Experimental Sense in Galileo's Early Works and Its Likely Sources

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Experimental Sense in Galileo's Early Works and Its Likely Sources EXPERIMENTAL SENSE IN GALILEO’S EARLY WORKS AND ITS LIKELY SOURCES T. B. Settle I am going to start by declaring a number of assumptions, some of them quite old fashioned and musty, others accepted by some as commonplaces but rejected by others as outrageous, and all still open to considerable clar- ification, if not contention. First, something happened in Western Europe in the decades around the year 1600 which, for better or worse, we have come to know as a “scientific revolution”. Certainly there had been anticipations and premonitions of such an event in the previous centuries, even antiqui- ty. And certainly there were further, what shall we call them?, “upheavals”, secondary revolutions, later on, as the new ways of investigating and under- standing nature spread and became consolidated. But, and this is a second assumption, some constellation of attitudes towards nature, habits of inquiry, collections of acquired tools (both material and mathematical) and previously gathered knowledge became a coherent enough package to emerge (perhaps to condense), to take root and begin to flourish, in these years. Third, the components of this constellation, as I’ve called it, were not invented ex novo in the decades indicated; all had been maturing indepen- dently or semi-independently for years, in some cases for centuries. What was new was, first, the “mix”, followed by a growing awareness of the power and possibilities of that mix among a restricted but significant pub- lic. Fourth, I don’t believe that the touted “victories” of the period, the law of free fall, for instance, or the beginnings of the wide acceptance of the Copernican system in the hands of Tycho, Kepler, Galileo and Gilbert, were a cause of the revolution, so much as among its first fruits. Finally, as just hinted, that restricted public included many actors all over Europe, some 832 THOMAS SETTLE still famous today and many, if not most, obscure or forgotten (including many only known to historians of other disciplines such as art, literature and music). If we seem to concentrate on Galileo, it is because he was one of the more visible players in the event and because we are fortunate enough to have large collections of original sources which yet reward further study. My object here, then, is to reflect on one aspect of the beginnings in Galileo, the origins and development of his capacities as an experimental investigator. Galileo did not start his career with a fully mature notion of proper “experimental research”; in so far as he reflected on what we like to call methodology, that would only come later, and we only have limited access to what such reflections might have been. No, Galileo started by start- ing, using materials and tools ready at hand, off the shelf, including what was available in his Tuscan environment as he was growing up. And his “practice” only evolved or matured in the course of his investigations. So my questions then become: What can we discover in Galileo’s early works of a sense of or sensibility for empirical investigation; what can we suggest about its possible sources; and what can we say about its early maturation? * * * To start at the beginning, we know little of Galileo’s early life, except that he was the first among several children of a father, Vincenzo Galilei, who was a professional musician, a music teacher, a composer and student of musical theory, and eventually himself an experimenter in what we would call today “musical acoustics” (we will be returning to this shortly). One consequence of this was that Galileo himself became an expert lutanist. Galileo grew up first in Pisa and then in Florence and acquired some of his early education from a member of the Vallombrosan Order, either in one of the Vallombrosan Houses in Florence itself or in the Mother House of the Order in the hills near Florence. In the fall of 1580 (not, as is usually given, 1581) he enrolled in the University of Pisa1 and continued his formal stud- ies until 1585 when, having “discovered” and been captured by mathemat- ics, he left the University. Galileo spent the next four years mostly at home in Florence, studying Euclid and Archimedes and becoming proficient enough both to take occa- sional jobs teaching mathematics2 and to draft a set of theorems on the cen- ters of gravity of solids of revolution,3 thereby extending the reach of 1 Del Gratta, R., “A proposito della data d’iscrizione di Galileo Galilei all’Università di Pisa [1580 settembre 5; e non 1581!]”, Bollettino storico pisano, 46 (1977), 556-558. 