Palo 6°Ê888]Ê ÕLiÀÊÇnÊUÊ7i`iÃ`>Þ]ÊÕÞÊ]ÊÓään N xäZ Alto November vote set for library-bond measure Page 3
www.PaloAltoOnline.com
Cities explore the future of wireless services
page 14 Shannon Corey Talk about the news at Town Square, www.PaloAltoOnline.com N Cover Palo Alto considers ultra-fast broadband Page 16 N Title Pages Kids dive into summer reading Page 20 N Sports Cardinal swimmers bound for Beijing Page 23 apr.com
It's just one click to a complete list of virtually all homes for sale in the Bay Area.
LOS ALTOS Charming 4bd/3.5ba Craftsman style home with spacious two story floor plan. Vaulted wood beamed ceilings, foyer with ridge skylight, large formal dining area, three slate finished FP’s and expansive rear courtyard. $2,490,000
PALO ALTO Gorgeous single level 1,600+/- sf condominium in prime downtown location. Spacious end unit with 2bd/2ba plus office or third bedroom. Gourmet kitchen with adjacent family room. Great floorplan. Hardwood floors. $1,230,000
MENLO PARK Built by Clarum Homes, renowned builder of energy efficient “green” residences, this two-story home with flowing floor plan has a solar photovoltaic electric system, on-demand water heater and high-efficiency furnace. $788,000
apr.com | PALO ALTO OFFICE 578 University Avenue 650.323.1111
APR COUNTIES | Santa Clara | San Mateo | San Francisco | Alameda | Contra Costa | Monterey | Santa Cruz
Page 2ÊUÊ7i`iÃ`>Þ]ÊÕÞÊ]ÊÓäänÊUÊ*>ÊÌÊ7iiÞ UpfrontLocal news, information and analysis Council calls for audit of theater probe, policies Next city auditor, not outside firm, Councilman Jack Morton absent. a culture clash between the world needs to take place.” “The police audit goes to wheth- that the police live in and the world As he has in the past, Yeh voted will conduct the cash-handling audit er the police acted properly here. that the rest of us live in,” Kishimoto against the audit. by Becky Trout That’s always a concern in any gov- said. Even after six years as a coun- “It does not shine a light on the ernment because the police have a cil member, Kishimoto said she still root causes of why this occurred. It wo separate audits are needed of the County of Los Angeles Office great deal of power,” Mayor Larry doesn’t understand the “world” of will not help the city move forward. to help end the drama sur- of Independent Review, should ex- Klein said. the police. ... It will not help the individuals who T rounding the Palo Alto Chil- amine the Police Department’s 11- Councilwoman Yoriko Kishimoto Councilman Sid Espinosa said the have gone through a long adminis- dren’s Theatre, the City Council month embezzlement investigation, agreed the review of the police, by audit would promote transparency trative process to be reinstated,” he decided Monday night. the council voted 7-1, with Coun- an outside expert, is needed. and “most importantly the com- Police auditor Michael Gennaco, cilman Yiaway Yeh opposed and “Part of the issue has been almost munity healing and moving on that VÌÕi`ÊÊ«>}iÊ5)
ELECTION ’08 Council OKs November vote on library bonds Poll finds support for measure just shy of two-thirds majority needed, but supporters optimistic by Becky Trout he long-anticipated library two-thirds of voters is needed. bond measure will appear on The bonds are expected to cost T the November ballot, the Palo about $25 per $100,000 of assessed Alto City Council decided Monday property value annually, or between night. $120 and $160 for most Palo Alto Yet a new poll shows that it may homeowners. be a close shave to win voter ap- Sixty-three percent of Palo Al- proval. tans polled initially said they sup- Results from a June survey of 600 port a $75 million bond measure Palo Alto voters, released Monday, that would construct a new Mitchell concluded that between 63 and 66 Park Library and Community Cen- percent of respondents are likely ter, expand the Main Library and to support the approximately $76.3 improve the Downtown Library. million measure. To pass a measure, approval by VÌÕi`ÊÊ«>}iÊ5)
COMMUNITY Summer theater director quits to protest firings Former Children’s Theatre Director Pat Briggs struggling whether to challenge her termination by Becky Trout ormer Children’s Theatre Di- turned into a police investigation rector Pat Briggs has spent into embezzlement. F more than a week debating Briggs, who was fired June 30, whether to challenge her recent ter- was given 10 days to appeal. If mination, but hadn’t reached a deci- Briggs challenges the termination, sion as of Monday, according to her she and the city will face off in a attorney, Jon Parsons. trial-like procedure adjudicated by But Alex Perez, who had been an outside arbitrator. Once the wit- hired to direct a summer Wing- nesses, evidence and other materials spread production, has resigned in have been presented, the arbitrator protest of her firing, and Bill Lib- would write a report and recom-
Darlene Bouchard eratore, Gunn High School’s choir mendation, which would be submit- director, has withdrawn permission ted to the city manager. to use his music in an upcoming Then either current City Manag- production of “Pecos Bill.” er Frank Benest or incoming City The termination of one-third of Manager Jim Keene would have the the theater’s full-time employees final decision, according to Assis- — Briggs and former Program As- tant City Attorney Donald Larkin. Dislodged sistant Richard Curtis — marked The ramifications of the firings The old Elks Lodge on El Camino Real in south Palo Alto came tumbling down Monday as demoli- yet another chapter in the ongoing are still mounting. tion crews started clearing the site for the construction of 45 housing units and a new, bigger lodge Children’s Theatre saga, which be- and recreation facility. gan last June with a burglary and VÌÕi`ÊÊ«>}iÊ5)
*>ÊÌÊ7iiÞÊUÊ7i`iÃ`>Þ]ÊÕÞÊ]ÊÓäänÊU Page 3 703 HIGH STREET, PALO ALTO, CA 94302 (650) 326-8210 PUBLISHER Our William S. Johnson EDITORIAL Jay Thorwaldson, Editor Jocelyn Dong, Managing Editor Allen Clapp, Carol Blitzer, Associate Editors Keith Peters, Sports Editor Town Tyler Hanley, Online Editor by Don Kazak Rebecca Wallace, Arts & Entertainment Editor Rick Eymer, Assistant Sports Editor Don Kazak, Senior Staff Writer Arden Pennell, Becky Trout, Staff Writers Newspaper wars, again Sue Dremann, Staff Writer, Special Sections Editor Karla Kane, Editorial Assistant verywhere I’ve gone in the year “non-compete” clause in San Marjan Sadoughi, Veronica Weber, Staff Photographers community the last few Mateo and Santa Clara counties in Jeanne Aufmuth, Dale Bentson, E weeks, people have asked their sale to Knight-Ridder. Kit Davey, Iris Harrell, Jack McKinnon, about the new Daily Post and what When that clause expired, Price Susan Tavernetti, Robert Taylor, Craig Wentz, Contributors that’s about. jumped back in and started the Monica Guzman, Christine Karavas, It’s about journalism getting more Daily Post. Thea Lamkin, Editorial Interns Jill Kimball, Arts and Entertainment Intern interesting and competitive once He’s been doing journalism Darlene Bouchard, Photography Intern again in Palo Alto because Dave since before then, too, starting DESIGN Price is back in town. a paper in Berkeley in 2005 that Shannon Corey, Design Director Price and partners Jim Pavelich closed last year and starting a Diane Haas, Sue Peck, Senior Designers and Dave Danforth started the Palo paper in San Francisco in 2006, Dana James, Paul Llewellyn, Charmaine Mirsky, Scott Peterson, Designers Alto Daily News in December 1995 which he is also running from the PRODUCTION and eventually started sister pa- Daily Post’s office on High Street Jennifer Lindberg, Production Manager pers in Redwood City, San Mateo, in Palo Alto. 180 Prominent Dorothy Hassett, Blanca Yoc, Burlingame and Los Gatos. They Price said he was convinced to California Clay and Glass Artists Sales & Production Coordinators later had a bitter split and Danforth come back to Palo Alto and start ADVERTISING Vern Ingraham, Advertising Director pulled out. the Daily Post because he felt there Cathy Norfleet, Display Advertising Sales Asst. The old Palo Alto Daily News, was an opening for a third locally Judie Block, Adam Cone, Janice Hoogner, under Price’s direction, was noted focused newspaper to compete with Display Advertising Sales Kathryn Brottem, Real Estate Advertising Sales for its feistiness, which often infuri- the Daily News and the Weekly. Joan Merritt, Real Estate Advertising Asst. ated public officials. The Daily News laid off six edi- David Cirner, Irene Schwartz, Former Palo Alto City Council- torial staff, none of them reporters, Inside Advertising Sales July 12th & 13th, 10 to 5 Alicia Santillan, Classified Administrative Asst. woman LaDoris Cordell famously in late June and stopped having a ONLINE SERVICES refused to speak to Daily News re- Monday edition as MediaNews Lisa Van Dusen, Director of Palo Alto Online porters because she said they twist- bowed to financial pressures. BUSINESS ed her meaning. “The Merc and Daily News have Theresa Freidin, Controller “They had a tabloid sensibility,” never been weaker journalistically,” Haleh Yee, Manager of Payroll & Benefits Paula Mulugeta, Senior Accountant Stanford journalism Professor Ted Stanford’s Glasser said. “There’s Elena Dineva, Mary McDonald, Cathy Glasser said. “Some of their stories been a sad diminution of quality at Stringari, Doris Taylor, Business Associates were ill-founded, sensational and the Merc.” ADMINISTRATION over-the-top.” Can Palo Alto sustain three local Amy Renalds, Assistant to the Publisher & But the paper became “an incred- newspapers? Promotions Director Rachel Palmer, Promotions & Online Assistant ible success,” Glasser said. Price thinks so. Janice Covolo, Receptionist; Ruben Espinoza, It was such a success in February His style of journalism can be Welcome home... Jorge Vera, Couriers 2005 that the Daily News group was offensive to people at times, with EMBARCADERO PUBLISHING CO. purchased by Knight-Ridder Corp., huge headlines and sometimes William S. Johnson, President Units available immediately! Michael I. Naar, Vice President & CFO; Walter publisher of the San Jose Mercury over-hyped stories, but he believes Kupiec, Vice President, Sales & Marketing; News, for $25 million. in what he does. 40 NEWELL ROAD 45 NEWELL ROAD Frank A. Bravo, Director, Computer Operations & Webmaster Price said he had earlier offers And he has made it work. Connie Jo Cotton, Major Accounts Sales from other newspaper companies. He’s a journalist at heart, driven Manager; Bob Lampkin, Director, Circulation & He also had high hopes for the to report the news, which is some- Mailing Services; Alicia Santillan, Susie Ochoa, Circulation Assistants; Chris Planessi, Chip future of the Daily News group thing non-journalists may not un- Poedjosoedarmo, Oscar Rodriguez Computer under Knight-Ridder, but that cor- derstand. System Associates poration, one of the most respected It’s like a gene. People either have The Palo Alto Weekly (ISSN 0199-1159) journalism companies in the coun- it or they don’t. is published every Wednesday and Friday by Embarcadero Publishing Co., 703 High St., Palo try, imploded in a shareholder re- The old Daily News did ferret out Alto, CA 94302, (650) 326-8210. Periodicals post- volt and no longer exists. stories that the Weekly or the Merc age paid at Palo Alto, CA and additional mailing Knight-Ridder’s Bay Area news- missed, and the same might be true 2BR/1BA $1550/month Studio Units $1000/month offices. Adjudicated a newspaper of general circu- Gated Community, 2 story units, Utilities Included, Covered Parking, lation for Santa Clara County. The Palo Alto Weekly papers, including the Daily News again. Fixed Utilities, Assigned Parking, Gated Community, Pool & Rec Room, is delivered free to homes in Palo Alto, Menlo Park, group, were bought by the Denver- “We’ve always gotten stories oth- Spacious Bedrooms, Private Patio Private Balconies, Laundry OnSite Atherton, Portola Valley, East Palo Alto, to faculty based MediaNews. and staff households on the Stanford campus and ers missed,” Price said. 1777 WOODLAND AVENUE 1609 WOODLAND AVENUE to portions of Los Altos Hills. If you are not cur- The Mercury News has been sav- One oddity is that the Daily Post rently receiving the paper, you may request free aged by layoffs and buyouts to its is not published online, which has delivery by calling 326-8210. POSTMASTER: Send address changes to Palo Alto Weekly, P.O. Box editorial staff and its parent com- been a major effort of almost all 1610, Palo Alto, CA 94302. Copyright ©2003 by pany faces the same economic woes newspaper companies. Embarcadero Publishing Co. All rights reserved. facing all newspapers with the loss “We don’t want to cannibalize our Reproduction without permission is strictly prohib- ited. Printed by SFOP, Redwood City. The Palo Alto of classified advertising (once a rev- print edition for online,” Price said. Weekly is available on the Internet via Palo Alto enue engine for newspapers), leav- But if he sees a model where Online at: http://www.PaloAltoOnline.com ing for online sites. newspapers can make money on- Our e-mail addresses are: [email protected], [email protected], [email protected]. Just last week, the Los Angeles line, he said he’d be interested. 1BR/1BA $1200/month 1BR/1BA $1400/month Missed delivery or start/stop your paper? Times laid off 150 editorial employ- With three local papers compet- Call 650 326-8210, or e-mail circulation@paweekly. Large Spacious Units, Fixed Utilities, Secured Parking, Large Units, ees and announced it would print ing for news, things are bound to be com. You may also subscribe online at www. Gated Community, New Carpets, Professional Landscaping, PaloAltoOnline.com. Subscriptions are $60/yr fewer pages, while the San Fran- interesting. N Laundry OnSite, High Ceilings Fixed Utilities, Gated Community ($30 within our circulation area). cisco Chronicle is reportedly losing Senior Staff Writer Don Short-term Lease Options: Month-to-month, 3 Months, $1 million a week. Kazak can be e-mailed at dkazak@ Price and Pavelich had a three- paweekly.com. 6 Months! Security deposit: Equal to one month's rent.
