New Jersey Shore Protection Master Plan
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
You are viewing an archived copy from the New Jersey State Library 1lllllllllllllllIlrflrlrllll~1 flllll1lfr~lrllrllllllll 3 3009 00067 69 You are viewing an archived copy from the New Jersey State Library NEW JERSE Y SHORE PROTECTION MASTER PLAN VOLUME 3 COMMENTS AND RESPONSES ON THE DRAFT SHORE PROTECTION MASTER PLAN OCTOBER 1981 State of New Jersey Brendan Byrne Governor Department of Environmental Protection Jerry Fitzgerald English Commissioner Division of Coastal Resources David N. Kinsey Director CN 401 Trenton, New Jersey 08625 Prepared By Dames & Moore 6 Commerce Drive Cranford, New Jersey 07016 Contract Number DBC-P168 Job Number 2422-013-10 You are viewing an archived copy from the New Jersey State Library VOLUME 3 COMMENTS AND RESPONSES ON THE DRAFT SHORE PROTECTION MASTER PLAN ~ I TABLE OF CONTENTS I Page I. INTRODUCTION 1-1 II. LIST OF COMMENTORS II-I A. State Government II-I B. Federal Agencies II-2 C. County and Municipal Agencies II-3 D. Organizations and Universities II-6 I E. Individuals II-7 III. COMMENTS AND RESPONSES BY TOPIC III-I .I A. General Comments III-I B. Legislative Authority III-9 C. Public Participation 111-11 D. Beach Access 111-15 E. Federal Involvement/Participation III-17 F. Funding, Benefit/Cost Analysis 111-19 G. Coastal Regulation - Dune Legislation III-23 I. General III-23 2. Dune and Shorefront Protection Act - Dune Legislation 111-27 H. Land Acquisition 111-35 I. Engineering Programs 111-37 J. Reach Concept 111-47 K. Reach Specific Comments 111-49 1. Reach 1 - Raritan Bay II1-49 2. Reach 2 - Sandy Hook to Long Branch 111-49 3. Reach 3 - Long Branch to Shark River Inlet III-52 4. Reach 4 - Shark River Inlet to Manasquan Inlet III-54 5. Reach 5 - Manasquan Inlet to Mantoloking III-54 6. Reach 6 - Mantoloking to Barnegat Inlet III-54 7. Reach 7 - Long Beach Island III-54 8. Reach 8 - Brigantine Island III-55 9. Reach 9 - Absecon Island III-55 10. Reach 10 - Peck Beach III-57 II. Reach 11 - Ludlam Island III-59 12. Reach 12 - Seven Mile Beach III-62 13. Reach 13 - Five Mile Beach II1-63 14. Reach 14 - Cape May Inlet to Cape May Point II1-63 15. Reach 15 - Delaware Bay 111-63 IV. REFERENCES CITED IV-I I .I I You are viewing an archived copy from the New Jersey State Library VOLUME 3 CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION ] This volume presents the comments and responses regarding the Draft Shore Protection Master Plan (Dames &. Moore, September 1980). The Department of -1 ~ Environmental Protection, Division of Coastal Resources (DEP/DCR) received com ments from public agencies, interested groups, companies, and individuals both in writing and at two public hearings. The public hearings were conducted by the DEP on November 6, 1980 at the Convention Hall in Asbury Park and on November 7, 1980 at \ Stockton State College in Pomona. ·1 i The comments provided in this volume were excerpted from the transcripts I of the two public hearings or from written letters received by the DEP. Verbatim transcripts on the public hearings, prepared by certified shorthand reporters, may be consulted at the DEP/DCR offices in Trenton or Toms River. All written correspon dence regarding the Draft Master Plan document may also be reviewed at the DEP offices. Comments on the Draft Master Plan were compiled and responses were prepared by the staff of both Dames &. Moore and the DEP. A list of eornrnentors and the origin of their comments is provided in Chapter II of this volume. Chapter III .." includes all comments and responses by topic. Comments were grouped into 11 general categories. A commentor is identified for each comment. Where appropriate, one response has been provided for duplicate or similar comments by different individuals or agencies. In the case of the comments on the proposed Dune and Shorefront Protection Act (A-1825), a general response was prepared in addition to the individual responses. I-I You are viewing an archived copy from the New Jersey State Library .: CHAPTER 11 LIST OF COMMENTORS - j A. State Government Comment Origin and Date 1 Public .) Commentor Written Hearing John Paul Doyle 11/06/80 State Assemblyman District 9 ' I Richard A. Ginman, Director 11/17/80 Division of Planning Department of Community Affairs Bruce Freeman 12/18/80 I NJDEP Division of Fish, Game, and Wildlife Marine Fisheries Administration Hazel Gluck 11/06/80 State Assemblywoman District 9 Honorable James R. Hurley 11/13/80 State Assemblyman, District 1 Millville, N.J. Brian Kennedy 11/06/80 j State Senator District Hf