T'he Journal

'Theological Studies

VOLUME XXVII

OXFORD AT THE CLARENDON PRESS COMMITTEE OF DIRECTION: Rev. DR BARNES, Hulsean Professor of Divinity, Cambridge. F. C. BuRKITT, D.D., Norrisian Professor of Divinity, Cambridge. Rev. DR CooKE, Regius Professor of Hebrew, Oxford. Rev. DR KENNETT, Regius Professor of Hebrew, Cambridge. Very Rev. DR KIRKPATRicK, Dean of Ely. Rev. DR LocK, Lady Margaret Professor of Divinity, Oxford. Rev. DR MASON, Canon of Canterbury. Very Rev. DR J. ARMITAGE RoBINSON, Dean of Wells. Right Rev. DR STRONG, Bishop of Oxford.

EDITORS: Rev. DR BETHUNE-BAKER, 23 Cranmer Road, Cambridge. Rev. F. E. BRIGHTMAN, Magdalen College, Oxford.

Printed in England At the OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS By John J ohnson Printer to the University I

INDEX OF WRITERS

PAGE BARNES, W. E. Dezetero-Isatah (R. Levy) • 4I7 Ecclesz"astes and the Early Greek Wz"sdom Literature (H. Ranston) 204 The Heart of Israel (G. W. Thorn) 4I6 Mz'cah, Obadiah,joel, andjonah (G. W. Wade). 205 Sacrifice z"n the Old Testament (G. B. Gray) 4I4 Zez'tschr.j. die alttestamentliche Wz"ssenschajt (N.F.) ii I, 2 207 BATIFFOL, P. D'UNE PRETENDUE REPRESENTATION DE LA CA THEDRA PETRI SUR UN SARCOPHAGE DU MUSEE DU LATRAN 396 BINNS, L. E. jeremz"ah and the New Covenant (W. E. Lofthouse) 418 BOUQUET, A. C. ST JOHN iii 25-A SUGGESTION . I8I BROOKE, A. E. REVIEWS OF WORKS ON THE NEW TESTAMENT 63, 297 BURKITT, F. C. Early Latin Hymns (A. S. Walpole). 220 PISTIS SOPHIA AND THE COPTIC LANGUAGE 148 ST SAMSON OF DOL . 42 Sol Salutis (]. Dolger) 420 TWO NOTES ON THE BAZAAR OF HERACLEIDES 177 BURN, A. E. THE AUTHORSHIP OF THE QUICUMQUE VULT • 19 BURNEY, C. F. CHRIST AS THE APXH OF CREATION 160 CASEY, R. P. NAASENES AND 0PHITES . 374 CHRISTIE, W. M. Hundert deutsche Fliegerbilder aus Palaestz"na (G. Dalman) 209 COLEMAN-NORTON, P. R. THE US.E OF DIALOGUE IN THE VITAE SANCTORUllf 388 CONNOLLY, R. H. Nestorius: The Bazaar of Heraclez'des (G. R. Driver and L. Hodgson) I91 COOK, S. A. CHRONICLE OF THE HISTORY OF RELIGIONS 321 COOKE, G. A. Hezekiel (G. Hiilscher) 20I iv INDEX OF WRITERS

