Guiarat Pollution Control Board Reglonal Office, Belgium Square, Silver Plaza Complex, Opp. Lin€ar Bus Stand, w\72 Ring Road, Surat -395 O03 - W€bsit€: www.spcb.sov.in ISO 9001and ISO 14001 certilied organization PUBLIC HEARING PROCEEDING It is hereby intormed that as per the Ministry ol Environment and Forest & Ctimate Change, Govemment ot India, New Delhi vide its notmcation no. S.O. 1533 dated 141092006 and its subsequent amendment S.O. 3067 (E) dated 01/12009, Public Hearing is ananged for of mb. Spectrum Dye3 .nd Chqmlcals Prlvate Limited, fo. p.oposed expansion ot S.O. Dyes- 900 MT/Monlh, Dispersing Agent-1500 MT/Month or Formulated S.O. Dyes-240o MT/Month and Dye IntermediateeTso MT/Month, plant located at Block No. 484, 502, 503, 504 & 505, NH-8, Vill :Palsana, Ta. Palsana, Dist. Surat, (Guja.at) covered under Category'A- as mentioned in their request applacation.
A copy ot the dralt Environment lmpacl Assessnent Report and the Executive Summary ot Environfi€nl lmpact Assessnent Report was sent to the tolloding authoritbs or offices to make available the draft EIA report for inspeclion to the public during nomal ofiice hours, till the Public Hearing is over.
'l. The Dislict Colbctor Ofice. Su.at 2. District Develoornent Office. Surat 3. Districl lnduslry Centre, Surat 4. Taluka Development Office, Tal: Palsana, Dist.: Surat 5. Additional Principal Chief Conservator of Forest (C), Ministry of Environment, Forest & Climate Change, col, Regional Oftic€ (We6t Zone), Kendriya Paryavaran Bhavan. E-5, Arera Colony, Link Road-3, Ravisankar Colony, Bhopal - 462016. 6. Regional Offce, Gujarat Pollution Control Board, Belgium Square, Silver Plaza Complex, Opp. Linear Bus Siand, Rang Road, Surat - 395 003.
Otier concemed persons haviog plausible stake in environmental asp€cts were requesled to s€nd their esponses in wriling to the concerned regulatory authorities.
The Public Hearing was held on 2510512018 at '11:00 hrs. at Late Shre€ Chhotubhal Dayalji De3ai Hall, B€hind Post Office. Palsana Main Road, Vlll: Palsana, Ta. pal3ana, Dist. Surat (GuJarat). An advertisement in English was published in "The Times of India" as we as in 'cujarat Samacha/. Surat Edition on 18/04/20'18. Guiarat Pollution Control Board Regional office, Belgium Square, Silver Pla", Complex, Opp. Linear Bus Stand, w\tt RinS Road, Surat -39S 003 - Webslte: www.gpcb€ov.in ISO 9001 and ISO 1,tO01 cerdtled oryanization Shrl S,O.Valrva (GAS), Relldenilal Addltional Dietict & Addldonal Dlstrkt [agiltate, Surat supervis€d and presided over the entire public hearing process.
A staiement sho,ving participants present during the public headng is enclosed as Annsxure A.
A statement highl(lhting issues raised by the participants and .esponded to by the representative ot the applacanl during the public h€aring in English and Gujarati Languages is encros€d as Annerurc B end Bl respectively.
A copaes of responses receaved in writing trom other persons having plausible stake and written representiation received during Public Hearing in environmenl,al aspecls are enclosed herewith collectively as Anneru.G C-l and C-25, the replies by applicant to the same arc encloGed herewilh colleclively as Annsxure D- l 8nd D-25-
Copies of public notice published in English and cujarati Edition is enctosed as Annexur+E.
4-2 Place: Palsana, R. WV. Patel I s(l)arAs^)r 16^s) Ta: Palsana Regional Otticer, Relidential Addltlonal Collector Dist.: Surat GPCB, Su.at. and Date: 25/05i2018 Additlonal Obt ict Uagbtrate, Surat
Encl: 1 Annexure A, B, Bl , C-l to C-25, D-1 to D.25 and E as above. 2 Video CD ot public hearing REGIONAL O}'FICI.]. SURAT GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD ffi\lrt 33E,llelgi m square. Opp. l,inear llus Sland.Ring Road. SURA'I-J950(13
ANNEXURE - A A statement 3howinq particioants present durlno the Dublic hearinq
As per the Ministry of Environment and Fofests, Govemment of India, New Delhi, vide its notification no. S.O.1533 (E) dated 't4|09/2OOO and its subsequent amendmenl S 0.3067 (E) dated 1''December 2009, Public Hearing has been fixed for the following project covered under CATEGORY 'A" of M/s Spectrum Dyes and Chemicals Private Limited for proposed expansion of S.O. \es- 900 MTMonth' Dispersitrg Agent- 1500 MTMonth or Formulated S.O. Dyes- 2400 MT/Month rnd Dye Itraermcdiates- ?50 MTMonth, at Block No. 484, 502,503' 504 & 505' NH-8' Vill. Palsana, Ta' Palsatrr, Dist. Surat.
The stalement showing Parlicipants present during public Hearing held on 25.05.2018 at'11:00 a.m at Lrte shree Chhotubhsi Dryalji Dessi Hrll, Behitrd Post Oflice, Palsatra Msin Rord, vill. Palsana' Tr.Palslna, Dist, Surat (Gujarat), is as under: a{.?d n?sr?4t ct"t t{a q?rlq?qt riataer, ddl fdcdat qn&ral{t r{is :llt{.qf. 1q33(tJ) rtt. tY-oe- ?oos r,{a actt qd[{ qt{?t 5{is A{.r, . 3o9o (tJ) ctt. o1-1?-?ooe q"Jriuta lt{d trlri4 sttt$ {* }Oscrr urdaa c{l{i}s, o g r{i5 arr uJ. ol€,1. {IEUJtt{ a6l 1 uaQlcrtrv ELq Q-r-?l1 w 2 ,( (e' c{(4/\( 31 ..s 6\ ) , , ) f&.''B 3. (z e4u- ;r,. e.,i's.,. 'l.\Ql 2-: t t7 z rc/ P^cE L oF t Sr.No. Name and Designation Organization/Village Signature 5 4t3 dr{ r,{a €lal d+qucu.{ 6[ 4 Ua..re-sl.A.Pale) Ve:-,a @I@ {rLt5h',f N.\uo', &.r grar-)- /rw ?.o".'-4 d"-"*4"-) ry- D qr ? Vv"1-* Ctr;F"A ^,t-rXr^,t .4|-^^ v fu,t4- S"it" 5 6 Po'lsu*tt bn^/ ' 1 \";.{ D--" .>12'2ra,J fu&"'- \ -1) d4"an c. il.^rr 9'')z^'* Y rl ,/7 t.-r._Lhb!. I .tY)._ -.6-d- (---> \ IL * J.,.^J. r,r.. h,//tt.z? tlt Yv4, Yl ^r-^ ,g ;i..1,; +11h,-.J. \u1 .Q,J ,[ev, H W,tfu) e,)elf-.--l . ;lliiil$L \5 1\\$ rnf ts' 6,1a| P^GE Z oF t: RECIONAL Of FICE. SURAl' ffi GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARI) \ttz 338, Belgium Square, opp. l,ine:rr lJus Stand, Ring Road, SURAT-395003 Sr.No. Name and Designation Organization/Village Signature ?,{a ql tttelucLLt{ n$t 3 {t5 "ttlt €f f+J' u) tA t c1 Ud I ,-'1 A ht]iA__ ,-r:'\lqv|lh .n.trtq ?lr(\r- oFt,rhrFrr rr\ !;r'.r c s x\ c 4 F4rJ Zl1-- ,l *,t"- r's r\ . 1a 'bt\,&.* u-l"wAa_ L6 tLioat R - ?^l'z B"lolun- t4 )it',.. hilerh ch.*\" )rtvfl':tr PW 2v Eiu -,i ariGt,rr,i arl'v, n, oll\f)c\l 4B @2: ,tl fi.}-t' Q'\ J.1 p"2Js-*-^Jfu"-";J -iln co +rru>\ d"r,r-axrS) -Qrt--at+-'k' o".'^ '1O O<'r'"" {ctJ.l w 3t 9^*).,.u 'A ,9.r* ?,-*, ^^ u E-"f ?{lol ( rLR\ ta {rrj.r | ^ (J:l C4 /'€-t <--., 2a 1 oc1 a$\r\ C'aG.e4 {/ Pa,r"t-."1 ^417>l* s'/U ^^4 ^/9'/L,.k' )r\ ftr..5",r, v -{rn,r) Vfll'ri(-'t ?.trf ,,qt1n,a. ." gzr r< -nl C-1 .tt4 .22 !a . a--n. e, -J A-4- :$ <,-"r qenrn.J.,.r,c \4 e' \-r 1gz?1 dLt-- t).+ 5iJ.ae-o.r- A,Eoet Zs Mtt,r"\ r.\ . Dtanr -qz T)"l Lg"l r,.n-r ow@ 2A -rr.\ir tl\c. \\(\-\-'.\ !5\\ "lq^or.- -qLrs.lXt ^.(,\ a\F{ mce j orf Rf CIO\AL OT'FIC[. SLRAT GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARD w\ttt 338, ltelgium Squrre, Opp. Lincar Bus Slard. Ring Ro.rd, stjtLAl -J95{}l).1 Sr.No. Name and Designation Organization/Village Signaturs r,{a l{+EUctpt ndl 5 {t5 "u{ Asl -itq .d {\l3ra, J-rrurv V C/\uWL ko -a,''".rll Hdlz. (fu/z< qfp-s'r.r-z' ^,lG *}}l'r \ *\2.'t".5 - .q."<1 oi.s\ \ < hl -i...",n \ \z \fi} 4fiUclrro'ifq& \f-o?^(4 ;l1pt"' clr.r v'V Q- rlr.)\- r, r'-n k?,) J1raf^l N r,.l 4 .n J"1 Cfs-*.rd4("-+ 6 S;tq \'----'<{- 9>--, {@F-1f0ote l<,8 flatet ^5 Ke nqt b ?qter 1,r dek ezey_efi. ,,i.)'Cr',et, {!r)uF,9r{srt tt) , lv 4cx ri l a'.tart-ztt ) st a4 -.t 'tf t- 2*"'')5 w 91..6. -al *t..rs \(*hr1111 $u:-- Po]cernq h1 $;n^ Lq*,\.J ih'"h- JO in",- 5\ 9r*l l.^,1+-l 9rl** t+ Y ( /oeett, LL;u-J At"ttr ,,f A E? ?dQ) Yw'n *oi'bht ( ALs(tN *(- 41" tJ , >r1 (Zn.G>' w 2> lP,lat ., - M"XL2' d44 o ' >"-'.-')1 \(A115.. b s.{l 't" t DC> \rI.' 2rl Y' -1 t".r^ r (gr I -=,oklh 3 ,+ e., !{a'J .^rr,^,2(41 ^1 PAaE + oFl. Sr. No. Name and Designation Organization / Village Name Signature q] 5ri s " { ?44 €f ritrrurl.tq "j "tt{ rt.{l ,f1r rr<8't\\3 Krrr'1d )IS4h-.-- \ s( >rt*'ti\ n'-4 -lEg 9-h'\-) €"lor,:"'.- * $a l"k"-"--- & -'6 t /'lae;{tl t lrthl /a lu^ou /1e4< 6z ffi-n,2ll.,g+ji*n,"', n Gto\fu I \YA4 jzn',,,. t) 9ft,?,r "9r^n- rt4 69 ,th4|uv 12* C,rc;1tL4 f/u4/ A? ?1-t^n rn..: o7 a'rtF 'n""'r''t- Y \ {^1 ('1 ! r.,.i'l (JO (?ur' -'''"^ C--, Nt.at h(|'1 Az CZt,o. ih []z R/. 69 'x\.. >l Sr (J.d-gtrl -r,.).:.rf 69 plo-;+ b-t* F^J.2^".-) P(^o-,u ent< o ti'5 ?4 ).flarr ur6 r cr, /fi1'rrrr-{t[ ") +l 7u*,-./"''.,.. Szw'4 1^4 --:-\<.^{ , -=}r , -1.1 f A?frJ. A P"6rc I afg Sr. No. Name and Designation Organization / Village Name Signature t{is q] s dr{ rAa €f ri+ert/trttq "j "u{ {dl J; ?3 V iK., " t"t'" ,p c. v-s <-\..r -a^urnir) a^ PtLe!- Qul-gong- w F$sn 4. finA s ?/rU/ -y'ahqr,l 4't Yql ea=t'- v\?| 0A *r' ^/' l+ L+-t- u/^ -l-!tt? *-- -Otn 5r.No. Name and Designation Organization/Village Signature 8{t3 "tr{ r,{i ,:'ltl {rqvnrtr a,s'l . l-{. /vrrr\ reJi fctls ct'z-'t- ,ry_ zs l 6q Mdn/-;-4 m /"2'/ ?*Z*e'o q0 Atsb* fu.lr--/? ?"^I' i-/ Q,r >^^:---J f\-^^o 9-*^l a;4 qL 14 g aaa)l9* 1>4l^k Al4 tp.W:)tt ll ae' - A+1; w Qrl 6 t rlot-- I' tu a v/'./a41 /).rt Z,,t-Zrt.'t It rnq*,,1h t1 eArn4 ,4'r4- | 'Taratt ? *t- 2our"u r' tta r $'- c tht q<\tv 2,&r< IT $ \g'1/ cr\. t' tJ da\ Ql.u- *n. s'i ,O." t uqtubr" Qgu)-- M ala-a-dar beao', 11 tsL;th"aU b- Dg"' S-.Ca.uuj- 9" li or^ t're\i g i) ec Pg t\ lrt'rT\'rj t''g 06, A/ \o3 A t. cL"*L AE tr / hFcB 7 / VrP(14 ' 104 KqnL.-l T "sU. Qv-'vici6'n 'l( SFe!Vr-\ Dr14t{ \o5 n \;n1a,qI',;- ,.1{* DqU /61"t) P^cE 7 oFV \>_ Rllclol\Al, ol t'lcu. st RAT GUJARAT POLLUTION CONTROL BOARI) 331i, Bdgium Square. Opp. Linear llus Stand' Ring RoAd. S(IRAT-395003 Sr.No. Name and De5ignation organization/village Signature rqis drq r{a €lril l|l€lt/rttq €1 lt/ fla'tJt X //ctit'ni' 'ffii*:l,i'ii,t rc'__l 31a rryut<1 ll!t+ p.rnJ Bhqvr"a- *' 'i n e ho-ntcas *+,rtol rrb rtr< leY (hoEan $ne Q1 I PAGE g oF I ANNEXURE - B {Enelish) the aoolicant durins the public hearine As per the p.ovisions of Notification No. S.O. 1533 (E) dated 14/09/2005 and its subsequent amendment 5.O. 3067(E) dated O1/12/2009, Ministry of Environment, Forest & Climate Change, Government of India, New Delhi, public hearing is conducted for M/3. Spectrum DYes And Chemicals h,t. Ltd,, located at Block No.484, 502, 503 A, 504 and 505, NH-8, Palsana, Ta': Palsana, Dist.: Surat(Gujarat) for Proposed Expansion of SO Dyes -900 MT/Month, Dispersing Agent -15m MT/Month Or Formulated SO Dyes -2400 MT/Month and Dyes Intermediate - 750 MT/Month. The Public Hearing held on 25105/2018 at 11.m hrs. at Late Shree Chhotubhai DayaUi Desai Hall. Eehind Post Office, Palsana Main Road, vill: Palsana, Ta, Palsana, Dist: Surat (Gujarat). This project is covered under cateSory 5(f) ol category "A'of above referred Notifications. Public Hearing is conducted under the chairmanship of Shri S.D.Vasava (cas), Residential Additional Collector & Additional District Magistrate, Surat. Shri R.V.Patel, Regional officer, GPCB Surat, Representative of Member Secretary GPCS; welcomed all the participants who remained present in the Public Hearin8, He outlined the various p,ovisions of the Notification and briefed about the procedural details for conducting this Public Hearing, including actions taken by GPCB for wide publicity of thi5 Public Hearing and the advertisement published earlier in the local daily newspaper. He announced that as per the provision of Notification, only affected persons will be allowed to make their representation in the Public Hearing while others havint plausible stake may submit their representation in writing which would be included in proceedings. He also made it clear to the gathering that thls committee is responsible only for preparation of proceedings of the meeting covering all the concerns raised during the Public Hearing. l.le then opened the public hearing with due permission of Chairman of Public Hearing and invited the Prgject Proponent to make the presentation oftheir pro.iect in local language. Then technical representative of M/r. Spectrum Dyes and Chemicals A,t. ttd, welcomed all and Save introduction of the project and pres€nted the technical information in local language regarding the project, company introduction, impact on environment due to proposed project, environmental management system, mitigation measures & socio €conomic .esponsibilities. After the presentation by project proponent, Representative of GPCB with due permission of Chairman of Public Hearing opened the forum for representations^uggestion/objections/ questions from the locally affected people. The statement showing issues/suggestions/objections/opinion raised by participants during the Public hearing and responded to by representative of the proied proponent during the public hearing is as unde.. Concerned Si. Na.ne and Address Point Represented and/or written Replies by No. submisrion Project Proponent welcomed 1. Sh ri Mohan He welcomed the company and Regional officer Ranchhodbhai re9resented that, my suggestion as the suggestaon. Patel, related to the representation done Vill.:8hatiya, and shown on record here. He informed that, there Ta.: Choryasi, Industries are releasing their waste are 2 CtTPs existing in this Dist.: Surat water in to Ealeshwar Khadi now area, which are treating days, which is required to be treated effluent of industries. lf Drior to release in Khadi. Such any matter of releasing machineries and equipment should polluted water into be installed, so that waste water can ground water/borewell be recvcled and reused after comes into noti€e of GPCB treatment. Infact, issue of the smell or either through coming out of the khadi water can intormation from any also be resolved and farmers and body, then GPCB will take animal husbandry both could get rid strad actaons as per of the same. Environment Act. water is released into ground through boring within the industrial area, due to which red water is Company's comin8 from the boring of the repregentative, on behalf farmers of nearby villages such as of their management Lingda, Vadadala, Baleshwar and asSured that, for other villages within the 2 kms. appointment of new radius. employees, they will He represented that, it is important organize meeting with that GPCB have organized Public Sarpanch of nearby Hearing for this project but othe. villages and p.iority will be industries alreadv established in this given to the local villagers region didn't organize Public and also provide training Hearing. accordingly. When the company is going to RegardinS fire fighting expand and there is co-ope.ation of provision, two industrial surrounding people, company associations exist in this should provide t.aining to the staff region and with their joint and worker to be employed in the efforts, provision of company. Sarpanch of seven necessary arrangements surrounding villages should be called for firefighting can be for meeting and discussion made possible. regarding employment to the local villagers and employment should provided as per their skills after providing proper training to them. so that local unemployed people can get employment and co- ordination between both can be maintained. So manv industries are located in this region but there is no fire fighter vehicle to overcome issue of fire accident. So joint meeting should be arranged in this matter and with the co-operation ol the nearby villagers, necessary arrangements in this regard is required to be implemented. Drinking water pipeline should be provided in this area and drinking water should be provided to villagers at their home. Government and GPCB, if jointly make provision of laying the pipeline 10 km deep into the sea, then the issue of the polluted water can be resolved. 