I Stephen B. Richer 12/15/80 'I N.J. Division of Travel &. Tourism Alfred Scerni 11/07/80 I Director of District Office Operations I For Congressman William J. Hughes Dr. Anthony Villane 11/06/80 State Assemblyman J District 10 11 - 1 You are viewing an archived copy from the New Jersey State Library LIST OF COMMENTORS B. Federal Agencies Comment Origin and Date Public Commentor Written Hearing Paul A. Buckley 10/22/80 Chief Scientist U.S. Department of Interior National Park Service, North Atlantic Region Boston, Mass. Plater T. Campbell 11/14/80 State Conservationist U.S. Department of Agriculture Soil Conservation Service Somerset, N.J. Charles J. Kulp 11/26/80 Field Supervisor U.S. Department of Interior Fish and Wildlife Service State College, Pa. William Matuszeski 11/06/80 Deputy Assistant Administrator U.S. Department of Commerce NOAA/OCZM Washington, D.C. Barbara M. Metzger, Ph.D., Director 11/11/80 USEPA Region II New York, N.Y. D.J. Sheridan, Chief, 11/26/80 Planning/Engineering Division Department of the Army Corps of Engineers Philadelphia, Pa. II-2 , . 1 I You are viewing an archived copy from the New Jersey State Library LIST OF COMMENTORS C. County and Municipal Agencies Comment Origin and Date Public Commentor Written Hearing Atlantic City Engineering Department 11/03/80 . Department of Public Works I Atlantic City, N.J. ., I Honorable Andrew J. Bedrarek 11/07/80 Com missioner Sea Isle City, N.J. ' I Leon S. Avakian 11/06/80 Municipal Engineer Asbury Park, N.J. Lloyd Behmke, Mayor 11/07/80 Barnegat Light Borough, N.J. Thomas W. Birdsall, P.E., President 11/12/80 Birdsall, Gerkin &. Dolan, P.A. Municipal Engineering &. Planning Wall, N.J. J .I I William T. Birdsall, P.E. 11/21/80 The Birdsall Corporation Belmar, N.J. J Honorable Thomas Black, Mayor 11/19/80 Borough of Sea Girt, N.J. I Robert E. Bos, P.E. 12/01/80 I Cahn, Inc. J City Engineer, City of Ventnor I Voorhees, N.J. Leonard T. Connors, Jr. 11/19/80 I Freeholder Director I Ocean County Board of Chosen Freeholders Toms River, N.J. Stephen DePalma 11/06/80 Schoor, DePalma &. Gillen, Inc. Municipal Engineers for Sea Bright Matawan, N.J. Steven Gabriel 11/19/80 Departm ent of Public Works City of Ocean City, N.J. j ll-3 You are viewing an archived copy from the New Jersey State Library l LIST OF COMMENTORS C. County and Municipal Agencies (Cont'd) Comment Origin and Date Public Commentor Written Hearing . , Charles Guhr, Mayor 11/07/80 Wildwood Crest, N.J. Robert Halsey 11/18/80 Director of County Planning Monmouth County Planning Board I Freehold, N.J. .1. Michael Hyland 12/08/80 Township Engineer J Ocean City, N.J. Michael Ingram 11/28/80 11/06/80, City Engineer 11/07/80 Department of Public Works Atlantic City, N.J. Elwood Jarmer 11/07/80 Planning Director Cape May County, N.J. Robert LaTorre 11/06/80 Publicity Director Borough of Seaside Heights, N.J. David Magno 11/17/80 Schoor, DePalma &. Gillen, Inc. Municipal Engineers for Sea Bright Matawan, N.J. Jim Mancini, Mayor 11/07/80 Long Beach Township, N.J. Paul McCarthy 11/07/80 Ocean City Administrator Ocean City, N.J. F. Brent Neale, Mayor 11/06/80 Monmouth Beach, N.J. Robert Nissen, Mayor 11/07/80 Ship Bottom, N.J. Andrew Previti 11/07/80 Municipal Engineers Sea Isle City/Ocean City, N.J. I II-4 I '1 You are viewing an archived copy from the New Jersey State Library LIST OF COMMENTORS C. County and Municipal Agencies (Cont'd) Comment Origin and Date Public " I" Commentor Written Hearing Francis A. Pyanoe, Mayor 11/19/80 "Borough of Belmar, N.J. Andrew Raffetto, Mayor 11/06/80 Spring Lake, N.J. Martin Vaccaro, Mayor 11/06/80 Borough of Allenhurst, N.J. J. Thomas Wood 11/28/80 Borough Engineer Representing Atlantic City, Ventnor City Margate City, and Longport, N.J. James C. Wood, Mayor 11/06/80 Stone Harbor, N.J. Charles Worthington 12/03/80 11/07/80 County Executive Atlantic City, N.J. I , J J J j ] I J II - 5 You are viewing an archived copy from the New Jersey State Library LIST OF COMMENTORS D. Organizations and Universities Comment Origin and Date Public f Commentor Written Hearing John Carey 11/07/80 Ocean City Coastal Conservation Committee Ocean City, N.J. Alvin A. Clay, Dean 11/10/80 College of Commerce and Finance Villanova University Villanova, Pa, Paul Dritsas 11/06/80 11/06/80 American Littoral Society Sandy Hook, Highlands, N.J. Marie Dugan 11/07/80 Ocean City Environmental Association . f Ocean City, N.J. Stewart C. Farrell, Ph.D. 11/19/80 Associate Professor of Marine Geology Division of Natural Sciences Stockton State College Pomona, N.J. David Fisher 11/21/80 New Jersey Builders Association Woodbridge, N.J.