On the WEST side of Hwy 101, all of the properties are just a short walk or biking distance SUBSCRIBE! to Stanford University, downtown Palo Alto, and the Stanford Medical Center. Support your local newspaper by becom- ing a paid subscriber. $30 per year for residents of our circulation area: $60 for INDEX Please contact us today and let us know how we can serve your needs. businesses and residents of other areas. HOURS OF OPERATION: Monday – Friday 9 am-7 pm / Saturday 9 am-6pm Pulse ...... 9 Name: ______Transitions ...... 10 Address: ______Movies ...... 11 Spectrum ...... 12 650.324.5225 City/Zip: ______www.wpapts.com Mail to: Palo Alto Weekly, Sports ...... 23 P.O. Box 1610. Palo Alto CA 94302 Classified ...... 30
Page 4ÊUÊ7i`iÃ`>Þ]ÊÕÞÊ]ÊÓäänÊUÊ*>ÊÌÊ7iiÞ Upfront
tively review, if we can, decision COMMUNITY Theater audit points made by the police.” VÌÕi`ÊvÀÊ«>}iÊή The audit will also examine les- sons learned and potential changes New women’s resource center to open downtown said, referring to former Director needed. Pat Briggs and Program Assistant “There’s no such thing as a per- Nonprofit to offer services Richard Curtis, both of whom were fect investigation,” he said. to women of all generations fired last month. In addition to the review of the Klein said he intends to form a police investigation, the council by Sue Dremann three-person subcommittee to refine unanimously assigned the next city he answer to Freud’s question the scope of the audit and negotiate auditor to examine the city’s cash- about “what women want” may a contract, rather than accepting handling procedures and policies. T finally be answered in Palo a contract that limited Gennaco’s Former Auditor Sharon Erick- Alto, when a new downtown wom- costs to $50,000. son’s replacement is expected to be en’s center opens in early 2009. That committee will have the au- selected within a month, Council- The nonprofit center, called Deb- thority to finalize a contract with man Pat Burt said. orah’s Palm, will be located in the Gennaco, the council decided. City Manager Frank Benest had former Victorian on Lytton bed- Gennaco will receive a list of 48 previously intended to hire an out- and-breakfast at 555 Lytton Ave. It questions to answer, and said he in- side consultant to conduct that ex- is named for the biblical prophet- tends to use the questions “as guide- amination, which would check the >À>Ê->`Õ} ess of ancient Israel who dispensed posts.” effectiveness of city policies, proce- wisdom to visitors from under a He said he hopes to “provide a dures, oversight and management re- palm tree. bridge with regard to the informa- lated to cash and travel, particularly Cross-generational mentoring, tion collected during the investiga- at non-City Hall locations. It would a resource library, classes, teas, a tion and to provide a level of trans- also examine monetary exchanges lunchtime speaker series, commu- Katie Ritchey is executive director of a new nonprofit center, Deborah’s parency to try to [clarify] — to the and contracts with the many non- nity-service opportunities and coun- Palm, that will replace the old Victorian on Lytton bed-and-breakfast degree we can — and try to objec- profit “Friends” support groups. N seling and support services will be when it opens in early 2009. offered, according to Katie Ritchey, in favor of the bond measure regard- the center’s executive director. midlife. An empty-nester after her perience,” she said. Library bond less of the polling results but said he Ritchey and a group of friends three children left home, she was Ritchey hopes Deborah’s Palm VÌÕi`ÊvÀÊ«>}iÊή was cheered by the numbers. bought the rambling blue Queen diagnosed with breast cancer. Her will become a resource center that The June poll also tested the ef- Anne-style home in spring 2006. mother also became incapacitated can help women transition through After hearing arguments in favor fectiveness of arguments for and The three palm trees on the proper- by a stroke, and Ritchey became her all stages of their lives. Two full- of the measure, however, support against the measure and sampled ty, symbols of the wisdom of Debo- full-time caregiver. time therapists will be available for rose to 66 percent. The margin of Palo Altans’ general feelings about rah, were a major draw, she said. “I cared for my mom for three individual and group counseling and error is 4 percent, according to con- the economy. As she walked amid the Victo- and a half years. ... Things hit you for support groups. No woman will sultant David Metz, with Fairbanks, It also found that 71 percent of rian wallpaper and gutted rooms and you don’t know where to go,” be turned away for inability to pay if Maslin, Maullin and Associates. respondents said there is “great” or recently, the air was punctuated by she said. “When you think of the she needs therapy, she said. Polling more than 67 percent be- “some” need for additional library the sound of workers retrofitting the lifespan of every person, there are Ritchey doesn’t plan to be one of fore an election is preferred because funding. building’s exterior walls. some significant times in life and the therapists. support can decline over time, he The council also unanimously “There is nothing like it here. ... everybody needs that affirmation “I want to be able to schmooze. I said. agreed to boost the energy efficien- It’s something I’ve wanted to do that you are not alone in the process want to understand people and I will “If a bond measure does go for- cy of the proposed Mitchell Park for a long, long time. It’s a love gift — that you are among friends and work with the counselors. I want to ward ... voters are going to have Library and Community Center to the community,” said Ritchey, a people get you.” be a more effective helper. I’m more to get more information,” Metz — the largest project to be funded Palo Alto native. A former biologist, Ritchey earned of a mother hen clucking around,” added. with the bond money. The efficiency Ritchey’s father was a plumber, a degree in human services after her she said. Yet the massive turnout expected increase adds an initial $1.3 million and her grandparents operated an children left home. At 53, she is now The old Victorian has come full in November will bring more rent- to the bond total, a cost recouped antique store in the Cardinal Hotel. getting her master’s degree in clini- circle, according to Ritchey. The ers, low-income residents and youth after 14 years, Public Works Direc- Ritchey’s love of community ser- cal psychology from Notre Dame de house was built in 1896 by a pioneer to the polls — voters who are ex- tor Glenn Roberts said. vice was instilled by Hugh Center, Namur University. woman, Hannah Kezia Clapp, the pected to help the libraries’ cause, In addition, the three projects her typing teacher at Jordan Middle Her senior undergraduate project daughter of a Massachusetts Bay col- he said. would cost an extra $750,000 to $1 School, she said. Center had his stu- was on women’s stress at midlife. onist. Clapp headed west in search “This race is definitely winnable,” million annually to maintain and dents assemble bags of groceries for Two nagging issues emerged for of better health after contracting tu- said Alison Cormack, chair of the staff, according to a city report. the needy at Christmas time. mid-life women: isolation and berculosis — crossing the plains on Better Libraries for Palo Alto, a Kishimoto expressed displeasure “I remember we went to the farm- stress. horseback in bloomers so she could group that is leading the campaign with those figures, asking city staff ing community in Gilroy on the yel- “Women in particular juggle so ride astride. She wore a pistol to ward for the measure. to concentrate on reducing the re- low school bus to deliver the bags of much. Most women tend to be care- off anyone who thought her attire in- As expected, the council vote to curring costs. groceries to farm workers. It was the givers and handle so much and they vited frivolity, according to research place the measure on the ballot was The projects will also cost $4.3 beginning of developing a heart for get depleted themselves. I want to by the late Palo Alto historian James unanimous, with Councilman Jack million to furnish and equip, a cost service,” she said. create a place where women will be H. Stone. Clapp became a promoter Morton absent. the library’s support groups, includ- Ritchey wanted to create a center esteemed. of the women’s suffrage movement “The moment has come for us to ing the Palo Alto Library Founda- where women could find answers to “I want it to be a place where we and for many years after her death, step up and work on this project. The tion and the Friends of the Palo Alto dilemmas they faced at every stage can learn from each other. There the house remained woman-owned design is right. The timing is right. I Library, have pledged to raise, ac- of life, she said. To get a sense of is no membership — I don’t want until 1936. N think the case has been made,” Coun- cording to Cormack. N those dilemmas, she surveyed local exclusivity. It’s not the number of Staff writer Sue Dremann can be cilwoman Yoriko Kishimoto said. Staff Writer Becky Trout can women, she added. letters you have after your name. e-mailed at sdremann@paweekly. Councilman John Barton admit- be e-mailed at btrout@paweekly. Her own struggles came in What qualifies you is your life ex- com. ted he would have probably voted com.
he had directed “Anything Goes” to pitch in this year after learning that awards that they would treat some- Carlsen], Ms. Briggs written re- Theater director this summer. former Assistant Director Michael one like that,” he said. sponse to the Preliminary Notice of VÌÕi`ÊvÀÊ«>}iÊή “I felt like in the long term [if] Litfin was fighting cancer early this To address the theater’s financial Termination and my 2.5-hour meet- the city realizes they are giving up year. Litfin died Feb. 1. troubles, the city should beef up its ing with her and her attorney on Perez, 43, a current Palo Alto resi- something greater maybe this action “When the city decided to rec- supervision of the theater, he said. June 5,” Morariu said in an e-mail dent who has been involved with the could in a very small way [commu- ommend termination for Pat and “I’m very distraught at the way to the Weekly. theater since 1972 and who directs nicate] how important we think Pat Rich was when I felt like this was the city has handled this. I have “I informed Frank of my decision, the creative-arts program at Menlo would be to the organization,” Perez moving in a direction I couldn’t sup- lost my trust in the Police Depart- but I did not consult or deliberate School, resigned from an upcoming said. port. This wasn’t Pat I was helping ment. with him,” Morariu said, calling the directing gig in protest of the two Liberatore could not be reached out anymore — this was a city pro- “I’m ashamed to have grown up process “standard practice.” terminations. for comment. gram.” in such a great place and have it be She said an “unfortunate mis- Liberatore, a Palo Alto native and Do said theater staff is still work- Perez said he thinks city admin- treated like this,” Perez said. communication” resulting from a choir director at Gunn High School, ing to select a director to replace istrators don’t realize how critical Meanwhile, Deputy City Manager schedule change left Briggs waiting withdrew permission for the theater Perez, and they have chosen a dif- Briggs is to the theater. She imbues Kelly Morariu has clarified that she in Parsons’ office for several hours to use his music in a Conservatory ferent version of “Pecos Bill” to participants with self-confidence, made the initial decision to termi- Friday, June 27, waiting for a deci- production of “Pecos Bill,” both perform. responsibility and “the ability to nate Briggs, not Benest. sion she was told would be arriving. Perez and Community Services Ad- Perez was to spend about three find our way for ourselves,” he “I made my determination based She was terminated the following ministrator Lam Do said. weeks beginning in mid-July direct- said. “Pat and Michael led by ex- on the findings from the administra- Monday. N Perez said he really struggled ing the Wingspread production. Perez ample. tive investigation and the Prelimi- Staff Writer Becky Trout can with the decision, knowing he has has directed many other summer pro- “I can’t believe after all those nary Notice of Termination [signed be e-mailed at btrout@paweekly. the ability to help young people if grams and said he particularly wanted years of service and after all the by Human Resources Director Russ com.