2 For instance in 1588: Schiavo, A., “Notizie Riguardanti la Badia di Passignano in Val di Pesa Estratte dai fondi dell’ Archivio di Stato di Firenze”, in Benedictina, 9 (1955), 31-92, p. 44. 3 Galilei, G., Theoremata circa centrum gravitatis solidorum (ms. c. 1586-87), in Favaro, A. (ed.), Le Opere di Galileo Galilei, 20 Vols, Firenze, Barbèra, 1890-1909, reissued with addi- tions: 1929-39 & 1964-66: 1, 181-208. EXPERIMENTAL SENSE IN GALILEO’S EARLY WORKS AND ITS LIKELY SOURCES 833 Archimedean techniques and (not just incidently) earning a reputation among some important contemporary mathematicians. Amid these mathematical studies he also drafted and circulated his first public work, La bilancetta, the Little Balance, in this case a balance which, he proposed, Archimedes might have used in detecting the goldsmith’s fraud in the crafting of Hiero’s crown4. [Can we think of Galileo as an experimentalist historian of science, attempt- ing to understand Archimedes by trying to simulate some of his work?] Galileo felt that the commonly told story about Archimedes in the bath could not be correct; the implied measuring technique would have been too impre- cise and certainly not worthy of the Syracusan’s real capabilities. By Galileo’s time, of course, balances had had a long history as tools: both in the abstract (at the core, for instance, of some of Archimedes’ mathematical techniques), and in the flesh as part of the kit of everyday work and trade. In this last regard, the economic health of medieval and renaissance Florence depended in part on the reliability and precision of the balances used by goldsmiths as well as those used in the Florentine Mint, the latter organization responsible since the early 13th century for the quality and content of the gold Florin. So Galileo was not really inventing a new device. What he was doing was stretch- ing his new Archimedean muscles and satisfying himself, if he bothered to worry about the issue at all, that with care and ingenuity one can, in fact, build very precise measuring instruments. The Little Balance starts by being a normal equal arm balance, a longish rod, balanced in the center, with a hook at one end and a balance pan sus- pended at the other, these at equal distances from the center. It differs from the normal balance in that one needs to be able to move the suspension of the pan from its “home” point, back and forth along its arm. And it also differs in that it requires a special, finely divided ruler along a portion of the rod with the movable pan. To create a ruler designed, say, for the Archimedean problem, testing a possible fraud and measuring the relative amounts of gold and silver in it: 1) start by hanging a sample of pure gold from the hook, and with the pan’s suspension in its “home” position bring the balance into equilibrium; 2) then immerse the gold in a container of water and slide the pan’s suspension along the rod until the balance is again in equilibrium; 3) mark the position of the suspension on the rod; this will be the “gold” point; 4) repeat these three steps with a sample of pure silver thereby establishing a “silver” point; 5) finally, install the special ruler between the two established “points”; 6) To test a suspect sample, simply repeat the first two steps using that sample; if the pan’s point of suspension then falls somewhere between the two previously established points, it is a mix, and its relative distances to those points will be in the ratio of the rel- ative amounts of each component. 4 Galilei, G., La bilancetta (ms. ca. 1586), in Favaro, A. (ed.), Le Opere..., 1, 209-220; Fermi, L. & Bernardini, G.(trs. & eds.), Galileo and the Scientific Revolution, Basic Books, New York, 1961: Appendix. 834 THOMAS SETTLE I have taken you through these details because I think that it is impor- tant to have a feel for the material aspect of the instrument. But we have not yet finished. What did Galileo use for the special rule? Here he shows some nice opportunistic ingenuity. He used a fine wire (he did not say so, but a good guess would be a standard steel lute string) which he wound tightly and compactly around the balance arm in the space between the two points. Then, since visually counting the wires to complete a measurement would have been difficult (the eyes glaze over), he recommended drawing the point of a stiletto across the wires between the points to be measured. A combi- nation of the slight sound resulting from the passing of the point of the knife from one wire to another and the tactile feel of that same jump through the handle of the knife would allow an accurate count. A nice touch for a musician. And one should say that the instrument, including the system of measurement, does work as proposed.
