Malouf More celebrations of Presser Notre nombril The flashlight at the Sommes-nous moralement supérieurs Wednesday Night end of the tunnel aux Américains? Page 3 Page 18-23 Page 13

Ensemble et libres Together and free

17 FÉVRIER 2011 • VOL. 4, NO 1 THE BILINGUAL JOURNAL OF REFLECTION, OPINION AND THE ARTS • LE JOURNAL BILINGUE DE RÉFLEXION, D’OPINIONS ET DES ARTS WWW.THEMETROPOLITAIN.CA REPRENONS LA RUE TAKING BACK THE STREET PHOTOS P.A. SEVIGNY P.A. PHOTOS Left to right: Westmount MP Marc Garneau, federal Liberal leader’s representative for Quebec, NDG-Lachine MP Marlene Jennings, D’Arcy McGee MNA After weeks of supporting Le Marcheur on St. Denis Street the anti-boycotters managed to take back the streets. Lawrence Bergman, Shefford MNA François Bonnardel, David Ouellet, The Metropolitain editor Beryl Wajsman and Eric Duhaime, columnist and organizer of Reseau liberté Québec. Missing from the picture are Howard Leibman, executive assistant to Mount Royal MP Irwin Cotler who had also arrived to lend support and brought a message from Mr. Cotler who was out of town and community activist Sharon Freedman. Beryl Wajsman Rédacteur et éditeur Éric Duhaime P.A. Sévigny [email protected] [email protected] sé[email protected] Boycott this! Les souliers d’Amir Le boycott sur insi, une partie des puissantes forces "progressives" du e député de Québec solidaire, Amir Khadir, ne fait pas Québec ont décidé de boycotter les produits et les que lancer des souliers. Il les boycotte! St-Denis est un échec Acompagnies israéliens en raisonde « l’apartheid L politique" d'Israël. Simplement de l’hypocrisie et une ruse. Par Au cœur de son comté de Mercier, la boutique Le Marcheur a uand cinq députés fédéraux, les chefs du PQ et du leurs mots et leurs actions elle a démontré, en folie et en honte, pignon sur la rue St-Denis depuis 25 ans. Yves Archambault y Bloc québécois et un nombre de plus en plus le vrai visage de cette partie de la société « civile » du Québec vend des chaussures venues des quatre coins du monde. Le 2 Qimportant de députés provinciaux condamnent vos qui tout en déclarant hardiment sa propre « différence », est octobre dernier, Monsieur Archambault reçoit une «mise en manifestations hebdomadaires comme étant « … totalement vraiment hanté par un doute de soi-même poussé par une demeure» d’une organisation radicale de gauche qui le menace inacceptables dans une société démocratique» vous pourriez jalousie des croyances individuelles des autres. de piqueter devant son commerce pour lancer un appel au envisager de plier les banderoles et de rentrer à la maison. En Un aspect du dernier effort de boycott qui est agréable est la boycott s’il continue de vendre des souliers fabriqués en Israël. date du samedi passé, ce semble être ce qui s'est avéré car les condamnation quasi-unanime de la participation du député de Ces radicaux veulent «faire de la rue St-Denis une zone libre militants de PAJU (Palestiniens et Juifs unis) ne se sont pas Québec Solidaire Amir Khadir dans l’harcèlement d'un d’apartheid israélien». Bref, une grande purge des produits de présentés alors que presque 20 personnes se sont réunis devant individu qu’il est sensé représenter - Yves Archambault - qui l’État juif. Le Marcheur, le magasin de chaussures de la rue St-Denis de

Suite à la page 6 Suite à la page 7 Suite à la page 8 2 THE MÉTROPOLITAIN • 17 FEBRUARY 2011 • VOL. 4, NO 1

WWW.THEMETROPOLITAIN.CA

Ensemble et Libres ~Together and Free Édifice Hermès, Tour A, Suite 155, 1470 rue Peel, Montréal, QC, Canada, H3A 1T1 Tel: 514-759-8541 Fax: 514-759-8544 e-mail: [email protected]

Rédacteur en chef et Éditeur Beryl P. Wajsman Senior Editor Alan Hustak Contributing Editor Brigitte B. Garceau Managing Editor Dan Delmar Rédacteur-adjoint principal Daniel Laprès Coordonnateur, Affaires internationales Leonard Dykler (Paris) Copy & Translations Mike Medeiros Photojournaliste Robert J. Galbraith Editorial Artwork Roy Piperberg, Melissa K. Wheeler Ventes et Marketing Genevieve Maclean, Joseph Mardini IT Director Valeri Prudnikov Webmestre François Charbonneau

Editorial staff Alidor Aucoin, Louise Labrecque, Pierre K. Malouf, Robert Presser, P.A. Sévigny, Sharman Yarnell, Robert Elman, David T. Jones, Mischa Popoff, David Solway

Editorial contributors Rouba Al-Fattal, Alain-Michel Ayache, Germain Belzile, Jean-Charles Chebat, Duff Conacher, Esther Delisle, Graham Dodds, Daniel Dufort, Robert Elman, Fred Eytan, Patrick C. Gagnon, Julius Grey, Rudyard Griffiths, Nancy Hinton, George Jonas, Barbara Kay, David Kilgour, Rémi Landry, Marc Lebuis, Lewis W. Mackenzie, Timothy Mak, Annette Paquot, John Parisella, Andrei Piontkovsky, Daniel Romano, Michael Ross, Francis Tourigny, Thomas R. Velk, Hubert Villeneuve, Albert A. Zbily

Strategic Counsel Charles S. Coffey Letters and Submissions The Métropolitain encourages letters and submissions from our readers in both official languages. SVP envoyer vos textes à:

[email protected] Disclaimer All materials accepted for publication may be subject to editing. The Métropolitain aims to meet the need for original and unconventional thought and opinion on local, national and international affairs. The opinions and views expressed by the contributors to The Métropolitain are strictly their own and do not necessarily represent those of the ownership, its advisors, members or editors. The Métropolitain does not accept responsibility for the views expressed in any letter, article or comment that appears in these pages. It does accept responsibility for giving these submissions the chance to appear. No reproduc- tion is permitted without prior written permission from the Publisher or Deputy Publisher. Any and all reproductions must clearly credit the specific issue, article and author as they originally appeared in The Métropolitain. THE MÉTROPOLITAIN • 17 FÉVRIER 2011 • VOL. 4, NO 1 LA PATRIE 3

Ex-dramaturge, romancier persévérant, essayiste et poète à ses heures, Pierre K. Malouf Pierre K. Malouf fréquente des fédéralistes et des indépendantistes, des gens de gauche et des gens de droite, des LA PATRIE jeunes et des vieux, des écrivains et des ingénieurs. Gentil comme tout, il ne dit pas toujours tout « Brasse-camarade » [email protected] ce qu’il pense, mais pense toujours ce qu’il écrit.

Notre nombril Sommes-nous moralement supérieurs aux Américains ?

imanche, 9 janvier 2011, 17 heures. service des nouvelles de Radio-Canada. Le à le faire à leur place. quand le cancer a accompli son oeuvre ! Les nouvelles à RDI. À quel grand événement du jour nous concerne En réalité, le débat politique est-il plus Il faut quand même nuancer ce que je viens Dévénement Radio-Canada donne-t-il davantage, car il a eu lieu chez nous. De quoi hargneux chez nos voisins du Sud que chez de dire. Au Québec, on ne se promène la priorité ? Choix de réponses : s’agit-il ? Mais du décès de Gaston l’Heureux, nous? Permettez-moi d’en douter. Tous les généralement pas avec une arme à la ceinture 1) la fusillade qui a eu lieu la veille à Tucson. voyons ! béni-oui-oui bien-pensants qui accusent de et encore plus rares sont ceux qui s’en servent Un désaxé du nom de Jared Loughner a assass- Je n’ai rien contre Gaston l’Heureux, homme racisme, de xénophobie, de fanatisme ou de pour tirer dans la foule. Mais il existe quelques iné cinq personnes et en a blessé treize, parmi on ne peut plus respectable qui fut un excellent crétinisme le Tea Party, Sarah Palin ou Bill rares exceptions, qu’il vaut la peine de lesquelles une élue de l’Arizona au Congrès, animateur. Sa mort est un triste événement. O’Reilley, l’animateur vedette du réseau Fox, rappeler. En 1984, à l’Assemblée nationale, Gabrielle Giffords, qui était d’ailleurs sa cible Mais que RDI en fasse la nouvelle du jour, ont-ils oublié les sinistres frasques de notre Denis Lortie fait trois morts et huit blessés. En principale. Une polémique fait déjà rage aux voilà qui est symptomatique du nombrilisme Pierre Falardeau national (Dieu ait son âme), 1989, à Polytechnique, Gamil Gharbi, alias États-Unis. Un grand nombre de commenta- qui afflige les médias québécois. Et qui ne se qui ne poussait pas les indépendantistes à faire Marc Lépine, fait 14 morts, toutes des femmes, teurs « libéraux » accusent la droite manifeste d’ailleurs pas seulement par le choix feu sur l’ennemi fédéraliste, non, mais qui, et 14 blessés, dont 4 hommes. En 1992, à républicaine, et plus particulièrement le Tea des nouvelles et l’ordre dans lesquelles on avec une bassesse qui donnait la nausée, se l’université Concordia, Valérie Fabrikant tue Party et Sarah Palin, d’avoir, par leurs propos nous les présente, mais aussi, je dirais même réjouissait après coup de la mort naturelle d’un quatre collègues et blesse une secrétaire. En incendiaires, provoqué le geste du meurtrier. surtout, dans la manière dont elles sont Claude Ryan, et qui apprenait d’ailleurs à ses 2006, au Collège Dawson, Kimveer Gill tue 2) le soulèvement populaire qui se poursuit traitées. enfants à haïr à la fois les Anglais et les traîtres une étudiante et fait dix-neuf blessés. depuis décembre en Tunisie et qui est à la veille Revenons, par exemple, aux événements de canadiens-français. L’un de ses rejetons l’en Pas mal pour un peuple de seulement sept de provoquer la chute du dictateur Zine el- Tucson. La plupart des commentateurs ont remercia d’ailleurs à ses funérailles. Je dois millions d’habitants! Mais ne dramatisons pas, Abidine Ben Ali au pouvoir depuis 23 ans. repris les bobards de la gauche américaine sans rappeler à ceux qui diront que je fais trop de il s’agit là de cas isolés auxquels il est vain de 3) le référendum qui débute le jour même au plus ample informé et sans le moindre esprit cas de Falardeau, qu’il était le chouchou des vouloir donner un sens. Tous ces assassins Sud-Soudan, et qui est l’aboutissement d’un critique. Joyce Napier, correspondante de médias, que les milieux nationalistes en étaient atteints de délire paranoïaque. Bien sûr, processus qui a débuté en 2002 avec un cessez- Radio-Canada à Washington, nous a livré un faisaient leur icône et que l’ex-premier certaines féministes trouvent encore le moyen le feu qui mettait fin à une guerre civile qui a reportage indigne d’une journaliste profession- ministre du Québec, Bernard Landry (c’est lui de dire que Marc Lépine n’était pas «fou», fait deux millions de morts. En 2005, un nelle. Les mêmes idées courtes ont d’ailleurs qui l’a dit), partageait la plupart de ses idées. mais qu’il s’agissait plutôt d’un idéologue accord de paix accordait au Sud-Soudan une été tartinées par de nombreux reporters et Falardeau n’était pas un marginal. Son triste conséquent, dont elles se sont d’ailleurs hâtées large autonomie. Du 9 au 15 janvier 2011, la commentateurs, entre autres par Richard Hétu exemple fut suivi il y a quelques mois par Le de faire un porte-parole des hommes population doit déterminer si le pays fera de La Presse. Évidemment, ces lancers de Réseau de résistance du Québécois, qui se québécois. Ce délire d’interprétaion propre- sécession ou maintiendra l'union avec le Nord. tartes à la crême ont pour louable conséquence permit, après la mort de Claude Béchard, de ment de chez nous est du même acabit que 4) aucune de ces réponses de nous flatter dans le sens du poil. Tout le faire paraître dans son journal en ligne un celui auquel la gauche américaine s’est livrée Si vous avez répondu 4), bravo ! monde sait que nous sommes moralement forum intitulé « Un de moins », dans lequel après les événements de Tucson. Le Texas, la Tunisie et le Sud-Soudan sont supérieurs aux Étatsuniens, ce peuple de tireurs des fanatiques se félicitaient de la mort d’un Nous n’avons pas de leçon à donner aux des contrées lointaines, les événements qui s’y fous, où les politiciens qui sont trop lâches fédéraliste. Voilà donc en quoi consiste notre Étatsuniens. Notre nombril, que nous aimons déroulent intéressent peu les Québécois, pour presser eux-mêmes sur la gâchette prétendue supériorité morale : attendre, bien tant contempler, est tout aussi crasseux que le surtout s’ils occupent un poste de direction au poussent les plus enragés de leurs concitoyens planqué, que crève l’ennemi et fêter ça ensuite leur.

