Doctoring the Mind : Why Psychiatric Treatments Fail Pdf, Epub, Ebook
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
DOCTORING THE MIND : WHY PSYCHIATRIC TREATMENTS FAIL PDF, EPUB, EBOOK Richard P Bentall | 384 pages | 03 Jun 2010 | Penguin Books Ltd | 9780141023694 | English | London, United Kingdom Doctoring the Mind : Why psychiatric treatments fail PDF Book Dewey Decimal. A must for those who question the medical model of 'mental illness' and those who don't! Towards the end of the twentieth century, the solution to mental illness seemed to be found. Add to cart. Doctoring the Mind by Richard P Bentall is a book of big words and lots of them. Which is also why I'm convinced CBT alone will not work with severe long-term mental illness, certainly not if it lasts a mere 6 months. Victoria rated it really liked it Jul 21, Original Title. Be the first to write a review About this product. Share Full Text for Free beta. To say that, just because we haven't found enough convincing evidence for the biological underpinnings a better word than "causes" of mental illness, we should abandon all research is downright shameful coming from the mouth of a scientific researcher! Get unlimited, online access to over 18 million full- text articles from more than 15, scientific journals. Although I don't see how these psychological mechanisms exclude the role of intrinsic biology for some people! He also doesn't hesitate to comment on those parts who are missing or problematic for both sides of the psych-med debate. Log in. Return to Book Page. That is, chemical imbalance in brain needs to be re-balanced using drugs. This view is backed with ongoing review of scientific research, and it should be noted that the narrative remains neutral throughout, steering clear of scaremongering. The Observer. He puts the patient back at the heart of treatment for mental illness, making the case that a good relationship between patients and their doctors is the most important indicator of whether someone will recover. Bentall, a professor of clinical psychology himself, can hardly be the most disinterested commentator on these arguments, but he has produced a lucid and accessible account of a tricky but endlessly absorbing subject. The book features a short history of psychiatry , also covering anti-psychiatry and clinical psychology. In fact, epigenetics, an even more interesting field of study to me, would agree that genes clearly have a complex relationship with our environment and life circumstances. Although not entirely either since I've read several accounts of good care in the USA as well. It simply hasn't given me any. Honestly, if I hadn't finished the book, I would've come away with the conclusion that he was the definitely part of what I call the "Church of Psychotherapy" branch of the anti-psychiatry movement. Buy from…. It's as if he couldn't really make up his mind about his feelings and conclusions regarding psychiatry. It also makes me very, very glad that I do not have a mental illness, at least, not one evident enough to make me conspicuous to these bastards. Details if other :. Independent Premium Comments can be posted by members of our membership scheme, Independent Premium. Health Mind Books. Although the precise mechanism by which chlorpromazine seemed to calm psychotic patients remains unclear to this day, the drug heralded a step forward from the psychiatric treatments that preceded it, which included electroshocks, insulin comas and, most notoriously, crude, ice-pick lobotomies of the sort carried out on Rosemary Kennedy, sister of JFK, leaving her virtually speechless, incontinent and incapable of independent living. There are no discussion topics on this book yet. Rating details. There are no Independent Premium comments yet - be the first to add your thoughts. New other. Although you might as well buy a CBT workbook and do it yourself. Not to be copied, transmitted or recorded in any way, in whole or part, without prior permission of the publishers. Mateusz rated it it was amazing Jan 31, Towards the end of the twentieth century, the solution to mental illness seemed to be found. He also doesn't hesitate to comment on those parts who are missing or problematic for both sides of the psych-med debate. After being awarded his doctorate, he moved to the University of Liverpool to undertake professional training as a Clinical Psychologist. Anneka rated it liked it Jan 06, This book is mostly opposed to precisely this definition of madness. Create a commenting name to join the debate Submit. You can see your Bookmarks on your DeepDyve Library. Chris rated it did not like it Sep 16, Showing Doctoring the Mind : Why psychiatric treatments fail Writer I was impressed by the body of literature he presents to support his arguements. Goodreads helps you keep track of books you want to read. Nevertheless, Bentall is never dogmatic and