DOCSLIB.ORG

Multinational Corporations: a Case of Impunity

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Multinational Corporations: a Case of Impunity Multinational Corporations: A Case of Impunity An argumentation analysis on the parliamentary debate of the Swiss Business Initiative Mirjam Hagmann Human Rights Bachelor Thesis 15hp Spring 2020 Supervisor: Anders Melin Abstract Non-governmental organizations (NGOs) and the media are constantly drawing attention to human rights violatio ns caused by multinational corporations abroad (MNCs). Due to the lack of an adequate framework to hold corporations accountable for their corporate misconduct across borders, there is a liability gap. Extensive research has been undertaken by politic a l philosophers as well as lawyers attempting to fill the gap, leaving the question why it still exists. Currently, there is a debate in the Swiss parliament about the implementation of a constitutional law which could fill this gap. By conducting an argumentation analysis on the parliamentary debate about the Swiss Business Initiative (SBI), this thesis seeks to analyze how politicians are framing the debate, as well as what normative concerns of the academy have been discussed or left out. Finally, the paper concludes with seven findings that could be focused on more in praxis. Keywords: Responsible Swiss Business Initiative, Human Rights, Global Justice, CSR, Multinational Corporations Word Count: 13’703 List of Abbreviations BoP Base of the pyramid CSR Corporate Social Responsibility GDP Gross Domestic Product GJM Global Justice Movement HRC Human Rights Council (UN) ICCPR International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights MNC Multinational Corporation NGO Non-Governmental Organiza tio n SBI Responsible Swiss Business Initiative (German: Konzernverantwortungs- initiative) SGSR United Nations Secretary-General's Special Representative UDHR Universal Declaration of Human Rights UN United Nations UNGC United Nations Global Compact UNGP United Nations Guiding Principles Table of Contents Abstract...................................................................................................................................... 2 List of Abbreviations ................................................................................................................. 3 1. INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................. 5 1.1 Introduction to the topic .............................................................................................. 5 1.2 Aim and Research Questions ........................................................................................ 6 1.3 Relevance to Human Rights .......................................................................................... 7 1.4 Theory and Method ..................................................................................................... 8 1.5 Delimitations ............................................................................................................... 8 1.6 Terminology ................................................................................................................ 8 2. THEORY .............................................................................................................................. 8 2.1 Literature Review......................................................................................................... 8 2.2 Theoretical Framework .............................................................................................. 12 2.2.1 Neoliberalism ......................................................................................................... 12 2.2.2 Global Justice ......................................................................................................... 14 2.2.3 Agents of global justice ........................................................................................... 16 2.2.4 Hard Law................................................................................................................ 17 2.2.5 Soft Law ................................................................................................................. 19 2.2.6 Voluntary mechanisms............................................................................................ 20 3. BACKGROUND ................................................................................................................. 22 3.1 The UN Guiding Principles .......................................................................................... 22 3.2 Choosing Switzerland and the SBI ............................................................................... 22 4. METHOD .......................................................................................................................... 23 4.1 Argumentation analysis.............................................................................................. 23 4.2 Material..................................................................................................................... 24 4.2.1 The Federal Popular Initiative in Switzerland ............................................................ 24 4.2.2 The parliamentary debate of the SBI ........................................................................ 24 4.2.3 Text of the Initiative................................................................................................ 25 4.3 Delimitations ............................................................................................................. 25 5. ANALYSIS AND DISCUSSION............................................................................................ 25 5.1 Argumentation analysis.............................................................................................. 25 5.1.1 Christa Markwalder ................................................................................................ 26 5.1.2 Cédric Wermuth ..................................................................................................... 27 5.1.3 Regula Rytz ............................................................................................................ 29 5.1.4 Zanetti, Claudio ...................................................................................................... 31 5.1.5 Conclusion ............................................................................................................. 32 5.2 Application of the theoretical framework to the parliamentary debate ....................... 32 5.2.1 Switzerland as an economic business location .......................................................... 33 5.2.2 Is Corporate Social Responsibility enough?............................................................... 34 5.2.3 International vs. State Law ...................................................................................... 35 5.2.4 State Sovereignty and Extraterritoriality .................................................................. 36 6. CONCLUSION ................................................................................................................... 38 6.1 Findings ..................................................................................................................... 38 6.2 Further Research........................................................................................................ 39 7. REFERENCE LIST ............................................................................................................... 40 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1 Introduction to the topic MNCs are becoming increasingly powerful in the domains of politics and economics, holding a large percentage of the world’s capital. Additionally, MNCs began to emulate into “global webs” making their legal structures more complex than ever—commonly referred to as the corporate veil. It took a long time for the social sciences, especially that of internatio na l relations to account for MNCs and not only states when it comes to questions about global power, distribution, “justice, freedom and economic security” (Strange, 1991: 245-246). After the Second World War, a strong political will to control the market lingered in society, which was advocated by Keynes, who believed that it was the liberal project and its consequences that led to such a detrimental economic situation and therefore suggested a mixed market control by using taxes and monetary policies to counterbalance economic recessions and depressions (Guger & Walterskirchen, 1988: 103-105). It was a short run for Keynesian economics, as the society did not want to return to its interwar social order, but found comfort in the re-emerging liberal thought which was strongly driven by Reagan and Thatcher. Neoliberalism was born and made to tackle the ascending globalization by releasing state regulation and revisiting the free market. A distinction of neoliberalism to that of classical neoliberalis m is the displacement of the nation state. Neoliberalism marks the beginning of states actively participating, facilitating and ensuring a self-regulating market (Wettstein, 2009: 175). Free market economy and deregulation offered ingress for MNCs to access all parts of the world, which drove competition for low production costs. Consequently, MNCs which established their headquarters in the Global North started operating in the Global South. Activis ts, NGOs and social movements began to draw negative media attention to corporate misconduc t in the Global South, calling for corporations to be held accountable for human rights violations committed abroad. Lacking a comprehensive framework
Load more

Recommended publications
  • SWISS REVIEW the Magazine for the Swiss Abroad February 2016
    SWISS REVIEW The magazine for the Swiss Abroad February 2016 80 years of Dimitri – an interview with the irrepressible clown February referenda – focus on the second Gotthard tunnel Vaping without nicotine – the e-cigarette becomes a political issue In 2016, the Organisation of the Swiss Abroad celebrates 100 years of service to the Fifth Switzerland. E-Voting, bank relations, consular representation; which combat is the most important to you? Join in the discussions on SwissCommunity.org! connects Swiss people across the world > You can also take part in the discussions at SwissCommunity.org > Register now for free and connect with the world SwissCommunity.org is a network set up by the Organisation of the Swiss Abroad (OSA) SwissCommunity-Partner: Contents Editorial 3 Dear readers 4 Mailbag I hope you have had a good start to the new year. 2016 is a year of anniversaries for us. We will celebrate 25 5 Books years of the Area for the Swiss Abroad in Brunnen this “Eins im Andern” by Monique Schwitter April, then 100 years of the OSA in the summer. Over the course of those 100 years, hundreds of thousands 6 Images of people have emigrated from Switzerland out of ne- Everyday inventions cessity or curiosity, or for professional, family or other reasons. The OSA is there for them as they live out their 8 Focus life stories. Its mission is to support Swiss people living abroad in a variety of Switzerland and the refugee crisis ways. It too is constantly changing. “Swiss Review” has had a new editor-in-chief since the beginning of No- 12 Politics vember.
