Fortifying Saint Cloud: Searching for Fort Holes Charles Peliska St
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
St. Cloud State University theRepository at St. Cloud State Culminating Projects in Cultural Resource Department of Anthropology Management 5-2018 Fortifying Saint Cloud: Searching for Fort Holes Charles Peliska St. Cloud State University Follow this and additional works at: https://repository.stcloudstate.edu/crm_etds Part of the Archaeological Anthropology Commons Recommended Citation Peliska, Charles, "Fortifying Saint Cloud: Searching for Fort Holes" (2018). Culminating Projects in Cultural Resource Management. 20. https://repository.stcloudstate.edu/crm_etds/20 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Department of Anthropology at theRepository at St. Cloud State. It has been accepted for inclusion in Culminating Projects in Cultural Resource Management by an authorized administrator of theRepository at St. Cloud State. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Fortifying Saint Cloud: Searching for Fort Holes by Charles Joseph Peliska A Thesis Submitted to the Graduate Faculty of St. Cloud State University in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Master of Science in Cultural Resources Management May, 2018 Thesis Committee: Rob Mann, Chairperson Debra Gold Mark Muniz 2 Abstract This thesis is about my efforts to locate Fort Holes – a civilian fortification built in September of 1862 in response to the nearby threats of Native American violence. A decade after the western parts of Minnesota were opened to Euro-American settlement, the actions of government agents, traders, and a small group of Native American actors led to violence on the frontier. The citizens of Saint Cloud constructed Fort Holes in a week and it only stood for a couple of years before they removed the lumber for the growing city. Throughout Minnesota, citizens constructed over 50 of these expedient “settlers’ forts,” sometimes in as little as 24 hours. As of 2014, none of these forts from the U.S. – Dakota War of 1862 had been examined archaeologically. In the summer of 2015, I began work on studying Fort Holes. The project included archival research, a gradiometer survey, and a targeted shovel test survey based on the results of the gradiometer survey to identify archaeological features or artifacts associated with the fort. The artifacts of that excavation were then cleaned, analyzed, and inventoried. While no definitive features or artifacts were found, the archival resources, as well as the gradiometer results show that this is likely the location of the fort, and larger excavations may reveal features missed in this project. 3 Acknowledgements I would like to thank my wife Katie; my family; Dr. Mann, Dr. Gold, Dr. Wingerd, Dr. Muñiz, Jennifer Howland, and all the faculty, staff, and community at Saint Cloud State University; the staff of the Stearns History Museum; and all of my fellow graduate students and members of the public that came and helped with the excavation. I would also like to thank the Minnesota Arts and Cultural Heritage Fund for a grant to perform the geophysical survey. 4 The Road goes ever on and on Down from the Door where it began… (J.R.R. Tolkien – The Fellowship of the Ring) 5 Table of Contents Page List of Figures .........................................................................................................................6 Chapter I: Research Questions ............................................................................................................9 II: Historical Background ......................................................................................................13 A Brief History of Central Minnesota .....................................................................15 Saint Cloud ..................................................................................................................22 Conflicts Both Home and Abroad ...........................................................................30 III: Fortifications of Stearns County and St. Cloud ...........................................................44 IV: Investigations ...................................................................................................................56 V: Analysis ...........................................................................................................................68 Land Use After Fort Holes ........................................................................................82 Landform and Soils Analysis ...................................................................................87 VI: Interpretations and Conclusion .....................................................................................99 Works Cited ...........................................................................................................................105 Appendix A: Fort Holes Project Inventory ........................................................................109 Appendix B: Artifact Distribution .......................................................................................124 6 List of Figures Figure Page 1: Google Earth Image of Area of Interest ..........................................................................10 2: Google Earth Image of Area of Interest with Circles Representing Dimensions of Fort Holes .........................................................................................10 3: Ojibwe – Dakota Debatable Zone ....................................................................................18 4: Map of Early St. Cloud ......................................................................................................23 5: Mitchell's Commission as Commissary General ...........................................................27 6: Photo of Samuel Holes circa 1862-1863 ...........................................................................48 7: Pullis Illustration of Fort Holes ........................................................................................53 8: Elevation of Fort Holes ......................................................................................................54 9: Fort Holes Topographic and Overview Map .................................................................58 10: From 1950 USGS Topographic Map of St. Cloud, MN ...............................................59 11: Saint Cloud during the Civil War ..................................................................................59 12: Processed Map of Weak Magnetic Features in the South Block ...............................61 13: Preliminary Gradiometer Map .......................................................................................64 14: Final Gradiometer Map ...................................................................................................65 15: Fort Holes Project Map ....................................................................................................66 16: Total Artifact Distribution Map .....................................................................................69 17: Total Artifact Distribution by Type ...............................................................................70 18: STP I-1 South Wall Profile ..............................................................................................72 7 Figure Page 19: Profile of STP I-1 ...............................................................................................................73 20: Profile of STP I-2 Showing Post Hole ............................................................................74 21: STP I-2 West Wall Profile ................................................................................................75 22: STP III-1, Feature 3 ..........................................................................................................76 23: STP III-1 Feature 10 ..........................................................................................................77 24: STP III-1 Profile ................................................................................................................78 25: STP III-2 Feature 9 at 58 cm Below Surface ..................................................................80 26: STP III-2 Feature 9 at 66 cm Below Surface ..................................................................81 27: Map of St. Cloud in 1862 .................................................................................................82 28: 1920 Sanborn Fire Insurance Map .................................................................................83 29: Aerial Photograph circa 1950s Showing Houses in Project Area..............................84 30: 1966 Photograph Showing Campus and Area of Interest ..........................................86 31: 1967 Photograph Showing Campus and Project Area................................................86 32: 1964 Aerial Photograph ...................................................................................................88 33: 2017 Google Earth Image with Overlay of 1964 Ring of Trees from Aerial Photograph ......................................................................................................89 34: Final Gradiometer Map with the Ring of Trees Overlay ...........................................90 35: STP III-1 Showing Fill Layer Outlined in Red .............................................................92 36: STP IV-1 Showing Fill Layer Outlined in Red .............................................................93 37: