DOCSLIB.ORG

Dr. William Mclaney Maribel Mafla Ana María Arias

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Dr. William Mclaney Maribel Mafla Ana María Arias 2010 THE THREAT TO BIODIVERSITY AND ECOSYSTEM FUNCTION OF PROPOSED HYDROELECTRIC DAMS IN THE LA AMISTAD WORLD HERITAGE SITE, PANAMA AND COSTA RICA. Dr. William O. McLarney Lic. Maribel Mafla Lic. Ana María Arias Lic. Danielle Bouchonnet 0 THE THREAT TO BIODIVERSITY AND ECOSYSTEM FUNCTION IN THE LA AMISTAD WORLD HERITAGE SITE, PANAMA AND COSTA RICA, FROM PROPOSED HYDROELECTRIC DAMS A follow‐up to McLarney and Mafla (2007): Probable Effects on Aquatic Biodiversity and Ecosystem Function of Four Proposed Hydroelectric Dams in the Changuinola/Teribe Watershed, Bocas del Toro, Panama, with Emphasis on Effects Within the La Amistad World Heritage Site With consideration also of La Amistad/Costa Rica and the Pacific Slope of La Amistad. Dr. William O. McLarney Lic. Maribel Mafla Lic. Ana María Arias Lic. Danielle Bouchonnet Programa de Biomonitoreo Asociación ANAI Contact Information: Asociación ANAI (Costa Rica): ANAI, Inc. (United States): Apdo. 170‐2070 1120 Meadows Rd. Sabanilla de Montes de Oca Franklin, North Carolina 28734 Costa Rica, C.A. USA Phone: (506) 2224‐3570 Phone/fax: (828) 524‐8369 (506) 2756‐8120 E‐mail: [email protected] Fax: (506) 2253‐7524 E‐mail: [email protected] [email protected] Respectfully submitted to: UNESCO World Heritage Committee April 22, 2010 1 Table of Contents EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 5 RESUMEN EJECUTIVO 8 INTRODUCTION 11 DAMS AS BARRIERS, AND THE IMPORTANCE OF DIADROMY 13 EFFECTS OF DAMS ON DIADROMOUS ANIMALS IN MESOAMERICA AND THE CARIBBEAN 17 EVENTS SINCE 2008 19 1. Social, Political and Legal Events: 19 Panama‐Atlantic slope: 19 Panama‐Pacific slope: 19 Costa Rica‐Pacific slope: 20 Costa Rica‐Atlantic slope: 20 2. Biological Investigations: 21 Panama: 21 Costa Rica – Pacific slope: 25 Costa Rica – Atlantic slope: 26 Darwin Initiative: 26 THE LA AMISTAD AREA AND ITS WATERSHEDS 28 THE LA AMISTAD AREA 28 FLUVIAL SYSTEMS OF LA AMISTAD, WITH COMMENTS ON PLANNED DAMS 30 Atlantic slope – Panama: 30 Changuinola/Teribe watershed 30 Atlantic slope – Costa Rica: 31 Sixaola/Telire watershed 32 Estrella watershed 33 Banano watershed 33 Matina watershed 34 Pacific slope – Costa Rica: 34 Grande de Terraba Watershed 34 Pacific slope – Panama: 35 Chiriqui Viejo, Piedras/Chico and Chiriqui watersheds 35 Conclusion: 36 THE AQUATIC FAUNA OF LA AMISTAD 37 FISH 37 Introduction and Overview: 37 ATLANTIC SLOPE SPECIES: 39 Family Anguillidae 39 Anguilla rostrata 39 Family Atherinidae 39 Atherinella chagresi 39 Family Gobiesocidae 40 Gobiesox nudus 40 Family Gerreidae 41 Eugerres plumieri 41 2 Family Haemulidae 41 Pomadasys crocro 41 Family Mugilidae 42 Agonostomus monticola 42 Joturus pichardi 43 Family Gobiidae 44 Awaous banana 44 Sicydium spp. 45 Family Eleotridae 46 Gobiomorus dormitor 46 OTHER FISHES OF CONCERN: 48 • Potamodromous species: 48 • Cryptic diadromous species: 48 • Euryhaline facultative wanderers: 49 • “New” species: 49 • Pacific slope diadromous species: 50 MACROINVERTEBRATES 51 BENTHOS: 51 SHRIMPS: 53 Overview: 53 ATYIDAE – ATLANTIC SLOPE: 55 Atya inocous 55 Atya scabra 55 Jonga serrei 55 Micratya poeyi 55 Potimirim glabra, Potimirim mexicana, and Potimirim potimirim 55 PALAEMONIDAE – ATLANTIC SLOPE: 56 Macrobrachium acanthurus 56 Macrobrachium carcinus 56 Macrobrachium crenulatum 56 Macrobrachium heterochirus 56 Macrobrachium olfersi 57 ATYIDAE – PACIFIC SLOPE: 57 PALAEMONIDAE – PACIFIC SLOPE: 57 SUMMARY: 58 SECONDARY EFFECTS OF SPECIES EXTIRPATIONS OR DRASTIC POPULATION DECLINES ABOVE DAMS 59 Predator – prey relationships: 59 Frugivores: 59 Omnivores, herbivores and detritivores: 60 General considerations: 60 Effects in high altitude streams: 60 1. Sediment dynamics: 62 2. Breakdown of allochthonous vegetable matter: 63 3 3. Water and substrate chemistry: 64 