2. smt. Sudhaben Written representation of Smt. Reply of her written Hemantbhai Desai, Sudhaben Hemantbhai Desai is representataon is Member of Taluka presented bv shri Hemantbhai included into Panchayat, Palsana, Desai, which is included into proceeorngs a5 Dist,:surat proceedings as Annexure-C-21 Annexure-D-21. At & Po.- Baleshwar Regional Officer, GPcB Ta.: Palsana, informed regarding Park Dist.:surat permitted without getting EC (Environment Clearance) to them. As per EIA Notification 2006, procedure of EC is applicable to pro.iects which falls under Category "A" & "8". EC is required to be obtained by the industries falling under category 'A' and 'B'. if any company doesn't follow the environment rules then strict action will be taken against such company. 3. Shri snehalbhai . He represented that, this company . Regional officer Patel, is existing & is in operation in this welcomed his Vill.: Palsana, area, since last moae than 25 years. suSgesnon. Ta.: Palsana, we didn't face any problem due to Dist.:surat this company. This company is contributing in social activities and will keep on contributrng in future with this kind of hope he welcomed this company. officet Shri Jhinabhai . He ,eoresented that, I am thanKul Regional his Yogibhai Surti, to this company for organizing this welcomed Vill.: Lingad, Public Hea,ing. He questioned that suggestion. Ta.: Palsana, there are 17 to 18 villages located in CompanYs Dist.: Surat. surroundings, where agriculture representative replied farming is carried out. But these that, Your suggestaon are farmers/Halpati are poor and there welcomed and we will is no facilitv like government houses make all efforts for for them. After working for whole Halpati Awas Yojana, an dav in the farms, they have to sleep whatever possible in open area in the night hours, efforts, planned under facing the p.oblem of air pollution & our CSR activity to be their health is affected. So thev are carried out in next 5 lacking such facility. He also added years oy our company that there is Satrish ganga river in and management. we L village Lingad, where he used to 8o will Sive efforts together I tor bath durins child hood & with our association for I villasers also used to wash their ar,anging for the I clothes, but now days it is not residence of Halpati. J possible, due to bad smell in the river. Steps should be taken, to Drevent bad sm€ll in the rivet, else I company should make provision of I medical facilities in allvillages. 5 Shri Umeshbhai He represented that, people of ReBional officer Patel, middle & lower class are residing in welcomed his Vill.: Vesma, nearby villages i.e. Sisodra, Puni, suSges!on. Ta.: Jalalpor, sandalpor, Vesma and other villages, Dist.: Navsari. who a.e working in this company. This company is helpful to many people in financial and social activity and will also continue their helD in future. Moreover, many years ago there was an incident of leakage in a Bromine bottle, being carried through truck near where he is residing, due to which villagers had faced many difficulties at that time. This company helped us at that time, so this company is admirable. 6 Shri Kanubhai D. He represented that, I know this . Regional office. Rathod, company since last many yea6. welcomed his Vill.: Palsana, Many people at different level are suggestion. Ta.: Palsana, working in this company and earning Dist.:surat. their lively hood. This company also contributing in religious and social activities. So lam welcoming this companv. 7 Shri Sikander . He represented that, company had . Regional officer Pathan, made presentation but 75% of informed that, your Vill.: Ealeshwar, people don't know about the act suSSestions and noted Ta.: Palsana, and rules. so many a times, we had objections will be i5 of Dist.:5urat. carried out agitation against this and if there any case industry but didn't get any result. reve.se boring, bring to Wheneve, we call GPCB to arrive our notice, We assure here fo, inspection, they say that you that will resolve such thev don't have vehicle or officers issues. aJe unavailable and intimates the companv for making all arrangement. We have brought notice ot many bore well to GPCB in which company is disposing their chemical contaminated water into ground. companies are giving slow poison to us by such activity. We are residing here with family. When we file complaint to GPCB or Collector, police comes and brings public into fear, due to which people go away due to fear and company achieves thei. objective. GPCB didn't co- oDerate with us. In past whenever one De,son used to suffer from cancer, whole Taluka used to get the news about that but at Dres€nt 50 cases of cancer are there in my village. All this is due to industries. I strictly oppose this company. Company .elease their polluted water directly without any treatment and release gases at night hours, due to which we are not able to sleeD. 8 Sh ri Patel Company has mentioned location of Regional officer Maheshkumar Palsana village 1.5 km in its informed that, your Fakirbhai, presentation, but not clear, suggestions and Taluka Panchayat whether the distance is shown from objections are noted. (ex) member, Highway or directly from industry, Vill.: galeshwar, because air pollution can spread in Ta.: Palsana, any direction. Dist.: Surat. company has mentioned cost of Rs. 15 lakh for olantation of 350 trees. That means one tree cost around Rs. 4500/-. 8ut according to me 50,000 trees can be planted in Rs. 15 lakh. So wrong details are mentioned here. Company says that they have taken wate, sample from thutpor village. I am member ofTaluka Panchavat but we are not aware about it and no such order has been pasged in the 5 Panchayat. We don't have objection for develooment but it must not be at the cost of people's life. Before giving any permission, people's interest should be taken in to consideration. So development should be done keeping in mind people's interest. Schools are located within 500 to 700 meter radius from this area. ComDanies are withdrawing borewell water by installing motors at 400 feet depth. This is agriculture fruitful area, so care should be taken, that this area does not get affected. Government is providing water storage facility under different yojnas (Projects) but is this for people or the industries ? once there was fire in Veerdev company in Palsana. At that time when we inspected the situation of the Palsana, we found that, higher level people shifted their house from Palsana but there was no arrangement for common people. Please frame the Rules, keeping in mind the interest of public can be maintained. lf people will survive, then there will be develooment. 9 Shri Anwarmiya He represented his written . Reply of the written Amirmiya Sheikh, representation which is attached rePresentation Annexed Vill.: Tarai, with this proceeding as Annexure-C- to the proceeding as Ta.: Palsana, 23. Annexure-D-23. Dist,: Su,at. . He furthel represented that, water bottle kept on the dias is of river Batrish Ganga of our Taraj village. You can see the level of water pollution. 10 smt. Oina Chauhan, . She submitted her written . Reply of the same has Gram Panchayat representation which is attached as been annexed in the Makhinga, Annexure-C-1 in a public hearing proceeding a5 Annexure- Vill.: Makhinga, proceeding. D-1. Ta.: Palsana, . Additionally rep.esented that, Dist.: Surat. industJial development is a necessit, for people now days. 8ut it should be carried out keeping in mind the interest & health of public. Now days people are facing problem of dlsease i.e. cancer, T.8., Asthma. 6 Industry should carry out development according to government rules & regulation There is no air pollution in our village but it can spread thJough air in any direction. . There are no primary tools in our villages. There is school for students but no park to play, no equipment to play, whole village is free from open toilet, but it is not utilized b! all people. So awareness program should be conducted, so that people can make use of it. 11 Shri Harendrasinh He represented that, company Regional officer welcomed Gohil, Principal, D. always co-operate in many activities the suggestion. 8. High school i.e. education activitv, Health Palsana, activity. Computer facility was Vill: Palsana, provided befo.e 3 years by this Ta: Palsana, company and helped the school for Dist: Surat constructing computer lab and R.O. Plant has been installed for d,inking water. For provision of science stream, this company oltered fund for development of science st.eam, so that students would not remain unaware of science knowledge. Institute helped to develop chemistry lab, physics lab and biology lab. To .esolve the problem of dropout ratio of Gujarat Government which is increasing now a days? NGO named Somya Sathi was established and 10th -12'h failed students are given training to develop their skill by this NGO. This company should carry out development and control pollution. T2 Shri Ashishkumar He represented that, I am 52 years Regional officer welcomed JashubhaiDesai, old and this company is in operation the suggestion. Vill: Palsana, since more than 25 years. This Ta: Palsana, company is livelihood for the Dist:surat villagers of Palsana and of nearby villages. This company carries out social activity in the Palsana village, so this company can be said as role model for other comDanies. This company is also ready to work in the other villages, whenever required, so I am welcoming this company. J Shri Hemantbhai . He represented in written which is . Reply of the written DahyabhaiPatel, included in the proceedinS as representation are Paryavaran Bachav Annexure C-24 annexed in proceeding Samitee, as Annexure D-24 Ta: Palsana, Dist: Su.at L4 Shri Pareshbhai He represented that, there are two Regional officer Maisuriya, Deputy sides of Palsana, one is we need informed that, your Sarpanch, Gram development and other is pollution suggesqons ano Panchayat Palsana, is also increasing with development. objections are noted. At & Ta: Palsana, Biggest problem is Government Dist: Surat Officers i.e. GPC8, Collector, etc. So my rePresentation is for those people, who are selling land. Industries are establishing today and will establish in future also. As villagers need money. Actually villagers should not sell land to industries so that this industries can not be established here. GPCB has never provided any facility to Palsana. No primary treatment is carried out by the units located in Palsana and Baleshwa/s dyeing mills. GPCS have not taken care of the same and waste water is directly sent to ctTP. Also GPCE doesn',t take care of CETP ope.ation/process. The sample of water taken from Taraj Khadi is presented by the person ofTaraj. Pollution has been increasin& for which you can check PHC'S data. oisease caused before 5 year has been increased up to 15-20%. lt means that people of Palsana village are physically challenged. Today pollution has been increased and farming has been decreased. we are opposing the industries from earlier point of time and we will keep opposing in future also. GPCg should take strict actions against incoming parks & industries. Air monitoring system is not provided in this area. Industries are releasing gases at any time. Nobody is listening to our complaint so to whom complaint is to be made? Our region is known as greenbelt region but no industries have taken 8 steps for development of the greenbelt. 6reen belt is very important, if there will be no green belt, there will be no reason for us to complaint. Such area should be developed, where there would be only green belt. Borewell of 50% farmers are not working due to lack of water. We have done mistake but vou have authority to take action on company and co-oDerate with us. So that we can develop Nirmal village and help us in providinS benefit of Government policies. Two bore wells of Palsana Gram Panchayat are not working. Underground water is available at deDth of 400 ft. ln which the level of COD and BOD is very high, due to which it cannot be used for drinking purpose. Industries are beneficial for us because nearby villagers are getting livelihood from it. lt is our representation that proper care and all necessary action should be taken for protection of environment, otherwise we will have to leave this place and migrate to other place after some time. When the accident of fire occurred in Veerdev company villagers had to vacated the whole area. But nobodv had lnowledge that what next steps are required to be taken. After that the situation was controlled with the co-operation of company. lt is our suggestion that air monitorinS system should be installed, guidelines regarding fruitfulness of land and training of other facilities should be imparted. You should take care whatever required and we are ready to provide co-operation for the same. Shri Mohmmad . He represented that, we don't have . Regional Officer BilalShailh, any objection with this Public informed that, your Ex. Sarpanch, Hearing but NA procedure ca.ried sugSestions and Vill: Baleshwar, out is not proper.50 % document objections are noted. Ta: Palsana, attached fo. NA orocedure are not 9 Dist: Surat authentic. Rajhans group is Soing to establish a textile park at Ealeshwar, which has acquired Government roads and land. Complaint for the same was made to Collector. Gujarat Government sent letter to colledor to cancel the NA procedure, if it is not legal. Mamlatdar reported in this matter that units have alreadv I started operation in this park and nothing as mentioned prevails. I have record reDort ot Baleshwar Talati cum Mantri that no units are going to operate in this area. Government officers are involved in this matte. and dyeing unit has not obtained permission. Collector during earlier Public Hearing ordered to stop the four units of eco textile park on basis of our representation. Water is released into ground through the motor of thousands of watts. GPCB was informed many times for the same but it did not take any action. GPCB must remain active in this matter. lf GPCS does not take anv action, problem will not be resolved. Public Hearing will be conducted as per rules but procedure which is requi,ed to be carried out as per Government rules and regulation are not ca.ried out accordingly. Baleshwar river is encroached by the company which can be inspected by you. No rules are followed for drainage line in this Khadi. No cases of violation of rule are registered in Taluka and if registered and forwarded to collector and DDO, they do not hear to the public. No officer in Taluka office or Mamlatdar office is performing their work . 