Prisoned Chickens Poisoned Eggs

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Prisoned Chickens Poisoned Eggs PRISONED CHICKENS POISONED EGGS AN INSIDE LOOK AT THE MODERN POULTRY INDUSTRY Karen Davis, Ph.D. BOOK PUBLISHING COMPANY SUMMERTOWN, TENNESSEE Book Publishing Company P.O. Box 99 Summertown, Tennessee 1-800-695-2241 © 1996 Karen Davis All rights reserved Cover design by Warren Jefferson ISBN 1-57067-032-3 99 98 97 4 3 2 Davis, Karen, 1944- Prisoned chickens, poisoned eggs : an inside look at the modern poultry industry / Karen Davis p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. ISBN 1-57067-032-3 1. Chickens. 2. Chickens--Diseases. 3. Eggs--Production. 4. Chicken industry. 5. Egg trade. I. Title. SF487.D27 1996 179'.3--dc20 96-45937 CIP Karen Davis is the founder and president of United Poultry Concerns, an international non-profit organization addressing the treatment of poultry in food production, sci- ence, education, entertainment, and human companionship situations. A portion of the proceeds from the sale of this book goes directly to funding the work of this organization. “In the tradition of Jeremy Rifkin’s Beyond Beef, Karen Davis has taken on the poultry industry in her thoroughly researched analysis of the gruesome, dirty and brutal lives of factory-farmed chickens.” Publishers Weekly “Davis documents the inhumane conditions of factory farm- ing, explicitly detailing the lives and deaths of battery hens raised in tiered brooding trays and of broiler chickens . Bolstered by unyeilding conviction, Davis argues her case with passion.” Booklist Table of Contents Prologue . 5 Introduction . 8 Chapter 1 History . .10 Early History—Beginning of the Modern Factory Farm— Reactions to the “Poultry Machine” Chapter 2 The Birth and Family Life of Chickens .25 When Living Creatures Become “Units”—School Hatching Projects—The Egg and Chick: Historical Symbols of Nature and Rebirth—Easter Egg Hunt and Egg Gathering—The Hen as a Symbol of Motherhood— Maternal Instincts of the Domestic Hen—Why Roosters Crow— Relationship Between the Rooster and the Hen— Bravery of Chickens—Formation and Laying of the Egg—Embryonic Development and Hatching of the Chick—Maternal Immunity Disrupted By Factory Farming: Marek’s Disease, Infectious Bursal Disease— Inside the Egg—Hatching—Mother Hen and Chicks— Commercial Hatchery—Treatment of Parent Flocks—Why Look at Chickens Chapter 3 The Life of the Battery Hen . .51 First Hand Impressions—The Cages—Laying Eggs in Cages—Diseases and Syndromes—Foot and Leg Deformities—Caged Layer Osteoporosis—Fatty Liver Syndrome—Swollen Head Syndrome—Salmonella— Antibiotics—Manure, Toxic Ammonia, Dead Birds, Expanding Complexes—Coccidiosis—“Cannibalism”— Debeaking—Dustbathing—Heat Stress—Mash, Mold Toxins, Mouth Ulcers—Forced Molting—Forced Molting Causes Salmonella—Disposition of Spent Hens—The Fight for Better Conditions Chapter 4 The Life of the Broiler Chicken . .83 Consumer Trends—Development of the Modern Broiler Chicken—Diseases and Syndromes — Orthopedic Disorders—Lucrative Research—Cruel Research—Troubled Birds—Sick Birds Going to Slaughter—Tumors and Infections—Obesity— Blackouts and Food Restriction—Other Diseases— Diseases Traced to the Feeding of Animal Products— Ascites: Pulmonary Hypertension Syndrome—Toxic Air—Excretory Ammonia—Overcrowding—Broiler Chickens in Cages—Dead Bird Disposal—Consumers— Invisible Contamination Chapter 5 The Death . .105 Numbers of Birds Killed—Manual Chicken Catching— Automated “Harvesting”—Transportation—Truck Accidents—No Federal Regulations—Shipment of Baby Chicks—Mass Transport Incompatible with Poultry Welfare—The Slaughter—Poultry Excluded from Federal “Humane Slaughter” Law—Slaughter Without Stunning—Pre-Slaughter Electrical “Stunning”—Post- Slaughter Electrical “Stunning”—Neck-Cutting—Ritual Slaughter—Spent Laying Hens and Small Birds— Gassing—Treatment of Unwanted Male Chicks—Pain and Suffering in Birds—The Fight for “Humane Slaughter” Protection Chapter 6 A New Beginning . .125 New Beginning—The “Free-Range” Chicken—See for Yourself—Cruel Experiments—No Federal Protection— Morally Handicapped Industry References and Notes . .144 Index . .173 4 PROLOGUE He woke up on the floor of the broiler shed with 20 thousand other bewildered young chickens under the electric lights, with the familiar pain in his throat and a burning sensation deep inside his eyes. He saw green leaves shining through flashes of sunlight, as he peeked through his mother’s feathers and heard the soft awakening cheeps of his brothers and sisters, and felt his mother’s heart beating next to his own through her big warm body surrounding him, which was his world. A crow had cried out, and another cried out again. He started—the spry, young jungle fowl was ready for the day, ready to begin scratching the soil which he had known by heart ever since way back when chickenhood first arose in the tropical magic mornings of the early world. In the jungle forest, the deli- cious seeds of bamboo that are hidden beneath the leaves on the ground are treasured in the heart of the chicken. The rooster called out excitedly: “Family, come see what food I’ve found for you this morning!”. His aching legs—they brought him back to reality as he closed his eyes stinging with ammonia burn—could not move. They could no longer bear the weight of flesh which bore down upon them, which was definitely not the body of a mother hen. A mother hen, an ancestral memory kept telling him over and over, had once shushed and lulled him to sleep, pressed against her body nestled deep inside her wings fluffed over him when he was a chick. That was a long time ago, long before he was a “broiler” chicken, crippled and incased in these cells of fat and skeletal pain. He was turning purple. His lungs filled slowly with fluid, leaking from his vessels backward through the valves of his heart, as he stretched out on the filthy litter in a final spasm of agony, and died. Karen Davis, “Memories Inside a Broiler Chicken House” 5 I remember how wonderful it was to peck my way through the shell and step out into the warm bright dawn of life. I have seen no other sunrise. We live in eternal noon- time. My birth was a grievous mistake. And yet an egg is developing in me, as always. I can’t stop it. I feel its growth, and despite all my bitterness, tiny surges of tenderness fill me. How I wish I could stop the egg from growing so that I wouldn’t have to know these tender feelings. But I can’t stop. I’m an egg machine, the best egg machine in the world. “Don’t be so gloomy, Sister. There are better times com- ing.” The insane hen in the cage beside mine has fallen victim to a common delusion here at the egg factory. “No better times are coming, Sister,” I reply. “Only worse times.” “You’re mistaken, my dear. I happen to know. Very soon we’ll be scratching in a lovely yard.” I don’t bother to reply. She’s cheered by her delusions. And since our end will be the same, what does it matter how we spend our days here? Let her dream in her lovely yard. Let her develop her dream to its fullest, until she imagines that the wire floor beneath her claws has become warm dry earth. We don’t have much longer to go. Our life span is only fourteen months of egg laying and then we’re through. An egg machine! There’s a great fluttering of wings along this cell block, and much loud clucking. The cages are opening, and one by one rough hands grab us. “You see, Sister. I told you better times were coming. Now we’re finally going.” Now we’re hung upside down, our feet are tied together with wire. “You see, Sister. It’s just as I told you—the better times have come at last.” We’re hooked to a slowly moving belt. Hanging upside down, we’re carried along through a dark tunnel. The wire bites into my flesh. Swaying through the darkness we go. The gurgling cries up ahead of us make clear what better times have come. 6 “Our reward, Sister, is here at last,” cries our mad sister. “We were good and laid many eggs and now we get our reward.” The cry of each hen is cut off so that her squawking becomes liquid bubbling. And then the sound of dripping: drip, drip, drip. “Oh, I can see it now, Sister, the lovely yard I spoke of, all covered with red flowers and . .” The mash runs out of her neck. William Kotzwinkle, Doctor Rat1 7 INTRODUCTION I did not grow up around chickens. As is probably the case for most people growing up in post-World War Two America, my personal acquaintance with chickens and other animals on the farm was confined to experiences at the table. There were some brief encounters with baby “Easter” chick- ens and rabbits way back in childhood, and a long sup- pressed witnessing of a brown hen beheaded on a chopping block with an axe by a playmate’s father. However, a chicken named Viva changed the course of my life and career.2 When I met her, I was an English teacher completing my doctoral dissertation in English at the University of Maryland. I had expected to teach English for the rest of my life. Yet during the mid to late 1980s I found myself increasingly drawn to the plight of nonhuman ani- mals in human society, particularly farm animals. The huge number of factory farm animals was astonishing. At the bot- tom of this pile were the billions of birds imprisoned in intensive confinement systems, totally out of sight. Farm animals were generally dismissed as beyond the pale of equal, or even any, moral concern because, it was argued, they had been bred to a substandard state of intelligence and biological fitness, and because they were “just food” that was “going to be killed anyway.” My experience with Viva, a crippled and abandoned “broiler” hen, put these matters into perspective.