Recommended publications
  • 2-Minute Stories Galileo's World
    OU Libraries National Weather Center Tower of Pisa light sculpture (Engineering) Galileo and Experiment 2-minute stories • Bringing worlds together: How does the story of • How did new instruments extend sensory from Galileo exhibit the story of OU? perception, facilitate new experiments, and Galileo and Universities (Great Reading Room) promote quantitative methods? • How do universities foster communities of Galileo and Kepler Galileo’s World: learning, preserve knowledge, and fuel • Who was Kepler, and why was a telescope Bringing Worlds Together innovation? named after him? Galileo in Popular Culture (Main floor) Copernicus and Meteorology Galileo’s World, an “Exhibition without Walls” at • What does Galileo mean today? • How has meteorology facilitated discovery in the University of Oklahoma in 2015-2017, will History of Science Collections other disciplines? bring worlds together. Galileo’s World will launch Music of the Spheres Galileo and Space Science in 21 galleries at 7 locations across OU’s three • What was it like to be a mathematician in an era • What was it like, following Kepler and Galileo, to campuses. The 2-minute stories contained in this when music and astronomy were sister explore the heavens? brochure are among the hundreds that will be sciences? Oklahomans and Aerospace explored in Galileo’s World, disclosing Galileo’s Compass • How has the science of Galileo shaped the story connections between Galileo’s world and the • What was it like to be an engineer in an era of of Oklahoma? world of OU during OU’s 125th anniversary.
    [Show full text]
  • On the Isochronism of Galilei's Horologium
    IFToMM Workshop on History of MMS – Palermo 2013 On the isochronism of Galilei's horologium Francesco Sorge, Marco Cammalleri, Giuseppe Genchi DICGIM, Università di Palermo, [email protected], [email protected], [email protected] Abstract − Measuring the passage of time has always fascinated the humankind throughout the centuries. It is amazing how the general architecture of clocks has remained almost unchanged in practice to date from the Middle Ages. However, the foremost mechanical developments in clock-making date from the seventeenth century, when the discovery of the isochronism laws of pendular motion by Galilei and Huygens permitted a higher degree of accuracy in the time measure. Keywords: Time Measure, Pendulum, Isochronism Brief Survey on the Art of Clock-Making The first elements of temporal and spatial cognition among the primitive societies were associated with the course of natural events. In practice, the starry heaven played the role of the first huge clock of mankind. According to the philosopher Macrobius (4 th century), even the Latin term hora derives, through the Greek word ‘ώρα , from an Egyptian hieroglyph to be pronounced Heru or Horu , which was Latinized into Horus and was the name of the Egyptian deity of the sun and the sky, who was the son of Osiris and was often represented as a hawk, prince of the sky. Later on, the measure of time began to assume a rudimentary technical connotation and to benefit from the use of more or less ingenious devices. Various kinds of clocks developed to relatively high levels of accuracy through the Egyptian, Assyrian, Greek and Roman civilizations.
    [Show full text]
  • Music and Science from Leonardo to Galileo International Conference 13-15 November 2020 Organized by Centro Studi Opera Omnia Luigi Boccherini, Lucca
    MUSIC AND SCIENCE FROM LEONARDO TO GALILEO International Conference 13-15 November 2020 Organized by Centro Studi Opera Omnia Luigi Boccherini, Lucca Keynote Speakers: VICTOR COELHO (Boston University) RUDOLF RASCH (Utrecht University) The present conference has been made possibile with the friendly support of the CENTRO STUDI OPERA OMNIA LUIGI BOCCHERINI www.luigiboccherini.org INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE MUSIC AND SCIENCE FROM LEONARDO TO GALILEO Organized by Centro Studi Opera Omnia Luigi Boccherini, Lucca Virtual conference 13-15 November 2020 Programme Committee: VICTOR COELHO (Boston University) ROBERTO ILLIANO (Centro Studi Opera Omnia Luigi Boccherini) FULVIA MORABITO (Centro Studi Opera Omnia Luigi Boccherini) RUDOLF RASCH (Utrecht University) MASSIMILIANO SALA (Centro Studi Opera Omnia Luigi Boccherini) ef Keynote Speakers: VICTOR COELHO (Boston University) RUDOLF RASCH (Utrecht University) FRIDAY 13 NOVEMBER 14.45-15.00 Opening • FULVIA MORABITO (Centro Studi Opera Omnia Luigi Boccherini) 15.00-16.00 Keynote Speaker 1: • VICTOR COELHO (Boston University), In the Name of the Father: Vincenzo Galilei as Historian and Critic ef 16.15-18.15 The Galileo Family (Chair: Victor Coelho, Boston University) • ADAM FIX (University of Minnesota), «Esperienza», Teacher of All Things: Vincenzo Galilei’s Music as Artisanal Epistemology • ROBERTA VIDIC (Hochschule für Musik und Theater Hamburg), Galilei and the ‘Radicalization’ of the Italian and German Music Theory • DANIEL MARTÍN SÁEZ (Universidad Autónoma de Madrid), The Galileo Affair through