    [Show full text]
  • Strange Bedfellows Culture and Politics in Conversation
    passages Strange Bedfellows Culture and Politics in Conversation Art in the Township: A Festival for Brenda Fassie p. 6 In the Shadow of the Pyramids: Swiss Art from Cairo p. 42 The 0.02692308-Gram Novel: Light Reading Courtesy of the E-Book p. 45 THE CULTURAL MAGAZINE OF PRO HELVETIA, NO. 50/2009 CONTENTS 12 – 39 Dossier: STRANGE BEDFELLOWS: CULTURE AND POLITICS IN CONVERSATION 3 EDITORIAL 40 LOCAL TIME What Price Culture? Rome: “An exhausting paradise” Janine Messerli Roman Arens 4 PRO HELVETIA NEWSFLASH Cairo: Egypt in the Alps Pro Helvetia > start > play Claudia Spinelli Lucerne Festival Orchestra Goes East 43 PARTNER PROFILE Echoes of Echoes 14 How Free Is Autonomous? Swiss Films: “Short films attract Bridge to the Caucasus Pius Knüsel a new, young audience to Swiss cinema” 6 REPORTAGE 18 A Cultural Fun Fair Felizitas Ammann Brenda Fassie for a Day Marc-Olivier Gonseth inter- Judith Reker (text) viewed by Mireille Descombes 44 IMPRESSUM Alexia Webster (photos) PASSAGES ONLINE 19 Ménage – Culture and Politics in NEXT ISSUE 11 CULTURE BEAT Conversation Artistic Licence – To Do What? Pro Helvetia’s new programme 45 VIEWPOINT Thomas Steinfeld Literature lite 22 “If everything were up to Monica Cantieni the market, only mainstream culture would survive.” 46 GALLERY Young Swiss National Council- A Showcase for Artists lors discuss cultural policy. “At the Binz Squat in Zurich” by Ingo Giezendanner 27 If I Were Minister of Culture… What would Swiss cultural policy be like if the artists were put in charge? Four Swiss artists share their
    [Show full text]
  • SWISS REVIEW the Magazine for the Swiss Abroad November 2019
    SWISS REVIEW The magazine for the Swiss Abroad November 2019 All change in parliament – greener, more women and more left-wing No more interest on savings – the spectre of negative interest rates Nuclear decommissioning – a challenge for the energy sector The publisher of “Swiss Review” is the Organisation of the Swiss Abroad (OSA). Happy New Year! We wish you lots of fun and good entertainment with the «Swiss Review» also in 2020. Your Organisation of the Swiss Abroad One newsletter to ensure better exchange of information Subscribe to the newsletter of the Organisation of the Swiss Abroad (OSA) and stay informed wherever you are: www.aso.ch/en/information/newsletter Swiss Review / November 2019 / No. 6 Contents Editorial 3 Green is the political colour 5 Mailbag Don’t worry, I will come to the federal elections of 20 October 2019 in a moment. But first I want to turn 8 Focus to the place where Swiss politics happens, the Fed- 2019 elections – a power shift of eral Palace itself. Did you know that the colour of its historic proportions dome roof was originally a shimmering copper red when the building was completed in 1902? The cop- 10 Knowledge per slowly oxidised over four decades, gradually giv- Star-gazing in Switzerland’s first-ever ing the dome a turquoise-green patina. The artisans dark-sky park who carried out necessary renovations to the roof in 2007 used artificially aged copper to preserve the oxidised colour to which the nation had be- 13 Society come so accustomed. The poor and the marginalised locked Parliament itself will have a very different, distinctly green, appearance up – Switzerland’s dark secret when it reopens for business, courtesy of the dramatic gains made by the Record-low interest rates spell tough country’s environmental parties at the ballot box.
    [Show full text]
  • Adept at Stealing the Limelight Villa Patumbah
    THE MAGAZINE FOR THE SWISS ABROAD JJUNIUNE 2013 // NNO.R.3 3 Parliament’s younger members – adept at stealing the limelight Villa Patumbah – the legacy of a rich Swiss abroad ORGANISATION OF THE SWISS ABROAD “The SwissCommunity platform networks Swiss people worldwide via the web.” Jean-François de Buren Graphic designer and mar keting strategy consultant Swiss in the United States “The beauty of Swiss- Community is the ability to easily share subjects you are passionate about.” Florian Baccaunaud Student Swiss in France “SwissCommunity? Chantal Kury It’s a new way of linking Licensed nursery-school Switzerland and the teacher Swiss abroad: it’s the way Swiss in Egypt forward.” “SwissCommunty is my gateway to my home country and to the world. The platform also offers a comprehensive service for the Swiss abroad.” Network with other Swiss abroad Keep up to date on relevant news and events Find an apartment – or the best fondue in town Discover Switzerland Sign up for free membership www.swisscommunity.org SwissCommunity partners EDITORIAL CONTENTS Swiss allies drift away ne issue is currently high on the agenda for many states, notably 5 Switzerland’s neighbours – the collection of taxes on assets which their citizens Mailbag Ohave concealed from the fiscal authorities using various schemes and often with 5 the assistance of financial institutions. The pursuit of those evading taxation and see- Books: Visions of and for Switzerland king optimized tax solutions is understandable in light of the debt situation facing many countries. Switzerland “the tax haven” finds itself directly in the firing line of many 6 disgruntled governments.
