arXiv:2101.06279v2 [astro-ph.SR] 3 Mar 2021 n h rtecutro S ihteSn nNvme 2018, November in D Sun, question. characteristics the this with situ tackle PSP in to of order encounter the go first in to sample the wind spacecraft ing to solar first pristine Sun the the Park the is of question. to 2016) open enough al. accelerated an et close Fox are still (PSP, particles is Probe these medium Solar How interplanetary wind. partic the of solar to stream the a as releases known constantly atmosphere solar The Introduction 1. Kretzschmar ac ,2021 4, March Astronomy .Froment C. ieteiec o antcrcneto tteboundarie the at reconnection magnetic for evidence Direct Goetz edo h wthak,a switchbacks, occur. the to of reconnection field magnetic for conditions favourable m and mag field a with guide conjunction strong in a reconnection have anti-parallel events quasi reconnection and inbound the the of at Most anti-correlated then and correlated first often holes. structures, coronal these from heliosphere; inner the in flections Conclusions. Results. Methods. Aims. Context. h eua ida hypoaaeaa rmteSun. words. the Key from away propagate they as wind regular the cur accomodate boundaries switchback the as However, rare. eevdOtbr 02020 30 October, Received SEP instruments. (SWEAP) S tadsac f4 o4 oa ai oteSndrn t fir its during Sun the to radii solar 48 to 45 of distance a at PSP 12 11 10 16 15 14 13 7 6 5 4 3 9 2 8 1 aoaoyfrAmshrcadSaePyis nvriyo University Physics, Space and Atmospheric for Laboratory eateto at,Paeay n pc cecs CA L UCLA, Sciences, Space and Planetary, Earth, of Department A Space Italy for Roma, Astrophysics-Institute for Institute National mtsna srpyia bevtr,Cmrde A 02 MA, Cambridge, Observatory, Astrophysical Smithsonian colo hsc n srnm,QenMr nvriyo Lo of University Mary Queen Astronomy, and Physics of School aoaor ’srpyiu eBreu,Ui.Bordeaux, Univ. Bordeaux, de d’Astrophysique Laboratoire h lcetLbrtr,Ipra olg odn London, London, College Imperial Laboratory, Blackett The ntttd ehrh nAtohsqee lntlge CN Planétologie, et Astrophysique en Recherche de Institut hsc eatet nvriyo aiona ekly C Berkeley, California, of University Department, Physics e-mail: pc cecsLbrtr,Uiest fClfri,Berk California, of University Laboratory, Sciences Space srpyia n lntr cecsDprmn,Univers Department, Sciences Planetary and Astrophysical oa ytmEpoainDvso,NASA Division, Exploration System USA Solar 20002, DC Washington, Inc., Technologies, BWX lmt n pc cecsadEgneig nvriyo M of University Engineering, and Sciences Space and Climate colo hsc n srnm,Uiest fMneoa M Minnesota, of University Astronomy, and Physics of School P2,CNRS LPC2E, 13 erpr h ietpeeo vdnefrmgei reconnec magnetic for evidence of piece direct the report We & .C Kasper C. J. , 1 h he tutrsaaye l hwtpclsgaue o signatures typical show all analysed structures three The h rtecutr fPre oa rb PP ihteSnr Sun the with (PSP) Probe Solar Parker of encounters first The .K Jagarlamudi K. V. , eaayetemgei edadpam aaeesfo h F the from parameters plasma and field magnetic the analyse We Astrophysics [email protected] 1 .Krasnoselskikh V. , u:hlopee u:oa id antcfils Magneti fields, Magnetic wind, Sun:solar heliosphere, Sun: ie h elho nes urn hesosre yPP r PSP, by observed sheets current intense of wealth the Given antcsicbcswt akrSlrProbe Solar Parker with switchbacks magnetic / nvriyo Orléans of University 12 aucitn.paper_reconnection_SB no. manuscript ff , / cigtednmc fteslrwn n vnulycontrib eventually and wind solar the of dynamics the ecting 14 cetdJnay1,2021 15, January Accepted , 15 .E Korreck E. K. , 1 , 5 1 .Velli M. , , 2 .Ddkd Wit de Dudok T. , / NS Aaeu el ehrh cetfiu,Olas Franc Orléans, Scientifique, Recherche la de avenue 3A CNES, / odr pc lgtCne,Genet D 07,USA 20771, MD, Greenbelt, Center, Flight Space Goddard Revillet 6 .Malaspina D. , 12 .E Larson E. D. , aldsicbcs r atclrysrkn nslrwin solar in striking particularly are switchbacks, called 1 ei edmgiuedces y90%. by decrease magnitude field netic ubudegso h iuctdcretset ihacentr a with sheets current bifurcated the of edges outbound n .L Stevens L. M. and , uhamcaimwudtu otiuei eofiuigtem the reconfiguring in contribute thus would mechanism a Such ABSTRACT tohsc n lntlg,VadlFsodlCvlee10 Cavaliere del Fosso del Via Planetology, and strophysics les, 1 ly A97075,USA 94720-7450, CA eley, ur- 42-30 USA 94720-7300, A et,oecncnetr httegoer fteeboundar these of geometry the that conjecture can one rents, t fClrd,Budr O833 USA 80303, CO Boulder, Colorado, of ity er .Agapitov O. , tencounter. st S P,CE,Tuos,France Toulouse, CNES, UPS, RS, NS 1N lé Geo allée B18N, CNRS, ooao ole,C 00,USA 80303, CO Boulder, Colorado, f 3,USA 138, W A,UK 2AZ, SW7 drt antcser u n urn he hw