16 Shri Sadik Gulam He represented that, this company . Regional Office, Mohammad is in operation since last 27 years. welcomed his Parekh, This company after expansion suggestiOn. Vill: Baleshwar, should follow the Government .ules Ta: Palsana, and rcgulations and install latest Dist: Surat equipments of environment & must 10 have desire to operate it efficientlv, so that the interest of the people can be maintained. t7 ShriEbrahim Musa . He regresented that, I have made . Regional Officer Patel. many applications in last 15 years informed that, your Ex. Sarpanch, and also displayed on Surat Channel, suggestions and Vill: Samrod, while standing into river water. Our objections are noted. Ta: Palsana, Samrod village is located on bank of Dist:5urat river. River water passes from nearby village & it is difficult to stand nearby due to bad smell. In the morninS, polluted water smells due to which people having breathing/respiratory diseases and can not come out of their houses and at that time if we inform authority, they don't take an, acton. 18 Shri Bhairav . He rep,esented that, I am 31 years Regional Officer Panchal, old and lam residing here for 31 informed that, your Vill: Palsana, yea.s and have studied f,om MS objections are noted. Ta: Palsana, Unrversity. lam pursuing final year Dist: surat of CA. I have completed my industrial traininS from this company. When you were awa,e that industries are €oing to establish here, then why did you sell out your land to them? 19 Shri Sikander He represented that, we don't have Regional Officer Pathan, problem with development but we informed that, necessary Vill.: Baleshwar, have Droblem with destruction. We actions are taken. Ta.: Palsana, have made march against pollution Dist.r Su,at. but there was no effect of it. We have caught water tanker many a times to prevent pollution and once we caught water tanker and parked it into eco gark and then informed Police Station, GPCB and Collector by phone but they shifted the liabilitv to each other and then we ourselves locked the gate. Thereafter I went there and took half bottle of polluted water from it, and at that time 20-25 people were there who were not able to breath but there was no outcome of it and no action was taken on it. It is my demand that offlce of GPCB should be shifted to Palsana from Surat. lf GPCB requires place then 11 we can provide the place in Baleshwar and we will co-oDerate. 20 Sh ri Patcl He stated that, those who Regional Officer Mahe5hkumar represented here, out of them many informed that, your Fakirbhai, people rep.esented in favour of objections a.e noted. Member of Taluka company, so bio-data of such Panchayat, persons should be collected and Vill.: Ealeshwar, investigation should be carried out Ta.: Palsana, re8arding what benefits they have Dist.: Surat. obtained from this company. In addition to this bio-data of people who represented against should also be collected. There should be a development but not at the cost of people. Earlier principal of a school represented here that this company has helDed his school but in this area, there are other more educational institutes of muslim trust, christian trust and others. So rules must be eoual for all. 21 Shri Hemantbhai He represented that, Block No 346 is Regional Officer DahyabhaiPatel, besides NH-8. That place must be informed that, your Paryavaran Eachav selected and GPCS and disaster objections are noted. Samitee, management office should be Ta: Pal5ana, established there. Dist:5urat 22 Shri Kaushikkumar . He presented his representation . Reply of the same has Manubhai Patel, which is included in proceeding as been included in the Vill: Ealeshwar, Annexure C-13. proceeding as Annexure Ta: Palsana, D-13. Dist: Su.at 23 Shri Sanjaykumar He represented that, Muslims of Regional Officer Desai, Baleshwar, ltadwa are mv friends. informed that, your GeneralSecretary, This meeting is conducted for objections are noted. Vishwa Hindu Spectrum Company. Your Parishad, representations are .egarding Eco- Vice President of textile park. People of this area have Bairang Dal, suffered loss due to Eco textile park. Ta: Palsana, Spectrum Dves and Chemical Dist: Surat company is first company in Palsana which has completed 28 years. I know the company since 28 years. I have worked for 22 years in multinational company. No person of my house is working in this company. We didn't need job. Company uses pipes of good quality and waste water of company is sent to CETP through it. CETP runs in A, g and C shifts, and if the CETP'5 12 emptoyees are not presented there then it may be considered thar company releases theiJ polluteo wate. without treatment. lf there rs any loss due to this chemical comp?n, then glve me in writing, 24 Shri Bismillahkhan He represented that, two persons of Regional Officer Pathan, Baleshwar died in Eco park. We info.med that actions Vill: Baleshwar, / caught two tankers of illegal actavities are carried out Ta: Palsana, chemical waste and made a according to procedure Dist: Surat complaint to GPCB and police, but ser up. polace came and took us into fear and everybody raised their hand, then we went with the Sarpanch and locked it. tam calling 10-20 times daily to Rathod sir of GPCB regarding this. He is the only officer of GPCB who pick up the call and no other person at GPCB pick up call. tf there is objection, companv should stop so that we know that justice has been served to us. peoole set affected by diseases and dies. So action should be taken regarding this. We have shown presence of bad odour to a person at 3 o'clock at night. 5-6 vehicles full of people of that person reached to Dolice stataon and PSI came to us and said to leave that person. Then I denied to leave him then after police took him to police station and released that Derson. 25 Shri Thakorbhai He .epresented that, mV fa,m is Regional Officer GopalbhaiPatel, beside the CETP plant. Flying ash informed that, your Vill: lsaroli, falls on t.ees of my farm. I can show objections are noted. Ta: Palsana, you that at this time trees of my Dist: Surat farm have turned black. There are four mango trees, two saga trees, and two guava trees. gardoli sugar factory is located in the center of the city but there is no complaint of that companv so far now. 26 Shri Yusuf He represented that, this company . Regional Officer Mohammad which is in operation since last 25 informed that, yodr Mankda, Member years, there are benefits by the objections are noted. Baleshwar Gram company but losses are mo.e than Panchayat, benefits. The proposed project Ta: Palsana, which is going in start should not be Dist: Surat permitted because it will cause heavy loss to nearby villages. Water released in to nearby Khadi are polluted due to which canal water cannot be used for farming or for drinking purpose. lt is my request that this company should not be oermatted. Shri R.V.Patel, Regional Officer, GpC8, Surat informed to the people present, to ast the questions or grve suggestions related to projed, if anv. public He further informed that, Before the HearinS, the Soard has received totat (25) written representations panchayat from others i.e. (1). Gram Makhinga, Sarpanchshri, At. Makhinga, Ta. panchayat Palsana, Oist. Surat, (2). Gram ttalva, At & po. ltalva, Ta. palsana, Dist: Surat, (3). Palsana Gram palsana, palsana, Panchayat, At. Ta. Dist: Surat (4). Gram panchayat Baleshwar, Ta. Palsana, (5). paryavaran Dist: Surat Shri B.M.patel, Seva & Charitable Trust, 2m, GIDC, Pandesara, pandya, paryavaran Surat {5). Mr. Mahesh Mitra, Thaltej, Ahmedabad, (7). Shri Tejash P. palsana, Oesai & Shri Pantajbhai Desai, At. (8). Shri Rohan Ahir, Vill: palsana, (9). Sh.i Ashish Vilaniya, Vill: Palsana, (10). shri Manish Mahadevwala, Vill: Bardoli, (11). Shri Rahul Puranik, Vill: Palsana, (12). Shri Mehul Dhimmar, Vi ; palsana, (13). Shri (aushik Manubhai patel, yogesh p. pandya, Vill: Baleshwar, (14). Mr. Saf€ty Health and Environment Association, Bharuch, (15). Shri Dharmesh Mistry, Bharuch, (16). Shri Manish B. patet, Vill: Gangpur, (17). Shri yagnik Patel, Vill: Eardoli, Dist: Surat (18). Shri Tushar surati, Vill: Baleshwar, (19). Shri yatin Ahir, Vill: Palsana, {20}. Shri Pranav Shukla, Vill: palsana, (21}. Smt. Sudhaben Hemantbhai Desai, Member of Taluka Panchayat, Palsana, Oist.: Surat, At & p.o. Baleshwar, Ta.: palsana, Dist,: Surat (22). Baleshwar lsh.oli Group Gram Panchayat (23). Shri Anwarmiya Sheikh, Vill.: Taraj, (24). Shri Hemantbhai Dahyabhai Patel, paryavaran Bachav Samitee, Ta: palsana And (25). Shri Ebrahim Musa Patel, Ex. Sarpanch, Vill: Samrod. These rep.esentations and replies given by the project proponent will be covered in proceeding. The .epresentation made in today,s public hearing and the reply of the same given by the project proponent will be covered in proceedings too. Video recording of the representation done in today's public hearing and prepared minutes will be forwarded to concerned authority for the permission of expansion ofcompany. Shri R. V. Patel, Regional Officer, GPCS, Surat summarized the conclusion of the public hearinL and with the due permission ofthe Chairman concluded with vote ofthanks. -.'<'t-----z-"--.'' Place: Palsana, R. wV. Patel s.(msiAifA=)\ tcAsl Ta: Palsana RsgionalOfficor, R63idential Additional Collsctor Dist.: Surat GPCB, Suraq and Date:25/0512018 Additional Dbtrici Iagisirai€, Surat 14 di.ar-dl r rqrsildlr c s uatqdl er0{a oryr cigl srl rt grqr{i r,ndet {qr.,m ui qrvenat ufaRft ct?r utqql{i qtiei gqrq a{?.t tt?3r.?du uafcr$ aa ui vocnq qQqd.t rieLcr?r, adl 4c{t u tr&edru sdg, Art.ri. 1q33(t ) ctt. \a/oe/?oos r4i iat qdl"tt {tuu. s{[s, rlt{.r, . :oso (rt) Cl. qe.dl qlct, utlQts q|Usrfl, cJn?td gQugr A?iaq a1S, gt<, {orr uQ.n{I, cjrrta qlS ulqE A?iaq "u uRRO als qaregftri 6q(Aa di r,uqsrarl r,ri 6.r{0.4. .{la[g]er"r lia:la fifitl i.crqulurl. ui cis gateq0 uGqt drl uGd qrr{I. ir{Q dS (et o{r als q .qte<,(e i{qf qtarar{ldl rtq"tc0ell cds {atqq0al utior stcn{l r,nlet. ir,rlrl \rR?trcraLsni ixdl gQa qRqler"u Qrl N{As ottqtri xrGd rq seet tgtQcr. lnd +Qsgr sttla rl+ }r{sc.tt ur. [d., "tt lrfaan cret iqdl" qRqq r,{r\an one i.qar )gRsct cer ''{Qds"n"{l qGR, uRh[i iq}w,6dn€or ic]dl )g"ftsct '{GR, urcae r{!.a qRqfvatell ual <1t q"ueq{t t?re{.ct €t!? ate alsf 6trt rlo'rrri eg src{t{i qrQc( uizcrituzludzrictcrr i{r r,rrrerr"r. URRO snt r{qqr{i i{Qer uq 2 ?! sr"[?"j 1A "ul{ iq"0.d ufaao (ar qa {?.tlt rguta sla 5au1 urul< u 4 ?! 5?"u?"j 5l{ lel "tt!r iqdlai uh0lq dl ?Vr{d slct tsrorf r,(a {?"ttt uul< u.gar '{Jtaii aq. Qorl. 46t al dq"[lu atl {o{ti qtqt cul-crrr e 5 iqdlaL ufiR0 ort lA a! s?"t?'j "ttr{ 3r{ ?!R4rd slct lar, t,ra rr?"ttt Urqtaq ug C dl ula rrdrLg rrLr i,{44 i{"rL lu"}eLaq( uc{{tqu utdQls qQsrflr0i !flra(tJ, qrrt rurr{lctt ctt{i iIrJ OC{L Uftur+ 3 q4{ 4'{r{ euori s1u4er d{ 8 td ?! e?d?"j .tt{ 3q"0ai ulaoo (trt 5{ ?vqr 9 tlA a! s?"u?.i .tt{ !ir{"(lai ulaacq 6trt 5{ rgrlra rlct r1arr, ui urar{ qqraq uqd? 1X r{l ,{lera{td iq$ s'+rqi !; qau$"u d ,aB4 vtlGls qQgr{b{ld flq{lar. }. nr{u, D, ii Qs rl..i B ! r,nqgi urtR vquqi !. r,uu"j qua 1t{ {rrtqd At A rla onv A{ e }; ucLlidl r{a qiur"{l alu r{a{tgr, {ra uQqqt {ocj 0. {lar|{i {la ctrcrLqi qLQcr 0. ct. : UA $t, agc05 nrstfl r,r[igr{l{f B. 8{ }; 9. rj?d u.{l.r0.o{t. ras??tft critl, *€ll qr{ rgr,ua rl cilsli E 6a1cl qLt rrqil {i orldurqi qqr r,tLqel }l{ ! cutr4i cigli iQa{dl r4r 0. ulue cttxai c sfi v{l"r r .t rr1,4d[ Adi. 8:lt ottcn GU] a qtd. titei{ {dl ctLa Q 0 } p.{l.dl.o{L{ qctrtLqti sloqgt gQuL r,nQa qa{tqt, uste"{l "i€ll. <,rclqr{i *ecaL stdrt gRa E, s}s sr6ct rJRzrri vt.lq{l flaq.e etc{l adl. i"j u.{l.dl.(,{l.a qt4 ?tqe d{1, ielt u'qtt dl{ dl.o.dt.{I. { tta{ ori r{l.o.dt.rll.ri { ulilu ate{ i qq u.r.ll.dl.o0. tzn"r rt',{.([ arlt, f {)at l}r.lct r,t}u?t .t?tt"( a(6r{lA l,{til"r qrgfii erua qtQer D. aaq o{g uQur+ erLq 0 } rlsqte {l.drr.d[. r,rissL auLdl Eu1 ] r,(qrrll ,{i{ (q) cr{ qAc{ i Ar( rr.tr oar i r-Icr rq rll eo qr+t qtul Ett rrqr 0. Q"rl 4d aql ata ! uaur;tr atgsL"n cdrl at{ fli qlctar qtJ rteu 0. utti utqg 10 tqf ?!i s?.tt?!i ctp{ iq'(idi UCaOO atrt tq ryura sla 1atu1 ura rr?'{tt uurla uc1ar adl. r,rdl i sit \usl ! Galcit r,ncrat 6lar i.at qr sssqi gss qrrad c.. rtLf oqt {1"0a{ct dlteq sfo qrcerLrl a:ll. ctl ctLi crl i Galcit{i€ll grusr "0sd 0. !{ette sarl ut l slu rdartn.j ddl af urxLl lac0cne !{aue sedlt r,r{r-i Ar.u? cJlarlced sEcta, r,ti cJtadce qte sdq sl6 Gafrl slrJ ,{Jrad c{lt{ a€I[. cJtaQca en{ E steq 3 A d.tA €la < ra{tl g{lqte seqti s-I6 sr?q qr aA riit. r,nrel rlql Qrrur 3qc q sr1 l teri oJlaQce qr olq. uoz Q5a1at qq0at qfe du sro crqt D ql qci sA 0 ,{qr aufl qLl !ac0 rrrn 0 } !u"0 q? qJrai ctO r,tt{li r{rE tG3r.? r,tLql } f€ll l,rl Rr{q rurr <,r"rdlA qi ne st r at ql.9rat1.d..ll atcr rAqrqL. qett{tq[ c1r{ riruaradt ct Q q]t <,itr B. xoo-xoo ga Gstorl uLqft t{ar B r,(i idl uier dl.r,rl.{. r,ri <,{I.uil.fl. qd qtue'I "0 {tat{i d I r{lqt c.tters aell. Galcil rl{nt rt) arcretas E strg ! Q Orlq 3 q"0ri qrarl qtcr c-ncl.ct crtl cnq4i crlsf{ fiutr wc,{l 11 tlA ?! s?.ur"i .ttt{ iq"{lai uRalo ctrr g\ rgura sla rjad {a r|a4rt uurla uqar srtdal udl ti st:i R"j s16a i6qqt s?qi uaa a o.j utjl u{(&[i ua 6a]oit a {dla rgrlc{left urcr ue stcl sla. uut! sBri A B ! 12 tA ?! s?"tt?"j "u{ iu.{lai u[iR0 ctrt 5){ rgura rla 5etu1 ua rte"ut urula u u.,1l.t{l.o{t. "0 ulQn qraxi adl qgt qa(tRrqi :uq s?qrqi {a 14 rJA ?t s?.n?"i .u{ iq"0+i u[aR(U srrL 3t{ ?Vr,ttd 3la {qr,{l r,{a {?"(tt uurla uqar idl '{rfl {ct d. fr v.llt.dl.o{l.i rcan4 cr?e olq of qf frtrrl. ?1 r0 E{aantl i'{Q sqtqi }, <, 15 tA ?t s?.it?"j .[r{ Sqdlai uRRfq clrr 3{ rp,ua rlct laRi ul ut.ui urul'ei uqae to, Cqulu(, s{ i osl laet6c-r rntdl d. iate.ll 16 tEf ?V s?"u?"j "{r{ iq"0ai ufaho 6trt 5{ ?liqrd gla {qrql ua a"{ri uutLa uq RrQ cgri vgt.r3 !, cis q 71 oer.(^qt, dr. qalttgl., (3 li(.ttnr+t sJtq qctt{.gu., ) riqtq<, cttq, (u) qtl{ {qtqct, otaqt. cu, qc.u{rBr. ('{) c,{1. dl. Qrr. ulct, ualcrgt lqt {.s lfl)<,tcr ?€, u.r,{ut.gl.r{1. ui3nrL, ge<, (9) r{l t{AQr risau, qarlq?q qqerqr€, fda, Ec-tiqr, (o) r{l icret {1. }t(t r4a ,{l {scra{6 dutJ, cttq, qc{tnr+r, (.) {l e-Iea ?adta, rrq : qctruqr, (e ) r{l qr6-tq [dc.ttq0ar, crrr, uc.trtgt, (ro) r{l {dlq {ottqqctt, qteslc,{I, (rr) r{l eqa grtfQr, cu4: r{arrtB[, (1?) rt qgc_( dl4?, c({: qcttngr, (r3 } ,{l slGts {"Ja{tt q)a! ru{ c{aa?, dt. : qcr qr, U. g?.t (1x) ,0 qlr}l {L rise{, lgd[ ica Q.s d. 3[r( @i4/' tllq: : \C{tulitl., r{r.dl.U}q 4af5Kttttll-l6.i ir( ), qc(tt{tgtt, ctt. utCRs raQsL{I, U.