PAGE CREED, J. M. The Approach to Christianity (E. G. Selwyn) 305 Herme!z"ca (W. Scott) . 77 DIX, G. H. THE ENOCHIC PENTATEUCH 29 THE BEN 130 DRIVER, G. R. Geschichte des Volkes Israel (R. Kittel) 2Il Grammaire del' Hibreu Biblique (P. Joiion) 212 Israel and Baby/on (W. L. Wardle) . 412 ON SOME PASSAGES IN THE BOOKS OF KINGS AND CHRONICLES 158 Sumer et Akkad (C.-F. Jean) 2I6 Sumerian Religious Texts (E. Chi era) 219 FEL TOE, C. L. Der Stadtriimische christliche Fest-Kalender im Alterthum (J. P. Kirsch) 109 GARDNER-SMITH, P. THE DATE OF THE GOSPEL OF PETER 401 ETTIO~K€1 N 179 A Handbook of Christian Ethics (D. S. ) 441 The Ethics of the Gospel (F. A. M. Spencer) 443 THE GOSPEL OF PETER 255 GRESSMANN, H. FOREIGN INFLUENCES IN HEBREW PROPHECY • 241 HOGG, J. E. NOTE ON 'THE MESSIAH BENJOSEPH' 4II HUGHES, H. M. La Reaction Weslt!yenne (M. Piette) . 426 HUNKIN, J. W. THE PROHIBITIONS OF THE COUNCIL AT JERUSALEM 272 JAMES, M. R. Old Testament Legends (ed. F. H. Marshal!) 320 LOCK, W. The Master-Idea of Saint Paul's Epistles (R. G. Bandas). 68 LOWE, E. A. THE VATICAN MS OF THE GELASIAN SACRAMENTARY AND ITS SUPPLEMENT AT PARIS 357 MANNING, B. L. The Constitution of the Domznican Order (G. R. Galbraith) '424 The Dominican Order in Britain before the Reformation (B. E. R. Fermoy) 313 McARA, M. Immanence and Incarnation (S. F. Davenport) 185 MINNS, E. H. Palaeographt"a Latina (W. M. Lindsay) 443 INDEX OF WRITERS V PAG& MONTGOMERY, W. Augustz"nus: eine PsychograpMe (B. Legewie) I05 La Morale de Saint Augustin (B. Roland-Gosselin) 106 MURRAY, R. H. The Anglican Revival (Y. Brilioth) . I07 Luther and the Reformation (J. Mackinnon) 3I5 Studi'en zur Geschichle des Konzils von Trient (K. D. Schmidt) 108 NAIRNE, A. Johannes Scotus Erigena (H. Bett) 422 Paul of Tarsus (T. R. Glover) . 69 NOCK, A. D. and the Greeks (W. Fairweather) 30 7 OAKESHOTT, M. J. The Christian Religion and £/s Competitors To-day (A. C. Bouquet) 440 Providence-Divine and Human (E. Griffith-Jones). 440 Science, Religion, and Reality (ed. J. Needham) 317 OMAN, J. Le Culte (R. Will) I83 Miracle and z"ts Philosophical Presuppositions (F. R. Tennant) I84 OTTLEY, R. R. •r/JofJovii'TO yap 407 PEARCE, E. H. The Ascetic Works of SI Basil (W. K. L. Clarke) 3I2 READE, W. H. V. INTELLECTUAL TOLERATION IN DANTE I REVIEWS OF WORKS ON ST THOMAS AQUINAS 92 RICHARDS, G. C. A Greek-English Lexicon (H. S. Jones) 76 ROBINSON, J. A. THE EARLY COMMUNITY AT CHRIST CHURCH, CANTERBURY , 225 SCOTT, C. A. The Life, Letters, and Religion of St Paul (C. T. Wood) 74 The Sermon on the Mount (H. Marriott) 72 REVIEWS OF WORKS ON CHURCH HISTORY 307 SLOTKI, I. W. EZEKIEL xvi 4 27I SMITH, B. T. D. St Paul and the Church ofJerusalem (W. L. Knox) 303 SOUTER, A. A hand-list of haif-uncial MSS (E. A. Lowe) • 75 Grzmdrio·s der Einleitung in das Neue Testament (H. J. Vogels) 75 STEWART, H. F. A. 1lf. S. Boethi de Consolatione Ph£/osophiae (A. Fortescue and G. D. Smith) I90 Pascal, Pensles (J. Chevalier) I88 vi INDEX OF WRITERS PAGE STREETER, B. H. Chris#an Beginnings (F. C. Burkitt) 71 THE WASHINGTON MS AND THE CAESAREAN TEXT OF THE GOSPELS 144 SYMONS, T. THE INTRODUCTION OF MONKS AT CHRIST CHURCH, CANTERBURY 409 TELFER, W. Julien d'Halicarnasse {R. Draguet) 81 Novatien (A. D'Ales) . 86 The Rule of Faith in the Ecclesiastical Writings of the first two centun·es (A. J. C oan) • 421 The Theology of Tertullian (R. E. Roberts) 88 TENNANT, F. R. The Nature of Religion (W. P. Paterson) . 434 PersonaNty and Reality (J. E. Turner) 438 Le Probleme du Miracle dans le Chrisft'anisme primitif (A. Fridrichsen) . 438 Science and the Modern World(A. N. Whitehead) . 427 TURNER, C. H. ADVERSARIA CRITICA: NOTES ON THE ANTI-DONATIST DOSSIER AND ON 0PTATUS, BOOKS i, ii. 283 MAR CAN USAGE: NOTES, CRITICAL AND EXEGETICAL, ON THE SECOND GOSPEL • 58 0 YIOC MOY 0 ArATTHTOC II3 WALKER, C. T. H. Den Allmiinneliga Kristna Tron (G. Auh!n) 89 WALL, J. ReHgionsgeschichtliche Erkliirungdes N. T. (C. Clemen) 418 WEBB, C. C. J. Aristoteles: Grundlegzmg einer Gescht"chte seiner Entwicklung (W. Jaeger) . 97 WHITNEY, J. P. REVIEWS OF WORKS ON CHURCH HISTORY 101 WIDGERY, A. G. The Theology of the Real (R. G. Milburn) . 444 WILMART, A. EASTER SERMONS OF ST AUGUSTINE 337 11

