DOCSLIB.ORG

An Indirect Convergence Between the Accademia Del Cimento and the Montmor Academy: the ‘Saturn Dispute’

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
An Indirect Convergence Between the Accademia Del Cimento and the Montmor Academy: the ‘Saturn Dispute’ Chapter 4 An Indirect Convergence between the Accademia del Cimento and the Montmor Academy: The ‘Saturn dispute’ Giulia Giannini Introduction The purpose of the present chapter is to examine an indirect (albeit signifi- cant) point of contact between the Florentine academy, later known as the Accademia del Cimento, and the so-called Montmor Academy: their role in the ‘Saturn dispute’. In particular, this essay intends to demonstrate how, despite fragmentary evidence and often interrupted exchanges, the issue of the plan- et’s strange appearances offers a unique standpoint from which to assess the interests and the ways in which the two societies operated, as well as the na- ture of their relations. The two academies were active between 1657 and 1666–7, in Florence and Paris, respectively. The first occasional meetings at the house of Henri Louis Habert de Montmor (1600–1679) can be dated back to the period between 1654 and 1656.1 However, it is only from 1657 – when the academy approved its own statutes – that the beginning of the Parisian circle can be dated with certainty. The Cimento, on the other hand, never had official rules or statutes.2 The dat- ing of its meetings can be determined thanks to the diaries kept by its acade- micians, and also through the only publication produced by the Florentine academy: the Saggi di naturali esperienze (1667). This book – signed by the ‘ac- cademici del Cimento’ and by the ‘Saggiato segretario’, Lorenzo Magalotti – attested that an ‘academy’, sponsored by Prince Leopoldo de’ Medici (1617– 1675), was ‘founded in the year 1657’.3 1 Harcourt Brown, Scientific organizations in seventeenth century France (1620–1680) (New York, 1967 (1934)), 69–71. 2 See in particular: Paolo Galluzzi, ‘L’Accademia del Cimento: ‘Gusti’ del Principe, filosofia e ideologia dell’esperimento’, Quaderni storici 48 (1981), 788–844. 3 ‘[…] la nostra accademia istituita dell’anno 1657’, Lorenzo Magalotti, Saggi di naturali espe­ rienze (1667) (Palermo, 2001), 40. English transl. in W.E. Knowles Middleton, The Experiment­ ers: a study of the Accademia del Cimento (Baltimore, 1971), 92. © koninklijke brill nv, leiden, ���� | doi:10.1163/9789004416871_005 <UN> 84 Giannini Even less information is available regarding the cessation of their activities. Having never official statutes, the Accademia del Cimento did not have an of- ficial closure either. By the time when the Saggi was published, the meetings had become sporadic, many of the academicians moved elsewhere, the prince was elected cardinal and thus the meetings simply ceased to take place. The circumstances that led to the disbandment of the Parisian group are equally unclear. In June 1664 – following a long debate on the form that the group should have taken in order to become more robust and better regulated–4 Christiaan Huygens informed Robert Moray that the Montmor Academy had ‘ceased to exist’. On its ‘remains’ another group activity emerged, spearheaded by some of the members of the Montmor Academy.5 They met in the house of Melchisedéch Thévenot (c.1620–1692), one of the most active members of the Montmor Academy, at least until the establishment of the Académie Royale des Sciences in 1666. The history of the relations between the two academies – which prior to the foundation of the Royal Society and of the Académie Royale des Sciences were the two most renowned groups of scholars engaged exclusively in matters of natural philosophy – is difficult to piece together, given that the various at- tempts to establish epistolary exchange often encountered delays, if not out- right indifference. Consequently, the dialogue between the two academies might be better described as a succession of monologues. 1 Fragmentary and Difficult Exchanges a Autumn 1658: Michelangelo Ricci, Melchisedéch Thévenot and the First Contact between the Two Academies As is well known, the first tentative contact between the two academies was made by Melchisedéch Thévenot,6 a French diplomat, bibliophile and man of letters, and a collector of travel literature. His language skills earned him the 4 See for instance: Christiaan Huygens to Lodewijk Huygens, 6 April 1663, Christiaan Huygens, Œuvres complètes de Christiaan Huygens, Tome iv. Correspondance 1662–1663 (The Hague 1891), letter n. 1104, 323–324; and Christiaan Huygens to R. Moray, 12 Mars 1664, Christiaan Huygens, Œuvres complètes de Christiaan Huygens, Tome v. Correspondance 1664–1665 (The Hague, 1893), letter n. 1218, 39–42. 