The Fourth Book of Maccabees in a Multi-Cultural City

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

The Fourth Book of Maccabees in a Multi-Cultural City The Fourth Book of Maccabees in a Multi-Cultural City Tessa Rajak Introduction There are those for whom the Fourth Book of Maccabees sits comfortably as a minor book of the Bible, or at least an adjunct, belonging to the wider bib- lical corpus, among them, naturally enough, experts on the Septuagint and related fields. But such a categorization is really only meaningful in the con- tingent sense that 4 Maccabees figures in two of the great Septuagint codices, Sinaiticus and Alexandrinus (of the fourth and fifth centuries respectively). It is probably not an advantageous approach if we seek to give this extraordinary little tract its due, and if we aspire to explore it without preconceptions, and to locate its context. True, the work was loved by the early Church; but even so, it is worth pointing out, very few Christian denominations have allowed it apocryphal or deuterocanonical status.1 This book is patently a pious and yet highly rhe- torical literary and philosophical composition in dialogue form; a product of the Graeco-Jewish Diaspora of the Roman period. We cannot absolutely rule out that what we have received through a complicated manuscript tradition (which is of course wholly Christian) is an original production of the early Church, posing as an authentic pre-Christian, Jewish discourse, a contribution to the appropriation of the Maccabean heritage by the “new Israel”. I shall pro- ceed here, however, as has been done almost universally, on the assumption that this is not the case, and that what we see is what we get, a rare example of late Jewish-Greek writing: in fact, our only full-length ancient Jewish-Greek (or largely Jewish) martyrology. The eighteen chapters are a rhetorical and philosophical elaboration on the narrative of the deaths in the persecution of the early 160s BCE conducted by the Seleucid monarch Antiochus (IV Epiphanes) of nine Jewish martyrs: an aged priest, Eleazar (in 2 Maccabees the martyr is a scribe), followed by seven sons and then their mother. Antiochus seeks to force Eleazar, and then each of the sons in turn to deny Judaism by publicly eating sacrificial pork. One by 1 In most academic collections 4 Macc appears in the category of Pseudepigrapha. © koninklijke brill nv, leiden, ���6 | doi ��.��63/97890043��694_007 The Fourth Book Of Maccabees In A Multi-cultural City 135 one, brutally terrorized, the boys refuse to eat the forbidden meat or even to pretend to do so as a device for saving the King’s honour. Each declares that he prefers extreme torture and agonizing death, in the knowledge that he has been loyal to the Law of his people, and in the certainty expectation of imme- diate access to heaven. Each son in turn personally confronts the enthroned tyrant, utters words of defiance and contempt, and gladly pays the price. They are encouraged and pressed by their elderly, widowed mother, whose exem- plary constancy wins the author’s special praise, and who herself dies last and untouched, by leaping into the flames. The narrative of our book is an expansion of the much briefer account of the same incident in a stirring, and equally gruesome digression within the late Hellenistic Second Book of Maccabees, chapters 6 (18–31)-7. There, the event was represented as taking place during the Maccabean revolt (167–164 BCE), as part of the persecution that culminated in the desecration of the Temple through the installation of a pagan cult. In 4 Maccabees the loca- tion of the martyrdoms is not clearly identified, but there are dim echoes of a distant conflict.2 The dependence of the 4 Maccabees version on the sec- ond Maccabean book is completely clear, even though 4 Maccabees is a very different kind of work in terms of genre, style and focus. There appears to be no added information in the latter; rather some of the background informa- tion derived from the earlier book seems to have become garbled; notably, in the preliminary scene setting, the name of the Seleucid commander repelled by an angel from the Temple is given as Apollonius instead of Heliodorus (4 Macc 4:10; cf 2 Macc 3:31–5). A proposed localization to a city of Roman Asia, quite recently put forward, is not compelling when set against the more familiar association with the great city of Antioch in Syria, as we shall shortly see. In what follows, I shall reflect upon the Antiochene connection from a new angle by exploring how 4 Maccabees might fit into what we can piece together of the history of the Jews of Antioch. I shall go on to view the position of 4 Maccabees between Greek thought and Jewish values, and between Judaism and Christianity, against the background of that mixed, sometimes conflicted, sometimes harmonious city. 2 Perhaps, however, the concluding mention of the King’s abject departure from Jerusalem after failing to get its people to change their identity and abandon the customs of their fathers (18:5) suggests that this was the location of the specific episode that has just been discussed..