INDEX OF ARTICLES PAGE THE EARLY COMMUNITY AT CHRIST CHURCH CANTERBURY. By J. Armitage Robinson 225 0 YIOC MOY 0 ArATTHTOC. By C. H. Turner II3 CHRONICLE: THE HISTORY OF RELIGIONS. By S. A. Cook 32I DOCUMENTS: EASTER SERMONS OF ST AUGUSTINE. By A. Wilmart 337 NOTES AND STUDIES: ANTI-DONATIST DOSSIER AND ON 0PTATUS, BOOKS i, ii, NOTES ON THE. By C. H. Turner 283 BAZAAR OF HERACLEIDES, TWO NOTES ON THE. By F. C. Burkitt • I 77 CATHEDRA PETRI, D'UNE PRETENDUE REPRESENTATION DE LA, SUR UN SARCOPHAGE DU MUSEE DU LATRAN. By P. ~~. ~ CHRIST AS THE APXH OF CREATION. By C. F. Burney I6o CHRIST CHURCH, CANTERBURY, THE INTRODUCTION OF MONKS AT.. By T. Symons 409 CHRONICLES, ON SOME PASSAGES IN THE BOOKS OF KINGS AND. By G. R. Driver • I58 COPTIC LANGUAGE, PISTIS SOPHIA AND THE. By F. C. Burkitt I48 COUNCIL AT JERUSALEM [ACTS XV 28, 29], THE PROHIBITIONS OF THE. By J. W. Hunkin. 272 DANTE, INTELLECTUAL TOLERATION IN. By W. H. V. Reade • I DIALOGUE IN THE VITAE SANCTORUM, THE USE OF. By P. R. Coleman-Norton. 388 ENOCHIC PENTATEUCH, THE. By G. H. Dix 29 €TTIQ~K€1N. By P. Gardner-Smith I79 EZEKIEL xvi 4· By I. W. Slotki 27I £cpofJoVIITO yap. By R. R. Ottley • 407 GELASIAN SACRAMENTARY, THE VATICAN MS OF THE, AND ITS SUPPLEMENT AT PARIS. By E. A. Lowe 357 GOSPEL OF PETER, THE DATE OF THE. By P. Gardner-Smith . 40I GOSPEL OF PETER, THE. By P. Gardner-Smith. 255 GOSPELS, THE WASHINGTON MS AND THE CAESAREAN TEXT OF THE. By B. H. Streeter 144 viii INDEX OF ARTICLES PAGE HEBREW PROPHECY, FOREIGN INFLUENCES ON. By H. Gressmann • 24I ST JOHN iii 25-A SUGGESTION. By A. C. Bouquet I8I KINGS AND CHRONICLES, ON SOME PASSAGES IN THE BOOKS OF. By G. R. Driver . 158 MARCAN USAGE: NOTES, CRITICAL AND EXEGETICAL, ON THE SECOND GOSPEL. By C. H. Turner • 58 MESSIAH BEN JOSEPH, THE. By G. H. Dix. 130 MESSIAH BEN JOSEPH, NOTE ON THE. By J. E. Hogg 4ll NAASENES AND 0PHITES. By R. P. Casey • 374 0PTATUS, BOOKS i, ii, NOTES ON THE ANTI·DONATIST DOSSIER AND ON. By C. H. Turner. 283 PISTIS SOPHIA AND THE (OPTIC LANGUAGE. By F. C. Burkitt. 148 QUICUMQUE VULT, THE AUTHORSHIP OF THE. By A. E. Burn • 19 ST SAMSON OF DOL. By F. C. Burkitt 42 WASHINGTON MS AND THE CAESAREAN TEXT OF THE GOSPELS. By B. H. Streeter 144 Ill