    [Show full text]
  • LSE European Politics and Policy (EUROPP) Blog: Switzerland's
    LSE European Politics and Policy (EUROPP) Blog: Switzerland’s ‘green tsunami’ slows to a trickle Page 1 of 6 Switzerland’s ‘green tsunami’ slows to a trickle Green parties were the main winners from the 2019 Swiss federal elections held on 20 October. However, as Clive H. Church writes, developments since the vote have illustrated the extent to which Swiss politics remains resistant to change. While the election generated some momentum behind efforts to strengthen the country’s climate policies, it remains unclear how far the process of ‘greening’ Swiss politics might go. The results of Switzerland’s 20 October election were, for once, quite meaningful, even if they passed largely ignored in Britain. However, as discussed at the time, they did not decide everything then and there. They left open the completion of the elections to the Council of States, or upper house, the question of the re-election of the seven strong collegial government and the evolution of green policies. Answering these queries, in turn depends on how the party balance in the National Council, or lower house, works out. In all these fields the green tsunami, in fact, rather found itself absorbed by the dunes and dykes of the consensual Swiss political system. So, even two months after the election, a surprising uncertainty remains about how far, and in what direction, the greening of Switzerland will actually lead. The second round The element of surprise continued throughout November as the second round of elections for the upper house were held on successive Sundays in thirteen cantons where candidates had not got over the quota.
    [Show full text]
  • SWISS REVIEW the Magazine for the Swiss Abroad September 2015
    SWISS REVIEW The magazine for the Swiss Abroad September 2015 A look back at politics over the past four years Who is voting for the issues that concern the Swiss Abroad in Parliament The conjuring trick over the magic formula Timea Bacsinszky’s struggles on and off the tennis court Retain Switzerland’s values and traditions? Vote SVP on 18 October 2015! You can elect SVP International candidates in the following cantons: Basel District Basel Geneva Grisons Lucerne St Gallen Schaffhausen Solothurn Zug Zurich By voting for one of the SVP Lists in the remaining cantons, you can help us in our efforts to further the fol- lowing causes of Switzerland and Swiss Expatriates: - Each Swiss has his Swiss bank account! - No mindless closure of consulates! - Safeguard the independence and neutrality of Switzerland! - Clear policy on asylum and foreigners www.svp-international.ch International Health Insurance 61 11 Based on Swiss standards Lifelong private medical treatment Worldwidefreechoiceofdoctorand clinic Furthermore: Internationaldisabilityinsurance Internationalpension fund ÖKOLOGISCH, Individual solutions for: Swiss citizens abroad SOZIAL, Expatriates of allnationalities Shorttermassignees /Localhire WELTOFFEN WÄHLEN SIE GRÜN! Die Grünen setzen sich in über 100 Ländern für Klimaschutz, Contactus! gerechte Handelsbeziehungen, Tel: +41 (0)43 399 89 89 Menschenrechte und Demokratie ein. Auch in der Schweiz. www.asn.ch ASN,Advisory Services Network AG Bederstrasse 51 CH-8027 Zürich info@asn.ch Contents Editorial 3 Election campaign speeches 5 Mailbag Today is 1 August and Swiss National Day. It is raining. Sitting at one’s desk to work is not a chore. It is not ex- 5 Books actly torrential rain outside nor a summer thunder- A Swiss writer in Iceland storm.
    [Show full text]
  • Wählen Sie Die Umwelt! National- Und Ständeratswahlen Vom 18
    Wählen Sie die Umwelt! National- und Ständeratswahlen vom 18. Oktober 2015 Sie sind das Zünglein an der Waage Naturschutz, Energiewende, Agrarpolitik: In den nächsten vier Jahren stehen wichtige umweltpolitische Entscheide an. Damit Natur und Umwelt gewinnen, braucht es jede Stimme. Besonders Ihre. Denn bei den eidgenössischen Wahlen wird es manchmal knapp – sehr knapp. Das zeigen Beispiele von 2011: • In St. Gallen entschieden nur 0,4% der Stimmen, wer in den Ständerat einziehen würde. Inhaltsverzeichnis • Im Tessin musste zwischen zwei Nationalratskandidaturen sogar das Los entscheiden. Welche Kandidatin, welcher Kandidat das Rennen macht, ist für die Umwelt jedoch wesentlich. Denkt • Umweltpolitik der nächsten und stimmt sie ökologisch? Oder ist ihm Umweltfreundlichkeit weniger wichtig? Denn auch bei konkreten Legislatur Seite 2 Umweltentscheidungen im Parlament wird es immer wieder eng – sehr eng: • Die Parteien im Umweltrating Seite 3 • 2014 lehnte der Nationalrat höhere Sicherheitsanforderungen für alte AKWs mit nur einer Stimme Differenz ab. • Tipps zur ökologischen Wahl Seite 4 Sie sehen: Einige wenige PolitikerInnen mehr im Parlament, die ökologisch denken – und schon wird ver- • Ausgangslage im und Kandi- mehrt zugunsten der Umwelt entschieden. Diese Wahlbeilage zeigt Ihnen, welche Parteien und Kandidie- dierende aus dem Kanton renden sich für die Umwelt einsetzen. Am besten füllen Sie Ihren Wahlzettel gleich während dem Lesen Bern Seiten 5–8 aus: So machen Sie ganz konkrete Umweltpolitik. Ihr Einfluss zählt! Neue Legislatur: Die wichtigsten Umweltthemen In den nächsten vier Jahren steht für die Umwelt viel auf dem Spiel. Die neue Zusammensetzung des Parlaments wird entscheidend dafür sein, in welche Richtung sich die Schweiz in diesen zentralen Dossiers bewegt: Energie • Die Energiestrategie 2050 bildet einen Meilenstein hin zu vermehrter Nutzung erneuerbarer Energien und Energieeffizienz.
