Fish population dynamics and management
Post-Chernobyl radiocaesium in fish from two Cumbrian lakes The Chernobyl reactor accident occurred ') 3000 , Devoke Water howeswater on the 26 April 1986 and the plume kg passed over England during 2-3 May (Bg • 1986. Much of the remaining activity 2000 - • • continued northwards over Scotland. but ; • .9 some moved westwards and then • • • *so• • returned to traverse Wales and northern 1000 .1.2, . • England during 7-8 May. Limited • :I 1114:1 radioactivity •S •• 1••:. • • •• • deposition occurred throughout the UK • •• and the highest values were recorded in -••' ••••••p I Cumbria. North Wales and pails of r, n Scotland. Early monitoring of fish showed Muscle 1986 1987 1988 1986 1987 1988 that, whilst the radiological significance of Months the fallout on marine fish was negligible. radionuclide accumulation by freshwater fish was significant, especially in high deposition areas such as the Cumbrian Lake District. It was soon found that there FIgure 19 Muscle rachocaectum values (Fig kg we/ ought) 1o3incinndua tic 0171De yoke were wide variations between lakes, fish Voter (-11= I ibb eind Lowesponier (n = 145) species and individuals of the same species in the same lake The objective of Overall geometric means for Radiocaesium content increased with fish the present investigation was to evaluate radiocaesium in brown trout (540 Bq kg) weight for wild trout from both lakes, sources of variation in rachocaesium in and perch (1192 Bq ka ) m Devoke Water perch from Devoke Water but not perch fish from two lakes. Devoke Water and were significantly higher than those in or pike from Loweswater Values for Loweswater. This work was performed in Loweswater (trout 404. perch 989 Bg kg -). perch were generally higher than those conjunction with staff from the Ministry of and mean values for perch were for trout in Devoke Water (Figure 18). and Agriculture. Fisheries and Food (MAFF) significantly higher than means for trout in the power-function relationship between and was supported financially by NERC both lakes. Mean values for pike (568 Bq radiocaesium content and fish weight and the Commission of the European kg ) in Loweswater lay between the invalidates the use of uncorrected means Communities. values for trout and perch. for temporal comparisons. Radiocaesium 3000- values in pre-Chernobyl trout and stocked trout were markedly lower than those in post-Chernobyl wild trout (Figure 113)This discrepancy between wild and 1000 • recently stocked trout provides strong 5 evidence that the food chain rather than kg • the water is the main route of SOO radiocaesium transfer to the fish. Bq (R The stomach contents of [rout and perch from Devoke water indicated a diverse 00 diet from zooplankton to sticklebacks. Both the trout and perch were in good 100 condition according to their length-weight • relationships and there was no indication radioactivity that diet differences had any significant Stocked trout 50 effect on the radiocaesium content of individual fish. Muscle • • There was a large variation in radiocaesium values between individual • Pre-Chernobyl fish, as data for trout from both lakes 10 1 1 1 1 1 , 1 i 1 LDS_ ' clearly show (Figure 19). When these 10 50 100 500 1000 Wet weight (Wg) values were scaled to a standard weight Figure 18 Relationship between muscle rad:cacti1/2W (R Bq kg.) and Net weight bilSci) for individual of trout to remove the marked effect of fish h1=:7:,: LIsig and r., , ,i from awoke Water regression lines are btted for both specles bui values for size, monthly geometric means for 18 stocked gout and 2 pre-Chernobyl gout were omitted from analysis (points enclosed by broken radiocaesium increased from April/May line). 1986 to a maximum in October 1986 in
13 Devokc Water and February 1987 in relative value of planting out unfed salmon Loweswater, then decreased parr or of feeding the parr in the hatchery exponentially at a slow rate in Devoke for rive weeks before planting. Studies Water and a fast rate in Loweswater, and made by MAFF in natural streams and finally increased slightly in Loweswater rivers have the Advantage of dealing with only (Figure 20). Geometric means for the "real world" but suffer some perch and pike followed a pattern sinElat problems in interpretation of the results to that for trout, except that maxima because of difficulties of control and occurred in Februaiy/March 1987 for replication. The studies by IFE have used perch,in both lakes and in lune 1987 for the Grasshohne channels (Figure 21) as pike in Toweswater "streams" to be stocked. The four chamiels can be set up as replicates in Although this work has evaluated some le= of Row and bed material and the sources of vanation in fddlocaesirun numbers of fish leaving the channels and content in fish, especially the effects of fish dying in the channels can be