DOCSLIB.ORG

4873 Transcript of Proceedings Coroner's

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
4873 Transcript of Proceedings Coroner's TRANSCRIPT OF PROCEEDINGS CORONER'S COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY MRS M. DOOGAN, CORONER CF No 154 of 2003 CANBERRA INQUEST AND INQUIRY INTO THE DEATH OF DOROTHY MCGRATH, ALLISON MARY TENNER, PETER BROOKE, AND DOUGLAS JOHN FRASER AND THE FIRES OF JANUARY 2003 DAY 50 Monday, 10 May 2004 .CF154/2003 10.05.04 4873 (c) WordWave Int'l [10.08am] THE CORONER: Just before we start, Ms Cronan, Mr Lakatos, I would like you to inquire of the 5 Chief Minister whether or not he wishes to return to this inquiry to give evidence about the contents of his letter to me of last Tuesday. I say that because the Chief Minister has been explaining his position to the media in various 10 interviews to the press. I wish to afford him the opportunity, if he wishes, to likewise explain or give some further evidence to this inquiry. In view of the evidence Mr Keady gave last Friday 15 and the Chief Minister's earlier comments, neither I nor counsel assisting see the need for Mr Stanhope to be recalled. But if he is of a different mind on the subject, then I am prepared to accommodate him. I would appreciate it if you 20 could make those inquiries and let me know, please Mr Lakatos. MR LAKATOS: That will be done. I should say that Mr Lasry gave the same offer to me and Mr Johnson 25 last week. I rather thought we conveyed what we thought was the position. That apparently is not so. We will pass it on and ask the question again. 30 THE CORONER: Thank you. Yes, Ms Cronan. MS CRONAN: I call Nicholas Lhuede. <NICHOLAS AUBIN RENE LHUEDE, AFFIRMED 35 <EXAMINATION-IN-CHIEF BY MS CRONAN MS CRONAN: Q. Would you please tell the Court your full name? 40 A. Nicholas Aubin Rene Lhuede. Q. Your current occupation? A. I am the fire management officer with Environment ACT. 45 Q. What is your professional address? A. Level 1 MacArthur House, Lyons. .CF154/2003 10.05.04 4874 N.A.R. LHUEDE X (c) WordWave Int'l MS CRONAN Q. You have made a statement in relation to this inquiry which is [ESB.AFP.0001.0231].This is a statement which has about 81 paragraphs and bears your signature on 8/12/2003. Have you had an 5 opportunity to go through that statement since you have signed it? A. Yes, I have. Q. Is there anything in that statement that you 10 now wish to alter or to correct before you give evidence? A. Yes, there are a number of paragraphs I would like to change. 15 Q. Tell her Worship which paragraphs you would like to change. A. Go to paragraph 32. In that paragraph the incident action plan for the Gingera fire was actually produced by Felicity Grant in the 20 planning team not myself as may be implied. Q. What is next? A. Paragraph 43, the next incident action plan I prepared for the Stockyard/Gingera fire was 25 finalised on the 15th. I commenced planning on the 12th but it was finalised on the 15th. Paragraph 51 at 7.30am not "PM". Paragraph 61, the Stockyard Gingera fire I believe merged on the 30 15th not the 16th, as I have stated. Paragraph 65, I would like to omit the words in the first sentence from: "In light of the abandonment of the proposed back-burn off Lick 35 Hole Road and Leura Gap trail". In paragraphs 66, 67, 68 and 69, the meeting where we discussed the prediction of where the fire would reach was actually on the Friday the 17th, 40 the evening meeting on that night. I believe Mr Gellie offered an opinion at that meeting that it could reach the urban interface by 6 o'clock. 45 Q. On Friday the 17th? A. Yes. That was at that afternoon meeting. .CF154/2003 10.05.04 4875 N.A.R. LHUEDE X (c) WordWave Int'l MS CRONAN Q. Any further corrections? A. They are the ones that I am aware of. I think it is correct now. 5 Q. We will go through the statement. Before we start, you also participated in a taped record of conversation with Constable Mark Travers on 13 February earlier this year? A. That's correct. 