4. Algal biomass and diversity: 65 5. Structure of the benthic macroinvertebrate assemblage: 66 Conclusion: 67 UNIQUE CHARACTER OF LA AMISTAD FLUVIAL ECOSYSTEMS AND THEIR RELATION TO OTHER ECOSYSTEMS 68 Importance of high altitude streams: 68 Uniqueness of La Amistad fluvial ecosystems: 70 Terrestrial systems within the World Heritage Site: 72 Downstream effects of natural barriers: 73 On site and downstream effects of dam/reservoir complexes: 74 Overview and reservoir effects: 74 Downstream effects: 76 Dewatering 77 Flow rate 77 Sediment transport 77 Temperature regimes 78 Changes in water chemistry 79 MITIGATION 80 Fish passage strategies: 80 Artificial rearing of migratory species: 82 The “landlocking” phenomenon: 83 Downstream mitigation: 84 Mitigation at the regional scale: 84 Conclusion: 85 RECOMMENDATIONS 87 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 89 REFERENCES CITED 90 APPENDIX I. TABLES 112‐116 APPENDIX II. MAPS 117‐123 4 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY In this paper we expand and update our previous report “Probable Effects on Aquatic Biodiversity and Ecosystem Function of Four Proposed Hydroelectric Dams in the Changuinola/Teribe Watershed, Bocas del Toro, Panama, with Emphasis on Effects Within the La Amistad World Heritage Site”, taking into account events occurring since that report was presented in February, 2008 and expanding coverage to include all of the La Amistad World Heritage Site watersheds in both countries and on both sides of the Continental Divide. This is necessary because it has become increasingly apparent that, chiefly as a consequence of dam proposals and in direct contravention of one of the stated purposes for declaring the La Amistad National Parks, all of the major watersheds within the World Heritage Site are threatened with multiple species extirpations and consequent secondary effects which stand to grossly alter the character of ecosystems within the Site and the surrounding protected areas and indigenous territories making up the La Amistad Biosphere Reserve. For the sake of convenience, in much of the discussion we divide the La Amistad region into 4 sectors – Costa Rica and Panama, Atlantic and Pacific slopes. While this report focuses on biological events and predictions, we must take note of the numerous protests against dam plans and associated development which have occurred in all 4 sectors, based not only on environmental issues, but also reflecting valid socio‐cultural, indigenous rights and local economic concerns. Of particular concern are open pit mining plans being developed in Bribri territory on the very periphery of the World Heritage Site on the Atlantic slope of Costa Rica, and which are perceived as related to nearby dam sites. Results of several important biological investigations in the La Amistad area have been published since our last report. These include inventories of fish and macroinvertebrates carried out by University of Costa Rica biologists and sponsored by ICE in the Grande de Terraba River drainage on the Paciflc slope of Costa Rica, advances in Asociacion ANAI’s continuing biomonitoring investigations on the Atlantic slope of that country, and an ongoing binational Darwin Initiative inventory focusing on the World Heritage Site, which has already reported numerous new country records and discovered 31 species of animals and plants new to science. However, perhaps the most immediately significant new investigation is a series of inventories undertaken by the Smithsonian Tropical Research Institute (STRI) in the portion of the Changuinola River watershed which would be directly affected by the CHAN‐75 and CHAN‐140 dams. Along with important new species records, the STRI report confirms the ANAI biomonitoring team’s assertion (based on monitoring in the Atlantic slope watersheds of Costa Rica and non‐quantitative surveys in the Changuinola/Teribe watershed of Panama) of