Recommended publications
  • Syllabus, Deuterocanonical Books
    The Deuterocanonical Books (Tobit, Judith, 1 & 2 Maccabees, Wisdom, Sirach, Baruch, and additions to Daniel & Esther) Caravaggio. Saint Jerome Writing (oil on canvas), c. 1605-1606. Galleria Borghese, Rome. with Dr. Bill Creasy Copyright © 2021 by Logos Educational Corporation. All rights reserved. No part of this course—audio, video, photography, maps, timelines or other media—may be reproduced or transmitted in any form by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording or by any information storage or retrieval devices without permission in writing or a licensing agreement from the copyright holder. Scripture texts in this work are taken from the New American Bible, revised edition © 2010, 1991, 1986, 1970 Confraternity of Christian Doctrine, Washington, D.C. and are used by permission of the copyright owner. All Rights Reserved. No part of the New American Bible may be reproduced in any form without permission in writing from the copyright owner. 2 The Deuterocanonical Books (Tobit, Judith, 1 & 2 Maccabees, Wisdom, Sirach, Baruch, and additions to Daniel & Esther) Traditional Authors: Various Traditional Dates Written: c. 250-100 B.C. Traditional Periods Covered: c. 250-100 B.C. Introduction The Deuterocanonical books are those books of Scripture written (for the most part) in Greek that are accepted by Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox churches as inspired, but they are not among the 39 books written in Hebrew accepted by Jews, nor are they accepted as Scripture by most Protestant denominations. The deuterocanonical books include: • Tobit • Judith • 1 Maccabees • 2 Maccabees • Wisdom (also called the Wisdom of Solomon) • Sirach (also called Ecclesiasticus) • Baruch, (including the Letter of Jeremiah) • Additions to Daniel o “Prayer of Azariah” and the “Song of the Three Holy Children” (Vulgate Daniel 3: 24- 90) o Suzanna (Daniel 13) o Bel and the Dragon (Daniel 14) • Additions to Esther Eastern Orthodox churches also include: 3 Maccabees, 4 Maccabees, 1 Esdras, Odes (which include the “Prayer of Manasseh”) and Psalm 151.
    [Show full text]
  • Abraham's Uncircumcised Children
    ABRAHAM’S UNCIRCUMCISED CHILDREN: THE ENOCHIC PRECEDENT FOR PAUL’S PARADOXICAL CLAIM IN GALATIANS 3:29 by Amy Genevive Dibley A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree of Joint Doctor of Philosophy with Graduate Theological Union in Near Easter Religions in the Graduate Division of the University of California at Berkeley Committee in charge: Professor LeAnn Snow Flesher, Chair Professor Daniel Boyarin Professor Eugene Eung-Chun Park Professor Yair Zakovitch Professor Erich S. Gruen Fall 2013 ABSTRACT Abraham’s Uncircumcised Children: The Enochic Precedent for Paul’s Paradoxical Claim in Galatians 3:29 by Amy Genevive Dibley Joint Doctor of Philosophy with Graduate Theological Union in Near Easter Religions in the Graduate Division University of California, Berkeley Professor LeAnn Snow Flesher, Chair This study proposes the Book of Dreams as the precedent for Paul’s program of gentile reclamation qua gentiles predating the composition of the Epistles by two centuries. 1 Dedication To my husband Peter, for whom the words loving and supportive and partnership hardly begin to encompass the richness of our journey together through this process. For our girls, Langsea and Lucia (5 and 4 years old as I submit this), who when playing “mommy” pause from dressing and feeding baby dolls to write their own dissertations. In thanks to the women of First Covenant Church in Rockford, Illinois and Kerry Staurseth (Langsea’s godmother) who watched those most precious to me so that this first child could at last be born, proving that it also takes a village to write a dissertation.