    [Show full text]
  • Galileo Galilei by Beatrix Mccrea Galileo Galilei Was an Italian Physicist, Engineer, and Astronomer Bestknown for Disc
    3/24/2019 Galileo Galilei - Google Docs Galileo Galilei By Beatrix McCrea Galileo Galilei was an Italian physicist, engineer, and astronomer best­known for discovering the four largest moons on Jupiter and his theory of gravity. His theory of gravity stated that if a bowling ball and a feather dropped at the same time in space they would land at the same time. He also invented the thermometer and an astronomical telescope. Galileo Galilei was born to Vincenzo Galilei and Giulia Ammanniti in Piza, Italy on February 15, 1564. He was the first of six children. There were two things that happened which led Galileo to find that he loved math and science. On The Famous People the text states “the first incident happened in 1581 when he first noticed that a chandelier despite swinging in small and large arcs took almost the same time to return to the first position.” The other incident was when he accidentally attended a geometry lecture. Both these incidents made Galileo find his love for science. Galileo discovered the four largest moons on Jupiter. On Biography.com it says Galileo Galilei was best known for discovering Jupiter and it’s four biggest moons. The names were Io, Europa, Ganymede, and Callisto. They were discovered by Galileo in January of 1610. Galileo used a better version of the telescope that made him made to see the four moons. Galileo Galilei had a very popular theory of gravity, that if there was no air resistance (like in space) you would drop a bowling ball and a feather and they would land at the exact same time.
    [Show full text]
  • Birth and Life of Scientific Collections in Florence
    BIRTH AND LIFE OF SCIENTIFIC COLLECTIONS IN FLORENCE Mara Miniati 1 RESUMO: em Florença. Este artigo descreve as trans- formações ocorridas entre os séculos 18 e O artigo centra-se na história das coleções 19 na vida cultural da capital da Toscana: as científicas em Florença. Na era dos Medici, artes e ciências foram promovidos, e os flo- Florença foi um importante centro de pes- rentinos cultivados estavam interessadas no quisa científica e de coleções. Este aspecto desenvolvimento recente da física, na Itália e da cultura florentina é geralmente menos no exterior. Nesse período, numerosas co- conhecido, mas a ciência e coleções científi- leções científicas privadas e públicas de Flo- cas foram uma parte consistente da história rença existentes, que eram menos famosas, da cidade. O recolhimento de instrumentos mas não menos importantes do que as co- científicos era um componente importante leções Médici e Lorena se destacaram. Final- das estratégias políticas dos grão-duques flo- mente, o artigo descreve como as coleções rentinos, convencidos de que o conhecimen- florentinas se desenvolveram. A fundação to científico e controle tecnológico sobre do Instituto e Museu de História da Ciência a natureza conferiria solidez e prestígio ao deu nova atenção aos instrumentos cientí- seu poder político. De Cosimo I a Cosimo ficos antigos. Sua intensa atividade de pes- III, os grão-duques Médici concederam o seu quisa teve um impacto sobre a organização patrocínio e comissões sobre gerações de do Museu. Novos estudos levaram a novas engenheiros e cientistas, formando uma co- atribuições aos instrumentos científicos, as leção de instrumentos matemáticos e astro- investigações de arquivamento contribuiram nômicos, os modelos científicos e produtos para um melhor conhecimento da coleção, naturais, exibidos ao lado das mais famosas e os contactos crescentes com instituições coleções de arte na Galleria Uffizi, no Pala- italianas e internacionais feitas do Museu zzo Pitti, e em torno da cidade de Florença tornaram-no cada vez mais ativo em uma e outros lugares da Toscana.