overwhelming dominance by diadromous migratory fish and shrimp in streams at middle and upper elevations on the Atlantic slope of the La Amistad area. Unfortunately, the Executive Summary of the extremely long (total 1,081 pages) STRI report attempts to serve public relations functions by underplaying the significance of diadromy and glossing over problems and limitations which are acknowledged in the full text. This tendency is extended and exacerbated in the recently published mitigation proposal by the engineering firm AES Changuinola and the consulting firm MWH which does however constitute an important new bibliographic resource. Descriptive sections of the present ANAI report place the rivers which arise within the La Amistad World Heritage Site in a geographic context of the ca. 10,000 sq. km. La Amistad Biosphere Reserve, and review the fish and macroinvertebrate taxa known from these watersheds, with emphasis on diadromous species known to occur within the World Heritage Site. For each of the 4 sectors of the La Amistad area we analyze all publicly available information on proposed dams and relate it to the threat of species extirpation and related ecological consequences. For the Pacific slope of Panama, we note that all access by diadromous species to streams within the World Heritage Site is already blocked by existing or nearly completed dams, leading to a hypothesis of 5 total or near‐total species extirpation. On the Atlantic slope of Panama, the only significant change since 2007 is progress toward completion and closure of the CHAN‐75 and Bonyic Dams. We report on proposals for 8 dams on the Atlantic slope of La Amistad/Costa Rica, and plans for one large and several smaller dams on the Pacific slope of that country. We conclude that if all presently proposed dams are constructed, 67% of the total watershed area of the La Amistad World Heritage Site will become inaccessible to diadromous and other upstream/downstream migratory
Load more

Recommended publications
  • 50000132.Pdf
    EDITORIAL EARTH Lic. José Ruperto Arce (Coordinador) Russo, Ricardo O. Reducción y mitigación de la pobreza en la Región Huetar Atlántica [Documento electrónico] / Ricardo O Russo y Eliécer Ureña… 1º ed.- Guácimo, CR: Editorial EARTH, 2006. 24 p. : il. Serie Documentos Técnicos, No. 4. ISBN 1. MITIGACIÓN DE LA POBREZA. 2. POBREZA. 3. MERCADO DEL TRABAJO. 4. EMPLEO. 5. REGIÓN HUETAR ATLÁNTICA. EARTH. I. Russo, Ricardo O. II. Ureña, Eliécer. Universidad EARTH Agosto, 2006. Las Mercedes de Guácimo, Limón Costa Rica Apartado Postal 4442-1000 San José, Costa Rica Teléfono 506 - 713 0000 • Fax 506 - 713 0184 Universidad de Costa Rica Universidad EARTH TABLA DE CONTENIDO 1. INTRODUCCIÓN………………………………………………………1 2. EL ESTUDIO DE LA POBREZA EN COSTA RICA ……………….1 3. LA POBREZA EN LA RHA…………………………………..………7 3.1. El ingreso y el empleo.………………………………………...7 3.2. Los servicios………….………………………………..….…..10 3.3. La oferta institucional….……………………………………...14 4. CONCLUSIONES Y RECOMENDACIONES …………… …….18 4.1. Conclusiones………………………………………….……….18 4.2. Recomendaciones………………………………………..…….19 4.3. Bibliografía……………………………………………..……...23 Universidad de Costa Rica Universidad EARTH Reducción y mitigación de la pobreza en la Región Huetar Atlántica - Ricardo O. Russo y Eliécer Ureña Reducción y mitigación de la pobreza en la Región Huetar Atlántica Ricardo O. Russo y Eliécer Ureña 1. Introducción Este análisis de la pobreza en la Región Huetar Atlántica (RHA) y sus alternativas de reducirla y mitigarla es parte de un estudio sobre el empleo, el ingreso y el bienestar de la población realizada por los autores como apoyo regional auspiciado por el Banco Interamericano de Desarrollo (BID). Se basa en parte en los informes sobre el mercado laboral, la capacidad y potencial de la economía regional, y los proyectos y propuestas presentado por instituciones, programas y organizaciones en la RHA durante la elaboración del estudio.