5 ‘A Paris il n’y avoit rien de nouveau en matiere de Sciences, sinon que l’Academie chez Mon- sieur de Montmor a pris fin pour jamais, mais il semble que du debris de celle cy il en pour- roit renaistre quelqüe autre, car j’ay laissè quelques uns de ces Messieurs avec de tres bonnes intentions’, Christiaan Huygens to R. Moray, 12 June 1664, Œuvres complètes de Christiaan Huygens, v, letter n. 1234, 69–70. 6 On Thévenot see especially: Robert McKeon, ‘Une lettre de Melchisédech Thévenot sur les débuts de l’Académie Royale des Sciences’, Revue d’histoire des sciences et de leur <UN>.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • PERSPECTIVE Steno, Targioni and the Two Forerunners
    dominici:ARGENTI 11/01/2010 11:40 Pagina 101 Journal of Mediterranean Earth Sciences 1 (2009), 101-110 doi:10.3304/JMES.2009.011 Journal of Mediterranean Earth Sciences JME S PERSPECTIVE Steno, Targioni and the two forerunners Stefano Dominici* Museo di Storia Naturale, Sezione di Geologia e Paleontologia, Università degli Studi di Firenze Via La Pira, 4 - 50121 Firenze, Italy ABSTRACT - The brief and enigmatic Forerunner written by Nicholas Steno after a two-year residence in Tuscany (1667- 1668) contains several basic intuitions of earth sciences. His work influenced contemporary natural philosophers through Europe, but was seemingly forgotten in the course of the next century. Only in Florence the naturalist and polymath Giovanni Targioni Tozzetti undertook a geological study of Tuscany and tested the validity of Steno’s hypothesis on the origin of mountains and hills. In relevant passages of his Travels (1751-1754), Targioni expressed a substantial agreement with Steno’s reconstruction, therefore planning a modernized version of Steno’s theory of the earth, which he published in his own Forerunner (1754). In this work he sets the agenda for the new disciplines of physical chorography and topography, wishing to complete their application to Tuscany in his own lifetime, so that Tuscany could be presented as a template of the earth. His fame as author of Travels and owner of one of the best natural history museums of Europe reached many savants who visited him and learned the results of his fieldwork and his geotheory. Some of the people who met with Targioni have influenced the development of geology, and important aspects of his ideas can be found in their writings.
    [Show full text]
  • Il Microscopio Di Galileo Antologia
    Il microscopio di Galileo Antologia Qui di seguito sono stati raccolti alcuni brani antologici relativi al microscopio di Galileo e alla microscopia del Seicento a cura dell’ Istituto e Museo di Storia della Scienza di Firenze. 1 Indice John Wedderburn: una preziosa testimonianza sul microscopio di Galileo (1610).............................3 Galileo Galilei: "un Telescopio accomodato per veder gli oggetti vicinissimi" (1623) ......................4 Giovanni Faber: Galileo "è un altro Creatore" (1624).........................................................................5 Galileo Galilei: descrizione del microscopio (1624) ...........................................................................6 Giovanni Faber: il nome “microscopio” (1625) ..................................................................................7 Vincenzo Viviani: Galileo inventore del microscopio (1654).............................................................8 Accademia del Cimento: un’osservazione al microscopio (1657).......................................................9 Carlo Antonio Manzini, le conquiste del microscopio (1661)...........................................................10 Robert Hooke: un ampliamento del dominio dei sensi (1665) ..........................................................11 Anonimo: "Modo di adoperare il microscopio" (1665-1667)............................................................13 Lorenzo Magalotti: la digestione d’alcuni animali (1667).................................................................14 Francesco
    [Show full text]
  • Evolutionoftherm00boltrich.Pdf