Ideas before identities. Justice before orthodoxy. 4 LA PATRIE THE MÉTROPOLITAIN • 17 FEBRUARY 2011 • VOL. 4, NO 1 Beryl Wajsman WWW.THEMETROPOLITAIN.CA Editeur et Rédacteur en chef [email protected]

Le rapport Payette Un autre affront à la liberté d'expression

« Je crois qu'il y a plus d'exemples du raccour- manner of prohibitive law and legislation langues officielles. Ou est-ce que c'est à proscrire ons le combat contre l'exécution de ce rapport, cissement de la liberté du peuple par des constricting not only what we may do but who aussi? Nous ne sommes pas certains si des nous a dit qu’il était étonné que la Fédération empiétements progressifs et silencieux par ceux we may be. Now it seeks to control what we may journalistes français pourraient passer l’examen professionnelle des journalistes du Québec avait au pouvoir que par des usurpations violentes et say by controlling who may report it and who onéreux sur la grammaire française du eu des commentaires positifs à propos du soudaines. » - James Madison may express it. A weapon such as this in the gouvernement. rapport. Nous avons répondu que naturellement hands of a government will give it the power to But it is the very notion that the Quebec state ils en auraient. En parlant à quelques membres u-delà d’un an, Dominique Payette, une silence any opposing voice simply by influenc- has the arrogance to think it has a right to control du FPJQ nous avons également entendu la ligne ancien journaliste et maintenant ing the "professional corporation" it gave birth to and invalidate those who practice our most de parti qu'il y avait " trop" de gens qui s'appel- Aprofesseure à l'Université de Montréal, to deny "accreditation." In speaking to several essential freedom that is so objectionable. We lent des journalistes et essayent d'entrer dans des a été mandatée par la Ministre de la culture leading constitutional lawyers they could think of cannot blame Payette alone. In her mandate, the conférences de presse et des galeries de presse Christine St-Pierre pour étudier des façons dont only one other jurisdiction in the free world that Minister made reference to the necessity for this législatives. Nous avons entendu l'objection aux les médias dans les régions du Québec et les had proposed such a comparable draconian study because of the "general crises of media in bloggeurs et aux auteurs des médias sur Internet. médias indépendantes dans les villes pourraient control. That place is Hungary, where prosecu- industrialized countries." What crises? Too much Ce qui est triste est qu’aux États-Unis les être aidés à l’ère des nouvelles technologies. Son tions of writers are actually taking place. What free expression? Is there a fear that some brave journalistes des journaux Internet comme rapport final, présenté la semaine dernière, est an example to follow. and enterprising writers may actually put some Politico, the Huffington Post et Slate.com sont allé bien au-delà de son mandat. En fait, c'est le Let us look at just two of the more odious dents into the historically revisionist nationalist célébrés, ici ils seront marginalisés. De notre plus grand affront à la liberté d'expression depuis arrows in Payette's quiver. The Quebec Press narrative that has given birth to so many lies that perspective, tout ceci est une tentative de les lois linguistiques. Ça mérite un rejet retentis- Council has a penchant for investigating the most have underpinned our culture wars of the past contrôler l'expression qui vise la protection sant. ludicrous complaints and giving them a serious- four decades? Is there a fear that too much truth d’emplois. Among her fifty-one recommendations are the ness they could never have on their own. This shall out? But of course this is the Minister who Since the American and French revolutions following: mandatory membership by all news newspaper was the victim of a complaint from recently encouraged Quebecers snitching on writers and journalists have been recognized as organizations in the Quebec Press Council; use someone who felt that by publishing pictures of each other in order to enforce the language laws. the fourth estate of government. For centuries, of the state's money power to coerce member- an Arab demonstration downtown where among In speaking to senior members of the Charest those concerns of the people that the legislature ship by withdrawing provincial advertising to all the epitaphs chanted were "Jews are our dogs" administration we were assured that the report will not address and that the judiciary cannot those who will not submit; giving the council - we were inciting hatred against Arabs. The was just being studied and there was no commit- address and that the executive is too busy to now a voluntary organization with only moral complaint did not take issue with the veracity of ment to implement it in whole or in part. We address, have been championed by a free and suasion - sanction power; controlling who is the report. Only with our reporting it. We won hope that is true. Because Payette's statocratic unfettered press. Try and control who is a called a journalist by organizing a professional against that complaint, but not before we had to bias is frightening at times. In one section she journalist and you take the first step to the corporation to control admission and demanding ask the council's officials whether they were clearly states that she favors " a new model of destruction of freedom. Accrediting writers is language testing for all those seeking profes- seriously suggesting that by reporting hate we regulation for the Quebec press." we were not like accrediting who can stand for public office. sional accreditation. "Accredited" journalists were inciting it. They did not know what to aware that there was an old model that regulated At it's best, the fourth estate is the staff of the would be given preference for matters ranging answer. And this organization, so bereft of moral the press. The bedrock of a free society is an innocent and the shield of the just. Destroy that from government information flow to protection compass is to be given more power? Stalin unregulated press. As Orwell wrote, the point of and you start to destroy liberty. Papineau and of sources. would be proud. free expression was the right " to say and write Lafontaine, Cartier and Laurier, Godbout and The report mirrors the past forty years of L'idée d’examens linguistiques pour recevoir those things that infuriate others." What part of Harvey, Trudeau and Levesque - all writers at goose-step conformity and suffocating statist l'accréditation mettrait sûrement fin aux affaires freedom does Mme. Payette and the Minister not one time in their careers - understood this inately. control in this province from it's very title - d’une grande partie des médias ethniques. C’est get? More importantly, what are they afraid of? They believed in the free battleground of ideas. "information in Quebec: a public interest." The le but des médias ethniques. Pour communiquer Un haut gradé du gouvernement Charest avec They must now be turning in their graves at the state has used the term "public interest" for all avec ceux qui n'ont pas encore maîtrisé nos deux qui nous avons parlé, et avisé que nous mèneri- betrayal of their most noble aspirations.

...si le Gouvernement nous protège de tout, qui donc nous protège du gouvernement ?

Citoyens Anti Gouvernement Envahissant ...if the Government protects us from everything else, then who protects us from the government? CAG E Citizens Against Government Encroachment C-10 www.cagecanada.ca THE MÉTROPOLITAIN • 17 FÉVRIER 2011 • VOL. 4, NO 1 LA PATRIE 5 WWW.THEMETROPOLITAIN.CA Dan Delmar [email protected]

Revenge of the nerds

was wrong. Almost exactly two years ago, I wrote in these makes perfect sense because these professionals require Independent Canadian bloggers like Warren Kinsella or Pierre pages that, as a proud journalist, I would be boycotting specific technical knowledge.Journalists do not require any Bourque regularly break stories that mainstream media outlets ITwitter and limiting my use of Facebook. I argued at the specific technical knowledge – and journalists know that. That’s miss; in fact, we often get our ideas from writers on the web time that traditional forms of media could remain competitive why so many of them are in favour of government-regulated (don’t tell anyone!). In the US, online media organizations are with social media if they simply fought back andput out a more media; because many know how mediocre and unremarkable more of a force. If the American government even considered entertaining product. interfering with The Drudge Report, Slate.com or The My six-month old Twitter handle, @delmarhasissues, Huffington Post, there would be hell to pay. In Quebec, virtually demonstrates how misguided I was in writing the piece, “Is no one bats an eyelash at the thought of statist media control. journalism dead? I will not be reduced to Twittering for Apart from the inherent problems with government-regulated attention,” and how I underestimatedthe power of nerds. That is press, the Charest government would be angering an increas- to say, those who are the earliest adopters of new technologies; ingly powerful group of organizations with these potential new who have an innate ability to predict how we will be living in regulations. The culture minister would be wise to look to recent the years to come. examples of non-traditional media having an enormous impact I hereby bow to our nerd overlords and embrace that journal- on the political landscape: Wikileaks and the ongoing protests ism and social media can not only coexist, but thrive together. in Arab countries, where much of the word isgetting out through Now, I must warn others. The Charest government could also be social media. underestimating nerds and even making the fatal mistake of Governments who attempt to regulate communication and going to war with them. free speech will undoubtedly face the wrath of the people, if Quebec’s culture and communications minister, Christine St. only because in 2011, it is all too easy to unleash wrath (as I Pierre, ordered last year that a government study be commis- write this, over 700,000 on Facebook are ‘attending’ “A Virtual sioned to look at, among other things, how the independent March of Millions in Solidarity with Egyptian Protestors”). press could cope with new technologies. Université de Montréal Why brave a cold Quebec winter to protest on the streets when journalism and communications professor Dominique Payette you can tweet? Tag your post with #Charest, and he’ll get the was given the job and her sweeping recommendations were message – with more force than if you were waiving a placard released recently. All 51 of them. in front of his office. One highlight – and I use the term with tongue firmly planted Since I wrote my anti-tech rant two years ago, I’ve experi- in cheek– was the suggestion that all media organizations be mented with social media; working inside the nerd universe, required to buy memberships in and be regulated by the Quebec instead of being stubborn and battling against it, has led to Press Council, that oracle of objectivity. . Outlets like The tangible results for the organizations I am associated with. My Métropolitain who refuse to be governed by this needless message to the Charest government: You cannot beat the nerds. regulatory body would be cut off from government advertising they are and that all it takes to replace them is a pulse and an You might as well join them. dollars (not that we’ve ever asked for taxpayer-funded handouts internet connection. It is ludicrous to commission studies with the premise that to begin with). When you're in the business of free speech, having someone somehow government can improve the media landscape. Another is the idea that media people would need to pass a arbitrarily decide what constitutes acceptable conduct can be Media at its core is a reflection of a society and changes should French test in order to be “accredited” by this professional problematic, to say the least. When a journalist crosses the line happen organically, from the people. Government interference association. This couldcome as troubling news for hockey from acceptable criticism into libel, well, we have the courts to could poison media, making it even more beholden to those in commentators and FM disc-jockeys across the province. C’est sort that out – nothing more is needed. Despite the preaching of power. du gros n’importe quoi. media purists and some journalism professors, this profession is The Premier has had a difficult year in media. If government But the recommendation I want to focus on takes aim directly not a science; our work is subjective and creative, thus decided who is a real journalist and who is not, could his at the aforementioned nerds. Payette suggests, in a sense, that extremely difficult, if not downright impossible to regulate. harshest critics be silenced? A far-fetched scenario, perhaps. those who don’t work for these traditional, accredited media Not only is there no consensus on what journalism is, but new But St. Pierre and Payette’s report has left the door wide open organizations cannot be real journalists. She wants to see these media innovations are raising questions on who journalists are. for all kinds of abuses. non-journalists placed at the bottom of the list when trying to And many of the best new journalists fall well outside of Quebecers need to get on Facebook and Twitter and tell their access government information; they would also be excluded traditional parameters. Who are Payette or St. Pierre to government that “Quebec is not China. We demand a free from protection mechanisms in place for their sources. potentially deny them access to information simply because media,#Charest” – all in a nerd-friendly 53 characters. Doctors, lawyers, pharmacists...virtually all professions have they practice their craft on the internet or don't have the buying Delmar @ Night airs weeknights on CJAD 800 in Montreal some sort of regulatory body or professional association. That power to join the Press Council? and www.cjad.com.