    [Show full text]
  • Cuando La Vida Era Tranquila: Land Use And
    SIT Graduate Institute/SIT Study Abroad SIT Digital Collections Independent Study Project (ISP) Collection SIT Study Abroad Spring 2018 Cuando la vida era tranquila: Land use and livelihood changes following the construction of the Chan 75 dam in Nance del Risco, Bocas del Toro Patrick McKenzie SIT Study Abroad Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcollections.sit.edu/isp_collection Part of the Earth Sciences Commons, Environmental Health and Protection Commons, Latin American Studies Commons, Natural Resource Economics Commons, and the Nature and Society Relations Commons Recommended Citation McKenzie, Patrick, "Cuando la vida era tranquila: Land use and livelihood changes following the construction of the Chan 75 dam in Nance del Risco, Bocas del Toro" (2018). Independent Study Project (ISP) Collection. 2796. https://digitalcollections.sit.edu/isp_collection/2796 This Unpublished Paper is brought to you for free and open access by the SIT Study Abroad at SIT Digital Collections. It has been accepted for inclusion in Independent Study Project (ISP) Collection by an authorized administrator of SIT Digital Collections. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Cuando la vida era tranquila: Land use and livelihood changes following the construction of the Chan 75 dam in Nance del Risco, Bocas del Toro Patrick McKenzie School for International Training: Panama Spring 2018 Abstract The Ngobe are Panama’s most populous indigenous group. While the Ngobe that live in the comarca have land and resource rights, those that live immediately outside of it do not. This issue has been exacerbated by the creation of Palo Seco Forest Reserve which has removed all land rights from the Ngobe living within it.
    [Show full text]
  • Socioeconomic Characterization of Bocas Del Toro in Panama: an Application of Multivariate Techniques
    Revista Brasileira de Gestão e Desenvolvimento Regional G&DR. V. 16, N. 3, P. 59-71, set-dez/2020. Taubaté, SP, Brasil. ISSN: 1809-239X Received: 11/14/2019 Accepted: 04/26/2020 SOCIOECONOMIC CHARACTERIZATION OF BOCAS DEL TORO IN PANAMA: AN APPLICATION OF MULTIVARIATE TECHNIQUES CARACTERIZACIÓN SOCIOECONÓMICA DE BOCAS DEL TORO EN PANAMÁ: UNA APLICACIÓN DE TÉCNICAS MULTIVARIADAS Barlin Orlando Olivares1 Jacob Pitti2 Edilberto Montenegro3 Abstract The objective of this work was to identify the main socioeconomic characteristics of the villages with an agricultural vocation in the Bocas del Toro district, Panama, through multivariate techniques. The two principal components that accounted for 84.0% of the total variation were selected using the Principal Components Analysis. This allowed a classification in three strata, discriminating the populated centers of greater agricultural activity in the district. The study identified that the factors with the greatest impact on the characteristics of the population studied were: the development of agriculture in indigenous territories, the proportion of economically inactive people and economic occupation other than agriculture; This characterization serves as the first approach to the study of sustainable land management in indigenous territories. Keywords: Applied Economy, Biodiversity, Crops, Multivariate Statistics, Sustainability. Resumen El objetivo de este trabajo fue identificar las principales características socioeconómicas de los poblados con vocación agrícola del distrito Bocas del Toro, Panamá, a través de técnicas multivariadas. Mediante el Análisis de Componentes Principales se seleccionaron los primeros dos componentes que explicaban el 84.0 % de la variación total. Esto permitió una clasificación en tres estratos, discriminando los centros poblados de mayor actividad agrícola en el distrito.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 Bocas Del Toro Cauchero Esc
    CALENDARIO DE BECA UNIVERSAL Y PLANILLA GLOBAL TERCERA ENTREGA 2019 DIRECCIÓN PROVINCIAL DE BOCAS DEL TORO 23 DE OCTUBRE DE 2019 Nº DISTRITO CORREGIMIENTO CENTRO EDUCATIVO 1 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE DIONISIA G. DE AYARZA 2 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE LAS PIÑAS 3 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE QUEBRADA EL BAJO 4 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE QUEBRADA LIMÓN 5 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE RAMBALA RAMBALA 6 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE RAMBALA CHIRIQUICITO # 1 7 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE RAMBALA CHIRIQUICITO # 2 8 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE RAMBALA CENTRO BET-EL 9 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE RAMBALA NUEVA ESTRELLA 10 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE PUNTA