INDEX OF AUTHORS AND BOOKS REVIEWED OR NOTICED

Acts xv 28, 29 ADAM, D. S. A Handbook of Christian Ethics ALLEN, P. S. Opus Epistolarum Des. Erasmi V I04 S. Augustine 105, I06, 337 AuLEN, G. Den Allmiinneliga Kristna Tr01z . 89 BANDAS, R. G. The Master-Idea of Saint Paul's Epistles or the Redemption 68 BARON, H. Calvin's Staatsanschauung und das konfessionelle Zeitalter S. BASIL. Ascetica. BATIFFoL, P. Le Siege Apostolique 103 BAUER, W. Das Johannes-Evang1lium • 66 , Gnechisch-Deutsches Worterbuch su den Schnjtcn des N.T. 67 BAUNARD, MGR. Un Siecle de l'Eglise de France, z8oo-z9oo 104 Bazaar of Heracleides I 77, 191 BETT, H. Johannes Scotus Erigena 422 BoNNET, H. See HAAs, H. BouQUET, A. C. The Chnstian Religion and its Competitors To-day 440 BRILIOTH, Y. The Anglican Revival 107 BROXAP, H. Later Non-Jurors 103 BuLLOUGH. E. See GILSoN, E. BuRKITT, F. C. Christian Beginnings 71 CAnoux, C. J. The Early Church and the World 310 CALDER, W. M. Notes on Anatolian Religion 324 CHEVALIER, J. Pascal, Pensies 188 CHIERA, E. Sumen"an Religious Texts • 219 CHOISY, E. L' Etat chritien Calviniste a Geneve au temps de TModore de Bese I03 2 Chronicles .xxii 1 o I 59 CHUMNos, GEORGios. See MARSHALL, F. H. CLARKE, W. K. L. The Ascetic Works of Saint Basil 312 CLEMEN, C. Religionsgeschichtliche Erkliirung des N. T. • 4I8 CoAN, A. J. The Rule of Faith in the Ecclesiastical wn"ters of the first two centuries • 42 I Colossians i 15-I8 I73 CoNsTANT, G. La Legation du Cardinal Morone pres l' Empereur et le Conctle de Trente I04 CoNTENAU, G. La Glyptique Syro-Htttite 321 D"Ad:s, A. Novatten 86 DALMAN, G. Hundert deutsche Fliegerbilder aus Palaestina 209 DANTE. Paradtso x 134 sq· 9 DAvENPORT, S. F. Immanence and Incarnation 185 x AUTHORS AND BOOKS REVIEWED OR NOTICED