accurately size and diet, it has also shown that there determined The four channels provide ale many unsolved problems. Differences two replicates of each of the two between species may be due to different neatments (stocking with unfed parr and metabolic rates (for example, different stocking with 5 weeks fed pan-) (Figure rates of gastric evacuation), and 22) The results from these small artificial differences between takes may be due to streams and those obtained from real variations in their limnology and the streams are complementaiy to one nature of their catchments. These and another and will be published jointly related problems are now being licr 21 G—me. )1 Grasknolme investigated. Preliminary data analyses suggest that 10 chant r m Thrly dna' Isi weeks after the commencement ot tyttie. Studies on strategies for the feeding, the fish stocked as unfed parr have a higher mean weight than the Esh planting of young, hatchery stocked as fed parr, but only about half Assessment of stress in wild reared salmon the population density Similar populations of fish As pan of a wider contract for MAFF, experiments are now in progress with Exposure of fish to environmental stress short-term studies have been made in trout. induces a complex series of physiological recent years in an attempt to Assess the changes. collectively Diown as the stress response A key element of the response 1000 Devoke Water is activation of the hypothalamio-pitunary- • interrenal axis, resulting in elevation of the • • hormone conisol. Atthough In the short- term. the stress response is believed to be of adaptive value to the fish, in the longer term, unalleviated, or chronic. stress can be very damaging Cortisol 500 itself has been implicated as a causal ') • kg Bq
(GM
1000 Loweswater
radioactivity
PILTI. 2.2A r dilli on (So'ne ['an- Muscle 500 •
0 1111 1986 1987 1988 Months Figure 20 Relationship between geometric mean (GM) rachoactithly in hi OlVn trout (GM Sri kg I time 0 months from May 19862 for Dedoke Water and &ayes-water (bmken /mos simply snow /roods, solid lines are exponential curves)
14 factor in stress-induced reduction of growth, disruption of the reproductive ml system, arid immunosuppression. ml Furthermore, the fact that cortisol elevation is a consistent feature of the (ng stress response has led to its use as a 160 (pg 16 reliable index of stress, Although most of our work, and that of others, has concentrated on the study of the effects of steroids environmental stress on fish within the steroids controlled conditions provided by the aquacultural environment, the 120 12 measurement of plasma cortisol levels provides a potentially useful diagnostic tool for assessing the likely effects of environmental stress on natural conjugated populations of fish. However, despite the 80 8 fact that plasma conisol levels are a good immunoreactive indicator of stress, their very lability under conditions of stress is a problem. A clear free demonstration of this is provided by removing fish individually from a single 40 4 holding tank. After a few minutes, plasma conisol levels in consecutive fish show a biliary stepwise increment, due to the immunoreactive disturbance associated with the removal and of previous fish (Figure 23). Under 0 0 controlled experimental conditions, this Con Ac Chr Con Ac Chr Biliary Con Ac Chr problem can be overcome, but, when sampling from wild populations, Plasma Plasma Bihary free Biliary prolonged disturbance of the fish is often cortisol steroids conjugated unavoidable, particularly if trapping or steroids netting is necessary to remove individuals. We have therefore been looking for an alternative to plasma Figure 24 The levels of cortisol In the blood, and free and conjugated corlicostemids in the bile for rainbow trout al rest (Con), following one hour of acute stress (AO and following twenty-four bows ol cortisol levels to indicate the "stress chromc stress (Chi). each value Is die mean for 10 fish ± SE status" of fish; an indicator of stress that is stable during short-term disturbance, such as that needed to sample the fish. When fish secrete large amounts of a levels in fish subjected to no stress at all. hormone into the bloodstream, as is the Both acute and chronic stress significantly 90 case with cortisol during stress, rather elevated blood conisol levels when ') ml than being allowed to accumulate in the compared to those of the unstressed fish blood, the hormone is removed. or (Figure 24). However, acute stress had no (ng - cleared". Clearance of cortisol occurs effect on the levels of unconjugated and 50 via two routes, the kidney (in the urine). conjugated derivatives of cortisol in the cornsol and the liver (in the bile), In addition, to bile. The levels of these compounds only aid clearance, the hormone is usually become elevated after exposure to metabolised to an inactive derivative, and prolonged stress. Therefore, Plasma Io cnemically conjugated to another measurement of the levels of steroid 3 5 II 1111121 molecule to enhance its solubility in water. derivatives in the bile of fish appears to Fish number We studied the accumulation of cortisol provide a way of avoiding the and its derivatives in the bile of fish confounding effects of capture stress Figure 23 Relationship between the order in exposed to a brief stress (1 h of when attempting to estabhsh the "stress which gout are removed from a tank and their plasma corbsol level; each value is the mean for confinement) and a prolonged stress (24 h status- of wild populations of fish l 6 fish ± of confinement) and compared these with