    [Show full text]
  • New Paths for Science ...10
    New paths for science ............................................ 10 Cells that regenerate Hunting for drugs Free passage the heart ............... 36 underground ......... 42 for refugees? ......... 44 Elections 2015: Howview the pagepartiesscience 26 Reinventing science Science is taking a hard look in the mirror, and it’s for the best. The problems it faces are increasingly clear: reproducibility, fraud and statistical bias, to name but a few. Back in 2013 the news magazine The Economist featured the front-page headline “How Science Goes Wrong”. For sure, it may be somewhat alarmist to talk about ‘a crisis of science’, but it does embody the idea behind the critical, unwavering view of the scientific community on the state of affairs in its own house. It is time then to welcome the wide variety of new solutions that are being proposed by researchers. There’s the DORA declaration, which veers away from the quantitative appraisal of research proposals, the Journal of Negative Results in Biomedicine, which encourages the publication of insignificant studies, and the new Swiss platform ScienceMatters, which allows researchers to publish simple isolated results free of the temptation to embellish them (see p. 22). Science has everything it needs to change. After all, it’s already in a day’s work for a researcher to question hypotheses and explain erroneous results. And now there are also the right tools. One no longer needs a publisher to ensure that news of discoveries is spread; it is now sufficient to upload manuscripts to free publication servers or online lab books. There’s even talk about replacing the peer-review system – target of so much criticism – with a quick, transparent and participatory online system for comments.
    [Show full text]
  • Page 12, Watts, 2008)
    =========================================================================== COMPARATIVE STUDY OF ELECTORAL SYSTEMS (CSES) - MODULE 5 (2016-2021) CODEBOOK PART 2: VARIABLES DESCRIPTION THIRD ADVANCE RELEASE - JULY 20, 2021 CSES Secretariat www.cses.org =========================================================================== HOW TO CITE THE STUDY: The Comparative Study of Electoral Systems (www.cses.org). CSES MODULE 5 THIRD ADVANCE RELEASE [dataset and documentation]. JULY 20, 2021 version. doi:10.7804/cses.module5.2021-07-20 These materials are based on work supported by the American National Science Foundation (www.nsf.gov) under grant numbers SES-1420973 and SES-1760058, the GESIS - Leibniz Institute for the Social Sciences, the University of Michigan, in-kind support of participating election studies, the many organizations that sponsor planning meetings and conferences, and the numerous organizations that fund national election studies by CSES collaborators. Any opinions, findings and conclusions, or recommendations expressed in these materials are those of the author(s) and do not necessarily reflect the views of the funding organizations. =========================================================================== =========================================================================== TABLE OF CONTENTS =========================================================================== ))) IMPORTANT NOTE REGARDING ADVANCE RELEASES ))) OVERVIEW OF "CODEBOOK PART 2: VARIABLES DESCRIPTION" ))) HOW TO NAVIGATE THE CSES MODULE 5 CODEBOOK
    [Show full text]
  • SWISS REVIEW the Magazine for the Swiss Abroad October 2016
    SWISS REVIEW The magazine for the Swiss Abroad October 2016 Switzerland’s locational disadvantage – an interview with Lovebugs’ vocalist Adrian Sieber The battle over organisations – how much Geneva pays for its international reputation The right to darkness – fighting light pollution with a star park As a Swiss Abroad, the decisions taken in Bern by the Parliament concern you directly. Do you follow political news? Do you participate in vote? And how do you inform yourself? Connect to SwissCommunity.org and discover the views of other Swiss Abroad! connects Swiss people across the world > You can also take part in the discussions at SwissCommunity.org > Register now for free and connect with the world SwissCommunity.org is a network set up by the Organisation of the Swiss Abroad (OSA) SwissCommunity-Partner: Contents Editorial 3 When the sky is lost to us 5 Mailbag 6 Focus Fighting light pollution with a star park I can vividly recall the most star-lit sky of my life. 10 Economy We were travelling in a rickety night bus in the high Brexit’s impact on Switzerland plains of Bolivia when our vehicle broke down around 3 am in the middle of nowhere. We used the 12 Politics involuntary break to exercise our legs. And there it Geneva fights for international was: the most remarkable star-lit sky I had ever seen. organisations We stood in the absolute darkness of the night-time The new power constellation in the wilderness while a sea of stars, the likes of which we Federal Palace had only known from melodramatic Steven Spielberg movies, stretched out Nuclear power vote of 27 November above us.