*>ÊÌÊ7iiÞÊUÊ7i`iÃ`>Þ]ÊÕÞÊ]ÊÓäänÊU Page 5
Cantor Arts Center, Stanford Continuing Studies, Upfront and Office of Science Outreach Present QUOTE OF THE WEEK Summer Science Lecture Series Why is Earthquake Prediction so Difficult? ‘‘ If your business is going to be
Earthquakes can be extreme catastrophes. Rapid urbanization of earthquake- cannibalized, it’s probably better prone regions means that a future earthquake with a million fatalities is a to be the cannibal. distinct possibility. The consequences of earthquakes might be mitigated if they could be predicted; however, to date, earthquake prediction has proven elusive. ‘‘ —Bob Harrington, an advisory-committee mem- ber, on turning over a city-run broadband network to Join us as Gregory Beroza, Professor of Geophysics, covers what it is that a city-approved contractor. See story on page 16. makes earthquake prediction an intrinsically difficult problem. He will also cover aspects of the earthquake process that we can predict, and what the prospects are for future progress. Thursday, July 10 7:00 PM Around Town Lawn Outside Cantor Arts Center, Stanford University CHILI CHILI CHILI! ... The FROM FACEBOOK TO FREE! crowds are gone, but the OBAMA... One of the co-found- glow — and perhaps gurgles ers of Facebook, 24-year-old Come early to wander through the galleries, and bring a picnic to enjoy on the lawn. — from the 27th annual Palo Chris Hughes, left the booming Alto Summer Festival and Chili Palo Alto company last year to For more information please visit: continuingstudies.stanford.edu Cook-off still remain. About become an “online organizing 20 teams competed at the guru” for the Barack Obama Mitchell Park festival July 4 and campaign, based in Chicago. hundreds of revelers sampled Hughes’ decision to leave an their concoctions. The Palo Internet powerhouse for a politi- Alto Firefighters, using their cal position made the New York bottled pepper sauce, won Times Monday. Hughes hasn’t SUR LA TABLE the People’s Choice award. decided what his post-election The judges — including parks plans are yet, the Times re- commissioner Paul Losch ported. and Councilman John Barton — picked the Lounge Lizard TEEN WINS LOCAL ART HON- SUMMER SALE Chili as the best chili overall. OR ... Francesca Harvie, a Palo In honor of Curtis Berger, the Alto High School student, was longtime chili celebrant from recently chosen for a one-year Chug-a-Lug University who scholarship to the Pacific Art died at last year’s event, Top League, an award that includes Gun Chili took the Spirit Award. tuition for five classes, student The Chili Penguins won first for membership, art materials and NOW their vegetarian chili and Elmo the opportunity to exhibit two and the Old Quackers took first works. “I have been doing art OPEN IN place in the “open” category. for as long as I’ve been able to And the best-decorated booth? hold a pencil,” Harvie wrote to PALO ALTO “Chiligan’s Island.” It’s not all the board of directors. In addi- pun and games, however. The tion to drawing, Harvie said she competition is serious business, enjoys woodcarving, coloring, as evidenced by one former sculpture and painting. The couple who verbally sparred scholarship was donated by over custody of their chili an Art League director, board % % recipes. A video of the event is member Mary Anne Baker n OFF posted at www.PaloAltoOnline. said. com; search under “chili.” #//+7!2% s #54,%29 s "!+%7!2% s 4!",%4/0 s ,).%.3 SCOOTER PARKING #/&&%% 4%! s %,%#42)#3 s 4//,3 '!$'%43 s -/2% TREES COMING DOWN ... As REQUIREMENTS COMING?... part of the emergency-water David Solnick, a Palo Alto supply project approved by Architectural Review Board voters last November, a row of member, prides himself on non-native trees and two stone making sure new buildings pines in the Duveneck/St. Francis accommodate bicyclists. The STORES NATIONWIDE SURLATABLE.COM neighborhood will be removed, outspoken architect recently Assistant Utilities Director Tomm announced he has a new pas- Marshall clarified recently. The sion as well — scooter park- non-native trees line a fence ing. With gas prices zooming between the Main Garden off toward $5 and scooter sales 4OWN #OUNTRY 6ILLAGE s %L #AMINO 2EAL s 0ALO !LTO Newell Road and residences on reportedly rising, perhaps he’s s -ONn3AT !-n0- s 3UNDAY !-n0- Walnut Drive. The new well will onto something. replace some of the community garden plots, Marshall wrote in PRESCRIPTION DRUG DROP a report. To replace them, the OFF ... As savvy Palo Altans city plans to remove ivy and the surely know, it’s not OK to invasive trees — saving 12 trees, dump old drugs in the trash or seven of which are oaks. The toilet. Instead, residents can two Italian stone pines near the take them to the Regional Wa- Main Library are old and have a ter Quality Control Plant at 2501 “heavy, uncorrectable lean,” cre- Embarcadero Way or Elephant ating an unsafe condition, Mar- Pharmacy at 4470 El Camino shall wrote. The work won’t begin Real in Los Altos. N until 2009 or later, when the city It’s aallll at youy your fi ngertips: PaloAltoOnline.com/real_estate begins work on the water project.
Page 6ÊUÊ7i`iÃ`>Þ]ÊÕÞÊ]ÊÓäänÊUÊ*>ÊÌÊ7iiÞ Digital Revolution. More movies, more choices, more programming.
45 Channels of Commercial-Free Music.
ON DEMAND—Tons of free shows and movies you can watch whenever you want. Most for free!
The Most Popular Cable Channels—A&E, CNN, ESPN, MTV and more.
Comcast Digital Cable $ 99 with ON DEMAND a month for 29 six months*
1-800-COMCAST
*Offer ends 07/27/2008, is only available in wired and serviceable areas in participating Comcast systems (and may not be transferred) and limited to new residential customers. Offer limited to Digital Starter Cable. AFTER THE 6 MONTH PROMOTIONAL PERIOD OR IF SERVICE IS CANCELLED OR DOWNGRADED, REGULAR CHARGES APPLY UNLESS SERVICE IS CANCELLED. YOU MAY CANCEL SERVICE BY CALLING 1-800-COMCAST. Comcast’s current monthly service charge for Digital Starter service is $56.99. Digital Cable service limited to a single outlet. Service subject to Comcast standard terms and conditions. Prices shown do not include equipment and installation charges, taxes, or franchise fees. Offers may not be combined with other offers. Certain services available separately or as a part of other levels of service. Basic Service subscription required to receive other levels of service. Not all programming available in all areas. Converter and remote required to receive On Demand services. On Demand selections subject to charge indicated at time of purchase. Call for restrictions and complete details. Comcast ©2008. All rights reserved. All trademarks the property of their respective owners.
*>ÊÌÊ7iiÞÊUÊ7i`iÃ`>Þ]ÊÕÞÊ]ÊÓäänÊU Page 7 Upfront
July 5 – July 13 OUR ANNUAL SALE News Digest Antiques—A Fun Way to Recycle Fatal car crash under investigation The two-car crash on Page DDISON NTIQUE Mill Road in Palo Alto last A A Thursday that killed one per- Palo Alto’s Finest Antique Store son and injured four others is 100 Addison Avenue at Alma, Palo Alto still under investigation and no arrests have been made, (the red building across from Anthropologie) the California Highway Pa- 11:00 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. trol (CHP) announced Mon- 650-328-1540 [email protected] day. David Jerome Guerrero, 36, of Milpitas was killed in the 1 p.m. accident. He had
been a backseat passenger >À>Ê->`Õ} in a black 2000 BMW 840i sedan that collided with a sil- ver 1996 Acura Integra west of Junipero Serra Boulevard near Deer Creek Road, ac- cording to the CHP. The CHP officer A.J. Ruiz (left) speaks with Ricardo Soto of Atlas Towing force of the crash rolled the Services following a fatal crash on Page Mill Road July 3. BMW, and it came to rest on its side. The driver of the BMW, a 36-year-old San Fran- cisco woman, suffered major injuries, as did a second Burpee trial set for October passenger, a 44-year-old San Jose man. A third pas- Todd David Burpee, who is charged with beating, senger in the car, a 38-year-old Pacifica man, suffered kidnapping and sexually assaulting a 17-year-old minor injuries, the CHP reported. Gunn High School student last Oct. 30, will go to The driver of the Acura, a 26-year-old Portola Val- trial on those charges Oct. 6. ley woman, also suffered major injuries. Burpee appeared in Santa Clara County Superior The identities of the injured have not been released, Court last Wednesday to set a trial date. His lawyer’s and there is no update on their conditions or extent of motion to exclude evidence from his car was denied, injuries. All were taken to Stanford Medical Center. Santa Clara County Deputy District Attorney James A preliminary investigation indicated the BMW Leonard said. was traveling west on Page Mill Road when it veered Burpee, a 2006 Palo Alto High School graduate, into the eastbound lanes and collided with the Acura, allegedly attacked the Gunn student after she rode according to the CHP. her bike home to her apartment on Arastradero Road, Several Palo Alto fire engines and Palo Alto police knocking her down and choking her. Allegedly, he units responded to the crash, and Page Mill Road was then put her in the back seat of his car and sexually temporarily shut down west of Foothill Expressway assaulted her. as crews cleaned up the crash. She escaped when he left the car at his girlfriend’s All five occupants of the two cars were wearing home in Sunnyvale. seat belts, the CHP said. N Burpee was arrested two days later near his moth- —Don Kazak and Christine Karavas er’s home in San Jose. “It could have been anyone,” he told police after Teens nabbed for $200K crime spree his arrest. “I was just mad.” Two East Palo Alto teen boys have been arrested He told police that he had had an argument with for an extensive spree of vandalism at construction his girlfriend. N sites around Palo Alto between April and June, caus- —Don Kazak ing roughly $200,000 of damage. In the course of their vandalism spree, which they Virus could have sickened 21 freely admitted to police, they went to construction people at Crown Plaza hotel sites at night and drove bulldozers through fences, Public-health officials suspect norovirus sickened knocking down portable toilets, fencing and concrete 21 people who visited Palo Alto’s Crowne Plaza Ca- forms, broke windows in temporary buildings and baña hotel in late June, Santa Clara County spokes- left graffiti in their wake, Palo Alto police Sgt. San- woman Joy Alexiou said. dra Brown said. The individuals primarily suffered from diarrhea In the most dangerous of their exploits, the teens and did not require hospitalization, she said. knocked down poles and beams of the new Campus Hotel visitors became sick between June 21 and 25; for Jewish Life, which is under construction at 901 no additional cases have been reported, according to San Antonio Road. Alexiou. “These kids are lucky they weren’t killed,” Brown Alexiou said noroviruses are common, and out- said. breaks have been traced to camps, cafeterias, nurs- The boys repeatedly vandalized a city-owned con- ing homes and cruise ships. They are spread through struction site at the Campus for Jewish Life, 2027 vomit and feces, not directly via food, according to East Bayshore Road, 3290 West Bayshore Road and the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. the Palo Alto Municipal Golf Course, where they took She said county inspectors and instructors have 18 golf carts and drove them around, leaving some of worked with hotel staff to prevent another outbreak. them in East Palo Alto and others on a levee. “We re-educate folks, make sure surfaces are clean, They also broke gas lines at the recycling center proper hand hygiene reminders,” Alexiou said. “The and damaged a bulldozer and caused damage at the staff has taken that seriously.” Palo Alto Sanitation Co. site at 2380 Embarcadero The hotel, located at 4290 El Camino Real, had re- Road. ceived at least two recent warnings from the county for They drove forklifts and bulldozers and often dam- a “major” problem with washing and sanitation, how- aged the ignitions of construction equipment, render- ever — one in August 2007 and one in March 2008. ing them useless. The hotel’s general manager was not available for The boys were caught because they allegedly stole comment. N a bike from a woman in Midtown, Brown said. When —Becky Trout they were caught by police on the bike theft case, one of the boys had a key to a bulldozer in his pocket, Brown said. N —Don Kazak LET’S DISCUSS: Read the latest local news headlines and talk about the issues at Town Square at www.PaloAltoOnline.com
