Irish and Irish-American Women in the District of Columbia, 1850-1890
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
KEEPING HOUSE: IRISH AND IRISH-AMERICAN WOMEN IN THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, 1850-1890 By Jennifer Lynn Altenhofel Submitted to the Faculty of the College of Arts and Sciences of American University in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in History Chair ___________________________ Dr. Alan Kraut ___________________________ Dr. Hasia Diner ___________________________ Dr. Tim Meagher ___________________________ Dr. Andrew Lewis ____________________ Dean of the College ____________________ Date 2004 American University Washington, D.C. 20016 ii KEEPING HOUSE: IRISH AND IRISH-AMERICAN WOMEN IN THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, 1850-1890 By Jennifer Lynn Altenhofel ABSTRACT This study documents the daily lives of Irish women as they became part of the social structure of Washington, D.C. Keeping House examines the evolution of Irish women's role in nineteenth century Washington, D.C. and notes how Irish women who came to the capital found domestic jobs that became rungs in the social ladder they climbed. In their move from working class to middle-class, Washington's Irish women formed a new cultural identity that corresponded with American middle-class values. Responding to values they brought with them from Ireland, and combining them with the virtues of American womanhood, Irish women used their experiences in Washington, D.C. as a foundation for middle-class association. Keeping House redefines the Irish woman's place within her ethnic community and within the community at large that provided her an opportunity to join the ranks of her fellow American women. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS ABSTRACT .................................................. ii LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS ........................................ iv INTRODUCTION : KEEPING HOUSE : IRISH AND IRISH -AMERICAN WOMEN IN THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA , 1850-1890 ............................... 1 CHAPTER 1: BUILDING A COMMUNITY : THE IRISH IN WASHINGTON , D.C., 1800- 1850..................................................... 25 CHAPTER 2: THE WILL OF PROVIDENCE : IRISH WOMEN ’S IMMIGRATION TO WASHINGTON , D.C. ........................................... 65 CHAPTER 3: TO HAVE AND TO HOLD : MARRIAGE AND FAMILY PATTERNS OF IRISH WOMEN IN WASHINGTON , D.C., 1850-1890 ........................ 108 CHAPTER 4: BROOM AND BOARD : IRISH WOMEN ’S LABOR IN WASHINGTON, D.C., 1850-1890............................................... 142 CHAPTER 5: TRIALS AND TRIBULATIONS : IRISH WOMEN ’S MORBIDITY AND MORTALITY IN THE CAPITAL CITY , 1850-1890 .............................. 185 CHAPTER 6: “TO KEEP THE PEACE ”: IRISH WOMEN AND THEIR CONTACT WITH THE LAW IN WASHINGTON , D.C., 1850-1890 ............................. 240 CHAPTER 7: “SO THEY MAY NEVER STRAY ”: THE ROLE OF THE CATHOLIC CHURCH IN THE LIVES OF WASHINGTON ’S IRISH WOMEN ......................... 275 CHAPTER 8: "A LITTLE BAND OF ZEALOUS WOMEN , FILLED WITH CHARITY ": IRISH WOMEN AT THE END OF THE NINETEENTH CENTURY IN WASHINGTON , D.C. .... 320 APPENDIX ONE : METHODOLOGY ................................... 348 APPENDIX TWO : AGE OF IRISH BRIDES ............................ 352 APPENDIX THREE : NATIONALITY OF MEN MARRIED TO IRISH WOMEN ......... 353 APPENDIX FOUR : BACKGROUND INFORMATION ON IRISH WOMEN IN CHAPTER FOUR 355 APPENDIX FIVE : MEDICAL REPORTS FROM COLUMBIA HOSPITAL FOR WOMEN .... 357 APPENDIX SIX : BACKGROUND INFORMATION ON WOMEN IN CHAPTER FIVE ..... 359 APPENDIX SEVEN : BACKGROUND INFORMATION ON ST. VINCENT DEPAUL SOCIETY MEMBERS AND THEIR CLIENTS .................................... 361 APPENDIX EIGHT : BACKGROUND INFORMATION ON WOMEN IN CHAPTER SEVEN .... 365 APPENDIX NINE : OCCUPATION CATEGORIES FROM UNITED STATES CENSUS , 1890 ................................. 369 BIBLIOGRAPHY .............................................. 371 iv LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS FIGURE 1: PERCENT OF IRISH ARRIVING IN THE UNITED STATES , 1820-1850 29 FIGURE 2: POPULATION OF WASHINGTON , D.C., 1800-1850 ............ 45 FIGURE 3: PERCENT OF IRISH IMMIGRANTS OF TOTAL POPULATION OF PRINCIPAL CITIES IN THE UNITED STATES , 1870-1890 ........................ 72 FIGURE 4: FOREIGN POPULATION OF WASHINGTON , D.C., 1850-1890 ..... 74 FIGURE 5: IRISH IMMIGRANTS BY WARD , WASHINGTON , D.C., 1850-1880 .. 79 FIGURE 6: IRISH AND FOREIGN WOMEN IN WASHINGTON , D.C., 1850-1880 . 88 FIGURE 7: FEMALE POPULATION IN WASHINGTON , D.C., 1850-1880 ...... 89 FIGURE 8: AGE DISTRIBUTION OF IRISH FEMALE POPULATION BY PERCENTAGE , WASHINGTON , D.C., 1850-1880 ................................ 91 FIGURE 9: IRISH WOMEN IN WASHINGTON , D.C. BY WARD , 1850-1880 .... 