{1.r0.0{1., Rqtdl r,r[0g gdrae r,ri Uc 18 Gujarat Pollution Control Board Regional Office, Belgium Square, Silver Plaza Complex, Opp. Linear Bus Stand, Ring Road, Surat -395 003 Website: www.gpcb.gov.in Annexure-C A statement showing response and comments received in written format from other concerned persons in the Environment aspects for M/s. SPECTRUM DYES AND CHEMICALS PVT. LTD., for Proposed Expansion of SO Dyes -900 MT/Month, Dispersing Agent -1500 MT/Month Or Formulated SO Dyes -2400 MT/Month and Dyes Intermediate – 750 MT/Month, plant located at Block No. 484, 502, 503, A, 504 and 505, NH-8, Palsana, Ta. Palsana, Dist. Surat (Gujarat), The Public Hearing held on 25/05/2018 at 11.00 hrs. At Late Shree Chhotubhai Dayalji Desai Hall, Behind Post Office, Palsana Main Road, Vill: Palsana, Ta. Palsana, Dist: Surat (Gujarat), as per the Ministry of Environment and Forests, Government of India, New Delhi vide its notification no. S.O. 1533 dated 14/09/2006. Comments received in writing from Concerned Sr No Annexure Persons Gram Panchayat Makhinga, 1 C-1 Sarpanchshri, At. Makhinga, Ta. Palsana, Dist. Surat Gram Panchayat Italva, 2 C-2 At & Po. Italva, Ta. Palsana, Dist: Surat Palsana Gram Panchayat, 3 Sarpanch, Shri P.P. Ahir, C-3 At. Palsana, Ta. Palsana, Dist: Surat Gram PanchayatBaleshwar, 4 C-4 At. Baleshwar, Ta. Palsana, Dist: Surat Shri B.M.Patel, Paryavaran Seva & Charitable Trust, 5 C-5 11, 1st Floor, Service Complex, P.No. 200, GIDC, Pandesara, Surat Mr. Mahesh Pandya, Paryavaran Mitra, 502, Raj Avenue, Bhaikaka Nagar Road, Nr. Thaltej 6 C-6 Cross Road, Thaltej, Ahmedabad Gujarat Pollution Control Board Regional Office, Belgium Square, Silver Plaza Complex, Opp. Linear Bus Stand, Ring Road, Surat -395 003 Website: www.gpcb.gov.in Shri Tejash P. Desai & Shri Pankajbhai Desai, 7 C-7 At. Palsana, Ta. Palsana, Dist : Surat Shri Rohan Ahir, 8 C-8 Vill: Palsana, Ta: Palsana, Dist: Surat Shri Ashish Vilani, 9 C-9 Vill: Palsana, Ta: Palsana, Dist: Surat Shri Manish Mahadevwala, 10 C-10 Vill: Bardoli, Dist: Surat Shri Rahul Puranik, 11 C-11 Vill: Palsana, Ta: Palsana, Dist: Surat Shri Mehul Dhimmar, 12 C-12 Vill: Palsana, Ta: Palsana, Dist: Surat Shri Kaushik Manubhai Patel, 13 C-13 Vill: Baleshwar, Ta: Palsana, Dist: Surat Mr. Yogesh P. Pandya, Safety Health and Environment Association 14 C-14 208, Vadilonu Ghar Shopping, Complex Kasak Fuwara, Bharuch Shri Dharmesh Mistry, 15 Block No. 14, House No. 1340, Narmada C-15 Appartment, Opp. Mamaltdar Office, Dist. Bharuch Shri Manish B. Patel, 16 C-16 Vill: Gangpur, Ta: Palsana, Dist: Surat Shri Yagnik Patel, 17 C-17 Vill: Bardoli, Dist: Surat Shri Tushar Surati, 18 C-18 Vill: Baleshwar, Ta: Palsana, Dist: Surat Shri Yatin Ahir, 19 C-19 Vill: Palsana, Ta: Palsana, Dist: Surat Shri Pranav Shukla, 20 C-20 Vill: Palsana, Ta: Palsana, Dist: Surat Gujarat Pollution Control Board Regional Office, Belgium Square, Silver Plaza Complex, Opp. Linear Bus Stand, Ring Road, Surat -395 003 Website: www.gpcb.gov.in Smt. Sudhaben Hemantbhai Desai, 21 Member of Taluka Panchayat, Palsana, Dist.: Surat C-21 At & P.o. Baleshwar, Ta.: Palsana, Dist.: Surat 22 Baleshwar Ishroli Group Gram Panchayat C-22 Shri Anwarmiya Amirmiya Sheikh, 23 C-23 Vill.: Taraj, Ta.: Palsana,Dist.: Surat. Shri Hemantbhai Dahyabhai Patel, 24 Paryavaran Bachav Samitee, C-24 Ta: Palsana, Dist: Surat Shri Ebrahim Musa Patel 25 C-25 Ex. Sarpanch, Vill: Samrod,Ta: Palsana,Dist: Surat 6t C;rP c .t\rn l. tl ,rn ll:q ulcr" uoareu' 1. t DJFI. .iw.rcr rut(lau g. gr o,. oz \c ANNEXURE.Cl- o51$rr lgurr \'rdrrur urs {rr\.rer:l 3..r"r .oirL<\"rsre- .+r.tt. Rrt*r l- lr-rei ailapt .srBoc o.Q<, 3gr'gt+t ffJ;--;..15- -4 .', 'o17oi7aot< {... e.d. "i"i"rO,ia,"'- t51oo11 "tt'R:q "'r'q'rr ,IT "2 L!?- aJrq. .ieirqa rurrflau U.Si"t*.xlt "z ficn rr€srr a€l &rrrr .i* .1..- r4il.'fr."ril qu:Qa. g1E.r-r:Q c'Pcis eg'ar'-p*/ *r,.-,'*; HlH. T*-.- "-'"1 "r*'i1 ]i;*tq' Q za{ , .rot1 g{ .,ts.^, arrltr . lre eur >gq {\ \rt€,q aqrr t\s crrr+l rr\ oo.*.I\ . I La.: sn arr\:r .i .srd aeuq L*- a\ "naL oQ qrfiJlPf,*i.*' i-t-r*on^'6z{ter.$r'r' -qct\strtc\-^ cH ts\e-r:l{'s\u{-1';:;_;: *l}1 j:'r]}.a-.t arrr .figl1 fi'r i^.* Lg-ol t}rrt\"n etq q^"L +rrsrac,i\.{ f\\Llq .i ' "{\f\ dAt'ldt e?6 ITO"T- €"rl rlGr{ -.2A\ d-* Le.cJ rn-rl ui .A\€rs){ Ut i- €Ja\(*"$rl fq+t|r+ a)€1'$ $taurr $re4 4-€'\q ^{ a-"sr'{ ^ gl.r .-.?. 'r1 antrG-ro Cutrtl rAr alg crl\c-t- "$r'8tt:il.rl (9rJ { -t ',nt"1 4it1:r't d9^\ .*-ail a{, *Tti' ",*t 99i tq. *f' *'-J 5,n--a{suz, "q *',.ni'J"L31i't'J''*,' 4 ;;r an.q''Q *T ,""j 2). a t*;;i,^_*+1{ .-s..i*1: - 'Is{ ta,"l],.J,1r^' #l ifl'-l;*"-5"e"r ,'a ' fGh-' -q 'i6q 'zT "t4'l il34 ggttos O-rrd- c'+ t-''a ort ,a.rf a:r r { -ts.tq *.'o"f[ a,rtr.s{\*r s\aq *q;:t "*; e'""r'\ *,..1 -_'-b-;.i5"r.'el Lc,.D i"*., arl\q *.q 9-rer Yf l.,F1f * -ri*.:-,r\r-{ rtof\ )zfq e*"tt :E]i^:]:j4 c-tas '"'i ""'i 4 {i*'l: 6'^;;- "t'o'o{ 'f) oucr anr\41-^ Lqg: 'aqr .Ie r{ ;' qd atax srl Fotr ez' "r] e&'ha- a-rurg ,,ur*&^;'f -Eb4 ^4 -E{':t DJtrt duercr nur,fl,cu $.T#tf,f1li Y licr aesrr ordl 6unr I dt. rrs3rqf 11. ur,flcq rL ---$-.ffi-.'iL ,." ioTLfl-,1l:"l .e-Er? "I't..,f:lr.,Fl ..[t]rr €'L\'urr''t -. crl L'\ '.\r{ Sal$J€c{ a*.{.*ri\{ ' ar6\:ra1\u> *'e"l -@Y tfn^ -'**':F ^ n^r...,-\\\L' ...' -gb+"-.+1 tf"l (1"t"tlqi'rttu{t*' >a''\\ -T.l 'lL 'aflefiffifl ;@*,.*..*'err, u' Br: - JII dr{lrr: .i.ci,*.ri\-'ti6t,.' . - \a\s ANNEXURE.C2 $i* \\aii\\a-.--:,-,.,.*-Y* 'i.'oo"'f.+n,:- roti -:-\ur -,.s' .)$]ifiS.r- 'Yr't'{ -\ s!1'$U{l - ia NQt\ r\\s\ osr"t\- - ' $\+Jtr{+rn \ :>1r iE3r1 '^X:**:*'i:"1 " #*i. i::l *ll *.*'*"*' - ;-' ;"-*** "\-:Y':;*"t t' zrrre.1;-. .^$u.g\q ;:t\\b €-8\ *\l;- *a Et{s "FB\ "i 'Adr\ -cr\: S+r .r'. rr\q\ 1\A$\ut\n. ar.qe{rgrr,R. ttc X(""r : | )t^ iitditdfr,6it'; g.u'|. derocr, dr. qc{ MYjLg {.61, -GS.., pl_ Nt ffi:::\.i3.lu*.rsr8.( rirrt8 'r / Rc SB"r{ ar'-lrt}e ' sigel ll ofiqrB i\t+Lar q q\-\q,\ \r\,lr$ A- \l ^ l^ ^..,q.O- 1fl* i:.r: - o^i 11"'1 :::1il;1.*:-*1;i' :llr':,i;i; c;'-#*,=..J--d"'':l ss..'.''*' :''o1\ ;.. ;.;;. :X.*" i"n a^4 i"'G'1-..l:".4 Q'q^ t1.'..;:*'-.:-:''-' rrrc-'l *'*1.. ;: --"t\o'o'a'o.t*' &{ 15{q6.1reQ f TL"*s;' fr":h"":l ;l \ .*xk' s\1 ;, ;il ta'.."^i s.....r,r;q t',-.oi}.r i ' su-Ne^tr. q"tl . c.re*ri..i ^.,=!\ a*, l*. J ry::::J11.re ;S'. -.,[.:'.;ln;.' *"1 '-*3-64t" ''* €.tlztql au.t-rD' t ?)or di. : orgra - ittlot aM g.u). rlgtoct, dr. u({arsrt, U. grd -j:l_::q 'r4 -t6e.ir (o L\+ ara- {. ol. rE*qr\\ bts\\ tLq\ c{ .r-Aa t\\\ oQ..t 1-r\ rrrl:t as\\sr- tr-i.€- -rr ;'s'* ad=r"+\ .,-? <-\\ 's"1\ or\t""'g \A*\-e-l "rr\t-\ 5rbcr ru a^R*\\ !a\rr €suN\i Cfe'rlt: q \Ar1 eqr.rrl\. "le.r-f rrr\ t$8\tl .\rrrer\ aA,r ^-r-Bf e€.+\--\ 6rra\\Lq . . qe-crtl t r-rar"'-t, a6) ocr$ dg\ ela\tJ 6:trr\t^rr\ lG trr:r c-r{eri^1.\ atlSa"{1 .r$,c'\ r'rr'r'(\ ' b:t.err \-a I e!\\'l-\ lie-er',:1 io tr 8{) rA\ --\t^r\ iS*.rff8 , -r-".. i arr"-rr\cl Cr-r<\ :rrGr\ .tr a^lq Qlit$cr. rrr\{ s\\ {_\\\ t-< .\\ a\rr N+ u.a. .r^.Q Fur' r y1k?- lo'f^ 19' +1lc 3 fta ssr afrGn PAISAIIA G RAM PAi{CHAYAT \u et $ | et I aJ rt ri?t tud GUJARAT STATE tqrr|(| $! At. Po. Palsana g.u). ucaren, Ta. Palsana. Dist Surat a. ucrarerr, l?. i Yl4l a\'rOo <(,r adlu ,) Y K,t r) }tti,il. ANNEXURE€ 3 ,t. uL"tir: !.{[\5r::l'il, :lz;-t.t \tc'tlt't t7tct 6tt'. n?-i1. ' cr'lriD g oe'tE tE r{:,t+r{ },{!?\ !tti} r,t-s it\s qttit.tl 1. ndsr):l tt?ilt -ii t{:t.t :,t1t1l t}.tr-.tl rq1. }tL ?,. +q3?,r st6u ,ii's jt\sett't'L R'ii rqtFts att'{t ut\qt. 3. +t5e\ sL6:r li'l it\seiril rtSut '',[-'tsc+r \. +\5a\ ltdr ",t'l ti qr'tt ':arLz't "tl ii'gir'tLlu'it !'!\4/A8.D Na. -- 131e-q Date : '101< lrf _ G.PC 5CI\RD, SURAT. .r-.R rcl;n PATSAIIA GRAM PA}ICHAYAT uc{tilQil aJtd ti?rrud At Po. Palsana Ta. Palsana, Dist. Surat 3.v). u<.rarerr, or. u PALSAI{A GRAM PANCHAYAT^UC{fl lqll ajlal uulud GUJARA? SfATE g"rkr At. Po. Palsana ar. icraten, grc Ta. Palsana, Dist. Surat li. at{lq: Jiit -ils0t dtt$rae 4 tz.dt7,t rtdr i.'s sftsc"tt 'ti {'tsPtttt {q{ di i 'tD i,tt'{dl. tt?{qt it \l[i.t:l jLft qtt{ q.j.1r1g?{ ttti:r .,t-l l&.scq1'ti r':.'{"t zrat ot@."rtti Rft 2n't't'1 G\.1r--rqn GUJARAT STATE g.r d t1 AT. & Po. BALESWA& ' !.q Ta. Palssna, Dist, Su.at or. u< |1.1 I,/ a.;:l'il ii: _1lll3o ---- ..,:+::_lp |SJl-k--- iil, a.Pi 1:',' r." SliiAT. ffi,,,r {drda reRl ETfi {EsI{ AtE GBR llL[F,Il' r,f lfillll tJrrircii aJFt ri?flud GUJARAT STATE gqr?rd l|mr rll' AT. & Po. BALESWA& |l' dc:lai Ta. Palsana' oisl. Sural ar. ucrarerr, li. ar{lu : --...- fQ"t.1 d'{qs' 9l aisa-q -st.t6-r5l 6,r.raiat.fl Br-4 a.'6-{ a,,t'r"4. a{i ;tig$ errQ.{ aerQt'e J,wr^i an"tll^ a-4s< al .tr ef6< rJffi'*l'tr cc.Q I N6et ec :: "=ffT*''3*:S !62rl I .tl ;p{5qe1 srJrc dr* G(btst'tr €raurv6 ^Q+tel gxlal- srE'cre"-0 htr;; J;i-a",ris"fi '+{l \- <1?, G... ,ar .r-S-rBa r-{) 6+t+eg-fl -t6t1' et..'r at g-& *l a-"Isj1,-l .gdus 6uTe G't'l+e(*l "i Gtrtezr-{ -_) *,r84' a,A"*er; 'urd) fln'"ftsL" eslf a"te--'r,.:'^'&8 3 -fi; #" 6"*oo1) t''r'i]zaat d-olJ orl g6"i E'a *;.tt{'l* 6901rr-r' j61:' .,*;,? ,.;G-q d',4. eL'Srleul gp.1 elqdlsl cl ISROI.I ORO|JP GRAil ordm daeldl eJtd u?ilud GUJAMT STATE lY d qa ;1-tig4a1 6 rfa< ole .6Gtsca't-t, atia'errq rfurr orrt4. q4J 4f53e1 or&o +fG GlL,.gr+n-t? 2fl< 6ez.6erii .goy'.- !3t I t{,ar lq I fQaor |:r* c{a GUJAMT STATE ilY?rd flqa ul. ol(tai AT. A Po. BALESITA& u. cll. {(llll€ll, 1". ta. Palsant, Dist. surat '{t cfl{lu : J-rt ei.s*rot da-rrQl\:J gqr?td tq ar{lu : ag d.ut du{lG€{ rs'tt .rrl ei6 ch r:rlRg "f""t:n errE d,ret- ^ A'C{E 611 or5r.rj?l eet4 -lgg e etiY?; cj+,dl sr--Q *'fgcq oru' urfl. etr[&4 ot ur ot\trsj a+rs-i"Q {-E t -€ Carr.tj +ri qr\ qr,s.[l {Drrq1 $ alq cf\ot r .:$o< - etr rg1 a.'r6' 6_r a tfaJ.p9r dt%8"1 S.oii*i 4,rrjira-ri gool €ier, 8nt4.t qa'rr$ t.' o1,6e1 a.Qt't I i 6a $, qgsa r 5.y.,4r,1-trDA Itq{tl cltr4drllun{w Itc?r r - lsd a)sax srsrr u") ill:<+r yr. tdecl r.r ardqeil, q. 6,re)scr Gqali ar rv-r) rcrr-a ertrd.iqa; c 4lra,ro rllae eogs artdcr qoo d. * "flq't Sqroi ril. c)q) e€Jd. ?rr (loa4i yqcrd?ncl a)cq: iqr 3rflscr)q) qrterqr etcl tot) d cr) d crl s)cr"fl crcrrq t?A r'ta qrueqr4) qeJl Gs<.r tq c)ar "r lr) oqrd 3. rc{rdeli qrpil qr) q)?acl cu?tc u -rqr sedr4 qlo d o) ?}t|qrcdcro|| ciadcr gol.tt vcn fa: d crelr Ocnd crrt.tt ,ttelld alurqa s?dl ?{ . r.ro ___L?'.g&_--.- uAtp. tq _ (.- a,/_ tS' ,^t d\6dc\S* cl /. Mo.: 9E25086982 R6g. No. E/5826/SURAT 1?., PARYAVARAil SEVA & CHARITABLE TRUST (Gujarrl Stato) qqlq"q d.tr Off.-11-1!t ^ .. Ftoor, S.rvic. Co]t|ptox, P. No. 200, c.t.D.C., p!nd!!..!, Sur.t.396 221 Ref. No.: Dite : d- d ca)ar)cr s:crrorr q:lnrrq €)er o) l..w.s.s.e. "fl dqsi errd<. t) S.roil d4 rrrelcfl *,u.Ferrr Ec?rri ?l)Ela {)u)Elri cn:rrdc, d $ qcl d4 rrGdl urvrr)g. olcrc4ty cJlqdce ql) 1u-n.il l<{tcl clrt('tJt ro ga o) c.fl"r cice .i€r?i qr"qr?i e)cr't d"n lsllel) qe el qi sl.r0. Er 6g-tr - qor€.c€r e)s c,taldcr 6,le a'l dqren 11 tes u3 r) di{l etrGcfl urrqq). g,t.fld ur qcsrcrrri ?i gcr)-e clJt? Elar)-l caraura seor rr2 sci:re q)a:la qpr rcicl d. a) er"l6 arrrg "rr ara d"fl 1i nJal d. cada: rarjlqi slesr{ s:qrqi erld dqi BoD slcll Jld r)€r.)"1 seO ud eltqr sr:e) ?r tcrc{ tqrq I crrq)4 Odl4 qr}0q u?Ju tcr.td gsrrr.r sr:s t). o. aelq cetp, uiSaer cFrp, z'isc\ge cErp, e.dry cerp qo)i4 vtgq ciruot) e:lar geil crg qrclrqi elrdcr t) ct) cerrer rctroa4 utsuersol) cr\,tclr rr) s)u ur r"illr slcr t) C dr d4 qrGdl ?it tql . c. ?i+cr)-aq I els.l)Ia 3 Y3t48l) qqldeet Sor ei"s r):l)cacr ire IZ.ru. (,'tr!, 6't PARYAVARAN tvt |TRAto/' (Resd No. E/20934/Ahmcd.b.d) Raj Avenue, Bhaikaka Nagar Road, Nr. Thaltej Cross Road, Thaltej. Ahmedabad.380 059 Phone : (079) 26851321 Email : paryavaranmitragyahoo.com Wobslte : http://paryaveranmilr!.org.ln ANNEXURE-g 6 Il(l:l,\l'11l,i1..PI|(,2liri 20 i l):tle: I ?/05/2018 To, Member Secretary Gujarat Pollution Control Board Gandhinagar Sub: Environmental Public Hearing of M/s. spectrum Dves & Chemicals Pvt.Ltd at survey Btock No.-484,502,5034, 504&50S, NH.No.8, Palsana-394315, Dist.:Surat, Gujarat to be scheduled on 25'h Mav 2018 Sir, We have studied the draft EIA report of the above mentioned project. Following are our observation/comments/questions regarding project and draft EtA report. 1. Page no. 421, shows the application date 17 /06/2017 for permission of usjng abstract ground water for industrial use from Central Ground Water Board but quantity of water requirement is not mentioned in the application. So for how much water requirement permission is grant? 2. As stated in table 2.10 on page no.2-30, Waste water generation and consumpttons very confusing as existing waster requlrement is 425KLD and wastewater generation from this is 140KtD, but for proposed oroject water requirement is 525KLD and wastewater generation is 130KLD. So how is this new proposed project generation less wastewater and why existing is not generattng less wastewater and vice-versa. 3. As stated in table 2.j.0 on page no.2-30, water consumption is 677.5K1D for processing and wastewater generation is gOO for existing and for proposed project water consumption is 922.5K1D for processing and wasrewater consumption is 1075KLD, so here consumption is less than waste generation, how is that possible...? 4. As stated paragraph in 2.9.5 on page no.2-46, is it viable to grow 35. Nos trees an 2000 sq. m, and which kind of trees are to be grown. suggestions for .iesG ^-p*1,{a 73 trt Lv' PARYAVARAN MITR44TIC (lttg(l \o. I ll)9.1{:\hmrrlrhad} Ral Av{iirue. Eharhaka ltagaf HoaJ li' I rr.illej Cross Road Thattel, Ahmedat'ad - 3gO 059 Phone : (079) 25E51321 Email : [email protected] Websile I httpr,/psryavaranmitre.org.in growing tree would be ,,Horticulture,, types of trees and Fruits produce from them should be supplied to workers and labour in free of cost. 5. As stated on 2.8.1.3 on page no 2-35,2-36.CETP Inlet and Outlet results are not according to the GPCB norms, so what are the solutions taken by the industry to rmprove the treatment process. 6. On page no.2-35, it is stated that comptete treated water is sent to CETP, water ft completefy but if treated then whv it i( nor ,, Your trury, yT, ,' , - Mahesh Pandya, 1) Collector, Surat 2)Regional officer, GpaB Surat 92'- (z Aovz.^ .) t< ..., tz' Ef*' {}. \t^r^tt"r, to-lo ANNEXURE.C+ nr. \(^ tar \: \ I O. r.i1n. rtirtl, \^\ . 96.1{593") {. rLLRU qhrL{Ir0, 1.'ri. lliet otid uld Rtr{: drid r\slr srdu d-s }.0re il6{a e0.0}s - r,eij . -rl '[qr.: vzt, \or, \o5;qox, \o\ - \i*. \e+ttRtt, f*.gra - dq?$ eL g.ucefi dr{lur: rr{o\/ro1z -tL ris rrQe t}. *.tL hr'iq ru) ui .tgj det),rL.r .r srqL iqL hriq srcr 3aL -0{ Xm 0. ttR't{ rts uqtr 4\.0 hi No. .r cl Co r,{It qLqi erdae s€0qr {tl{iJ r4r{ei {e{1. Uale- : Zl I c1^ ( tr eonn---.ffi 1c {ttd +.lt4t srdu {-s },{kcr lrdQa e{1.0)s - r,e)g tqr: vzr, \ol,, t{og, qoy, qor{ - .tit. ,{e+{Lerr, [t.gr.t - tdu iqr.ti otr4e !,r'tl d. u1g dut6d {t,rid c,rcrl r}. rig (r) qolr iqrti <' 2 -rcu 6rirr5rq.{l \r.{Iu.r a.0 .{1. *tj sidqq 6c4q rJ.qL$.l,i. r.'l {'id.ri r,rLtar.tr{l ui o/rr {i }u ou6td4 qi iql .r rrl g.rrr\sL d-{t,rle i?.{1. qr orqr (e) 6 ,rte0 ,rle3t.t ott+A, j,r.0.tL 6.qLr!.d. rlrril 1rr,t rLc[.{l .rdtL.t v3{l ua r r.y? erur e{ler./ dl.++t r}. ui RicrcL tL) +g tl.rro eLui c0at .rLc[ / dl++r t3r1,rLc 6a0 qil. qL"r {ad aiae rg eftar idl.rn.ft "r3{t,rLe r}. ui 6.qLtl.d. {tqid'tl dq.0 \r{ sre v q'irQe 0. qi o{lvr s qi?gq.t.{L u) lr qertrgrL.u +tL0q \iq .r{ \0 3 6sr r.u rs,{r 0. ui r.ro gae{l soo ga g4l.ti q.i{lcr srLqqL.rl &. qi *rc{r r,trE, pH, \,{ 1Le0{i TDt coD, BOD .[ .uar .rqrl \sr0 .,trrq si.{rp{l'{lqrer.t3 t{l e'icL. tr{l qrii .u80.0 dc0,ri or.irt q.t:i,rl d.t erc'i d. sLe{'{etttgtr qr.t rirrr{c.t q'iat qjt tr aer (e) qir.ti uett oirt et{e r}. qi qnv.ftd i .{r,ilI qe,ar urqL.{l 0. 6.u6.d. {tr'i€ Svor drr4{ utgr,tLg.tl R+.ur (zoZ) {l,t4ea daA ] Qdlert{3 d. ui +tgq qr* r,u Qdlqrsfi uoqr oti{lor.u {re{l qer utlur rrrJ cr{e r}. cru q,aft gc,{rd.r'i r,irr q{e d deA \oi uet,te0,rr) crcrr,u tr{t te,{t darL ,ueft.0 cgetecar qorsqri d grtel \.irt uLsi ?rqr $3{rr.t erile d c?rr \citL 6cruer{ ot icr qars'i .titrLqr eL,iiq d. *t{l \rii4,rRl{rrti oio{h q.0 tCt d. d.qul.d. {triJ Svot.ri.r,0 r'ird 1t.y\ erq c{lar /flen{,ue[t Itrrrt{l .tigcrrl. flad.a ttt CFfp i dg "d j.{4. uLaqr orru oig$rLr{ltr -0ae r0.d.tt.t. wO qD srr'i. *r0 ur0-0 urgoug.0 r.{l.ti4 gq6'rat rarl ui o+{e ui. Qr{li \eL g3rr{ qrl. gn$ } GpcB r.ult .n j,{e.0 re gerd rot Bi l,u rttc{ore ic qutq eLdt qcsrd edl. * jt{4a{l qdrqr uLO gr{l \oo {lar *adl q.u{q ec0. r,ti j\.0 EaLrt 3r.tl{ lgNa,rLett dlQdlg ur0rti oiserri ureq! egj. s.rll.dl.r,0. tqLr,L r'u eLd.r .$srdL i,r4i gei$r ,tillu ql{r6 edl. ui i,r4d rte{l ui 4lss{l gfurr't gr,{l iaL{e e{. ui i,r"0i }adlq ge'i$r.ti4rii.r,st qqrl.e r]. cl r,udl i\.0 .r{r. otr'i\i rD qi Srel { vtJtt "t 4tt4 E{nr {9e u6< fur qld (cawg) j rl6,ret rtdl{t}a c{lQe -tall. ut4i ot$ rird,rte0 Qs+tqr qLe \re0 {qtf .u} gi6r{eL,{"rcrL dlQcu 6.ar6.a1. {tQJ{i..r{l crrL id s'i.6,reL }eugdut r,u{e {{1. * qlar {ra teet eirt sls elol 0. o{Rd $tjR "Jtrl Orqrf qldldl,' cu.r.rr ddn d. eui i.'