Antigenic Relationships Among Floc-Forming Pseudomonadaceae
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ANTIGENIC RELATIONSHIPS AMONG FLOC-FORMING PSE UDOMONADA CEA El FRANK W. CHORPENNING, DAVID H. SCHMIDT, HUGH B. STAMPER and PATRICK R. DUGAN, Department of Microbiology, Ohio State University, Columbus, OH 43210 Abstract. A number of cross-reactions were observed between the antigens of floc- forming pseudomonads. Immunodiffusion tests of trichloroacetic acid extracts showed that antigens are shared by some Zoogloea spp. and Pseudomonas spp., yet other Zoo- gloea and Pseudomonas spp. lack these antigens. One of the antigens was also found in Gluconobacler. This demonstration of a close antigenic relationship between some, but not all, members of the 3 genera must be weighed against the limited number of char- acteristics which establish the generic distinction. OHIO J. SCI. 78(1): 29, 1978 Members of the genera Zoogloea, Glu- bacter using agglutination and tube pre- conobacter, and Pseudomonas share many cipitation tests. He reported that A. of the same distinctive characteristics, suboxydans (Gluconobacler) strains con- and studies of ecological significance stituted a distinguishable serologic group, (Crabtree and McCoy 1967, Friedman unrelated to A. rancens. Other species and Dugan 1968, Friedman et al 1968, were not included in the study. In view Dugan 1975) have been handicapped by of the difficulties in identifying pseudo- difficulties in identification. These bac- monad bacteria, we have examined the teria are all gram-negative, polarly-flag- serologic reactions of examples in 'S of the ellated, aerobic rods, and are frequently genera mentioned above. isolated from aquatic habitats where they grow as flocculent aggregates of MATERIALS AND METHODS Organisms. Pseudomonads included in this cells rather than dispersed. They are study were Zoogloea ramigera 115 (ATCC 25935), nonfermentative, catalase-positive organ- Z. jilipendula P84, Z. ramigera 1-16-M (ATCC isms which produce varying amounts of 19623), P. denitrificans (ATCC 13867), Gluco- extracellular polymer that has been im- nobacter oxydans, subsp. oxydans (ATCC 9433), G. oxydans subsp. suboxydans (ATCC 621) and plicated in the bio-flocculation process Pseudomonas species C3 which was isolated (Friedman et al 1969). Interest in these from raw water and previously described organisms is related to the ecological (Friedman and Dugan 1968). significance of the flocculation phenome- Preparation of Antigens. Cultures were grown for 2 days at 26°C in a 12-liter fermenter con- non in removal of organic and mineral taining trypticase soy broth (TSB) (Becton, water pollutants (Dugan and Pickrum Dickinson, Cockeysville, MD) except that 1972). Many of these bacteria are in- mannitol-yeast extract-peptone broth was used digenous to aerobic waste treatment for growing the Gluconobacter spp. The cells were collected by eentrifugation, using the systems and have high adsorptive cap- KSB continuous-flow apparatus (Sorvall, RC2B abilities in addition to strong hydrolytic Centrifuge) and washed twice in saline by the and oxidative capacities (Joyce and Du- same procedure. The antigens were extracted gan 1970). from whole cells with 0.25N trichloroacetic acid (TCA) by the method of Van Eeden (1967) There are few reports concerning anti- except that the TCA soluble extracts were genic relationships among the Pseudo- dialyzed against 3 changes of phosphate-buf- monadaceae other than for the genus fered saline (pH 7.4) at 4°C. An extract of TSB was prepared in the same way, as a con- Pseudomonas. An exception is Mclntosh trol. Extracts were stored at 4°C with 0.02% (1962), who studied antigenic analysis of sodium azide added as a preservative. organisms attributed to the genus Aceto- Antisera. Rabbits were immunized by in- jecting suspensions of the heat-killed organisms iManuscript received May 27, 1977 and in re- (4 x 109 cells) subcutaneously in Freud's in- vised form September 15, 1977 (#77-43). complete adjuvant. The schedule consisted of 29 30 F. W. CHORPENNING ET AL Vol. 78 2 injections a month apart. Some animals were bacter oxydans subsp. suboxydans (fig. lb). injected a third time after a lapse of several months. Test sera were collected when trial The reactions of antisera against Pseudo- bleedings produced good homologous reactions. monas sp. C3 likewise demonstrated Immunodiffusion Tests. Antisera were ex- strong cross-reactions with Z. ramigera amined by immunodiffusion against trichloro- 115 (figs. 2a and 2b). The reaction of acetic acid extracts of the homologous and heterologous organisms. Some immunodiffu- identity is clear in figure 2b. A different sion tests were performed in Petri plates and antiserum against C3 again exhibited some by the micro-modification (Wadsworth cross-reactions with Z. ramigera 115 but 1957). In either case, 1% Noble Agar was also showed a reaction of identity with employed and 0.05% trypan blue was added for better visualization. Precipitation patterns both G. oxydans subspecies (fig. 2c). The