite Plastician discovering and The biggest, most important rage” sound into grime, and using the particularly, they put me onto using using new tools to develop his sound, names in grime agree. As Skepta same tools that DJ Target and Wiley the TS404 in FruityLoops to create he still returns to the program that said in 2014, “As long as there are were jamming with in East London— these weird, warping, wobbly bass anchors grime, and in particular, the 12-year-old kids turning on their which he’d read about online, on in- lines,” Plastician remembers. version of his youth. “I still have a mum’s PC with a cracked version of ternet forums. “I began writing on “When they showed me how to working copy of FruityLoops 2.0 just FruityLoops, making their own DIY that solely out of samples I’d found use that, I began bringing it into in case I ever feel like revisiting that sound, there’s grime.”
[ October 2018 ]
PSN478.recording.indd 23 9/19/18 6:17 PM [ 24 ] soundRECORDING Play (continued from page 18)
stage with Foo Fighters, learning to play music. Appropriately, the middle kit—labeled “quirky” on the mic in- put sheet, which is posted online—is a Ludwig set that he borrowed from his pre-teen daughter, Harper. The kit is so tiny that he had to sit on a milk crate to play it, Grohl comments in the video. Thorp reports, “I was 38 chan- nels wide for the drums, plus a stereo room. I was trying to not be rude and steal every microphone out of the EastWest locker, because they do have two other working rooms. Thankfully, I’m a Lauten Audio art- ist, so I brought a fair amount of Lauten mics with me.” Noting that the published mic input list is not entirely accurate, Thorp elaborates, “The Clarion is on kick, my 120s are on overheads, with that’s me just pushing the mics up. Neve, but I love the top air of an API. I was 80 percent there and thought, 220s on the toms, 120s on hi-hats, I’ve never gotten a room sound like So in certain situations—and it’s list- once Dave comes in, I’ll dial it in, ad- and an Eden mono overhead on the that before.” ed on the track sheet—I was using just some levels and we’ll be golden. ‘tight’ kit” on which Grohl starts (and Happily, with so many micro- API 550s on the kicks and snares” of Dave showed up and he didn’t come which he played with Them Crooked phones in play simultaneously, East- all three kits. in the control room, he just start- Vultures). There’s an in-house Neu- West’s Studio One houses an 80-in- “I’ll get some nice air and attack ed playing the first kit. I unmute the mann U47 FET on the kick drum put Neve 8078 that was configured out of the API. Then, for low-mid, speakers and listen and … well, I’m of the “Bonham” kit on which Grohl from two smaller consoles. “I used I can use the Neve EQ to get really done!” ends the piece, Thorp adds. “And I a big chunk of the console,” Thorp punchy and mid-y. That’s my ‘trick,’ Play was filmed in black and white had 421s on toms and 67s on over- says, although he muted almost all so to speak,” he says. by director of photography Brandon heads.” but the microphones on the specific Thorp says he developed a good Trost using 12 roving mini-cameras A pair of Cascade Fathead ribbon drum kit on which Grohl was playing. working rapport with Foo Fighters to capture Grohl performing each mics through Compex compressors “I left the two toms between open as tech Samon Rajabnik during the pro- of his parts. On the Roswell Films captured the room. “They’re on the ambience; I didn’t want that to sound duction of Concrete and Gold, which website, Grohl’s individual perfor- floor, X-Y, on a stereo bar pointed at unnatural.” was also recorded in EastWest’s Stu- mances on each instrument are avail- the Bonham kit and the Vultures kit. While every mic went through the dio One. “He would get the drums in able for viewing and separate music A friend texted me and asked how Neve, Thorp supplemented the signal this really sweet spot,” he recalls. charts may be downloaded. A plan of I got the room sound. That’s Dave, chain on certain channels. “There For the Play sessions, says Thorp, the live room details the instruments dude; he hits so hard. That is not a was a fair amount of EQ, and I love “He was out there playing the kits used and their respective positions in reverb trigger, that’s the room sound, the midrange and the low end of a while I got sounds and levels. I felt the space. The first part of the mini-doc intercuts behind-the-scenes studio has real-time upsampling options so A project with a mix of audio and footage with interviews with stu- Anderton you can compare whether a higher virtual instruments is more prob- dents from the Join the Band music (continued from page 21) sample rate improves a virtual in- lematic because you can’t arbitrarily school in L.A.’s San Fernando Val- strument’s sound. Second, there’s change a project’s sample rate. How- ley. Therapy’s Eddie Kim and Bran- an easy workaround. If a project ever, you can export the MIDI file don Kim brought together Grohl’s though, reality intrudes: Running consists solely of virtual instru- driving the instrument and save the voiceover, the student interviews projects at 192 kHz limits the num- ments, change your project’s sample preset you’re using. Then create a and the music tracks recorded and ber of audio streams, stresses out rate to 192 kHz, render