    [Show full text]
  • Galileo's Eyeglass: an Orchestral Work Celebrating the Discovery of The
    GALILEO’S EYEGLASS: AN ORCHESTRAL WORK CELEBRATING THE DISCOVERY OF THE MOONS OF JUPITER AND THE RINGS OF SATURN Jay Alan Walls, B.M.E., M.M. Dissertation Prepared for the Degree of DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY UNIVERSITY OF NORTH TEXAS August 2011 APPROVED: Joseph P. Klein, Major Professor and Chair of the Division of Composition Stephen F. Austin, Committee Member Cindy McTee, Committee Member Lynn Eustis, Director of Graduate Programs in the College of Music James C. Scott, Dean of the College of Music James D. Meernik, Acting Dean of the Toulouse Graduate School Walls, Jay Alan. Galileo's Eyeglass: An Orchestral Work Celebrating the Discovery of the Moons of Jupiter and the Rings of Saturn. Doctor of Philosophy (Composition), August 2011, 149 pp., 2 figures, 2 tables, 47 examples, 3 appendices, bibliography, 43 titles. Galileo's Eyeglass is a celebratory work for full orchestra with standard instrumentation commemorating Galileo Galilei's discoveries of the four largest moons of Jupiter and the rings of Saturn in 1610. The composition is approximately 14 minutes in duration, and although divided thematically into four parts, the music is continuous. The work exhibits primarily a blend of contemporary styles and compositional elements, yet it is rooted in traditional tonality; furthermore, the piece is interspersed with references to Galileo's life and times, including quotations of a toccata composed by the scientist's brother, Michelangelo Galilei, transcribed from lute tablature. Chapter 1 of Part 1 investigates relevant historical threads extracted from the backdrop of Galileo's life, from reflections on the events that shape the musical program, to the selection and preparation of the period music composed by Galileo's brother.
    [Show full text]
  • Galileu Galilei: El Naixement De La Ciència Moderna
    Galileu Galilei: el naixement de la ciència moderna Victòria Rosselló Rosselló, V. (2016). Galileu Galilei: el naixement de la ciència moderna. In: Ginard, A.; Vicens, D. i Pons, G.X. (eds.). Idees que van canviar el món. Mon. Soc. Hist. Nat. Balears, 22; 53-65. SHNB - UIB. ISBN 978-84-608-9162-8. Disponible on-line a shnb.org/SHN_monografies Resum: El pensament de Galileu suposa el punt de partida de la Revolució Científica amb l’aparició d’una ciència on l’experimentació hi té un paper fonamental en contraposició a la ciència aristotèlica vigent al segle XVI. Amb el seu esforç intel·lectual, Galileu va fer trontollar l’edifici conceptual del seu temps amb el canvi d’actitud mental davant els problemes físics. La física galileana suposà una nova manera de mirar el món, que pretenia descobrir les lleis físiques que regulen els processos naturals. La nova manera d’analitzar els fenòmens de la naturalesa fou un procés que pot descriure’s com el pas de la recerca de causes a la recerca de lleis. La física aristotèlica s’ocupava del canvi (motio) i tenia com a objectiu comprendre els fenòmens de la naturalesa mitjançant l’examen de les causes. El coneixement pràctic (techne) havia estat exclòs per Aristòtil de la Filosofia Natural per considerar-lo inferior al coneixement científic (episteme). La Revolució Científica va consistir en bona mesura en la progressiva dissolució d’aquesta diferenciació i en la reconciliació del coneixement adquirit amb la pràctica amb l’obtingut mitjançant la raó. 54 Idees que van canviar el món Galileu Galilei va néixer el 15 de febrer de 1564 a Pisa i fou el primer de sis germans.