    [Show full text]
  • Unraveling the Mystery of the Old Testament Canon
    '.i rr:c $16:fr'ref , !L 1. ) tr, /LL , J.,t, - \t1ft, I \ryTI(}DH,Cil}E,S? Unraveling the Mystery of the Olcl Testament Canon to limit the their owlt faith for the Pharisees hcgitn. there ample. the Dead Sea scrolls, cotltaining rcn thc Chtrlclr tlrc books tlrey witnted to iltclude in thcir 'l'estatneltt saciecl tcxts ol lhc Esscrrc scct of 'ltrdaisrrt' were rlo New citlloll. Like the early ' Masorctic, Sanrari- revisccl Ilebrew Old'I'estarnent texts show evidencc tl['tltc hooks. Church, ihe Jews of Christ's tiure were not tan, antl [.,XX text bases. alortc wcrc trscd irs ScriP- particular set ol texts (be- the lall of Jerusaletn united atottncl a Testament used in the early tlowever. with ture. l-he Okl pro- yoncl the Tbrah, that is). They were orga- Rouran world was in AD 70. an intense stattdardization Cltrrch throughout the irized around a liturgical life in the temple cess begatr. Only the Pharisee ancl the not tlre l{ebrew Old Testametlt, Llut a trans- liturgical life, they survived this ancl synagogue' For this Testament into Creek Samaritirn sects of Judaistn lation of the Olcl 'lestatnent came to use texts in the services' However' 'Ihe process. 'l'he collection of Old callccl the Septtragint (LXX)' LXX the production bccrrrne thc the liturgical life prececled Alexarldria cluritrg lhc irooks into wltat cvcttttlally ' s as trlttrslatctl in of the texts ancl formed their conteit' [Iis- in the Masoletic text was begun by thc l)harisees reign of Ptolerlry II Philadelplltts as the .lewish faith cleveloped in Ctlttttcil ttl'.larrrnia,
    [Show full text]
  • Torah in the Diaspora: a Comparative Study of Philo and 4 Maccabees
    Western University Scholarship@Western Electronic Thesis and Dissertation Repository 4-22-2013 12:00 AM Torah in the Diaspora: A Comparative Study of Philo and 4 Maccabees Christopher J. Cornthwaite The University of Western Ontario Supervisor Dr. Daniel A. Smith The University of Western Ontario Graduate Program in Theology A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the equirr ements for the degree in Master of Arts © Christopher J. Cornthwaite 2013 Follow this and additional works at: https://ir.lib.uwo.ca/etd Part of the History of Religion Commons Recommended Citation Cornthwaite, Christopher J., "Torah in the Diaspora: A Comparative Study of Philo and 4 Maccabees" (2013). Electronic Thesis and Dissertation Repository. 1207. https://ir.lib.uwo.ca/etd/1207 This Dissertation/Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by Scholarship@Western. It has been accepted for inclusion in Electronic Thesis and Dissertation Repository by an authorized administrator of Scholarship@Western. For more information, please contact [email protected]. TORAH IN THE DIASPORA: A COMPARATIVE STUDY OF PHILO AND 4 MACCABEES (Thesis format: Monograph) by Christopher J. Cornthwaite Graduate Program in Theology A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts The School of Graduate and Postdoctoral Studies The University of Western Ontario London, Ontario, Canada © Christopher J. Cornthwaite 2013 Abstract This thesis examines how Judaism was Hellenized by comparing how difference, boundaries, and syncretism function in both Philo and 4 Maccabees. Recent historical and anthropological methods demand rejection of old approaches to these works which differentiated between the Judaism and the Hellenism in them and were often dominated by attempts to show where these authors’ intellectual fidelities lay.