94 FIGURE 10: PERCENT OF MARITAL STATUS BY NATIVITY AND RACE FOR WOMEN OVER FIFTEEN YEARS OF AGE , WASHINGTON , D.C., 1890 .................. 116 FIGURE 11: MARITAL STATUS OF IRISH WOMEN OVER FIFTEEN YEARS OF AGE , WASHINGTON , D.C., 1850-1880 ............................... 117 FIGURE 12: BIRTHPLACE OF MEN WHO MARRIED IRISH WOMEN , 1850-1889 .. 125 FIGURE 13: NATIONALITY OF FATHERS OF CHILDREN BORN TO IRISH MOTHERS , 1860-1880............................................... 130 FIGURE 14: FOREIGN , IRISH , AFRICAN AMERICAN AND SLAVE WOMEN IN WASHINGTON , D.C. AND GEORGETOWN 1850-1860 .................... 155 FIGURE 15: IRISH WOMEN TREATED AT THE DOUGLAS MILITARY HOSPITAL BY ILLNESS , WASHINGTON , D.C., 1862-1864 ....................... 195 FIGURE 16: PRIMARY CAUSE OF DEATH FOR WOMEN IN WASHINGTON , D.C., 1874- 1883 BY NATIVITY .......................................... 201 FIGURE 17: CANCER DEATHS OF WOMEN BY NATIVITY AND TYPE IN WASHINGTON , D.C., 1874-1890 ......................................... 209 v FIGURE 18: IRISH PATIENTS IN COLUMBIA HOSPITAL FOR WOMEN & LYING -IN ASYLUM , WASHINGTON , D.C., 1866-1894 ....................... 216 FIGURE 19: IRISH WOMEN ARRESTED IN WASHINGTON , D.C., 1867-1887 BY MARITAL STATUS ............................................ 263 FIGURE 20: OCCUPATION OF IRISH WOMEN ARRESTED IN WASHINGTON , D.C., 1861-1887............................................... 269 FIGURE 21: MARITAL STATUS OF IRISH WOMEN OVER FIFTEEN YEARS OF AGE , WASHINGTON , D.C., 1850-1880 ............................... 328 1 INTRODUCTION: KEEPING HOUSE: IRISH AND IRISH-AMERICAN WOMEN IN THE DISTRICT OF COLUMBIA, 1850-1890 The St. Aloysius’ Parochial and Industrial School of Washington, D.C. needed help so the Ladies’ Relief Society of St. Aloysius’ Catholic Church answered the call. In 1876, to commemorate America’s 100 th birthday, the Ladies’ Relief Society held a bazaar and festival to raise money for the female industrial school associated with the church. Just five years earlier the Ladies raised $8600 for the school at a similar fair. 1 Hopes were high that the Centennial fair would raise just as much. Many of the women who helped with both events were Irish and Irish-American. Maria Conlan, a second-generation Irish immigrant, and her nieces participated in the fair. They presided at the centennial table and helped sell goods for the benefit of others. Margaret Cleary, born in Ireland, and her daughter Katie, born in Washington, D.C., also worked many nights at the fair hosting the industrial table that offered dolls 1 “St. Mary’s House of Industry,” Catholic Mirror , January 21, 1871. 2 for sale. One of the dolls was “the maid of Erin, a tiny blonde, bearing in her left hand the harp; and in the right a long green pennant; her attire is… garnished with garlands of shamrock and emerald ornaments.” 2 The Centennial fair lasted two weeks in February and each night visitors to the bazaar would purchase items donated by the Ladies’ Relief Society, buy food and drinks and generally celebrate into the evening. The Washington City Hibernian Benevolent Society (WCHBS) in support of their mothers, wives, sisters and daughters, attended the charity fair and created quite a stir. One evening when every one began to feel blue, and signs of a dull evening were appearing, the Washington City Hibernian Association—75 men in full regalia— marched into the room under the command of Captain Thomas Montgomery, and of course the spirituous of as many fair damsels were raised at once to concert pitch. The Lord loves a cheerful giver, and the Hibernians recognizing this, made mirth and charity go hand in hand, and their visit to the fair will be remembered among the pleasurable and profitable events. 3 Just a couple days after the visit from the WCHBS, Miss Belle Lucas, a granddaughter of Irish immigrants 2 "Charity Box," Charity Fair Chronicle , no. 2, February 15, 1876, 4, Box 72, St. Aloysius Catholic Church Archives, St. Aloysius Catholic Church, Washington, D.C. 3 Ibid. 3 financially contributed to the evening and advertised her and her mother’s dressmaking shop in the Charity Fair Chronicle , the daily newsletter of the bazaar. 4 These Irish and Irish-American women of the Ladies' Relief Society are examples of immigrant women’s resilience and adaptability in America, and in particular, Washington, D.C. The social prominence and status they achieved was a result of their acculturation to American ideals. The cultural traits and identities that Irish women brought with them combined with the cultural traits and identities of this Southern town. This reciprocal process resulted when “groups of individuals having different cultures” came “into continuous first-hand contact, with subsequent changes in the original cultural patterns” of both groups. 5 These groups, Irish women and their employers and neighbors, shared “continuous first-hand contact” in their workplaces as domestic and employer. Moreover,