Page 8ÊUÊ7i`iÃ`>Þ]ÊÕÞÊ]ÊÓäänÊUÊ*>ÊÌÊ7iiÞ Bicycle theft ...... 6 Theft related Psychiatric hold ...... 1 Found property...... 1 Driving w/ suspended license...... 1 Commercial burglaries ...... 3 Vandalism...... 3 Foot patrol ...... 2 Hit and run ...... 1 Credit card forgery ...... 1 Violation of court order...... 1 Medical aid...... 4 Misc. traffic...... 2 Fraud ...... 3 Warrant arrest...... 3 Other/miscellaneous...... 4 Theft from auto...... 5 Grand theft...... 4 Atherton Outside assistance...... 1 Vehicle accident/property damage.....4 Petty theft...... 3 June 30-July 6 Special detail ...... 1 Vehicle impound...... 5 Residential burglaries...... 6 Theft related Suspicious circumstances ...... 2 Vehicle tow ...... 5 Vehicle related Commercial burglaries ...... 1 Town ordinance violation ...... 3 Alcohol or drug related Driving without license ...... 1 Grand theft...... 2 Tree blocking roadway ...... 1 PulseA weekly compendi- Drunk in public ...... 6 Hit and run ...... 1 Petty theft...... 1 Trespassing ...... 1 Drunken driving...... 3 Theft from auto...... 1 Residential burglaries...... 2 Warrant arrest...... 1 um of vital statistics Possession of drugs...... 3 Vehicle accident/injury ...... 2 Vehicle related Possession of paraphernalia...... 3 Vehicle accident/no injury...... 3 Bicycle stop ...... 4 Watermain break...... 1 POLICE CALLS Miscellaneous Vehicle accident/prop. damage ...... 2 Miscellaneous traffic...... 4 Welfare check...... 2 Animal call...... 1 Palo Alto Vehicle tow ...... 1 Parking/driving violation ...... 1 Disturbing the peace...... 2 Alcohol or drug related June 28-July 2 Suspicious vehicle ...... 3 VIOLENT CRIMES Lost property ...... 2 Drug activity ...... 4 Vehicle accident/no injury...... 2 Violence related Misc. penal-code violation ...... 4 Drunk in public ...... 2 Vehicle code violation...... 2 Palo Alto Child abuse/neglect ...... 1 Noise ordinance violation ...... 7 Drunken driving...... 2 Miscellaneous Alma Street, 6/29, 1:39 p.m.; domestic Domestic violence ...... 2 Psychiatric hold ...... 1 Possession of drugs...... 1 911 hang up ...... 2 violence. Theft related Trespassing ...... 2 Miscellaneous Attempt to contact ...... 2 University Avenue, 6/30, 7 p.m.; child Petty theft...... 3 Vandalism...... 5 Disturbance ...... 3 Citizen assist...... 2 abuse/neglect. Residential burglaries...... 4 Warrant arrest...... 8 Domestic dispute ...... 1 Construction...... 3 Ramona Street, 7/2, 7 p.m.; domestic Shoplifting...... 5 Warrant/other agency...... 7 Found property...... 1 Coroner case ...... 3 violence. Vehicle related Menlo Park Lost property ...... 3 Disturbing /annoying phone calls ...... 1 Abandoned auto...... 2 June 30-July 6 Missing juvenile...... 1 Domestic disturbance...... 1 Menlo Park Auto recovery...... 1 Violence related Other/misc...... 2 Fire call ...... 3 300 block of Terminal Avenue, 7/5, 5:59 Auto theft ...... 1 Battery ...... 1 Property for destruction ...... 1 Follow up ...... 1 a.m.; battery.
*>ÊÌÊ7iiÞÊUÊ7i`iÃ`>Þ]ÊÕÞÊ]ÊÓäänÊU Page 9 JOSEPH A. COHEN
Joseph A. Cohen died at age 87 on June 18 at Stanford University Hospital. Born in Poland he came to Chicago with his family in 1929. After World War II he served as a Public Health Officer in the Military Government in Japan for 2 years. He practiced Internal Medicine in Chicago before TransitionsBirths, marriages and deaths coming to Stanford University Medical Center in 1962 to do a residency in psychiatry. After practicing psychiatry for some years he returned to Internal died June 23 in Palm Desert, Ca- She was preceded in death by Medicine and retired 10 years ago. He is survived by his wife of 46 years, Deaths lif. her husband in 1997 and her son Born in San Francisco and Ned in 2006. Hasie Cohen of Los Altos, daughters Toby Cohen of Green Bay, Wisconsin, raised in Burlingame, she gradu- She is survived by her sisters, Deborah Cohen of El Cerrito, California, his son-in-law Robert White and Reuven Peri ated from the University of Cali- Jane Kelly of Napa, Calif., and Pat Reuven Peri, 75, a longtime resi- grandchildren, Maxwell White and Mari White of Green Bay, Wisconsin. His fornia, Berkeley. Barrett of Elko, Calif.; daughter life-long passion was learning, and in his early eighties the study of French dent of Palo Alto, died June 19 in She and husband, Robert “Bob” Kathy and son-in-law Tom Grant his sleep. Salz, met in Lake Tahoe and were of Grass Valley, Calif.; two grand- captivated him. Donations can be made in his name to Doctors Without He was born in Germany and married in Dallas, Texas. After children; and two great grandchil- Borders or his physician David H. Liang, M.D., Room H2157, 300 Pasteur later moved to Kiryat Haim in four years in Dallas they moved to dren. Palestine. He earned his master’s Drive,. Stanford, California 94305, Attention: Sunny Pellone. Menlo Park, where they lived for PAID OBITUARY degree in electrical engineering the next 50 years. In their back- from Technion University in Hai- yard, they raised a grove of 100 fa, Israel, where he met his wife, holly trees, which became the site Zipora, another Technion student. for a long series of holiday clip- In 1967 they moved to the Unit- your-own-holly parties. ed States, living in Redwood City A talented artist, she enjoyed Recycle and San Carlos before finally set- drawing, painting, printmaking Get Moving! tling down in Palo Alto. and wood and clay sculpture. She your He worked as a hardware and and her husband were avid trav- software engineer, designing sys- elers whose destinations included Camp Avenidas tems used by electric power and Egypt, Greece, China and Russia, Summer Fitness water utilities. He later worked as among others. In her travels, she a consultant in the same field. loved learning about local art. Academy After retiring, he devoted much time volunteering for local groups such as the Food Closet, Avenidas August 18-22 and Stanford’s Partners In Caring. 10 am - 3:15 pm Aside from his work, he was an Weddings avid reader and traveler, fluent in at Little House three languages and a loving fa- Amy Andersen and Alex Gould were married at a private estate in ther. Napa Valley June 14. Five days of fitness, He is survived by his wife, Zi- The bride is originally from Kentfield in Marin County, Calif., and fun & personal growth! pora Peri of Palo Alto; sister, Yael is the daughter of Carsten and Gail Ander- Haruvi of Haifa, Israel; daughter, son. A graduate of the University of Southern Body & brain fitness Michal Peri and her husband Ty- California, , she is an entrepreneur and the Healthy gourmet lunches ler Holcomb of Irvine, Calif.; son, founder and CEO of Linx Dating, a private Dan Peri of Los Altos, Calif.; and offline dating network based in Palo Alto. Giveaways & prizes two grandchildren. The groom is from Philadelphia, Penn., and Health fair & awards A memorial service was held at is the son of Dr. Richard and Susan Gould. A Congregation Etz Chayim in Palo doctoral candidate in economics at Stanford Alto. and a graduate of the University of Penn- sylvania and Stanford Law School, he is the Call (650) 289-5436 or Mary E. Salz founder and CEO of Revolution Media in visit www.avenidas.org Mary “Betty” E. Salz, 87, a Palo Alto. The couple will live in Palo Alto. for details and to register! longtime resident of Menlo Park,
*/!. 345!24 -#$/..%,, Joan Stuart McDonnell, her Christmas tree farm in the Sierra Foothills, the Lost Mine a long-time Palo Alto resi- Tree Farm. dent, dies at 78 For decades, she owned and operated Joan's Bookkeeping Joan Stuart McDonnell Service, working with small businesses on the Peninsula. She died in her home of 51 years loved her clients and found joy in keeping their books. City of on Sunday, June 29th from A lover of travel near and far, from the nearest Starbucks Palo Alto cancer. in Palo Alto and Los Altos, to the small villages of Germany Recreation Born in Park Ridge, where she traveled to find her roots, Joan loved making new Presents Illinois to George and friends from all over the world. Pauline Stuart, Mrs. Mrs. McDonnell is survived by her three daughters, Molly McDonnell graduated from Fox, Julie M Daley, and Kathryn (Katie) M Peuvrelle; her Michigan State University ex-husband and long-time friend, Thomas McDonnell; four where she was a member of grandchildren, Liza Rosenberg-Fox, Jackie JacksonDaley, the Chi Omega sorority. Jennifer Lapetina and Christopher Peuvrelle; cousins Barbara An independent woman with an incredible sense of humor, Hummel and Christine Polanco; and great-grandson Lucas Mrs. McDonnell led a full and varied life. She was an avid JacksonDaley, with three great-grandchildren due to arrive 24th Annual figure skater and figure skating judge. As a child she skated in the fall; and her beloved pet Chihuahuas Marshall, Rosie on the ponds of Michigan and she renewed her love of skat- and Peanut . Palo Alto Weekly ing in 1963 at the Winter Lodge (known then as the Winter Services will be Sunday, July 6th at 4 PM at The Center Club). She went on to become a figure skating judge, traveling for Spiritual Living, 1195 Clark Street, San Jose, California nationally and internationally. Locally, she was a long-time 95125, (408) 294-1828, www.sanjosecenter.org member (and officer) of the Peninsula Figure Skating Club, Internment at Alta Mesa Cemetery will be private. a board member of the Winter Lodge where she received the Donations in lieu of flowers to: Tall Bear Award, and a member of the “Dull Blades” figure Peninsula Humane Society (http://www.peninsulahumane- skating team. society.org/) September 12, 2008 Mrs. McDonnell was also an avid oil painter and gardener. United States Figure Skating Memorial Fund (http://www. She loved tending to her home garden in Palo Alto, as well as usfigureskating.org/About) Register online at PAID OBITUARY www.PaloAltoOnline.com Page 10ÊUÊ7i`iÃ`>Þ]ÊÕÞÊ]ÊÓäänÊUÊ*>ÊÌÊ7iiÞ STANFORD THEATRE