the metrontario group 6 LA PATRIE THE MÉTROPOLITAIN • 17 FEBRUARY 2011 • VOL. 4, NO 1 Beryl Wajsman WWW.THEMETROPOLITAIN.CA Editeur et Rédacteur en chef [email protected]

BOYCOTT THIS! SUITE DE LA PAGE 1

possède un magasin de chaussuresnommé Le PAJU. Well, boycott this PAJU! Sud visaient la ségrégation, la marginalisation denounced Palestinian violence and hate. For Marcheur et qui a la « témérité » de vendre des Arabs inside Israel have complete civil rights et l’annulation de sa population noire. L'Israël the sake of the credibility of Quebec's true chaussures israéliennes. Peut-être les voix plus including the recognition of Arabic as an est en Cisjordanie seulement parce qu'elle s'est progressives, it is time to hear this message out raisonnables de la société civile du Québec official language. There are Arab judges, défendue contre des guerres d'agression de ses in the open, clearly proclaimed and candidly devraient maintenant se concentrer sur la CSN diplomats and some 15 members of Parliament voisins arabes. Il n'y a aucune politique de defended. If it is not done, then Quebec's et la CSQ. including several representing parties destruction de la population palestinienne. Tout dream of the "projêt national" will be hijacked This call for a boycott of products and dedicated to the break-up of the State. Jews à fait le contraire. L'Israël toute entière cherche by purveyors of parochial prejudice, like Amir divestiture of investments in Israeli companies still cannot get visas to most Arab countries. is not important in and of itself. Its importance We would also like to remind the CSN and lies in its manifestation of that part of Quebec CSQ that Israel is the only society in the world society that is still caught up in the hypocrisies where more than half its population is affili- of petty narcissisms and the prejudices of its ated with unions. In most of the Arab Middle own narrow particularities. And how petty the East union leaders are routinely harassed, L'Israël est en Cisjordanie seulement parce qu'elle s'est narcissisms are. These groups start boycotting beaten up and sometimes killed. Israeli consumer goods and then want to move Except for the right to vote, Palestinians défendue contre des guerres d'agression de ses voisins arabes. on to companies such as Caterpillar that, living on the West Bank have - in law -many besides tractors, sells boots, caps, toys and of the same equity rights. And yes, far too Il n'y a aucune politique de destruction de la population palesti- pocketknives to Israel. In other words nothing many cases where rights have been abrogated that would really cause the boycotters any by individual Israeli officials. There are nienne. Tout à fait le contraire. L'Israël toute entière cherche sa discomfort. problems there. But hardly of the type to justify The cell phone was developed in Israel by the use of the word apartheid. Israel has reconnaissance et la paix de sorte qu'elle puisse seretirer. Israelis working in the Israeli branch of extended full medical, educational and social Motorola. Most of the Windows NT and XP services to the Palestinian population. The operating systems were developed by infant mortality rate, as well as the rate of those Microsoft-Israel. The Pentium microprocessor finishing high school is the highestamoung was made in Israel. Voice mail technology was Arab societies in the Middle East. Some 30% developed in Israel. So our suggestion is that of the student body of Hebrew University is sa reconnaissance et la paix de sorte qu'elle Khadir, rather than led by those loyal to the these"progressives" first cause themselves a Palestinian . Israel not only subsidizes social puisse seretirer. doctrines of social democracy and truth. little discomfort and refrain from using all services – including Palestinian universities – it Several years ago, at the first ever conference Martin Luther King a dit : « Une société these instruments that allow them to dissemi- has also helped to get the Palestinian Authority between leaders of Quebec civil society and commence à mourir quand elle demeure nate their disinformation and propaganda. But on its feet by fully outfitting its police force Israeli diplomats - sponsored by the Institute silencieuse envers l’injustice ». Au Québec, no, that would be too inconvenient for them. including the supply of some 150,000 for Public Affairs of Montreal - FTQ President aujourd'hui,résolvons de ne pas rester They want their cake and they want to eat it weapons. Henri Massé said that he saw nothing to silencieux quand nous entendons des too. Particularly those pseudo-intellectuals in Les politiques de l’apartheid en Afrique du condemn in Israel's policies and vehemently mensonges déguisés en vérité. THE MÉTROPOLITAIN • 17 FÉVRIER 2011 • VOL. 4, NO 1 LA PATRIE 7

WWW.THEMETROPOLITAIN.CA Éric Duhaime possède près de 20 ans d¹expérience comme conseiller politique à Ottawa et à Québec et comme consultant Éric Duhaime international en développement démocratique. [email protected] Il est co-fondateur du Reseau Liberté-Québec.

LES SOULIERS D’AMIR, SUITE DE LA PAGE 1

Même s’il n’est pas juif et que les communiste du Canada. LONGUE LISTE En septembre dernier, Khadir avant que la population déchante et souliers israéliens Beautifeel POSITIONS RADICALES À la suite des attentats du 11 participe à la commémoration des cesse de faire d’Amir Khadir le représentent moins de 2% de ses Un député, payé par vos taxes, septembre revendiqués par al-Qaïda, martyrs de la résistance libanaise du politicien le plus populaire au ventes, Monsieur Archambault refuse s’efforce de nuire à un simple Khadir évoquait la possibilité d’un Hezbollah. Québec? de céder au chantage. Il vend ces commerçant de sa circonscription qui complot de la CIA. À l’Assemblée nationale, Khadir En attendant, combattons sa chaussures de bonne qualité depuis vend légalement des produits venant En 2006, en plein conflit armé initié multiplie les interventions pour campagne d’intimidation en allant plus de 15 ans. Apolitique, il refuse d’un pays avec lequel le Canada a une par le Hezbollah, Khadir était le seul dénoncer la seule démocratie du magasiner chez Monsieur qu’une poignée d’idéologues entente de libre-échange et le Québec politicien à ne condamner qu’Israël Moyen-Orient sans jamais une seule Archambault samedi après-midi. extrémistes lui dictent ce qu’il peut des accords de coopération. sans dire un mot contre le Hezbollah. fois condamner les organisations Votons avec nos pieds en achetant vendre. De son activisme pour un groupe En mars dernier, Khadir reçoit à terroristes islamistes, ni les tyrannies des chaussures. Nous vaincrons le Depuis, tous les samedis, aux «islamo-marxiste» classé terroriste à l’Assemblée nationale Jamal Zahalka, du monde arabe. terrorisme économique de Khadir meilleures heures de vente, une son soutien public pour George leader politique israélo-arabe prônant Combien de Monsieur une paire de souliers à la fois. dizaine d’activistes obstruent l’entrée Galloway, propagandiste payé par la la dissolution d’Israël. Archambault devront être terrorisés © Journal de Montréal de son magasin avec des affiches anti- télé d’état iranienne, Khadir n’en est

Un député, payé par vos taxes, s’efforce de nuire à un simple commerçant de sa circons- cription qui vend légalement des produits venant d’un pays avec lequel le Canada a une entente de libre-échange et le Québec des accords de coopération.

Israël, distribuent des tracts qui pas à sa première controverse avec ses appellent au boycott de la boutique et positions extrémistes sur les questions apostrophent les clients. du Moyen-Orient. Surprise samedi dernier: Amir Musulman non-pratiquant, Khadir Khadir s’est joint aux manifestants, ne soutient pas certaines causes en compagnie de ses camarades Jafar islamistes par conviction religieuse, Khadir, ex-membre du Comité mais participe plutôt à l’alliance central du Parti communiste du «anti-impérialiste» entre l’extrême- Québec, et William Sloan, membre gauche et les islamistes qui se forge du comité central du Parti partout en Occident. 8 LA PATRIE THE MÉTROPOLITAIN • 17 FEBRUARY 2011 • VOL. 4, NO 1 P.A. Sévigny WWW.THEMETROPOLITAIN.CA [email protected]

LE BOYCOTT SUR ST-DENIS EST UNE ÉCHEC, SUITE DE LA PAGE 1

Yves Archambault, pour démontrer leur fédéral de Mont-Royal Irwin Cotler. Après PAJU avait également fait face à l'embarras Après quatre mois de manifestations soutien au droit de l'homme d'affaires de la rue que le député conservateur Steven Blaney a dans une manifestation récente quand un intermittentes, Archambault perd rapidement St-Denis de gérer sa propre entreprise et ont condamné le boycott comme du « … terror- manifestant de PAJU - devant les leaders de la la patience avec le théâtre de rue devant son repris la rue. Une victoire après presque treize isme économique », le chef du Bloc québécois coalition anti-boycott Éric Duhaim, Beryl magasin. Bien qu'il soit reconnaissant de tout semaines. Les partisans du magasin avaient Gilles Duceppe a suivi avec sa propre lettre Wajsman et David Ouellette - a commencé à l'appui qu'il a reçu au cours des dernières repris la rue et les boycotteurs de gauche et dans laquelle il a dit que le boycott (avec une crier des insultes racistes à Tshibain semaines, il a dit au The Metropolitain qu’il pro-Palestiniens n’étaient pas présents. Une autre série récente d'incidents antisémitiques) Tshibungu, un nouveau immigré au Canada n’arrive pas encore à comprendre pourquoi ils victoire pour la liberté du commerce et le droit d'être laissé en paix. « C'est une question de principe », a dit Normand Guay pendant qu'il quittait le magasin avec sa nouvelle paire de chaussures. « Ce type a le droit de gérer sa propre entreprise sans qu’on lui dise ce qu'il devrait Après quatre mois de manifestations intermittentes, ou ne devrait pas faire. » Après le gros titre du dimanche précédent quand Le Journal de Montréal a publié une Archambault perd rapidement la patience avec le photo en première page montrant la députée de NDG Marlene Jennings essayant une paire de chaussures dans le magasin d'Archambault, un nombre de plus en plus important de théâtre de rue devant son magasin. députés fédéraux et provinciaux et de person- nalités assorties des médias utilisent la manif sur St-Denis comme une occasion fait sur mesure pour démontrer leur soutien au milieu des affaires infortuné de la ville. Indépendamment du samedi quand Jennings n'a aucune place dans la société ouverte et originaire du Congo. [les militants de PAJU] considèrent son et le député libéral fédéral de Westmount Marc démocratique du Québec. Dans une lettre « Que fais-tu ici ? », a-t-il crié. « Ta peau magasin un endroit approprié pour une Garneau sont venus pour acheter quelques adressée à Adam Atlas, le président du n'est même pas blanche comme la mienne. » discussion au sujet de la politique du Moyen- chaussures, plusieurs informations rapportent Congrès juif québécois, Duceppe mentionne « Qu’est-ce que la couleur de ma peau à Orient que Benoît Dutrizac, l’animateur populaire de que le boycott est « … totalement inaccept- avoir avec le droit de cet homme « Peut importe ce qui arrive, » a dit radio de Montréal, est venu au magasin afin able dans une société démocratique », et s’est [Archambault] de gérer son entreprise sans Archambault, « … je ne laisserai toujours pas de s'acheter une paire de chaussures de même assuré qu'une copie soit envoyée à que des gens lui disent quoi faire? », a quiconque me dire ce que je peux ou ne peux que l’ancien ministre de la justice et député Archambault. demandé Tshibungu. pas vendre dans mon magasin. » THE VOLUNTEER The riveting story of a Canadian who served as a senior officer in Israel’s legendary Mossad. For seven-and-a-half years, Ross worked as an undercover agent — a classic spy. In The Volunteer, he describes his role in missions to foil attempts by Syria, Libya, and Iran to acquire advanced weapons technology. He tells of his part in the capture of three senior al Qaeda operatives who mas- terminded the 1998 attacks on American embassies in Kenya and Tanzania; a joint Mossad-FBI operation that uncovered a senior Hezbollah terrorist based in the United States; and a mission to South Africa in which he intercepted Iranian agents seeking to expand their country’s military arsenal; and two-and-a-half years as Mossad’s Counterterrorism Liaison Officer to the CIA and FBI. Many of the operations Ross describes have never before been revealed to the public. THE MÉTROPOLITAIN • 17 FÉVRIER 2011 • VOL. 4, NO 1 LA PATRIE 9

WWW.THEMETROPOLITAIN.CA David Solway is the award-winning author of over twenty-five books of poetry, criticism, educational theory, and travel. He is a contributor to magazines as varied as the Atlantic, David Solway the Sewanee Review, Books in Canada, and the Partisan Review. His most recent book is [email protected] The Big Lie: On Terror, Antisemitism, and Identity.