    [Show full text]
  • November 2018 P&F Newsletter LONG
    WELCOME And just like that the weather shifted, and storms have raged across Italy. The cold season has arrived, though we hope that the rest of Autumn and Winter will be a little gentler. There are fewer visitors in the streets, and the lights of the city cast a warm glow as sunset falls a little earlier each day. It’s time to explore cozy galleries, to indulge in the best of rich Tuscan stews and roasted chestnuts. Or simply a drizzle of the first press of olive oil over toasted bread will make the perfect humble supper by the fireplace as the nights grow colder. With best wishes from SUZANNE, CORSO, BEI, LESLIE, VANNI, ANNA PIA, RAFFAELLA, AND MARISA. PITCHER & FLACCOMIO PICKS FOR NOVEMBER A NOVEMBER NOTE FROM SUZANNE: HOLD THE DATE AND DONATE Ciao everyone! Yet again, we need your help. On December 1st and 2nd, the American International Women's League ONLUS organises a Christmas bazaar. I am asking you all to think about what you would like to do to help make this a fabulously rich affair. We need a lot of things to sell, we need your clothing, so please go through your closets (and those of your significant other, plus your kids, etc.) to collect the things you no longer need. We are looking for all types of clothing plus purses, gloves, scarves, evening gowns, cocktail dresses, jewellery (diamonds, or not) and hats. Please let us know as we have volunteers going around Florence collecting things for the bazaar. Call Roberta Magni on number 3333956718 Another idea.
    [Show full text]
  • Esfera Celeste Tierra
    De La Tierra a La Esfera Celeste David Barrado Navascués INTA De La Tierra a La Esfera Celeste David Barrado Navascués INTA cDavid Barrado Navascués CATÁLOGO GENERAL DE PUBLICACIONES OFICIALES http/www.publicacionesoficiales.boe.es Los derechos de esta obra están amparados por la Ley de Propiedad Intelectual. No podrá ser reproducida por medio alguno, comprendidos la reprografía y el tratamiento informático, sin permiso previo de los titulares del © Copyright. © Instituto Nacional de Técnica Aeroespacial «Esteban Terradas» (INTA) Edita: NIPO: Impreso: 078-14-006-6 En línea: 078-14-005-0 Depósito Legal: M-31696-2014 Diseño y Arte: Vicente Aparisi Tirada: 1000 ejemplares Fecha de edición: noviembre 2014 Imprime: Imprenta Nacional del Boletín Oficial del Estado. 4 De la Tierra a la Esfera Celesteb «Nec fasces nec opes, Sola Artis sceptra perennant» 1 Tycho Brahe 1.- «Ni los honores ni las riquezas: solo la perfección de la obra es lo que sobrevivirá», en su epitafio. 5 cDavid Barrado Navascués 6 De la Tierra a la Esfera Celesteb edicatoria D A Iñaki, Anabel y Mariní, por su fortaleza y ejemplo. A todos los que luchan contra un cáncer. También para Eva, Susana, Carlos, Maleni, Angelines, Víctor y Mari. 7 cDavid Barrado Navascués ndice n ÍNDICE DE FIGURAS ……………………………………………………………………………………………… 10 n AGRADECIMIENTOS ……………………………………………………………………………………………… 14 Ín PROEMIO ………………………………………………………………………………………………………………… 16 n HÉROES, DIOSES Y CONSTELACIONES: ASTERISMOS Y CATASTERISMOS ……… 18 n NAVEGACIÓN Y ASTRONOMÍA EN LA PENUMBRA DE LOS TIEMPOS REMOTOS
    [Show full text]
  • "The Florentine Camerata: Documentary Studies and Translations." by Claude V
    Performance Practice Review Volume 3 Article 5 Number 1 Spring "The lorF entine Camerata: Documentary Studies and Translations." By Claude V. Palisca Hugh Wiley Hitchcock Follow this and additional works at: http://scholarship.claremont.edu/ppr Part of the Music Practice Commons Hitchcock, Hugh Wiley (1990) ""The Florentine Camerata: Documentary Studies and Translations." By Claude V. Palisca," Performance Practice Review: Vol. 3: No. 1, Article 5. DOI: 10.5642/perfpr.199003.01.5 Available at: http://scholarship.claremont.edu/ppr/vol3/iss1/5 This Book Review is brought to you for free and open access by the Journals at Claremont at Scholarship @ Claremont. It has been accepted for inclusion in Performance Practice Review by an authorized administrator of Scholarship @ Claremont. For more information, please contact [email protected]. 78 H. Wiley Hitchcock Claude V. Palisca. The Florentine Camerata [:] Documentary Studies and Translations. Music Theory Translation Series. New Haven and London: Yale University Press, 1989. vi, 234p, With this book of eight documents relating to the musical deliberations of the Camerata — that informal but intense group of intellectuals assembled by Count Giovanni Bardi in late sixteenth-century Florence — Claude Palisca adds yet another definitive work to the theoretical studies he has long been publishing. He presents each document in its original language (Italian or Latin) and in a flawless, graceful translation; and he introduces each with several pages of helpful orientation to its contextual