    [Show full text]
  • Pseudepigrapha Bibliographies
    0 Pseudepigrapha Bibliographies Bibliography largely taken from Dr. James R. Davila's annotated bibliographies: http://www.st- andrews.ac.uk/~www_sd/otpseud.html. I have changed formatting, added the section on 'Online works,' have added a sizable amount to the secondary literature references in most of the categories, and added the Table of Contents. - Lee Table of Contents Online Works……………………………………………………………………………………………...02 General Bibliography…………………………………………………………………………………...…03 Methodology……………………………………………………………………………………………....03 Translations of the Old Testament Pseudepigrapha in Collections…………………………………….…03 Guide Series…………………………………………………………………………………………….....04 On the Literature of the 2nd Temple Period…………………………………………………………..........04 Literary Approaches and Ancient Exegesis…………………………………………………………..…...05 On Greek Translations of Semitic Originals……………………………………………………………....05 On Judaism and Hellenism in the Second Temple Period…………………………………………..…….06 The Book of 1 Enoch and Related Material…………………………………………………………….....07 The Book of Giants…………………………………………………………………………………..……09 The Book of the Watchers…………………………………………………………………………......….11 The Animal Apocalypse…………………………………………………………………………...………13 The Epistle of Enoch (Including the Apocalypse of Weeks)………………………………………..…….14 2 Enoch…………………………………………………………………………………………..………..15 5-6 Ezra (= 2 Esdras 1-2, 15-16, respectively)……………………………………………………..……..17 The Treatise of Shem………………………………………………………………………………..…….18 The Similitudes of Enoch (1 Enoch 37-71)…………………………………………………………..…...18 The
    [Show full text]
  • Scripture in the Second Temple Period – from “The Law” to “The Law and the Prophets”
    Scripture in the Second Temple Period – from “the Law” to “the Law and the Prophets” A Mental List – the idea of “Scripture” begins as a rough, somewhat amorphous, mental catalogue of holy writings, which are mostly contained on individual scrolls • The basis for the concept of Scripture is the five “books of Moses” o Genesis, Exodus, Leviticus, Numbers, Deuteronomy ▪ These are held by all Jews to be uniquely holy and divinely inspired • In synagogue Judaism, they are joined by the hazy category “and the prophets” The Development of “And the Prophets” (539 BC – 70 AD) • When we today hear the phrase “and the prophets,” we think of the writing prophets of the Old Testament and their “books of prophecy” o Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ezekiel, “the Twelve,” and Daniel • But ancient Jews commonly had a much more expansive list of “prophets” in mind o Modern Jews designate Joshua, Judges, Samuel, and Kings as the “former prophets” and Isaiah, Jeremiah, Ezekiel, and “the Twelve” as the “latter” ▪ The rest of the modern Jewish Bible is then referred to as “the Writings” • I.e. Psalms, Job, Proverbs, Ruth, Song of Songs, Ecclesiastes, Lamentations, Esther, Daniel, Ezra, Nehemiah, and Chronicles o For ancient Jews, the picture is not so clear – personages like Enoch, Abraham, David, Solomon, Job, Daniel, etc. would have been viewed as “prophets” (cf. Acts 2.29-30) – so, if one were to possess authentic writings by (or possibly about) these persons, they might also be considered to be “prophetic” and a part of “the prophets” ▪ E.g. Psalms (for David), Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, and Song of Songs (for Solomon), Lamentations (for Jeremiah), etc.
    [Show full text]
  • APOCRYPHA: the HIDDEN WRITINGS ______Men’S Ministries International
    APOCRYPHA: THE HIDDEN WRITINGS _______________________________ Men’s Ministries International Introduction to the Apocrypha I. Introduction to the Holy Scriptures A. Names and Definitions 1. Bible - Greek “biblos” - a book - Matthew 1:2 2. Canon - Greek “kanon” - rule or standard 3. Septuagint - “seventy” - Old Testament in Greek - 180 BC 4. Vulgate - “common” - Old Testament in Latin - 4th Century AD B. Process 1. Revelation - God directly communicates truth not known 2. Inspiration - Spirit-moved people to produce Spirit-breathed readings 3. Illumination - influence of the Holy Spirit for understanding C. Divisions 1. Old Testament - Covenant - 39 books a. The Law - Pentateuch or Torah b. The Prophets -Major/ Minor (Isaiah, Jeremiah, Lamentations, Ezekiel, Daniel) c. The Writings 1. Historical - Joshua thru Esther 2. Poetical - Job, Psalms, Proverbs, Ecclesiastes, Song of Solomon 2. New Testament - 27 books a. Gospels d. Pastoral Epistles - 1,2 Timothy, Titus, Philemon b. Acts of the Apostles e. General (Hebrew) Epistles c. Pauline Epistles f. Prophetic - Revelation D. Canonicity 1. Apostolic - Was the book written by an Apostle or someone who knew an Apostle? 2. Spiritual Content - Proven a means of edification? (grace/justification/ holiness) 3. Doctrinal Soundness - Did the book conflict with the other books? 4. Usage - Was the book universally recognized and quoted by the Church Fathers? 5. Divine Inspiration - Did it give true evidence of Divine inspiration? - II Timothy 3:16 II. Introduction to the Apocrypha Books (Old Testament) A. Development 1. None of these books is included in the Hebrew canon of Holy Scriptures 2. Written some time between 300BC and 100AD - Septuagint - inclusive 3.