PEÑA I.P.T CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE 11 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE PUNTA PEÑA C.E.B.G. PUNTA PEÑA 12 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE PUNTA PEÑA CAÑAZAS 13 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE MIRAMAR MIRAMAR 14 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE MIRAMAR ALTO LA GLORIA 15 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE MIRAMAR LAS CAÑAS 16 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE MIRAMAR LOS MOLEJONES 17 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE MIRAMAR LOS CHIRICANOS 18 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE PUNTA ROBALO PALMA REAL 19 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE PUNTA ROBALO VALLE SECO 20 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE PUNTA ROBALO PUNTA ROBALO 21 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE PUNTA ROBALO LA CONGA 22 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE BAJO CEDRO C.E.B.G. BAJO CEDRO 23 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE BAJO CEDRO QUEBRADA GARZA 24 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE BAJO CEDRO ALTO CEDRO 25 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE BAJO CEDRO C.E.B.G. RÍO AUYAMA 26 CHIRIQUÍ GRANDE BAJO CEDRO EL ESCOBAL 24 DE OCTUBRE DE 2019 Nº DISTRITO CORREGIMIENTO CENTRO EDUCATIVO 1 BOCAS DEL TORO CAUCHERO ESC. CAUCHERO ARRIBA 2 BOCAS DEL TORO CAUCHERO ESC. LOS HIGUERONES 3 BOCAS DEL TORO CAUCHERO ESC. LOMA AZUL 4 BOCAS DEL TORO CAUCHERO ESC. LOMA ESTRELLA 5 BOCAS DEL TORO CAUCHERO ESC.
    [Show full text]
  • CENTRO AGRONÓMICO TROPICAL DE INVESTIGACIÓN Y ENSEÑANZA DIVISIÓN DE EDUCACIÓN PROGRAMA DE POSGRADO Análisis De Situación
    CENTRO AGRONÓMICO TROPICAL DE INVESTIGACIÓN Y ENSEÑANZA DIVISIÓN DE EDUCACIÓN PROGRAMA DE POSGRADO Análisis de situación del territorio INDER Matina- Limón como contribución a la fase inicial de la Planificación del Desarrollo Rural Territorial Trabajo de graduación sometido a consideración de la División de Educación y el Programa de Posgrado como requisito para optar por el grado de Máster en Práctica de la Conservación de la Biodiversidad Carolina Cascante Carvajal TURRIALBA, COSTA RICA 2015 2 4 DEDICATORIA A Dios, que con su infinito amor y misericordia me ha sostenido siempre. A todas las comunidades que continúan soñando y trabajando por un mundo mejor. A mi familia que inspira mis propios sueños. A mis amigas y amigos, que son la otra parte de mi familia. 5 AGRADECIMIENTOS Al personal de La Escuela de Postgrado, particularmente al equipo de las Maestrías Prácticas, por su apuesta a la formación de profesionales más integrales. Al servicio de Pesca y Vida Silvestre de los Estados Unidos por su apoyo económico. Al personal del Inder, particularmente al destacado en la Oficina Subregional de Batán, por la oportunidad de trabajo y el acompañamiento en el trabajo de campo. A la generación de estudiantes del CATIE 2013-2014, por el apoyo académicos y humano durante estos dos años de estudio. 6 CONTENIDO DEDICATORIA .................................................................................................................. 5 AGRADECIMIENTOS ........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Bocas Del Toro Mission
    Image not found or type unknown Bocas Del Toro Mission DOMINGO RAMOS SANJUR Domingo Ramos Sanjur, B.A. in Theology (Adventist University of Central America, Alajuela, Costa Rica), is the president of Bocas del Toro Mission. Previously, he was a pastor and area coordinator in Bocas del Toro. He is married to Ruth Luciano and has three children. Bocas del Toro Mission is an administrative unit of the Seventh-day Adventist Church in Panama. It is a part of Panama Union Mission in the Inter-American Division of Seventh-day Adventists. Territory and Statistics Bocas del Toro is a province of Panama with Bocas del Toro as its capital city. As of 2018, it had an area of 45,843.90 km2 and a population of 170,320 inhabitants.1 It shares borders with the Caribbean Sea to the north, the province of Chiriquí to the south, the indigenous region of Ngöbe Buglé to the east and southeast, the province of Limón in Costa Rica to the west and northwest, and the province of Puntarenas in Costa Rica to the southwest. Bocas del Toro Mission has 30 churches, 4,272 members, and a population of 127,414. Its offices are on Avenida 17 de Abril in El Empalme, Changuinola, Bocas del Toro, Panama. Its territory includes the Bocas del Toro province and the Nio Cribo region, which itself includes Kankintú and Kusapín. It is a part of Panama Union Mission of the Inter- American Division.2 Bocas del Toro Mission also has 28 groups, two schools, one high school, three ordained ministers, and six licensed ministers as of 2018.
