Canadian Philosophical Review

Revue canadienne de philosophie

Articles Descartes: la primaute du libre vouloir sur la raison PETER SCMOLLS Foucault historien et •• historien » du present J. N. KAUFMANN How the Self-Defeating Argument Against Determinism Defeats Itself STEPHEN M. KN ASTER The Schematics of Continuant Identity NOI.LAIG MACKEN/IE How Scientific Laws Can Be About Individuals ROBERT M. MARTIN Le realisme scientifique de Feyerabend BERNARD BAERTSCHI Accidental Functions DOUGLAS EHR1NG

Critical Notices/Etudes critiques "1 Don't Ciet No Respect" W. E. COOPER Having at Equality Again: A Reply to Boulad-Ayoub and Cooper KAI NIELSEN No End of Ideology MILLIARD MtONOVLTCH The Formalist Treatment of Spinoza

VANCE MAXWELL

Interventions

Book Keviews/Comptes rendus Twenty-fifth Year of Publication Vingt-cinquwme anniversaire de publication VOL. XXV, NO. 2 Ete/Summer 1986

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. 25 Sep 2021 at 13:35:34, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use. Revue trimestrielle de l'Association canadienne de philosophic publiee avec l'assistance financiere du Conseil de recherches en sciences humaines. Dialogue beneficie egalement du soutien de l'Universite de Montreal et de l'Universite de Waterloo. Published quarterly for the Canadian Philosophical Association with grant support from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council. The assistance and support of the and the University of Montreal is also gratefully acknowledged.

Publiee par Wilfrid Laurier University Press pour l'Association canadienne de philosophic Published by Wilfrid Laurier University Press for the Canadian Philosophical Association

President/President: SARAH J. SHORTEN University of Western Ontario Editors/Redaction: FRANCOIS DUCHESNEAU Universite de Montreal MICHAEL F. MCDONALD University of Waterloo Board of Referees/Comite d'experts E. J. ASHWORTH University of Waterloo WON LAFRANCE Universite a"Ottawa JONATHAN BENNETT Syracuse ANN MACKENZIE York University University LOUISE MARCIL-LACOSTE Universite de GUY BOUCHARD Universite Laval Montreal DAVID BRAYBROOKE Dalhousie VANCE MAXWELL Memorial University University of Newfoundland PATRICIA SMITH CHURCHLAND ROBERT NADEAU Universite du Quebec a University of Montreal California, San Diego JAN NARVESON University of Waterloo PAUL CHURCHLAND University of Cali- CALVIN NORMORE fornia, San Diego DOUGLASODEGARD University of Guelph DAVID COPP University of Illinois, c. PANACCIO Universite du Quebec a Chicago Trois-Rivieres DAVID GALLOP Trent University T. PENELHUM University of DAVID GAUTHIER University of CARLOS PRADO Queen's University Pittsburgh w. R. SHEA McGill University YVON GAUTHIER Universite de Montreal ROGER A. SHINER University of NICHOLAS GRIFFIN McMaster University SARAH J. SHORTEN University of Western IAN HACKING University of Toronto Ontario HANS G. HERZBERGER University of WAYNE SUMNER University of Toronto Toronto JOHN THORP University of Ottawa J. N. KAUFMANN Universite du Quebec a Louis VALCKE Universite de Sherbrooke Trois-Rivieres D. N. WALTON University of Winnipeg PIERRE LABERGE Universite d'Ottawa

ISSN 0012-2173 © 1986 Association canadienne de philosophie/Canadian Philosophical Association Printed in Canada/Imprime au Canada Second class mail Courrier de la deuxieme classe Registration No. 2661 Enregistrement No. 2661 Postage paid at Kitchener Port paye a Kitchener Return postage guaranteed Port de retour garanti

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. 25 Sep 2021 at 13:35:34, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use. DIALOGUE

Canadian Philosophical Review/Revue canadienne de philosophic

Vol. XXV, No. 2 Ete/Summer 1986

Articles Descartes: la primaute du libre vouloir sur la raison PETER SCHOULS 211 Foucault historien et « historien » du present J. N. KAUFMANN 223 How the Self-Defeating Argument Against Determinism Defeats Itself STEPHEN M. KNASTER 239 The Schematics of Continuant Identity NOLLAIG MACKENZIE 245 How Scientific Laws Can Be About Individuals ROBERT M. MARTIN 251 Le realisme scientifique de Feyerabend BERNARD BAERTSCHI 267 Accidental Functions DOUGLAS EHRING 291

Critical Notices/Etudes critiques "I Don't Get No Respect" w. E. COOPER 303 Having at Equality Again: A Reply to Boulad-Ayoub and Cooper KAI NIELSEN 311 No End of Ideology HILLIARD ARONOVITCH 327 The Formalist Treatment of Spinoza VANCE MAXWELL 337

Interventions Against Miracles JOHN COLLIER 349 Modest Scepticism BRUCE FREED 353 Does Remembering Doing the Deed Presuppose Personal Identity? ROGER SMOOK 363

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. 25 Sep 2021 at 13:35:34, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use. Book Reviews/Comptes rendus JEAN ROY, Hobbes and Freud, translated by THOMAS G. OSLER JAN ZWICKY 367 LOUISE MARCIL-LACOSTE, La thematiqiie contemporaine de I'egalite PIERRE ANSART 369 JAROMIR DANEK, Etoiles et horizon du domicile: cosmologie et monadologie de I'homme MARC RENAULT 371 TERENCE PENELHUM, God and Skepticism C. G. PRADO 375 ALAN MONTEFIORE, editor, Philosophy in France Today EUGENE F. BERTOLDI 379 JANINEFILLION-LAHILLE, Le « De ira » de Seneqiie et la philosophie stokienne des passions RICHARD BODEUS 382 JEAN LARGEAULT, Les systemes de la nature YVON GAUTHIER 384 MICHEL J. BLAIS, La logique: line introduction DANIEL LAURIER 385 MICHAEL FRIEDMAN, Foundations of Space-Time Theories: Relativistic Physics Philosophy of Science STEVEN F. SAVITT 388

Books Received/Livres re$us 391

Announcements/Chronique 396

Erratum 399

Downloaded from https://www.cambridge.org/core. 25 Sep 2021 at 13:35:34, subject to the Cambridge Core terms of use.