Land: Territory, Domain, and Identity
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized Public Disclosure Authorized The opinions expressed in the report are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of the International Organization for Migration (IOM) or the Transitional Justice and Reconciliation Commission (TJRC). The designations employed and the presentation of material throughout the report do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of IOM or the TJRC concerning the legal status of any country, territory, city or area, or of its authorities, or concerning its frontiers or boundaries. IOM is committed to the principle that humane and orderly migration benefits migrants and society. As an intergovernmental organization, IOM acts with its partners in the international community to: assist in meeting the operational challenges of migration; advance understanding of migration issues; encourage social and economic development through migration; and uphold the human dignity and well-being of migrants. This report/publication has been issued without formal editing by IOM. Cover photo by Soraya Ututalum Layout design by Bianca Canoza A report submitted by the WB-IOM technical team to the Transitional Justice and Reconciliation Commission (TJRC) i LAND: TERRITORY, DOMAIN, AND IDENTITY Acknowledgements The report was produced based on materials prepared by the Study Group on Marginalization through Land Dispossession of the Transitional Justice and Reconciliation Commission (TJRC) and by a technical team from the World Bank (WB) and International Organization for Migration (IOM), which worked in support of the Study Group. The Study Group comprises Atty. Ishak Mastura (Convener), Mr. Guiamel Alim (Member), Atty. Anwar Malang (Member), Ms. Fatima Kanakan (Member), Dr. Francisco Lara (Member) and Dr. Faina Abaya-Ulindang (Rapporteur). The WB-IOM technical team thanks all the community members, village leaders, local, regional and national government officials, civil society representatives and others who participated in the research The lead author of the report is Dr. Fermin Adriano. A joint WB-IOM technical team comprising (in alphabetical order) Mitch Abdon, Nelia Agbon, Assad Baunto, Ica Fernandez, Elmer Mercado, Matt Stephens, Atty. Erwin Tiamson and Peter Van der Auweraert contributed major parts of the report. A GIS/data team comprising Pam Clavio-Galenzoga, Michael del Mundo and Marife Bacate gathered and encoded data and visualized key data sets on maps. Peter Van der Auweraert of IOM provided technical advice on the overall framework and particularly on relevant global experience. Paul Prettitore of the World Bank advised on restitution and reparations. Romina Sta. Clara of IOM also provided helpful guidance and advice. The Foundation for Economic Freedom facilitated a series of private sector forums as input to the report. Salic Ibrahim and Anisah Ebrahim of MARADECA in Marawi City assisted with field coordination for the field research in Wao, Lanao del Sur. Hasim M. Guiamil of IOM and Elezor Trinidad and Chris Pascual of the World Bank provided outstanding administrative and logistical support. Soraya Ututalum provided invaluable editorial assistance. Matt Stephens of the World Bank was the Task Team Leader for this activity from the World Bank. The peer reviewers for the report were Professor Patricio Abinales of the University of Hawaii, Professor Carmen Abubakar of the University of the Philippines Institute for Islamic Studies, Ivonne Moreno (World Bank and former General Deputy Head of the Colombia Land Restitution Unit) and sociologist/cultural scholar, Marian Pastor-Roces. The technical team wishes to give special thanks to Mo Bleeker, Atty. Ishak Mastura and Atty. Cecilia Jimenez as the Chair and members of the TJRC, respectively, for their advice and confidence in our work. Particular guidance was provided by Atty. Mastura in his role as convener of the Land Study Group. We also thank Atty. Raissa Jajurie, Mary Louise Castillo and Mariecris Araga of the TJRC for their support to complete this report. We would like to thank the following individuals and institutions that allowed us to access their archives and data: ii • University of the Philippines Population Institute • ARMM Executive Secretary Laisa Alamia • ARMM Regional Human Rights Commission • Maj. Carlos Sol of the Joint Coordinating Committee on the Cessation of Hostilities (JCCCH) • Commissioner Raissa Jajurie, Commissioner Froilyn Mendoza and Romy Saliga of the Bangsamoro Transition Commission (BTC) • Ismael Maulana, Chair, Regional Reconciliation and Reunification Council, ARMM • Hadja Bainon Karon, Former Regional Vice Governor, ARMM/Secretary, DSWD-ARMM • Professor Abhoud Syed Lingga of the Institute