    [Show full text]
  • Información General De La Región Limón
    LIMÓN PROVINCIA 7 Aspectos generales Posición Geográfica Reseña histórica División Territorial Aspectos Físicos Características Demográficas Posición Geográfica I. ASPECTOS GENERALES Cantones y Distritos Posición Geográfica Limón Pococí La Región Huetar Caribe (RHC) según Decreto Ejecutivo N° Siquirres Talamanca 7944--‐P del 26 de enero de 1978 de Regionalización oficial de Costa Rica y sus Matina modificaciones, se define como el área que comprende los cantones de: Limón, Guácimo Pococí, Siquirres, Talamanca, Matina y Guácimo; todos ellos de la provincia de Limón. El cantón Central que es Limón, cumple el rol de ser el centro administrativo y económico de la región. Mediante el Decreto Nº 37735--‐ PLAN del Sistema Nacional de Planificación, del 26 de junio 2013, (Artículo 58) se modifica el nombre a Huetar Caribe. Esta región está localizada en la zona oriental del país, entre las coordenadas 9°05’ y 10°56’ latitud Norte, y los 82°33’ y 83°57’ longitud Oeste. Limita al Norte con la República de Nicaragua, al Este con el Mar Caribe, al Sureste con la República de Panamá, al Sur con la región Brunca, al Oeste con la Región Central; y al Noroeste con la región Huetar Norte. La RHC tiene una extensión territorial de 9,188.52 km2 (918.852 ha), lo cual representa el 17,98% del territorio nacional. Cerca del 38,8% del territorio se encuentra bajo algún régimen de protección ambiental. Reseña Historica En la época precolombina el territorio que actualmente corresponde a la provincia de Limón, estuvo habitado por indígenas de los grupos llamados huetares, suerres, pococís, tariacas, viceitas, terbis; los cuales conformaron tres principales provincias, denominadas Suerre, Pococí y Tariaca, las que agruparon varios poblados.
    [Show full text]
  • Cacao, the Guaymi and Reforestation in Western Panama
    NGÖBE CULTURAL VALUES OF CACAO AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT IN WESTERN PANAMA by JEFFREY JAMES STOIKE (Under the Direction of Carl F. Jordan) ABSTRACT This thesis examines questions of conservation and development pertaining to the Ngöbe, an indigenous group in western Panama, with a focus on cacao (Theobroma cacao Linn.) agroforestry. A political ecology framework is applied to cacao agroforestry as sustainable development amongst the Ngöbe in a historical context. Through research based on both academic and grey literature, as well as an unpublished thesis, I discuss Ngöbe symbolic values of cacao in the context of conservation and development trends in the region. I make specific reference to the Mesoamerican Biological Corridor (MBC), a transnational conservation program which promotes cacao agroforestry in Ngöbe communities. I conclude that future conservation efforts should be directed towards the development of policies that enhance broader Ngöbe values for cacao and should not rely overwhelmingly on market-based criteria. INDEX WORDS: cacao, agroforestry, sustainable development, Mesoamerican Biological Corridor, Bocas del Toro, Panama, Ngöbe. NGÖBE CULTURAL VALUES OF CACAO AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT IN WESTERN PANAMA by JEFFREY JAMES STOIKE BA, University of California Berkeley, 1999 A Thesis Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of The University of Georgia in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree MASTER OF SCIENCE ATHENS, GEORGIA 2009 © 2009 Jeffrey James Stoike All Rights Reserved NGÖBE CULTURAL VALUES OF CACAO AND SUSTAINABLE DEVELOPMENT IN WESTERN PANAMA by JEFFREY JAMES STOIKE Major Professor: Carl F. Jordan Committee: Julie Velásquez Runk Paul Sutter Electronic Version Approved: Maureen Grasso Dean of the Graduate School The University of Georgia August 2009 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Many people have assisted in the production of this thesis, an unconventional process from start to finish.
