University of Nevada, Reno Late Holocene Toolstone Procurement
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
University of Nevada, Reno Late Holocene Toolstone Procurement and Land-Use Strategies in the Black Rock Desert and High Rock Country of Northwest Nevada A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in Anthropology by Stephen J. LaValley Dr. Geoffrey M. Smith/Thesis Advisor May, 2013 Copyright by Stephen J. LaValley 2013 All Rights Reserved THE GRADUATE SCHOOL We recommend that the thesis prepared under our supervision by STEPHEN J. LAVALLEY entitled Late Holocene Toolstone Procurement and Land-Use Strategies in the Black Rock Desert and High Rock Country of Northwest Nevada be accepted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF ARTS Geoffrey M. Smith, Ph.D., Advisor Gary Haynes, Ph.D., Committee Member Scott D. Bassett, Ph.D., Graduate School Representative Marsha H. Read, Ph.D., Dean, Graduate School May, 2013 i Abstract This thesis tests current interpretations of Late Holocene (5,000 cal BP to present) archaeology for the Black Rock Desert and High Rock Country (BRD/HRC) through an assessment of the toolstone procurement and land-use strategies of the region’s prehistoric occupants. This is achieved through: lithic analysis from Paiute Creek Shelter (PCS), a recently excavated rock shelter with stratified cultural remains spanning the Late Holocene; X-ray fluorescence analysis of artifacts from PCS, Hanging Rock Shelter, Silent Snake Springs, and Smokey Creek Cave; and spatial analysis of 623 archaeological sites in the BRD/HRC. Results indicate that no changes occurred in how obsidian toolstone was procured between the Middle Archaic (5,000-1,500 cal BP) and Late Archaic (1,500 cal BP to contact), while residential mobility intensified during the Late Archaic, likely promoting increased trade in the region. ii Acknowledgements There are numerous people and organizations that I would like to thank for their participation in helping me complete this thesis. I would first like to thank SARF/ GBPRU and the anthropology department for funding my studies at UNR. My research could not have happened without funding from the College of Liberal Arts, the Graduate Student Association, and the Desert Research Institute. I also would like to thank the Am-Arcs of Northern Nevada and GSA for supporting my travels to several conferences. There are many individuals to whom I am greatly thankful for their support and aid in the completion of this thesis. Craig Skinner and Jennifer Thatcher at the Northwest Research Obsidian Studies Laboratory and Richard Hughes at the Geochemical Research Laboratory provided the XRF analysis for this thesis, sometimes within unthinkably fast turnaround. Some source provenance data in this thesis was shared by Geoff Smith, Kristina Wiggins, Melinda Leach, and John Fagan; thank you all very much, it has provided much needed substance. Thanks go to Kathryn Ataman and Dave Valentine at the BLM Winnemucca Field Office for their assistance and support. Finally, thank you Gene Hattori, Rachel Malloy, and Maggie Brown for providing access to collections in the Nevada State Museum. In addition to the many SARF/GBPRU student employees and volunteers who have assisted in the cleaning, labeling, and recording of the PCS assemblage, I would like to thank those before me who excavated the shelter including: Ghufran Ahmed, Anna Camp, Mark Estes, Ted Goebel, Jon Grant, Brant Ivey, Lisbeth Louderback, Geoff iii Smith, and Dave Valentine. Also, special thanks to Janine Tingson for illustrating the artifacts, Kristina Wiggins for helping analyze debitage, and Ellie Maniery for the flake tool analysis. I must thank my committee – Dr. Geoffrey M. Smith, Dr. Gary Haynes, and Dr. Scott D. Bassett – for their support, critiques, and edits. Thank you Geoff for introducing me to PCS and the Black Rock Desert/High Rock Country; I am not convinced that I would have found as much fulfillment in Grass Valley. Gary, thanks for being awesome; I look forward to an invitation to the Clovis Mafia. And thank you Scott for showing me the ways of GIS and deterring me from taking a bigger bite out of it than I could chew. I would also like to thank my family and friends, for whose support could not be found anywhere else. Thanks go to Tony Taylor, the only other member of my cohort, and Verla Jackson, for their support and advice along the way. I am very grateful for my parents, who encourage my pursuits down whatever path I decide to wander. And finally, Chrissy – I am forever indebted to her for everything she has done. I had no clue what I was doing in graduate school before I met her. She gave me invaluable advice and structure in my life that has made me a better student, archaeologist, and person. She was and is the sounding board for all my woes and I look forward to spending many more years with her. iv Table of Contents Abstract ................................................................................................................................ i Acknowledgements ............................................................................................................. ii List of Tables .................................................................................................................... vii List of Figures .................................................................................................................... xi Chapter 1: Introduction ....................................................................................................... 1 The Black Rock Desert/High Rock Country .......................................................... 3 Background ............................................................................................................. 3 Climate/Environment .................................................................................. 3 Archaeology ................................................................................................ 7 Addressing the Issue of Scale ............................................................................... 15 Previous Regional Studies ........................................................................ 15 The Current Study ..................................................................................... 18 Research Goals...................................................................................................... 18 Chapter 2: Materials .......................................................................................................... 20 Paiute Creek Shelter .............................................................................................. 21 X-Ray Fluorescence Lithic Assemblages ............................................................. 26 Paiute Creek Shelter .................................................................................. 27 Hanging Rock Shelter ............................................................................... 28 Silent Snake Springs ................................................................................. 30 Smokey Creek Cave .................................................................................. 31 Regional Site Inventory ........................................................................................ 33 NVCRIS .................................................................................................... 33 Previous Sundance Fieldwork................................................................... 35 Chapter 3: Methods ........................................................................................................... 39 Excavations at Paiute Creek Shelter ..................................................................... 39 v Laboratory Analysis .............................................................................................. 41 Descriptive Analysis ............................................................................................. 42 Lithic Raw Material .................................................................................. 42 Debitage Analysis ..................................................................................... 42 Core Analysis ............................................................................................ 44 Tool Analysis ............................................................................................ 45 Groundstone Analysis ............................................................................... 50 Integrative Analysis .............................................................................................. 52 X-Ray Fluorescence Analysis ................................................................... 52 Biface Reduction Curves .......................................................................... 55 Statistical Analysis .................................................................................... 57 Geographical Information System ........................................................................ 57 Site Inventory ............................................................................................ 58 Site Distribution ........................................................................................ 58 Site Function ............................................................................................. 59 Characterization of Prehistoric Land-Use ................................................. 60 Summary ..............................................................................................................