DOCSLIB.ORG

Populism Against Progress

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Populism Against Progress Populism Against Progress Mark Wegierski Canadian-Polish Research Institute The True and Only Heaven: Progress and Its Critics, by Christopher Lasch. New York and London: W.W. Norton, 1991. 591 pp. $25. This is a bold and incisive book by the reads the book, one can see “Vanity well-known cultural critic and scholar Fair” as an apposite image for con- best remembered for his pointed de- temporary society, with its ceaseless scription in a 1979 book of the culture whirl, consumption, and meaningless of narcissism. Although Christopher circulation (of money, goods, and Lasch, like his predecessor Marshall people), while “the Celestial City” McLuhan, is virtually a fixture of would be the metaphor for a more North American pop-culture, he settled society with a sense of limits, teaches history at the University of a genuine community. Those who Rochester rather than at a “prestige” most determinedly confound the two university. The fact that someone of are the liberal evangels of progress. his caliber is at Rochester, rather than This work—written in a forthright Harvard, underscores the ongoing style which should probably be a con- decline of the big-name universities comitant of any work espousing a and the emergence of academically populist approach—can be under- superior institutions of the so-called stood as, among other things, one of “second tier” in the United States. “philosophical archaeology.” Lasch The work begins with a quotation reaches back into the past in an at- from Nathaniel Hawthorne from tempt to descry, describe, and revivify which the phrase forming the title of a populist tradition of social criticism the book is derived. The reference is (with which he largely identifies), to those who very stubbornly and which has set itself against the mate- “stoutly contend” that “Vanity Fair” rialistic and consumptionist excesses rather than the real “Celestial City” is of capitalism. The work is noteworthy “the true and only heaven.” As one for identifying, and bringing to 114 • Volume VI, No. 2, 1993 Mark Wegierski broader attention, a fairly extensive There are also some well-directed Protestant, “Dissenting” and Calvin- criticisms at a certain type of conser- ist-centered, English-speaking tradi- vatism, which Lasch characterizes, in tion of critique and resistance to capi- the second chapter, as “Nostalgia: The talism. In this respect the work Abdication of Memory.” The third challenges somewhat the conven- chapter, although appreciative of tional understanding which places “The Sociological Tradition and the much of that opposition in the Catho- Idea of Community” (which includes lic and Continental European context. Burke), pointedly criticizes Although the “anarcho-syndicalist” “ Gemeinschaft- Georges Sorel—interpreted as a quint- schmerz.” Although a profound pessi- essential populist—is fairly exten- mist, Lasch tries to anchor his hopes sively discussed, most of the other fig- in something that is at least within the ures in the book, such as Thomas realm of possibility. Carlyle with his emphasis on duty, Although Lasch might be sympa- William Morris with his crafts ap- thetic to a critique of contemporary proach, G.D.H. Cole, the guild-social- society such as that expressed in Claes ist, and Josiah Royce, the philosopher Ryn’s The New Jacobinism, he would of “social loyalty,” are part of the En- probably strongly react against any glish-speaking context. attempt to defend a strong elitism or The book is in some ways a lament class privilege of any sort. Lasch un- that modern-day socialism has been doubtedly would see Jean-Jacques dominated almost exclusively by Rousseau as one of the foremost crit- Marxism—the form of socialism ics, rather than intellectual architects, which, with its emphasis on a strictly of contemporary society, especially in scientific underpinning and on purely a work such as The Discourse on the economic achievement, was in fact, Arts and Sciences. As a populist and according to Lasch, the closest to the social democrat, Lasch rejects elitist capitalism which it strove to oppose. philosophical liberalism and capital- One is reminded of a possible earlier ism (which he sees as largely cotermi- approach to socialism in John Rus- nous) while embracing democracy. kin’s famous aphorism: “I am a Tory This