indicat shows sheet current one but shear, magnetic oderate cia,AnAbr I419 USA 48109, MI Arbor, Ann ichigan, sAgls A 09,USA 90095, CA, Angeles, os nepls N545 USA 55455, MN inneapolis, 7 antcrcneto.Teinvlct n antcfield magnetic and velocity ion The reconnection. magnetic f oecrepn ofl eesl Ddkd i ta.2020; al. et degrees, Wit de of (Dudok tens reversals few full a to of are correspond (fr polarity) deflections some most sunward Although prevalent wind component. the the radial solar in its the pronounced of particularly of are ation field which 2019), magnetic ubiqui al. the the et (Bale in revealed observations deflections approach an of These al. made presence et radii. and Badman 2020) solar al. 2019; 35.7 et al. Szabo at et 2020; originat- (Riley al. stream hole et Kim coronal slow-wind 2020; small a a in from embedded ing was spacecraft the inocriga h onaiso he wthak cross switchbacks three of boundaries the at occurring tion dn odnE N,UK 4NS, E1 London ndon, , 8 .L Whittlesey L. P. , 2 .J MacDowall J. R. , reconnection c vae h rsneo bqioslclsdmgei de- magnetic localised ubiquitous of presence the evealed ED n oa idEetosApa n Protons and Alphas Electrons Wind Solar and IELDS cneto tsicbc onaisapast be to appears boundaries switchback at econnection 2 .Fargette N. , 12 ff tn otebedn ftesrcue with structures the of blending the to uting o an-iar,365Psa,France Pessac, 33615 Saint-Hilaire, roy 2 .D Bale D. S. , 16 3 .Lavraud B. , .S Mozer S. F. , e 2 , 9 ril ubr ae1o 11 of 1 page number, Article , 10 tem originating streams d 3 9 , , 4 .Pulupa M. , 11 .Larosa A. , .W Case W. A. , linflwjet. flow ion al ,I-00133 0, e o ies © agnetic osof ions S 2021 ESO of s dby ed 2 ff 1 C. , are ers M. , 12 vari- tous K. , om A&A proofs: manuscript no. paper_reconnection_SB
Mozer et al. 2020). Their duration spans from a few seconds (e.g Bale et al. 2019; Krasnoselskikh et al. 2020; Agapitov et al. to a few hours (Dudok de Wit et al. 2020). For these structures 2020). Krasnoselskikh et al. (2020) have also reported strong the electron pitch-angle distributions show that the strahl, the currents at switchback boundaries, which is confirmed by the high energy electron population emanating from the Sun, fol- statistical analysis conducted by Larosa et al. (2021). lows the orientation of the magnetic field (Kasper et al. 2019). Current sheets are privileged regions for magnetic reconnec- This suggest that these ‘switchbacks’ are localised twists in the tion to occur. In the case of magnetic reconnection, the mag- magnetic field and not simple polarity reversals or closed loops. netic field topology is reconfigured to a simpler configuration, Cross helicity measurements, in addition, show that magneto- converting magnetic energy into thermal and kinetic energies hydrodynamic waves follow the magnetic field inside the switch- (e.g Cassak 2016; Zweibel & Yamada 2009; Zweibel & Yamada backs (McManus et al. 2020). This magnetic field twist is cou- 2016). Particles are ejected away from the reconnection site at pled with a proton velocity enhancement that is most of the a velocity close to the Alfvén velocity, and the plasma is lo- time, but not always, of the order of the local Alfvén velocity. cally heated. Reconnection in the solar wind is typically detected As shown by Larosa et al. (2021), velocity enhancements inside through the observation of an ion flow jet within a bifurcated switchbacks can be only of a few percent of the velocity outside current sheet (Gosling et al. 2005). The probability of crossing of the structures. The statistics of these enhancements show a the reconnection site, the so-called diffusion region, is low due continuum of fractions of the local Alfvén velocity. to its small spatial scale (of the order of the ion inertial length Structures similar to switchbacks were observed before in di). A correlation between the evolution of the magnetic field the solar wind (e.g Balogh et al. 1999; Horbury et al. 2018). and the particle density, later followed by an anti-correlation, or However, the new observations from PSP revealed persistent the other way around, is typically observed when reconnection features, populating a significant fraction of the measurements. exhausts are crossed. Such behaviour is consistent with Alfvén Such short events had also never been observed before. The waves propagating along the magnetic field, away from the re- scattered observation of switchbacks further away from the Sun connection site on either side of the exhaust, as demonstrated could be due to their deterioration as they travel, even though by Gosling et al. (2005). In PSP observations, reconnection ex- these structures seem to be able to live long enough