Town and Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1997 ANGUS COUNCIL REPORT on OBJECTIONS to the FINALISED ANGUS LOCAL PLAN REVIEW VOLUME
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Town and Country Planning (Scotland) Act 1997 ANGUS COUNCIL REPORT ON OBJECTIONS TO THE FINALISED ANGUS LOCAL PLAN REVIEW VOLUME 2 Reporters: Richard E Bowden BSc(Hons) MPhil MRTPI Richard G Dent BA(Hons) DipTP FRTPI Dates of inquiry: 23 January – 25 April 2006 Finalised Angus Local Plan VOLUME 2 CONTENTS Introduction page Part 4, Town Directory – the larger settlements Arbroath: Development Strategy 1 Arbroath: Development Boundary 3 Arbroath: A1 Housing - Montrose Road and Omission: Crudie Farms 5 Arbroath: Policy A6 - Regenerate! North Arbroath 24 Arbroath: Policy A9 - Opportunity Site, Ernest Street/ Palmer Street 26 Arbroath: Policies A10 - Cairnie Street / Stobcross and A16 - Westway – 29 Dundee Road; Retail Arbroath Arbroath: A11 - Opportunity site, Wardmill /Dens Road 78 Arbroath: Policy A12 – Working, West of Elliot Industrial Estate 83 Arbroath: Policy A19 - Hospitalfield House 85 Arbroath: Omission - Land at Elliot 87 Arbroath: Omission - land north of Warddykes, 90 Brechin: Key Issues and Development Strategy & Town Centre and Retailing 93 Brechin: B1 – Housing, Dubton Farm and Omission – 96 Crookston East/Unthank Farm Brechin: B9 – Community Woodland, Cookston 102 Carnoustie and Barry: Key Issues – caravans and camping 104 Carnoustie and Barry: Development Strategy – Carnoustie seafront 106 Carnoustie and Barry: C6, Working – Clayholes, Carnoustie (proposed amendment) 108 Omission - Panbride North/Carlogie Road, Carnoustie Carnoustie and Barry: C8 - Primary School Site, Thomas Street 121 Carnoustie and Barry: C9 - Primary School Site, Queen Street 123 Carnoustie and Barry: Omission – Carlogie 126 Carnoustie and Barry: Omission – land north of Newton Road playing fields, 129 west of Carlogie Road Carnoustie and Barry: Omission – land at Clayholes (Newton Farm) 131 Carnoustie and Barry: Omission – Panbride/Westhaven 134 Carnoustie and Barry: Omission – site for “superloo” 139 Carnoustie and Barry: Omission - proposals map – road closures 140 Carnoustie and Barry: Omission – Barry by-pass, south 142 Carnoustie and Barry: Omission – Barry by-pass, north 145 Carnoustie and Barry: Omission – Greenlaw 148 Carnoustie and Barry: Omission – Barry Road west 151 Carnoustie and Barry: Omission – Waterybutts 155 Finalised Angus Local Plan Carnoustie and Barry: Omission - land north of Barry 158 Carnoustie and Barry: Omission - land at Victoria Link, A92 163 Forfar: Residential Development - General background 168 Forfar: Site F4 – Wester Restenneth 172 Forfar: Site F5, Whitehills Nursery 176 Forfar: Site F7, New Neighbourhood, Westfield 178 Forfar: Omission – Land at Gowanbank 201 Forfar: Omission – Land at Suttieside 205 Forfar: Omission – Land at Slatefield 208 Forfar: Omission - Land at Turfbeg 212 Forfar, Kirriemuir and the Angus Glens Housing Market Area 219 Forfar: Site F12 – Working, Orchardbank 223 Forfar: Site F14: Primary School, Whitehills Nursery 226 Paragraph 15, Primary Schools Forfar: F17 - Forfar Loch 229 Forfar: Omission – Land at North Mains 232 Forfar: Land at Orchardbank – conflict of land use 235 Kirriemuir: Paragraph 3 – Key Issues & Development Strategy 239 Kirriemuir: Residential Development - General background 242 Kirriemuir: Site K(b), Westfield/Lindsay Street, 246 Kirriemuir: Site K1, Shielhill Road, 248 Kirriemuir: Site K2, Hillhead 250 Kirriemuir: Land to the south of Beechwood Place 262 Kirriemuir: Omission - land at Sunnyside 270 Kirriemuir: Omission - land at Herdhill/Martin Park 275 Kirriemuir: Omission - land at Pathhead, Forfar Road 277 Kirriemuir: Omission - land at Newton Park 279 Kirriemuir: Omission - land north of Cortachy Road (two sites) 281 Kirriemuir: Residential Development – Conclusions 284 Kirriemuir: Site K4 – Working, East Muirhead of Logie, Forfar Road 308 Monifieth: Site Mf 4 - Budden Drive Cemetery Site 310 Monifieth: Omission – Land at Ashludie Farm, Mains of Ardestie and 317 Ardownie Farm Montrose: Settlement Statement – Paragraphs 1-5 325 Montrose: Site M1 - Brechin Road & Omission - Marykirk Rd Hillside 327 Montrose: M4 Opportunity Site – Sunnyside Hospital 330 Montrose: M9, Railway Sidings - Montrose Station 332 Montrose: Omission - Glaxo site 335 Finalised Angus Local Plan INTRODUCTION This report considers all objections lodged, and not subsequently unconditionally withdrawn, against the terms of the finalised Angus Local Plan Review including the first, second and third rounds of pre-inquiry changes. The report is set out in 3 volumes: • General and policy objections (Parts 1, 2, 3, 5 and 6) and appendices; • The larger settlements – Arbroath, Brechin, Carnoustie and Barry, Forfar, Kirriemuir, Monifieth and Montrose; • The remaining settlements in the Town