Recommended publications
  • Broiler Chickens
    The Life of: Broiler Chickens Chickens reared for meat are called broilers or broiler chickens. They originate from the jungle fowl of the Indian Subcontinent. The broiler industry has grown due to consumer demand for affordable poultry meat. Breeding for production traits and improved nutrition have been used to increase the weight of the breast muscle. Commercial broiler chickens are bred to be very fast growing in order to gain weight quickly. In their natural environment, chickens spend much of their time foraging for food. This means that they are highly motivated to perform species specific behaviours that are typical for chickens (natural behaviours), such as foraging, pecking, scratching and feather maintenance behaviours like preening and dust-bathing. Trees are used for perching at night to avoid predators. The life of chickens destined for meat production consists of two distinct phases. They are born in a hatchery and moved to a grow-out farm at 1 day-old. They remain here until they are heavy enough to be slaughtered. This document gives an overview of a typical broiler chicken’s life. The Hatchery The parent birds (breeder birds - see section at the end) used to produce meat chickens have their eggs removed and placed in an incubator. In the incubator, the eggs are kept under optimum atmosphere conditions and highly regulated temperatures. At 21 days, the chicks are ready to hatch, using their egg tooth to break out of their shell (in a natural situation, the mother would help with this). Chicks are precocial, meaning that immediately after hatching they are relatively mature and can walk around.
    [Show full text]
  • The Us Egg Industry – Not All It's Cracked up to Be for the Welfare Of
    File: 10.03 drake JBN Macro Final.doc Created on: 4/24/2006 9:38:00 PM Last Printed: 5/8/2006 10:51:00 AM THE U.S. EGG INDUSTRY – NOT ALL IT’S CRACKED UP TO BE FOR THE WELFARE OF THE LAYING HEN: A COMPARATIVE LOOK AT UNITED STATES AND EUROPEAN UNION WELFARE LAWS Jessica Braunschweig-Norris I. Chickens Used for Food and Food Production in the United States Egg Industry: An Overview................................513 II. The Implications for Laying Hens: Plight and Protection...................515 A. Cage Systems.................................................................................515 1. The United States Cage System..............................................517 2. The EU Standards: Out with the Old, In with the New..........518 a. Unenriched Cage Systems: The End of the Traditional Battery Cage..........................518 b. Enriched Cages ................................................................519 c. Alternative Systems: The Free Range or Cage-Free System..............................520 B. Beak Trimming.............................................................................520 C. Forced Molting .............................................................................522 D. Transportation and Slaughter........................................................523 III. The Disparity: United States Welfare Law and Policy and the EU’s Progressive Legislative Vision.......................................525 A. The United States Law & Policy: Falling Behind .......................526 1. Non-Existent Federal Protection
    [Show full text]
  • Lesson Eight
    Class of Nonviolence – Lesson Eight Animals, My Brethren by Edgar Kupfer-Koberwitz The following pages were written in the wounded or killed for my pleasure and Concentration Camp Dachau, in the midst of all convenience? kinds of cruelties. They were furtively scrawled in • Is it not only too natural that I do not a hospital barrack where I stayed during my inflict on other creatures the same thing illness, in a time when Death grasped day by day which, I hope and fear, will never be after us, when we lost twelve thousand within inflicted on me? Would it not be most four and a half months. unfair to do such things for no other purpose than for enjoying a trifling Dear Friend: physical pleasure at the expense of others' sufferings, others' deaths? You asked me why I do not eat meat and you are wondering at the reasons of my behavior. These creatures are smaller and more helpless Perhaps you think I took a vow -- some kind of than I am, but can you imagine a reasonable man penitence -- denying me all the glorious of noble feelings who would like to base on such pleasures of eating meat. You remember juicy a difference a claim or right to abuse the steaks, succulent fishes, wonderfully tasted weakness and the smallness of others? Don't you sauces, deliciously smoked ham and thousand think that it is just the bigger, the stronger, the wonders prepared out of meat, charming superior's duty to protect the weaker creatures thousands of human palates; certainly you will instead of persecuting them, instead of killing remember the delicacy of roasted chicken.