Canada already knows a Muslim Sit-Com is not the answer BS anchor Katie Couric recently went on resolve—whether the fast of Ramadan ends with were planning to blow up buildings and public Nor are institutes like Dar al-Islam merely record deploring the “bigotry” and cucumber sandwiches or goat stew—are transit systems? Where are the so-called Toronto localized phenomena. Lebuis informs us that in C“seething hatred” that Muslims are offensively disingenuous efforts to minimize the 18 who conspired to blow up the Toronto Stock Edmonton, “some public schools offer an Islamic supposed to be facing in the U.S., and proposing a threat of a slickly encroaching Islamic ethos. The Exchange and behead the Canadian prime Studies course to ‘expose’ their students to “Muslim version of the Cosby Show” as a remedy stated intention of Little Mosque’s creator, Zarqa minister? Or Said Namouth involved in an Sharia,” without the slightest “challenging view” to this lamentable situation. Of course, Ms. Nawaz, is to put the “fun back into fundamental- international terrorist plot or Momin Khawaja of what Shari’a entails. The curriculum is Couric’s reading of America’s ostensible anti- ism” and to give people “a sense that Muslims convicted of terrorism-financing operations and “developed by MAC’s representatives in Alberta, Muslim attitude is total nonsense of the sort have so many similarities to non-Muslims…It’s building a remote-control detonating device or and only MAC approved books are being associated with the political delirium of the the same issues, you know, a father and his Montreal resident Ahmed Ressam of the thwarted studied.” The Islamic syllabus is going national. “progressivist” class. The American people on the rebellious teenage daughter…just because you’re LAX strike? This is only an abridged list. The same is true in the U.S. As Robert Spencer, whole are probably among the most tolerant to be Muslim your standards may be a little bit different, Little Mosque on the Prairie is a fable in bad director of Jihad Watch and prolific author on the found anywhere in the world, with the glaring but they’re still the same issues.” taste. (I have just now watched an episode in subject of the history and politics of Islam, points exception of the scandal-mongering left that has One begs to differ, if one must beg at all. Pace which one of the characters flaunts a gleaming out, “the Islamic groups that vet American public falsely donned the egalitarian mantle. Ms. Nawaz, standards tend to be a lot different. razor-sharp box cutter to disembowel a sofa chair. school textbooks…make sure that the Islamic Apart from the sheer absurdity of Ms. Couric’s Muslim daughters have good reason to fear their Have they forgotten so soon?) Canadian viewers instruction in these textbooks presents a picture of suggestion, there is also adramatis personae fathers and brothers who often regard rebellious- who enjoy this program and chuckle at its fusty Islam that is so pristine…it sometimes crosses the problem. Who would such a TV show include ness as a capital offence. The three daughters of and inappropriate humor are in a state of denial or, boundary from mere pro-Muslim bias into among its characters, wonders Abigail Esman in a Muslim-Canadian business man Muhammad in Andrew Bostom’s apt phrase, “Islamically outright Islamic proselytizing.” Spencer contin- FrontPage Magazine article: wannabe Times Shafia, who were found drowned in a car at the perplexed.” But at some point reality must ues: “Of all the arenas in which the stealth jihad is Square bomber Faisal Shahzad, or Farooque bottom of the Rideau Canal near Kingston, intervene. The genuine issue has nothing to do advancing, the most crucial is in our schools, Ahmed who planned to bomb Washington’s Ontario, might attest to the truth that programs like with the canard of “Islamophobia,” which is where stealth jihadists have found a welcoming Metrorail stations, or Nadal Malik Hassan who Little Mosque labor to dissemble. So might 16- nonexistent, or a supposed “backlash” against environment among teachers deeply steeped in slaughtered his fellow soldiers at Ford Hood? But year old Aqsa Parvez, murdered by her father for Muslims, which is frankly undetectable. Media the multicultural ethos.” These credulous or why stop there? How about Dallas resident Yasser Abdel Said who did away with his two teenage daughters for dating unapproved boys? Or Zein Little Mosque on the Prairie is an averting fiction, a fantasy which has no reality outside the heads of multiculti Issa in St. Louis who killed his daughter for dating an African-American? Or Chaudhry Rashid in CBC executives and a politically indifferent audience. True, all sit-coms are averting fantasies and are meant to be Jonesboro, Georgia, who strangled his daughter reassuringly non-controversial. But in cases like this one, the subject is already heavily politicized and bears the for trying to leave an arranged marriage? Or Mohammed Shojaeifard of Roslyn, New York, clear implications of social disquietude, if not outright menace. who shot his estranged wife, mother-in-law and young daughter? To name just a few. Indeed, several of the 9/11 nineteen trained and refusing to wear the hijab, or 20-year-old Khatera entertainment initiatives intended to neutralize partisan pedagogues “present a view of Islam that operated in the U.S. Perhaps some of their Sadiqi gunned down by her brother, along with what does not exist do far more harm than good whitewashes its violent history and intolerant thespian impersonators might make a cameo her fiancé, for the crime of asserting her independ- since they effectively obscure what does. religious imperatives.” We might designate these appearance on the hypothetical al-Cosby show, ence. The real issue, whether in Canada or the United schools as representing the higher sit-com. The trading jokes with the rest of the cast. The comic Little Mosque on the Prairie is an averting States or anywhere in the West, has to do with the Islamic academies go much further, bordering on material would be inexhaustible: honor killings, fiction, a fantasy which has no reality outside the infiltration of Sharia-compliant usages and the status of domestic maddrasas inculcating “an wife beating, polygamy, martyrdoms, dhimmi- heads of multiculti CBC executives and a politi- customs throughout the culture, and especially unequivocal hatred toward non-Muslims and a tude, jizzya, blowing up churches, incinerating cally indifferent audience. True, all sit-coms are with the proliferation of Islamic schools featuring deep suspicion toward Western culture.” buildings, Jew-bashing, slavery, lawfare, paramili- averting fantasies and are meant to be reassuringly a jihadist curriculum, all too often winked at by The sandstorm bearing down on us is no desert tary recruiting—the laughs just keep on coming. non-controversial. But in cases like this one, the our public authorities. For example, the Dar al- mirage. It we do not learn to practice the That should put America at ease and salve Ms. subject is already heavily politicized and bears the Imam school in Montreal sports an affiliation with discipline of political meteorology, we will Couric’s tender soul. clear implications of social disquietude, if not the Muslim Association of Canada (MAC) and eventually find ourselves buried under the Here in the Great White North, we have already outright menace. There are far too many troubling, the Muslim Brotherhood, both jihadist organiza- turbulent changes in the world’s ideological mounted a Muslim-friendly sit-com, courtesy of real-life characters “out there”—convinced tions. According to Marc Lebuis, editor of the climate. Certainly, promoting sit-coms that the left-leaning Canadian Broadcasting jihadists, second-generation extremists, terror website Point de Bascule (Tipping Point) which suppress the Islamic agenda and somnolize the Corporation, called Little Mosque on the Prairie. mentors, fundamentalist preceptors, inflammatory diligently tracks the inroads made by stealth jihad public is not the answer we are looking for. It is filled with babbling pseudo-Muslims who imams, philosophical enablers and practicing and Shari’a advocacy programs in Canada, the Monitoring or closing down Islamic schools that have little in common with their real-world killers—to allow for a calming immunity to the school’s program is anti-Semitic, anti-Gay, anti- indoctrinate Muslim youth in favor of Islamic compatriots. The women on the show are actual. Women, pro-suicide bombing, and endorses noted advances into the heritage culture would be far Westernized females in silky chadors lording it Indeed, were Abigail Esman surveying the Islamic apologists like Salam Elmenyawi, Tariq more useful, as would the defusing of the curricu- over their men like not-so desperate housewives. Canadian scene, she might wonder why certain Ramadan, Yusuf al-Qaradawi, Waleed lar bomb being primed and armed in our own The clean-shaven, jeans-clad, latte-quaffing, prominent Muslim jihadists are nowhere to be Najmedinne and Sheema Khan—the latter Chair mainstream educational system. yuppie imam exists nowhere in Islam. The sort of seen on Little Mosque. Where are Misbahuddin of CAIR-CAN, who believes that Muslims must Sit-coms or no sit-coms, this is no laughing problems which the little community must Ahmed, Hiza Alizadeh and Khurran Sher who “fortify” themselves against Islamophobia. matter. 10 GLOBAL VILLAGE THE MÉTROPOLITAIN • 17 FEBRUARY 2011 • VOL. 4, NO 1

GLOBAL VILLAGE David Jones, co-author of Uneasy Neighbo(u)rs: Canada, the USA and the WWW.THEMETROPOLITAIN.CA David T. Jones Dynamics of State, Industry and Culture, is a former U.S. diplomat who [email protected] served in Ottawa. He now lives in Arlington, Virginia."