15 Microbes in the aquatic environment
An epibiont on Chromatium During August 1990 a sulphidd rich solution lake in central Spain was studied jointly with the University of Valencia In this lake a dense popiilation of the large (5 x 3 pm) purple photosynthetic bacterium Chrernahurn okenh developed at 9 m 2`'tiof the depth in anoxic water About population carried a small (2 pm), non- motile epibiont. The embiont with its host. were prepared for electron microscopy and an unusual and apparently unique life cycle was revealed (Figures 25a, b). Chromahurn is often found close to the top of the anoxic hypolannion in lakes, espectally if suffacient hydrogen sulphide is available (which the photosynthetic bacterium uses as reductant in the presence of light). Like most aquatic phototrophs, Chnomatium excretes dissolved organic carbon (DOC), and because cell densities are so high, the Chroma hum cells effectively swim around in a 'soup' of DOC of their own making. It is this DOC which, we believe, sustains the eplanont on the Chromahum By remaining attached to the outside of the Chromahum, the epibiont profits not so much from material provided by its own host, as from DOC produced by the large number of neighbours of its own host.
After dividing once or twice, the epibiont produces a tail-like, detachable infective stage. This is transferred to another Chromahum cell by physical contact. and Fachare25a Life cycie bacterium in-mg an die the 'tail' develops into a mature organism ph=sy ediesc riartetrun Chrornattum of the next generation It appears that the Stage 1 Epithet?! art Can-owau= ;hi ansvilissine extremely high population densities Electron hhcregllsph x217e(ii2; achieved by Chromatium are critical to Stage 2 Mature etualutatut TEM:L:7(RM) the success of the epibiont - both for the tew 3 Sphiem vilh ;elective 'UV (1S:cunning completion of its life cycle and for the Lied= Micrograph 221000) Stage 4 Eplloioni inches sole& e 110111 provision of dissolved organic carbon to 25ll nghh Thansevss,-, second Chi carnatium sell (TEM of tall x5500u) hheregaeph ef enta e ChatitriatLure. support its growth. Sage 5 infective trzu2sIeneci lo second ChaernenUrr This epitaarit L villdearticr tote Genetics of freshwater lage I CIT71 K52000). bacteria Studies in this area remain focused on the developed to detect recombinant for positive identification) appears to he transfer of genes and the detection of pseudomonads carrying a colonmemc approximately IC cells ml , which is specific bacteria in the freshwater marker gene. Some of the techniques that equivalent to the target organism environment. Work on the detection of have been developed do not necessitate accountino for <1"0 of the total number of genetically modified microorganisms culturing the target organisms. This is bacteria in lake water. As a result of the (GMMOs) is carried out in collaboration important because, following their release need for the containment of GMMOs. with the Department of Genetics and into freshwater, it may not be possible to microcosms that IMF= the natural Microbiology at Liverpool University. recover them using standard environment have been developed Using Pseudornonas puhda and other bacteriological methods, yet they may Molecular techniques for the detection of freshwater pseudomonads as model remain viable within the sample. These GMMOs are being ex-tended to include recombinant organisms. an assessment techniques include bioassay, DNA fundamental studies in aquatic has been made of their ability to survive, hybridisation and immunological bacteriology A basic problem is the and the fate of their recombinant genes. A detection. In general. the detection limit diversity of organisms encountered in range of molecular techniques has been (ie the minimum number of cells required most natural environments, but the
16