    [Show full text]
  • Ann. Anim. Sci., Vol. 20, No. 4 (2020) 1509–1525 DOI: 10.2478/Aoas-2020-0073
    Ann. Anim. Sci., Vol. 20, No. 4 (2020) 1509–1525 DOI: 10.2478/aoas-2020-0073 EFFECTS OF CAPONIZATION ON GROWTH PERFORMANCE AND MEAT PHYSICOCHEMICAL PROPERTIES OF CROSSBRED CHICKENS* * Jolanta Calik1♦, Sylwester Świątkiewicz2, Joanna Obrzut1, Katarzyna Połtowicz1, Józefa Krawczyk1 1Department of Poultry Breeding, 2Department of Animal Nutrition and Feed Science, National Research Institute of Animal Production, 32-083 Balice n. Kraków, Poland ♦Corresponding author: [email protected] Abstract The aim of the study was to determine the effect of caponizing on body weight and physicochemi- cal properties of meat of the capons – hybrids obtained from the crossing of hens of the Yellowleg Partridge (Ż-33) breed with meat roosters. The study covered 80 hybrid roosters, which were randomly assigned to two groups of 40 animals each (8 boxes of 10 birds in each group). Group I (control) consisted of uncastrated roosters while group II included birds, which were castrated at 8 weeks of age under local anaesthesia by a vet. Birds were fed ad libitum with the same standard diets and kept on litter under optimal environmental conditions with a stocking density of 7 ani- mals/m2. At the end of fattening, i.e. in the 20th week of life, 8 birds with a body weight close to the group average were selected from each group for slaughter. After slaughter, the effectiveness of the procedure was checked (lack of testicles), then the slaughter performance of birds, physicochemi- cal parameters of the pectoral and leg muscles were determined, and sensory evaluation was per- formed. The procedure of castration of hybrid roosters had a positive effect on body weight, feed conversion ratio and carcass traits.
    [Show full text]
  • Capon Production in South Dakota W
    South Dakota State University Open PRAIRIE: Open Public Research Access Institutional Repository and Information Exchange South Dakota State University Agricultural Bulletins Experiment Station 4-1-1940 Capon Production in South Dakota W. E. Poley Follow this and additional works at: http://openprairie.sdstate.edu/agexperimentsta_bulletins Recommended Citation Poley, W. E., "Capon Production in South Dakota" (1940). Bulletins. Paper 335. http://openprairie.sdstate.edu/agexperimentsta_bulletins/335 This Bulletin is brought to you for free and open access by the South Dakota State University Agricultural Experiment Station at Open PRAIRIE: Open Public Research Access Institutional Repository and Information Exchange. It has been accepted for inclusion in Bulletins by an authorized administrator of Open PRAIRIE: Open Public Research Access Institutional Repository and Information Exchange. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Table of Contents Characteristics of Capons_________________________________________________________________ _____________________ 3 Selection of Breeds________________________________________________________________________________________________ 4 When to Caponize_______________________________________________________________________________________________ . 5 Identification of Sex --------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 5 The Caponizing Operation -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 6 Adequate
    [Show full text]
  • Prisoned Chickens, Poisoned Eggs
    PRISONED CHICKENS, POISONED EGGS An Inside Look at the Modern Poultry Industry First published 1996. Revised Edition 2009 Book Publishing Company By Karen Davis, PhD Karen Davis, PhD, President United Poultry Concerns PO Box 150 Machipongo, VA 23405 (757) 678-7875 [email protected] 2 Table of Contents Preface to the New Edition Prologue Introduction Chapter 1 History Chapter 2 The Birth and Family Life of Chickens Chapter 3 The Life of the Battery Hen Chapter 4 The Life of the Broiler Chicken Chapter 5 The Death Chapter 6 A New Beginning References Index 3 Preface to the New Edition I wrote Prisoned Chickens, Poisoned Eggs in the mid-1990s in order to bring attention to the billions of chickens buried alive on factory farms. At the time, neither the animal rights movement nor the public at large knew very much about chickens or about how the poultry industry originated and developed in twentieth-century America to become the model for industrialized farmed-animal production around the world. Some informative articles and book chapters had appeared, but the poultry industry’s own detailed and glowing account of its transformation of the chicken, from an active outdoor bird scouring the woods and fields to a sedentary indoor meat and egg “machine,” filled with suffering, diseases, and antibiotics, remained largely unknown. The purpose of Prisoned Chickens, Poisoned Eggs was to bring this story to light in a way that would reveal the tragedy of chickens through the lens of the industry that created their tragedy without pity or guilt. The book became, as I’d hoped it would, a blueprint for people seeking a coherent picture of the U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • News Bulletin
    Issue 24, July 2014 News Bulletin http://www.aasg.org.au CONTENTS AASG News ................................................................................................................................ 2 National News ............................................................................................................................. 3 Regional News ............................................................................................................................ 4 Conferences and Symposiums: Conferences, symposiums, and workshops ............................. 8 Groups, Institutes and Networks: Fellowships, programs, scholarships, employment, grants ... 18 Report from the Field: Fiona Probyn-Rapsey @ Wesleyan University – ASI-WAS fellowship 2014 .......................................................................................................................................... 21 New Books: Summaries from publishers’ websites .................................................................. 24 Call for Submissions ................................................................................................................. 29 Awards ...................................................................................................................................... 34 Book Reviews ........................................................................................................................... 35 Journals: Human-animal related journals, special issues and articles .....................................
