Marten Van Cleve
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
MARTEN VAN CLEVE - THE MASSACRE OF THE INNOCENTS Comparative Study of Different Versions of the Subject and the Function of Drawings in Flemish Workshops During the 16th-Century Ellionore Schachnow Department of Culture and Aesthetics, Stockholm University Spring 2020 ABSTRACT Department: Department of Culture and Aesthetics, Stockholm University, Art History Address: 106 91 Stockholm University Supervisor: Maria Beatrice De Ruggieri Title and Subtitle: Marten van Cleve - The Massacre of the Innocents: Comparative Study of Different Versions of the Subject and the Function of Drawings in Flemish Workshops During the 16th-Century Author: Ellionore Schachnow Author’s Contact Information: Midskeppsgatan 1, 120 66, Stockholm, [email protected] Essay Level: Master’s Thesis Ventilation Semester: Spring 2020 This thesis examines Marten van Cleve’s painting the Massacre of the Innocents from the Stockholm University Art Collection through technical examinations that were conducted at Spökslottet in January 2020 (X-ray, UV, IRR). The aim of the thesis is to examine Marten van Cleve’s painting technique, style and composition by comparing the painting with 5 similar versions of the subject the Massacre of the Innocents. Moreover, the thesis compares the underdrawing of the painting from the Stockholm University Art collection with the drawing from Göttingen that are similar in composition and signed by Marten van Cleve. Additionally, this thesis examines the relationship between preparatory drawings and the underdrawings in the artists environment in order to learn more about Marten van Cleve’s painting process as well as achieve an insight into contemporary 16th-century Flemish artists. Keywords: Marten van Cleve, Maerten van Cleve, Marten van Cleef, The Massacre of the Innocents, Technical Art History Contents Introduction ................................................................................................................................ 1 Aim and Research Questions ................................................................................................. 2 Theoretical Framework .......................................................................................................... 2 Previous Research .................................................................................................................. 3 Material and Method .............................................................................................................. 5 Disposition ............................................................................................................................. 6 Delimitations .......................................................................................................................... 6 Technical Entry .......................................................................................................................... 7 Support ................................................................................................................................... 7 Ground Layers ........................................................................................................................ 8 Underdrawing ....................................................................................................................... 10 Underpainting ("Abbozzo") ................................................................................................. 11 Paint Layers .......................................................................................................................... 11 Varnish ................................................................................................................................. 12 Comparative Study of The Massacre of the Innocents ............................................................ 16 Copies of the Massacre of the Innocents .............................................................................. 16 Preliminary Notes About the Compared Paintings .............................................................. 17 Index of the Compared Paintings ......................................................................................... 19 Comparison .......................................................................................................................... 20 Marten van Cleve – The Massacre of the Innocents (Christie’s version) ........................ 20 Marten van Cleve – The Massacre of the Innocents under the Snow (Monaco version). 23 Marten van Cleve – The Massacre of the Innocents (Ader version) ................................ 24 Marten van Cleve – The Massacre of the Innocents (Private collection Switzerland) .... 25 Der Bethlehemitische Kindermord, Kunstsammlung der Universität (Göttingen) .......... 26 Conclusion ............................................................................................................................ 28 The Signed Drawing by Marten van Cleve from Göttingen .................................................... 29 Technical Notes About the Drawing .................................................................................... 30 Comparative Study Between the Drawing and the Painting ................................................ 31 Drawings in the 16th-Century Antwerp Workshop .................................................................. 33 Drawings and Underdrawings in Pieter Bruegel the Elder’s Workshop .............................. 35 Conclusion ................................................................................................................................ 38 Bibliography ............................................................................................................................. 40 Literature .............................................................................................................................. 40 Internet Sources ................................................................................................................ 41 List of Illustrations ................................................................................................................... 43 Introduction The story of the Massacre of the Innocents derives from the Bible (Matthew 2: 16-18). King Herod ordered the assassination of all the male children in Bethlehem under the age of two after being informed by the wise men that Jesus was born. In the painting The Massacre of the Innocents, the biblical scene is set in a snow-covered Flemish village. The motif has been interpreted as containing political connotations where the roman soldiers in the painting represents the Spanish army and German soldiers were ordered to regain control over Phillip II’s rebelling provinces.1 The captain on the horse in the foreground to the right is surrounded by a group of people who begs for mercy, in the centre of the painting there is a man that hands over a petition to a soldier on a horse. To the right a soldier leaves the house with a child under his arm and to the left there are two soldiers who tries to break into the house by force. There is a child that is murdered and bleeds in the snow in the foreground to the right and there is a woman with a child being chased by an armed soldier in the foreground to the right. The Massacre of the Innocents in the Stockholm University Art Collection has been attributed to the Flemish artist Marten van Cleve, but the painting is not signed. Previously the painting was attributed to Pieter Bruegel the Younger. Although, there is a drawing that is signed by Marten van Cleve in the copperplate collection of the university in Göttingen with a similar composition and figurative themes that indicates that the painting may be of the same old master.2 The Massacre of the Innocents by Marten van Cleve have been a part of the Huss collection3 and the Berg collection in 1882 and since 1884 the Massacre of the Innocents has been a part of the Stockholm University Art Collection.4 The Flemish artist Marten van Cleve (1527-1581) became a master in the Antwerp Guild of St Luke during 1551-2. Van Cleve studied under Frans Floris. In 1556 Marten van Cleve set up his own studio with apprentices that were recorded from 1558 and onwards, his sons Gillis II, Marten the younger, Joris and Nicolaas also used the studio. During the 1560s and 1570s the workshop of Marten van Cleve was productive, creating a vast amount of copies of van Cleves original paintings, although the chronology of his original works are unclear. The low-life scenes that depicts peasant weddings, festivities or plundering soldiers were influenced by the work of his 1 Christie’s, https://www.christies.com/LotFinder/lot_details.aspx?intObjectID=5813550, retrieved 05/02/2020. 2 Karling, Sten, The Stockholm university collection of paintings: catalogue, University of Stockholm [Stockholms univ.], Stockholm, 1978. 3 As Pieter Bruegel the Younger. In the Huss collection catalogue, it says that the painting came from Löwenhielm’s collection although the painting is not mentioned in the Löwenhielm catalogue from 1857. 4 Weibull, Nina & Olausson, Magnus (red.), Mästerverk från Spökslottet: den Bergska samlingen, Nationalmuseum, Stockholm, 1995, pp 51–52. 1 contemporary Pieter Bruegel the Elder.5 There are at least 20 paintings with a similar composition that depicts the Massacre of the Innocents, although many have been attributed to Pieter Bruegel the Younger.6 The attribution of the different version have been disputed among scholars.