diversity of aquatic ammonia-oxidising Science Education. in Birmingham in Imow that energy generation in anaerobic bacteria (nitrifiers) is considered to be January 1991. Interest in the distribution of protozoa with hydrogenosomes leads to relatively low, thus permitting the CCAP educational resource materials in the production of hydrogen, and that application of such techniques. Some the USA has led to discussions with a hydrogen is a prime requirement of success has been achieved (in North American distributor, methanogens, we can expect some collaboration with Liverpool University) in correlation between the synthesis of new the development of DNA probes to detect There has been significant progress with protozoan biomass and the production of and identify ammonia oxidisers obtained cryopreservation, and with the new methanogens. This correlation is from culture collections. These probes development of new and improved clearly illustrated in Figure 26 which are now being applied to natural techniques for the preservation of some shows data from the ciliate Metopus communities strains of protozoa, especially small palaeformis. The data are taken from amoebae. Following adaptation to axenic ciliates of all sizes and all physiological Electron microscopy culture, all the Naegleria strains in the states. The volume fraction of Electron microscopy continues to be used Collection are now cryopreserved, with methanogens within the ciliates stays within a wide range of projects. The two high post-thawing survival rates. relatively constant, at around 1% of that of principal projects making use of the Improved methods continue to be the protozoan host. This would imply that department's facilities in the past year developed. These will permit a greater methanogen production is simply a were: an investigation of the transport of range of CCAP cultures to be passive consequence of ciliate growth: fine and flocculated particles in rivers ciwopreserved, leading to significant cost the rate of hydrogen production by the under different flow conditions; and the savings. ciliate will maintain a certain bacterial investigation of the ultrastructure of biomass growing at a rate which anaerobic protozoa and their methane- Anaerobic protozoa corresponds to that of the host ciliate, But producing bacterial endosymbionts. A We have shown that the bacteria which our continuing investigation indicates that study of bacterial parasites of salmonid live inside anaerobic ciliates do produce the interaction may be more complex. fishes and their possible control by methane (so they are methanogens) and The ciliates seem to exert some subtle selected bacteriophages has also begun that their growth, al least within the one control over the methanogens, dictating using high resolution transmission ciliate species investigated, is coupled to when the latter undergo what appears to electron microscopy. the growth of the host ciliate. In all be synchronous cell division. This work protozoa most energy generation goes continues with the fruitful collaboration of Various algal cultures have been towards the synthesis of the the Marine Biological Laboratory examined for CCAP, and some novel macromolecules required for new growth (University of Copenhagen), Helsingor, bacterial reproductive structures have (eg proteins, nucleic acids). Since we Denmark. been examined in collaboration with Lancashire Polytechnic, The electron microscope facilities also supported the work of a visiting scientist from Leningrad studying the feasibility of cryo-preserving large amoebae, and scientists from the • University of Valencia studying the ciliate structure and life cycle of the bacterial 200 — epibiont on Chromatium (see above). per • Culture Collection of Algae and Protozoa (CCAP) • • CCAP and its activities were reviewed in • 1990. The Review Group realised the (pm') • academic and commercial importance of • • the Culture Collection and the need to •• • • continue to support it. The major changes in structure were the appointment of a • • •••• •• • • ••• single Curator for both freshwater algae 100 • 0 • and protozoa, and the making permanent • "6 i.s of previously period appointments. CCAP biovolume 66 •• ,_•• ,..„, • /•••• • • continues to be one of the major depositories for microalgae, ••• itapa- •; cyanobacteria and protozoa, and as such all••••• • • • it is becoming increasingly recognised as • al 11 • an internationally important genetic Oak )•0 • 14,10• •• • resource centre. The service role of CCAP continues to expand as greater co4 numbers of cultures are ordered, • particularly by clients interested in algal Methanogen biotechnology and ecotoxicity testing. 10000 20000 Other services include contract research and the provision of a safe depository service. CCAP education services remain closely associated with the Shell Education Service, with another Individual ciliate biovolume (pm) successful display of CCAP products at Figire 26 Relationship between individual cell volumes of the ciliate Melopus paleeformis and the the annual exhibition of the Association for total volume of methanogen symbionts each ciliate contains.
