Spring 2002 Book Review Editorials You Can Be Catholic and Pro-Choice by Neil Mccarthy the Tycoons Club He Vatican and U.S
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Newsletter of Westchester Coalition for Legal Abortion, Inc. Vol. 31, No. 1 Spring, 2002 Danger in Black Robes ush “is substantiating fears the 5th Circuit. He presently serves as Bible is not that he would attempt to turn U.S. district judge in Mississippi, having considered a the federal judiciary into a been appointed by Bush Sr. He is a controlling right-wing monster.” (Detroit staunch opponent of abortion rights legal author- BFree Press) To do so he has committed who believes Roe v. Wade should be ity in Ameri- himself to packing the courts. Without overturned. As a state senator, he voted can jurispru- exception, all of Bush’s nominations are for a constitutional convention to dence, adamantly anti-choice. overturn Roe and he voted against Pickering, in Three candidates for the federal state funding for family planning one of his bench, which is a lifetime appointment, services. At the 1976 Republican Party few published have been nominated by Bush: Charles opinions, convention, while serving as a Missis- Sen. Chuck Schumer, cited Exodus. Pickering, Michael McConnell, and sippi Republican party official, he Senate Judiciary Carolyn Kuhl, each with frightening chaired the platform subcommittee that Unfortu- Committee member, track records on civil rights in general called for a constitutional amendment nately, this opposes the Pickering and reproductive rights in particular. banning abortion. promotion of nomination. • Charles Pickering is being consid- Charles Pickering also views the religion from ered for the U.S. Court of Appeals for federal bench as a pulpit. Although the Please see Judges on page 14 Attorney Playing Politics with Our Health his session of the NYS Legislature saw a major break- General Tthrough on the Women’s Health and Wellness bill — but the deal is not yet sealed. Women’s Health and Wellness has stagnated in Albany Investigates for the past four years due to the Senate’s insistence on a broad opt-out for religious institutions that do not support CPCs birth control. Senate Majority Leader Joseph Bruno, after a long struggle, agreed to narrow the exemption, and, in risis Pregnancy Centers February by an overwhelming bi-partisan vote of 50 to 8, the C(CPCs) are now widely revamped legislation passed that chamber. recognized as the true houses of The differences between the Assembly and the Senate ill-repute. These centers, often versions must still be reconciled. The Assembly bill is still the strategically located near abor- better one; it eliminates deductibles and co-pays that may tion clinics, provide anti-abortion prevent women from getting life-saving cancer screenings. counseling and materials, along Attorney General Eliot Spitzer Also, there is no so-called “conscience clause” whatsoever. with pregnancy testing. Patients Any employer who provides insurance coverage for prescrip- are promised caring medical attention, but instead are shown tions must also cover prescriptive birth control. horror films about abortion and are told lies about the The biggest impediment to enacting into law Women’s psychological impact of the procedure. Health and Wellness had been the Senate’s gaping birth These business practices aroused the interest of Attorney control opt-out. Now the major obstacle is that the Senate General Eliot Spitzer who has been concerned that CPCs version includes deductibles and co-pays which pose a might be using deceptive advertising and/or practicing serious problem for lower-income working women. medicine without a license. In January the Attorney Advocates are unsure that the differences between the General’s office issued subpoenas to nine entities that Assembly and new Senate versions can be ironed out now th operate CPCs. On February 28 Spitzer announced an that the special elections of February 12th have passed. There agreement with the entity Birthright of Victor New York, Inc. was pressure on both chambers of the legislature to pass a Please see CPCs on page 12 Please see Health on page 12 Patriot: On the That’s Me! Ex-President’s by Catherine Lederer-Plaskett WCLA Board Chair Mind hat does it mean to be By Polly Rothstein Wa good parent? Is it ne thing on my mind someone who accepts his or Ois the large envelope bulging from extraordinary her child’s behavior blindly, declaring that only unquali- letters and notes, an outpouring of compassion, affec- fied acceptance is the sign of true love? Is it the refusal tion, and gratitude. These kindhearted missives started to provide constructive criticism out of fear of being coming after I explained in two columns that sepsis labeled abusive and uncaring? No. It is facing the on- after back surgery left me permanently handicapped, going challenge of providing