{4 hktrer,u {.'il{ I qrqct ti r'[6,rer 6(aur .tr{I. * cio{h qrq eln ( ser rr'legu.t otrotrt) qnr i,r4 tqr Rrrtrsr ru) rer or'idor,, Clar.l, nlar.i :terqqr il$, sje+ri, Ooe *qr tlq,sr.ti.{r{rrt qt. i.tr snd .{rdrqtsrti rg\Brj lrruBr .r€{{'1. pMlO, +ri CO2, SO2, pM2.S tct qlr6r qrdlx*t eqrti orur{l dqr lrdcr d-s ].0Ee ]sa{ e'iqre{l }.{be {ldgcr,ti e0Q eqr\i grtqd qqrl. rttlr * {r.rq qntea rtL) oqder rtr6{Lr err). .{q{LBu out.u .{l.dq.dl. (lrt,r.r{l {"ar Jeq {"ar) .ti dec{ e +dti eerrti rgreLi qil srr{ rioii *qr } i+rrtt r,ior, i4rtt.tr ?ior, }.ttr.tr ricr.ii !ruer Uo$q rlrsrri cr{l rqr l|Acr 0. e.u.ti 6erC.t rrL{eL pMlO lti pM2.5 .rdLc+j qqqL.u gLrd luet i r{lQ dlq'i is+t.ti vLq d ui r4rr. }.qr? :,ti dt.oll. tr r'[cri. lu,iaet 4A t]. nr0ot grc ltc ur.r.tL d.qr6. d. tt{'iJri !r.0.u urgrug.tL Rr 4\.{l.u hktrBt ,rP 6.uu6. d. {\iJ{i GpcB i 3}t\$ luRd I'IOC dlQe.te{l qi r,ulr.u tcnL 4.crrRd-a cdl{r.$ slt{t}a (r,C.) .{Br qt dlQe {{1. *r{l Rr"uer.[ eL g.ucefl s{l rut+.tdt. .rig ureL {l,rU -t dlqL elqti rrrel jq.{l qr 4urr,{oLCt dqL si6:,1. j,{4'rr 6.qr6. d. {.id Xzot Jrr.0 {oner {iqr{a .u} +c.r i,{4-0 da?,.u e{rd r er.t r,rQet d. ,rig iui gdl :r,rL 0 } j.'{4tr urgotrg'ti hrrurrti iu{e u64-e, reust-+arer rut4 dh, rlu.Jt.*. ge,, elae, u.tq quedl ui 4lrn,utr g,0al urter 0. *{ q+r.r rLQe,re{}. *p{} j{4 qii €rafl ej,{ dr eLc] d. .l \\r lo 5 ri i,{-0.ri si6 ,r'ia'i w+rrLo rrLq *{l } qLoL ercr.{I, }{tEe {ld*rr er$, eqr,ri cio{Ir. lrLr.u iltt qacr ci d,r4 qLrt g.l6\gL.r.ter dlQe tell ceu rtoL r,iqr rL) *cr.t, eqr {D - iln {ldctr .tr) si6,{,!t 6,rsret gler .trll. t t ugate dt lCI.r .'rJeL \etrgu, qarr.rt our.u el{e ,re{L,tr eiiii d. s,rri Rqc 4lriq 6-ar{l0{a i.r.0 * sqr q.u.rc{l itr-lhi ttLor ero(l edl etLl eritr urgotrgrti t]ar ur ttrrt qr.lr Strui aLt \r et' {rgqa{li uur{l .tc qr.v 0 }, uL j'{4 aq.t q{r.ll g. "tiaL {qij e'ir'ii. an,rA qi iqq .n ridr t{I{ v 0. .tqt \q+t9tt.ti Utqe u[ uqloriori. {e].t 4qr u) q.u{ r*r'{s[i ra{Icr r] uti r'tL i\.0i 6ier cr'i d{l i,r'rL{l {oreft d. uru.ti h"+rg ?..-iu- : I google.co.in l m.timesofindia.com C-) i 6'r \1i tn, i8.) \5' AHMEDABAD: Officials of Gujarat Potlution control Board (GPCB) issued immediate closure notice to Spectrum Dyes and Chemicals located at Baleswar of Palsana taluka of Surat District some 20 km off Surat city. This action was taken after the unit management was found guilty of releasing untreated Chemical water directly in to Baleswar c fa ke pipeline installed by them . rrinrt Summer vacation in :?r35.m lsrael ill lof I iri -l1i! main en CiA htQs //mail Soogj€ conv ./scJm.il-static/ 4vk=8'nail PHOTO-2o1E-05-15' I I -18'17 jPg \filt ..ooo Vodafone lN 3G 9:36 AM 72%n I google.co.in F-plro*r Baleswar Khadi (Creek ) is located some 500 meters off the site of the unit. "We had received a complaint that unit management is releasing the untreated harmful water waste in the creek directly during the night hours. Our team raided the facility on Z\ Jul 19, 2012 and caught the untreated water that was being released to the creek by joining a fake pipeline to the storm water line," said Anil Patel, in- charge officer of GPCB , Surat. Open in app r 'rl=At a Summer vacation in Gtsi::r35.m lsrael 0 5/t512018, ll 42 A)' Iof I main.€.t GA PHOTO-2o18-05-l 5-l I -lE'04 jPg htFt/msit.Booglc.cff t/-/scvmr;l-static/-4Vk=gmail trl\c' ' ..ooo Vodafone lN 4G 9:37 AM 71%!J) A google.co.in m.timesofindia.com C-) I served a notice of closrlre bY GPCB , Director Gandhinagar under section 33 (A) of water act. The concerned unit belongs to Pratibha group, a known name in I city's Textile circle. GPCB Surat has issued 1 10 show cause notices to different pollution creating industrial units in months of June and July, 2012 and it has issued 1 9 notice of directions in this period along with issuing 63 closure notices . Power and ons of units who a re notices are cut off by the authorities . ,s=nr1 Summer vacation in GIIII:'r35,m lsrael lofl 5lt5t20ta,lt 42 At\ lr(, (1qri< ) Jttr{ot) dHot) G ua qr \rl }l 8060072 o r'l.{ Oir.r li< a ur) .,l.ln a u').11 lil rror,r\?o.?.r ?,t'ro1,l,ico,lr\q,q9'r Jilq< 'na lq ur(a.q( ,,i1( xqlRarli O,L,i 4n 6n rai o{lk,n Ara ' + tLe:"i ! ,r@oro ,,.' b it &Rq t{8.0 qt o,'r ,il. ri U J||]iot) g]tdr) b exo) qt \o .\l 806007 r 1of1 li.i , orgr), _T;; , -.- 8..n-.- - i:,?ro q'dr I ; I A u,).,) sl. I r101,i30?.r!ro,rcJ J.rc.o.,{oJr lr0. I I !$ d& QEnqRl , clln rrel qA qt.!1"{l Ordl tr gc,trca,rtoo,rrJo,rcJs,rna, aooa.ao,a, ?rtd,?ar9,t?a9.?r{co,3 ?or,l Rliq{ r?tor{ AR qa l}<{ r/n.{/rln.i/re a.?.?/io dl qr r sra C5{<\oz e, *f :[1"fi fr tr ::i:t;,111 *,iililt l;iff ,T,. "f":.ffi?i:i[", | 25lL' :rrrio gr{"t'l o Ud qe \oJf B C6006,., t.0 n?( ry {) 1ol 1 111.,-8:,.' i:..n_: I "t"*l---__i..,*";;; !9l,ru?0,?rs?,i.r?.r,r.c,!tJrc !s!? \e? lo.e!.so I rc? ro .iqr Y9 Qqnq?l J I i qqiaar.ilS)Ldl .nn 6rl qa qtn.n AJid) '.4{t? !ill{l ..r- or,o! o,orh {enA :ly :t"Tnr,:: j.:l",tL" "",iiiilil;is :j," _:?.t3.1,.,lil:, 11+? Ir,. |l \-r-\.-'0JJ t0iro.000.t0.:rt6- \J tltrr t. \ \r |:1r't,.,ltr.t I .J.,r.tt i_! rr a r. / : rflHat) gxot) o ua q? \r, (r)s/d?i aiolr : \or,.( i.{ rl?d (t nr ,,,".r Ajrd I i u'I..').'il. I l I r?t,rt!o,tqio,?tJ?.?t!?.?r.I iqrJ. uora,q3,'],v.rl,r9ct.!?ro t< Aasr rQri{ tll da frttlr{.I j srln e* } {l lcr u.c{I.(.r! ro) ,rcr&q.c liftr i)!.? !i*!,(. udlottri J. I rqlRqr.{ ArA onn 6d ut dn.n Ardl or.rft,. oG F.d eqq * lly::friIHn::;;:J1g :ilIil H i. "f.:"t311'::::" S .f,lom : K.r-n Ahl 'To, Pal tsq ro, ANNEXURE.CS T?e.Jt ar\a) ' lh c-'( 6PCB 3 u zql Ot. B al 65l ,'rri< 1-) eiA Pa*-'o ' ell enrecr\S .gub: Lx?ans'f.n 6.1 'Lrrl clc4+ Show P "'taonoJ 'i6\'a'Al3 L \\Jot\ J I i v- '6 "'o't D"l oJ sc-clAutn -4 ' 4hc e^?dnct6nv^rdr'st-'' ',-0 'lr P: 6 -l e. otn P .r nJ 92eelttl $ez-zatSe 'tbr9 a e1 a'.4 \a I {cl4e. 'f es l o carl e'r4 0 l o) ?Yl €Yt'l 3 { h €-n .l <6 e244 'lT'teA-a9- etase 'l- 6A? ot AalS JrA=.-elr^J '1 + cr.g 6jell qs 'l.r1Clq' It\Il "r4.u '13 tS e-.art1 u Fvel ln.t Pqrt +o 5rr9,'1 h'r 9 \)tr'r'l -A'l P ('J O3 'Pq rl h f,n'rtrr ) "rr 4 , -I?o\c.,vr Atl,J P ort s qi.91 \\/ P O'\N ci\ t^ - J+ d.r(r,z. -?\ r.^.,t . {.$ .1- to. ANNEXURE-C 9 Qi^".'{..-c- C\J"r,* g"t\*."'. o<\xl Bo"\"1., Sr.* \ro,"Ar €groJ."ld^t (,^L\ic H.""^.*i "4 spectrwr W) el^ d c\e''.iq "l ej r fJ{qrlo. &qo4.J s,n" t"t- s.'r\\ \i\ce- {., Jnq.^.1 Ydv\- qrd""-\* +"*r1..}3 .dle- gt\i- h€"$-S "t s(ec\-rsnn {a .+ eke",^iqo\eJ. dt \- o\\Ffi6 \4 '--tI e'vt..t\ic\r.\ 4 $5,-rig ..'f\ {\e_ le..rl .l"..-b _rt[. + \. .r""iqg u va,.) h",t,gR^}. -+.u-qaJ4 \A\\^ie-l<"l"Vll J."r"\1*.e..I . \".\5,.^f^ i6 e.\ye\ p.r.\+q"\.". ^^J"4, l\e, *o.a* * {.,.o\.x, $-In*!., \-\-\. * R$\ \er\rs s6$p..rs \s3 NeI q vAJ 6-"d (-\e_ 6+o >es.:qg -\ .i:.Jar i"dcr.r^"Ji"ie1 + pJ*q6o., t \ s'.+ *-d o- sur Jg 4>. -(i-.e_ t^^flo1-.o"t \ \n^r- '\o p,re4.,t- tF-"I ?e,j\e_ &:_ 4kl (l""i.t * \J€_ ore_ s:e\sr..e- .\\{ (l .n€.4 . Ba\ .t:"skel. \* l."r\rl*tJ, $$."\ (r\s"r" q\*{-q6, Vi\e: f^\s*' ANNEXURE.C IO lo, Reglonal Officer, Gularat Pollutlon Control Board, Surat. Subjcct: ltfishes 60r Upcomlnt Sp€ctrum project. Resp€€ted Sir, My self M.. Manish Mahadevwala, t/C. Head of Chemic?1, Engineering Department A of Diwaliba poh/technic. In regards of '- the expansion of the Spectrum Dyes and Chemicals which is situated at palsana, I would ljke to express my personat grace for this company,s trowth. Spectrum is a role model company towards the d€velopment of relationship between lndustry and Education system. Thev are always eagerly participate and contributed their values towards students upliftment. i.e. Activelv participating in internship progiam scheme, provides Practical industry visits, lectures. They are dedicated towards the Gujardt Government Skill India program, in this area they have created and provided new job opportunities too. I wish them to grow because it,s directly impact rhe people,s growth, their Socio economic conditions, intrastructure. My heartly wishes forthe betterment of the Spectrum Dyes & Chemicats. Thanks & Regards (fu r- Manish Mahadevwala UC. HOD in Chemical Engineering Department Diwaliba Polytechnic, Uka Tarsadia University, Maliba - Mahuva Campus, Bardoli, Surat, Gujarat Mobile No:99131996110 a\ ./ E\N hltps://m6il.yahoo.comrd/folders/2hessages/ 1096??.intl=in& lang=c' (q ANNEXURE-C 11 subjecl: Suggestion for public hearing ol Spectrum dyes [email protected] To: [email protected] Date: luetday. May 22,2OI8, 2:48:07 PM GMT+5:30 Respected Sir, I would like to convey my message in respect of Spectrum Dyes and Chemicals' Palsana. SDectrum is well established company which is provided Local employment or necessary legal facilities to the Palsana town people Spectrum is always doing their contribulion towards Palsana village or taluka in form of Education, Medical and religious or social activities. Therefore my personal .equest for welcoming the expansaon project of Spectrum. Thanks and Regards Rahul Puranik Palsana Respected Srr I would hke to convey my message tn respect ol Spectrum Oyes and Chemlcals Palsana spectrum is wett estabhshed company which is provded Local employment or necessary legal facilities lo the Palsana town people. spectrum is atways doing their coniribulion towards Palsana vitlage or taluka in forrn of Educaiion, Medical and religious or social activilies. Therelore my personal requesl fof welcomlng lhe expansion project of Speckum Thanks and Regards RahulPuranik Palsana s.\"\( rofl - mh!|21@holmarl coo e23zola (9 Ma Palsana Review about SPectru mI/Yes and Chemicals, ANNEXURE.C12 Mehul Dhimar T!. ,;:::,'. r lrr i ).? lr'1 In gp b'o{trr r' ': gpcbrosrl@yrloo ''r' ' l{cspr'cted Sir" i)rc: arrt| ( lrcnlrral:' I'a|;llnll' t \\'ou|(l Ilkc l{) coll\e\ nl\ |]l!\\J!'J ||l ltspcel ol.\PcclItlllr SpcctrulD|l,\\o|lcstabllshcdc{n)lpltll'\\lilchi5||(r\(lc(ll,oc.lltlrrPloYll)$]tol'llcc!s5i|'.ylcgallitciliticst(llc in i'rn oi ri(rlrcariotl, N4c(licxl !i';'.i1,X'Illl;:i5"ing rhcir conrribrri(n) ror ar.rl. r,alsanu r illugc o' ralura .rlrd rcllqlt'tl\ trr so(llll it(llvltlu\ (rl ptlst'rr:rl reqrr.'-t l0r *tl':'rrrring rhc erDirlr\r()rr Dr\)i'J!l SIcrlrurrl iit.r.fiu. "'t 'l-h:lnk\ irrld Ilc!lar(ls lchul I)hinrrrlrr l)illsiulit h(psr/outbok.livo.codvd6/?palh=/marusenlilemd,p - ANNEXURE.C I3 @ S6FETY hERttr exo EHVIROI{l-lENr 6SSOCI€TloN . | .,., < Ets." rh |-'dd, P.TAJ953P T.A,1953 I FEclsTRan(N : 0)^ F/61 5.€hrnrn 'vid l;i'd' ;#i..'*;'"" S :T-T-T^I''::'^:,,Tat Ac! Iet*' I I iii6J,.j-i"*-* u' m 6 nr the ticotrp I t ! Lld' dl \l/s SItcttnrrl lr'r\ rnrt ( h(nticrls I'r1 Subic.l: l.n\ir,inrrcn! l'rrhli. lllrrrinl I Dcar Sn lha mlnl t. l'le!st gi Lld. Prl5r rl mc t chet I industt]? llow \\hic\ t] sno f I ,vr. Ltd. Palsana 3n) O. I r;llth. Di imbuluncc room rrith curl strfl) rt prescnt? Nhal \\ill be 1. l'n of loarl tnrplolnrenl )!ei irn(l Chcmicals Pvt. l-td. T .\l|erl lhcnr sho\! ciuse nolice ,lrtion ol rn\ lionm.n! issues ar Il Jonc sincc lisl 2 Yetrs? And anY in J,restncc of Co\'L aulhorities? hc conlD.u-\'\\e hereb)' srongl) equipmenr _t -'- I $,v, IfiFETY HEIITTH ffND ElrvlRoNl.tEHT 6SSO(l6TlOtl R€GlSlR nON : (l) Fy'615/€naruch uhder P T.a1e'o (2) Gui /528/Bh6'uth lnd€r lhe sec. t I (3) Donalon orampl€o uts 80 C oltr'B I \inrunr f( I Thanking )ou rnd $ il a For, Safcty. llcalrh an v v---::-e, ?f.-)Aq Yortsl{ I'il'arli r r- M:rnrr:inr, trd.rte -- I C. C. To Ji n.o Cril.c 15 - 9U8A'I 1., 3 Hl. .:p..i-r.rt. JD7"5 chc,'-i fvt. 1-f{. P -\l s.e 'r' " T I (r ANNEXURE-C 1! sfufrt* d+ i. t x, q{i. t t v., r+ +qt+46efr gqmc-$qfr'hlr+d fttrtn1 sifus{ i'.rl'.'ir','.lll) gwror$qfuiilr+g f r lkg< ' 22-5-.ta',. qRr I furq , d-qcr+gg€tfusdcr.fr. (*. FRtTurT, fudr _ qta) a1 qqlcrufr q *o Vrdr€ a1 +or-frurqfr r (1) *qft +-qee +1 oq-runeer +1rw.t olg< f+-i Eq FunctionatArea Expert + qtq nqr s-€fi qFqr +t{-+t{ t * ffi +rq Foqr i s€*1 qr6r0 nr[ ssa] qqq rqlqr dqr rr* gq $ s-0 oi{ €q qm o}fi s}q. eil. g}q. * d di i fus fuifr r (2) .bl|i ih-:$€? * Oct-Neaef * s n eig€ fu.i Eq FunctionatArea Expert srq+ srFrsrfr gs+1 qrorfr .r{fi i fr r0 r (3) tffi q-qss $ qgt-NABET+crm'tsig€ hi 6q FuncrionatArea Expert d Fjrd r S foq t{ri ftcti s-{ri t ss 4il-n +r nq 3lt{ (11) F- tq.lqt I (14) sLEAc 61 ct t d;Tfr d RA 5q roR sT compliance +1 t*toa Iooqfavnqstqrr0 qrs ss+1 qrfirt { I .ri (15) ocr-NABET +1 6R€€i ffi mq g*ri t 3vd r0< tqr*fr1 * sc{ sfi-€q o'{* olc.S.3lq.ireidf*ifrr go (16) oct-NABET 5r f+qqqqR 6{€-€ i ffi tri c[6i * ffi FunctionalArea Expert i q{ E{qrr ffi eta RqH i qlc ld€ } {fr tgqlw{l q-{ s6A i 3{d tq'rd {dri d fq+fr t rrqr e{rq gsr dn qr d'Irn t ss+1 ls'rd r qcil } fts, crfr t tcqr 3{|+1 t r a F{ Ts m t - qsn Gfu.d fq'n r qrfi qR i-qr gs{r frqrrql t fr F€ 3}q.oi.*r. C d-+ r 5 otel arfre *' spr A{r I qtavn rtgt stEAc sl s'd tffi o1 i ssfi fd,rd cqd 6t t trr cFd{rd d fr (i9) sLEAc +1 drq t ti;q{ +l Fci Eq roR compliance *1 e*t+-a loo ss ssd gEd;c+ fdlqd i rqa +tt qat lzoy d- rqa of r (23) ii*{ * s{q gtrc t opce d il{F i riir{ i< m{i +1 nfu Ei n s{r€ a di ffi i ffis #S qrq fuqt qr*rfiracrt+fi qrq Es+1 s.d * frqft T€ s'fr sr4qlA t orrrq nqr srq+{ slq.sit.dq. d rsl +1R-ifi r nqr sc{rt qR{ { lit qq ffifie im* s{d qrfr qr6rt r (26) {qffiq ot6 srqr{ d qqr qs fri-e if i.qr{.s}. tqtJ or ti*vn qrffi qfu s1 ffi + fdcc t srt frrn rari +1fq+frr (27) s{srr< tr{dR g;o ein-S qrqr qr6r qr-srt i ffi ft *' i ssd r (28) orqarkr f+ ffiqR srFr6r0 6r Qiqrqr slq oil.dq. d rqd 6ri sl fuitr r (31) {rr ct+€ + iic,ln srgtl< leRR * srdnr cE{ * d,if n$.irri h 6ffi b +Tn erfiqrci F+g frq-6rqr3ocn€ftrtnqtrilmqrffi +qprdcs€fuqr i efr{ rffi q d;qfi + ffi ffiqR qFmrt or slitr{rqr s}q.oi.o}r. I tqa +tr 1ez1 gv rtie t ererl< F {;qfr ei?rdr {irfi * iq+qr 3{Fr6rt ol ftir{rqr s}q si Sq. C rqa +ri d Feid r iu : TdGirirM(ft-{ffi qrfliti*frqF{ift r qftr Frgn d?rfu) {-a o ANNEXURE-C 15 !{R, dr.??io\/?o1z {a'{ lt[ic€[l' cls?ld rEqer li.iaq dJ, {szt-ro r,l, "ritll.rctt . flrrrr :- +i larr sr{$ ari }{lrq ql?{r {!+qt-rr.t ouord... qdrou't atdq, nh-rq 6.rriJa Rq{ ?,{-qQ '{l{ nCl tr-uuuij rnLccrj }, r,u.o-a orcrqi * au<{ rs4i d. l{{l rr{ uEus ud r to3 d. rai i{ ur r 1t€3r1'{l brqsu nd, dt lr.r. Uea{l , .Llcl l I ill .r,l No -l-831-! Dale -z!LSlN. E \c'N R^^'8t) lll lt' OTHERF!I-E 300 -= +tga.r 316$.1-s i{sq i*fi **Hffi al-i- [lr't ,, o'1{l.|ra t}. ,it or<'t'ti lt'ir't oiiricri {l?