    Evolution of the Thermometer Dalence's Thermometer 1688. Evolution of the Thermometer^ 3> BY HENRY CARRINGTON BOLTON Author of Scientific Correspondence of Joseph Priestley EASTON, PA.: THE CHEMICAL PUBLISHING Co. 1900. COPYRIGHT, 1900, BY EDWARD HART. CONTENTS. I. The Open Air-thermometer of Galileo, . 5 II.. Thermoscopes of the Accademia del Cimento, 25 III. Attempts to obtain a scale from Boyle to Newton, 41 IV. Fahrenheit and the first reliable Thermom- eters 61 V. Thermometers of Reaumur, Celsius, and others 79 Table of Thirty-five Thermometer Scales,. 88 Chronological Epitome, 90 Authorities, 92 Index, 97 91629 EVOLUTION OF THE THERMOMETER I. THE OPEN AIR-THERMOMETER OF GALILEO. Discoveries and inventions are sometimes the product of the genius or of the intelligent in- dustry of a single person and leave his hand in a perfect state, as was the case with the ba- rometer invented by Torricelli, but more often the seed of the invention is planted by one, cultivated by others, and the fruit is gathered only after slow growth by some one who ig- nores the original sower. In studying the ori- gin and tracing the history of certain discov- eries of scientific and practical value one is often perplexed by encountering several claim- ants for priority, this is partly due to the cir- " cumstance that coincidence of independent thought is often the cause of two or more per- " sons reaching the same result about the same time and to the effort of each nation ; partly to secure for its own people credit and renown. Again, the origin of a prime invention is some- i 6 EVOLUTION OF THE THERMOMETER, times obscured by the failure of the discoverer to claim definitely the product of his inspira- tion owing to the fact that he himself failed to appreciate its high importance and its utility.
    [Show full text]
  • A Phenomenology of Galileo's Experiments with Pendulums
    BJHS, Page 1 of 35. f British Society for the History of Science 2009 doi:10.1017/S0007087409990033 A phenomenology of Galileo’s experiments with pendulums PAOLO PALMIERI* Abstract. The paper reports new findings about Galileo’s experiments with pendulums and discusses their significance in the context of Galileo’s writings. The methodology is based on a phenomenological approach to Galileo’s experiments, supported by computer modelling and close analysis of extant textual evidence. This methodology has allowed the author to shed light on some puzzles that Galileo’s experiments have created for scholars. The pendulum was crucial throughout Galileo’s career. Its properties, with which he was fascinated from very early in his career, especially concern time. A 1602 letter is the earliest surviving document in which Galileo discusses the hypothesis of pendulum isochronism.1 In this letter Galileo claims that all pendulums are isochronous, and that he has long been trying to demonstrate isochronism mechanically, but that so far he has been unable to succeed. From 1602 onwards Galileo referred to pendulum isochronism as an admirable property but failed to demonstrate it. The pendulum is the most open-ended of Galileo’s artefacts. After working on my reconstructed pendulums for some time, I became convinced that the pendulum had the potential to allow Galileo to break new ground. But I also realized that its elusive nature sometimes threatened to undermine the progress Galileo was making on other fronts. It is this ambivalent nature that, I thought, might prove invaluable in trying to understand crucial aspects of Galileo’s innovative methodology.
    [Show full text]
  • A Saint in the History of Cardiology
    Arch Cardiol Mex. 2014;84(1):47---50 www.elsevier.com.mx SPECIAL ARTICLE A saint in the history of Cardiology Alfredo de Micheli ∗, Raúl Izaguirre Ávila National Institute of Cardiology Ignacio Chavez, Tlalpan, DF, Mexico Received 19 December 2012; accepted 22 January 2013 KEYWORDS Abstract Niels Stensen (1638---1686) was born in Copenhagen. He took courses in medicine Niels Stensen; at the local university under the guidance of Professor Thomas Bartholin and later at Leiden Anatomy; under the tutelage of Franz de la Boë (Sylvius). While in Holland, he discovered the existence of Physiology; the parotid duct, which was named Stensen’s duct or stenonian duct (after his Latinized name Muscular fibers; Nicolaus Stenon). He also described the structural and functional characteristics of peripheral Heart muscles and myocardium. He demonstrated that muscular contraction could be elicited by appropriate nerve stimulation and by direct stimulation of the muscle itself and that during contraction the latter does not increase in volume. Toward the end of 1664, the Academic Senate of the University of Leiden awarded him the doctor in medicine title. Later, in Florence, he was admitted as a corresponding member in the Academia del Cimento (Experimental Academy) and collaborated with the Tuscan physician Francesco Redi in studies relating to viviparous development. In the Tuscan capital, he converted from Lutheranism to Catholicism and was shortly afterwards ordained in the clergy. After a few years, he was appointed apostolic vicar in northern Germany and died in the small town of Schwerin, capital of the Duchy of Mecklenburg- Schwerin on November 25, 1686.
