Programs in Nepal
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Programmatic Evaluation of Search for Common Ground (SFCG) Programs in Nepal Report Submitted to Search For Common Ground Lazimpat, Kathmandu Report Submitted by Tulasi R. Nepal, Consultant Sagun Basnet, Consultant Prakash Bhattarai, Consultant Shiva K. Dhungana, SFCG, Nepal September, 2010 Acronyms AFN Antenna Foundation Nepal ARD ARD Inc. CA Constituent Assembly CAAC Children Affected by Armed Conflict CAFAAG Children involved in Armed Conflict and Armed Group CFUG Community Forestry Users’Groups COE Criteria of Effectiveness CPN Communist Party of Nepal DDC District Development Committee DM&E Design, Monitoring and Evaluation FD Farakilo Dharti KD Khulla Dharti FGD Focused Group Discussion FM Frequency Modulation FMDC Far-west Media Development Centre HRPLSC Human Rights Protection and Legal Service Centre KII Key Informant Interview LDM Local Decision Makers LPCs Local Peace Committees NED National Endowment Fund for Democracy NGO Non-Governmental Organization NW New World PSAs Public Service Announcements PWL Peace Writ Large R4PB Radio for Peacebuilding RPP Reflecting on Peace Practice SB Sunou Bolou SFCG Search for Common Ground TOC Theory of Change UNIFEM UN Fund for Women VDC Village Development Committee WOREC Women Rehabilitation Centre YLT Youth Leadership Training YN Youth Network ii Acknowledgements On behalf of the evaluation team, I thank those who took part in the evaluation process as participants and provided information to our queries during our visits and interviews. Without their generosity, our evaluation would not have been completed. Thanks are due to the SFCG Nepal program team for availing us this opportunity. Sincere thanks goes to Serena Rix Tripathee, Country Director, and SFCG Nepal for important feedbacks and challenging questions. Rajendra Mulmi, Director of Programs deserves earnest thanks for his ever-willingness to support and amazing togetherness compounded by ideas to complete this evaluation. In fact, their encouraging gestures and words have always incredibly bolstered our work and motivation. I would like to extend my team’s best appreciation to Design Monitoring and Evaluation Specialist of SFCG, Shiva K. Dhungana for his constant involvement through the evaluation design, field visit and report writing. His guidance, motivation and support have been instrumental for the completion of this task. The SFCG staff, Community Peacebuilding team, Media team and also the Finance team at the centre as well as in the field has been very much cooperative and willing to arrange our visits, interviews and meetings. Their open and honest opinions on the topics of evaluation have given us so much. Similarly, the members of the Youth Networks and the youth clubs; and the staff members of the NGO partners have also made this evaluation possible with their positive support for arranging the meetings and visits on one hand, and their honest opinion about the situation on the other. I would like to acknowledge the hard work that Sagun, one of the evaluation team members, have put and also her extra efforts to finish the report on time by coordinating among us. Her sense of belongingness to this work is praiseworthy. Similarly, I also extend my thanks to another team member Prakash, for his hard work and ever smiling gestures and positivity even in difficult times during the field trips. Last, but not least, we also acknowledge the efforts put by the support staff of SFCG Nepal and all other known, unknown individuals who have helped bring the evaluation to a reporting format. Tulasi R Nepal Evaluation Team Leader iii Table of Contents Acronyms ........................................................................................................................................ ii Acknowledgements ....................................................................................................................... iii Executive Summary ....................................................................................................................... 1 Chapter 1 Introduction ................................................................................................................ 10 1.1 BACKGROUND ................................................................................................................. 10 1.2 PROJECT SUMMARY ..................................................................................................... 10 1.4 CONTEXT .......................................................................................................................... 15 1.5 STRUCTURE OF THE REPORT .................................................................................... 18 Chapter 2 Evaluation Design ....................................................................................................... 19 2.1 EVALUATION FRAMEWORK ...................................................................................... 19 2.2 EVALUATION METHODOLOGY ................................................................................. 21 2.3 LIMITATIONS OF THE EVALUATION....................................................................... 22 Chapter 3 Program Effectiveness ............................................................................................... 23 3.1 STRATEGIC GOAL AND OBJECTIVES ...................................................................... 23 3.2 PROGRAM APPROACH ................................................................................................. 28 3.3 OUTPUTS AND DELIVERABLES ................................................................................. 28 3.3.1 Capacity Building .......................................................................................................... 29 3.3.2 Media Programming ...................................................................................................... 32 3.3.3 Support to Community Peacebuilding ........................................................................... 34 3.4 PARTNERSHIPS ............................................................................................................... 38 3.4.1 Observations on Partnership ...................................................................................... 38 3.4.2 The Synergy between Partner’s programs ..................................................................... 44 3.5 SUSTAINABILITY ............................................................................................................ 44 3.6 ATTRIBUTION .................................................................................................................. 45 Chapter 4 Peace Effectiveness ..................................................................................................... 46 iv 4.1 CRITERIA OF EFFECTIVENESS .................................................................................. 46 4.1.1 Creation of reform of institutions of mechanisms ......................................................... 46 4.1.2 Independent peace initiatives that decrease dividers and increase connectors ............ 47 4.1.3 Resistance to violence and provocations to violence .................................................... 48 4.1.4 Increase in People's Security and Sense of Security ...................................................... 49 4.1.5 Meaningful improvement in inter-group relations ........................................................ 50 4.2 STRATEGIC LINKAGES ................................................................................................ 51 4.3 UNINTENDED IMPACTS ................................................................................................ 55 Chapter 5 Theory of Change Effectiveness ................................................................................ 56 Chapter 6 Key Findings ............................................................................................................... 66 6.1 PROGRAM EFFECTIVENESS ....................................................................................... 66 6.2 PEACE EFFECTIVENESS ............................................................................................... 69 6.3 THEORY OF CHANGE EFFECTIVENESS .................................................................. 71 Chapter 7 Challenges and Recommendations ........................................................................... 73 7.1 Challenges ........................................................................................................................... 73 7.2 Recommendations .............................................................................................................. 75 Chapter 8 Conclusion ................................................................................................................... 80 Annexes.......................................................................................................................................... 82 Annex 1: ToR for Evaluation .................................................................................................. 82 Evaluator’s Role ....................................................................................................................... 89 Annex 2: Field Visit Schedule .................................................................................................. 91 Annex 3: People met and interviewed .................................................................................... 94 Annex 4: Checklist Questionnaire .......................................................................................