    [Show full text]
  • INTERNATIONAL Revlfew of POULTRY SCIENCE
    '>Z'?^p?y TOME VIII. ir 1935. //(jiy ^if •,. No. 1/2 INTERNATIONAL REVlfew OF POULTRY SCIENCE OFFICIAL ORGAN OF THE WORLD'S POULTRY SCIENCE ASSOCIATION EDITOR: Dr. B. J. 0. TE HENNEPE ROTTERDAM (Holland) This Review is free fo all members of the World's Poultry Science Association. All subscriptions should be sent to the Editor: Dr. B. J. C. te Hennepe, Rotterdam, or to the Secretary- Treasurer: Dr. G. F. Heuser, Cornell University, Ithaca, N.y., U.S.A. SUBSCRIPTIONS. $5.00 annually in advance. The personal membership of the W.P.S.A. per amounts to $5.00 For affiliated societies ,, „ $25.00 year ADVERTISEMENT RATES. One page, per issue $12.00 Half page, per issue $7.00 Special attention is called for BREEDERS' ADVERTISEMENTS which are now fixed on $1000 per full page, during 1 year. TOME VIII. 1955. No. 1/2. INTERNATIONAL REVIEW OF POULTRY SCIENCE OFFICIAL ORGAN OF THE WORLD'S POULTRY SCIENCE ASSOCIATION EDITOR: DR. B.J. CTEHENNEPE ROTTERDAM (Holland) Published by: Frifz PfenningstorfF, Berlin W 57 FOREWORD to the First Number of the Eîgth Volume. I herewith have the honour to offer you Vol. 8, No. 1/2 of the Inter- national Review. In the seven Volumes published since 1928 summaries have been given of numerous publications dealing with poultry. In spite of the crisis there is no decrease in the number of publications regarding poultry, but I am sorry to say, owing to lack of finances, I have not recently been able to review and publish articles as quickly as I should like to, after their appearance.
    [Show full text]
  • Practical Poultry Raising (May 2015 Revised Edition) Peace Corps Publication No
    PRACTICAL POULTRY RAISING (MAY 2015 REVISED EDITION) PEACE CORPS PUBLICATION NO. M0011 Knowledge and Learning Unit The Peace Corps’ Knowledge and Learning Unit (KLU), a department of the Office of Overseas Programming and Training Support, makes the strategies and technologies developed by Peace Corps Volunteers, their co-workers, and their counterparts available to development organizations and workers who might find them useful. KLU works with Peace Corps technical and training specialists to identify and develop information to support Volunteers and overseas staff. KLU also produces and distributes training guides, curricula, lesson plans, project reports, manuals, and other material. Peace Corps-generated materials are also developed in the field. Some materials are reprinted “as is”; others provide a source of field-based information for the production of manuals or for research in particular program areas. Materials submitted to KLU become part of the Peace Corps’ larger contribution to development. This publication was produced by the Peace Corps with funding from the U.S. Agency for International Development’s Bureau of Food Security. It is distributed through KLU. For further information about KLU materials (periodicals, books, videos, etc.) and information services, or for additional copies of this manual, please contact KLU and refer to the KLU catalog number that appears on the publication: Peace Corps Overseas Programming and Training Support Knowledge and Learning Unit 1111 20th Street Washington, DC 20526 Tel: 202.692.2640 Fax: 202.692.2641 Abridged Dewey Decimal Classification (DDC) Number: 636.5 Share your experience! Add your experience to the Peace Corps library of resources. Send your materials to us so we can share them with other development workers.