PAGE DEDIEU, J. Histoire politique des Protcstantsfranfais • I04 DE LA BouLLAYE, P. L'Etude Comparie des Religions ii, 332 DE VUIPPENS, I. Le Paradis Terrestre au Troisieme Ciel. 327 DIBELius, M. An die Thessalonicher ~~ ii. An die Philipper 64 DoLGER, F. J. Sol Salutis 420 DRAGUET, R. Julien d'Halicarnasse 8r DRIVER, G. R., and L. HooGSON. Nestorius: The Bazaar of Heracleides 191 DuCHESNE, L. The Early History of the Christian Church iii (tr. C. )ENKINS). IOI DuFOURCQ, A. Les Religions pai"ennes et la Religion juive comparies 329 Enoch 29 Ezekiel 20I , xvi 4 27I FAIRWEATHER, W. Jesus and the Greeks or Early Christianity in the tidewa_v of Hellenism 307 FLICHE, A. La Riforme Grigorienne 103 FoRMOY, B. E. R. The Dominican Order in England bifore the Reformation 313 FoRTESCUE, A., and G. D. SMITH. A. M. S. Boethi De Consolatione Philosophiae 190 FRIDRICHSEN, A. Le Probleme du Miracle dans le Christianisme primihj 438 GALBRAITH, G. R. The Constitution of the Dominican Order, z:u6-z;6o 424 GAUDEFROY-DEMOMBYNES. Le Pelerinage a la Mekke 324 ,, La Syrz'e a l'ipoque des Mamelouks 325 GAZIER, A. Histoire genirale du mouvement ]ansiniste • 104 Gelasianum 357 GILsoN, E. The Philosophy of St. Thomas Aquinas, Eng. tr. by E. BuLLOUGH 92 , Saint Thomas d' Aquin 92 GLORIEUX, P. La Littirature Quodlibitique 95 GLOvER, T. R. Paul of Tarsus 69 Gospel of Peter GouGAUD, L. Gaelic Pioneers of Christianity • GRAY, G. B. Sacrzjice in the Old Testament • GRIFFITH-)ONES, E. Providence-Divine and Human GRUHN, A. Der Schlussel zur Mythologie HAAS, H. Bzlderatlas zur Religionsgeschichte Handbuch zum Neuen Testament ( ed. H. LIETZMANN) S. HIPPOLYTUS. Philosophumena V 6-Ir, viii 12-15 HonGsoN, L. See DRIVER, G. R. H6LSCHER, G. Hezekiel . 201 Isaiah xl-lv 4I7 )AEGER, W. Aristoteles: Grundlegung einer Geschichte seiner Entwicklung 97 jEAN, C.-F. Le Pichi chez les Babyloniens et les Assyriens 323 Sumer et Akkad • 2ll jENKINS," C, See DucHESNE, L. Jeremiah. 4I8 S.John • 297' 2 99 " iii 25 • ISI JoNES, H. S. A Greek-English Lexicon 76 JoiioN, P. Grammaire de f Hibreu Biblique 2I2 Journal of the Manchester Egyptian and Oriental Society xi 324 KENNEDY, W. P. M. Elizabethan Episcopal Administration 104 Kmn, B. J. History of the Church to A. D. 46I IOI AUTHORS AND BOOKS REVIEWED OR NOTICED xi