the instru- new project at 192 kHz. Import the mixed by Thorp into the documen- your computer, and some plug-ins ment, and then sample-rate con- MIDI file, load the instrument and tary’s final mix. its preset, and render the track at the “It’s awesome to see these kids target sample rate (or render it at the try to figure it out. I’m still trying For the past few years, I’ve been higher sample rate before bringing to figure it out, still pushing myself, the audio into your lower-sample- looking for the next challenge, doing researching the hypothesis that both rate project—most modern DAWs something I’ve never done before,” will convert the file automatically to says Grohl’s voiceover. His frustration the pro and con higher-sample-rate the new sample rate). This way you with not being able to play a 23-min- can enjoy the benefits of high-sample- ute part without messing up is visible advocates are right. rate virtual instrument sounds in low- in the first part of the video. But at sample-rate projects. the end of the day, says Grohl, “The won’t even work at that sample rate. vert it back to a lower sample rate. Craig Anderton’s new book series, The reward is just to play.” Fortunately, there are solutions. Because the audio was rendered, Musician’s Guide to Home Recording, is Darrell Thorp First, not all plug-ins exhibit is- all audio is in the audio range, so now available from Hal Leonard in soft- www.darrellthorp.com sues. Cakewalk by BandLab (a free it won’t generate harmonics at the cover, and on www.reverb.com as a se- download from www.bandlab.com) lower sample rate. ries of ebooks. Roswell Films https://play.roswellfilms.com
[ October 2018 ]
PSN478.recording.indd 24 9/19/18 6:17 PM soundPOST | BROADCAST [ 25 ] briefs AI’s Implications for Production Music
BY STEVE HARVEY GameSoundCon LOS ANGELES, CA—Are robots coming Adds VO Track to take your job? If you’re a song- e me o o writer or a composer, they’re already www. me o co .com i eo here. me m ic o e i co - For years, many questioned whether AI, a technology that began ere ce ei e cto er in the 1950s, could ever crack the i o e e i t i e r code of creativity, which might be rt eri wit t e etwor considered a uniquely human trait. to cre te m ti e io tr c But in the last several years, machine o t i o e er orm ce i learning has made significant advanc- i eo me i c i i e t es such that we should no longer ask oo t ow et if AI can make art. Rather, when pre- sented with a photograph, a painting ter cti e e i reeme t. or a piece of music, we must ask, Was Amper Music is one of a number of emerging AI-based production music services. this made by a human or a machine? CAS to Honor And the answer is not always obvious. Music?” The panel will explore the duction Music Association) board Lee Orloff As composer Andrew Gross ob- current state of AI-generated music member. “There are no laws; there t t e t serves, “It’s no longer a question of for sync licensing, whether for film, are just ethical arguments and con- when AI will start generating business television, video games or other visual versations that we can all have.” w r to e e e r r and competing with human compos- media. The online AI music platforms op- i o e e t e i em ers—it’s happening now.” During the But as much as the panel will fo- erate similarly. A user selects param- io ociet www.ci em io- fifth annual PMA Production Music cus on the technologies, workflows eters such as genre, length, tempo, ociet .or wi o or m ti e Conference, to be held September and business models, there will also instrumentation and so on, and the c em w r omi te 26-28 at the Loews Hotel in Hol- be some discussion around its poten- site generates a file. The method used ro ctio o mi er ee r o lywood, CA, Gross will moderate tial regulation. “Because there’s noth- to create the music and the assign- wit it i e t cco e t e “AI-Generated Music: How Will This ing in place at the moment to stop it,” ment of the composition’s copyright Impact the Future of Production says Gross, who is also a PMA (Pro- (continued on page 26) reer c ie eme t w r i reco itio o i wor o more t e t re i m i ce . Genelec Gives The Rules and Tools Behind the Mixes Immersive Guidance of The Darkest Minds e e ec ree / Immersive Solutions 2018 i e- BY STEVE HARVEY oo ow o e rom www. CULVER CITY, CA—In The Darkest e e ec.com ro i e r ctic Minds, a 20th Century Fox film di- o er iew o ri ci e orm t rected by Jennifer Yuh Nelson, most tec ic co i er tio i o e of the world’s children die, while the i immer i e io re ro ctio survivors are rounded up by the gov- o wit recomme e e e ec ernment after they develop mind con- e er tem co i r tio trol powers. The movie is based on the first in a series of young adult o tw re ti itie co er novels written by Alexandra Bracken. o tmo ro . For co-supervising sound editors Will ot er orm t . Files and Warren Hendricks, the prin- cipal challenge was to give the film’s Sony Bows Post mind control powers individual sonic Rooms signatures with a good or evil twist, while also—rather more prosaically— o ict re dealing with an evolving post-produc- o t ro ctio er ice www. tion schedule. In The Darkest Minds, the world’s remaining teenagers develop superpowers, so the film’s o ict re o t.com ei e In fact, the evolving schedule was audio team had to give those powers individual sonic signatures