17 Physico-chemical processes in catchments
The transport of radionuclides through the Chernobyl Weapons Testing natural environment Radioactive fallout on Curnbrian 98o lakes On 26 April 1986. a major accident Easily occurred in reactor of the Chernobyl Soluble 72% nuclear power station in the Ukraman Republic of the Soviet Union. Up to 2030 of the fission and activation products in the Insoluble reactor have been estimated to have escaped over a period of the next 11 days. after which time emissions suddenly 28% ceased. The emissions were of two types: small particles of fuel rods with their Sediment Air Air Sediment casings, and gaseous products which either remained in the atmosphere in that form or which condensed to form very fine particulate material. The fuel rod Figure 27 'The relaLve proponions of caesium lapin different soi trees which al o easily soluble and particles contained high concentrations of effectively insoluble in water The Chernobyl matenal in air Vids sampled on 3 May 1986 Weapons uranium, plutonium, strontium and lest matepal was a composite sample from 1959 Sediment samples were obtained from different ruthenium, as the main components Since depths sti a sediment core taken February 1987 the particles were relatively large they were mainly deposited within I0 kin of the plant, although small numbers of particles although it absorbs onto particles it due to a slow transport of caesium into the have been reported from areas as far prefers to be in solution: it is easy to middle of clay mineral particles, from apart as Sweden and Greece. However, measure in environmental samples. and it where it is very difficult to extract it, ie it is the radioactive cloud which drifted over is actively taken up by animals and plants essentially locked in an unavailable store. Europe for several days and eventually as it has very similar properties to Transfer from water to sediment reached the UK, consisted of potassium. condensation products, mainly 131- The major study dunng the first year after Iodine, 137-Caesium, 134-Caesium, 103- There was an early impression that the the accident concentrated on measurements in two lakes, Windermere Ruthenium and 106-Ruthenium (plus some Chernobyl caesium was more readily other very short-lived isotopes) available than the deposition following (north basin) and Esthwaite Water. atmospheric testing of atomic weapons. In Although the lakes are located within 2 km Although most of the UK received a collaborative programme with the of each other, the former is a deep (65 m), relatively small amounts of deposition. the National Radiological Protection Board mesotrophic lake while the latter is passage of the cloud of radioactivity over and the Atomic Energy Authority, Harwell, shallow (15 m) and hypereutrophic. The Cumbria on 3 May coincided with very samples of atmospheric particulate change with time in observed activity in heavy rain, so that the highest levels of material from the Chernobyl peak and the water column of Esthwaite Water is deposition in the country were recorded from just before the peak of the weapons shown in Figure 28. Both lakes behaved in this region. In conjunction with the fallout (1959) were sequentially extracted similarly, showing a rapid reduction of Institute of Terrestrial Ecology and the using a series of chemical solutions and activity, with levels reducing by 50% University of Lancaster a programme of the chemical forms of caesium were within 13 days in Esthwaite and 70 days in work to study the processes of transport compared. Approximately 70' irof the Windermere. The patterns of change of radioactive material through the natural Chernobyl material was found to be shown by caesium activity in the deeper aquatic environment was rapidly soluble in water whereas only 8% of the (hypolimnetic) and shallower developed, starting within a few days of weapons fallout was soluble (Figure 27). (epilimnetic) water reflect the stratification the accident (funded by Her Majesty's Although definite interpretation of these and mixing of the water. Hence, while Inspectorate of Pollution and later by the results was clouded by the possibility that activity in the surface fell continuously, Commission of the European changes had taken place in the weapons activity in the bottom water remained Communities (GEC)), Since 131-lodine test material during its 29 years of constant from soon after the deposition has a very short half life (eight days) the storage, this was the first hard evidence of until the autumn. This was a result of majority of the studies used a difference in availability Another thennal stratification of the water column, measurements of caesium isotopes interesting factor was that within nine which isolated the bottom waters from the although a small amount of ruthenium data months of the deposition, less than 10% of removal processes operating in the was obtained. However, there are good the caesium from Chernobyl was found to surface waters. scientific reasons for studying the be easily soluble when sediments from transport of caesium as a typical "tracer" the bottom of Winderrnere were The removal of radionuclides from the element: it has a very simple chemical subjected to the same treatment. It has water colunm resulted from three form (monovalent cation) in solution; now been shown that this phenomenon is processes: flushing out from the lake of
18
N.