Archive Search Result
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
4/8/2021 Search the San Jose Mercury News Archive Archive Search Result FALLON STATUE OPPOSED MAYOR, HISPANICS AT ODDS AGAIN DATE: March 22, 1990 THOMAS FARRAGHER, Mercury News Staff Writer PUBLICATION: San Jose Mercury News (CA) EDITION: Morning Final SECTION: Local Page: 1B Leaders of some city Hispanic groups are condemning as biased San Jose's $820,000 tribute to Capt. Thomas Fallon, who claimed the city for the United States during a 19th century war with Mexico. Mayor Tom McEnery said Wednesday he plans to schedule a formal discussion about the project with Javier H. Salazar, director of the Aztlan Academy of Ethnic Heritage, who has denounced the city's plan to erect a statue to Fallon as an insult to Mexican-Americans. "It's a militaristic celebration of war," Salazar said. "Would the city erect a monument to celebrate the defeat of the Japanese in the second world war?" Fallon, an early mayor whose home on West St. John Street will be converted into a historical museum, has been cast in bronze for a statue to be placed on a traffic island just north of Plaza Park. According to a city history, Fallon raised the Stars and Stripes on July 14, 1846, after angry natives had cut it down during the Mexican-American War. ''Anybody who's interested in the history of San Jose and in remembering the people who built this valley is a friend of mine," McEnery said. "But the flag was raised on Market Street. That is a historical fact." Salazar, who already has met with McEnery to discuss the statue, argues that the city should be celebrating its ethnic diversity instead of a military victory over early settlers. ''The Mexicans and the Hispanics in San Jose pulled down the flag two or three times," Salazar said. "When the cavalry came with arms, the flag remained. There's no need to celebrate that." Felix Alvarez, executive director of El Teatro De Los Pobres, a Hispanic theater group, said he would not be surprised if the Fallon statue is torn down by Mexican- Americans angered by what the monument represents. ''Thomas Fallon in military garb astride a horse, planting the American flag as a military victory over the Mexican township of San Jose is offensive," said Alvarez, who criticized McEnery for not soliciting more public comment before pushing for the statute. "When Mr. Fallon arrived in San Jose, the Mexican community welcomed him and helped him and he married into the Mexican family. That isn't portrayed." McEnery, who has written a fictionalized account of Fallon's exploits, said Fallon is worthy of a perch on Market Street because he "represents the assimilation of this valley." The mayor said Fallon never killed or plundered. "He was my kind of soldier," McEnery said. Esther Medina, executive director of the Mexican American Community Services Agency, said Fallon is a legitimate part of San Jose's history. "Our biggest concern is that the history of the Mexican influence here has not been properly recorded or been given anywhere near equal importance," she said. "It hasn't even been acknowledged." McEnery pledged to do that with future public art projects, including gateway sculptures planned for major thoroughfares leading to the downtown. While Salazar and others say Fallon should not be placed in Plaza Park and should be recast as a less militaristic character, it may be too late. Nairobi-born artist Robert Glen's creation of Fallon and a compatriot is scheduled to be delivered to the project site within weeks. Kathy Chavez Napoli, who called herself a spokeswoman for a coalition of community and cultural groups founded after the flap over McEnery's abandoned plan to take over the Spanish- language Studio Theatre, said there is widespread disapproval of the Fallon statue. It will be discussed, she said, during a 6:30 meeting tonight at Mother Olson's Inn, 72 North Fifth St. ''A large segment of the community opposes this," Napoli said. "We just keep on being told that the city knows best for us, as if we're children. We are not children. We can recognize what's important. We should have some input." https://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_action=doc&p_docid=0EB731EA9E9FE065&p_docnum=63&s_dlid=DL0121040822393427344&s_… 1/2 4/8/2021 Search the San Jose Mercury News Archive Back to your search results | Return to the search page | Printer Friendly version https://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_action=doc&p_docid=0EB731EA9E9FE065&p_docnum=63&s_dlid=DL0121040822393427344&s_… 2/2 4/8/2021 Search the San Jose Mercury News Archive Archive Search Result FALLON STATUE OPPOSED MAYOR, HISPANICS AT ODDS AGAIN DATE: March 22, 1990 THOMAS FARRAGHER, Mercury News Staff Writer PUBLICATION: San Jose Mercury News (CA) EDITION: Morning Final SECTION: Local Page: 1B Leaders of some city Hispanic groups are condemning as biased San Jose's $820,000 tribute to Capt. Thomas Fallon, who claimed the city for the United States during a 19th century war with Mexico. Mayor Tom McEnery said Wednesday he plans to schedule a formal discussion about the project with Javier H. Salazar, director of the Aztlan Academy of Ethnic Heritage, who has denounced the city's plan to erect a statue to Fallon as an insult to Mexican-Americans. "It's a militaristic celebration of war," Salazar said. "Would the city erect a monument to celebrate the defeat of the Japanese in the second world war?" Fallon, an early mayor whose home on West St. John Street will be converted into a historical museum, has been cast in bronze for a statue to be placed on a traffic island just north of Plaza Park. According to a city history, Fallon raised the Stars and Stripes on July 14, 1846, after angry natives had cut it down during the Mexican-American War. ''Anybody who's interested in the history of San Jose and in remembering the people who built this valley is a friend of mine," McEnery said. "But the flag was raised on Market Street. That is a historical fact." Salazar, who already has met with McEnery to discuss the statue, argues that the city should be celebrating its ethnic diversity instead of a military victory over early settlers. ''The Mexicans and the Hispanics in San Jose pulled down the flag two or three times," Salazar said. "When the cavalry came with arms, the flag remained. There's no need to celebrate that." Felix Alvarez, executive director of El Teatro De Los Pobres, a Hispanic theater group, said he would not be surprised if the Fallon statue is torn down by Mexican- Americans angered by what the monument represents. ''Thomas Fallon in military garb astride a horse, planting the American flag as a military victory over the Mexican township of San Jose is offensive," said Alvarez, who criticized McEnery for not soliciting more public comment before pushing for the statute. "When Mr. Fallon arrived in San Jose, the Mexican community welcomed him and helped him and he married into the Mexican family. That isn't portrayed." McEnery, who has written a fictionalized account of Fallon's exploits, said Fallon is worthy of a perch on Market Street because he "represents the assimilation of this valley." The mayor said Fallon never killed or plundered. "He was my kind of soldier," McEnery said. Esther Medina, executive director of the Mexican American Community Services Agency, said Fallon is a legitimate part of San Jose's history. "Our biggest concern is that the history of the Mexican influence here has not been properly recorded or been given anywhere near equal importance," she said. "It hasn't even been acknowledged." McEnery pledged to do that with future public art projects, including gateway sculptures planned for major thoroughfares leading to the downtown. While Salazar and others say Fallon should not be placed in Plaza Park and should be recast as a less militaristic character, it may be too late. Nairobi-born artist Robert Glen's creation of Fallon and a compatriot is scheduled to be delivered to the project site within weeks. Kathy Chavez Napoli, who called herself a spokeswoman for a coalition of community and cultural groups founded after the flap over McEnery's abandoned plan to take over the Spanish- language Studio Theatre, said there is widespread disapproval of the Fallon statue. It will be discussed, she said, during a 6:30 meeting tonight at Mother Olson's Inn, 72 North Fifth St. ''A large segment of the community opposes this," Napoli said. "We just keep on being told that the city knows best for us, as if we're children. We are not children. We can recognize what's important. We should have some input." https://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_action=doc&p_docid=0EB731EA9E9FE065&p_docnum=63&s_dlid=DL0121040822393427344&s_… 1/2 4/8/2021 Search the San Jose Mercury News Archive Back to your search results | Return to the search page | Printer Friendly version https://nl.newsbank.com/nl-search/we/Archives?p_action=doc&p_docid=0EB731EA9E9FE065&p_docnum=63&s_dlid=DL0121040822393427344&s_… 2/2 4/8/2021 Search the San Jose Mercury News Archive Archive Search Result HISPANICS DEPLORE MCENERY'S STATUE CHOICE DATE: March 23, 1990 THOMAS FARRAGHER, Mercury News Staff Writer PUBLICATION: San Jose Mercury News (CA) EDITION: South County SECTION: Local Page: 6B Leaders of some city Hispanic groups are condemning as biased San Jose's $820,000 tribute to Capt. Thomas Fallon, who claimed the city for the United States during a 19th-century war with Mexico. Mayor Tom McEnery said Wednesday he is planning to schedule a formal discussion about the project with Javier H.