    [Show full text]
  • Xeravits, Géza G. "Abraham in the Old Testament Apocrypha." Abraham in Jewish and Early Christian Literature
    Xeravits, Géza G. "Abraham in the Old Testament Apocrypha." Abraham in Jewish and Early Christian Literature. Ed. Sean A. Adams and Zanne Domoney-Lyttle. London: T&T Clark, 2019. 29–40. Bloomsbury Collections. Web. 28 Sep. 2021. <http:// dx.doi.org/10.5040/9780567675545.ch-002>. Downloaded from Bloomsbury Collections, www.bloomsburycollections.com, 28 September 2021, 22:19 UTC. Copyright © Sean A. Adams, Zanne Domoney-Lyttle and contributors 2019. You may share this work for non-commercial purposes only, provided you give attribution to the copyright holder and the publisher, and provide a link to the Creative Commons licence. C h a p t e r 2 A BRAHAM IN THE O LD T ESTAMENT A POCRYPHA * G é z a G . X e r a v i t s Th e patriarch Abraham is one of the most pre- eminent fi gures of the Old Testament. Th e “fi rst Jew,” benefi ciary of God’s promises and covenant is an exciting personality already according to the primary epical source where he fi rst appears (Genesis). It is no wonder that later biblical texts and the authors of the literature of early Judaism were heavily interested in Abraham, and developed a rich tradition around him.1 Th is contribution intends to explore texts that belong to a rather artifi cial category, the Deuterocanonical books or the Old Testament Apocrypha. Th ese late Second Temple period writings do not appear in the Hebrew Bible, but found their way into the Septuagint and its parent versions.2 Th e evidence might be categorized into four distinct groups.
    [Show full text]
  • Reconsidering the Roman Catholic Apocrypha Alex Andersen Southeastern University - Lakeland, [email protected]
    Southeastern University FireScholars Classical Conversations Spring 2019 Reconsidering the Roman Catholic Apocrypha Alex Andersen Southeastern University - Lakeland, [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://firescholars.seu.edu/ccplus Part of the Catholic Studies Commons, and the Religious Thought, Theology and Philosophy of Religion Commons Recommended Citation Andersen, Alex, "Reconsidering the Roman Catholic Apocrypha" (2019). Classical Conversations. 3. https://firescholars.seu.edu/ccplus/3 This Term Paper is brought to you for free and open access by FireScholars. It has been accepted for inclusion in Classical Conversations by an authorized administrator of FireScholars. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Southeastern University Reconsidering the Roman Catholic Apocrypha Alex Andersen English 1233 Professor Grace Veach April 12, 2019 Andersen 1 Abstract For centuries, Protestants have debated with Roman Catholics and Orthodox Christians over the canonicity of the Roman Catholic Apocrypha, a collection of seven books and two additions to books composed from the third century B.C. to the first century A.D. and considered to be canonical by all major non-Protestant Christian denominations. This thesis plunges into this discussion on the Roman Catholic Apocrypha’s canonicity, contending that the Roman Catholic Apocrypha is noncanonical. First, this thesis propounds two broad models for canonicity, the Community Canon Model and the Intrinsic Canon Model, and maintains that the Intrinsic Canon Model is a better model for canonicity than the Community Canon Model. It then explains that many books in the Roman Catholic Apocrypha do not fit the Intrinsic Canon Model’s criteria for canonicity. Next, an argument is made that the Jews had fixed the Hebrew canon during the lifetimes of Jesus and the apostles and that this Hebrew canon excluded the Roman Catholic Apocrypha.
