Independent Evaluation of Hirola Antelope Beatragus Hunteri Conservation Status and Conservation Action in Kenya
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
A REPORT FOR THE KENYA WILDLIFE SERVICE AND THE HIROLA ANTELOPE MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE SEPTEMBER 2000 INDEPENDENT EVALUATION OF HIROLA ANTELOPE BEATRAGUS HUNTERI CONSERVATION STATUS AND CONSERVATION ACTION IN KENYA Thomas M. Butynski, PhD Senior Conservation Biologist Zoo Atlanta’s Africa Biodiversity Conservation Program National Museums of Kenya INDEPENDENT EVALUATION OF HIROLA ANTELOPE BEATRAGUS HUNTERI CONSERVATION STATUS AND CONSERVATION ACTION IN KENYA Two drafts of this report were provided to the Kenya Wildlife Service and to the Hirola Antelope Management Committee for review. The corrections, suggestions and comments of the reviewers have been incorporated into this final report. The views expressed in this report are those of the author. They do not necessarily reflect the views of the Kenya Wildlife Service, Hirola Antelope Management Committee, or Zoo Atlanta. Cover: Adult female hirola (Hunter’s antelopes) Beatragus hunteri. This “Critically Endangered” species and genus is endemic to south-east Kenya and south-west Somalia. This illustration, by a “Mr Wolf”, is based on a skin collected by H.C.V. Hunter in 1887 and appeared with Sclater’s (1889) initial description of the hirola. i INDEPENDENT EVALUATION OF HIROLA ANTELOPE BEATRAGUS HUNTERI CONSERVATION STATUS AND CONSERVATION ACTION IN KENYA CONTENTS CONTENTS............................................................ ii LIST OF TABLES...................................................... vii LIST OF FIGURES.....................................................viii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS.................................................... x 1. EXECUTIVE SUMMARY............................................... 1 2. INTRODUCTION.................................................... 3 3. THE NAME “HIROLA”............................................... 5 4. TAXONOMY OF THE HIROLA.......................................... 5 5. PHYSICAL DESCRIPTION OF THE HIROLA.............................. 7 6. DISTRIBUTION OF THE HIROLA...................................... 11 6.1 Natural Geographic Range in Kenya and Somalia............. 11 6.2 Introduced Population in Tsavo East National Park......... 20 7. POPULATION ESTIMATES, TRENDS AND CURRENT STATUS OF THE HIROLA... 37 7.1 Natural Population in Kenya............................... 37 7.1.1 Problems with the database......................... 37 7.1.2 Early population estimates......................... 37 7.1.3 Aerial censuses by DRSRS and others (1973-96)...... 38 7.1.4 The 1995 KWS census................................ 42 7.1.5 More comments on aerial surveys of savanna antelope populations.................................... 48 7.2 Natural Population in Somalia........................... 51 7.3 Introduced Population in Tsavo East National Park....... 52 7.3.1 The 1963 translocation............................ 52 7.3.2 The 1996 translocation............................ 61 7.4 Captive Population....................................... 66 7.5 Conservation Status...................................... 67 7.6 Legal Status.............................................. 68 8. ECOLOGY AND BEHAVIOUR OF THE HIROLA........................... 68 8.1 Scientific Studies...................................... 68 8.2 Seasonal Distribution and Movements..................... 69 8.3 Habitat Description...................................... 70 8.4 Habitat Preference....................................... 79 8.5 Diet and Feeding......................................... 83 ii 8.6 Social Organization and Population Structure............. 84 8.7 Reproduction............................................. 88 8.8 Predators................................................ 90 8.9 Diseases................................................. 90 9. WHAT CAUSED THE DECLINE IN THE NUMBER OF HIROLA?................ 92 9.1 Introduction............................................. 92 9.2 Food Shortages........................................... 93 9.2.1 Habitat loss and degradation..................... 93 9.2.2 Drought and diseases.............................. 97 9.2.3 Loss of floodplain grasslands................ 98 9.2.4 Competition with livestock.................... 101 9.3 Poaching................................................. 104 9.4 Inbreeding/Demographic Depression........................ 111 9.5 Decline of Arawale National Reserve...................... 111 10. HIROLA TASK FORCE/HIROLA MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE................. 112 10.1 Background............................................... 112 10.2 Terms of Reference....................................... 113 10.2.1 Terms of reference for the Hirola Task Force..... 