    [Show full text]
  • Jan Kochanowski University Press
    Jan Kochanowski University Press This is a contribution from Token: A Journal of English Linguistics Volume 8/2019. Edited by John G. Newman, Marina Dossena and Sylwester Łodej. Special Editors for volume 8: Giovanni Iamartino and Irma Taavitsainen. © 2019 Jan Kochanowski University Press. Token: A Journal of English Linguistics 8, 2019 Italy and the Royal Society: Medical papers in the early Philosophical Transactions Lucia Berti University of Milan ABSTRACT During the first years of the Royal Society’s existence, a whole network of natural philosophical exchanges was set up between the Fellows and foreign gentlemen interested in the study of nature. From the exchanges with Italy, medicine appears to be one of the major topics of interest; and a series of medical papers based on Italian researches appear in the Society’s journal, the Philosophical Transactions (PT). This article is a linguistic and socio-historical analysis of 25 medical papers published in the PT in the first fifty years of its existence. The selected articles were either translations of Italian writings or reports of Italian research. The purpose of the study is: (1) to illustrate from a linguistic and socio-cultural point of view the nature of Italian medical contributions to the early PT; and (2) to investigate Anglo-Italian relations through the Royal Society’s medical interaction with Italians by analysing the PT articles and further contextual resources from a critical perspective. Keywords: Anglo-Italian relations, medical writing, Philosophical Transactions, Royal Society, seventeenth century. And your own intelligence will spur you on, without the urging of others, to inform yourself about these matters; in the same way you will be led, without doubt, to encourage all the keen minds of Italy to employ their talents in advancing the sciences and the arts by observations and experiments faithfully and diligently performed.
    [Show full text]
  • Nummer Toegang: 1.02.01 Inventaris Van Het
    Nummer Toegang: 1.02.01 Inventaris van het archief van C. van Heemskerck [levensjaren 1646-1702]: Gezant te Wenen, te Brussel, te Madrid, te Altona, te Constantinopel en te Parijs, 1672-1701 Versie: 15-08-2019 Th.H.P.M. Thomassen Nationaal Archief, Den Haag 1994 This finding aid is written in Dutch. 1.02.01 Heemskerck 3 INHOUDSOPGAVE Beschrijving van het archief......................................................................................5 Aanwijzingen voor de gebruiker................................................................................................6 Openbaarheidsbeperkingen.......................................................................................................6 Beperkingen aan het gebruik......................................................................................................6 Materiële beperkingen................................................................................................................6 Aanvraaginstructie...................................................................................................................... 6 Citeerinstructie............................................................................................................................ 6 Archiefvorming...........................................................................................................................7 Geschiedenis van de archiefvormer............................................................................................7 Vrijwilliger op de vloot en bestuurder
    [Show full text]
  • Birth and Life of Scientific Collections in Florence
    BIRTH AND LIFE OF SCIENTIFIC COLLECTIONS IN FLORENCE Mara Miniati 1 RESUMO: em Florença. Este artigo descreve as trans- formações ocorridas entre os séculos 18 e O artigo centra-se na história das coleções 19 na vida cultural da capital da Toscana: as científicas em Florença. Na era dos Medici, artes e ciências foram promovidos, e os flo- Florença foi um importante centro de pes- rentinos cultivados estavam interessadas no quisa científica e de coleções. Este aspecto desenvolvimento recente da física, na Itália e da cultura florentina é geralmente menos no exterior. Nesse período, numerosas co- conhecido, mas a ciência e coleções científi- leções científicas privadas e públicas de Flo- cas foram uma parte consistente da história rença existentes, que eram menos famosas, da cidade. O recolhimento de instrumentos mas não menos importantes do que as co- científicos era um componente importante leções Médici e Lorena se