|tri srcr.ri d .ur qhricr sdra d r4i tqt s ?a('{l t' Xl {ti mir t i3 {ltdqi reritr 'r{I' qtdl er"rcit dicri rrII. iqt u6's irer cuq .iqq.t ,lrlrll ErL qiri OTHERfII,E ANNEXURE-C 16 O M/s ENvlRoNlsENr PUBLIC HEARII{G OF ',sP-E-cTRul::-=" " MOST URGENT FROTII B Patel' Manish Dist' surat' ii. C"r.rour, P.o. Gangadhara'Ta' Palsana' pin code - 39431O'Gujarat' Resident of Project affected area ' hoo.com E mail sent - from oul e mail id'EE!g!ra! TO, tUlS-GPCB' ms'qpcb@quiarat'qov'in' cc. M i n i ster-MoEFGG' dr.harshvardhan@sansad'nic''n' ps to minister, EFCC' Ls?4effgq@gsY!!!!' i c i n t minister for statet d [email protected] ' *secretary EF & cG, gecrqoef@nlerD' *ms-seiaa mssei a agj@g mai l.co m ' a rat I n *chairman-gpcb, c hai rman-9Pc b@g ui '9ov ' ' 241 1 1 92 * regional off icer,GPCe, Surat'-026t 2442696' re:gPeb:9crt(D$ci!!r?!sqvi!' *proponent has submitted his consultant's EXPIRED page 659 desired AGCREDITED GERTIFICATE, ( EIA )'so he has ToR comPliance is NOT lN ORDER' moreover' page 660)' more submitted NABET validation letter' ( EtA from over, there is NO ANY WRITTEN CONFIRMATION' EXPIRES' MoEF-ToR, that, if AGCREDITED CERTIFIGATE then in lieu for that' even a NABET VALIDATION TO""') ls LETTER ( wlrH T& C APPLY AS SUBJECT ' OF SUCH VERY WELL AGCETABLE- SO IN ABSENCE lS NOT CLARIFICATION, desired ToR -A-z-i' GOMPLIENCE 11{ ORDER. We request NABET'I||oEF to look to th:s carefully' Gc Dast. magistrate' publlc hearing' Chairmanr distr environment \ Guiarat Suratr ,) "N cotlectol'su1@suiatat'qov'in' Qy^ cc \ \r) ^"S' FOR A READY REFERENCE DESIRED EIA PAGES ATAGHED HEREWITH ETVIRONMENT PUBLIC HEARING OF iI/S ,SPECTRUM DYES & CHEMICALS PvT LTDI PALSANA DIST. SURA?. GUJARAT p!. note that, (i) ver 03, clause 9.1 g not complled- ( copy attached for ready reterence ) OR is this clause remoyed for this prorect proponent, pl confirm by return mall Innedaately. (.i) Exphed accredited certlflcate submitted in EIA (..0 Why Consultant has NOT DECLARED on front page that he is NABET ACCREDITED CONSUITAI{T, and not used NABET mark ( logo ) also, [email protected], pl ensure that, all IIABL approved lab has to fumlsh I'IABL approved certlflcate, ln all EIA report, CG [email protected]. lust sharinq with vou ne more classic case of EIA report. thls can be considered as suo-moto-as.we find. there are more such cases alreadv reported bv other Nco/trublic and covered In MoM. UNFORTUNATELY ALL THE EIA DOES NOT ROUTE THROUGH ENVIRONMENT PUBLIG HEARING ROUTE. AND ENVIRONMENT GLEARANGE ALSO GRANTED GC [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], [email protected], pateliaveshl [email protected], lust sharlnlr wlth vou a one more classic case of EIA reDort. Sub. ENVIRONMENT PUBLIC HEARII{G M/S ,SPECTRUM DYES A CHEMIGALS P\/T LTD, TA. PALSANA DIST. SURAT. GUJARAT, on 25 May 2018 ToR Letter 1{o: lA-J-l1O'l I151712017-lA-ll (l} , 5 (0 A, Daled= 9112,12O17-issued by MoEF, New Delhi DESIRED EIA PAGES ATACHED HEREWITH FOR A READY REFERENCE DYES & ENVIRONMENT PUBLIC HEARING OF M/S 'SPECTRUMGUJARAT CHEMICALS PVT LTD' PALSANA DIST' SURAT' Respected m S GPCB' To our view, ElA, prepared by QGI'NABET ACGREDITED, is NOT to quality mark' We wonder How EIA was accepted by GPGB for env'ronment pubtac hearing, WITHOUT A VALID ACCREDITED of CERTIFICATE' & lN ElA, there is no any copy written letter / memo / order from MoEF'SLEAGt T & G whEthET NABET VALIDATION LETTER With also be apply ( which is also an expired one) can accepted as mandatory desired ToR compliance' and Referring to MoEF l4 Sept' O6 notification' news successive public notice released in local as papers by MS'GPCB, inviting public to submit applicable ORAL /written response to MS'GPGB' directly It is very clear that, as a 'public' we are official concerned ONLY with MS-GPCB -or-his authorized nominee' for our pl obtain satisfactorv replv from proponent' MS'GPCB' following comments and "tf-t-=- authorizld nominee' HAS TO ASSESS THE RELIABLITY AilD AUTHENTIGITY OF REPLY and IHEN oNLY TO PROPONET{T's the the same in MoM' and to forward irr"orpot"t" a trard copy of reply to our above address'through suitable meanst REQUEST TO MS'GPCB' ol lf anY of our comment' You feel it from our unreasonable to accept, pl' omit it list, with a due written iustification to ust 02 HEREW]TH FORA READY REFERENCE DESTRED EIA PAGES ATACHED REPLY'( MoEF'SLEAC'NABET'II|ABL)'and incorPorate the same in MoM' o3 PI. REGISTER OUR COMMENTS AS UNDER' for an appropriate/ satisfactory reply from project proponent or other concerned regulatory authoritY' 04 ElA,EIA' to We wish this EIA should be a quality ensure public, to set up an environmentally SUSTAI NABLE PrqU!'c!9jt Ggtetaf pt""id" of presentation as proiected Pt. ""py on screen on the date of environment public hearing, and Pl inform, what inforrnation are out of executive summary' E02 a Pl. clarifyr, what is a constraint for consultant, for NOT officially disclosing on EIA front page ,that consultant is NABET Acc@and forNor using NABET official mark ( logo)' b is it that iust mentioning on front page of EfA, as NABET/EIA/14"71S,A OO{8' MoEF/SLEAC/GPGB/PUBLIG, has to take it q Sranted that consultant ffi;=" t a HERE'ITH FoR a READY REFEREN.E' "4"E" ^t^cHED ENVIRONI$ENT PUBLIC HEARING OF M/S ,SPECTRUM DYES A CHEMICALS PVT LTD, PALSANA DIST. SURAT. GUJARAT NABET AGCREDITED CONSULTANT? E03 Pl refer NABET VER 03,clause 9.1'9' ( copy attached) Pl. provide clarification on, WHY the cost of ' ElA, and cost of monitoring base line studies, is not disclosed in the beginning of EIA chapter 1, ( at least ,we could not find it) just to assess the value paid to consultant is worth OR NOT, OR is it not necessary to disclose this information for this ElA. pl confirm. E04 WE PRESUME NABET ACCREDITED GONSULTANT & NABL LAB APPROVED PERSONNEL MUST BE AWARE OF THIS. Pl let us know,At later date, in case, if, 'undertaking' as submitted by PROJEGT PROPONENT and/or ACGREDITED GONSULTANT, found to be incomplete, misleading, or any data on ANY PAGE as submitted in EIA report, OR 'DECLARATION submitted by AGGREDITED GONSULTANT, found not to be factual, then what is the provision to initiate any legal action being initiated by MoEF-SLEAG-GPCB-QGI ( NABET- NABL )-as applicable, as ACCREDITED GONSULTANT has to comply all directives set by above environmental regulatory DESIRED EIA PAGES ATACHED HEREWITH FOR A READY REFERENCE El{vtRoNMENT puBl-tc HEART G oF M/S ,SPEGTRUM DYES & CHEMICALS PvT LTD, PALSANA DIST. SURAT. GUJARAT authorities, E05 Declaration by EXpERTS, (coordinator-FAE) tMP. MANDATORY DOC, NOT SUBMITTED IN ErA t!! ot PL explaan with satisfactory reply why , such important document not submitted in ElA, ( NOT SUBMITTED IN EIA.AT LEAST WE COULD NOT FTND rN aNY Eta I -13) 02 Pl clarify ,Has MoEF/ NABET exempted you, UNDER A WRITTEN NOTE, from submitting such VTTAL anu- mandatory document in ElA. o3 .declaration' lf not, pl submit with alt dcsired details ln repsect to NABET approved coordinator, I{ABET 12 FAE, ( core.lH.empanelledlwith period of invotvement, with date and signature , and with a supporfing HARD copies of NABET minits,( pl. do not ask to refer web site), iustlfldng, the DUE approval of NABET coordinator, and all FAE, for the sector and category as assigned to this pro E06 Good that proponent has provided VALTD NABL accredited certiticate, (t) BUT pL proyade exptanation, WHy the supporting docunents for .SGOPE OF ANALYSIS l{OT provided, (iD Out of various base line studies, like, AlR, WATER ( including microbiologlcat one), SOIL, NOISE, what scopes l are covered in referred NABL acc?edited ce?tificate, ( as submltted on EtA page 661 ) (r.i) How about approved scopes ( other than NABL) of analysis, As per FRONT PAGE, M/S POLLUCON LAB,. I{ABET/ MoEF approved laboratory -!as also carried out such analysis, DESIRED EIA PAGES ATACHED HEREWITH FOR A READY REFERENCE. ENVIRONMENT PUBLIC HEARING OF M/S ,SPECTRUM DYES & CHEIVIIGALS PVT LTD, PALSANA DIST. SURAT. GUJARAT and pl. provide explanation, on, WHy copy of his NABL / MoEF approved lab certificate-with scope ot analysis, NOT SUMBITTED IN EIA (iv) Who has issued a work order to potlucon lab, Surat, proponent OR consultant, pl provide a copy of works order issued to lab ( you can erase your commercial part ) E07 pl. provade a HARD GOPY of general structure ElA, APPENDIX lll & lll A, ot EIA notitacatlon as amended till last available date, and ancorporate the same an manits of ^ this environment public hearing. E08 Mandatory, ToR compliance As thas as an expansaon proiect, we presume, proponent must be having a desired qualifaed staff for existing unit, so before submltting EIA to GPGB, Pl. provide intolmation on, was there a double check by project proponent , fol all mandatory ToR compliance (statutory & technical ), A I to 13 , B 14,1.7,I TO 4, wath all sub clause, as applicable, pl. confarm the same , AND PL. BE NOTED AT LATER DATE IF ANY INCOMPLETE / MISLEADING INFORMATION OBERVED, MoEF.SLEAG.AS.APPLICABLE HAS TO REVOKE 'EC' IF ALREADY GRANTED, AND OCI. NABET.NABL-MoEF has to cancel all their EIA preparation approval / lab approval certificates issue to consultanus, lab. E09 Rain water harvesting, Pl provide information, For EXISTING unit, For last three AY, how much m3 rain water was harvested and reused and at which operation, (in process-green belt-other as drinking water) E 10 tusDs, You haye used ,amy law materials and will be keep on using it, many must be hazaedous, OL PRIOVIDE EXPLANATION, WHY COPY OF ALL DESIRED 'MSDS' not submitted in EIA ( as such DESIRED EIA PAGES ATACHED HEREWITH FOR A READY REFERENCE ENVTRONI|EN.I PUBLIC HEARING OF M/S ,SPECTRU]UI DYES & CHEMICALS P\/f LTD, PALSA A DIST. SURAT. GUJARAT informatlon are always available from other EIA)' OR Has lUloEF permited you in writing, not to submit such MSDS in ElA, if so, pl. provide hard copy of same' What is a value addition of providing CD to GPGB' when it has not subiected for public reference. E t1 THIS IS AN EXPANSION UNIT- ON EXISTING PEMISES. GREEN BELT DESIGNING. 01 What tree density norms given by MoEF-SLEAC-GPGB- CPGB -as applicable to your project ? 02 What is TOTAL PLOT AREA. in m2 ? T FOR EX|STING UNtT, 03 How many trees, what trees, has already been planted for EXISTING unit, and what was APTI value of planted trees, o4 What was green belt area in m2 and in percentage for EXTST|NG UNIT, ? o5 What was average water requirement per m2 of green belt area, for Existing UNIT? o6 PL. PROVIDE INFORMATION ONt Whether and what qty, of FRESH wateT (61 per day )rand /or tecycled water ( m3 per day) , and lo( rain water harvested (m3 per day) used for green belt for existing area for EXISTING UNIT 07 HAD YOU GOMPLIED TREE DENSITY NORMS FOR EXISTING UNIT? FOR EXPANSTON UNtT, 08 DESIRED EIA PAGES ATACHED HEREWITH FOR A READY REFERENCE for EXPAT{SION unit' o9 What will be gteen belt area m2 and in pelcentage 'n for EXPANSION UNIT' ? to green What will be average water lequirement per m2 of belt area' lor EXPANSION UNIT? 11 PL. PROVIDE INFORMATION ON' Whether and what qty of FRESH water (m3 per day )'and /or recycled water ( m3 per day) and /or rain water hawested (m3 per day) will be used fol' green belt for EXPAI{SION UNIT' 12 HAD YOU COMPLIED 'TREE DENSITY NORMS' FOR EXISTING UNIT UNIT? 13 provade information on' whether any trees with Pl ' with qtyr with APTI values with watel detaals, ' requirement per sq m2 green belt area' Wefe planted out side of proiect area' for ExlsTll{G UNIT and for proposing unit, gsl Side Of proiect 3792 for EXPANSTON UNIT' if so, pl. provide full details, FINALLY, wall you comply green belt density norms for total ptoiect area' Before commissioning yout project' PL. GONFIRM after consulting vour NABET ACGREDITED GONSULTANT. Pt. note' if any deviation or non conformance is observed in this details, even at later date, by us or by any other public,NGo, then MoEF-SLEAC'GPCB wil be asked to revoke issued EC. a Pl. provide copy of public notice, issued in local news paper, for this environment Public hearing, b DESIRED EIA PAGES ATACHED HEREWITH FOR A READY REFERENCE ENVIRONMEIiIT PUBLIC HEART G OF M/S cllEMtcat-s pvT paLsAl{A ,SPECTRUM DYES & !Tp, D!ST. SURAT. cuJARA? rt proponent has absorbed the cost p;|i,";;." "f for rhis environmeit puotic "nd-- ] :::-"tl,"T^1"*ment iearnes, llnen Pl. tet us know app value, and whether proponenr can claim such expenses under their environmental head. GSR E 13 Pl. provide information on l,"t you have monitored NOISE "it ", LEVEL at, NH, SH, RLy L|NE ( NOT tN RLy STATION BUT AT ANY RLY TRACK AREA FROM PUBLIC ROAD), and at any other H|GH NOTSE AREA AS SUSPECTED , LIKE AT TRAFFTG JUNGTION / CHOKADI / CHAR RASTA, like wise, if so. pl. provide details and if not, why such hagh noise area not consldered for monitoring noise tevel-OTHERWf SE, STNCE lT tS l- NECESSARY TO PROJECT THIS DETAILS, PL. NOTE, THIS BASE LINE STUDIES WILL HAVE TO BE CARRIED OUT AGAIN, and incorporate the same in MoM, WE REQUEST DIST. MAGISTRATE, ( chair person, environment public hearing) to instruct proponent for this, if our comment as worth for consaderataon. E14 D1 Uarious photographs as pasted, in ElA, are of which date. pl. specify it EtA page wise, and photographs wise, ,2 lUhy digital date photograph not pasted, just to iustify, :he same wete taken durlng base line studies period. r 'OR 1{EXT T!ME, NABET AGCREDTTED CONSULTANT ENSURE, THAT ALL PHOTOGRALHS W|LL BE WtTr{ 'YILL ,IGITAL DATE ONLY WITH SOMNE ONE FROM THAT ITREA WHERE BASE LINE STUDIES WERE COT{DUCTED E 15 How you wilt ensure, that , nearest .mindhola, river, 1-.6 km) will not be polluted in any way, by your project 4c!!Yi4e!:__ E't6 For all raw material storage, have you carried out COMPATABILITY STUDIUES for storang a|| RM, if, so pt. provide the same, and if not, pL. PROVIDE THE SAME, AND CONFIRM, YOUR STIRAGE DETAILS ARE IN ORDER wtTH THtS COMPATABtt.tTy sTuDutEs, DESTRED Era pa('Es ATAGHED HEREW,TH FORA READYREFE[Ett(lf, OF lll/s DYES & ENVIROXMENT PUBLIG HEARTNG 'sPEcrRuM GHEMTCALS Pvr LTD, PALSA!!4 !Er:!gl4r:9glll4r E17 EfA 3, ( Pages 277 to 385 ) No HEAoER FoorER FoR PRoPoNENT/coNSUL THESE ARE VITAL DETAILS OF PROJECT PROCESS DETAILS. Surprisingly' why EIA 3 ( starting from disperse yellow 3 has no any confirmation on which G, 2Oo %...... , ' propiect proponent this EIA belongs and who NABET ACCREDITED GONSULTANT has prepared this EIA report' how data cab ne considered as authenticated' you not change ElA,3, then pl. affix all the NOW, It can ' pages ( 277 lO 385) with RUBBER STAMP' OF PROJEGT PROPONENT & COI{SULTANT with signature and then only inco?porate the same in MoM. Out of 112, pages ,Only I page is down loaded to iustify this quote, and attached here with for a Teady reference of all concerned as marked in to & cc columnt E 18 Since the project proponent is a signatory to submit this EIA to GPCB, the date for environment public hearing' already allotted by respected Dist' collector/dist. Magistrate, and all procedings being conducted under presence of Dist. Magistrate, ( chair person' dist. environment public hearing ), we would strongly appeal, project proponent, to carry out one more detail review of entire EIA report, through their own staff, or through consultant ( with NABET approved coordinator and '12 FAE ) or through outsource any other personnel, may be a retired govt staff, and then only to submit a final EIA report. so that, at later date, more statutory /technical queries can not be reported by any public, NGO. Or, as usual GPCB only should not issue a closure notice for not complying environmental set directives, as, entire commissioning of expansion project, SOLELY depends upon QUALITY of this EIA report, hope, all regulatory authorities as marked in to /cc column will definitely agree, F We would lake to attend, a final EC meeting, with MORE DESIRED EIA PAGES ATACHED ITEREWITH FOR A RE/A'DY REFEREIICE ENVIRONMETT PUBLIC HEARI "".",go.i"-iii,ii.-ff,11n3,'"T1"";"Jf,llXlI jlj". -:" G #.s-9:+rr!E3tthti!aeerins, we request Ms-GpcB, to torw"ra .-,;:;;-. _^_. - l H prosress' supported bv A cooD quarty oi;;;;,;;"''"t ."" no technrcar query, as ,, ;;Tt"l}:":lfff AGGREDTTEO li? CONSULTANTS, which, i, tu-, fir" setting up of an environ'r-ir-rri, cr ra,- "rr-=rr"" I t!. puts OR cfarification_ ' _,_,__.