10 Q. That is at [DPP.DPP.0007.0332]. Have you similarly gone through the transcript of that record of conversation before coming to court? A. Yes, I have been through that. 15 Q. Is there anything in that document you would like to alter or correct? A. No, nothing that I am aware of. 20 Q. You say in paragraph 5 of your statement that at the time of the January 2003 fires you were employed by the Environment ACT as the fire management officer with ACT Parks and Conservation Service. You were appointed to that position in 25 September of 2002. Before that you had employment with New South Wales State Forests for 7 to 8 years in a range of roles. The last 4 or 5 years were focused on 30 harvesting planning management of native forests on the New South Wales north coast. Could you outline in slightly more detail what roles you did perform when you were working with the New South Wales State Forests? 35 A. My last job before I came to the ACT was as harvest planning manager in north-east region. That involved the planning and scheduling of harvesting operations in native forests in the plantations for the north-east region in New South 40 Wales State Forests. That was my primary duty. However, fire and fire suppression activities were also a core part of my duties. They took priority when fires did occur. I was involved in fire suppression, fire management activities as 45 required. Q. Over what kind of period were you involved in .CF154/2003 10.05.04 4876 N.A.R. LHUEDE X (c) WordWave Int'l MS CRONAN fire suppression activities, was it the whole 7 to 8 years? A. Yes, at differing levels. 5 Q. When you say "at differing levels", could you outline sequentially what involvement you had with fire suppression? A. In my first position when I was based at Bombala - my first position at Bombala, quite 10 limited duties there because there weren't many fires in the period. But I was involved in stand- up and some suppression activities whilst employed at Bombala. I was two years there. 15 Then I moved to Bulahdelah district. Again harvest planning role. Whilst there I was involved in some prescribed burned planning. I was involved in fire suppression activities. A number of quite small fires that were suppressed 20 quickly but also a number of larger interagency fires did occur in that period that I was involved in at a planning level and initially incident control level. 25 Q. So what period are you talking about at that stage? A. That would have been about 1997 when I was there. 30 Q. Just for the one year? A. I was there for a couple of years. I think there was one or two big fires in that period and a number of smaller ones that I was involved in. After working in Bulahdelah, I was in Newcastle 35 for a year. I recall I had fairly limited involvement in fires at that stage and then moved to Coffs Harbour where I was there for two-and-a-half years. Each of the years I was there, we had quite active fire seasons in and 40 around Coffs Harbour. While there I fulfilled a number of functions, including divisional commander and also planning on the Incident Management Team for some 45 section 44 fires. So there was quite extensive involvement. Two of those fire seasons did run probably for a period of six weeks, I suppose, and .CF154/2003 10.05.04 4877 N.A.R. LHUEDE X (c) WordWave Int'l MS CRONAN during that period that was a fairly significant focus of my activities. Q. So you were involved in a planning role in 5 fires being managed by the New South Wales Rural Fire Service over that period? A. Yes. That's correct. Yes. Q. Did you have incident control system training 10 at that stage? A. I had received AFAC 404 training. I can't recall when, but it was some time in my period while working at Coffs Harbour. 