New START Had It Easy

n December 22, 2010, the Republic. And this falls into the category of upgrades and to trust that the intima- ing, interagency cleared (and thereby Senate having spent much The rhetoric was over the top; the "trust"-- not the Reganesque "trust tion in the New START preamble time consuming) detail; Otime wailing and gnashing truth, of course, more complicated. but verify" sobriquet that character- that defensive antiballistic missile -- blew off the endorsements by teeth approved the New START New START is a useful follow on to ized the 1987 Intermediate Range systems are not limited. Trusting every living former Secretary of Treaty with Russia. From the the expired START treaty notably Nuclear Forces (INF) treaty. "Trust" Americans is much harder. And State. language, one could have thought its with prospective additional strategic in INF was easy--it was with the trying to nail down an Obama Does the above sound familiar? advocates believed it to be the arms missile reductions and a revived Soviets. "Trust" for New START is commitment is akin to nailingJello Moreover, as was the case for New control's Second Coming (or at least inspection regime. Its problems fall harder--the Republicans need to trust to a wall. START, the Senate demanded the a much accelerated new millennium) into the category of what cannot be a Democratic president and adminis- There really is nothing new under "negotiating record" of the INF while its opponents characterized it known, rather than what specifically tration to implement promised the sun. In 1988, having completed Treaty. This demand was a as a cup of hemlock for the is in the Treaty. nuclear warhead modernization and the INF Treaty with Presidents consequence of an Executive Branch Reagan-Gorbachev signing on claim that it could adjust elements of December 8, 1987, the the 1972 Antiballistic Missile Treaty Administration anticipated rapid based on points discussed during the ratification by the Senate. The negotiations albeit not directly Treaty was widely popular in the reflected in treaty text. After much United States and globally, particu- negotiation over what was to be larly in Europe. It had been part of provided (and diplomatic thrashing Europe/NATO politics for most of a to compile detailed records of decade from painstakingly agreed negotiating sessions), the INF deployments in European basing delegation provided a large safe countries to stop-and-start negotia- filled with material to be seenonly by tions to a comprehensive agreement senators and/or staff with appropriate eliminating all intermediate and security clearances. The upshot? shorter rangeU.S./Soviet missiles Virtually nobody ever accessed the with detailed arrangements for their INF material; it was a political rather destruction and subsequent verifica- than a substantive demand. In tion of their elimination. contrast, the New START delegation But the Democratic controlled stiff-armed the demand for the Senate had no special interest in negotiating record, and it was never making the Republican president provided and thus what may have (and the prospective Republican been discussed about defensive presidential nominee for 1988) look systems remains unknown. good by quickly endorsing a Finally, Senator Nunn battened on Republican drafted/negotiated arms an obscure piece of Treaty language control agreement. (Does this and insisted that its wording would tension between Executive and permit the Soviets to manufacture Congress sound familiar?) SS-20 stages. Absurd, but no So the Senate Democrats decided counter argument could convince the to put its mark on the INF Treaty. senator, so the U.S. negotiators Most didn't want to reject it; after all returned to Geneva to create "arms control" was one of their language to satisfy him. In contrast, political icons, but they wanted to Republican Senator McCain insisted leave the impression that the that New START preamble language Republicans hadn't done that good a noting"…the interrelationship job (and they could have done between strategic offensive arms and better). So they: strategic defensive arms…will -- demanded endless testimony by become more important as strategic a wide variety of senior figures to nuclear arms are reduced…" appear before not just the Senate prejudiced development of the U.S. Foreign Relations and Armed ballistic missile defense program and Services committees but their House should be deleted. Arguing that the analogues; preamble was not legally binding, -- posed quite literally 1,000 the Administration declined to questions regarding the Treaty-- renegotiate the point, leaving the questions with complex, multipart issue unresolved. variants only with ancillary connec- Ultimately, the Senate ratified INF tion to INF but which protocol 93-5, but New START only 71-26, a demanded be answered in painstak- "squeaker" in political terms. THE MÉTROPOLITAIN • 17 FÉVRIER 2011 • VOL. 4, NO 1 GLOBAL VILLAGE 11

WWW.THEMETROPOLITAIN.CA Mischa Popoff is a freelance political writer with a degree in history. He can be heard on Kelowna’s AM 1150 on Friday mornings between Misha Popoff 9 and 10. [email protected]

Haiti and the scandal of The Global Fund our hard-earned tax dollars have been to it immediately. The United Nations Development Program and the U.S. is more of the highly irresponsible pouring into Haiti since the earthquake last And who is it that has pointed to the corruption of (UNDP) distributes the money collected by The military and criminal gang rule that Haitians have Yyear and things have only worsened. Bono’s, Gates’ and Bruni-Sarkozy’s fave charity? Global Fund. It’s an über-liberal UN bureaucracy been subjected to since they were a French colony. Here’s a thought... maybe money and aid aren’t the Some nasty American right-wing think tank? with zero transparency. Nile Gardiner, a senior Second, Haiti needs businesses, lots of ‘em. Only answer. Nope. It was none other than John Parsons, the fellow at the American Heritage Foundation, businesses create jobs. You’d think smart people It is now crystal clear that The Global Fund, inspector general of The Global Fund. He characterizes the UNDP as “a large black hole.” like Bono, Gates and Bruni-Sarkozy might realize although much ballyhooed, is totally corrupt. This is examined just four of the 145 countries that the Can you believe this? People are dying in Haiti and this. After all, they all owe their success to business. the high profile charity that pretends to fight AIDS, fund claims to help and found a whopping $34 surprise! the UN is to blame. Why are Haitians any different? tuberculosis and malaria and which benefits from million had been stolen! Here’s a little tip for the bleeding-heart jet-set: if Liberal bleeding hearts have to learn that you lucrative, high-profile support from the likes of U2 Are these just isolated examples, as the fund’s you see the letters U and N next to each other on can’t “inject” prosperity into people. Prosperity has front-man Bono, Microsoft founder Bill Gates and executive director, Michel Kazatchkine, claims? any of the paperwork for your favorite charity, to be earned, not because it’s the fair way to go, but France’s First Lady Carla Bruni-Sarkozy. The Nope. The really interesting part is that Parsons BAIL the-heck OUT! Hey Bono, Gates and Bruni- because history shows it’s the ONLY way to go. United States and Canada have pledged to give a can’t examine the books of the other 141 projects Sarkozy! I’m talkin’ to you! Even when medicine and food are donated instead whopping $10 billion to this fund for various third- because the countries being helped won’t allow it. Haiti doesn’t need charity. First it needs joint of cash, they’re stolen by Haitian officials, sold on world improvement projects, including Haiti. But if ‘Scuze me? Even the United Nations isn’t this Canadian and American military rule to bring law the black market, and the money all ends up in the fund can’t even keep its own affairs straight, we corrupt. Well folks, hold onto your hats, and wallets, and order. Sound cruel? The alternative to responsi- Swiss bank accounts. You feeling all warm-n’- must demand that our politicians stop contributing because it turns out they are. ble military rule by responsible nations like Canada fuzzy inside yet? Sadly, it's time for some realism. 12 GLOBAL VILLAGE THE MÉTROPOLITAIN • 17 FEBRUARY 2011 • VOL. 4, NO 1

The Hon. David Kilgour is Canada’s former Secretary of State for Asia-Pacific and for WWW.THEMETROPOLITAIN.CA David Kilgour Central & Eastern Europe and the Middle East. He is a tireless international human rights campaigner and has co-authored, with David Matas, the seminal study on the tragedy of [email protected] organ harvesting in China. He is the co-author with David T. Jones of Uneasy Neighbours.

Democracy in the Arab world s more and more Arab countries turn their backs on The experiences of new, emerging, and restored democracies increasingly fearful of another democratic uprising at home. autocracy, Canada can be a key player in encouraging offer lessons for the rest of the world. One of the most There are several initiatives Canada could take to encourage Ademocratic governments to take hold. important is the need for national reconciliation in often democracy in the Arab world. One is to improve our own In the 22 member states of the Arab League, many people difficult transitions – as in the case of South Africa under governance, for instance by improving the dignity of low- now appear to be turning their backs on autocracy, declaring to Nelson Mandela, for example. Those who commit crimes income Canadians. themselves and the world that governance of, by, and for the should be held accountable in courts, and anger must not As well, in future dealings with despots, our government people is a universal value. descend into violence and score-settling. should be clearer about Canadian values, including independ- The end seems closer for democratic window-dressing, pious For members of the Arab League – all with large Muslim ent media, pluralism, an impartial judiciary, and transparent, declarations of good intentions, and unfair elections like the majorities – a major issue in terms of democratic governance accountable, and responsive governance. We should no longer one in Egypt last year, where the governing party’s majority in will be how to apply the direction given in the Qur’an: permit persons connected to authoritarian regimes – such as parliament jumped from 75 to 95 per cent in the first round of voting. Hosni Mubarak reportedly once described the Egyptian army For members of the Arab League – all with large Muslim majorities – a major issue in as democratic because army commanders weighed opinions from their officers before making decisions. How ironic that terms of democratic governance will be how to apply the direction given in the Qur’an: the army’s conduct in the huge popular uprising against Mubarak has thus far been mostly exemplary, with soldiers ''commanding right and forbidding wrong.” marshalling citizens amicably through the street protests in Cairo. ''commanding right and forbidding wrong.” Belhassen Trabelsi, the brother-in-law of ousted Tunisian Egyptians have had enough of tyranny, corruption, and When Indonesia, the largest Muslim democracy, held parlia- president Ben Ali – to become permanent residents of Canada. torture by the interior ministry, and have indicated that the mentary elections in 2009, support for fundamentalist parties We should deliver aid to countries with corrupt governance recent looting was done in part by secret police seeking to declined. Most voters seemed concerned about good only through civil society organizations in the receiving create the impression that, without Mubarak, the country governance, jobs, and economic development. Overall, support country or through international NGOs. Building good would fall into chaos. Why, they ask, do roughly 36 million for fundamentalist parties fell from 39 per cent to 29.5 per cent. governance institutions, including human-rights organizations, Egyptians live on less than a dollar a day? And why are 90 per In the later presidential election, President Susilo Bambang should be a major focus. CIDA is currently disbursing $20 cent of the unemployed under 30 years of age? In terms of Yudhoyono won re-election easily; his strategy of co-opting the million to Egypt and $1.3 million to Tunisia every year. With gender equality, Egypt currently ranks 124 out of 130 nations good governance agenda and launching a wide-ranging anti- the strong likelihood of severe food shortages arising almost surveyed. corruption campaign was well received. Similarly, in immediately in both countries, CIDA should announce a In the Economist’s 2010 democracy index of 167 countries, Malaysia’s 2008 elections, most of the electorate voted for special food relief and deliver it quickly. Egypt ranked 138, Tunisia 144, and Yemen 146. What must the parties that promised good governance. Parties that had purely In essence, what Egyptians, Tunisians, and others in the citizens of the Arab League countries that fared even worse – religious agendas did poorly. Voters, two-thirds of which are Arab world are doing is eschewing the West’s security and Saudi Arabia (160), Libya (158), Djibouti (154), Sudan (151), Muslim, resoundingly rejected the ruling party in four major stability concerns in favour of their own democratic and and the United Arab Emirates (148) – be thinking now? states, despite its attempts to appeal to religious sentiments. development aspirations. Their cries of “Hurriyya” (liberty) Many diverse populations around the world have cast off On Feb. 2, Iran’s Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, who ordered have so far not been accompanied by anti-western ones; tyrants in the past. An estimated 85 of those tyrants were violent attacks on pro-democracy protesters in 2009, claimed instead, many Arab democrats appear to be looking to the toppled by popular protests, and about 62 of the countries in weakly to have encouraged the uprising in Egypt. Independent West for unequivocal support for meaningful democratic question have since become democratic (in the broader sense observers say the common cause for which people are rallying change. of the term), despite some reversals in recent years. is not religion, but democracy, and that the Tehran regime is This article first appeared in themark.com THE MÉTROPOLITAIN • 17 FÉVRIER 2011 • VOL. 4, NO 1 L’ÉCONOMIE 13 WWW.THEMETROPOLITAIN.CA Robert Presser L’ÉCONOMIE [email protected]

The Flashlight at the End of the Tunnel Can we cement a fragile recovery in 2011?

tatistics often mask a reality that is more economic growth. Consumers are facing a host of complex than the numbers. The US has attacks on their pocketbooks for basic staples of a Sbeen in recovery for over a year, yet typical North American existence that could dampen most Americans will tell you that it feels as if it disposable income and therefore slow growth in has not even started. In Canada, our recession 2011. was the mildest of all the industrialized nations Here are the major economic headwinds of yet our mindset is still influenced by the slow 2011 facing North America: recovery of our southern 1)Record prices for basic foodstuffs: The neighbour. Economists in both countries have United Nation’s Food and Agriculture said that employment growth is the key to Organization reported in early January that sustaining the recovery; consumer confidence food prices have spiked to their and, eventually, consumer spending must highest nominal levels since 1990, exceeding be strengthened via income growth Exhibit 1 overall. Those who are already employed need Continued on page 14 to have more disposable income in order to lost over 8 million jobs during their two year increase household spending and those who recession and have only added back just over 1 successfully return to the workforce must re- million workers. Canada, in contrast, lost only initiate their normal spending levels. Increased 400,000 jobs during its 9 month recession and consumer spending and confidence are self-re- has added back almost all of enforcing and given that consumer spending is those. Indeed, Canada is poised to outstrip the now 65% of all North American economic U.S. in relative job growth in 2011. activity, there can be no sustained recovery Exhibit 1: Canada vs. U.S. monthly unemployment rate without a growing workforce. (percent) seasonally adjusted data Throughout 2010 most corporations rebuilt Data sources (seasonally adjusted): Statistics their profitability without rehiring workers, Canada and U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics seeking profits through higher (Department of Labor). / Chart: CanaData - Reed productivity. That trick has to come to an end Construction Data. as eventually companies realize that they need For full-time workers the only way to increase their to expand their workforces to sustain the spending power is via wage hikes, and exhibit 2 supply of good and services. We finally saw looks at the relationship between U.S. wage companies start hiring in earnest in the last increases and spending growth over nearly 20 quarter and now both the US and Canadian years. The correlation is remarkable; with 4% real economies are creating jobs consistent with wage growth in 2010, there is more income their long term monthly averages. available to be spent – but that money may be The U.S. has a lot of catching up to do – they sucked up by expenditures that do not promote

Mutant Mad Cow Disease in Toronto. Murder in Palm Beach. The arcana of Bermuda offshore banking. Ex-CIA and Mossad men desperate to seize a weapon of mass destruction from Al-Qaeda, off the Caymans, on the morning of 9/11. Oh, and love. What more could you ask for in this hard-cover thriller by Robert Landori. Get it at Chapters/Indigo, or order an author-signed copy from the publisher.