    [Show full text]
  • We're So Glad You Are Participating in the Real Organic Project
    We’re so glad you are participating in the Real Organic Project certification program. We are a grassroots, farmer-led movement created to distinguish soil-grown and pasture-raised products under USDA organic. This application will help us learn more about your crop and livestock systems. It shouldn't take you long to fill out right now behind your computer. Certification is free and inspection is based on a farm tour, rather than paperwork. There are 9 Sections in the application, but you only have to fill out the sections that apply to your farm. SECTIONS: 1. Farm Information (All Farmers Must Complete) 2. Crops (All Farmers Must Complete) 3. Split Farm (All Farmers Must Complete) 4. Greenhouse/High Tunnel 5. Livestock 6. Ruminants 7. Poultry 8. Pigs 9. Review and Submit (All Farmers Must Complete) If you prefer, you can also print and complete it on paper and mail it to us at the address below. If there are questions that don't apply to your farm, simply type NA (Not Applicable). Please submit the form even if it is incomplete, and your inspector will get any missing answers with you in person. Questions? Call Linley at (970) 317-0309 or email her at [email protected] Optional—mail completed printed form to: Linley Dixon 31417 Highway 550 Durango, CO 81301 The full Real Organic Project Standards: https://www.realorganicproject.org/provisional-standards 1 SECTION 1: FARM INFORMATION. Farm Name: Organic Since: Certifier + Certification Number: Full Mailing Address: Farm Physical Address(es): Primary Contact First and Last Name: Primary Email: Phone (mobile or best number to arrange visit): Website: Total Stewarded Acreage: Acres in Organic Crops Production: Acres in Organic Pasture: Acres in Trees/Conservation: Acres of Non-Certified Production: Please list the crops you grow, including pasture, and approximate acreage of each (Note: If you grow more than 10 crops, OK to answer "mixed vegetables" for example.
    [Show full text]
  • Chicken's Digestive System
    Poultry Leader Guide EM082E Level 2 4-H Poultry Leader Notebook Level II Identifying Poultry Feed Ingredients ........................................................3 How to Read Feed Tags ............................................................................7 Boney Birds ............................................................................................ 11 Chicken’s Digestive System ...................................................................17 Poultry Disease Prevention .....................................................................25 Poultry Parasites and Diseases ...............................................................27 Cracking Up—What’s in an Egg? ..........................................................31 Making and Using an Egg Candler ........................................................35 Constructing a Small Incubator ..............................................................39 Determining the Sex of Poultry ..............................................................45 Maternal Bonding and Imprinting (Follow the Leader) .........................49 Preventing Cannibalism ..........................................................................51 The Peck Order .......................................................................................55 Economics of Broiler Production ............................................................59 Poultry Furniture .....................................................................................65 Types of Poultry Housing .......................................................................69
    [Show full text]
  • City News September 26
    Councillor defends right to ask questions BY PETER HACKNEY Ms Vithoulkas told City News that after she Lynda’s fight for City of Sydney Councillor Angela Vithoulkas placed her Question on Notice, CEO Monica hris Peken has defended her right to ask questions, after Barone asked her to withdraw it. animal rights C claiming the City’s CEO asked her to withdraw “I refused because it was a valid question,” said BY PETER HACKNEY Lynda Stoner can remember the exact moment Photo: a Question on Notice directed to Sydney Lord Ms Vithoulkas. that led her to become one of Australia’s leading Mayor Clover Moore. A City of Sydney spokesperson confirmed that animal rights activists. Questions on Notice are posed in writing at “the CEO cannot request Councillors withdraw “It was nearly 40 years ago and I was visiting least a week before Council meetings, to give a question” – however the spokesperson claimed my parents’ place in South Australia. The TV was respondents time to research their answers. Ms Ms Vithoulkas was not asked to remove her showing footage of harp seal pups being battered Vithoulkas’s question to Ms Moore concerned question. and skinned alive. I just couldn’t get it out of my Kings Cross cheesemonger Claudia Bowman’s “The CEO informed Councillor Vithoulkas head. involvement in the upcoming Local Government that Council had no involvement in the events “When I got back to Melbourne, where I was living NSW (LGNSW) Conference. planned as part of the LGNSW Conference. at the time, I bought a copy of Peter Singer’s book Ms Bowman, who ran unsuccessfully on Ms In light of that, the CEO sought clarification Animal Liberation and read the first three chapters Moore’s election ticket last year, was scheduled to on whether [she] wanted to proceed with her in the back of the cab before I even got home.
    [Show full text]