Published in: The New England Journal of History Winter, 2001, Vol. 57, No. 2, pp. 59-83 Power To The People: The Progressive Movement for the Recall, 1890s-1920 Rod Farmer Rod Farmer, Ph.D. Franklin Hall 252 Main St. University of Maine at Farmington Farmington, Maine 04938 Phone: (207) 778-7161 (office) (207) 778-9298 (home) Email:
[email protected] Fax: 207 778-7157 Historian Warren Susman said of the people of the United States that: “The American is most characteristically a reformer and his history a series of reforms.” Susman saw “an almost continual impulse to reform from the days of the first English settlers on this continent who 1 proposed from the start nothing less than.....the establishment of the Kingdom of God.” Each generation of Americans has had its particular collection of reform efforts. That period known as the Progressive Era, from the 1890s to around 1920, brought a great change to American life by implanting in the nation the idea that government should be more proactive in solving economic and social problems and more responsible for creating a just and humane society. However, for most progressives, this enlarged government was also to be a more democratic government, because only a more democratic government could be trusted with the new powers and responsibilities. Historian Arthur S. Link found that, beginning in the 1890s, there “were many progressive movements on many levels seeking sometimes contradictory objectives” and that “despite its actual diversity and inner tensions it did seem to have unity; that is, it seemed to share 2 common ideals and objectives.” This paper will hold that the democratic ideal was one of those common ideals shared by most progressives, and this ideal can be identified in the crusade for the recall.