Dear Studio 9, please rush me____author-signed copies of Fatal Greed at $39.00 each (including tax and postage). My cheque is enclosed. Or, I choose to pay by Visa Mastercard Amex (please circle one) Mail or fax to: 514-937-8765 Card number ...... exp ...... Name ...... Address ...... City/Postal Code/Prov.-State ......

Studio 9, 9 Parkside Place, Montreal, QC, Canada H3H 1A7 Phone orders: 514-934-5433 14 L’ÉCONOMIE THE MÉTROPOLITAIN • 17 FEBRUARY 2011 • VOL. 4, NO 1

WWW.THEMETROPOLITAIN.CA

THE FLASHLIGHT AT THE END OF THE TUNNEL, CONTINUED FROM PAGE 13

the previous high set in 2008. Food prices are prices. After falling during the recession, US Congress that maintains the Bush-era tax at record levels in 61 countries, and a return to Chinese prices are rising not only because of cuts for two more years with no significant Employment growth is food riots is a virtual certainty in the develop- gradual Yuan appreciation but also because of spending reductions – that game will also ing world in countries where current inflationary pressures (wages and input costs) come to an end soon, and Americans will start the key to sustaining government subsidies are unsustainable. For within the Chinese economy. The era of cheap to pay to close the federal deficit as well. the North American consumer, foods made Chinese manufacturing is coming to an end due 5)An international crisis ignored so far – with wheat, rice, corn and sugar are going up, to internal structural changes in their economy Pakistan: Not enough people are talking about the recovery; consumer as are other staples like coffee. Consumers and the effect will be amplified by a rising the assassination of Punjab provincial governor may end up having to spend what they thought Yuan, forcing consumers to suddenly start SalmanTaseer who opposed his country’s confidence and, was discretionary income on the basic necessi- ties of their daily existence. 2)Sustained higher oil prices: While we may eventually, consumer not see the record $145 per barrel price of late 2008, it is likely that a $100 barrel will spending must translate into $4 per gallon gas across many regions of the US and sustain $1.30 per litre in be strengthened via Canada. Those who recall the onset of the financial crisis in October 2008 will remember that it coincided with record high gas prices, income growth overall. leading many who were faced with refinancing their homes at that time with the stark choice of either paying their mortgage or gassing up the car to go to work. Oil is also an important factor in food transportation and therefore has a instability is downplayed on purpose in the double effect on consumers – in their cars and popular media because those in charge think at the dinner table. If consumers spend their that the situation is too complicated to explain extra income on transportation, then they to a population base ignorant of international cannot spend it at Wal-Mart or Target. affairs. Imagine the challenge our news editors 3)Chinese Yuan appreciation: Referring to are going to face when they have to educate Wal-Mart and Target, a lot of paying more for goods for which they received radical anti-blasphemy laws, which made him everyone on how Pakistan became a problem those products from toys to knock-down only price cuts in previous years. a liberal politician in an increasingly radical- so “quickly” and why we were not told sooner. furniture come to us from China. Consumers 4) Taxes, taxes, taxes: At least 10 US states ized society. The gradual disintegration of Every economic recovery faces challenges, have benefitted from almost 30 years of falling and one Canadian province (Ontario) are in Pakistan reminds me of the slow decomposi- whether economic or political. In the case of prices on a wide range of goods due to the ever- such dire fiscal shape that taxes will have to tion of the Austro-Hungarian and Ottoman the current recovery from the Great Recession, increasing economies of scale afforded to us via rise substantially to fill the deficit gap. Illinois empires between 1848 and 1914 – it happened we did not collectively address many of the Chinese industrialization. In short, the Chinese was one of the first to take the plunge by in small incremental steps, ever weakening the structural economic and, indeed, social made itcheaper and the savings were passed on hiking the state tax rate from 3% to 5% to fill fabric of their governments and societies until problems it exposed. We papered them over to us; we bought these goods with debt and then an expected deficit of 40% of their state a war was unleashed and they imploded. The with cheap government money and hoped for the Chinese invested their profits in the debt budget. Measures such as these will become danger today is that we cannot afford to let the best, that a future government, or indeed, a that we issued to them. It was a good game the norm as states slash spending and raise Pakistan become a failed state, not only future generation, would solve until our debt got out of hand and now the revenues to compensate for the massive because it has nuclear weapons but also them. Procrastination is not absolution, not goods are going to get more expensive. Some compression of their tax bases following the because of the size of its population, its critical given the magnitude of what we have prover- economists estimate that the Yuan is underval- recession. Ontario’s go-slow attitude towards geopolitical positioning and the utter impossi- bially swept under the rug. Our job-based ued by up to 40%; most agree that an reducing its $20 billion CAD annual deficits is bility of occupying its territory to put it back recovery will continue only as long as the appreciation of at least 20% is inevitable in going to make it the top debtor province before together. North Americans need to be problems described above remain simmering order to address significant international trade long and will make Quebec look like a fiscal concerned because the outbreak of a civil or and do not froth over. The chance of all five of imbalances that have been created by having tightwad – their taxes are going up as well, but regional war in Pakistan would certainly these issues remaining contained is not the Yuan linked to a falling US Dollar. not before this year’s provincial involve India, possibly China, coalition forces high, but we can probably deal with them Referring to the two graphs representingthe election. Employers will increase salaries only in Afghanistan and the Russians. It would individually without throwing the recovery off US-Chinese trading relationship, Chinese to see those extra funds transferred to the local disrupt world trade and most likely cause a track. If two or three become critical concur- exports to the US have recovered but the rising authorities. Note that this scenario does not double-dip recession in the West as consumers rently then we can expect the recovery to come value of the Yuan is an increasing threat to consider the tax deal recently concluded in the close their wallets out of fear. Pakistan’s to an abrupt end.

Ideas before identities. Justice before orthodoxy. THE MÉTROPOLITAIN • 17 FÉVRIER 2011 • VOL. 4, NO 1 SOCIETY 15

WWW.THEMETROPOLITAIN.CA George Jonas is a Canadian journalist, SOCIETY who has also written novels, plays, and George Jonas poetry. [email protected]

The imperative of individualism

hen I was 10, a rusty mastiff coin. A call for individual responsibility: “Ask Sports come in two kinds, gladiatorial and als, contrary to the stereotype cultivated by our followed me home from the not what your country can do for you — ask athletic. Both require skill, endurance, and risk-averse society. Wplayground. It accepted a dish of what you can do for yourself!” would have determination, but gladiatorial sports routinely Take seat belts. Responsible risk-takers had liver from my mother, then curled up in front impressed me more. involve mortal risk as well. In gladiatorial them installed in their cars long before anyone of my bed. Whenever my parents approached, Such a call would have cut against the grain sports, failure doesn’t translate into the loss of obliged them — I did in the early 1960s — but it raised its massive head and growled. of the times, though. People doing things for points on a scoreboard but the loss of one’s this didn’t make mandating seat-belt use less I felt flattered. The dog had a collar but no themselves were the last thing governments life, at least potentially. intrusive. Seat belts save lives that seat-belt tag. “Can I keep it?” I asked my father. wanted. As the 1950s receded, modern welfare Skiers, mountaineers, speed contestants, and laws demean. That’s simple enough — but it’s “If that were a real question,” my father states started recognizing everywhere what a aviators are among those who engage in unfortunate that some people protest Big replied, “my answer might be yes. But you and treasure irresponsible and dependent people gladiatorial sports. Their performance is Nurse’s intrusion by choosing the worst of I know that what you’re actually asking is: Will were to them. Dysfunctional citizens were a usually measured by a stopwatch rather than both worlds. They refuse to put on their seat you, dear parents, keep a dog for me? Feed it, master key in the hands of the official bureau- opinion, and their worst penalties are assessed belts — until they see a policeman. walk it, groom it, muzzle it? And the answer to cracy, the new ruling class. They could open not by a referee but by gravity. The laws of Unwise. It’s not just cutting off your nose to that is no.” every private door that the responsible and the physics are unforgiving but fair. They consider spite your face but risking your life without Considering the rusty beast sucked down independent had locked, turning a man’s house no one’s gender or religion. Friction acts making a point. A responsible civil libertarian more liver at one sitting than my weekly from a man’s castle into the government’s equally on the privileged and the dispossessed. keeps buckled up. The time to release oneself allowance, Dad was probably right. Letting a theme park. Inertia has never heard about prejudice or from the grip of the nanny-state is when a affirmative action. This understanding often police officer pulls alongside. Do it then — the makes risk-takers highly responsible individu- more ostentatiously, the better. Nowadays, sports are almost alone in defining the concept of “fairness” accurately as one person having the same chance as every other. Competitive sports teach us to expect equality of opportunity, not equality of results. Virtually no other social arena does that anymore. child adopt a dog teaches responsibility, but In officialdom’s daily raids on personal parents adopting a dog for a child teaches only sovereignty, in its oozing takeover of the indulgence. Mostly Mastiff, as father dubbed individual, the irresponsible have become the the liver-guzzler, went to an acquaintance’s battering ram of the state. They provide the farm, where it soon distinguished itself by excuse, the justification, the casus belli for staring down a fox that was after a prize turkey government intrusion. We’re in a period in cock. This act of bravery netted Mostly Mastiff which dependence is patriotic, the role model many Brownie-points, only to lose them a is a snitch, and the ideal citizen a ward of the week later when it gobbled down the gobbler it state. saved. Paradoxically, it’s the recreational world, the Father saw a lesson in this for me, as he did world of sports, the seemingly frivolous in most things. “Any dog sturdy enough to playing fields, that continue to foster a willing stare down a marauding fox is sturdy enough assumption of personal responsibility, along to eat a tom turkey,” he commented. I often with daring, risk-taking and independence. If thought of this in later years while observing athletes, from parachutists to sumo wrestlers, the watchdogs of the state in action. Long share one principle, it’s that there are no before I heard the question “Who is guarding excuses. Unless individuals pull their weight as the guardians?” Mostly Mastiff had answered competitors or members of the team, no one it for me. can (or should) pull it for them. Perhaps this is why President John F. Nowadays, sports are almost alone in Kennedy’s inaugural exhortation to defining the concept of “fairness” accurately Americans: “Ask not what your country can do as one person having the same chance as every for you — ask what you can do for your other. Competitive sports teach us to expect country” never inspired me. States doing equality of opportunity, not equality of results. things for individuals and individuals doing Virtually no other social arena does that things for states seemed two sides of the same anymore. 16 SOCIETY THE MÉTROPOLITAIN • 17 FEBRUARY 2011 • VOL. 4, NO 1 Bill Economou WWW.THEMETROPOLITAIN.CA [email protected]