PAGE I Kings xviii 26 I 59 2 Kings iv I3 • I 58 KrRscH, J. P. Der Stadtromische chnstliche Fest-Ka/ender im A/terthum I09 KrTTEL, R. Geschichte des Volkes Israel , 2II KLOSTERMAN, E. Das Markusevangelium 300 KNOPP, R. Einfuhrung in das Neue Testament 67 KNox, W. L. St Paul and the Church ofJerusalem 303 LAGRANGE, P. M.]. Evangile se/on Saint Jean 299 LEGEWIE, B. Augustinus: eine Psychographic I05 LEHMANN, E., and others. Lehrbuch der Reli'gionsgeschichte 329 LE MARCHANT, A. Greek Religion in the iime of Hesiod • 323 LEvY, R. Deutero-lsaiah 4I7 LEwis, J· Mother-worship in Egypt 324 LIETZMANN, H. An die Galater 65 , An die Korinther i, ii 6s LINDSAY, W. M. Palaeographia Latina iv 443 LoFTHOUSE, W. F. Jeremiah and the New Covenant p8 Lorsv, M. L'Evangile selon Luc 63 LowE, E. A. A hand-list of half-uncia/ manuscnpts 75 S. Luke . 63 , , xxiii 53, 54 ·180 MACKINNON, J. Luther and the Reformation 3I5 S. Mark. ss, 300, 301 xvi I. I8o " 8. 407 MARRIOTT, H. The Sermon on the Mount 72 MARSHALL, F. H. Old Testament Legends from Georgt"os Chumnos 320 S. Matthew xxviii r 1 79 MERCER, S. Tutankhamen and Egyptology MERRIL, E. T. Essays in Early Christian History MrLBURN, R. G. The Theology of the Real

MoGK1 E. See HAAs, H. MuLLER, K. Kirchengeschichte 3II NEEDHAM, ]., and others. Science, Religion, and Reality 317

NoLLOTH 1 C. F. The Fourth Evangelist . 297 NowAcK, PROF. W. Schabbat 329 0ESTERLEY, W. 0. E. The Sacred Dance 326 S. 0PTATUS. Contra Donatistas 283 PATERSON, W. P. The Nature of Religzon 434 S. Paul . 68, 69, 74, 303 PEARSON, A. F. S. Thomas Cartwright and Elizabethan Puritanism I03 PIETTE, M. La Reaction Wes/iyenne dans I' Evolution Protestante 426 Pistis Sophi'a . I 48 Proverbs viii n I 6o PuLLAN, L. Religion since the Reformation I02 Quicumque vult I9 RADIN, P. Monotheism among Primitive People 33I RANSTON, H. Ecclesiastes and the Early Greek 1¥isdom Literature . 204 RA WLINSON, A. E. J. The Gospel according to S. Mark • 30I RoBERTS, R. E. The Theology of Tertullian . 88 xii AUTHORS AND BOOKS REVIEWED OR NOTICED

PAGE RoCQUAIN, F. La France et Rome pendant les guerres de religion 104 RoLAND-GossELIN, B. La Morale de Saint Augustin 106 RoUGIER, L. La Scholastique et ' Le Thomisme ' • 93 Ri.icKERT, H. Die Rechiferligzmgslehre auf dem Tridentischen Konzil 104 ScHMIDT, K. D. Studien zur Geschichte des Konzils von Trient 108 ScoTT, W. Hermetica . 77 Scotus Erigena, Jo. • 422 SEDGWICK, H. D. Ignatius Loyola 103 SELWYN, E. G. The Approach to Christianity 305 Semaine d' Ethnolo!JI'e Religieuse 331 SMITH, G. D. See FaRTESCUE, A. SPENCER, F. A. M. The Ethics of the Gospel ,44' St Thomas Aquinas: papers from the Summer School of Catholic Studies at Cambridge 1924 92 TENNANT, F. R. Miracle and its Philosophical Presuppositions 184 THORN, G. W. The Heart of Israel: an approach to the Psalms 416 TuRNER, J. E. Personality and Reality • 438 Vita S. Samsonis 42 VoGELS, H.]. Grundriss der Einleitung tn das N. T. 75 WADE, G. W. Micah, Obadiah, Joel, and Jonah 205 WALPOLE, A. S. Early Latin Hymns · 220 WARDLE, W. L. Israel andBabylon 4I2 WHITEHEAD, A. N. Sct'ence and the Modern World. 427 WILL, R. Le Culte 183 WINDFUHR. Baba Mezia 328 WooD, C. T. The L•fe, Letters, and Religion of St Paul 74