recognizes the benevolent intent of psychiatrists to help their patients. Want to Read saving…. I really have no patience for it. And while some studies indicate a weak genetic component in severe mental illness, others point to a much stronger correlation with environmental stress. If anything, neuroscience, in emphasising the brain's failures, has advocated a more simplistic approach: a chemical imbalance in the brain? But it only goes so far. Angie rated it really liked it Feb 08, Related Articles. This is not nearly as easy a question to answer as you might think. He later returned to his alma mater of Liverpool to work as a lecturer, after a brief stint working for the National Health Service as a Forensic Clinical Psychologist. The existing Open Comments threads will continue to exist for those who do not subscribe to Independent Premium. Biological psychiatry had triumphed. Mark rated it it was amazing Aug 01, Richard Bentall picks apart the science that underlies current psychiatric practice across the US and UK. Okay, granted, antipsychotics are probably more physiologically dangerous than any kind of therapy except when it's so pointless that the patient, stuck with despair, ends up killing himself. Although there is some evidence indicating a connection between excess dopamine in the brain and the onset of psychosis, the connection between serotonin deficiency and depression, a connection presumed by drugs like Prozac, has never been proven. Bedside manners are fundamental, compassion should be a requirement. Want to bookmark your favourite articles and stories to read or reference later? Other editions. Some good points in particular his criticism of the genetic studies GWAS with Ill defined parameters. Preview — Doctoring the Mind by Richard P. It lay in biological solutions, focusing on mental illness as a problem of the brain, to be managed or improved through drugs. Other Editions 8. Emotional Female. Our top books, exclusive content and competitions. Preview — Doctoring the Mind by Richard P. Shop for Books on Google Play Browse the world's largest eBookstore and start reading today on the web, tablet, phone, or ereader. Aug 08, John W rated it really liked it. He goes overboard at times tho, which I feel lessens his argument overall. Green; Kelechi Ubozoh. Benthall is a research psychologist and goes through the history of psychiatric treatments in relation to psychotic illnesses, such as bi-polar and schizophrenia, although he does touch upon depression. This is another myth that is attacked in this book. Will finish it Kelly Buck rated it it was amazing Dec 01, Biological psychiatry had triumphed. Get print book. There is little agreement about what constitutes any mental illness. Jan 22, harrie kd added it. Doctoring the Mind : Why psychiatric treatments fail Reviews The author does a pretty decent job of critiquing the role of medication in the treatment of mental illness, but clearly didn't go in as deep with psychotherapy not as many notes and references, for one. This is probably the result of his personal bias. Error rating book. If you're lucky, they'll have actual therapeutical tools, backed by at least some theory and evidence, that can help. Starting with surprising evidence from the World Health Organization that suggests that people recover better from mental illness in a developing country than in the first world, Doctoring the Mind asks the question: how good are our mental healthcare services, really? It lay in biological solutions, focusing on mental illness as a problem of the brain, to be managed or improved through drugs. Sign up to our newsletter using your email. Conversely, why aren't sufferers automatically cured as soon as their life circumstances improve? But what could be wrong with your brain? And it's as true for medications as it is for psychotherapy. Print Hardcover and Paperback. Biological psychiatry had triumphed. Yet, even today, Bentall argues, studies on the connection between mental illness, brain chemistry and heritability remain inconclusive. Please follow the detailed Help center instructions to transfer the files to supported eReaders. Very refreshing and thought-provoking read. Also by Richard P Bentall. Which is all the more confusing when he admits, on the very same page, that conducting objective research on it's efficacy is even more difficult than it is for psychopharmacology. I'm not saying they don't exist, but clearly that statement doesn't represent a universally agreed upon consensus. As of now, it's woefully incomplete and short-sighted. The upshot is that the more intrusive treatments have in the past been held to be helpful when they were not: leucotomy, insulin coma, ECT and that drug treatments are often pursued at damaging levels since individual variation is not adequately allowed for. That is, chemical imbalance in brain needs to be re-balanced using drugs.