__t!:::=s.tF ,.aarit^.t J l{ope, our pretaminary feed back -"y irrrpror" quality of r EIA , and ourfu her review studies is continuing, and the inlormed ro Ms K tr-::gtt+we suggest, proiect eprg =qE!94qte. proponent sho.rld asE=siG content s of thls ElA, eighter through lN HOUSE STAFF OR outsource the experts, to assess the paid for this EtA is worth or not , & MoEF-SLEAC.NABET-]||ABL.GPCB-GPGA to assess the quality of this ElA, whether it is worth for setting up the environmentaly SUSTATNABLE unit i]r Gujarat, or at later date only, as usual, GpGB wit| issue a closure notices. where bv- ,,::incraaqina _ _:::::! ..-6h-r^..-^-l L lhanks, :::=r !!l:nr lUanish B patel Pl excuse for any typing or any other mastakes. File-spectrum-patsana-25051 a M ENC. DESIRED EIA PAGES DOWiI LOADEDTiOM GiPCB WEB SITE, IS ATACHED HEREWITH, FOR A READY REFERENCE. N iFT Eil TM{T - {CI IFT f{STF _+A_utq tQ.q - _-\zrqrTkr(q FILE -SPECTRUM.SURAT-2505{ 8 DESIRED EIA PAGES ATACHED HEREWITH FOR A READY REFERENCE ''v\ ANNEXURE.C 1+ lvl Gmail yagnik patel <.nv.r'.gnii@9f^?) alr.com> Welcome ot Spsctrum Oyes and Chemicals <6nv.ys9n'kclg@it.@m> t.g.at p.t l foe. May 22, 2016 ar 5 22 PM To [email protected]. I rculd lito io sy fd ths tis expansin or Sp.ctrum Oyos and Chemi€ts Pvr Lld, pdsaa spelMn oy6. a ch.maals w,rt5 lo expa.d lneir business, lt is eaiy app@'al.d nM b€€use sFclrum has a lo.al endoym.t b€ctqrolnd. ded@ted lo €nvirodrFnt 3oa€6s pogF|lm dsv6bprr6l ready to d*rcp fi6 t@l s6 €6nohi. lif€ stylo ol p€opl6 ld oivi.g val@bb tund6 !o 6du6tion sysrem. This 6rT.ny is €ally a€e *har tE do and $i|l do. ,eodino to csR rhe, h.@ w6lt prcp.r.d visjon t@. Ih's Unir rdally mpo.ranr lor the $e GOP.I Gqar.l 's 'ncrease In Enwonm.nial mans I rould lil6 lo inldm you rh3r Sp€drum 6 vdy aclrE ,l@b€r ot Na Pahana hdostriat asialion iCETP ) Pta.r, *hEh B lro orga.'elon io c@mat io ev..nvtdm.nr. So, We ae @lcme lh6 Poi:cl. M.S..Enviondent Sci. a\tlaas: iloti Bha av. Asdol €9*'...,^. ilN\ \(, sd'N t ANNEXURE.C 13' YG, vtilQrs arlbsr{l efl, GaiaPr 3?cl qd)s catc'tct Oqa: qctarett .atd utc)cr tis?q st€rl ?i"s illsca ur' Gr' 'll f6atdct ardca sfl. qqura4edl?dqr{lqd'q?rll}|,dlgsl:\'lc{ltSlluxalldorurracrrgiucr?ittrl'4tdutdcr iiaq slJl ai.s SRsc+l lQ{ uclceut 3et?t) 'le earo dect 'tig 1i' grr tttqqt c1'rzt< utc) edt dqo{l ctt} 4 trrefl 14 du"{l t}. dq4 eqt:t l))otqqt uRot:g d. ur dqdl {'l)otlc) rqrdls ar)s)d e)"vrrr{l g{l ''rr3 d r4ls trEtt r{d 3,ro{l eqtat ctt}t"tt fasta rt) etrgtt str) serf d aai 5?d. sJld 'lcr ridcl s).ofl. erurgcr, ,rcrstelt vtel,{ls ettol qii.. iv4 dr ur .rqt v'lo)sa ql ritqqten ga0 z)"tcrt{l 6lofl eq), ?'trQil { urr u'l'}sa d a,ttqspqt4 ate) i aeste:it 5'l.f) cttq 4r Gsta tlt) etrrudl ed) t) :i"i cau oatect g ql d,r"fl a dr ?n?cr 5?, g. z'rrvo) lQat3j 4q gura ledl qcloqe arJ)ti : e3.o'r.Coqz C\oV*ilt"l .//- @F\ ANNEXURE-C I-3 !G, y rl'lQrs ulastd eil, fct?rcr Ygqer Geier:r ca)j g?d l?qar qcrsrerr t'rrcl uardcr e)s4:r srur::i,s 3l-isc+ yr. l?. 4 qcrlls faqdrl ol lc4cl idq 'jil, $ ac0o urdla ?dqt?fl qcl+ttel Jl{, dtgat: ,.rc.rarerr uNafld vuroolg i qcrettett qrd rarr)cr eQsgrr st€Jrl ?i-s e[iscn Gd :acrcqqr 3aru) va aar.r r)eqr :1ig 9.,, ear iv4 crrq ,fl aefl X4 :iv4 d. rdr 5u4 eqrer ,1rtqt )611tct.tt,.lfiqttg ,r"rarq atc) d. aar d,r'0 rt))o{rc) lelrds cr)s)d e).rrlal g:l ,rr3 d. 5q4 eqrer olqqr Gslet qr) ererr srq) setI t] u4 see). ult?t s{)d ,{crarel ,ald ertdcr 3l.ol). 6tg€(1, qc{?1t?1 ytErfls alqt qJ)).. .rr qr 5q4 otr "lqr u'lc)sa zrrqqrel erQfl e)"rcrrd Ooil eie), ulell d 4t !)c)sa d a,irosraqr.il ale) .) aosre rll dq.f) crrq qr Gsrs rr) errru.fl id.l t) ,"r.) q€it?qt carq g z'it riv4 d aa z'rev szr gi. z'tt\tq) GZr q({atetl otalut t ?3.oq. eoqz , / R4f\ ,r\ c(A\ V "p\* ANNEXURE.C20 Wednesday r0 ' \tct. g{1 xrlfr's -}'^l,jl, ' lil.* >qut. ian>r..J ur!, "+r<( s.$vq :ScS )f>lSc-+1.fl a'i;g -{a'q.''N : -! ti' _, , x$tq *{\, x l -)t o.iq' !l,i-ca p{.. ;r \ hr 8\r-fl qc\\{\ rfia\er.} I} r51-,.-r2 q1-., -.-l *,irj fu u r-,r q.r. er r'rrri i-,,ir.r..l- fue.-^= {sc1 .A9*I gurdo Eriaond rrlcr I flrg3r riurua aerqell arg+r riuraa rtqatel, li. gra ffi :detet : g.u). cdqr, ar. u< x*"x{lttl"xi,ilY.;"q':L groaY &''D 0' a.r:trQ +rr ft\tr\\t tt ".i ar6r4 r{ #* nr".r-r*) .iot}t'leli ,.^tr} }' 3^r ciea' ..s"' L*rt ['r,'11 stl'aut4 ejtri ",iTer ). orrr",l ')tcr)o?l itn.t rtu'' '241t1- zeuoa gr?t{ s\iti el*ri\i€-t- '{l &l ':;.€ ' -iq,\.r rrrp"rai ir,.19 1;}ct Afr srr "hsr a31q a^tGe ir ne"ut *t\ill-- ft.,. r. -4ae\\ 'rpur "rt\ ol 6.Q' ".gr<'rrr:,r, U{'"I[-\.roq Rr -srcrrn'q\e]..",) .{ .nur "n. "i. ' a,1r,.-,rqi .?.r/ e.ra.i .)* q;U ..r'',r.rrai arril utrl..$- | - (itS ,qaulzQ sui -arer:rg{,, erurorrri cr{ e^nut{ e ....,r.il N.*u E. sr€(rrg\ crfcg €'€q ei eQ r 1+rr.rsf oiiar e*otQt.t. .:.rr r €rtE o?ra, a-ar sj egD 0. .,srrr ftu*rt+ai, I o.rt *rer$er -,, *,i rlt .3.rocrr{i .rrl.r= O. €qi sr'tttr ef}rq q alrt Ti sitL, l|fr .rtr'(l arroi'r etr?,rqr.r'r arriq--D.trori oPcg qu ,D.dqv *."S qgg ct €r.rcrtj)'tr orro{€rt- aa, crPcg .etoa.ri"{ elcf aartl.tl ftrrrrt+ar'r c C.z4J at&a [t16uq ..,lr.'0. e,fl't,*n eH a'iutfi,Citl .f..4, -a o{:6!nQ' €cii crr4E. .e'rer+r pltnnei.qi4 fi $f\e 9:.r 0. ?qz gfarei zuri 'q,et SueTau gF-atL Q ."rrl' Q.u:!lqq a+r) e Atu il 'trr>.r $&lerl -T ' Satar{l -rt .tier i 4en{ 'rriJz urril ' tserretcrt ji.r .'+4 crrc-q Euii @f 5, ".ta.r -g.$.rt4 -f'L. etla,{ Su ir ctre$l' r,rt}q 4rttrr a'b earurtl{ \-qsrrrrsr..\"4- 3lrl ga'rqr -griar-t &-rt .i$llt- o$*'r.i .r.i -rer ;1+A a' } Sttrrr"6\ -? "{\E q*{. ArQ r, a'. : ddlq : .{lcr,,,,r, ^r,r._0{ qrt}t aor.\"q .>" *q{rq .rl$giq e'riar $.a1 Sa. {ari 6rc1 *16r{ .o-;€Fr a3rr F. z..ior?. €nucq dl| er.i, - a.i *r$ Id o"o .q *q .EEa. atr{. eppri'.rrq! F+c1sr .,^Y31i, arr ErbH {aor{{-n r,r.lar Rmre\{ fe+ftr dear qrsr4 z4rc--q *Druay ' r.i 3"1o ,{0 otnsl .rr{- :u.r= Q .rre{ er6' } " GUJARAT STATE {vfld flr{ AT. & Po. AALESWAR' U. ul. olc:l'Ui Ta. Palsana, Oist. Sutat ar. q<{dtelt, l?. Y.4 /eot< / cq ar{lu : .r..tf o1.t/ t< n ANNExuRE-c zz sZl*aedt,"e^t{L, (5{<\ lc gl'c{' ftrq er :- +t.nqq..t +N..r -g,,lrr .A ddlU : ce) .r,rr r\1 a.q olA\t{l iirofi o. fqe.rsu:! .-.'il;"t*s,l 3t."k*. { *.' nerr ri"\e{i.,.\i ol.rq .$4-stg orluqrii.r.ul- Cr4l .llrqr{r fqrql eq'r * :l-.rfl,rr rroi giu }-tl.l tl 6"ir "tr,Q*\ O .-t."r *r.*.oi a4 D€g esrst 3x1ge4 3, 6tna\r.u:l €irlre-q rrri dArr4 O. i. +Q .O*1 "ifr l_" ^r,t6,^'ui ca45q q,&r,.l'"rrt +.,.g- !sl"r , .r"6 >+"rl8q .s\dlq g."^'.q .u.s. (t3) dA\\a\ -,,,.rq" e5qfi - crurg St,.fC 31+-..r,q\-1 ta&-$i\ oe$. *'a 1Srrqr') a.tri +rt6' l*q }it S.:li -rr f*r {ar el .ri. d>1.i .'rr-rrii=t1 gulq.. eJu'' Lca.: fug atarrlr{'r *,.a ao"d-,r qi a, og'4-*i Slxl o1., ;, g€re se.a .grr ,,.a .rt*stdqr'l d3 n{{au g\ €t* 'roq aMal4. Qr:u rt-t C.r|f{:! b - auj. tla o.g,"+1.r-, -AC\ taury4 'qtcr9'-gaq\\lltil' (of: 4!.r .ir. i ol}et2t t otv a+ruX ara.er r. qtY r qll -rl Qr fi.uq %?q d-\lFt(,-!r @_€_41 , caa) ob{a{ret olr.{dr fhf$ct i 5'.C1 crluatec $urji da43f. $atl aiis.t aiue.rr rri S*.rrd ar\\\cr\ { Lcc) .rl.r r-\r1 €"rls.-ol .rrQ la*uq1q d*6iet- ij qt$$irq orcr c-\a\\84 t\rr ir Ur c lL .A\ a-qa{ d c\\4 aAq clAgl'\trl '\ Arq a1-!\-) ..G q.rnd c<$cr -..r,otqt asti 1n .rA85\t1 c{r?ri +rc+t\.l trrt' €r*l n+ t s€rprrrri or,.r\ *.ara\ -\ t *,,1 .'^,,..*1t. 5gr ilb5rl dtE ogrt rr.tpo.eacm gv d .'tr 7a. Palsana, Oist. S0rat +'r(- +rra .19.El j':"- - ; J'o3;or )-nrc-r.li.n4c11 kli"*Ti*\r1 er\ rr .Qrrw ".:cot t-t " 'g\) i'{ \rarQ .qqq1 .^... .l";,\:-T'";"'!.ffiTQrri"r q{ eo,*$.a :i1s$ :yd\\ :1"1.*q<{ ia:14 rldi'til.,;1 (9kl d-sl ,r.1q1Efl,.."nl orh .rr._,fqe{- at o.r.rl \\ i\ Str.e.trr- ?lcdlll 6€5 a{{i-t're t{ t -\Cl zr$cJ '{5'er8-. I Cocor €'\ c{rrA .r.rr& eyr\6 cfi qq*qX** .r*\k,t, -t rX$- c$r$'s -Ese.!% CL\?AI adl -1c"1 -$e:B \g /A\ *Jw"oJ'1.r.-.' B.'d.-*'' *"/l € S"nscor , sr{s'eA<\l ftGS $ -Qr{t3.-e e/l }aaT ga +3t{ c.rir.rsrai ofl lral0'piot -g.,r t"-tlil-'ri ---*G i!, 'R{\ | ,-<\ *J\ Gtl a4 oicrl ''x'{\ qgcrt *'/\ \t(\ -q{,N-a\ "^r-rof -r.<.<- q{b\s, r(!r.rr, :lr'i"'Q ajLA. =o*t rrL{\ Photographs (Annexure-23) ANNEXURE.C 2q dt ?q-q-?o1a uRr{l ucett sesar uEq q?ct. trt"t"0er Udq 3 uat*s a1s g r. 4 6q"{l u1 o. ict"s 66q16.1 er[A:{"t {h,il,{tell ,0stncu ee ar{lr+.ti ielc{ srqr Av"ttRi qtnrf {Zdl ut{rl qtqrars 0 r,ri slttvg x1n", .,uuel j*a*Ai",uo., qtdrq?gt{i artndr ?{esrqq. u}dl es ${!e qly"u r4r {lqfl{i o,*o** *a tr{- Qcll {fl qicr D. z. ir{dlQ e.u"0 rlh.{lqUidl qqrsr ?4a )rlda{d"t "os('lcrt- ciqi cqqNlrqor 8?ql t"0a{ot qeql oa{l ste 0 rrQ. l !{ i <,uei {dqa ruGd r,uqqr{i e. l Q6lg cier ruqfi4t Ogtcr u] a: flel"e s{l ,ar"*ri ,ua. o",. uq(l cErp r{i il:1il:::*1stuqq ttdi qrq0 uqil qG i"ll ta? u{tgl } strtd slsqr){i r'uQ g. gr{dlt ",8;{i;;; Qcll r'rufl t{ict 0. qqrdr qfcq,e.{l o.,nTu-lu*l rtu{l "t }crtq i cu{ .r}€rfl oecia,j -.ia'"l :]i:li*-ltirl qt{rt qi 'u} {ict 0. "r"* ' Uqt?t ai{ clrclqqldl qrx{l , rstr,[ o"o, ,*, uq eQa qrdq qur,r r{?a{ds-* .* rqRer -r,{rLet {ul dr,{c{r,{l .tl ixi fq4?l i(E tl€st? r4t{l grq. rirf. JiEt uq0' Rstei epqtqi " !"1: qr{?trt s{ otqtqq('( qr ;1ilff '{q0 uq<' tq"{re cia{rrar€, 12. a{rral qrqa qeA Rqtd ficuq cm rudl qd i {t}.{l a{t,{ g]litet r,u seqtt urQ iqdl qrt ecll r,rufl ior 0_ r:. re{Rs Al GIQa Qrlcr:r(?-ia iudll alar vclr qr 4g{ {d i u} r,u Qr 6ue-I5d o{qi Are{ Rqq c{6 gg\qt qa aq d41{ uq..tl g?c{1 .1u r4?"d B. qta{? t(0 utua-r {iaq yy'"nq_. qlct E{aa{d gl. s. Annexure-D A statement showing written replies given by Project Proponent of M/s. Spectrum Dyes And Chemicals Pvt. Ltd., at Block No. 484, 502, 503, A, 504 and 505, NH-8, Palsana, Ta. Palsana, Dist. Surat (Gujarat), to response and comments received in written format from other concerned persons in the Environment aspects for M/s. Spectrum Dyes And Chemicals Pvt. Ltd., for Proposed Expansion of SO Dyes -900 MT/Month, Dispersing Agent -1500 MT/Month Or Formulated SO Dyes -2400 MT/Month and Dyes Intermediate – 750 MT/Month, plant located at Block No. 484, 502, 503, A, 504 and 505, NH-8, Palsana, Ta. Palsana, Dist. Surat (Gujarat), before Public Hearing held on 25/05/2018 at 11.00 hrs at Late Shree Chhotubhai Dayalji Desai Hall, Behind Post Office, Palsana Main Road, Vill: Palsana, Ta. Palsana, Dist: Surat (Gujarat) as per the Ministry of Environment and Forests, Government of India, New Delhi vide its notification no. S.O. 1533 dated 14/09/2006. Comments received in writing from Concerned Sr No Annexure Persons Gram Panchayat Makhinga, 1 Sarpanchshri, At. Makhinga, Ta. Palsana, Dist. D-1 Surat Gram Panchayat Italva, 2 D-2 At & Po. Italva, Ta. Palsana, Dist: Surat Palsana Gram Panchayat, 3 Sarpanch, Shri P.P. Ahir, D-3 At. Palsana, Ta. Palsana, Dist: Surat Gram PanchayatBaleshwar, 4 D-4 At. Baleshwar, Ta. Palsana, Dist: Surat Shri B.M.Patel, Paryavaran Seva & Charitable Trust, 5 D-5 11, 1st Floor, Service Complex, P.No. 200, GIDC, Pandesara, Surat Mr. Mahesh Pandya, Paryavaran Mitra, 6 502, Raj Avenue, Bhaikaka Nagar Road, Nr. Thaltej D-6 Cross Road, Thaltej, Ahmedabad Gujarat Pollution Control Board Regional Office, Belgium Square, Silver Plaza Complex, Opp. Linear Bus Stand, Ring Road, Surat -395 003 Website: www.gpcb.gov.in Shri Tejash P. Desai & Shri Pankajbhai Desai, 7 D-7 At. Palsana, Ta. Palsana, Dist : Surat Shri Rohan Ahir, 8 D-8 Vill: Palsana, Ta: Palsana, Dist: Surat Shri Ashish Vilani, 9 D-9 Vill: Palsana, Ta: Palsana, Dist: Surat Shri Manish Mahadevwala, 10 D-10 Vill: Bardoli, Dist: Surat Shri Rahul Puranik, 11 D-11 Vill: Palsana, Ta: Palsana, Dist: Surat Shri Mehul Dhimmar, 12 D-12 Vill: Palsana, Ta: Palsana, Dist: Surat Shri Kaushik Manubhai Patel, 13 D-13 Vill: Baleshwar, Ta: Palsana, Dist: Surat Mr. Yogesh P. Pandya, Safety Health and Environment Association 14 D-14 208, Vadilonu Ghar Shopping, Complex Kasak Fuwara, Bharuch Shri Dharmesh Mistry, Block No. 14, House No. 1340, Narmada 15 D-15 Appartment, Opp. Mamaltdar Office, Dist. Bharuch Shri Manish B. Patel, 16 D-16 Vill: Gangpur, Ta: Palsana, Dist: Surat Shri Yagnik Patel, 17 D-17 Vill: Bardoli, Dist: Surat Shri Tushar Surati, 18 D-18 Vill: Baleshwar, Ta: Palsana, Dist: Surat Shri Yatin Ahir, 19 D-19 Vill: Palsana, Ta: Palsana, Dist: Surat Shri Pranav Shukla, 20 D-20 Vill: Palsana, Ta: Palsana, Dist: Surat Gujarat Pollution Control Board Regional Office, Belgium Square, Silver Plaza Complex, Opp. Linear Bus Stand, Ring Road, Surat -395 003 Website: www.gpcb.gov.in Smt. Sudhaben Hemantbhai Desai, 21 Member of Taluka Panchayat, Palsana, Dist.: Surat D-21 At & P.o. Baleshwar, Ta.: Palsana, Dist.: Surat 22 Baleshwar Ishroli Group Gram Panchayat D-22 Shri Anwarmiya Amirmiya Sheikh, 23 D-23 Vill.: Taraj, Ta.: Palsana, Dist.: Surat. Shri Hemantbhai Dahyabhai Patel, 24 Paryavaran Bachav Samitee, D-24 Ta: Palsana, Dist: Surat Shri Ebrahim Musa Patel 25 D-25 Ex. Sarpanch, Vill: Samrod, Ta: Palsana, Dist: Surat ANNEXURE.D 1 SPECTRUM dr{lq: eq/oq/?ola uR r{1, n?liq/ darrl r{1, {t0Jtt cI{ ri{.?r qoe, ,{os0, qor [iqq, lnd +Qriq stdt d* ][dsc{ Bdae AQ)s oct]g "t vu r, qi uou rr18 uauqtr v. gra. uqlqrqftq cls q"uoqft dr.. ?q,/q,/?ol. aL r1n etrlct 0. I xt] ltG.0 rtu.rL ortora. {ta"{l{ Eo{ s{1, qQa qi u1*sa $9a oqu{ ri<,i0a r,tqc.tls'rl r lturrl0ial I uafdr rieal|{i ql "{ll u{rql ia{t{l +q}aar r{'.{hl tihl. 9q '( fiqa{ € ctt r,u Qgql"0 rufi.{l rerRs cnqtqi sralsr{ trier +uras ottut 1rjrtr.01rri ttLudl. 4rqcn{i rata.c{. 0. (0t4r6A .il0Q}ua roos"0 ulJlsn-x Sttr) ?. qt rlgH"il srdrt{l urirt r(r. rlQa v1irea1 sr{st{ {tei{ r({{l qrq qaa riqrarai a€11. riqraraHi ' 0 qfS ue u(l.e srqr {t) urriqz 59.ctrum Dls & Ch.m(.lt Pvr Lrd a!ta-502-!o3 -50.. x.|r. xo.;4, P.h.D, !a! Goi.rn-t 9attt xdi. i .9t $2aaot5t5, .91 ga2aSarlba . inioa.c. dr.ct.{ cig utgtl Hlgc1 qi R"tt rrco 0c.tl 0atz[t,"ru {x ga rrvu 041 ri"rcittt{ \rt{lar et[.rcn{ }octct (derzftqu {s tlQ uq0 cereui ad. al l"tt Qrt'{iar d aga. l{fscrcnqi 4qrl. c{g Acr.r Us?qt ? ut"rl (dU "i, ao ltctr "i. ?.c r,rt rls{"[ ue{qqgr Orc-rt{. atgstxi utQa sslert cu{{ r,nd.a cerp {e(fl '{bcn }Qlc.t lieflqi Eact r,t3rqrd r{l{a pepl r,ri lrqr l"se qi !ra{e lgrl"u cri{l {uaf cteredl rtcrrqar trEf rtrrq art{af E. € r4tul c 61.{1. "u dal rarict rtlq iqr Ntr.rf argrrrri o1a a1 1"0 B r,ri r,rdl u€l?rat ro rll rq [dRa eu:ril. ,{rGdl qrqdl. yr0 qrr 5. rlt dsq lQlcl ui ruaq"j dc sD.d.un Oves & Ch.m'cale A^ lrd a{a+so2-5o:U-5o4, N.ri. no.d t Lo, S!nr, G{j..n-t9!r5, hdL I .rl 102440675, .91 9ala5Adl . hba3o.drudivt .m www sp.clrumdv.s com R.B n.f.d ofii(.:br, ACMC A.r|, ArxrE i llrL io.d, Aidh.,i lEl, Mcnh.i a0d)59 crN No U2al IOMH 19a9PTCl7@a SPECTRUM ld+atr qsrat Qar gtu rqtn ur o]?. Rar 5va sr.rtr{i {r.{il. i i"0 glct dqndl qrGd r,{rqdl. !. ?. r{L Asl{\i rJ["( Qce r{estrdl"tt faq\ €qtct qa qQa olladce fdcra gralsr{l grc !aa1 €ld Attd dar qe("{l ru?lrr u4l "i. rs i{t tJl4rt A QQrqi gt,-t"n"u riur{. rtnr Qr.ldirg rn sl€s "i 10.9 ut"ri "i. ry,{ ur r,{Lic0 B. ger"0 duqr"{l {tG.ft"{l dsa qtl{"{l. 13. r,u rfu){ ui:l"ft gl{l :J.drra i Rqfiseqt ultre "[t rn {t[d.0 - utlfig u4lq?qr {c{{l larqcu loar cpce ulcqeta !q1c.t a1!, qr< urfull rorr1. r*i cpcg ecnrt saqr{i r,(ie. 5custa ui tJqtlrl Qqfl "0 age qLqdl. 1U. r4r ds{ d 5attrc Aare ccce a- r,u oicldl uGdl - uLtFIs sl{ clver.r r,rflst{l"lt +t{ nratrt r,ri O]Erd. ulcEt"r 3llet a13, qaa ur{d rror1. ,{L@d qt''{dl. \ \.t. qr rlgl erp {i rig urgft Ar r{ {3{ ErP rri {rQ+ia.0 rig uLqft qtq0 dq.da.Jl q6 s?cr( cerp qrl ! ug0 g6 s?cn qerl : cuu 3r. iaal ud qtl cpca ur{ "[ {tGdl clq al i"[ Etq B. t{tGd d asa qrudl. 1S. r4r rlsq i crd toor"lt g't Ec r{ r,tt asxi crd ?ooy'n Vcn Ec {i irBrac{ cnq(ie ladl ttct'j uraa tla adl <,rdl err<"j 'lcta stc{rqi urqi 0. ec qrG.[ r,tqc{I. idl iucrq"n RQ! tJwtta Qultqi ut"ri "t. r c s ur utQc.ft d. to. l*( Art o ? eqtrt utq0 al qurter rngftat curtet rei lAse ?rttqqrdl qct rre1. a1 urg-<,ug fd.t :xlil' lf ;ru1;:l I.