destacaram. Final- das estratégias políticas dos grão-duques flo- mente, o artigo descreve como as coleções rentinos, convencidos de que o conhecimen- florentinas se desenvolveram. A fundação to científico e controle tecnológico sobre do Instituto e Museu de História da Ciência a natureza conferiria solidez e prestígio ao deu nova atenção aos instrumentos cientí- seu poder político. De Cosimo I a Cosimo ficos antigos. Sua intensa atividade de pes- III, os grão-duques Médici concederam o seu quisa teve um impacto sobre a organização patrocínio e comissões sobre gerações de do Museu. Novos estudos levaram a novas engenheiros e cientistas, formando uma co- atribuições aos instrumentos científicos, as leção de instrumentos matemáticos e astro- investigações de arquivamento contribuiram nômicos, os modelos científicos e produtos para um melhor conhecimento da coleção, naturais, exibidos ao lado das mais famosas e os contactos crescentes com instituições coleções de arte na Galleria Uffizi, no Pala- italianas e internacionais feitas do Museu zzo Pitti, e em torno da cidade de Florença tornaram-no cada vez mais ativo em uma e outros lugares da Toscana.
    [Show full text]
  • The Institutionalisation of Scientific Thinking in the Tuscany of the Last Medici
    Domenico Pietropaolo The Institutionalisation of Scientific Thinking in the Tuscany of the Last Medici It has become customary in general accounts of the Grand Duchy of Tuscany during the first three decades or so of the eighteenth cen­ tury, which correspond to the last years of the long Medici dynasty, to speak a little disparagingly-and even with a touch of irony-of its institutional culture, portraying its chief representatives as being either absorbed in the self-complacent protocol of the court or else intent on dispensing ultimately insignificant erudition at the podium, where only rarely is the audience treated to a flash or two of ac­ tual brilliance. To the extent such general statements are acceptable without being universally binding, this is perhaps a sufficiently rea­ sonable, if definitely uncharitable, appraisal of the situation. Cer­ tainly if we attempt to define its parameters geographically, we soon enough come across men like Giambattista Vico in the Vice-kingdom of Naples, Antonio Conti and Antonio Vallisnieri in the Republic of Venice, and Ludovico Antonio Muratori in the Duchy of Modena, and the comparison cannot possibly be favourable to the Tuscan literati. If we instead approach the question historically within the Grand Duchy itself, we immediately encounter the luminaries of the Accademia del Cimento (1657-1667), namely Giovanni Alfonso Borelli, Francesco Redi and Vincenzo Viviani, all of whom were dead by 1703, and we are forced to admit that their successors' contribution to world knowledge was not of an
    [Show full text]
  • Gevaarlijke Kennis (Dangerous Knowledge, 2007, Sample Translation)
    Sample Translation Dangerous Knowledge (Gevaarlijke kennis) by Luuc Kooijmans (Amsterdam: Bert Bakker, 2007) Translated by Diane Webb LUUC KOOIJMANS – DANGEROUS KNOWLEDGE III IN SEARCH OF A REPUTATION Niels Stensen and Jan Swammerdam faced an uncertain future. There were no paid positions for research scientists, and those wishing to indulge in observation and experimentation were forced to do so in their free time. To earn a living, Stensen and Swammerdam would have had to become practising physicians, but the idea did not appeal to them. Not only had almost all current medical theories been called into question – owing in no small part to their own work – but they also believed that the foundations of medical science were too shaky to sustain any serious practice. A great many anatomical and physiological issues had first to be resolved, and as physicians they would have far too little time for this. Even as university lecturers they could not be certain of continuing their research, for empirical study was not a generally accepted approach in academic medicine. Universities were primarily institutions for the dissemination of classical learning, with little attention being paid to new findings. The lack of any convincing alternative had led most European universities to cling to outmoded teaching material, and the spirit of Aristotle still prevailed. Students were given Galen and Hippocrates to read, and were instructed in the doctrine of the four humours. There were, however, outside the universities, various forms of private seminars, in which more widely ranging and controversial material could be handled than in university lectures, and where fresh insights therefore made faster inroads.