in the slow hausts have been reported at the heliospheric current sheets solar wind to be generated close to the Sun and observed at a (HCS), in interplanetary coronal mass ejections (ICME), and in few tens of solar radii (Tenerani et al. 2020a). The ubiquity of some isolated current sheets, but not so far at the most frequent switchbacks in PSP observations (also during subsequent peri- current sheets observed which are those that bound switchbacks helia) could also be due to the co-rotation of the probe with the (e.g. Phan et al. 2020; Lavraud et al. 2020; Fargette et al. 2021). Sun during the encounters, allowing the probe to meet a larger In this paper, we analyse the boundariesof three switchbacks number of them, even if they were emitted by a rather localised that were crossed during the first solar encounter of PSP. At least source on the Sun (Horbury et al. 2020). We also note that there five out of six current sheets show direct evidence of magnetic is presently no consensus between the few statistical studies that reconnection. They were observed on November 1 and Novem- have quantified the degree of occurrence of switchbacks with the ber 2, 2018, that is to say five and four days before perihelion. At radial distance from the Sun (Tenerani et al. 2020b; Velli et al. that time, PSP was located between 48 and 45 solar radii from 2020). the Sun. The observations are presented in Sect. 2. After the de- Observational studies invoke the formation of these struc- tailed analysis of the three events in Sect. 3, we summarise their tures either by processes occurring deep in the solar atmo- properties and discuss the implications of our observations on sphere (Dudok de Wit et al. 2020; Krasnoselskikh et al. 2020; the switchbacks dynamics and propagation in the solar wind in Macneil et al. 2020; Woodham et al. 2021) or directly in the Sect. 4. solar wind (Ruffoloet al. 2020). These two types of origins have also been explored on the numerical and theoretical side: on the one hand, via interchange reconnection in the corona (Fisk & Kasper 2020; Drake et al. 2021) or jets in the solar at- 2. PSP observations mosphere(Roberts et al. 2018; Sterling & Moore2020; He et al. 2.1. Data 2020); on the other hand, via waves growth generated by the ex- pansion of the structure away from the Sun (Squire et al. 2020) We used magnetic field measurements made by the FIELDS or shear-driventurbulence in the solar wind (Ruffolo et al. 2020). suite of instruments (Bale et al. 2016). The vector magnetic field As of today, the mechanisms leading to the formation of switch- was measured from DC to several tens of hertz by the flux- backs is still unclear and it is unknown whether different popula- gate magnetometer (MAG) while magnetic fluctuations above tions of switchbacks might be generated by distinct mechanisms. 10 Hz were measured by the Search-Coil Magnetometer (SCM, Their omnipresence, however, shows that they could play an im- Jannet et al. 2020). Our analysis of wave activity (Sect. 3.2) and portant role in the dynamics and heating of the solar wind. its properties is based on waveforms (73.24 samples per sec- Several interesting properties of the switchbacks arise from ond, 3 components), auto- and cross-spectra (cadence of 28 sec- the study of their boundaries. The rotation of the magnetic onds, full spectral matrix), and band-pass filter (BPF) time series field at the boundary of switchbacks make them current sheets (cadence of 0.87 seconds, one component only: u in the SCM by definition. Via a superposed epoch analysis, Farrell et al. sensor frame) of the search-coil. BPF time series represent the (2020) highlight that events with a rapid deflection in the mag- amplitude of the wavefield in specific spectral bands. All these netic field show a clear decrease in the magnetic field mag- data products are provided by the Digital Fields Board (DFB, nitude at their boundaries (7% - 8%). The authors conjec- Malaspina et al. 2016). The sampling rate of the waveforms cor- ture that these dropouts are caused by a diamagnetic current responds to the survey cadence during the early part of the solar created at the boundaries by a pressure gradient in the re- encounter phase. During the close encounter phase, this cadence gion where the magnetic field is rotating. This kind of mag- increases fourfold. However, none of the switchback boundaries netic field dropout coupled with a proton density increase at observed during the close encounter show as clear evidence for switchback boundaries were clearly present in several studies reconnection as the ones that we present below.
Article number, page 2 of 11 Froment et al.: Magnetic reconnection at a switchback boundary