with a good or evil twist. t ree ew t io i i e t e o what led Files and Hendricks to share o ict re t io er it their credits. “I came on to supervise “It was a perfect scenario in many and did the final mix, primarily with ot e ter e i e or o and I brought Warren on to help do the ways because Warren and I have very Andy Nelson.” The final mix was sound design,” Files recalls. “He did similar and overlapping skills. I felt completed on Fox Studios’ Howard e i mi i wit two i some great sound design and the cli- very confident handing the reins to Hawks Stage in Culver City, CA. co o e o tmo c i i- ents really loved it. Then the schedule him, and the clients felt very confi- “I’ve joked a number of times over tie e ter or remote i extended so far that I could no longer dent with him taking them because the years that my entire career at this e ect co or r i re iew stay on the project full-time.” Fortu- he had been involved with the sound point is based on kids with super- e ter wit i e or nately, Hendricks was able to take over design up to that point, and he’s also powers,” laughs Hendricks, whose o e i . File’s role and shepherd the project an excellent mixer. I had mixed the sound design credits include two in- through the mixing stage, he says. temp mixes, then Warren took over (continued on page 26)
[ October 2018 ] [ 26 ] soundPOST/BROADCAST
AI Amper Music is perhaps the high- ogies are useful collaborative tools. have the right to attach a name as a est profile AI music platform, but One YouTuber, Taryn Southern, add- composer and their own publishing (continued from page 25) it was not the first to market. That ed her own lyrics and vocal melodies entity, to collect royalties should it air honor appears to go to Jukedeck in to an AI-generated Amper composi- on television, in the U.S. and world- the UK, which to date has reportedly tion to create “Break Free,” a video— wide,” or monetize it on YouTube, he are two areas in which the services generated over half a million tracks which also uses AI-generated imag- says. “A CEO could say, My family tend to differ. for customers worldwide, including ery—that is approaching two million and I are the composers and we’re Amper Music offers fully cus- Coca-Cola and Google (which has views. going to start a publishing company. tomizable music. (Amper CEO and its own AI-generated music and art The most ambitious—or auda- They could register with BMI and co-founder Drew Silverstein, an research project, Magenta). cious, perhaps—example of AI-gen- ASCAP and collect royalties just like award-winning composer, producer Founded by Cambridge Univer- erated music is “Daddy’s Car.” In anyone else.” and songwriter for visual media, will sity graduates, Jukedeck is working 2016, researchers at Sony Computer Xhail takes a different approach, be on Gross’ panel.) Gross has tried toward total AI music synthesis, not Science Laboratories used the com- Gross observes. “They register those Amper’s system: “I was able to up- just machine-generated composi- pany’s Flow-Machines technology to copyrights. Xhail in effect becomes load a video, make a start point and tions, using artificial neural networks. create a pop song, in collaboration the owner and publisher of that piece an end point, and identify anything I The company’s R&D team posted with composer Benoît Carré, in the of music.” Kiely has noted in past wanted to hit, like a cut. I would say an eight-bar piano piece on its blog style of The Beatles. A more recent interviews that sync and royalty rev- it was high school-level at best, but it in late 2016, noting, “To the best of project by SKYGGE, a collective enue is shared with contributing mu- was impressive in that it had the right our knowledge, it’s the first time a of French creatives, used Flow-Ma- sicians and composers, with writers idea. It’s just that it was using sounds computer has written and produced chines as an inspirational and col- retaining 100 percent of their rights that you might find in GarageBand or a complete ‘song,’ from start to finish, laborative tool to generate sections and Xhail owning 100 percent of the Logic.” using purely machine learning-driven of songs, melodies and instrument publishing. At the other end of the spectrum, techniques.” and vocal tracks to produce an en- In much the same way as AI ser- Xhail, which will be represented on In one possible dystopian future, tire album, engineered and mixed by vices like LANDR and CloudBounce, the panel by CEO and founder Mick machines could make composers and humans, entitled Hello World. (It can and iZotope’s Ozone 8 Mastering As- Kiely, who has over 30 years of expe- songwriters redundant. But Gross be- be heard on Spotify, YouTube and sistant software might be taking busi- rience in music composition and live lieves that AI music software develop- elsewhere.) ness away from lower-cost mastering performance, creates custom AI-gen- ers view composers and musicians One gray area regarding AI music, engineers, AI music platforms may erated pieces using human-generated as future partners. “The better the says Gross, is the issue of rights and be impacting composers working on loops and stems. “I’ve heard some musicians, the better the composers publishing. Where these services offer low-budget sync licensing projects. of the results; it’s pretty impressive,” they’re able to hire to program the royalty-free music, he says, “A com- But Gross can also see an upside: “As says Gross. “They have a very tight AI, the better the AI will be able to pany can purchase this music and a composer, I can see it being a great set of specs that they send to their write and produce better-quality mu- there’s no composer attached to it. tool. You use it as inspiration. I like composers. The quality is quite good sic,” he says. They own all rights to it, both master that.” because they’re well-produced loops There is already evidence that and publishing, in perpetuity.” Production Music Association that humans created.” these AI-generated music technol- Potentially, “That company would www.pmamusic.com
