Site-Specific Labeling of Cellular Proteins with Unnatural Substrates of Biotin Ligases by Irwin Chen AB, Chemistry
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Site-specific Labeling of Cellular Proteins with Unnatural Substrates of Biotin Ligases by Irwin Chen A.B., Chemistry (2000) Harvard University M.S., Chemistry (2002) Stanford University Submitted to the Department of Chemistry in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology September 2007 © 2007 Massachusetts Institute of Technology All rights reserved Signature of the Author: ____________________________________________________ Department of Chemistry June 5, 2007 Certified by: _____________________________________________________________ Alice Y. Ting Pfizer-Laubach Associate Professor of Chemistry Thesis Supervisor Accepted by: _____________________________________________________________ Robert W. Field Chairman, Departmental Committee on Graduate Students This doctoral thesis has been examined by a committee of the Department of Chemistry as follows: ________________________________________________________________________ Timothy M. Swager John D. MacArthur Professor of Chemistry and Head of the Department Chair ________________________________________________________________________ Alice Y. Ting Pfizer-Laubach Associate Professor of Chemistry Thesis Supervisor ________________________________________________________________________ Barbara Imperiali Class of 1922 Professor of Chemistry and Professor of Biology 2 Site-specific Labeling of Cellular Proteins with Unnatural Substrates of Biotin Ligases by Irwin Chen Submitted to the Department of Chemistry on June 5, 2007 in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy ABSTRACT E. coli biotin ligase (BirA) catalyzes the site-specific ligation of biotin to the lysine within its 15-amino acid peptide substrate (AP). We harnessed the high peptide substrate specificity of BirA to develop a general methodology for site-specific protein labeling with biophysical probes. We synthesized an isosteric ketone analog of biotin and discovered that BirA also ligates it to the AP with similar kinetics while retaining the high peptide specificity of the native reaction. Because ketones are absent from native cell surfaces, recombinant AP-fused cell surface proteins can be tagged with the ketone analog, and then specifically conjugated to hydrazide- or hydroxylamine-functionalized molecules. We demonstrated this two-step protein labeling methodology on purified protein, in the context of mammalian cell lysate, and on epidermal growth factor receptor expressed on the surface of live HeLa cells. Both fluorescein and a benzophenone photoaffinity probe were incorporated, with total labeling times as short as 20 minutes. To develop new protein labeling methodology, we synthesized azide analogs of biotin, but found that BirA did not accept them as substrates. Our efforts to rationally design mutations in the active site to accommodate these analogs met with little success. We thus investigated in vitro compartmentalization as a platform for re-engineering the substrate specificity of BirA through in vitro evolution. Selections did not enrich for BirA mutants that could catalyze ligation of the azide analog to the AP, but instead highlighted the technical difficulties of our in vitro compartmentalization strategy. We used phage display to engineer a new and orthogonal biotin ligase-acceptor peptide pair for site-specific protein labeling. Yeast biotin ligase (yBL) does not biotinylate the AP, but we discovered a new 15-amino acid substrate for yBL, which we call the yeast acceptor peptide (yAP). The yAP is not biotinylated by BirA, and thus we were able to specifically label AP and yAP fusion proteins co-expressed in the same cell with differently colored quantum dots. We fused the yAP to a variety of recombinant proteins and demonstrated biotinylation by yBL at the N-terminus, C-terminus, and within a flexible internal region. yBL is also very sequence-specific, as endogenous proteins on the surface of yeast and HeLa cells are not biotinylated. This new methodology expands the scope of biotin ligase labeling to two-color imaging and yeast- based applications. Thesis Supervisor: Alice Y. Ting Title: Pfizer-Laubach Associate Professor of Chemistry 3 Acknowledgements I would first like to thank all of the people who have helped me edit this thesis. I thank my advisor, Professor Alice Y. Ting, for taking the time out to read drafts of most of my chapters. I also thank Dr. Hemanta Baruah and Yoon-Aa Choi for proofreading Chapters 5 and 6, respectively. Lastly, I am deeply grateful to my fiancée, Nicole DeBenedictis, for bravely venturing into the scientific arena and providing an extremely detailed and careful reading of my thesis for