position sharply contrasts with of the sternest sort, a socialist, a com- that of a typical “paleoconservative” munist.” These were the schools and like Paul Gottfried, who defends a approaches (guild-socialism, utopian form of political liberalism and pro- socialism, etc.) that were so vocifer- visionally accepts capitalism while at ously and polemically condemned in the same time identifying the central Marx’s Communist Manifesto. problem of contemporary America as One of the real strengths of the an excess of “democratic” or “social book is its willingness to criticize con- democratic” ideology. Lasch’s admo- ventional understandings of political nition to someone claiming to be a categories, as in the first chapter, “The true conservative would be to become Obsolescence of Left and Right.” a friend of the common people, On Lasch’s True and Only Heaven HUMANITAS • 115 wholeheartedly as opposed to tacti- “hard” side of managerial capitalism cally or provisionally, . (e.g., budget cuts and plant closings). Lasch very pointedly criticizes the As an aggressively self-seeking, elit- so-called “New Class” which further ist and very powerful group, they are strengthened its hold on America af- in no way like the sentimental “tree- ter the 1960s. As he makes this cri- huggers” often found on the Left. tique, he expresses a strong sympathy Lasch would argue that neither the for the downtrodden working and true conservative nor the true social- lower-middle classes in America, ist can be impressed by America to- whose outlook, although it includes day—a restless culture based on the obviously unsavory elements, puts inflammation, through all-pervasive some real limits on the grotesque advertising, of the grossest appetites; hyperconsumption society which has saturated by relentless media images now arisen. of violence and libidinous sexuality The group whose outlook Lasch such as have never existed before in would probably reject the most human history; and ultimately a soci- strongly is the neoconservatives. In his ety exhibiting great cruelty and the estimation, they would form part of crassest self-interest. “the New Class.” They are a group Populism, in spite of its possible within it that is particularly adept at authoritarian colorations, may at this pushing for and defending con- stage be the only force that can mean- sumptionist capitalism, that is able to ingfully confront this emergent dysto- derive enormous wealth and personal pia. If it is really true, as Lasch argues, advantage from its political involve- that we have moved today “beyond ment, and that argues strenuously for, Left-Right,” then perhaps the manifest and often helps to bring about, the conflict now is between populism and elitism. 116 • Volume VI, No. 2, 1993 Mark Wegierski.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Harrison Stetler Thesis
    “A skilled surgeon presiding at the birth of a new culture”: Christopher Lasch on the Politics of Post-Industrial Society Senior Thesis by Harrison Stetler Advisor: Professor Rebecca Kobrin Second Reader: Professor Casey Blake April 2016 Department of History Columbia University 16, 520 Words Acknowledgements: Writing this thesis has been an extraordinarily trying and rewarding experience, which I would not have been able to complete without an inordinate amount of help and support from friends and family. I owe a great debt to all my fellow students and to Professor Kobrin for providing an immense amount of support over the past year. I would also like to thank Professor Blake for guiding me through this study of Lasch’s thought. Likewise, I owe a debt of gratitude to a number of other teachers—Professors Mark Mazower, Adam Tooze, Mark Lilla, and Nicholas Dames, in particular—who have participated in a number of smaller yet indispensible ways throughout this long process. For letting me rant incessantly about Christopher Lasch, I am not sure whether I should apologize to or thank my friends. Thank you to my suitemates—Mark, Jackson, Kal, Derek, and Gerry—in particular. Thank you to Ruby, my intellectual soul mate, for venturing with me— through Adorno, Melville, and Flaubert—along our path to mystical modernism. I see this essay as a partial capstone to that journey. Thank you to Max for preventing me from thinking that “this is not the land of truth.” Thank you to Elena for humoring me during many a procrastination break outside of Butler.