The Stanford Theatre is at 221 Uni- versity Ave. in Palo Alto. City Lights (silent, 1931) Charlie Chaplin falls in love with a blind girl. Wed. at 7:30 p.m. The Smiling Lieutenant (1931) The romance of an officer and Movie reviews by Jeanne Aufmuth, Tyler Hanley, and Susan Tavernetti a violinist is thwarted. Wed. at Movies 9:10 p.m. Strategic Air Command MOVIE TIMES (1955) A baseball player is Mongol (R) recalled to active military duty. 1:30, 4:15, 7:00, 9:50 Note: Screenings are for Wednesday through Thursday only. Thu. at 7:30 p.m. Brick Lane (PG-13) --- Guild: 2, 4:30, 7 & 9:30 p.m. The Visitor (PG-13) 2:00, 4:30, 7:10, 9:35 The Chronicles of Narnia: Century 12: 12:15 & 3:40 p.m. No Highway in the Sky (1951) (Times are Fri thru Thurs) Prince Caspian (PG) (Not Reviewed) A scientist believes the plane Forgetting Sarah Marshall Century 12: 7:05 & 9:55 p.m. he is on will crash. Thu. at 5:40 (R) (Not Reviewed) & 9:35 p.m. Get Smart (PG-13) --1/2 Century 16: 11:05 a.m.; 1:45, 4:30, 7:10 & 9:55 p.m. Century 20: 11:30 a.m.; 12:30, 2:15, 3:15, 5, 6, 7:40, 8:40 & 10:30 p.m. Gonzo (Not Rated) Aquarius: 1:30, 4:30, 7:15 & 9:45 p.m. (Not Reviewed) Hancock (PG-13) Century 16: 11 & 11:35 a.m.; 12:10, 12:45, 1:25, 2, 2:35, 3:10, 3:50, 4:20, 5, 5:30, 6:15, 6:50, 7:25, (Not Reviewed) 8, 8:40, 9:15, 9:50 & 10:25 p.m. Century 20: 11:10, 11:25 & 11:50 p.m.; 12:15, 12:40, 1:05, 1:30, 1:50, 2:15, 2:40, 3:05, 3:30, 3:55, 4:15, 4:35, 5:05, 5:30, 5:55, 6:20, 6:40, 7, 7:30, 7:55, 8:20, 8:45, 9:05, 9:25, 9:55 & 10:20 p.m. The Happening (R) -1/2 Century 16: 10:15 p.m. Century 12: 12:10, 2:40, 5:10, 7:40 & 10:10 p.m. Hellboy 2: The Golden Army Century 16: Thu. at midnight. Century 20: Thu. at midnight. (PG-13) (Not Reviewed) The Incredible Hulk Century 16: 11:40 a.m, 2:20, 5:05 & 7:55 p.m. Century 12: 12:05, 1, 2, 3, 4, 4:50, 6, 7, 8, 9 (PG-13) --- & 9:50 p.m. Indiana Jones and the Century 16: 1:20, 4:15, 7:20 & 10:10 p.m. Century 20: 1:45, 4:35, 7:25 & 10:25 p.m. Kingdom of the Crystal Skull (PG-13) --1/2 Iron Man (PG-13) ---1/2 Century 16: 11:10, 4:35 & 10:05 p.m. Century 12: 12:20, 3:20, 7:10 & 10:15 p.m. Kit Kittredge: An American Century 16: 11:25, 1:55, 4:40, 7:15 & 9:45 p.m. Century 12: Noon, 1:20, 2:30, 3:50, 5, 6:20, 7:30, Girl (G) (Not Reviewed) 8:50 & 10 p.m. Kung Fu Panda (PG) ---1/2 Century 16: 11:20, 1:40, 4:05, 6:35 & 9 p.m. Century 20: 11:20, 1:45, 4:10, 6:35 & 9 p.m. The Love Guru (PG-13) Century 16: 2:15 & 7:35 p.m. Century 12: 12:30, 1:40, 2:50, 4:20, 5:30, 6:45, 7:50, 9:30 & 10:20 p.m. (Not Reviewed) Mongol (R) (Not Reviewed) CinéArts at Palo Alto Square: 1:30, 4:15, 7 & 9:50 p.m. Roman De Gare (R) Aquarius: 2, 5, 7:45 & 10 p.m. (Not Reviewed) Sex and the City (R) --1/2 Century 16: 11:30, 3 & 6:45 p.m. Century 20: 12:50, 4, 7:10 & 10:20 p.m. Shrek the Third (PG) ---1/2 Century 12: Wed. at 10 p.m. !" The Visitor (PG-13) CinéArts at Palo Alto Square: 2, 4:30, 7:10 & 9:35 p.m. (Not Reviewed) WALL-E (G) ---1/2 Century 16: 11 & 11:45 a.m.; 12:35, 1:35, 2:25, 3:05, 4:10, 5, 5:35, 7, 7:30, 8:05, 9:35, 10 & 10:35 ! p.m. Century 20: 11:15 & 11:45 a.m.; 12:15, 12:45, 1:15, 1:55, 2:25, 2:55, 3:25, 3:55, 4:35, 5:05, 5:35, 6, 6:35, 7:15, 7:45, 8:15, 8:45, 9:15, 9:50 & 10:20 p.m. !! Wanted (R) ---- Century 16: 11:15 & 11:50 a.m.; 1:50, 2:30, 4:25, 5:10, 7:05, 7:50, 9:40 & 10:30 p.m. Century 20: 11:40 a.m. 12:20, 1, 1:40, 2:20, 3, 3:40, 4:20, 5, 5:40, 6:20, 7, 7:45, 8:25, 9:05, 9:45 &10:25 p.m. "#$ You Don’t Mess With the Century 16: 10:35 p.m. Century 12: 12:40, 3:30, 7:20 & 10:25 p.m. Zohan (PG-13) (Not Reviewed) ( Skip it (( -iÊÀi`ii}ʵÕ>Ìià ((( Ê}`ÊLiÌ (((( "ÕÌÃÌ>`} Internet address: For show times, plot synopses, theater addresses, trailers and more information about films playing, go to Palo Alto Online at http://www.PaloAltoOnline.com/ ON THE WEB: The most up-to-date movie listings at www.PaloAltoOnline.com
We make you look good on paper!
/)2 (-2 Right in Your ))2 ) , BACKYARD! 1 3 ) 1 ) 1 ,4 . - 26 (High Resolution) *52'%" & 0 +)3
$#!1 ()( < ,21)
*>ÊÌÊ7iiÞÊUÊ7i`iÃ`>Þ]ÊÕÞÊ]ÊÓäänÊU Page 11 Editorial ‘Show us’ time on library bonds Public must be given answers to 2007 library-audit criticisms and “five library” Editorials, letters and opinions inefficiencies before November bond election Spectrum recisely one year ago, then-City Auditor Sharon Erickson issued an “Audit of Library Operations” that had 32 specific recommenda- Leave it alone families, teens and seniors , to some more people would not have homes P tions on how to make the libraries more efficient in terms of opera- Editor, of the wild and crazy parade par- to return to and much of our campus tions and thus able to be open more hours without adding more staff. I believe that many of the pro- ticipants. But mostly we enjoyed the would not be available for providing While many recommendations have been acted upon under posed changes for Oregon Express- joyous celebration of diversity and education to those in our commu- Director of Libraries Diane Jennings, others remain. Jennings way seem good to a traffic engineer acceptance. nity. We’re very grateful for all of actually moved early to make staffing efficiencies, downgrading but bad to people who use these in- Most of us, gay and straight, were their help. They’re the greatest! staff levels at College Terrace and Downtown branches to tersections. in the crowd watching together as Diana Van Der Ploeg With proposed changes, the red- local businesses, politicians, musi- Butte College President improve scheduling elsewhere. cians and some very colorful en- Butte Campus Drive It’s no surprise that Erickson’s staff found Palo Alto libraries light time for Oregon would shorten at Middlefield but would frequently tertainers marched on by with the Oroville generally were in the poorest shape of 10 Peninsula community message that being different is okay libraries they visited. Besides their general condition they suffer be longer at other signalized cross streets because of the extra time for today! Climate panic from overcrowding, poor lighting and inadequate meeting space, the left-turn arrows on the cross streets. How anyone can spend their time Editor, audit found. It also is no surprise that the audit concluded operating Do these changes collectively nul- and energy trying to keep the lovely David Schrom — “valuescientist” five branches is more expensive than operating fewer branches. lify each other? people that I shared that day with — notices that the climate appears What was surprising was that the audit found serious With regard to the three un-signal- from loving each other and marry- to have changed from what he re- deficiencies in staff scheduling, with a profusion of job titles. ized intersections (e.g. Waverley), the ing if they want to is a mystery to calls as a child (Weekly, July 2). The audit noted that over the past decade staffing has increased article quotes Mr. Prasad as saying, me. Panic! Hysteria! We must be roiling while hours open have decreased — not acceptable — even “The medians [blocking cross-street Danielle Mewes Our Mother The Earth! though 71 percent of respondents to a survey cited having traffic] ... would improve safety by Seale Avenue The Earth has been here for 4.5 additional hours (especially evenings and weekends) as either prohibiting aggressive drivers that Palo Alt billion years. Nothing is happening important or very important. take left-turn chances.” with its climate that hasn’t happened But the survey question that showed a heavy preference for When I stated at a public meeting Thanks to firefighters many times before. The climate has five branches was flawed in that there was no comparison of that accident statistic showed these Editor, been much hotter. The oceans have operating costs, staffing inefficiencies and impact on open hours. intersections to be quite safe, he dis- On behalf of Butte College I’d like been much higher. CO2 levels have With the City Council now officially scheduling a huge library missed the statistics as not impor- to thank those in your fire depart- been many times higher (during ice bond election for November, voters need to see a complete, tant. He seems to be more concerned ment who responded to the Hum- ages, yet). detailed response to the library-audit recommendations — and a with perceived risk than actual risk. boldt Fire in Butte County. They not The Earth’s climate has always review of the policy of having five branches, with perhaps a new, According to accident statistics, only saved Butte College from seri- been in flux and always will be. more realistic survey — before being asked to underwrite major, each of these three intersections has ous and devastating destruction but Walt Kimball multi-decade improvements in library facilities. an average of one turning accident they protected our communities. Waverley Street Until those operational issues can be addressed convincingly, per year. By contrast each signal- Without their great efforts many Palo Alto ized intersection has an average of the Weekly cannot editorially support the November library three rear-enders per year, presum- bond measure. ably caused by stopped traffic. Do YOUR TURN traffic lights create more danger than un-signalized left turns? The deeply personal The philosophy behind these pro- The Palo Alto Weekly encourages comments on our coverage or on posals is that people do not have the issues of local interest. price of plagiarism judgment to make a safe turn with- out a left arrow, despite statistics to What do you think? What would win your support for a library bond t was a sad coincidence that both graduation speakers at Palo Alto measure in November? High School’s June commencement exercises apparently plagia- the contrary. The county has asked I rized parts of their speeches. for public comments about options Submit letters to the editor of up to 250 words to [email protected] It was only because a fellow student happened to discover one for each intersection. Why does it or shorter comments to [email protected]. Include your name, of the instances — lifted from a graduation speech at another not include a “leave-it-alone” option address and daytime phone number so we can reach you. We reserve the right to edit contributions for length, objectionable content, libel and factual errors high school — that the plagiarism came to light, humiliating the so that it can get genuine feedback? I think that some improvements known to us. Anonymous letters will generally not be accepted. speakers and embarrassing the school. You can also participate in our popular interactive online forum, Town We don’t know what, if any, consequences may come down on are warranted, but most intersec- Square, at our community website at www.PaloAltoOnline.com. Read tions, such as Cowper and Waverley the young plagiarists. But we hope they and others will ponder blogs, discuss issues, ask questions or express opinions with you neighbors any should remain unchanged. time, day or night. implications of what they did — the most serious of which may Robert Herriot Submitting a letter to the editor or guest opinion constitutes a granting of per- be deeply personal. Byron Street mission to the Palo Alto Weekly and Embarcadero Publishing Co. to also publish Putting aside embarrassment to the school, which will pass, Palo Alto it online, including in our online archives and as a post on Town Square. questions raised by the plagiarisms (1) undermine the credibility For more information contact Editor Jay Thorwaldson or Assistant to the Editor of the students’ entire academic achievements and (2) reflect Let’s hear it Tyler Hanley at [email protected] or 650-326-8210. on standards of the school, or at least on the “culture of hyper Editor, achievement” that seems to prevail in Palo Alto. By all means let’s go with the Speaking generally, if any student is willing to copy the work traffic-flow changes proposed at of others to garnish his or her graduation speech — one of the Oregon Expressway and Middlefield greatest honors a school can bestow on a student, reserved for Road. And we need to get started the most outstanding of the outstanding — it can’t help but raise right away, because when the 2860 questions about the student’s earlier performance or in the highly homes are built and completed by competitive college-application process. 2014, there will be even more ve- But the real issue runs deeper than what others think. The hicles crowding our city streets. real issue is what the students think of their own abilities. For How about 6,000 automobiles. students to feel they must crib from others’ means they don’t Let’s hear it for “high density”! feel their work is good enough to measure up to the standard-of- Barbara Cleveland appearance they, their parents, teachers or peers have set. Kipling Street The result is that they deprive themselves of the deep, abiding Palo Alto sense of satisfaction that comes from knowing “I did it myself!” The sense of creative joy that comes with completing a challenging Gay Pride Parade assignment, a difficult essay, a class presentation or a graduation Editor, speech is forever lost to them — even if there is no nagging fear I recently attended the Gay Pride of detection, or even if they are able to shrug off what should be a Parade in San Francisco with my sense of humiliation with an “everyone does it” rationalization. 15-year-old daughter. That personal loss is the saddest part of plagiarism. We enjoyed every minute of it, from the train ride in with other
Page 12ÊUÊ7i`iÃ`>Þ]ÊÕÞÊ]ÊÓäänÊUÊ*>ÊÌÊ7iiÞ Check out Town Square! Hundreds of local topics are being discussed by local residents on Town Square, a reader forum sponsored by the Weekly on our commu- nity website at www.PaloAltoOnline.com. Post your own comments, ask questions, read Diana Diamond’s blog or just stay up on what people are talking about around town!