your child with structure, and continued coming after my stupendous birthday/ support and insights—shining a light on his or her retirement dinner on October 27, the articles in The actions and asking her or him to do better, reach higher, Journal News by David McKay Wilson and in The New to be the best person that child can be. We love our York Times Westchester section by Kate Stone children not because they are perfect but because they Lombardi, and my emotional final fund-raising letter in are ours. The goal is to enable our children to choose the December. I’d like to thank each person who wrote by right path, not the easy one. mail and email or phoned, but that goal is becoming Then why is it deemed unpatriotic to ask of our more remote. There are simply too many. I am more country what we ask of our children? Right wing zealots grateful than I can say to those who took the time to have reserved the term “patriotic” only for those who express themselves to me and say such memorable accept the Bush administration’s agenda blindly and things. without a sound. Those of us who hold up a mirror, who My health largely dictated my decision to retire, but decry the systematic dismantling of basic civil rights, those who predicted it wouldn’t be easy were right. who demand that our government live up to promises After building WCLA and running the show for nearly made long ago in our Constitution and Bill of Rights are 30 years, exiting is an emotional emery board. My head being labeled traitors. The basic rules of parenting are is still in issue politics: reproductive rights of course, but being replaced by the bully tactics of the playground. also gay rights, separation of government and religion, I criticize my country because that is my responsibil- and protecting the earth from human damage — to ity; I love this country and want it to be all that it can be. name a few. To close my eyes to its flaws would be unpatriotic. To If not for the Internet, I would be uninformed and succumb to the name-calling and intimidation of the not even know it; that is, I’d be restricted to what’s in fanatical conservatives who are trying desperately to The New York Times, The Journal News, and the radio, hold on to power is to allow terrorism to win. It is your mostly NPR. Online reports convinced me that George job and mine to be the very best parents that we can be and Jeb, Katherine Harris, their lawyers and thugs to our country—to shine a light on every action and illegally manipulated vote counting in Florida and stole reaction. There were founding fathers AND mothers; the election. The partisan Supreme Court majority then now there are legal guardians—us. gave the election to Resident Bush. I’m having fits over Dubya’s ultra-conservative Westchester Coalition for Legal Abortion, Inc. © 2002 domestic policies, pandering to the religious right in 237 Mamaroneck Avenue, White Plains, NY 10605 914/946-5363 • www.wcla.org anticipation of the 2002 and 2004 elections. Take Executive Director: Nancy K. Montagnino reproductive rights: counting embryos as children under Office Manager: Fran Snedeker Medicaid, calling for spending for abstinence-only Assistant: Leonore Young Board of Directors: Catherine Lederer-Plaskett, Chair; Tamika Coverdale, education equal to spending for birth control (family Robert Fertik, Neil McCarthy, Joseph Melhado, Deena Weintraub, Eve planning) clinics, cutting off funds for international Widdows family planning and UNFPA. In his welfare reform plan, Editor: Catherine Lederer-Plaskett Editorial Contributors: Phillip Chonigman, Judi Lerman, Neil McCarthy, Bush is allocating $100 million to push poor women Nancy K. Montagnino, Polly Rothstein, Fran Snedeker, Deena Weintraub Circulation: 70,000 Founded in 1972 Please see Ex-Pres on page 18 2 ProChoice, Westchester Coalition for Legal Abortion, Inc. Spring 2002 Book Review Editorials You Can Be Catholic and Pro-Choice by Neil McCarthy The Tycoons Club he Vatican and U.S. Conference of Bishops have he Guinness Book of World Records, 2002 edition, Tstrongly criticized Catholics who are pro-choice. This is Thad a disarming piece of trivia in the Influential bad politics by the Church but here’s something most People section. It turns out President George W. Bush’s Catholics don’t know: it’s also bad theology. cabinet is the wealthiest one in U.S. history. Of the 16 That’s the message two professors — Daniel A. full cabinet members, 13 are millionaires; seven of the Dombrowski and Robert Deltete — offer in their recent 13 own assets worth more than $10 million. They’re book, A Brief, Liberal, Catholic Defense of Abortion (U. of nicknamed the “Tycoons Club.” Illinois Press, 2000). This bit of trivia raises some interesting questions: The Church hierarchy says life (or personhood) begins at Whom does this cabinet represent? Can a multi- conception and that abortion is, therefore, murder.