    [Show full text]
  • Environmental and Social Stress Factors
    Urban Research in the Developing World: From Governance to Security Richard Stren Project on Urbanization, Population, Environment, and Security. Supported by the U.S. Agency for International Development through a cooperative agreement with the University of Michigan Population Fellows Programs Comparative Urban Studies Project Occasional Paper No. 16 WOODROW WILSON INTERNATIONAL CENTER FOR SCHOLARS, 1998 1 RICHARD STREN Urban Research in the Developing World: From Governance to Security Richard Stren Director, Center for Urban and Community Studies University of Toronto Toronto, Canada Introduction: Building an Urban Research Agenda Against the backdrop of a major demographic shift from rural to urban in most parts of the world (a shift that has already been largely accomplished in Europe, North America, and much of Latin America), the research literature on urban questions has shown a number of distinct patterns over the years. One pattern is the continuing influence of international disciplinary perspectives. In spite of the fact that urban questions cut across disciplines, and that solutions to urban problems involve ideas and coalitions of interests that are usually very broad and projects that are very practical, researchers--and the research literature--tend to be specialized. Thus, an economist in Bombay is likely to choose themes and a methodological approach to her urban problems that are more similar to her economist colleagues in Santiago than to her sociological colleagues in Delhi. In spite of some tendencies toward interdisciplinary research in urban studies worldwide, the disciplines--which are organized at a global level with common standards of approach, journals, conferences, and professional behavior--are still very powerful.
    [Show full text]
  • Imagination Movers: the Construction of Conservative Counter-Narratives in Reaction to Consensus Liberalism
    Imagination Movers: The Construction of Conservative Counter-Narratives in Reaction to Consensus Liberalism Seth James Bartee Dissertation submitted to the faculty of the Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy In Social, Political, Ethical, and Cultural Thought Francois Debrix, Chair Matthew Gabriele Matthew Dallek James Garrison Timothy Luke February 19, 2014 Blacksburg, Virginia Keywords: conservatism, imagination, historicism, intellectual history counter-narrative, populism, traditionalism, paleo-conservatism Imagination Movers: The Construction of Conservative Counter-Narratives in Reaction to Consensus Liberalism Seth James Bartee ABSTRACT The purpose of this study was to explore what exactly bound post-Second World War American conservatives together. Since modern conservatism’s recent birth in the United States in the last half century or more, many historians have claimed that both anti-communism and capitalism kept conservatives working in cooperation. My contention was that the intellectual founder of postwar conservatism, Russell Kirk, made imagination, and not anti-communism or capitalism, the thrust behind that movement in his seminal work The Conservative Mind. In The Conservative Mind, published in 1953, Russell Kirk created a conservative genealogy that began with English parliamentarian Edmund Burke. Using Burke and his dislike for the modern revolutionary spirit, Kirk uncovered a supposedly conservative seed that began in late eighteenth-century England, and traced it through various interlocutors into the United States that culminated in the writings of American expatriate poet T.S. Eliot. What Kirk really did was to create a counter-narrative to the American liberal tradition that usually began with the French Revolution and revolutionary figures such as English-American revolutionary Thomas Paine.
    [Show full text]
  • Epiphany and Authenticity: the Aesthetic Vision of Charles Taylor
    Epiphany and Authenticity: The Aesthetic Vision of Charles Taylor Brian J. Braman The language of self-fulfillment, self-actualization, and self-realization have become common currency in contemporary culture. In fact, these ideas can be subsumed under the inclusive term of authenticity. Cultural critics such as the late Allan Bloom and Christopher Lasch see this desire for individual self-fulfillment, for being authentic, as a form of narcissism that closes ott concern for the greater issues that transcend the self, be they political or religious. For Charles Taylor, however, although a certain moral relativism can be associated with the desire for self-fulfillment, this posi­ tion is in the last analysis a profound mistake. What the critics of authentic­ ity fail to see is the moral ideal underlining this desire for authentic self-re­ alization. This ideal is the intense desire to live one ·s life by a higher standard. In short, the question of the constitution of authentic human exis­ tence is a question of a moral ideal that ought to be taken seriously because the meaning of authenticity has shaped, and continues to shape, our under­ standing of what it means to be human. For Taylor the idea of authenticity is a rich, vibrant, and vitally impor­ tant addition to any conversation concerning what it means to be human. Authenticity, properly understood. is "a picture of what a better or higher mode of life would be, where better and higher are defined not in terms of what we happen to desire or need, but offer a standard of what we ought to desire.'' 1 Taylor's view of authenticity expresses the conviction that terms such as self-fulfillment and self-realization are not just cover stories for narcissism, nor are they terms that justify a stance that is labeled the "liber- I Charles Taylor.