    [Show full text]
  • The Books Between the Testaments: What Christians Should Know About the Apocrypha
    The Books between the Testaments: What Christians Should Know about the Apocrypha SESSION 1 Why do some Bibles contain extra books? Why are they called different things by different religious groups? How do Protestants, Roman Catholics, and Eastern Orthodox differ in their understanding of the importance of these books? Introduction Have you ever noticed that some Bibles have the words “with Apocrypha” written on their spines? In the Revised Standard Version of the Holy Bible, these words refer to nineteen books or parts of books placed after Malachi and before the Gospel of Matthew. How did these books come to be placed in the middle of the Bible, and what value, if any, do they have? If you exam- ine The New American Bible used by Roman Catholics, you will fi nd that this Bible has no such middle section. Why? How then do these Christians regard these books, and do they read them? These are some of the questions that we will consider in the fi rst session before turning in the second session to study Tobit, which is one of the means that even though Protestants have usually called books in the Apocrypha. these books the Apocrypha and gather them together between the Old and New Testaments, Roman Catholic What Do We Call and Eastern Orthodox Christians regard them as Scrip- These Writings? ture but acknowledge them as Scripture that was writ- ten later than the other books. Since still other books Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox Christians are called the New Testament Apocrypha, the term Old call some of the books that Protestants fi nd between Testament Apocrypha is often preferred.
    [Show full text]
  • A Quick + Comprehensive Introduction to the Bible
    START HERE a quick + comprehensive introduction to the Bible START HERE a quick + comprehensive introduction to the Bible with Deuterocanonicals/ Apocrypha START HERE a quick + comprehensive introduction to the Bible with Deuterocanonicals/ Apocrypha PHILADELPHIA START HERE: A QUICK AND COMPREHENSIVE INTRODUCTION TO THE BIBLE © 1998, 2017 American Bible Society American Bible Society 101 North Independence Mall East FL8 Philadelphia PA 19106-2155 Revised edition. First issued as “Bible Reading Helps.” ISBN 978-1-941448-48-9 / ABS Item 124609 (Standard edition) ISBN 978-1-941448-49-6 / ABS Item 124610 (with Deuterocanonicals /Apocrypha) Printed in the United States of America American Bible Society offers many Bible resources for adults and children, including book introductions, discussion questions, cultural backgrounds, and more. Visit our website: resources.americanbible.org You can also visit our Bible Search tool to read and interact with the Bible in hundreds of languages. Bibles.org “In the beginning was the Word …” John 1:1 (ESV) START HERE WITH THE BIBLE he Bible is one of the greatest books the world has ever seen. It is a book full of profound wisdom and insight about human nature T and the character and purpose of the God who created all things. Throughout the centuries, people from many lands have opened the Bible and read from it in their own language. Here they have learned about God’s love and justice. Great leaders and thinkers, along with people who are poor, suffering, or oppressed, have searched its pages and explored its truths, looking for the answers to life’s problems and challenges.
    [Show full text]
  • The Apocrypha
    The Apocrypha by Daniel J. Lewis © Copyright 2000 by Diakonos, Inc. Troy, Michigan United States of America 2 Preface The apocrypha may be the most well-known collection of biblical documents, other than the Old and New Testaments, which is regularly neglected and ignored. In the past these books have been highly valued for private study and devotion by both the ancient Jewish community and also the ancient Christian community. The earliest Christians used for their Bible the Septuagint (LXX), the Greek translation of the Old Testament, as well as the growing number of documents which now make up the New Testament. The Septuagint contained a number of Jewish works written between 200 B.C. and 100 A.D., specifically a number of additions to Old Testament books (Esther, Daniel, Jeremiah, Chronicles) as well as other works, some fictional, some historical and some theological. These works were eventually excluded from the Protestant and Jewish canons (but eventually retained in the Roman and Orthodox canons). Their canonical status was somewhat ambiguous until the 16th century, when they were given deutero-canonical status by the Roman Catholic Church at the Council of Trent. Though the Protestant Reformers considered such works to be less authoritative than the canonical Scriptures, they did not discard them. In fact, the apocryphal books have been printed in most versions of the English Bible (including the KJV) from earliest times until 1827, when they were omitted. Since that time, Protestants, especially, have regarded the apocryphal books with suspicion, even though they were part of the devotional literature of the Christian church for most of its history.
    [Show full text]