    [Show full text]
  • Mapping Dante: a Digital Platform for the Study of Places in the Commedia
    Humanist Studies & the Digital Age, 5.1 (2017) ISSN: 2158-3846 (online) http://journals.oregondigital.org/hsda/ DOI: 10.7264/N3MG7MXK Mapping Dante: A Digital Platform for the Study of Places in the Commedia Andrea Gazzoni Abstract This essay presents Mapping Dante, a project for the study of the geography of the Divine Comedy through a digital map visualizing all of the place-names mentioned in the text. First, the project background is sketched out by a concise overview of the history of the reception and visualization of Dante’s geography, of the constellation of digital Dante projects, and of GIS literary mapping. Second, specific stages and issues of Mapping Dante are discussed: the making of the dataset and its categories, the heterogeneity of medieval geography, the structure of the map with layers and pop-up cards. Conceived as a repository of Dante’s encyclopedic use of geography in the Commedia, the map is also an experiment in connecting text and cartography through the possibilities offered by GIS technology. By exploring different visualizations of a set layers based on textual, cultural and rhetorical categories, users can search for patterns in the distribution of Dante’s geographical references, and can retrieve information relevant to each passage in which a place is mentioned. Mapping Dante [www.mappingdante.com] is a project in progress for the study of the geography of the Divine Comedy. Launched in May 2016, it consists of a digital interactive map with all of the place-names mentioned in the poem, and of additional non-cartographic materials: the Italian text of the Commedia with links to all of its geographical references, a network visualization of the relations between individual cantos and places, and a set of charts with quantitative analyses of the same dataset on which the map is based.
    [Show full text]
  • Galileo in Hell (1638), Is Generally Considered the Beginning of Modern Science
    Galileo’s last and perhaps most important book, Discourses on Two New Sciences Galileo in Hell (1638), is generally considered the beginning of modern science. The book Galileo’s Measurements of Dante’s Inferno and the begins with a discussion of the properties and resistance of materials. With Beginning of Modern Science remarkable foresight, Galileo showed how the size and shape of all existing objects and living bodies, from ants to elephants, to planets and stars, are determined by a few simple rules. This powerful, novel idea and rules, that University of California, Los Angeles today we call “scaling laws,” are one of the most useful tools that scientists have Center for Medieval & RenaissanceStudies for understanding nature. Royce Hall 314 It is tempting to say that the development of scaling laws was strongly influenced Friday, October 29, 2010 by the literary and artistic cultural environment in which Galileo received his early education. But what led Galileo to the scaling laws? 9:30 Coffee, pastries He first mentions his work on the resistance of materials in a letter to Antonio de Medici in 1609. In his Discourses on Two New Sciences, Galileo refers to a 10:00 Welcoming Remarks discussion with a foreman in Venice’s Arsenal as the element that stimulated Lee Walcott (Managing Director Emeritus, The Ahmanson Foundation) his interest in the study of materials. But another hypothesis has been advanced Massimo Ciavolella (Italian, UCLA) and Claudio Pellegrini (Physics, recently by Mark Peterson: Galileo had been thinking about these problems UCLA), symposium organizers well before he wrote the letter to Antonio de’ Medici, and before he became a Professor in Padua in 1592 and started visiting the Arsenal.
    [Show full text]