    [Show full text]
  • U.S. Intellectual and Cultural History: Literature of the Field (951) Fall 2008 Professor Ratner-Rosenhagen Office: Mosse Humani
    U.S. Intellectual and Cultural History: Literature of the Field (951) Fall 2008 Professor Ratner-Rosenhagen Course Schedule: R 1:00-3:30 p.m. Office: Mosse Humanities, 4112 Room: Humanities 5257 Email: [email protected] Credits: 3 Office Hours: R 10:00 a.m-12:00 p.m. This course introduces graduate students to the scholarship in U.S. intellectual and cultural history. Our syllabus includes both classic and cutting-edge studies in U.S. thought and culture, which will provide students a foundation in the diverse subjects, competing theories, and contested modes of interpretation that have defined the field for well over a half century. We will investigate what many regard as the inherent interdisciplinarity of the field, examining how developments in philosophy, anthropology, political theory, and cultural studies have influenced the ways in which historians of thought and culture have understood their own enterprise. Because intellectual historians like to think about thinking, this course will have its fair share of theory. However, all of the readings, both theoretical and historical, will raise questions of general concern: How to understand the agency of historical actors, ideas, and ideologies? How to measure intellectual and cultural influence? How to access the felt experience and the moral world views of people from the past? How to apprehend the meanings of particular cultural discourses in their own time and place? By asking questions about the creation, transmission, power, and influence of ideas, beliefs, and cultural sensibilities, we will address issues that not only have defined the field, but also have broader applicability to the discipline as a whole.
    [Show full text]
  • Jay Langdale 2011 Panel Paper
    Jay Langdale Andrew College The Philadelphia Society Dallas, Texas, April 2, 2011 The Idea of Progress in America Before and After Progressivism ______________________________________________________________________________ Two decades ago, Christopher Lasch opened his work The True and Only Heaven: Progress and Its Critics with what he notably described as a “deceptively simple” query. “How does it happen,” Lasch wondered, “that serious people continue to believe in progress, in the face of massive evidence that might have been expected to refute the idea of progress once and for all?” 1 Over the course of the twentieth century, Lasch was among a host of scholars, including the British historian J.B. Bury, the American historian Arthur Ekirch and the American Sociologist Robert Nisbet, who examined the intellectual history of the “idea of progress.” 2 Lasch’s The True and Only Heaven , though, was distinguishable from the others in both its attempt to assess the late twentieth century consequences of the idea as well as in its insistence that there were profound differences between the prophetic Christian view of history and the modern notion of progress. The difference, Lasch maintained, was that modern views of progress did not so much offer “the promise of a secular utopia that would bring history to a happy ending,” as much as they held out “the promise of steady improvement with no foreseeable ending at all.” 3 Generally speaking, Lasch’s observation continues to provide a useful starting point for a consideration of the idea of progress in modern America and, as this paper will argue, the entirety of the American experience.
    [Show full text]
  • William E. Leuchtenburg President American Historical Association 1991
    William E. Leuchtenburg President American Historical Association 1991 William E. Leuchtenburg The infectious enthusiasm, gentle humanism, and judicious scholarship of William E. Leuchtenburg have inspired students of American history for more than forty years. As a scholar, the 1991 president of the American Historical Association is known to historians as one of the leading authorities in the world on the United States in the twentieth century. As a teacher, Leuchtenburg has attracted legions of students at New York University, Smith College, and Harvard University, where he taught in his early years; at Columbia University where he was the De Witt Clinton Professor of History and taught for thirty years; and, since 1982, at the University of North Carolina, Chapel Hill, where he is the William Rand Kenan, Jr., Professor of History Born in New York City to working-class German and Irish parents who grew up in poverty