underlying sound was established, he concentrated on drifting, high-speed temp mixes for early cuts and audi- Darkest Minds says, he would add elements specific bys and takeoffs—all the dangerous ence playback in 5.1. Eventually, with (continued from page 25) to the character. stuff.” the changing schedule, the budget How does a sound communicate Files and Hendricks came on- would no longer stretch to a final good or evil? “The character Clancy board as the director’s cut was being Atmos mix. stallments of the X-Men series, Dead- and the main character, Ruby, are assembled, which was fortuitous, as “After the final mix was done, the pool and Fantastic Four, among many both Oranges,” Hendricks offers as their sound design “rules” essentially next week they called and said, ‘Hey, others. In X-Men, he observes, char- examples. Each character’s sounds set the tone for the film. Those rules we want an Atmos mix,’” Hendricks acters have distinct powers with dis- were layered. “There were high were picked up by the new picture reports. “We had to reverse engineer tinctive sounds. In The Darkest Minds, tones and low tones and sounds for editor when there was a change part- it in only three days—without the cli- the kids have one of five powers, des- eyes coming on, stuff like that. We way through the project. ents.” The director, having signed off ignated by color: orange, red, yellow, built similar sounds for Clancy, as “He really got it,” says Files. “He on the final mix, and emotionally ex- blue or green. “You have people with far as pitch and rhythm, but they understood the language that we had hausted following the studio screen- the same general power, but you still were built out of things like screams created and ran with it. He took our ings, couldn’t return for the Atmos need to make them sound distinct,” or reverse metal ‘ronks,’ and when stuff and made it even cooler, be- mix, he says, “so we had to be really says Hendricks. we isolated those elements more out cause he reused it more and more conservative,” and not stray from the “All the powers need to sound dis- of the general Orange power sounds, and pushed more sound design in the 7.1 mix. tinct from each other, but even within they really felt a lot darker and more movie.” Fortuitously, Hendricks continues, the characters who have the same imposing.” Files reports that about 75 percent “The workflow that we set up, where power, they need to sound the same Any sounds that came from the of his studio movie projects are re- it’s all native, and especially now with but slightly evil, or slightly good,” editors’ respective libraries were pro- leased in Dolby Atmos, and he works Atmos functionality being built into says Files. “It was all about character- cessed specifically for this project, natively about 90 percent of the time. Pro Tools, made it all possible with a ization. We had to make the powers but there was an opportunity to grab This film was different, however; it minimal amount of prep time and a sound powerful and cool and cine- new sounds at California City Mu- was released in Dolby Atmos, but minimal amount of crew people hav- matic, adding drama to the scene, but nicipal Airport in the desert north of that was a last-minute decision. ing to deal with it. the challenge was to give them some Los Angeles, a go-to location for re- “Warren and I like to blur the “Had it been a year ago, it would real character.” cording cars. “That was our primary lines between editing and mixing. As probably have taken a couple of Hendricks set his own rules for recording for this show; we recorded soon as we start designing and ed- weeks to figure it out. But with the the characterization, he says. “They a Dodge [Challenger] Hellcat,” says iting sounds, we’re also mixing. We new [Pro Tools] functionality, it would sound ridiculous if you were to Hendricks, with Hollywood recordist try to set up our workflow in such a turned out not to be a super-painful explain them to somebody else. But John Fasal. “He has a good relation- way that we have all the mixing tools process—though I would not recom- I know that this three-frame sound ship with that airfield. [The sounds available to us from the beginning,” mend that this be the way people ap- is for a Yellow-powered person’s eyes are] meant to be over the top and he says. proach Atmos!” coming on, and this is the sound of crazy and make the character driving In that sense, they were ready to Avid a Blue using their powers.” Once the the car feel a little dangerous, so we mix in Atmos, but were delivering www.avid.com
[ October 2018 ] soundPOST/BROADCAST [ 27 ]