were read at various times, but examples shown cross-reactions of anti-C3 with Z. rami- in the figures were photographed between 18 gera 115 and Z. ramigera 1-16-M were and 36 hours. confirmed with still another antiserum (fig. 2d), but a reaction between this RESULTS serum and Z. filipendula P84 could not Antisera to 6 floc-forming pseudomon- be demonstrated. ads, which produced strong precipitation reactions with homologous extracts, cross- Evidence that antibody specificities in reacted with extracts from certain other antisera raised to Z. ramigera 115 and pseudomonads. Both of the Zoogloea Pseudomonas sp. C3 are identical is pre- spp. exhibited cross-reactions with Pse- sented in figure 3, where the reactions of udomonas sp. C3 and one cross-reacted the 2 antisera with an extract of Pseudo- with Gluconobacter spp. These antisera monas sp. C3 were reactions of identity. FIGURE 1. Cross-reactions between antisera to Z. ramigera 115 (center well) and other pseudomonads: Pseudomonas sp. C3 (1), Gluconobacter oxydans subsp. suboxydans (2), Gluconobacter oxydans subsp. oxydans (3), Z. filipendula P84 (4), Z. ramigera 1-16-M (5), and Z. ramigera 115 (6). Fig. la shows a multispecific serum, Fig. lb shows a reaction of identity (arrow) between Z. ramigera 115 (6), Pseudomonas C3 (1), Z. ramigera 1-16-M (5) and Gluconobacter oxydans subsp. suboxydans (2). did not cross-react with extracts of P. A similar experiment, using an extract of denitrificans. At least 6 cross-reactions Z. ramigera 115 as the antigen, con- of apparently different specificities were firmed this identity. observed. Using an antiserum to Z. ramigera Immunodiffusion tests indicated the 1-16-M, reactions of identity were ob- complexity of the cross-reaction (fig. la) served with Z. ramigera 115 and Pseudo- and produced partial clarification. Some monas sp. C3, but were weak and could antisera against Zoogloea ramigera 115 de- not be clearly photographed. Antisera fined an antigen which is identical with to Z. filipendula P84 yield cross-reactions one of Pseudomonas sp. C3 and Glucono- with Pseudomonas sp. C3 and Z. rami- Ohio J. Sci. ANTIGENS OF THE PSEUDOMONADACEAE 31 FIGURE 2. Cross-reactions between antisera to Pseudomonas sp. C3 (center well) and extracts of other pseudomonads. Fig. 2a and 2b show reactions with Pseudomonas sp. (1) and Z. ramigera 115 (6). Fig. 2c shows reactions of identity with Z. ramigera 115 (6), G. oxydans subsp. oxydans (2) and G. oxydans subsp. suboxydans (3). Also present (arrow) is a reaction of partial identity with Zoogloea filipendula P84 (4) and Zoogloea ramigera 1-16-M (5). Fig. 2d shows a reaction of identity between Pseudomonas sp. C3 (1), Z. ramigera 115 (6) and Z. ramigera 1-16-M (5) with a different preparation of antiserum. Although the latter reaction (5) is faintly visible in the photo, it was clearly seen in the gel. gera 1-16-M, but not with Z. ramigera DISCUSSION 115, thus appearing to involve a different A variety of antigens have been demon- antigen. strated in floc-forming pseudomonads The cross-reaction between the G. which cross the lines of established genera. oxydans subsp. suboxydans and Z. rami- No single antigen defines a species or gera 115 is shown in figure 4a. Clearly, 2 genus and the presence of a variety of or more antigens relate these organisms. carbohydrate antigens is suggested. At Whether one of these is the same spe- least 3 different antigenic determinants cificity as the one observed in antisera to are shared by Zoogloea ramigera 115 and Z. ramigera 115 and Pseudomonas sp. C3 Pseudomonas sp. C3, indicating a close has not been determined. The Glucono- relationship between these organisms. bacter spp. shared a different antigen One of these determinants was also found which was not demonstrated in either Z. in Z. ramigera 1-16-M, but none were ramigera 115 or Z. filipendula P84, (fig. demonstrated in Z. filipendula P84, or in 4b). A list of the antigenic relationships Pseudomonas denitrificans. observed is presented in table 1. Table 1 shows that a number of in- 32 F. W. CHORPENNING ET AL Vol. 78 TABLE 1 Reactions of Identity Observed with Heterologous Species Antiserum Against: Extract From: Z. ramigera 115 Pseudomonas sp. C3 G. oxydans subsp. sub- oxydans Z. ramigera 1-16-M Z. ramigera 1-16-M Pseudomonas sp. C3 Pseudomonas sp. C3 Z. ramigera 115 and 1-16-M G. oxydans subsp. sub- oxydans G. oxydans subsp. oxydans FIGURE 3. Identity of the major antibody Z. filipendula P 84 Z. ramigera 1-16-M specificities in antisera to Pseudomonas C3 Pseudomonas sp. C3 (1) and Z. ramigera 115 (2) was shown by testing against Pseudomonas sp. C3 extract G. oxydans subsp. Z. ramigera 115 (4). Wells 3 and 5 contained antiserum to suboxydans G. oxydans subsp. oxydans Z. filipendula P84 and the two bottom wells G. oxydans subsp. Z. filipendula P84 were empty. oxydans G. oxydans subsp. sub- oxydans teresting relationships were demonstrated and that several different antigens appear to be shared across generally accepted From the results presented, it appears taxonomic lines.