in the Hell’s Kitchen district of Manhattan, Leuchtenburg spent his adolescent years in a small apartment on Gleane Street in Queens. The saying in his family for a good while has been “it’s a long way from Gleane Street,” as Leuchtenburg has been honored with not one but two endowed chairs and with distinguished senior fellowships, among them from the Guggenheim Foundation, the Mellon Foundation, and the National Endowment for the Humanities and at the Center for Advanced Study in the Behavioral Sciences, the National Humanities Center, and the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars. He was appointed to the Harmsworth Chair at Oxford University; has been invited to deliver prestigious lectures in this country and abroad, including at such venues as the U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Identity in the Globalizing World1
    Elliott-3772-Ch-01:Elliott-3772-Ch-01.qxp 8/14/2008 8:24 PM Page 1 1 Identity in the Globalizing World 1 Zygmunt Bauman ‘There has been a veritable discursive explosion in recent years around the concept of “identity”,’ observed Stuart Hall in the introduction to a volume of studies published in 1996. A few years have passed since that observation was made, during which the explosion has triggered an avalanche. No other aspect of contemporary life, it seems, attracts the same amount of attention these days from philosophers, social scientists and psychologists. It is not just that ‘identity studies’ are fast becoming a thriving industry in their own right; more than that is happening – one may say that ‘identity’ has now become a prism through which other topical aspects of contemporary life are spotted, grasped and examined. Established issues of social analysis are being rehashed and refurbished to fit the discourse now rotating around the ‘identity’ axis. For instance, the discussion of justice and equality tends to be conducted in terms of ‘recognition’, culture is debated in terms of individ - ual, group or categorial difference, creolization and hybridity, while the political process is ever more often theorized around the issues of human rights (that is, the right to a separate identity) and of ‘life polities’ (that is, identity construction, negotiation and assertion). I suggest that the spectacular rise of the ‘identity discourse’ can tell us more about the present-day state of human society than its conceptual and analytical results have told us thus far. And so, rather than composing another ‘career report’ of contentions and controversies which combine into that discourse, I intend to focus on the tracing of the experiential grounds, and through them the structural roots, of that remarkable shift in intellec - tual concerns of which the new centrality of the ‘identity discourse’ is a most salient symptom.
    [Show full text]
  • The Anatomy of Antiliberalism
    Michigan Law Review Volume 92 Issue 6 1994 The Anatomy of Antiliberalism Jeffrey R. Costello University of Michigan Law School Follow this and additional works at: https://repository.law.umich.edu/mlr Part of the Law and Philosophy Commons Recommended Citation Jeffrey R. Costello, The Anatomy of Antiliberalism, 92 MICH. L. REV. 1547 (1994). Available at: https://repository.law.umich.edu/mlr/vol92/iss6/12 This Review is brought to you for free and open access by the Michigan Law Review at University of Michigan Law School Scholarship Repository. It has been accepted for inclusion in Michigan Law Review by an authorized editor of University of Michigan Law School Scholarship Repository. For more information, please contact [email protected]. THE ANATOMY OF ANTILIBERALISM. By Stephen Holmes. Cam­ bridge: Harvard University Press. 1993. Pp. xvi, 330. $29.95. Stephen Holmes1 has recently published an engaging and stimulat­ ing, though finally unsatisfying, book. At a time when modern liber­ alism is being assailed seemingly from all sides - by fundamentalist Christians, conservative libertarians, critical race and feminist legal scholars, and communitarian political scholars - Holmes endeavors in The Anatomy ofAntiliberalism to defend the faith from attack by a discrete and somewhat nonobvious group of theorists. The book pur­ ports to weave the works of thinkers as diverse as Joseph de Maistre and Roberto Unger into a coherent tradition of "antiliberalism" and, in so doing, to correct the oft-repeated errors of both historiography and interpretation that run through this tradition. That he is only partly successful in these aims reflects more on his taxonomic choices than his substantive analysis.
