The 10Th Korea-Canada Forum Report
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
제 10 차 한국-캐나다 포럼 Korea-Canada Forum REPORT 일 시: 2012년 10월 4일 – 6일 장 소: 서울 신라 호텔 공동 주관 • 서울국제포럼 (The Seoul Forum for International Affairs) • The Asia Pacific Foundation of Canada 후 원: 한국국제교류재단, 한국가스공사 (KOGAS) 1 목 차 I. 포럼 개요 …………………………………………………………………………………….………… 3 II. 포럼 프로그램 ……………………………………………………………………………….…..… 3 III. 주요 토의 내용 ……………………………………………………………………………………… 6 IV. 참석자 명단 ………………………………………………………………………………………… 32 2 Ⅰ. 제 10 차 한국-캐나다 포럼 개요 1. 일 시: 2012년 10월 4일 - 6일 2. 장 소: 서울 신라 호텔 3. 공동 주관 • 서울국제포럼 (The Seoul Forum for International Affairs) • The Asia Pacific Foundation of Canada 4. 주 제: Beyond the Canada-Korea Special Partnership: Building Middle Power Leadership 5. 재정지원: 한국국제교류재단, 한국가스공사 (KOGAS) II. 포럼 프로그램 October 4, Thursday 18:30-20:00 Welcoming Dinner for Canadian Delegation hosted by Hong-Koo LEE, Chairman of The Seoul Forum for International Affairs, Former Prime Minister Venue: Orchid Room (23F) October 5, Friday Venue: Orchid Room (23F) 8:30-9:00 Registration 9:00-9:20 Welcome and Introduction Chair: Ku-Hyun JUNG, President of The Seoul Forum for International Affairs Opening remarks by the co-chairs of the Korea-Canada Forum, Sung-joon YIM, Distinguished Professor at the Hankuk University of Foreign Studies, Former Ambassador to Canada Stephen TOOPE, President and Vice-Chancellor of the University of British Columbia 3 9:20-10:00 Opening Speech Sihyung LEE , Deputy Minister for Trade, Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade 10:00-12:00 Session I: Political Developments and International Relations of Canada and Korea Chair: Sung-Joo HAN, President Emeritus of the Seoul Forum for International Affairs, Former Minister of Foreign Affairs Political Developments: Presenters: Korea – Hyehoon LEE, Member, Supreme Council, Saenuri Party Canada – Stockwell DAY, Former Minister of International Trade & Minister Responsible for the Asia-Pacific Gateway & Corridor Initiative, APFC, Distinguished Fellow, Board Member of RCI Capital Group International Relations: Korea – Jin PARK, Executive President of Asia Future Institute, Former Member of the National Assembly Canada – Paul EVANS, Professor, Liu Institute for Global Issues, Director, Institute of Asian Research, University of British Columbia 12:15 Lunch Venue: Pine &Bamboo Room (23F) Hosted by Korea Gas Corporation (KOGAS) Luncheon Speaker: Hong-Koo LEE, Chairman of The Seoul Forum for International Affairs, Former Prime Minister 14:00-15:45 Session II: Global Economic Crisis and Economic Prospects in Korea and Canada Chair: Yuen Pau WOO, President & CEO, Asia Pacific Foundation of Canada Presenters: Canada – Leonard EDWARDS, Former Deputy Minister, Department of Foreign Affairs & International Trade, Former Ambassador to Korea and Japan, G20/G8 Sherpa to the Prime Minister from 2008-2010, APFC Distinguished Fellow Korea – Jong Wha LEE, Senior Advisor to President Lee Myung-Bark, The Blue House and Korea’s G-20 Sherpa for 2011 Kihwan KIM, Distinguished Visiting Scholar, Korea Development Institute (KDI) 15:45-16:00 Coffee Break 16:00-18:00 Session III: Korea-Canada Partnership for Energy and Sustainable Development Chair: Sung-joon YIM, Distinguished Professor at the Hankuk University of Foreign Studies, Former Ambassador to Canada Presenters: 4 Korea – Hoesung LEE, Vice Chair of the UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) Yonghun JUNG, Counsellor for Energy and Environment to the Minister, Ministry of Knowledge Economy Canada – Gary WEILINGER, Vice President, Strategic Development External Affairs, Spectra Energy Transmission West John PARK, President, RCI Capital Group Philip LEE, Vice-President, RCI Capital Group 19:00 Dinner Hosted by David Chatterson, Canadian Ambassador to Korea Venue: Ambassador’s Residence October 6, Saturday Venue: Orchid Room (23F) 9:00-10:45 Session IV: Middle Power Leadership in Global Affairs: Soft Power and Public Diplomacy Chair: Leonard EDWARDS, Former Deputy Minister, Department of Foreign Affairs & International Trade, Former Ambassador to Korea and Japan, G20/G8 Sherpa to the Prime Minister from 2008-2010, APFC Distinguished Fellow Presenters: Canada – Kyung-Ae PARK, Korea Foundation Chair, Director, Centre for Korean Research, University of British Columbia Tom PERLMUTTER, Government Film Commissioner & Chairperson, National Film Board of Canada Korea – Woosang KIM, President, The Korea Foundation Jie-ae SOHN, President and CEO, The Korea International Broadcasting Foundation (Arirang TV & Radio) 10:45-11:00 Coffee Break 11:00-12:00 Roundtable: The Future Role of Canada-Korea Forum Chair: Dalchoong KIM, President Emeritus, the Seoul Forum for International Affairs Professor Emeritus, Political Science, Yonsei University Panelists: Yuen Pau WOO, President and CEO, Asia Pacific Foundation Paul EVANS, Director, Institute of Asian Research, University of British Columbia Jae- Seung LEE, Professor, Korea University 12:00-12:15 Wrap-Up Session Co-chairs: Stephen TOOPE and Sung-joon YIM 12:30 Lunch Venue: Pine &Bamboo Room (23F) Afternoon: Optional Tour 5 III. 