Board of Contributors Palo Alto’s hair-pulling lack of commitment to mediation
by Jeff Blum man, feeling somewhat assuaged. The par- made me wonder whether we could avoid ’ve still got hair so I could tear some out ties could have formulated a public state- Put Patricia Briggs, Richard another potentially expensive brawl. Put Pa- in frustration. ment of apology that did not irreparably tricia Briggs, Richard Curtis, city represen- I It isn’t the ordinary annoyances of ev- damage the standing of the officers or of Curtis, city representatives, tatives, and a seasoned mediator in a room. eryday living getting the police force. Let the apologies fly. Come up with a solu- to me. My immediate and a seasoned mediator in The result might have been no civil lawsuit tion that somewhat restores their dignity and hair-pulling frustra- by Hopkins against the city, no expensive a room. Let the apologies tion is particularly ir- lawyers, perhaps a smaller payout to Hop- their reputation to Pat and Rich. Have them ritating because it is a kins, perhaps some disciplinary action but fly. Come up with a solution acknowledge that their bookkeeping and ac- fixable problem in an no criminal charges instituted against the that somewhat restores their counting efforts were less than stellar. arena in which I work: officers. Have all parties agree that the investi- mediation. My efforts to make mediation a more per- dignity and their reputation gation of the police investigation may be Palo Alto lacks vasively used first step in a dispute-resolu- to Pat and Rich. Have them dispensed with. Imagine the expenses that commitment to it, and tion process took me to meetings with the acknowledge that their could be saved and the personal and com- has for years. Yet, I city attorney and other city staff members. munity healing that could occur. failed to change the I learned that city ordinances might have to bookkeeping and accounting Alas, the mechanisms for instituting such status quo when the opportunity arose sev- be changed, and that various other obstacles efforts were less than stellar. mediation between the various parties do not eral years ago when I was on the Human to instituting mediation existed, such as con- exist. Relations Commission. tracts between city-employee unions and the I requested that the city explore expanding city that did not provide for mediation, de- Perhaps someday someone with a little use of mediation to resolve complaints by termining who could mediate disputes in a more time and energy than I had will yank citizens against city employees and disputes particular situation, and the need for union discouraged and sidetracked by other Hu- responsible parties into a room by the hair, between employees and the city. This request approval. man Relations Commission issues, and by and change ordinances and union contracts followed the sad saga of the late Albert Hop- Fair enough, I thought. I believed these work and commitments to my family. to make mediation a far more available first kins, who was pulled from his parked car obstacles could be overcome. Couldn’t the This less-than-satisfactory result occurred step in resolving disputes. and beaten by two Palo Alto police officers union representatives and employees be con- too frequently for my satisfaction, in my vol- I would offer my services but perhaps I in a well-publicized incident. vinced of the benefits of mediation when unteering experience on the commission. should pass. I am afraid that if I yanked My thinking was that if Hopkins, repre- their contracts came up for renewal, for The press of time and other obligations often someone else’s hair they might yank mine sentatives from the police and the officers example? After all, it would be a voluntary led me to pull back, to resign myself to being back. N involved had mediated perhaps the matter process. If it failed the usual options such as satisfied with merely having raised people’s would have taken a more positive route than litigation remained. consciousness of a problem. Palo Altan Jeff Blum, a family law at- a messy courtroom confrontation The process of arranging meetings and My frustration at having failed to further I envisioned the officers and the police becoming educated about the problems instill mediation into the dispute resolution torney practicing in Palo Alto, is a former representatives apologizing to Hopkins in involved in changing the system occurred process rose to the surface again while fol- member of the Human Relations Commis- a setting where their comments could not over many months. Rather than take the next lowing recent events involving the Palo Alto sion and a member of the Board of Direc- be used against them, and Hopkins, whom I steps such as meeting with union representa- Children’s Theatre. tors of the Palo Alto YMCA. He can be e- knew well enough to know he was a proud tives from several different unions I became Reading weekly about this painful story mailed at [email protected]. Streetwise What movie are you most excited to see this summer? Interviews by Thea Lamkin. Photographs by Darlene Bouchard. Asked on Homer Avenue.
Amoriah Hartley Leah Gaeta Herbert Brams Brandon Wiebe Michael Dave Retailer Student Antique-Radio Restorer Business Marketer Technological Consultant Lotus Way, East Palo Alto Erstwhile Court, Palo Alto Regent Place, Palo Alto Woodhill Drive, Redwood City Filbert Street, San Francisco
“I’ve been breaking my neck to see “I actually really want to see ‘Wanted.’ “The movies I’d like to see are down at “I’m kind of excited about that “’WALL-E.’ That’s the one. I love Pixar ‘Sex in the City,’ but nobody will go I really like thrillers and I heard that the Stanford Theatre, old film noirs. I’ll Batman movie. I’m a big fan of movies. They always come up with the with me. I don’t know, maybe it will it’s better than everyone expected it tell you one movie I’d like to see, but I Christian Bale and it’s the last one perfect things.” make me more empowered.” to be.” don’t think they’ll make it: ‘Xena, War- with Heath Ledger.” rior Princess.’”
*>ÊÌÊ7iiÞÊUÊ7i`iÃ`>Þ]ÊÕÞÊ]ÊÓäänÊU Page 13 Cover Story
While cities have experimented with providing Internet access, some businesses, such as Jungle Digital Imaging in downtown Palo Alto, have offered their own free Wi-Fi to customers. INTO THIN AIR How municipal Wi-Fi fizzled — and why Valley leaders won’t let it go Story by Arden Pennell Photographs by Marjan Sadoughi
Manuel Gomez, center, and Binyamin Blum access the Internet via Wi-Fi at Coupa Café in Palo Alto.