    [Show full text]
  • The Ethics of Authenticity Charles Taylor
    The Ethics of Authenticity Charles Taylor ' ' Harvard University Press Cambridge, Massachusetts and London, England --- --- 12 THE ETHICS OF AUTHENTICITY consequences you have to pay for the positive fruits, but rather how to steer these developments towards their greatest promise and avoid the slide into the debased forms. Now I have nothing like the space I would need to treat all three of these themes as they deserve, so I propose a short-cut. I will launch into a discussion of the first theme, concerning the dangers of individ- ualism and the loss of meaning. I will pursue this II discussion at some length. Having derived some idea of how this issue ought to be treated, I will THE INARTICULATE DEBATE suggest how a similar treatment of the other two might run. The bulk of the discussion will therefore concentrate on the first axis of concern. Let us exam- ine in more detail what form this arises in today. We can pick it up through a very influen- -· tial recent book in the United States, Allan Bloom's The Closing of the American Mind. The book itself was a rather remarkable phenomenon: a work by an aca- demic political theorist about the climate of opinion among to9'.ay' s students, it held a place on the New York Times' best-seller list for several months, greatly to the surprise of the author. It touched a chord. The stance it took was· severely critical of today's educated youth. The main feature it noted in their outlook on life was their acceptance of a rather facile relativism.
    [Show full text]
  • Of Critical Theory: a Legacy of Paul Piccone and Telos
    Fast Capitalism ISSN 1930-014X Volume 5 • Issue 1 • 2009 doi:10.32855/fcapital.200901.001 The “Americanization” of Critical Theory: A Legacy of Paul Piccone and Telos Timothy W. Luke Introduction Much of the “critical theory” being written in Western Marxist, Frankfurt School or new populist registers all across North America today must be tied back in some fashion to the lifework of Paul Piccone and the journal Telos. Since Telos has continued developing and diversifying its discourses of critique after Piccone’s death in 2004, whatever multiple identities these new schools of critical theory have acquired since the end of the Cold War during 1991, and the advent of the War on Terror in 2001, also cannot be easily untied from ongoing developments with this unusual publication. Along with its multiple networks of radical writers and global audiences of loyal readers, Telos today still pushes hard to be ahead of the curve in critical theory, while staying attentive to its own eclectic philosophical craft. Quite unlike many other self-acclaimed radical publications, which spin thick webs of rhetoric about their engaged political resistance, but then never open their pages to an ongoing expression of truly concrete critical differences, Telos has spent over 40 years of publishing many of the most electrifying, diverse, and controversial figures that one could read in one place. From many varied nationalities, classes, theoretical movements, religions, ideological schools, cultures, and political perspectives, a wide array of people have worked with Telos at pivotal points in their intellectual lives (Luke 2005b). From these engagements, the nature of critical theory in the U.S.A.
    [Show full text]
  • CHRISTOPHER LASCH and PRAIRIE POPULISM Jon K
    University of Nebraska - Lincoln DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln Great Plains Quarterly Great Plains Studies, Center for Summer 2012 CHRISTOPHER LASCH AND PRAIRIE POPULISM Jon K. Lauck University of Iowa Follow this and additional works at: http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/greatplainsquarterly Part of the American Studies Commons, Cultural History Commons, and the United States History Commons Lauck, Jon K., "CHRISTOPHER LASCH AND PRAIRIE POPULISM" (2012). Great Plains Quarterly. 2802. http://digitalcommons.unl.edu/greatplainsquarterly/2802 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Great Plains Studies, Center for at DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. It has been accepted for inclusion in Great Plains Quarterly by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@University of Nebraska - Lincoln. CHRISTOPHER LASCH AND PRAIRIE POPULISM JON K. LAUCK Christopher Lasch was born in Omaha in cast over a generation of historians and cul­ 1932. By the end of his life, cut short at age tural critics who came of age in the 1960s and sixty-one, he had become one of the most 1970s."2 A product and one-time devotee of famous intellectuals in the world.l During his the American Left, Lasch later solidified his life of active writing from the time of the early standing as a commanding figure in American Cold War until the fall of the Soviet Union, letters as a trenchant and at times brutal critic Lasch's distinctive voice pierced through the of American liberalism. din of the nation's noisy political and cul­ Throughout his life, both when he was tural debates. The historian Jackson Lears firmly planted in the traditions of the Left recalled, in particular, the "spell that Lasch and after his dissent began, Lasch embodied a prairie skepticism about the vision and drift of his fellow intellectuals, the allegedly liberating aspects of modern life, and the coercive incli­ Key Words: agrarianism, Cold War, Iowa, liberalism, nations of technocratic planners.
    [Show full text]