    [Show full text]
  • Panama: Land Administration Project (Loan No
    Report No. 56565-PA Investigation Report Panama: Land Administration Project (Loan No. 7045-PAN) September 16, 2010 About the Panel The Inspection Panel was created in September 1993 by the Board of Executive Directors of the World Bank to serve as an independent mechanism to ensure accountability in Bank operations with respect to its policies and procedures. The Inspection Panel is an instrument for groups of two or more private citizens who believe that they or their interests have been or could be harmed by Bank-financed activities to present their concerns through a Request for Inspection. In short, the Panel provides a link between the Bank and the people who are likely to be affected by the projects it finances. Members of the Panel are selected “on the basis of their ability to deal thoroughly and fairly with the request brought to them, their integrity and their independence from the Bank’s Management, and their exposure to developmental issues and to living conditions in developing countries.”1 The three-member Panel is empowered, subject to Board approval, to investigate problems that are alleged to have arisen as a result of the Bank having failed to comply with its own operating policies and procedures. Processing Requests After the Panel receives a Request for Inspection it is processed as follows: • The Panel decides whether the Request is prima facie not barred from Panel consideration. • The Panel registers the Request—a purely administrative procedure. • The Panel sends the Request to Bank Management, which has 21 working days to respond to the allegations of the Requesters.
    [Show full text]
  • Live and Dead Coral Cover on Three Reefs and Public Perceptions of Degradation Around Almirante Bay, Bocas Del Toro Phoebe Thompson SIT Graduate Institute
    SIT Graduate Institute/SIT Study Abroad SIT Digital Collections Independent Study Project (ISP) Collection SIT Study Abroad Fall 2016 Live and dead coral cover on three reefs and public perceptions of degradation around Almirante Bay, Bocas del Toro Phoebe Thompson SIT Graduate Institute Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcollections.sit.edu/isp_collection Part of the Civic and Community Engagement Commons, Community-Based Research Commons, Environmental Health Commons, Laboratory and Basic Science Research Commons, Latin American Studies Commons, and the Terrestrial and Aquatic Ecology Commons Recommended Citation Thompson, Phoebe, "Live and dead coral cover on three reefs and public perceptions of degradation around Almirante Bay, Bocas del Toro" (2016). Independent Study Project (ISP) Collection. 2488. https://digitalcollections.sit.edu/isp_collection/2488 This Unpublished Paper is brought to you for free and open access by the SIT Study Abroad at SIT Digital Collections. It has been accepted for inclusion in Independent Study Project (ISP) Collection by an authorized administrator of SIT Digital Collections. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Live and dead coral cover on three reefs and public perceptions of degradation around Almirante Bay, Bocas del Toro Independent Study Project SIT Panama: Tropical Ecology, Marine Ecosystems, and Biodiversity Conservation Fall 2016 Phoebe Thompson Bowdoin College, Class of 2018 i Abstract Almirante Bay is a lagoonal body of water off the western Caribbean coast of Panama. The islands within the bay are popular tourist destinations, drawing visitors from around the world to explore beaches and coral reefs. However, the reefs in Almirante Bay are continually exposed to both natural and anthropogenic stressors, such as temperature inversions, boat pollution, sedimentation from dredging, and chemical runoff from coastal banana plantations.