L'Itineraire

he newsroom at L’Itineraire, magazine remains one of the and encouragedme to pursue my new career path. most unique in Montreal because it is the only one in the I continued writing and working harder, gaining confidence Tcity where you will also find several tables set aside for with each tap of the keyboard. I subsequently also gained more homeless people to eat. That’s because the publication is confidence when it came to dealing with the many people I was published, sold and written by members of Montreal’s homeless encountering on a daily basis. population and serves as a vehicle to help restore their pride while Every month L’Itineraire provides us with subject ideas to write articulating their points of view. about but I have also been able to generate my own ideas most of The magazine is published by a non-profit organization and the time. And it is these articlesthat I feel particularly attached to about 150 people, including myself, sell L’Itineraire in different as they have generated the most positive feedback. One entitled locations across the island of Montreal. Each vendor is assigned at “The value of a friend”, as well as another called “Honesty least one or two locations to sell. A number of us can also be found counts” received particularly favourable reviews from my clients. in métro stations. In fact, on one occasion a Montreal-area teacher came over to I will soon be celebrating a small milestone as March 22nd will shake my hand at the market and told me that he had read my mark my 5 year anniversary of selling L’Itineraire. I still article to his students in the classroomand that it received positive remember March 22nd 2006, the first day I started working at the the pleasure of meeting many friendly and interesting people who feedback. Atwater Market selling the magazine. It was a bit of an inauspi- offered me a friendly ear before purchasing a copy. I worked three The next time you visit Atwater Market there is a good chance cious debut. I bought a few copies and was given a few extra consecutive winters outside in the cold selling the magazine. you will see me asI currently still work there five days a week. I copies for free to get me started. However I did not last long that December has always been my best month and I try to work as still enjoy chatting with merchants and supplying them with day. In fact, I was so discouraged I did not return until Easter many days aspossible. It was quite a relief when I was eventually change. Many people are used to me being there and are loyal weekend when the weather turned milder. This time, Mother given permission to sell the magazine indoors. customers - I know many on a first-name basis. Nature seemed to be smiling down on me as I was able to sell as I continued working at different sites in and around the market. Some people working at the market buy the magazine regularly many magazines as I had I had brought with me. However my successful experiences selling the magazine soon and I’m proud to say I remain one of our top sellers. I soon also realized that due to the high volume of people who awakened a new fire inside of me as I sought to expand my I have truly enjoyed working in the Atwater Market and I love frequent the market it remained a location that was worth frequent- horizons by also writing articles for L’Itineraire. the atmosphere. It feels great to help the homeless people of ing on a regular basis. So much so, that I started working there I am proud to say that five months after I started selling the Montreal as well as the entire L’Itineraire organization over these three days a week. I became a regular fixture and throughout the magazine through rain, sleet and snow I had my first article past five years. year I continued uttering my sales pitch, “Journal de la rue pour published. Soon after my articles started appearing every month. I want to continue doing my job as working hard and honestly aidez les sans abris, street paper to help the homeless”. Sometimes It was an extremely valorizing experience to see my name and provide great rewards. This has truly been an eye-opening experi- my words fell on deaf ears with disinterested people passing me by words in print. Eventually some of the people I met at Atwater ence that has also allowed me to gain a new understanding and and seemingly looking straight through me while other times I had Market would stop to tell me that they had enjoyed my articles appreciation of the true powers of the printed word. THE MÉTROPOLITAIN • 17 FÉVRIER 2011 • VOL. 4, NO 1 SOCIETY 17

WWW.THEMETROPOLITAIN.CA Rev. John Vaudry is a Presbyterian minister, pastor of Cote des Neiges Rev. John Vaudry Presbyterian Church, Montreal. [email protected]

It Can Happen Here

merican author Sinclair Lewis, in his chilling 1935 who has studied the Dutch situation first-hand, wrote in La Accuse)—was produced in Germany in 1941 as Nazi novel It Can’t Happen Here, imagines the United Presse in October, 2010 that, “In 2005, in the Netherlands, propaganda. The Nazis had already been practicing euthanasia AStates becoming a fascist state. Doremus Jessop, a doctors intentionally brought about the deaths of over 1,000 for the mentally and physically handicapped. Dr Leo small town Vermont newspaper editor, tries valiantly to warn people without their explicit request or without reporting their Alexander, a psychiatrist who worked with the Office of the his compatriots that what is taking place in Europe in the actions to the authorities.” Chief of Counsel for War Crimes at Nuremburg, stated in 1930s could occur on this side of the Atlantic, but is met with It appears impossible to deny that there was a slope (slippery “Medical Science Under Dictatorship” (New England Journal disbelief—“It can’t happen here.” or otherwise) in Holland, and it is difficult to see why we in of Medecine, July 1949) that according to the records, some The National Assembly of Quebec’s Select Committee on Quebec would be any different from the Dutch. Is it obvious 275,000 “socially unfit” people were put to death in “killing Dying with Dignity (with the slogan of the pro-euthanasia that we are morally and ethically superior to others? Is human centers” under the Nazis. movement of the last 30 years written into its very title!) has been holding hearings across the province for several months. They have heard a variety of opinions and will soon be faced with the unenviable task of writing their report. Of course, this matter of the care of the sick, the suffering Protestant theologian Karl Barth wrote, “No community, whether family, and the terminally ill is extremely important. Protestant theologian Karl Barth wrote, “No community, whether family, village or state, is really strong if it will not carry its weak and village or state, is really strong if it will not carry its weak and even its even its weakest members…a community which regards its weak members as a hindrance, and even proceeds to their weakest members…a community which regards its weak members as extermination is on the verge of collapse.” Many people feel that mercy-killing (euthanasia) and a hindrance, and even proceeds to their extermination is on the verge of assisted suicide should be legalized. But are these the best options we can come up with? And do we really want to turn our physicians, with a tradition—going back at least to the collapse.” Hippocratic Oath—of being healers, into killers? We are always assured by the proponents of doctor-assisted suicide and euthanasia that such practices would be strictly voluntary. It would always be a matter of the sick person nature here and now somehow radically unlike human nature As ghastly as this was, Alexander observed, it was only the choosing freely to have his or her life ended. in other countries and other times? thin end of the wedge. “The methods used and personnel No doubt, safeguards would be written into the law to Recently, I watched a classic foreign film (subtitles and all) trained in the killing centers for the chronically sick became prevent any abuses. that very sympathetically tells the story of a woman with an the nucleus of the much larger centers in the East, where the As someone who met with the Select Committee, I was incurable debilitating illness who asks her physician husband plan was to kill all Jews and Poles and to cut down the Russian struck by the astonishing naiveté of the several of the to kill her by means of a lethal drug dose. He agrees to her population by 30,000,000.” members who seem to think that voluntaryeuthanasia could request and she dies to soft piano music being played in the Present-day Holland’s practice of euthanasia is, of course, not possibly become involuntary in time. It is well next room. It is a powerful presentation of the case for quite different from that of Nazi Germany, but both are documented that the Netherlands, for example, began by voluntary euthanasia, and it has been used by some in our day examples of societies moving away from respect for the permitting doctors to kill only those patients who wished to to promote the cause of euthanasia and assisted suicide. inviolability of the person, and arriving at the point where die, but eventually came to adopt a lax attitude toward the However, just as you are about to be seduced by the film’s involuntary euthanasia is tolerated. It can’t happen here? God legal safeguards surrounding the practice. Dr Antoine Boivin, message, you remember that this movie—Ich Klage An (I help us if we don’t awaken from our complacent slumbers. 18 SOCIETY THE MÉTROPOLITAIN • 17 FEBRUARY 2011 • VOL. 4, NO 1

WWW.THEMETROPOLITAIN.CA

Editor’s Note: We received an overwhelming response to our Wednesday Night Celebration edition in the last Met. The following are more tributes to this remarkable institution. More celebrations of Wednesday Nights A tribute to Diana and David Nicholson's Wednesday Nights

Isabelle Ramsay-Brackstone Wednesday Night’s is where this happens. Where true ensure that the right connections between the invites are made Paget, Bermuda “thinking outside the box” takes place. Not your typical ”You and that the tone and environment promote great conversa- must think this way” forum, but a true and honest exchange of tions. I met my husband, Kirby Brackstone, at Wednesday The Nicholsons greeted me in their salon for the first time ideas. I cherish the fact that opinions are welcomed and not Night back in 1997. Kirby and I now live in Bermuda, but back in 1996. I was then a graduate student at HEC Montreal, shut down, where you are allowed to argue your point of view always go to Wednesday Nights when we are in Montreal. completing a M.Sc. in International Business. I love debates, and often agree to disagree. It is a place where thinking differ- Diana is Kirby’s Godmother. We sure wish we could be closer sharing ideas, learning about the arts, trade, diplomacy, and ently is celebrated. to be part of their salon more often. politics, among many other subjects. I love going to Wednesday Nights because I always meet Kirby joins me in wishing David and Diana many more There are few places where civil debates are still allowed, fascinating characters, find business relationships, and more years of fascinating Wednesday Nights. May love, health and where ideas are shared and where great minds can meet. importantly develop friendships. David and Diana always peace accompany them every week. They make it relevant Dear Wednesday Nighters Donna Logan David Beigie Founding Director, The School of Journalism University of British Columbia I regret that I was unable to represent my dad Carl at the 1500th gathering. But I wanted to share these words of congratulations as you embark on the next 1500. I had the great, good fortune to meet Diana and David long before they My father enjoyed debate and discussion. And he loved to teach. This was his main currency in life. Wednesday started the Wednesday Night Salon. I already knew they were very special Night provided an ideal setting for all his passions to come together in one place with people he cared about. people. The salon started... I have many fond memories of great sessions and The concept of a salon – while centuries old – couldn’t be more current. At a time when so much is made of meeting a broad, cross-section of incredible people! Then political events social media, I find that the term comes up decidedly short in the “social” department. The challenges and intervened, The Montreal Star, where I toiled, died... I went to Toronto and opportunities facing our nation and world today can’t be meaningfully distilled into short tweets and sound subsequently to Vancouver. Fortunately, I travelled a fair bit and would drop bites. Yet people still try. in on Wednesday nights whenever I could. I was constantly amazed at the It is my view that individuals very soon will set aside notions of relations by keypad and mouse click and return parade of luminaries and intellectuals who came through the door at 33 to actual conversation and in-person engagement. After all, this is what we are put on earth for – to participate in Rosemount. I think if Queen Elizabeth II had walked in, I would not have actual human relations – however graceful or messy. been too, too surprised. The truly amazing part of all this is that Diana and So everything old is new again. And at this mile marker I hope people gathered this evening realize that you are David managed to revive an anachronistic practice and make it relevant to the at once both old-fashioned – and the next big thing! My father would have been pleased to be in the thick of modern world. Having lived in Halifax, Montreal, Toronto and Vancouver, I things with all of you. believe it could not have happened anywhere else in Canada. Best wishes for the future. THE MÉTROPOLITAIN • 17 FÉVRIER 2011 • VOL. 4, NO 1 SOCIETY 19