15 Q. The AFAC 404 training, what does that involve? A. It looks at incident management, looking at the roles and functions of the positions within an Incident Management Team. 20 Q. So you have had experience over the eight- year period from the range of activities from crew member, RAFT crew member up into the Incident Management Team level? A. Yes, that's correct, although I actually never 25 did a RAFT fire when I walked in. Most fires with the State Forests are vehicle based, but in essence, yes. Q. Before you came to Canberra you had no RAFT 30 experience? A. I had actually done RAFT training with State Forests. That would have been in the mid-'90s. In terms of actual fighting of a RAFT fire with State Forests, it was rarely necessary because it 35 had quite an intensive road network as a result of the harvesting activity. So most fires were often vehicle and using heavy machinery. Very rarely did we walk into a fire in that distance and use hand tools.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Commemorating the Overseas-Born Victoria Cross Heroes a First World War Centenary Event
    Commemorating the overseas-born Victoria Cross heroes A First World War Centenary event National Memorial Arboretum 5 March 2015 Foreword Foreword The Prime Minister, David Cameron The First World War saw unprecedented sacrifice that changed – and claimed – the lives of millions of people. Even during the darkest of days, Britain was not alone. Our soldiers stood shoulder-to-shoulder with allies from around the Commonwealth and beyond. Today’s event marks the extraordinary sacrifices made by 145 soldiers from around the globe who received the Victoria Cross in recognition of their remarkable valour and devotion to duty fighting with the British forces. These soldiers came from every corner of the globe and all walks of life but were bound together by their courage and determination. The laying of these memorial stones at the National Memorial Arboretum will create a lasting, peaceful and moving monument to these men, who were united in their valiant fight for liberty and civilization. Their sacrifice shall never be forgotten. Foreword Foreword Communities Secretary, Eric Pickles The Centenary of the First World War allows us an opportunity to reflect on and remember a generation which sacrificed so much. Men and boys went off to war for Britain and in every town and village across our country cenotaphs are testimony to the heavy price that so many paid for the freedoms we enjoy today. And Britain did not stand alone, millions came forward to be counted and volunteered from countries around the globe, some of which now make up the Commonwealth. These men fought for a country and a society which spanned continents and places that in many ways could not have been more different.
    [Show full text]
  • Allerdale District War Memorials Transcript
    ALLERDALE War Memorials Names Lists Harrington Village Memorial-Transcription ERECTED IN GRATEFUL MEMORY/OF THE MEN OF THIS PARISH/WHO SACRIFICED THEIR LIVES/IN THE GREAT WAR/1914-1918 ERECTED 1925, RE-SITED HERE 2001/RE-DEDICATED BY THE BISHOP OF CARLISLE/THE RIGHT REVEREND GRAHAM DOW/12TH JUNE 2001 WW1 South Face Column 1 S AGNEW/H AMBLER/JC ANDERSON/JN ARNOTT/C ASKEW/F BARKER/L BERESFORD/J BIRD/E BIRD/ED BIRNIE/ RC BLAIR/H BLAIR/W BLAIR Column 2 S BOWES/J BOYLE/W BROWN/JT BROWN/J BYRNE/R BURNS/J CAHILL/M CASSIDY/T CAPE/J CARTER/JH CRANE M DACRE West Face Column 1 JM STAMPER/H TEMPLETON/R TEMPLETON/WH THOMAS/T TINKLER/H TOFT/J TWEDDLE/J TYSON/C UHRIG J WARD/W WARDROP/T WARREN/M WATSON/J WAUGH/J WESTNAGE/A WHITE/G WHITEHEAD Column 2 M WILLIAMSON/E WILSON/H WILSON/J WILSON/W WOODBURN/H WRIGHT/A WYPER North Face Column 1 JR LITTLE/WH MCCLURE/D MCCORD/D MCGEORGE/T MCGLENNON/W MCKEE/A MCCLENNAN/A MCMULLEN/ J MCNICHOLAS/H MASON/W MILLICAN/J MOORE/WH MOORE/G MORTON/J MORTON/J MURPHY/T NEEN/ J O’NEIL Column 2 G PAISLEY/I PARK/W PARKER/JJ PALMER/FH PICKARD/J POOLE/GF PRICE/TP PRICE/R PRITT/A RAE/J RAE H REECE/R RICE/P RODGERS/JW ROBINSON/T SCOTT/W SCRUGHAM/N SIMON/T SPOONER East Face Column 1 Page 1 of 159 H DALTON/JTP DAWSON/G DITCHBURN/E DIXON/NG DOBSON/B DOLLIGAN/W DORAN/M DOUGLAS/H FALCON JJ FEARON/J FEARON/J FERRY/H FLYNN/TH FRAZER/T GILMORE/W GILMORE/T GORRY/J GREENAN Column 2 WJ HALL/WH HARDON/J HARRISON/J HEAD/J HEWSON/TB HEWSON/A HILL/A HODGSON/J HUNTER/TB HUGHES A INMAN/JW INMAN/D JACKSON/W JACKSON/H JEFFREY/G JOHNSTON/J KEENAN WW2
    [Show full text]
  • Victoria Cross Award
    MEDIA RELEASE VICTORIA CROSS AWARD Thursday 13 February 2014 Lyons Liberal candidate Guy Barnett has welcomed today’s announcement by Prime Minister Tony Abbott of the awarding of a posthumous Victoria Cross to Burnie-born soldier Corporal Cameron Baird. The late Cpl Baird, a member of the 2nd Commando Regiment based at Holsworthy Army Barracks, was killed on operations in Afghanistan on 22 June 2013. He also received the Medal for Gallantry (MG) for actions taken in combat in 2007 in Afghanistan. Mr Barnett said Cpl Baird will be the 14th Tasmanian to receive Australia’s highest military honour. ``When you consider that Cpl Baird is only the 100th Australian to be so recognised, it highlights the incredible valour Tasmanians have demonstrated in many theatres of war, he said. “Tasmania punches above its weight when it comes to bravery in wartime. 14% of Victoria Cross recipients come from Tasmania but we only have 2.5% of the Australian population. This is an amazing contribution in which all Tasmanians can be proud. “Harry Murray VC of Evandale is Australia’s most highly decorated soldier and a statue of him was unveiled by the then Governor-General in February 2006. “The first two Australian born soldiers to receive the Victoria Cross were Lieutenant Guy Wylly and Trooper John Bisdee both of Tasmania. “Their stories are told in my book ‘Our Heroes-Tasmania’s Victoria Cross recipients’, produced with the support of the Tasmanian RSL, now in its third edition. “Tasmanians to receive the Victoria Cross, and the locations of their memorials
    [Show full text]
  • RSL (Tasmania) Hobart ANZAC Day Commemorative Committee Chairman: Mr T
    ANZAC Day Hobart th 25 April 2018 Major Anniversaries 100th Anniversary of first Battle of Villers-Bretonneux – 4th & 25th April 2018 75th Anniversary of the Battle of the Atlantic – 1st May 2018 50th Anniversary of the Battles for Fire Support Base Coral & Balmoral – 11th May 2018 75th Anniversary of the sinking of the Centaur – 14th May 2018 100th Anniversary of the Battle of Hamel, France – 4th July 2018 65th Anniversary, Armistice ends Hostilities in Korean War – 27th July 2018 100th Anniversary of the Battle of Amiens – 8th August 2018 100th Anniversary of the Battle of Mont St Quentin – 31st August 2018 100th Anniversary of Breaking the Hindenberg Line (WW1) – 29th September 2018 75th Anniversary of Hellfire Pass and the Thai Burma Railway (WW11) – 16th October 2018 100th Anniversary of WW1 Armistice – 11th November 2018 COMMEMORATIVE ORDER OF SERVICE Those who feel they are unable to stand during the service may remain seated. The service will be led by: The Right Reverend Doctor R. Condie, Bishop of Tasmania Major J. Freind, Divisional Commander, Salvation Army The Most Reverend J.C. Porteous DD, Archbishop of Hobart Chaplain S. Sargent, Staff Chaplain Tasmania, Australian Army Singing will be led by the combined choirs of: St. Michael’s Collegiate School, The Hutchins School and Sing Australia Choir Accompanied by: Australian Army Band–Tasmania and Salvation Army Band Mounting of Catafalque Party Please stand for the mounting of the Catafalque Party Wreath Laying Ceremony Hymn - “O God, Our Help in Ages Past” 1. O God our help in ages past, 3. Before the hills in order stood, Our hope for years to come, Or earth received her frame, Our shelter from the stormy blast, From everlasting Thou art God, And our eternal home.