    [Show full text]
  • Saturn Dispute”
    An indirect convergence between the Accademia del Cimento and the Montmor Academy: the “Saturn dispute” Giulia Giannini, Università degli Studi di Milano Introduction The purpose of the present chapter is to examine an indirect (albeit significant) point of contact between the Florentine academy, later known as the Accademia del Cimento, and the so-called Montmor Academy: their role in the “Saturn dispute”. In particular, this essay intends to demonstrate how, despite fragmentary evidence and often interrupted exchanges, the issue of the planet’s strange appearances offers a unique standpoint from which to assess the interests and the ways in which the two societies operated, as well as the nature of their relations. The two academies were active between 1657 and 1666-7, in Florence and Paris, respectively. The first occasional meetings at the house of Henri Louis Habert de Montmor (1600-1679) can be dated back to the period between 1654 and 1656.1 However, it is only from 1657–when the academy approved its own statutes–that the beginning of the Parisian circle can be dated with certainty. The Cimento, on the other hand, never had official rules or statutes.2 The dating of its meetings can be determined thanks to the diaries kept by its academicians, and also through the only publication produced by the Florentine academy: the Saggi di naturali esperienze (1667). This book – signed by the “accademici del Cimento” and by the “Saggiato segretario”, Lorenzo Magalotti– attested that an ‘academy’, sponsored by Prince Leopoldo de’ Medici (1617-1675), was ‘founded in the year 1657’.3 Even less information is available regarding the cessation of their activities.
    [Show full text]
  • ENGLISH BAROQUE with CIRCA 1 Magical Spell of the Night English Baroque with Circa
    CREATIVE TEAM 2019 Paul Dyer AO Artistic Director Yaron Lifschitz Artistic Director, Circa CANBERRA INTERNATIONAL Benjamin Knapton Associate Director MUSIC FESTIVAL Libby McDonnell Costume Design Llewellyn Hall Peter Rubie Lighting Design Thursday 2 May 7:30pm Yaron Lifschitz, Libby McDonnell, Richard Clarke Set Design SYDNEY This Production premiered on 2 May 2019 at Llewellyn Hall as part of City Recital Hall the Canberra International Music Festival. Wednesday 8 May 7:00pm Friday 10 May 7:00pm CHAIRMAN’S 11 Saturday 11 May 2:00pm Proudly supporting our guest artists. Saturday 11 May 7:00pm Concert duration approximately 90 minutes with no interval. Please note Wednesday 15 May 7:00pm concert duration is approximate only and is subject to change. Friday 17 May 7:00pm We kindly request that you switch off all electronic devices during the performance. MELBOURNE Melbourne Recital Centre Saturday 18 May 7:00pm Sunday 19 May 5:00pm BRISBANE QPAC Tuesday 21 May 7:30pm A Baroque wig: Paul Dyer’s first inspiration image for the series. ENGLISH BAROQUE WITH CIRCA 1 Magical Spell of the Night English Baroque with Circa PRELUDE Alex Palmer English Overture SCENE ONE – THE COURT Henry Purcell Curtain Tune from Timon of Athens, Z 632 John Dowland Behold a Wonder Here from The Third and Last Booke of Songs or Aires Henry Purcell Overture from King Arthur, Z 628 Henry Purcell Aire from King Arthur, Act II, Z 628 Henry Purcell Hornpipe from King Arthur, Act III, Z 628 Henry Purcell How Blest are Shepherds from King Arthur, Act II, Z 628 Henry Purcell 3 Parts Upon a Ground, Z 731 SCENE TWO – THE BEDROOM Henry Purcell Overture in C minor, Air in C minor, The Triumphing Dance from Dido & Aeneas, Z 626 Henry Purcell Ritornelle in D minor, Thanks to these lonesome vales, Dance in D minor from Dido & Aeneas, Z 626 George Frideric Handel Gentle Morpheus, son of night from Alceste, HWV 45 SCENE THREE – THE CHAPEL Arcangelo Corelli Concerto grosso in D major, Op.
    [Show full text]