spelling and grammatical mistakes. Any remaining mistakes in this thesis are solely my own fault. Next, I thank the National Science Foundation Graduate Research Fellowship, the American Chemical Society Organic Division Fellowship sponsored by Wyeth Research, and Alice’s many grants for allowing me to live comfortably (for a graduate student) in Cambridge over the past five years. Lastly and most importantly, I am deeply grateful to many people who have contributed to my intellectual and personal growth over the past five years. First and foremost, I would like to thank Alice for her mentorship. I could never have imagined that my decision to join Alice’s fledgling lab would turn out so well. In the beginning she patiently taught me, a complete biology neophyte, all of the basic molecular biology techniques and knowledge that have finally become routine after over four years of practice. Towards the end of my graduate career, I appreciated her switch to a more hands-off approach, allowing me to try out my own ideas to solving problems. Throughout my time in her lab, her tireless enthusiasm and devotion to the members of her laboratory has been inspirational to me. From Alice I have learned how to improve my oral and written communication skills, which are critical to the success of any 4 scientific career. In particular, I thank her for the opportunities to present my work in front of her colleagues; those experiences have greatly helped me find a job and prepare my thesis defense. I remain deeply grateful to my former advisor at Stanford, Professor Barry Trost. His passion for science and devotion to being an educator continue to influence me. I am also grateful for the periodic kind words from Professor Justin Du Bois at Stanford. I thank Professor Stuart Licht for helpful discussions on kinetics and Professor K. Dane Wittrup for his help in troubleshooting yeast display. I also thank Professors Tim Swager and Barbara Imperiali for their helpful comments on this thesis. I am equally grateful to all past and present members of the Ting laboratory for teaching me valuable lessons in science and life. I wish you all the best of luck in your future endeavors. I thank Dr. Mark Howarth for his intellectual contributions to my first paper. I also thank Yoon-Aa for her enormous contributions to my last paper and Sarah Slavoff for enlightening me with her fascinating studies of other biotin ligases. I thank Hemanta, Yoon-Aa, Chi-wang Lin, Dr. Dan Chinnapen, Dr. Sujiet Puthenveetil, Dr. Yi Zheng, and Marta Fernandez-Suarez for their friendship and countless words of wisdom. I would like to give a special acknowledgement to the IVC subgroup (Hemanta, Dan, Yoon-Aa, Dr. Guobin Luo, E. Ken Hamill). I fondly remember our character-building struggles with “bands or no bands,” “the big dude,” and “Natasha.” I have also been blessed with the opportunity to work closely with a talented group of undergraduate researchers. I thank Eric McNeill for his great work on the Pauson-Khand route to “ketone biotin” and Lara Collazo for her invaluable help and 5 sunny disposition. I would also like to thank Jeremy Baskin, Karen Riesenburger, and Sean Liu for the fun times when we worked in Building 56. I would also like to thank my friends outside the MIT community for helping me maintain a life and perspective outside of the lab. In particular, I would like to thank Shai Sahay, Jon Man, Justin Saif, Mike Dillon, and Jimmy Young for their friendship. I am deeply grateful to my mother, father, and brother Ray for their kindness, empathy, generosity, and love over the years. Watching the Philadelphia Eagles play on Sunday afternoons with Ray was a great way to unwind after a long week of work. Finally, I am most grateful to my fiancée, Nicole. I am the lucky beneficiary of her patience, kindness, generosity, and love. I also thank her for stressing the importance of standing up for what I believe in, being proud of who I am, and adopting healthier dietary habits. My survival of the graduate school experience has greatly depended on her emotional support. I cannot imagine my future without her by my side. 6 Table of Contents Title Page ............................................................................................................................1 Signature Page....................................................................................................................2 Abstract...............................................................................................................................3 Acknowledgements ............................................................................................................4 Table of Contents ...............................................................................................................7 List