    [Show full text]
  • A Technical, Administrative and Bureaucratic Analysis of the Victoria Cross and the AIF on the Western Front, 1916-1918
    i Behind the Valour: A technical, administrative and bureaucratic analysis of the Victoria Cross and the AIF on the Western Front, 1916-1918 Victoria D’Alton Student Number 3183439 Submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts University of New South Wales Australian Defence Force Academy 22 October 2010 ii Originality Statement I hereby declare that this submission is my own work and to the best of my knowledge it contains no materials previously published or written by another person, or substantial proportions of material which have been accepted for the award of any of any other degree or diploma at UNSW or any other educational institution, except where due acknowledgement is made in the thesis. Any contribution made to the research by others, with whom I have worked at UNSW or elsewhere, is explicitly acknowledged in the thesis. I also declare that the intellectual content of this thesis is the product of my own work, except to the extent that assistance from others in the project’s design and conception or in style, presentation and linguistic expression is acknowledged. Victoria D’Alton UNSW Student Number 3183439 22 October 2010 iii For my friend, Lieutenant Paul Kimlin, RAN O156024 1 January 1976 – 2 April 2005 ‘For many are called, but few are chosen.’ Matthew 22:14 iv Abstract This thesis focuses on the how and why the Victoria Cross came to be awarded to 53 soldiers of the AIF on the Western Front from 1916 to 1918. It examines the technical, administrative and bureaucratic history of Australia’s relationship with the Victoria Cross in this significant time and place.
    [Show full text]
  • Lrhcnujkq0jx9tia.Pdf
    Following are articles taken from The First Post over the last 50 years. Many will not have read these previously but they form part of our history. The articles are not taken as a history of the Association or the Battalion but feature for those now getting on in years to help you remember some of the history that occurred in our time. PRIMUS AGAT PRIMAS This is the last edition of the First Post. It is a sad moment for me, a moment to reflect on a group of young Australians who came forward when their country needed them. They were the generation born from war (WW1) and were now stepping into the shoes of their fathers. and continued at different times through to the return of the unit to Australia in July 1942. The 2/1st battalion had fought in North Africa, Greece, Crete and in Syria and had spent three months in Ceylon and now was looking forward to a break. But that was not to be. Early September 1942 saw the battalion heading to New Guinea and a different type of warfare. I wonder if the historians who write about Kokoda and the tourists who The desperation, the mud, the mountains, the lack of food and sleep, a fanatical enemy, cannibalization by the enemy all with no end in sight. No-one can ever walk in their boots. 2/1st BATTALION ACTION NOVEMBER 1942 Interviewed by Daily Telegraph March 24th 1956 This cites the heroism of a force led by Captain B. W. T. Catterns, of the 2/1st Battalion, in an attack on a Japanese encampment during the advance on Sanananda in November, 1942.