    [Show full text]
  • Bernhard, Laurent (2020)
    This is a pre-copyedited and author-produced version of the following article accepted for publication: Bernhard, Laurent (2020). The 2019 Swiss federal elections: the rise of the green tide. West European Politics, 43(6), 1339-1349. Published version: https://doi.org/10.1080/01402382.2019.1710687 SERVAL Repository: https://serval.unil.ch/en/notice/serval:BIB_355945E4CA46 [The article begins on the next page] The 2019 Swiss federal elections: The rise of the Green tide LAURENT BERNHARD laurent.bernhard@fors.unil.ch Abstract The Greens made spectacular gains in the 2019 Swiss federal elections. In a campaign that was dominated by the climate change issue, the party outperformed the Christian Democrats to become the fourth largest party in the lower house. This status enabled the Greens to legitimately request a seat in government (the Federal Council). However, their attempt to unseat a member of the Liberals in the government, failed due to the resistance of the right-wing parties. Hence, the Green wave was not strong enough to change the composition of the federal government. Keywords: Switzerland; election; Greens; climate change; parties 1 Background to the election In 2015, the radical right Swiss People’s Party (SVP) won the federal elections and managed to add a second representative to the seven-member cabinet of the Federal Council (Bernhard 2016), thereby restoring the so-called ‘magic formula’. This formula reflects an unwritten rule dating from 1959 that grants each of the three largest parties of the lower house (currently the SVP, the Social Democrats (SP), and the Liberals (FDP)) with two seats in government, and the fourth largest party (i.e.
    [Show full text]
  • The Swiss Confederation a Brief Guide 2018
    THE SWISS CONFEDERATION A BRIEF GUIDE 2018 THE SWISS CONFEDERATION A BRIEF GUIDE 2018 Cover The glacier blue water of the Fedacla river meets the turquoise of Lake Silvaplana. The river continually washes fresh debris into the Fex delta: banks of gravel and mud form and then submerge. The photo was taken by a drone from a height of 90 metres. EDITORIAL Dear Reader Of all the texts, reports and dispatches that are published by the federal authorities – and there are an awful lot of them – ‘The Swiss Confederation – A Brief Guide’ – is prob- ably the most frequently requested. Two hundred thousand copies of the 2018 edition have been printed, even though the guide has also been available on the ‘CH info’ app since 2016. The overview it gives of our political system, govern- “Direct democracy means much ment, the administrative authorities, our parliament and more than occasionally consulting the courts is not ‘just’ teaching material for schools. The interest shown in the guide is also an expression of the close the public.” relationship between society and politics. In a sense, each voting citizen in Switzerland is a politician, and politically active, just to different degrees. Every three months we are called to the ballot box to make political de- cisions; we follow the debates or take part in them. Some- one launches an initiative, someone else a referendum, and others write letters to newspapers, tweet or speak up at their communal assembly. Direct democracy means much more than occasionally consulting the public. It is an embracive, relatively confus- ing, sometimes time-consuming, delicately balanced, per- manently rotating and constantly changing mechanism, whose purpose is to include in the decision-making process all those who must live with the consequences of the deci- sion.
    [Show full text]