주요 토의 내용 (Presentations & Discussions) Session I : Political Development and International Relations of Canada and Korea 1. POLITICAL DEVELOPMENT: Presentation by Hyehoon LEE, Member, Supreme Council, Saenuri Party; Stockwell DAY, Former Minister of International Trade & Minister Republic of Korea Currently, multiple political leadership changes are happening in Northeast Asia. Along with this megatrend of leadership changes, various other changes are taking place, including the rise of nationalism due to territorial disputes; power shifts; the shifting balance of power; the rise of China; a rebalancing or pivoting US; a returning Russia; a Japan trying to ‘normalize’ by erasing the image of defeat post-WWII; South Korean policy changes towards North Korea; and North Korea’s reprioritizing from a Military First policy to party and economy first policy. Thus, change in international relations is expected to be extremely dynamic if all of these trends are set in motion. Within Korean domestic politics, there will be a presidential election on December 19th. Currently, there are three candidates running: Madam Park, daughter of the former President Park Chung-Hee, is running as the ruling party’s nominee; Ahn, a successful businessman, is running as an independent; and Moon, a lawyer and chief of staff for former President Roh, is the nominee of the main opposition party, the Democratic United Party. In a recent public opinion poll, Park scored 37.7%, Ahn 29.8% and Moon 22.5%. Although the poll illustrated Park’s prominent position in a three-way competition, if Ahn and Moon supporters are merged, Park would lose. In the case of the 2002 presidential election, President Roh and Jeong agreed on a single candidacy at the very last minute. Timing thus seems the most important part when forming an alliance. All three candidates declared economic democratization as the upcoming election’s main issue. Economic democratization has never been an issue until general public started to think about it due to ongoing polarization. A recent public survey showed that 98% of people considered economic democratization as the most important topic for the election. In essence, economic democratization can be described as building a safety net to protect ‘economically weak’ small and medium enterprises (SME) from chaebol, or business conglomerates. Over the years, Korea’s chaebols have developed through economic concentration. SMEs, usually subcontractors, are shaken or collapse according to the chaebols’ decision. Thus, new policies of limiting economic concentration by the chaebol are highly expected to be proposed by each candidate. 6 Usually, discussions in presidential elections focus heavily on different visions and policies related to people’s livelihood. However, in the current election, rather than policy discussions, the focus has been on the candidacy collision issue. It is time for candidates to debate over different policies such as economic democratization rather than focusing on candidacy alliances. In other words, the election should be more policy-oriented, or else it will lead to a tragic result. Canada For Canada, three points bear mentioning. For starters, looking at Canadian politics in the past, the Liberal Party became the governing party in 1990 when the Conservative parties split the votes. But in 2000, the two Conservative parties came together under the name of Alliance Party. In politics, having two or more political parties means having two or more different policy options that people can choose from. It is certainly beneficial to people since they can make decisions more easily when there is a clear policy distinction. In Canada, two opposite parties had clear differences in fiscal and economic policies. In terms of economic policies along with political development, Canada did not consider a stimulus during the 2008 world economic crisis. Even during this economic downturn, when most of the world was considering a stimulus, Canada had very limited view of it. Quantitative easing sounded attractive, but this would increase the money supply and possible lead to an increase in inflation and a decrease in debt and credit capability. In January, 2013, the United States will face a downgrading since pumping in 40 billion dollars every month will not be plausible or possible. With a very limited view of quantitative easing, Canada introduced significant rules, including a banking regulatory system. As a result, the World Economic Forum, OECD and IMF all pointed to Canada