    [Show full text]
  • Centros De Votación Para Primarias Panameñistas
    CENTROS DE VOTACIÓN PARA PRIMARIAS PANAMEÑISTAS - 28 DE OCTUBRE DE 2018 Provincia Distrito Corregimiento Centro Votación Mesa Electores BOCAS DEL TORO BOCAS DEL TORO BOCAS DEL T. (CABEC.) 3 COL. ROGELIO J. IBARRA 1 365 BOCAS DEL TORO BOCAS DEL TORO BOCAS DEL T. (CABEC.) 3 Total Centro 365 BOCAS DEL TORO BOCAS DEL TORO BOCAS DEL T. (CABEC.) Total Corregimiento 365 BOCAS DEL TORO BOCAS DEL TORO BASTIMENTOS 171 ESC. BASTIMENTOS 2 317 BOCAS DEL TORO BOCAS DEL TORO BASTIMENTOS 171 Total Centro 317 BOCAS DEL TORO BOCAS DEL TORO BASTIMENTOS Total Corregimiento 317 BOCAS DEL TORO BOCAS DEL TORO PUNTA LAUREL 1406 ESC. ISLA POPA 3 34 BOCAS DEL TORO BOCAS DEL TORO PUNTA LAUREL 1406 Total Centro 34 BOCAS DEL TORO BOCAS DEL TORO PUNTA LAUREL Total Corregimiento 34 BOCAS DEL TORO BOCAS DEL TORO CAUCHERO 2661 ESC. LOS HIGUERONES 4 184 BOCAS DEL TORO BOCAS DEL TORO CAUCHERO 2661 Total Centro 184 BOCAS DEL TORO BOCAS DEL TORO CAUCHERO 2985 ESC. LOMA AZUL 5 180 BOCAS DEL TORO BOCAS DEL TORO CAUCHERO 2985 Total Centro 180 BOCAS DEL TORO BOCAS DEL TORO CAUCHERO Total Corregimiento 364 BOCAS DEL TORO BOCAS DEL TORO TIERRA OSCURA 3011 ESC. SECRETARIO 6 181 BOCAS DEL TORO BOCAS DEL TORO TIERRA OSCURA 3011 Total Centro 181 BOCAS DEL TORO BOCAS DEL TORO TIERRA OSCURA Total Corregimiento 181 BOCAS DEL TORO Total De Distrito 1,261 BOCAS DEL TORO CHANGUINOLA CHANGUINOLA (CABEC.) 1135 ESC. CHANGUINOLA 7 295 BOCAS DEL TORO CHANGUINOLA CHANGUINOLA (CABEC.) 1135 Total Centro 295 BOCAS DEL TORO CHANGUINOLA CHANGUINOLA (CABEC.) 1819 ESC.
    [Show full text]
  • The Use of Tropical Forest (Agroecosystems and Wild Plant Harvesting) As a Source of Food in the Bribri and Cabecar Cultures in the Caribbean Coast of Costa Rica 1
    THE USE OF TROPICAL FOREST (AGROECOSYSTEMS AND WILD PLANT HARVESTING) AS A SOURCE OF FOOD IN THE BRIBRI AND CABECAR CULTURES IN THE CARIBBEAN COAST OF COSTA RICA 1 CARLOS RAMOS GARCiA-SERRANO AND JUAN PABLO DEL MONTE Ramos Garcia-Serrano, Carlos and Juan Pablo Del Monte (Departamento de Producci6n Vegetal: Botdnica y Protecci6n Vegetal Escuela Superior TJcnica de Ingenieros Agr6nomos, Ciudad Universitaria Sn, 28040 Madrid, Spain; email [email protected]). THE USE OF TROPICAL FOREST (AGROECOSYSTEMS AND WILD PLANT HARVESTING) AS A SOURCE OF FOOD IN THE BRmPd AND CABECAR CULTURES IN THE CARIBBEAN COAST OF COSTA RICA. Economic Botany 58(1):58-71, 2004. For the Bribri and the Cabecar Indians of Costa Rica the environment is divided in two: the "near", indigenous space; and the "'far", natural space, which they think does not belong to them. In the former, the following agroecosystems can be distinguished according to biodiversity and intensity of human activity: tropical home garden, rotating slash- and-burn agriculture, plantain polyculture, and plantain monoculture. In the "far" space, these two culturally close groups harvest wild plants observing ancestral rules, which have helped ensure a sustainable use of forest resources. Their diet is based on 84 species, of which 24 are harvested in the "'far" environment (hombr6n, semko, platanillo, tacaco, etc.) and 60 are obtained in the "near" environment (maize, bean, cacao, manioc, etc.). Owing to acculturation, exotic species (mainly rice, sugarcane, plantain, cacao and citrus fruit) have become part of their diet and crops. El Maneso del Bosque Tropical (Agroecosistemas y Recoleccion de Flora Silvestre) coho base de la Alimentacion en las Culturas Bribri y Cabecar de la Costa Caribera de Costa Rica.
    [Show full text]