t seemed like such a good idea — Internet for everyone, of San Carlos. launched a network of the same name in May. The WiFi101 net- everywhere. So much so that cities across the United States The city has historically looked at a different technology any- work, they say, could once and for all bridge the “digital divide” I announced plans for citywide Wi-Fi networks in an excited way, the super-fast cable service known as “fiber,” of which separating residents from the benefits of Internet access. chorus starting in the early 2000s. it installed a roughly 40-mile network in 1996-98. The City While wireless initiatives nationwide and in Silicon Valley But in the last few years, most cities’ plans to provide Internet Council will consider a proposal from Web firms to expand the falter, local leaders are hesitant to let them fade. There is hope access through a wireless network have fallen flat, deflated by fiber network at its July 7 and 14 meetings. here, and a search for better solutions, they say. shortcomings in technology and financial woes. Yet Silicon Valley leaders insist wide-range wireless Internet This spring, Silicon Valley became the latest casualty of the continues to hold promise. itywide Wi-Fi access seemed brimming with potential a Wi-Fi flop. Bill Marion, Milpitas’ information service director, believes few years ago. Proponents said a free service, or at least In April, Internet-service provider Earthlink pulled out of Wi-Fi could help anyone who needs Internet “in the field” — C one that offered both free and premium options, could Milpitas, part of a strategy to abandon the municipal-wireless from city inspectors to real-estate agencies. While Milpitas al- help poorer communities reap Web-based benefits. business altogether. In May, Metrofi announced plans to pull ready has a smaller wireless system on main roads for its emer- It would democratize the Internet, they said. Others dreamt the plug on Wi-Fi service to Cupertino, Sunnyvale, downtown gency vehicles, it is now considering using Earthlink’s leftover of improved business or city services, or just offering residents San Jose, Santa Clara, Foster City and Concord. Those services equipment to restart a Wi-Fi network. another Internet provider. And simply put, the idea was down- went dark in June. Wireless services could help machines communicate with right nifty. While privacy concerns or doubts about practical Throughout, Palo Alto has remained mostly on the sidelines, each other — streamlining city and business functions, accord- implementation surfaced, many embraced the idea of ubiquitous partially by intent and partially by chance. ing to Seth Fearey, the vice president and chief operating offi- Internet. In the evolution of the wired world, it seemed like the The city’s latest brush with Wi-Fi — a branded moniker for cer of Joint Venture: Silicon Valley Network. Fearey’s group is next step. the short-distance wireless data transmission standard — came leading the Wireless Silicon Valley project under which Silicon Yet citywide Wi-Fi ultimately fell prey to both technological to an end this spring, when a business group working on estab- Valley Metro Connect is conducting the San Carlos pilot. and fiscal maladies, just like the adage that there’s no such thing lishing a Valley-wide wireless network, Silicon Valley Metro And the ideal of the Internet as a great equalizer lives on as a free lunch. Connect, canceled plans to use Palo Alto as a test site in favor in East Palo Alto, where a nonprofit coalition called WiFi101 When governments from Philadelphia to San Francisco an-
Page 14ÊUÊ7i`iÃ`>Þ]ÊÕÞÊ]ÊÓäänÊUÊ*>ÊÌÊ7iiÞ Cover Story
nounced plans for municipal Wi-Fi in their house and everything would systems circa 2004, they were hesi- work. Well, not necessarily,” he said. tant to incur costs. So many brokered Many simply weren’t familiar with deals that saddled Internet firms Wi-Fi, accustomed to wire-based with the task of building and run- services such as DSL or cable, he ning networks. said. According to Rick Kitson, a Earthlink arrived in Milpitas in spokesman for the City of Cupertino, 2006 and pulled out this spring, the city’s relationship to the firm was transferring its infrastructure to the limited to one of “light-pole tenant.” city, which is considering what to do MetroFi rented poles on which to next, Marion said. hang equipment, and the city paid Finally, a basic practical concern nothing for the service, he said. lies at the heart of municipal Wi- Sunnyvale had a similar set-up, Fi — does outdoor Internet service with the business renting poles. truly fill a need? “It wasn’t a partnership,” city Web giant Google pays for a free spokesperson John Pilger empha- Wi-Fi network in Mountain View as sized. part of a five-year agreement with In such arrangements, it was up to the city, set to run through 2011. the Internet firm to turn a profit. Resident Sam Sherman said he Kitson said MetroFi tried several has trouble getting the Google Wi- business models in Cupertino, in- Fi signal at home and hasn’t tried it cluding a home-subscriber service outside. Why? and selling advertisements to sup- “I prefer to be inside because port its free service. there’s air conditioning,” he said. But this spring, MetroFi an- Sherman is a barista at the popular nounced it was canceling Wi-Fi Dana Street Roasting Company cafe, efforts throughout the Bay Area. which already had a Wi-Fi network News reports quoted Lucie Poulica- before Google’s and doesn’t rely on kos, MetroFi’s vice president of op- the Web firm’s service to link pa- erations, as saying the company was trons to the Internet, he said. considering bankruptcy. Daniel DeBolt, a reporter at The Poulicakos declined to comment Mountain View Voice, the Week- for this article, suggesting instead ly’s sister paper, said he searched MetroFi CEO Chuck Haas, who did for people using the Wi-Fi network not return phone calls. outdoors for articles on the Google Behind the failure of subscriptions service. and advertising to sustain business He couldn’t find any. lies a deeper flaw — the technology Google representative Andrew itself. Pederson cited a Google corporate- If Wi-Fi worked well over large blog entry that said 15,000 differ- metropolitan areas, perhaps it would ent computers log on to the network attract more customers and advertis- monthly. The city has about 70,000 ers. But it doesn’t, according to resi- residents, according to a 2003 cen- dents and city officials. sus. One problem is the frequency on Unlike MetroFi and Earthlink, which Wi-Fi is broadcast, which — however, Google doesn’t need to unlike old-fashioned analog televi- profit from the arrangement. Peder- sion frequencies — is suited for short son said the firm is driven by a desire distances, Fearey said. to give back to the city — and the The architecture of a Wi-Fi net- belief that more people online is bet- work therefore relies on many trans- ter for Google, anyway. mitters relatively close to one another to blanket a given area, a structure n the wake of MetroFi and Earth- called a mesh network. Some trans- link’s departures, city officials mitters, known as nodes, aren’t con- I are wistful for what could have nected directly to the Internet server been. but rather relay the data to nodes that “Any time a company like that Seth Fearey, vice president and chief operations officer of Joint Venture Silicon Valley Network, holds a Cisco are. fails to succeed, especially a local wireless “access point” signed by board members. The nonprofit is piloting a Wi-Fi network in San Carlos. The individual nodes, in turn, can company, you know the people per- be blocked from communicating sonally. It’s very sad,” Kitson said of with one another by tall buildings, MetroFi’s departure. hills or other obstructions. Company leader Haas is a Cuper- This means Wi-Fi installed out- tino resident and volunteers with the doors often remains outdoors, un- Boy Scouts, he added. able to penetrate thick walls. The city couldn’t afford MetroFi’s Sunnyvale’s brick library proved $1,000-per-node or $135,000 asking impermeable to MetroFi nodes de- price to take over the technology and spite two close-by installations, Pilg- operate the network, so it will disap- er said. The city eventually installed pear for the time being, he said. But its own Wi-Fi within the building, Silicon Valley being Silicon Valley, a he said. new solution may not be far off. All these physical obstacles can “We’re excited for the next tech- make Wi-Fi service unpredictable nology and business model to come — “a bit voo-doo,” according to along because undoubtedly there Solomon Hill, a partner in the East will be [one],” Kitson said. Palo Alto Wi-Fi effort. That model may have already ar- In some cases, an amplifier can rived. Or such is the hope behind bring the Wi-Fi signal indoors — Fearey’s Wireless Silicon Valley but that represented a surprise hurdle project. for Milpitas residents, according to A project task force of city offi- Bill Marion, the city’s information- cials, utility and sheriffs’ depart- service director. ments and transportation authorities People signing up for Earthlink’s looked specifically for sustainabil- fee-based wireless service for about ity when it solicited for proposals in $20 monthly hadn’t expected the 2006, Fearey said. hidden cost of the $100 amplifier, “There’s been a long history of he said. wireless companies setting up all In Milpitas, the central hub of the city Wi-Fi network used by police and fire departments is situated on a “A lot of people probably thought their equipment and then a year or they could just open up their laptop rooftop. VÌÕi`ÊÊiÝÌÊ«>}i® *>ÊÌÊ7iiÞÊUÊ7i`iÃ`>Þ]ÊÕÞÊ]ÊÓäänÊU Page 15 Cover Story
Faster than a speeding data stream Fiber — not Wi-Fi — may become Palo Alto’s Web venture of choice by Arden Pennell
hile the nation looked to Wi-Fi, Palo Alto has 40 miles throughout the city to be leased to telecom long had its eyes on another technology — fi- firms. W ber. Exploration of the super-fast cable-based Although a 70-home trial run in the Community service has been going on since 1996. Center neighborhood earned back some of the initial Next Monday, Palo Alto’s City Council is expected cost of building the network, a citywide system would to discuss fiber-to-the-premises Internet service once cost $35 million, according to 2004 estimates. more. Some questioned whether the city, as a public en- A consortium of technology firms — including tity, should go head-to-head against telecom firms in Canada-based Axia NetMedia, PacketFront and 180 providing Internet service. Connect — has proposed expanding the city’s current It took until this year for the city to break even on fiber network to a citywide, ultra-high-speed service. the cost of installing the network, according to Joe It could start operating before the end of the year, ac- Saccio, the deputy director of the administrative ser- cording to the proposal submitted to the city. vices department. The $44 million project has already garnered praise About 40 local businesses use the ring now, with from city staff, council members and a three-person some cable unused, Klein said. advisory committee to the mayor. They like its low The city would have eventually lost contracts to a financial risk — and the cutting-edge business advan- more competitive seller anyway, according to Andy tage they say it could lend the city. Poggio and Bob Harrington, who urged adopting the Orders of magnitude faster than cable services of- proposal. fered by telecommunications companies, a fiber net- “If your business is going to be cannibalized, it’s work would be a boon to businesses and residences, probably better to be the cannibal,” Harrington said. Mayor Larry Klein has said. It would attract, retain If the consortium doesn’t meet its performance tar- and aid local companies, he added. gets, the city would retain a “reversionary right” to He predicted that as gas prices rise, more people get its assets back, the third committee member, Bern could choose to work at home with help from the effi- Beecham, said. cient fiber network. Recreationally, the time to down- The tech consortium sketches a speedy timeline in load a movie would shrink from hours to minutes. the proposal: The network could be built completely Many other nations already have fiber connections, within three years — and return positive cash flow and Palo Alto needs a system as well in order to stay within two. competitive, he added. If the city agrees to fast-track the plan, the service At one gigabyte per second, the proposed ultra- could reach homes and businesses before the year’s high-speed network would have voice, video and data end. capabilities — and it would be priced competitively, In a report released last week, city staff praised the according to Axia Chief Technical Officer Drew Mc- proposal overall but expressed hesitation over rushing Bill Marion, information-services director for the City of Milpitas, Naughton. into the agreement. holds a Wi-Fi repeater. In April, Internet-service provider Earthlink The city would incur no debt and spend none of The plan still leaves crucial details undefined, in- pulled out of the city, as part of its plan to abandon the municipal-wire- the General Fund to finance the project, according cluding the impact of construction on city neighbor- less business altogether. to the proposal. Rather, the city would commit about hoods and whether enough retail providers could be VÌÕi`ÊvÀÊ«ÀiÛÕÃÊ«>}i® $13 million in assets, including the current fiber ring, attracted to sell the service, the report states. revenue from its 45 paying customers, as well as pos- The report also lists concerns including lawsuits two later they go out of business. So the criteria is a sustainable business sibly waiving city fees. from Internet retailers objecting to the competition model,” he said. The tech consortium would provide the rest of the and whether the city would be saddled with service Under that umbrella falls a variety of wireless — but not necessarily Wi- $44 million and build, own and operate the network. obligations if the project falls through. Fi — technologies, as well as the goal of serving businesses, rather than Retail service providers such as Comcast would be Axia’s McNaughton said lawsuits from firms such households, he said. the middlemen, selling services to customers. as Comcast could be avoided by creating partnerships The nonprofit chose a proposal from a group of corporations calling itself The city would agree to use those retail services, early. Silicon Valley Metro Connect, whose members include Cisco, IBM, Azulstar, provided they are competitively priced, according The network would also increase competition SeaKay and most recently Covad