    [Show full text]
  • Our Heroes: Tasmania's Victoria Cross Recipients
    Centenary of ANZAC Edition OUR HEROES Tasmania’s Victoria Cross Recipients “ For Valour” by Guy Barnett MP All photographs contained in this publication displaying Australian War Memorial ID are courtesy of the Australian War Memorial. Some information in the booklet courtesy of the Australian War Memorial and the Department of Veterans’ Affairs Published September 2015 Copyright © Guy Barnett 2015 All Rights Reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, recording or any other information storage and retrieval system, without prior permission in writing from the publisher. ISBN: 978 0 9942331 3 4 Printed by Foot & Playsted, Launceston, Tasmania 7250 Cover Image courtesy of the Australian War Memorial Dedication This book is dedicated to all Tasmanians who have served, and their families. Centenary of ANZAC and 4th Edition iv | Tasmania’s Victoria Cross Recipients by Guy Barnett MP Contents Foreword: The Hon Will Hodgman MP ..............................................................................................................1 Foreword: Senator the Hon Michael Ronaldson .......................................................................................2 Introduction: Robert Dick .............................................................................................................................................4 The Centenary of ANZAC : Guy Barnett MP ..................................................................................................5
    [Show full text]
  • Cenotaph Order of Service 2019
    ANZAC Day Hobart th ANZAC25 April Day 201 Hobart9 th 25 April 2019 COMMEMORATIVE ORDER OF SERVICE Those who feel they are unable to stand during the service may remain seated. The service will be led by: Chaplain S. Sargent, Staff Chaplain Tasmania, Australian Army The Right Reverend Doctor R. Condie, Bishop of Tasmania Major J. Freind, Divisional Commander, Salvation Army The Most Reverend J.C. Porteous DD, Archbishop of Hobart Cenotaph Announcer: Mr Brian McKenzie OAM Singing will be led by the combined choirs of: St. Michael’s Collegiate School & The Hutchins School Accompanied by: Australian Army Band–Tasmania Mounting of Catafalque Party Please stand for the mounting of the Catafalque Party Welcome to Country Sergeant Bradley Maynard 12/40th RTR Wreath Laying Ceremony Hymn - “O God, Our Help in Ages Past” 1. O God our help in ages past, 3. Before the hills in order stood, Our hope for years to come, Or earth received her frame, Our shelter from the stormy blast, From everlasting Thou art God, And our eternal home. To endless years the same. 2. Under the shadow of Thy throne, 4. O God our help in ages past, Thy saints have dwelt secure, Our hope for years to come, Sufficient is Thine arm alone, Be Thou our guard while troubles last, And our defence is sure. And our eternal home. Amen The Lord’s Prayer Prayers In Commemoration of the Fallen, for the Commonwealth, for Peace and Fellowship Scripture Reading The Address COMMEMORATIVE ORDER OF SERVICE Those who feel they are unable to stand during the service may remain seated.
    [Show full text]
  • Irish Australia, the Great War and the 1920 St Patrick's Day Parade
    T Archbishop Mannix led by fourteen Victoria Cross recipients in the 1920 St. Patrick’s Day parade. Source: National Library of Australia, http:/ / nla.gov.au/ nla.obj-143782348 An Illusion of Unity: Irish Australia, the Great War and the 1920 St Patrick’s Day Parade The participation of fourteen Victoria Cross recipients, a controversial archbishop and a notorious entrepreneur in the 1920 St Patrick’s Day parade in Melbourne provides context to the bitter political and sectarian divisions of the conscription debates at the time. Tim Sullivan Former Assistant Director, Australian War Memorial On 20 March 1920, fourteen Victoria Cross recipients of the church who only formally worshipped mounted on white horses provided an escort for Daniel late in life, and a staunch Irish republican who unequivocally supported the Empire’s war from the Mannix, Archbishop of Melbourne, who was leading the outset) put him at odds with easy definition.2 St Patrick’s Day parade in Melbourne in an open car. John Wren, a ‘colourful’ self-made Catholic entrepreneur, Wren made his fortune as a bookmaker in Collingwood, a had orchestrated the parade to honour Mannix and to predominantly Catholic working-class inner-city suburb demonstrate the loyalty of Irish Australians, which had of Melbourne. He thrived in the industrial, political been questioned during the conscription debates in 1916 and religious tribalism that was Melbourne in the late and 1917.1 Having an honour guard of decorated veterans nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. of the Great War was intended to associate Mannix and Australians of Irish and Catholic heritage with the war Wren took on the establishment, which frowned on effort and its ultimate victory.
    [Show full text]