for Bangsamoro Studies • Reydan Lacson of the Institute for Autonomy and Governance • Marian Pastor Roces, independent author and cultural scholar • Fr. Albert Alejo, SJ, Ateneo de Manila University • Dave de Vera, Philippine Association for Intercultural Development (PAFID), Inc. • Aveen Acuna, Recognition of the Rights of the Indigenous Peoples in the Autonomous Region in Muslim Mindanao for their Empowerment and Sustainable Development (IP-DEV) • Paul Cagara, Municipal Planning and Development Coordinator, Upi • Hon. Datukaka Camsa, Presiding Judge, Shariah Circuit Court, Datu Odin Sinsuat • Narumbai Datukon, Clerk of Court Shariah District Court • Atty. Ranibai Dilangalen, Officer-in-Charge, Public Attorney’s Office, Maguindanao • Jesus Escondida, Municipal Administrator Midsayap • Dr. Norma T. Gomez, Notre Dame University • Quraish Langcap, Mohammad Omar and Kutin Kanim, Consortium of Bangsamoro Civil Society (CBCS) • Yamashita Mangacop, Deputy Chair, Maguindanao Task Force on Reconciliation and Unification • Myra Medina, Catholic Relief Services • Danilo Muyco, Chief, Land Management Division, CENRO-Midsayap • Vicente Rabara and Benedicto Pineda, NaTuLaRaN Mu Peace Council • Maria Belen Sabio, Municipal Councilor, Midsayap • Upi Mayor’s Council • Midsayap Council of Elders The team acknowledges the financial support of the World Bank-administered Korean Trust Fund for Economic and Peace-building Transitions and of the Australian Embassy, Philippines, through the Australia-World Bank Philippines Development Trust Fund. iii LAND: TERRITORY, DOMAIN, AND IDENTITY iv Foreword The World Bank (WB) and the International Organization for Migration (IOM) have been working alongside the government and other partners for decades to support growth and stability in Mindanao. Both our organizations appreciate that historical injustice is at the core of Mindanao’s peace and development challenge. This is recognized in the 2014 Comprehensive Agreement on the Bangsamoro between the Government of the Philippines (GPH) and the Moro Islamic Liberation Front (MILF). And it was reaffirmed by His Excellency President Rodrigo Roa Duterte in his first State of the Nation Address when he noted that, “There’s a historical injustice committed against the Moro people. We have to correct it.” The GPH and MILF established the Transitional Justice and Reconciliation Commission (TJRC) with a mandate to correct these historical injustices. The TJRC identified marginalization through land dispossession as a key concern. It established a Study Group comprising esteemed experts from within and outside Mindanao to undertake a study and identify recommendations to address this issue. The World Bank and the International Organization for Migration were privileged to have been invited to support the TJRC’s work. This technical report, Land: Territory, Domain and Identity, is our contribution to the study group. It informed the overall TJRC report that was released in March 2016 and the Land Study Group’s own report that is being issued in parallel with this one, Dealing with the Past and Land Dispossession in the Bangsamoro. We thank the entire TJRC team for their confidence in our respective institutions and the collegiality of our working relationship. v LAND: TERRITORY, DOMAIN, AND IDENTITY Land lies at the intersection of peace and development in Mindanao. Injustice and unjust dispossession of land – combined with confusing and overlapping legal and institutional frameworks for land administration and management – are a major trigger of violent conflict. And the lack of security of tenure is a hindrance to much-needed investment that can generate jobs and increase incomes in what remains an agrarian economy. While this report captures a narrative of historical injustice, contemporary dimensions of the problem, driven by local politics and resource conflicts must also be addressed. The report draws on local and international examples of success to lay out recommendations to try to deal with the problems both of the past and the present. This report is the second joint WB-IOM output on land conflict in Mindanao, building on a 2013 scoping mission. This has been a productive and constructive partnership that we hope to continue in the future to help the government and other partners to implement the recommendations of this and the TJRC report to help the people of Mindanao move forward to a future of stability and prosperity. Mara Warwick Marco Basso Country Director Chief of Mission World Bank Philippines International Organization for Migration Philippines vi Preface As chairperson of the Transitional Justice and Reconciliation Commission (TJRC), it is my pleasure to present the report “Land: Territory, Domain, and Identity”, prepared