Communications. to staff and the advisory committee’s recommenda- among providers, he said, noting Axia’s fiber network The companies initially picked Palo Alto as a test site, but ducked out in tions. in Alberta, Canada, has caused the number of provid- March in favor of San Carlos because the city administration was already a After 25 years, the city could either renew the con- ers to skyrocket from seven to 94. Competition would Covad customer, Fearey said. tract with the consortium — or buy the entire infra- create lower prices and benefit consumers, he said. For the San Carlos trial, which is currently being set up, the companies are structure for $1, according to the proposal. City staff is recommending an initial “Letter of In- not solely relying on much-maligned Wi-Fi technology, according to Assistant In a study session Monday, Councilwoman Yoriko tent,” covering the most basic points of agreement, City Manager Brian Moura. They will use WiMax, a longer-range technology, Kishimoto said she is thrilled to finally see a viable then creating a more detailed final plan. to connect Wi-Fi hotspots, he said. fiber plan. Beecham Monday urged the council to draft the But further technological details are murky, with Fearey and Moura saying “I can’t wait to get to the end,” she said. letter and set an October deadline for final contracts. they know little of the specifics and Covad declining numerous requests for It’s been a long road. The exploration of fiber began The council will decide how to move forward at its comment. in 1996 but foundered due to financial concerns. meeting next Monday. N Like Palo Alto’s upcoming consideration of a fiber service, the San Carlos The city paid nearly $1.9 million 12 years ago to Staff Writer Arden Pennell can be e-mailed at model will be commercial, Moura said. install a roughly ring-shaped fiber network stretching [email protected]. “This is really about giving small businesses another choice. ... This is very much an economic development focus,” he explained, adding it was a six-month trial. The service will operate in an outdoor, square-mile business area, he When Earthlink vacated Milpitas, it left behind a $1.8 On many days, the library is full of kids and an occa- said. million infrastructure — for free. The city put out a call sional adult jostling for space at computer terminals. Fearey is confident the wireless will work out, someday. It is just too valu- for proposals on how to take advantage of it and got two For students and city residents, the Internet-as-equaliz- able an idea to go away, he said. offers, Marion said. er concept — now more idealistic than necessary in many For example, wireless technologies that send only small bits of data in short One is from Veraloft, which operates networks in Paci- communities — is a bare reality, according to Hill. bursts could streamline plenty of services, he predicted. fica and Half Moon Bay and has partnered with WiFi101 “We’re in the middle of Silicon Valley [and] ... the A soda machine could alert vendors when empty without an employee in East Palo Alto. economy is now online. If you don’t have access you’re having check it. Water or electrical meters could send the city their readings The other is a joint proposal from Google and iNet going to be cut off,” he said. without a staff member having to visit. solutions to form a nonprofit to operate the network, ac- Hill knows other networks have fizzled. WiFi101 won’t, “Once this initiative is in place, there’s going to be an explosion of business cording to Marion. A review process involving the city he said. and services that take advantage of it,” he said. attorney and council will take place next, he said. The network is operated by a consortium of nonprofits, Milpitas’ Marion agreed. including the Ravenswood City School District, where City workers completing inspections would no longer need to fill out re- mid the pull-outs and uncertainty, one city is em- Hill is technology director; One East Palo Alto, a long- ports then upload them in separate steps if they could access the Internet in bracing Wi-Fi as a solution to social inequality. time community-betterment group; and career-focused A In May, the WiFi101 network went live in East JobTrain, among others. the field, he said. Building inspectors, for example, spend about an hour at the end of the day Palo Alto. They are working to not merely run a Wi-Fi network putting their data online. If Milpitas’ 12 inspectors could each save an hour a It’s a city where only one in five families has a comput- — but create a self-perpetuating wireless culture, accord- day, that would make 60 saved hours a week, he said. Put another way, that’s er at home and even fewer have Internet access, according ing to Hill. one-and-a-half fewer employees for the city to bankroll. to a 2001 survey in the school district, Hill said. The consortium, also called WiFi101, will operate a Page 16ÊUÊ7i`iÃ`>Þ]ÊÕÞÊ]ÊÓäänÊUÊ*>ÊÌÊ7iiÞ Cover Story IMPROVE THE QUALITY OF YOUR LIFE technician-training program for final key to bridging the so-called with quick & easy meal solutions! young people, primarily through Job- digital divide for his underserved Train. Those trainees will then be- community. come the technical-support staff be- But as with so many other Wi-Fi A fun and innovative concept in meal preparation moving hind the fee-based service WiFi101 schemes, this one isn’t proceeding offers to residents and businesses. the meal assembly process out of your kitchen and into without a few clouds on the horizon. Without tech support, the network our specially equipped dinner assembly store. is free to all comers. With support, The server had already been Dream Dinners it costs $15 monthly for individuals slowed by the number of users as guests preview a monthly menu online at and $50 for businesses. of early June, Hill said. Even with- dreamdinners.com and select their dinners – book a date to attend The network is currently funded out advertising — the group wants a meal assembly session at our Dream Dinners retail by a three-year grant from Califor- to first finish installing the network location – paying for each session online. nia Emerging Technology Fund, a Life just got easier! over the next two months — 424 us- matching grant Hill and others must ers had used it , in addition to the 50 fundraise to meet. They are hoping or so private users, according to Stu- with your scheduled session. 4546 El Camino Real - Suite B12 the training and support service will art Jeffery, who is also working on provide money in the long run, Hill 4546 El Camino Real - Suite B12, Los Altos &)#*&) . the project. (650) 948-8794 said. www.DreamDinners.com In addition to the sustainabil- “We’re starting to sort of wonder First time customers only please. Expires: 07.31.08 ity plan, the technology powering how much bandwidth we’re going WiFi101 will help it surmount hur- to need. ... We’re already maxing dles other networks have stumbled out the connection,” Hill reflected. over — literally, he said. The consortium hopes to find a cor- Rather than a node-based mesh porate partner to donate bandwidth, network, Wifi101 is powered by he said. high-performance antennas, he ex- And a Weekly test of the network plained. failed to find and sustain an Internet The antennas, made by Altai Tech- connection at several points within nology and costing about $10,000 the city, including near antennas at each, are installed on school build- ings, tall buildings — and even the City Hall and Costaño Elementary Four Seasons Hotel, which lent a School. patch of roof for the cause, he said. Ultimately, the East Palo Alto net- The city is relatively flat with only work resembles other Wi-Fi networks a few tall structures, so the antennas in Silicon Valley — full of potential Your Child’s Health University shouldn’t have too much trouble, ac- yet marked by uncertainty. It is un- cording to Hill. And if the signal has clear right now whether WiFi101 can Lucile Packard Children’s Hospital offers classes, seminars and resources trouble penetrating walls, residents bring Internet to the people. designed to foster good health and enhance the lives of parents and children. can purchase an amplifier for as little Or whether the Covad-consortium as $60, he added. can successfully woo small busi- The only area where the signal nesses in San Carlos. SIBLING PREPARATION may have trouble reaching is near the Palo Alto border in the baylands, Or whether the plan Milpitas picks Designed for children two years of age and older, this class prepares siblings for the will work out in the end. where the group has yet to find a suit- emotional and physical realities of the arrival of a newborn. able place to install an antenna. But one thing is certain. The sun Hill was in high spirits when talk- hasn’t set on municipal Wi-Fi yet, at - Saturday, July 19 ing about the network, perhaps the least not in Silicon Valley. N CHILDBIRTH CLASS BY THE SEA Take a childbirth preparation class in a unique, retreat-like setting at the Ritz-Carlton Hotel in Half Moon Bay. This course includes breakfast and lunch for two at the hotel, as well as participation in breastfeeding and cesarean birth classes. - Sunday, July 27
INFANT AND CHILD CPR Parents and other childcare providers will learn the techniques of infant and child CPR and how to avoid choking hazards. Mannequins are used to provide hands-on training. - Sunday, July 27
PEDIATRIC WEIGHT CONTROL PROGRAM This family-based, behavioral and educational weight management program promotes Bill Kitson, Cupertino’s public information officer, in the city’s Commu- healthy eating and exercise habits for overweight children and their families. More than nity Hall. Cupertino was serviced by Metrofi, which pulled the plug on 80% of children achieve long-term weight loss through this program – and parents its Wi-Fi service in June. lose weight too! The new session starts soon, so call (650) 725-4424 to pre-register. Spaces are limited.
Call (650) 723-4600 or visit www.lpch.org to register or obtain more information on the times, locations and fees for these and other courses.
LUCILE PACKARD CHILDREN’S HOSPITAL
Solomon Hill, technology director for the Ravenswood City School Dis- CALL TODAY TO SIGN UP FOR CLASSES (650) 723-4600 trict, talks about WiFi101, a new East Palo Alto Wi-Fi initiative, in the network room of the district’s office on June 20. *>ÊÌÊ7iiÞÊUÊ7i`iÃ`>Þ]ÊÕÞÊ]ÊÓäänÊU Page 17
$ %&
! % "!&$
#%! $%% " #% $
48 flavors to choose from at any given time ! " ! " # $& %! $% "!&$ Wilby Optical www.axispt.comAXIS #103 650.326.9111 %' Town & Country Village
! University Mission Medical Clinic PALO " ALTO Medical Aesthetics Body Sculpting HARD WARE Vote for us: )! Best New Business; '# Best Skincare #(#$%!# $%$) %$!""
!#&$& & #%' $%& 20% Off $!& grand opening special '!%!#&$$! %#% )% $ !( %!( ! %! (# !( % " 327-7222 !
Thank You to the Palo Alto Weekly Readers or voting us . . . DecisionIt’s 2008! This year’s Best of Palo Alto celebrates the sovereign right to’08 vote. Let your voice be heard! Best Desserts VOTE by July 11th at PaloAltoOnline.com All entries eligible for dozens of prizes, including dinners, gift certifi cates and theatre events. 3RD YEAR IN Hail to the Chef! Best French No Free Lunch Best Manicure/Pedicure Best Men’s Apparel 2008 HALL OF FAME (Restaurants) Best Indian (Food & Drink) Best Massage Best New (non-restaurant) 2 Gleim Jewelers – Jewelry Store Best Ambiance Best Italian Best Bagels Best Men’s Haircut Business NEW TO 2 Midpeninsula YMCA – Gym Best Nursery/Garden Supplies Best Asian/Fusion Best Martini Best Breakfast Best Shoe Repair HALL OF FAME 2 PA Sport and Toy – Toy Store Best Bar Best Meal under $20 Best Burrito Best Skin Care Salon Best Pet Store 2 Darbar – Indian $%# #("*#! Best Spa Best Pharmacy/Drug Store RETURNING TO (% )'%' # '# Best Burgers Best Mediterranean Best Coffee House 2 Fuki Sushi – Sushi/Japanese Best Value Hotel/Motel Best Sporting Goods Store THE BALLOT AFTER %!#"' #!!#"&'#%$" "##" Best California Cuisine Best Mexican Best Delicatessen 2 Palo Alto Bicycles – Bike Store #ALIFORNIA !VE s WWWAVALONYOGACOM s #& %!#"' Best Veterinarian Best Stationery Store THREE YEARS IN Best Chinese Best New Restaurant Best Desserts 2 Tamarine – Vietnamese Best Yoga Best Toy Store HALL OF FAME Best Dining with Kids Best Outdoor Dining Best Grocery Store 2 Village Stationers – Stationary 2 Fish Market – Seafood Best Ice Cream Best Women’s Apparel The finest Italian Best Ethnic Best Pizza The National Mall Store 2 Garden Court Hotel – Hotel Best Milkshake restaurant in Palo Alto # Best Splurge (Retail Shopping) The Campaign Trail 2 Whole Foods – Produce Hobee’s – Best Breakfast and the Freshest FREE Best Produce 2 Best Romantic (Fun Stuff) ND Seafood daily. Best Bike Shop 2 YEAR IN 2 Kepler’s Books and Magazines Best Seafood Best Sandwiches Best Bookstore Best place for a back-room deal – Bookstore
HALL OF FAME
Best Takeout Best Solo DiningDining Best Boutique Best place for a political rally 2 Longs Drugs – Pharmacy 2 Kirk’s Steakburgers – Burger GARLIC Best SportsSports BarBar Goods and Services Best Eyewear Best place to picnic with Peet’s Coffee – Coffee House Midtown Shoe Repair – Shoe 2 2 FRIES Best SteakSteak (Services) Best Florist campaign volunteers 2 Prolifi c Oven – Desserts Repair Best place to make a stump Best SundaSundayy BrunchBru Best Auto Care Best Furniture Store 2 Hobee’s – Sunday Brunch 2 Osteria – Italian (With(With purpurchasechase of $10$10.0000 or more.more speech VOTING Best Sushi/JapaSushi/Japanesen Best Dry Cleaner Best Gift/Novelty Shop 2 Village Cheese House – 2 Palo Alto Hardware – Hardware Must present this ad.) BestBest ThaiThai Best Frame Shop Best Green Business Best place to meet an Sandwiches 2 University Art Center – Framing anonymous source ENDS Best Vegetarian Cuisine Best Gym Best Hardware Store Hall of Fame status is awarded to any business that wins fi ve BestBest VietnameseVietnamese Best Hair Salon Best Jewelry Store Best place to lunch with lobbyists consecutive years in the same category. They return to the regular Best Wine ListList Best Hotel Best Lingerie Wear “Best of” balloting after three years. SUNDAY! # "# ! "!$ ! !!" s Creative Finds for Creative Minds READERS’ CHOICE FOR BEST CHINESE RESTAURANT Out of the Ordinary Just the best toy store. FAST. EASY. FUN! ")' %%)'(&&'"((%' ( (Not out of the way) " $"&$ Framing #&
Select from the widest choice '%'!*()&$$ ( LUNCH & DINNER of frames in the Bay Area. ""+ ) ,%*' Come explore and enjoy! '$)'$(&%')$( BANQUETS COCKTAILS ') - '$*( $(( GOURMET FOOD $2995 msrp "" " " TO GO 1067 N. San Antonio Rd. " "" # "! at El Camino Real ! "!s (AMILTON !VE s '$ %+'%%# 531 STANFORD AAVENUE,, PPALO AALTO,, CACA 9430694306 Los Altos ALSO IN s 3AN &RANCISCO