-. * *'.".*,o,.o ,.gr ror.orrs,.er *rr:rgo Ardtn" &dt ro'd' a^ i,fi,fi'Jiffi€jg'ifi r. urruoulrgorrcrror R€,Lste'.d Oftce :101, ACME t|.I., -*#, SPECTRUM uGdl ugrgt r, 0.orcr v.'r, qtdi 'i, rer- 1?q,99?r+ ro, ld.otr:r ro.s, qr+i.i, rqo u? r,(qc,{l 0. 14. qr rls{ri on(? sr?ou "0[i oql €r(? s€ou "0[i Rq,{ ljro{"tl ? arq] lrc{'( s?{i ? arqil r,{ra a dia. i{a a di"r( ?t{erg } }f{s("n{ "r{ ruaq ! lQrcnat "u){ qi I dcl"r Oqtt a Qql, {i }o{e . . ?..e uro(i ,r. ?q r{?sr?s{l< q? dlli Rq{"ft "rga.... 0 4a I dclat herrr Qr,r{l }Qsc.r (rjtn?t) Aqql, ?o@ "t Gd{r€"r, d:to r,{a qr.ertd' l9r!r gecn xi qtqil. \e. €m? s€ dcl"{ entaqr } }Qscar a1 qQa Or ui sflqi. I ?o. rrclarq[ ctteJ8u[ Yoo Qs{ 4Qet B r,{r ?,icf"(l {(Gd - uLtGls slfl rlveta d{ ur tu}q Hr) GpcB , tegrc url ulcqet"t 3?1c-t r,r13. qra ur{ell rrot1. €tldl dur{ u. , U?rfJt auuu, f3urer {airq.e, o1Q?ct,o{rq. {uqc-t"n "{l {Gdl l,{tqc{l. ?1. r+t ds){r{i srrn{ra a{} qqrtar qt dcl"{l RJr.r or,toQ Qul|l{i 4Qe0 0 SQsc+ r,{i rrruqr"0 r+a< utelcal vr?q u, faattct r.e u("ri.i. r?6 .,{a qa qg qd, {( uq ua qa[q?qr Ur?g tO, Aa{trt 10.9, qtcti i. ?'{o. q? qtt? cPcB €c(?r 10 6UIdr So.clrum Ov.t & Ch.h(.lt M l!! l-al.-lo{t-gt3rg,., r6,n, P.r..E, S{.! G!i..n.:ttrar5, irli: t €r lta2aaottts, €t'..tr. t ilaslllta . itloa$.ovndv...@ wrw lD€drundve\ .om R.auler€d Otl'.e :101, A(Ml Ph., A't I\.d nrb id, A.dlE i la), Mqnb.i a@59 clN N o u2ar IOMH I989pIC!760O SPECTRUM fdr.trr"tt ou]t rirnqa r,ri rttq t rli nryact of?r af i"0 uGdl ttL.'{dl. r,u rlgrr eqtet i"tt [ardtr ro {l{l qi r,{ qgqa r,ttlro{tv"tt rtt{a urrtRs, urQ.cl rttuLqi +(,{tRg, trtfds. ott0ts qr(fs, r(U!, 6taq qtrl:q, dl {ta sla grqf, Rlerq r,urlcar. Al sla aq. 6ltu attrr rA B l,ta ?Ai,0ctt ro ?U, u{ As'{){i emqqt } Ultcq4r QaB r*r r,icl"{l {tfdd - UILGI! sl{l olv?td e[ 6.,rd ad c].n.tl usre, it{"0 {rat, qfcEu4 !tlc.{ o13, qa< utlell roit. ir{"j ur(q, {rorq, u{ qd, q?{q?q( qtl qt{? {uqt'u GPCB ul +t(trc1 €ler.1l a"0 qtGdl qtqdl. q{ qtGd ?q. ut Qsri "j cuQs 6.ute"tqOO se'Isdl Ocu ro "ft ctfsgt4t"0 uqtoil qt3 61al . .r{ erfd+"r .rgrat az R'll t{i l{tai .t. q,.te ue qtqa{l 0. urLf*g r,uEr stq{i qtutq4t €]tt af qr ucu0a Orarrqi lacu sqi str. r+L argt tai rerd. qturqt{i r{tc?t. i"0 ,{tR.0. q{"rt,tqlq?E qQqtqaE ?s. r,u dstr{ Ec<.u ar+ !n rLs{"t el8 cr{ "tt } [3a r,rlBa Qq10 dsc.L... Qu10"0 {rG.0 cpce s?curri "u dl sl{{i r{t r,rLd<-t E. ?o. r{t rls{at ocat aqt q{"u qtNs r,{ A3{"( Oc So.drum Ov.3 & Ch.mr..lt M trd t-aL-!O2-5o:ll5oa, rr,ll. iro.-& P.h..., S!nr, G!i.r:r-:t!xttt, r.di, r +9I 9124'(tt5t5, €r 9!245!96 . tilotra..hfidys..6 ww so..rru6dy.5 coo i.B6r.r.d offic. Ol, ACMa ,1.r, AraL,l xurL t . r{r ds'{ Q ual ctd. dse{ sroo rl"s UIsa{ ut. (d 1u[0ga uGsall Sp. subjecr: Information on querys towards lws. spectrum Dyes & chemicars p!,t. Ltd. Brock No.4g4,502, 503 A, 504 & 505, palssna, Ta. Dist.Surat for Enuiron.entat pubtic H"a,ing O";s/saof f. Derr Sir. With res-pect to observation / comments / questions regarding the proposed project & drafi EIA repon, we would like to give our cladficalion as belo$. civing these units infotmation-li- tGal E)(ecutive sumrn.ry is giuen-nihi-lociliiiguug" (Gujarati). (According ro EtA Notification 2006 as per AppendixlV) The execulive sum maD-oilh-E unirlll The execurive rurmary o- rhel6SGJlrqecr found in village panchayal. rs Siven by CPCB lo Sarpanch / Talari for publishing oD rhe norice troard in rhe village l nere are rhore tnan 50 dying mill. Rclated informarion - witt Ue avaitaUte ar incinerator planl. chemicsl plant in lhis area, Regional oflice, Gujarat Pollution Control Board. $here the air pamrneters when and wherc Surat. rdxsD oy \rrl-|' ano gtven oelatts ol tt accordrng to norms. Ihis unit sends several MLD;asG;;G;!o Currontly,965 kilo liters/ day and-1f80 tito CETP parameters and its online are noL liters / d.y total 2245 kilo liter / day purified shown. The copy of its pat"ameter... water will be sent to CETP. Det ils of warer quality are given in the EIA repon, paRe No. lJ for further delails pl€as€ refer chaprer 2l page no 37, Figure no. 2.9 (b). Before the enrironmintafili iEoiliG In lhe Kadodara village. the PEPL has fire render- onrl, al presenl, al the time ofthe accident in and fire safety equipment. the Chemical facrory, giving information about the equipmenl that has be€n in excess oftime, in rhe taluka. This produces unit heavylhemicah. Civ-e Details of $e product for lasi four-monrhs hi"i its four month CST bill, export information, been put on GST"s websit€, and producl inlbnnation. In this unit, giving infonnation-boui-rhe Related information provided-n th-EIA .epon improvement of all the CCA, NOC, EC P.ge No.273,189 6nd 4ll. rilldate. 5p.cr.u6 Oy.i & Ch.m'..t3 P( lrd p.e.n r{!r5o2-5o1ta!lt, i.|l. xo.-8, , s{nr, cci.Er.Soa!13, kdt t +91 9i2riot5r5, €1 9a2a5t9oaa . r,,iocrr..t undv.rcm wsr R€86r.r.d offi.. :tor. AcMa ,t r., A..h..t tod. no.d, a.dh.,i (t), Mum!|i /utr59 crN No u2at roMsrgalrflclr56 SPECTRUM 8. tn this unir, which w chemicals a!! u-;; we do not us€d ctrem-cati wfiii[GJitrtbiied ftw material and given the details of Dy Deoils given chemicals Sovemment. of raw material in which ar€ prohibited by the EIA reporr, Chapter govemnen!. 2, Section 2.6.1, T;bte 2.7 Page No.,25-27. rr rne un|l ts rn between human the This unit does nor-coil-EG-G hurnan settlehent, then the govemment policy settlem€nl, the indusFies are located a.ound lhis should b€ informed aboul how many melers unit. The nearby human senlemen! 1.9 rway from is km lhe human habitation. away frcm Palasana village. t0. lf this unit is noifar froi NEJ8, ifrinlhe- constructrcn ol propos€d expansion will be oone informalion given by lhe govemment policy to 75 mete6 away from the mid-poinr ofN.H-4E. should b€ mention thal how much distance should be as far 6s possible. II lf the construction is old-n rhE uiit,lien- The propos€d expansion *illle do-ne rn information lhe given in the open arca is accordance with the policy ofSUDA. gaven on the basis ofthe SUDA Rule. 12. In t-his unir. rhe green belt shoutd-E Exrsting and Proposed Creenb€lt Details civen in according ro the rules of gov€mment and Execulive Summlry Page No. 16 and Table No. lhe numb€r of trees. and lhe copy of the 10.6 paSes no. 245 in the EIA report as well number of trcss cul for expansion proiect. Il. Civing a copy of rhe inrerview and Efn Related infonnarion -lill E-available-Ei repon conducred by rhe CPCB and CPCB Regional office, Gujarat Pollution Control Board, before gening lhe environmental clesmnc€ Surat. oflhis unir lo the Droiect. t4. Give the name ano addEss-Ji-GEb R.lated infomation - wittE avaitaUte from who oflicer, visited this unit. Regional office, Cuj&"at Pollution Conrol Board. Surat, 15. I o grve the copy ol the Intormation. if th€ For this unit, cost of treaunenioiGliiGGili CrcB or CETP has the cost information to about 3 lakhs p€r MLD. the puriry of one MLD water in an ETp of this unit ETP. To inform the unit about the conditions This unil has been iorplied-iith tne menlioned in the previous EC in th€ year conditions stated in the pr€vious EC in rhe"| ycar 2004. 2004. EC Compilstion Report provided in EtA Repon Pa{e No. 386. 17. This unir wilt us. ftom bo.elF6viO" Information on the impact oT wGiconsurnption information "atei about removal of drinking and the Foduction of chemicals on farm water, agricultuml us€ wate., soil fertility production, Chapte.4, Section 4.4, page no. IZJ- problems in adjac€nt 6reas. 124 and Section 4.9 page no. 128-t29. th€ details of land descriptions 6re given in the EIA .€pon. Chapter 3, Table No. 3. t6, pp. 74. is provided. lnformation on irnproving rhe qusliry of soil is given in chapter 4, section 4.5, page no, 124-l25. chapter 10, section 10.6, p8g€ no. 250. 18. ln lhis uni! the name of chemicals thir 6s p€r hazardous chemical rule, list oic[imrcars come wilh the hazardous chemical rule, ano given in EIA report, Table 2.7, page No.25 and the copy ofgovemmenl policy rcgardinq to that will be done according to ,,produclion. sp€cltvd Ov.r A Ch.6'c.ts Pn ttd r.ar+5oit-5o!A.5oa, N.x. xo.-!, p.t n, !ot, 6q..n-:r9a!1t l.tL r +9r lt2atlottts, +91 982atdn8 . aniotrp. rl. storaSe and impon of Hazardous- CGmicii menl) Rules,2000". t9. Cive details of Consumption ofEffious . Construction of proposeaixpu"sir*"i chemicals. Rule ofiuman s€fllemenl p€r U.. as meter away from the center ofthe N.H-4E. rule ofN.H,48, ruie ofconstruclion. rule of . This unil docs no! come in t!€iween the human tmnsport, online manual monitoring rule. s€tllemenl, the industries are locareo surounding of this unit. The nearest human seJtlement is L9 km away from palsana v||rage. . Although Cenainly adhere and follow to rne rules like online monitorinS. CDCR. hazardous and other waste (management and tmnsboundar) movemenr) rules, 2016 elc in future also. 20. There pilasana-Glul,o. are 400 unirs in Related informalion - will be a"ailable fiom Civing information abour cpCB, number of Regional office. Cujarar Pollulion Conrrol Board. staff to the govemmenl. e4uipmenrs, LAB, Sural. d,sasler m6n6gement. hospilal. bumba anbulance for monilorinp il. 2t. Cive the informarion rcgardi-cheiica Details of lhis are given in ih--€lA-rcpon, used as mw material in this unil affecl chapler 4. section 4.9 page no. 128 and Chapter human heahh and animal bird, sea life 6nq 10, Section 10.6, pageNo.250. environmenr. IfCPCB hes explained village panchayat and villages in the area of l0 km then give information about ir. Civing details of three year. expense lis by This unit is always ready for any hetps regaraing lhis unit for the social, r€ligious, economic soci!1, r€ligious, economic, education. heallh. for activities. education, health of sunounding the surrounding vill.ge. in the lasl l0 years. l0 k.m area villages. Infomralion is given in the EIA Repon. page No.552. ll. Ifthis unit has given anylublic conrribution Information of last l0 years CSR activittes ts then informing it. iven in EIA re 21. GPCB gives infomlation about list of Related informalion , witl be availalte from equipment available that identiry rype of gas Regional oflice, Cujarot Pollurion Conrlol Board. to be produce when mixing ofchemicsls by Surat. this uni|. the quanriry of gas. lhe proponion of 8as. lhe human. animals & birds. impact identificaliqn acrossthe environmenl. production lfthe annual ofthis unit is morc Akhough lhe annual lumover of thii unit is not than 500 crcres, rhen 2% of the profits mor€ than 500 c.ores, the unit is always rerdy for doring the year arc us€d in social economic soci!|, religious, cconomic, education, h€hh. for work. Cive the infomation about when. the suFounding village, in the last l0 years. wherc and how much amount of money Details given in EIA .eport, Page No.552. spend for which qpe of uork in this aflected area. :6 of the reporl of lhe last three yean of this unrt s bmineC annril enrirontnent audn Sp.ctrum Ov6 & Ch.mr..ls M Ud p.ren., traa.5o2-5ot^.5tx, r{.H |{o..t s!a! G!,a.n.,9a3 r5, hdd r.9r 9G2'r{,'5rS. +9r $2a!,!908a €dbatr9. SPECTRUM rhe Enuironmenr audiriTih-iliiii- in CPCB office e 21. Copy of th.Epon? the t"sT.ee lG of The r.pon of rtr. larr thGlffinnrrrt ,.non of oe annual rcpon of dis unit ... this unil has been submifled in the concem :8. Copy ofcaop informatGn foihurnin hGtth Information is pror idiJ in EIA repon-. ligi no in l0 km r.dius from this unil ... 617. 29. cive derails or *-*-El[islnir ro- To increase rhe erwironmit aiarenls or ttrc environment, place and expens€s.... organization's employees and the surrounolnc ar€!s, we have phnned and will be organizing world envlronment day on sth of June every yeat, This unit has work done for the prolection of pmposed projecl environmenl, delails ol exp€nditure given in the EIA rcpon, s€clion lO.5 q Table No. l0 and 10.I0 Page No. 250 and:51. t0. To inform the *ut., con.umprion-phn b, Not Applicable for rhis propoxd expansion relearing pip€ line and recycling ofrhis unir from CETP to the sea. Thanking You. For. ll'/!. Spectrum Dyc! & Chemicrk pvt, Ltd. EJ (Aulhoriscd Signarure) Sp.crrum Ot.t & Ch.m'et! M trd l-'||+502.503]5i,., x.H. io,-!, p.k .., So,r! colr:r-:l94'r5, ftiac | 1,r $ilartl75r5, ,1 9taitasaqla . idolc. rtoY r*i fdqal, l d rlslr sttiqr {.s 3[lscrt urttQa frlfd]s o'ds "i vcY, 'rot, 'rorrl, uou x1i u {a"0q uiq ,{L uQa ufise r+i ttte oqu{ doi0a r,rqafsaf I BrT g[tr,r] I uafar rieshi o{l "{ll u{tQ .au{l +ueat r,trll{ dtd. 9{ [i\u +u€ dt rn Qgqal stdstfl eiu cpcerl 4le rlQa ulfseal st{gt{l urirt rtt{li adl ! ou{y. i r,t rfuq [ic] nxclQq {rll. qr\ qqrardqi al0uorl3 ur uRs r4r:{l cur{i ctfsl"0 ttgrsr{l qt) opce eqtct grqt {r) ttauqz acttdl i cpcs (et st{qt6l srqtdl qtGdl r,u.{dl. qruqtqi qrQar E. \uq0af ?. qr rfu{"ft nrqd ui t{tG.0 }aths stdgtfl ueiep{i 6 ed, ouu{ qtqdl. qqrtrr, ci€r ruqftdt gOgeqr, dr,{r{l gqrr hstc.r cJIi tdt nG.0 uttitr 3Q r,uQc0 d, 6tstqt\ds {rG.{l 6qtda QufE qi r,{tQa0 0. oi+rorl Rull Ol ,jvr,r d[ toan ur Guaotr slat E. r. uc 5p.d.um OVs & Ch.m Lc.t! Pv! lrd l{a+5o2.5€ .!O., tr.n. No,-6, t lr.n ,sq.t 6!F.x.tatr5, ||xti. i +9r 9424a0675, {! 9alatlqL . ,'bCrc.d^jddv6.m ww sp.crrumdFs com R.g6rer€d Otfic€ 9r, AaMa tl&., Ai.,'.rl Xlrt i..d, &rdh..t (t), Mci!.i a(ns9 CrN No U2arrcMrlllrrrcltCd SPECTRUM r. drqst Os({ r,rfQstfl sl{, '{G tqtt rr. ulnts uogt{l slfl :1trra ulcgeta 3ilat 0 3, {?.1 9. www.gpcb.9ov.in 3. l,tt Qg{"n ccA. Noc, Ec"t 0. qr rLs{{i ttir{t.ror.3rr{t(? r{i €Letqt €?.(d r4a r({a rtretal"{l fiaa qrai 5rH€r.?, o{itrsrt{ qro err q{ 1"j 0. lat gtdsr{ rttricr 'i. rs i\t r,rQsrfldr Qqlldl qtGd r*t''adl. 6qrod Qqfe t{[ s]vs "i e.q, ut"ti 'i. eo'{e r{tlc0 d. r,u ds{qi Occu q{{i crqrt{a c{bto{bf{at els cd4r uul a_ r*L ilr.j ugRd qtqfl nercl uanqur.ti €rcrHi cs,r [3a1 fdeazGau tri r1C{,, }ac{l qrat{r €rc.rqi ue{ i"j q{lus1l Svor r rcoBc.tl Glerzftqn rlu 5cr eex.r {]"{la{rr ?, ccto"t srcrr{i r,{dc.{ ola{ af Cic.tl Qetz0qu qe rlg urqf. rp. i"{l Hrl6d qtqc{L cETP{iqlsatqt{i i,{tqrf.ut"ri'i. 33 cru ul.acrtla qfQaRrt qt) qcrUlar ui i.j frsrq cecazcece arl slcl E. tP.crrun Oy.s & Ch.m'ott M trd a-a!l-9ll-!Q3^-5o4, |l,fi. No.{, r.h.n ,9i.r! 6ll....-!9€13, ri4. +9r $24.0t5r5, €r 9atatag! . ' 6ioarF.r!,aF3.Gft *w R.8sr.'.d ot(. !or, AcM! ,t Ardtart !r, tarh to.d, Ar.rEn (!1, Mun6.r a@69 crl\ rro u2a l loMs lrarFrcl,6ca SPECTRUM cPcB "t( Aq{ cqr, qrq0, ,rr{t"{, l{,rt.{?qt, 03,(? s€an Rarrat rucr<"{l oriiU{l"j r rie,"tru"ft 4scr. t q"trqR, t. r,tt rls{ sc{r?r wq{lrj(Qdl orqrc{ r,u r+cfdl Qcr< tlqrOrl Qqltri xt) sla srdqtdl"{l {LGdl"0 qudl. "tsa utQc.ft E grrqr v. Oo(cr y.c qr'ri ... r?c qa vs?E to, Aa{(rr io.s, qrar, "t, ?t{O, 1q. rJs'Ic-to5a uatcrgar GpcB ua cpcB ,0 r4r {cldl {t[Adl -utl(ilt sl{l c1*ra c(ttsc(rJ4"0 }{tGc{l qlcEard "r5cr.... iilat or13, qea utlell ror1. 1S. 4 Ar{"u }(lgcn } esrrrqt €o{asvct ise q dcldl fdora 0r,{16A Rqfe{i us?q( Boo r+td ! a6l idl ){tG.{I. ?, Aa{.cr ?.s.3, i\es e.g qr.ti .t ?q-?o 10. rlt rlsq"ft vqR.j risc-("l ual 5pecl.un oyes & Ch.h'c.k M ltd p.tt r{&lo2-50:}a5l'., rr,H. 1|o,{, n , !nr, 6ots .t-tt9a!r5, 16rr. r rtr to.rFurJrl, rrt ,otalts! ! |nttrlt!.atn ittalaarl w\t toadruhdv.5 .oi, R.g ner€d ofi'.€ !ot. AcMa ttr|, A..I!ari t!.t io..t, .dhai tEl, Mlma.i aaoosg c N No u2al loMrj l9!9prctr56! SPECTRUM a{tclu{ct( r,{tt? r,{Jl t{r{t r4rUl Olq Cl id r,uQc,{l B, 6tsu+.{ds r{tG.0 6.auJ,l "t5Ct. Rqll {i r,tt\cft 0. orrtlrl Qult h{ 1ta dl tcert ue 6'{aotr slc.{ E. r. gc