WWW.THEMETROPOLITAIN.CA

More celebrations of Wednesday Nights Rage, rage into Wednesday Night

Reflections by Felix von Geyer noeticism to any informed debate or opinion. – which as anyone who comes to know her For what is unique to Wednesday Night and They also cover the spectrum of small ‘l’ soon realizes can never be limited to one – is common to all Wednesday Nighters is its “Do not go gentle into that good night, liberalism. Where Leonard Schapiro once the vastness of her social network where she is surrounding bonhomie. Old age should burn and rave at close of day; divided the Rationalists and Nationalists of held with the highest esteem. If invited back for a second time it seems, Rage, rage, against the dying of the light.” 19th century Russia into liberal-conservatives Had she been Shakespeare’s role model for you are always a Wednesday Nighter and (Dylan Thomas) and liberal-radicals; David`s focus is more the nurse in Romeo and Juliet, would an wherever you are when you bump into fellow conventional, markets, finance and who might entirely different play have emerged, avoiding Wednesday Nighters away from the ike the two matching lines of a be doing what and where. Importantly, he the banalities of Act 5 (as a Theatre Director Nicholsons, it is as though an unexpected and villanelle poem such as Dylan Thomas guarantees the bounds and realms of relevance friend of mine has referred to them)? welcome family reunion. Labove, Diana and David Nicholson and decorum, though occasionally is guilty of One cannot but wonder how as a couple, they As bland as this may sound, once you realize intertwine their alternate lines that have slicing out an incisive observation and fails to upend the idea of ‘behind every great man is the variety of professionals, finance experts, recurred throughout the poetry of Wednesday allow debate to become too penetrating. an even greater woman’ for Diana is ably and economists, academics, diplomats, politicians, Night that last December pushed through its However, his task is a little like the Speaker of encouragingly supported by her husband in intelligence experts, documentary and film 1500th successive Wednesday – more than 25 the House, which he undertakes objectively what she does, says and whom she cares to makers not to mention journalists who grace years. and usually with aplomb. know – even if intelligence services visit to their threshold, then like the red wine that that Between them they introduce, compare and Diana however seemingly embraces the new find out if secrets might be in the process of seeps between your lips while there, you’ll contrast people, their perspectives, opinions age of sustainable development and one being traded. Perhaps they too should come value the experience of being a Wednesday and deeds that are the substance and form that suspects privately she believes the way is along and find out – just bring a bottle of red Nighter, even if David won’t quite allow bring shape, solidity and occasionally lingering possible but political will is lacking. Her forte wine. anyone to rage, rage into the night! Beyond measure An Thien Ngo

How to measure the contribution of Wednesday Night to our society and to the lives of the individuals who gather each week in the Nicholsons' salon? By insights gained, connections forged, endeav- ours catalyzed, new fields explored? What has the greatest impact? Is it the informal conversations with prominent figures from the upper echelons, or the warm welcome extended to each new guest, making him or her feel instantly at home? Why is each evening so uniquely enjoyable? Is it the timeliness of the selected topics, or the skillful shaping of the conversation to highlight the knowledge and interests of the assembly? We need more spaces like Wednesday Night, where people with diverse expertise meet with learners and teachers from all walks of life, to share their opinions on issues that matter. Bravo David and Diana, and best wishes for all your Wednesday Nights in the future!

THE MÉTROPOLITAIN • 17 FÉVRIER 2011 • VOL. 4, NO 1 SOCIETY 21

WWW.THEMETROPOLITAIN.CA

More celebrations of Wednesday Nights The University of Wednesday-Night

P. David Mitchell spanning a myriad of ideas. almost every topic and visitor legitimate governors of [the] Wednesday-Night resembles) market, the arts, etc. than On occasion, seated around before opening discussion, potentially unruly discourse” no one is expected to study would have been possible in The Age of Enlightenment the dining room table were which he steers like a pilot that took place, Diana is the before-hand but a time- any other way. David and spawned the salon, an money managers who through calm and sometimes ultimate helmsman guiding consuming-to-prepare and Diana I am grateful for the important place for the oversaw billions of dollars in turbulent skies, encouraging the agenda and implicitly the extensive set of background opportunity to experience exchange of ideas, an funds; at other times special- 'experts' to share their wisdom discourse, holding in reading usually is provided. your gracious hospitality and increase in knowledge and a ists in computer security, yet attempting to permit all to abeyance her symbol of And two massive websites to participate in the develop- source of pleasure and friend- foreign policy, economics, have input. An impossible power -- breakfast for David. devoted to Wednesday-Night ment and sharing of ship for participants. And an politics, medicine, education, task at which he excels. It is customary for someone summarize and expand on knowledge and friendships. influence on society. etc. occupied these chairs. Traditionally salons were to thank special guests and the discussions. Through my May you continue as long as Wikipedia tells us that Our gracious hosts invite organized by women and group; I will attempt to participation I found that I you wish and then participate salons “were carried on until guests from all walks of life Wednesday-Night is no express collective apprecia- was much better informed in some future salon hived off quite recently, in urban and many countries to share exception. Like the Parisian tion for our hosts. Unlike a about current events, political from Wednesday-Night. Viva settings, among like-minded their knowledge or perspec- “salonnieres” who were “the university seminar (which intrigue, the economy, the Wednesday-Night! Excelsior! people”. Clearly that author tive on nearly every never visited David and Diana conceivable topic. Those Nicholson's stately home on privileged to be regular guests Rosemount Avenue on any of owe a debt of gratitude to the past 1500+ Wednesday- David and Diana for conceiv- Nights where still can be ing and offering this found a warm welcome, lively incomparable educational conversation over a glass of opportunity. And for cleaning wine and a large adopted up the next day. family gathered to learn, to Host David magically share and to enjoy informal produces a video to provide and formal discussion background information for Something unique Laura and David Kilgour Ottawa

Diana, David and friends have achieved something unique and important with their uninterrupted Wednesday salons over so many years. In our travels around the world, we have never heard a similar institution. All of us who have participated are wiser and better for the experience. We only wish we could have attended more often from Ottawa. Long live David, Diana and Wednesday Nights. Never better, never warmer Stephen Blank

From someone who spent some moments on Canadian TV in the 1990s (when I headed the Council of the America’s Canadian Program in New York City), I can tell you that the lights were never hotter, the questions never tougher, the company never keener and the conversation never quicker than around the Nicholson’s table on Wednesday night. Might I also say, the friendships were never warmer, the wine more plentiful or hosts more gracious. Hail to David and Diana! One of North America's largest and most dependable suppliers of steel foundation products.

Pipe and Piling Supplies' high quality stocks include:

• Wide-flange Beams • Spiral Pipe • Bearing Pile Beams • Piling Pipe • Sheet Piling • Concrete Piles

Pipe & Piling offers competitive pricing and quality pre- and post-sale expertise. It's twelve sales and stocking facilities are available to serve you across North America in:

Vancouver Edmonton Calgary Toronto Montreal Halifax 604-942-6311 780-955-0501 403-236-1332 416-201-8189 514-879-9008 902-835-6158

Washington Nebraska Kansas Illinois Michigan Pennsylvania 253-939-4700 402-896-9611 1-800-874-3720 1-800-874-3720 1-800-874-3720 1-800-874-3720

www.pipe-piling.com THE MÉTROPOLITAIN • 17 FÉVRIER 2011 • VOL. 4, NO 1 SOCIETY 23

WWW.THEMETROPOLITAIN.CA

More celebrations of Wednesday Nights Plus ça change..the 700th tribute By Sam Totah are very special–”don’t leave home IMF, well known diplomats, ambassa- his famous signal on the huge bell right am trying to do, right at this moment. without it” dors, consuls, politicians - including the above the bar. That signals that the In resumé to visualize what exactly Dear Diana and David, I do want to mention– in a special ex-Premier of the Province, profession- drinking period will be sitting instead transpires on the scene at the The year is now 2011, you have just way– the name of Diana– the hostess, als from all walks of life– specially of standing. Seriously– that is when Nicholsons’ Wednesday soirées you moved out of the house - 33 the other partner in this private lawyers and investment executives, and guests are channeled to an adjacent have to be there in person. “Point Rosemount avenue, Westmount, enterprise of the Nicholsons. She plays multiple choice of others…. from A to room and then those sitting round the finale”. All hearsay can give you a clue Quebec, still in Canada (!) and I just a different role. In fact, while David is Z. The point is that indeed these soirées large rectangular table and others to what some people call comme les reviewed what I had written some the official spokesman of the agenda attract “by-invitation-only” people from taking the back seats better distinguish soirées intellectuelles du XIXième fifteen years ago about your and the official moderator of the all countries and professions. The the triage of “who is who”. Noblesse siècle en Europe!. Wednesday Nights Salon on the production known to all attendees as common denominator is that someone oblige– everyone finds his little niche That’s it!–you never know what to occasion of the 700th anniversary. the “Wednesday Night out chez les knows either David or Diana or one of in the atmosphere of silence among expect from the hosts and for that Now, you have passed your 1500th Nicholson”, Diana is in fact the unoffi- their guests. Anyhow– an interesting attendees and blasting videos contour- matter from the guests. What appears anniversary of your unforgettable “plus cial moderator. She is the one that mix of people and topics and wine is ing the three sides of the elegant on the surface to be a simple subject of ca change plus c’est la même chose” senses the pulse and depth of the what makes up these evenings– room–signaling indeed the tumultuous discussion is more complex when soirées with some slight changes, but discussion and at times brings the officially from 8:00p.m. to midnight. discussions are yet to commence. people of all walks of life present differ- the spirit is still the same ! Hope you discussions tangentially to virtual The first hour on each side of the Et voilà… ent points of view. I witnessed would like the following to …my reality. spectrum is for the very brave. In fact, That is when real action begins. Both discussions on the conflict in the tribute to the 700th I am writing on the Nicholsons’ from eight to nine p.m. there is some politicians and diplomats are relaxed former Yugoslavia and came out of soirées the way I see in the dim light socializing– one greets each other and when the famous motto off the record these soirées, perplexed by what I August 2, 1995 when I enter that well known house in the hosts, and people try to figure out is reiterated officially. Then there is learned to be the other person’s point of The anniversary date is always a Westmount. Yes, in Westmount, but not both what you do and how you happen spring in the air– and everyone wants to view. There will be at times a feeling of good opportunity to look back and necessarily for Westmounters. The to be in the same spot that same talk more than just sit back and listen to déjà-vu and other times you will be view the events from a different point guests come from all over the world. If evening! the wisdom freely expounded. This is filled with so much new information of view i.e. in hindsight. When David my memory serves me well, dignitaries The shallowness of these casual not exactly it! One realizes that it is that you can hardly wait for the next and Dianastarted these unique soirées – that walked in through the doors have discussions is very much in contrast very difficult to assemble images on New York Times Sunday edition to re- long, long long time, almost 14 included the Managing Director of the with what is to come after David gives the spoken words alone. Something I educate yourself. years, ago — their first special guest was Dr. Carl Beigie – the US-made Economist who was residing then with the Nicholson family — in Canada. 14 years multiplied by 365 days is a long time in anyone’s calendar. But it seems that David is breathing the same air he was breath- ing almost a decade and a half ago. The air that David breathes is “the success of the soirées, the exchange of information, the discussion, the arguments, the video output during the soirées, the video input during the off-hours, the faxes to the guests, the telephone calls to the special guests, and on and on and on… “Indeed very few of us realize what goes on behind the scenes and for that matter in the specially designed studio basement of the Nicholsons until that special Wednesday arrives on our agenda. Then we have to rush for that If we build it, they will come. “bottle” from the Government controlled Liquor Store, where the Magil Construction prides itself on its reputation for excellence. staff have become friendlier in recent Its expertise has been perfected on projects of every conceivable size and years. I don’t know why. Maybe complexity. Delivering a project on-time and on-budget has been there is some kind of privatization or fundamental to Magil's success. competition in the air! Back to the Nicholsons –theirs by contrast is a private initiative– not Founded in 1953 by architect Louis B. Magil, the company specialized government supported and yet it has in residential construction. It has since expanded into commercial, survived for 14 years. Chapeau. Hats industrial and institutional construction valued in billions of dollars. www.magil.com off. All in all — the Nicholsons soirées :OVWV\YUL^KPNP[HSÅHNZOPWSLJOH[LH\JVT