113 10.2.2 Terms of reference for the Hirola Management Committee.................................... 114 10.3 Action Plan............................................. 115 11. 1996 TRANSLOCATION............................................ 116 11.1 Objectives............................................... 116 11.2 Background............................................... 116 11.3 Personnel................................................ 117 11.4 Capture Method and Numbers Caught/Translocated........... 117 11.5 Sensitization of, and Approval by, People in Garissa District............................................. 118 11.6 The Court Injunction and its Effects.................... 119 11.7 Post Release Monitoring and Research in Tsavo............ 120 11.8 Fenced Sanctuary in Tsavo East National Park............. 120 11.9 Costs of Translocation................................... 121 11.10 Problems and Constraints................................. 122 11.11 Conclusions of the Hirola Task Force..................... 123 12. POPULATION VIABILITY ANALYSIS................................. 124 13. LOCAL HIROLA CONSERVATION ORGANIZATIONS....................... 127 13.1 Introduction............................................ 127 13.2 Harroru Community Hirola Conservation Group.............. 127 13.3 Arawale Youth Wildlife Community......................... 131 13.4 One Community Based Organization for Hirola Conservation. 132 14. EVALUATION AND RECOMMENDATIONS: RESEARCH....................... 133 14.1 Evaluation............................................... 133 14.2 Recommendations.......................................... 133 14.2.1 Research on the Tsavo hirola population.......... 133 14.2.1.1 Conduct a total population count in Tsavo every 3 years................. 133 iii 14.2.1.2 Assess the genetic health of Tsavo population......................... 134 14.2.2 Research on the natural hirola population....... 134 14.2.2.1 Transfer the focus of the field research programme from Tsavo to the natural population............. 134 14.2.2.2 Closely monitor the relative size and trend of thenatural population....... 134 14.2.2.3 Support research by Kenyan and Somali students.............................. 140 14.2.2.4 Retrieve missing 1995 KWS hirola census data........................... 143 14.2.2.5 Rewrite the 1995 KWS hirola census report.............................. 143 14.2.2.6 Establish three hirola information bases in Nairobi........................... 144 14.2.2.7 Conduct more PVAs..................... 144 15. EVALUATIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS: TRANSLOCATIONS............... 145 15.1 Evaluations.............................................. 145 15.1.1 The 1963 translocation........................... 145 15.1.2 The 1996 translocation........................... 145 15.2 Comments on the 1996 Translocation....................... 146 15.2.1 Capture methods and choice of age groups......... 146 15.2.2 Building predator - proof sanctuaries............ 149 15.2.3 Placing radio collars on hirola.................. 152 15.3 Recommendations.......................................... 154 15.3.1 The Hirola Translocation Subcommittee‘s recommendations for future translocations.... 154 15.3.2 Recommendations from this evaluation............. 156 15.3.2.1 Translocation method and age group.... 156 15.3.2.2 Predator-proof sanctuaries............. 156 15.3.2.3 Radio collars......................... 157 15.3.2.4 Collection of data..................... 157 15.3.2.5 Information on the 1996 translocation. 158 16. EVALUATION AND RECOMMENDATIONS: ESTABLISHING NEW POPULATIONS... 158 16.1 The Need for more Populations of Hirola.................. 158 16.2 KWS Managed Areas vs Private Game Ranches as Translocation Sites................................. 159 16.3 Evaluation of Potential Sites for Hirola Translocation... 161 16.3.1 Background....................................... 161 16.3.2 National Parks and National Reserves............. 161 16.3.2.1 West bank of the Tana River Primate National Reserve....................... 161 16.3.2.2 Tsavo East National Park.............. 161 iv 16.3.2.3 Tsavo West National Park.............. 162 16.3.2.4 Nairobi National Park.................. 162 16.3.2.5 Meru National Park..................... 163 16.3.3 Private game ranches............................ 163 16.3.3.1 Boabab Farm, Mombasa................... 163 16.3.3.2 Hilton Wildlife Sanctuary, Taita Hills.. 163 16.3.3.3 Athi River Game Ranching............... 164 16.3.3.4 Lewa Downs Wildlife Sanctuary.......... 164 16.3.3 5 01 Jogi (Pyramid) Wildlife Sanctuary... 165 16.3.4 Priority sites for establishing hirola populations 166 16.4 Establishing a Captive Population........................ 166 16.4.1 Evaluation....................................... 166 16.4.2 Recommendations.................................. 167 16.5 Removing more Hirola from the Natural Population......... 168 17. EVALUATION AND