and Village Directory along with all other settlements. The Environmental Assessment of Plans and Programmes (Scotland) Regulations 2004 implement European Union Council Directive 2001/42/EC (the Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) Directive) on the assessment of the effects of certain plans and programmes on the environment. Under these Regulations, all new and replacement structure and local plans - and those started on or before 21 July 2004 but not adopted or submitted to the legislative procedure for adoption before 22 July 2006 - must be subject to SEA. Scottish Ministers, however, may direct that a particular plan or programme is exempt, if they decide that such an assessment is not feasible. Initially it was anticipated that the Angus Local Plan Review would be capable of adoption prior to 22 July 2006. Accordingly, a strategic environmental assessment would not be required under the terms of the Directive. More recently it was recognised that adoption by 22 July 2006 had become unlikely and a written request for exemption was submitted to the Scottish Ministers on 16 February 2006. The Scottish Ministers granted the exemption, as requested, on 28 March 2006. The inquiry took place between 23 January and 25 April 2006 in various locations in Angus. Where requested, the proceedings were conducted as a formal public local inquiry but, for the most part, the objections were discussed at informal hearings. The Reporters sat separately other than for the hearing of objections against Policy SC1, Housing Land Supply and Policy SC6, Affordable Housing. In considering objections, account has been taken of the evidence presented at the inquiry, written material, supporting documents and site inspections. When requested, the Reporters visited objection sites on an accompanied basis. Evidence submitted following the close of the inquiry was taken into account only if it was received before the particular matter to which it related had not been dealt with by the appropriate Reporter. Any late documents have simply been passed to the council to be considered as thought fit. Finalised Angus Local Plan Recommendations are made in respect of all objections heard at the inquiry and those where objectors elected to rest on written submissions. Objections deemed by the council as invalid (or not in conflict with the terms of the plan) have not been considered and are not the subject of recommendations. Overall, it is believed that the recommendations would lead to the local plan conforming to the provisions of the Dundee and Angus Structure Plan. Richard E Bowden Richard Dent Reporter Reporter Finalised Angus Local Plan Review Arbroath: Development Strategy Objector Reference Wm Morrison Supermarkets PLC 913/1/2 Procedure Reporter Written Submission Richard Bowden ______________________________________________________________________ Background 2.1 Page 103 of the finalised local plan review at paragraph 7 provides an 8 bullet point development strategy for Arbroath. This makes reference to promoting regeneration, development opportunities and investment within the town, to strengthen the role of Arbroath as a retail and service centre and to develop its visitor potential based on its heritage features. Of particular concern to this objection, the fifth bullet point reads: “Encourage new development and investment where this will strengthen the role of the town as a retail and service centre.” Basis of the objection 2.2 It is pointed out that the development strategy for Arbroath, whilst encouraging new development and investment does not distinguish between the town centre and locations outwith the town centre. On this basis it is argued that the Arbroath Strategy is not in conformity with the approved structure plan and conflicts with national planning policy, in particular NPPG8 Town Centres and Retailing. It is pointed out that the aims of the approved structure plan for town centres and retailing are set out in paragraph 5.7 of that document. It is noted that these include promoting town centres in their roles as important shopping destinations as the first choice for new retail development. It is also noted that NPPG8 supports this approach, for example by its policy objectives of sustaining and enhancing the vitality, viability and design quality of town centres as the most appropriate location for retailing and other related activities. Based on these considerations, the objector argues that the fifth bullet point of paragraph 7 on Page 103 of the FALPR should be amended to read as follows: “Encourage new development and investment where this will strengthen the town centre as a retail and service centre.” The council’s response 2.3 The council notes that Arbroath is the largest town in Angus and has a range of retail and other facilities, not necessarily in the town centre, such as the retail warehouse