Download File

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Download File From the Schoolhouse to the Statehouse: The Role of Teach For America and Its Alumni in Education Policy Vikash Reddy Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy under the Executive Committee of the Graduate School of Arts and Sciences COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY 2016 ©2016 Vikash Reddy All rights reserved ABSTRACT From the Schoolhouse to the Statehouse: The Role of Teach For America and Its Alumni in Education Policy Vikash Reddy Teach For America (TFA) is a non-profit whose mission involves addressing and eliminating the racial achievement gap in education. To that end, TFA recruits and trains thousands of teachers each year, mostly recent college graduates, to spend two years teaching in low-income neighborhoods across America. The theory of change publicly espoused by TFA, however, includes a second component that is predicated on the notion that participation in TFA will be a “transformational experience” for those who join the organization – an experience that will turn participants into lifelong advocates for educational equity, and inform and influence their future endeavors. While TFA has long been a magnet for controversy, the criticisms have come to include the organization’s place in a policy context awash with neoliberal influences. Researchers have looked at the impact of TFA teachers on student outcomes with increasingly sophisticated research designs, but much less has been written about the second half of TFA’s theory of change. Further, while the exploits of TFA and its alumni in policy are increasingly the subject of both academic and popular articles, little of this research examines the role that the TFA experience is playing in the current work of TFA alumni in policy. Using data gathered from 45 semi-structured interviews with TFA alumni who now work in public policy, as well as news sources, public statements and press releases from TFA and its leadership and other publicly available materials, this dissertation examines the ways in which TFA and its alumni are involved in education policy, and how the TFA experience factors into the lives and work of these alumni. This study also examines the ways in which TFA and its alumni are engaged in matters of charter schools and school choice, teacher evaluation and accountability, and teacher preparation policy, as well as the ways in which alumni credit their TFA experience for influencing their views. Further, this work looks to separate the influences that come directly from TFA, such as TFA messaging or TFA-planned events, and those that are the result of joining TFA, but that fall outside of TFA’s immediate control. TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF TABLES ....................................................................................................................... iii PREFACE ..................................................................................................................................... vi I. POLICY AND POLITICAL CONTEXTS ............................................................................. 1 OVERVIEW OF DISSERTATION ...................................................................................................... 4 AMERICAN EDUCATION POLICY ................................................................................................... 5 AMERICAN EDUCATION REFORM – DOMINANT ACTORS AND INTEREST GROUPS ...................... 18 TODAY’S LANDSCAPE AND TFA ................................................................................................ 27 RESEARCH QUESTIONS ............................................................................................................... 33 CONCLUSION .............................................................................................................................. 34 II. BACKGROUND AND THEORETICAL CONTEXTS ..................................................... 36 TEACH FOR AMERICA ................................................................................................................ 36 SOCIAL MOVEMENT LITERATURE AND TFA .............................................................................. 44 RESEARCH AND LITERATURE ON TFA AND TFA ALUMNI.......................................................... 56 CONCLUSION .............................................................................................................................. 63 III. STUDY METHODOLOGY ................................................................................................ 65 RESEARCH QUESTIONS ............................................................................................................... 65 STUDY DESIGN ........................................................................................................................... 66 DATA SOURCES AND COLLECTION ............................................................................................. 67 DATA ANALYSIS ........................................................................................................................ 75 VALIDITY AND RELIABILITY ...................................................................................................... 76 LIMITATIONS .............................................................................................................................. 77 IV. ALUMNI REFLECTIONS ON CORPS EXPERIENCE ................................................. 79 MOTIVATION FOR JOINING TFA ................................................................................................. 80 GENERAL IMPACT OF TFA PARTICIPATION ................................................................................ 88 PLACEMENT SCHOOL CHALLENGES AND STRENGTHS ................................................................ 96 TEACHERS UNIONS ................................................................................................................... 105 CONCLUSION ............................................................................................................................ 109 V. ALUMNI REFLECTIONS ON POLICY AND THE IMPACT OF TFA ON POLICY PREFERENCES ....................................................................................................................... 113 CHARTER SCHOOLS AND SCHOOL CHOICE ............................................................................... 115 TEACHER EVALUATION AND ACCOUNTABILITY ....................................................................... 130 TEACHER PREPARATION ........................................................................................................... 138 CONCLUSION ............................................................................................................................ 150 VI. TFA, TFA ALUMNI, AND POLICY CHANGE ............................................................. 153 TEACH FOR AMERICA, LEADERSHIP FOR EDUCATIONAL EQUITY, AND THE POLICY WORLD ... 154 ALUMNI ENGAGEMENT WITH FORMAL AND INFORMAL NETWORKS ......................................... 172 LARGER POLITICAL QUESTIONS ............................................................................................... 184 CONCLUSION ............................................................................................................................ 198 VII. CONCLUSION ................................................................................................................. 201 TEACH FOR AMERICA PARTICIPATION ..................................................................................... 202 TEACH FOR AMERICA AND PUBLIC POLICY.............................................................................. 205 STUDY LIMITATIONS ................................................................................................................ 207 IMPLICATIONS .......................................................................................................................... 208 REFERENCES .......................................................................................................................... 212 Appendix A – Interview Protocol for TFA alumni ................................................................ 236 Appendix B – Alumni Interviewees ......................................................................................... 240 ii LIST OF TABLES Table 3.1: Sample – Corps Year ...................................................................................................70 Table 3.2: Sample – Corps Region ...............................................................................................71 Table 3.3: Sample – Current Occupations ....................................................................................72 iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS Words don’t exist to adequately thank my mom and my dad for their intellectual support, their emotional support, and their financial support through the writing of this dissertation, and throughout my graduate school experience. Their influence on this work can be traced far further back than their encouragement to pursue a Ph.D. They taught me how to read, write, and think critically about the world around me, and I owe more to them than I can express in the space afforded. The same goes for Dr. Shravanthi Reddy and Dr. Anjani Reddy. My attempts to escape their shadows may never meet success, but such attempts have always led to my best work. My committee members have been extraordinary, not just in their service here, but for everything they have taught me heretofore. Doug
Recommended publications
  • September 11 & 12 . 2008
    n e w y o r k c i t y s e p t e m b e r 11 & 12 . 2008 ServiceNation is a campaign for a new America; an America where citizens come together and take responsibility for the nation’s future. ServiceNation unites leaders from every sector of American society with hundreds of thousands of citizens in a national effort to call on the next President and Congress, leaders from all sectors, and our fellow Americans to create a new era of service and civic engagement in America, an era in which all Americans work together to try and solve our greatest and most persistent societal challenges. The ServiceNation Summit brings together 600 leaders of all ages and from every sector of American life—from universities and foundations, to businesses and government—to celebrate the power and potential of service, and to lay out a bold agenda for addressing society’s challenges through expanded opportunities for community and national service. 11:00-2:00 pm 9/11 DAY OF SERVICE Organized by myGoodDeed l o c a t i o n PS 124, 40 Division Street SEPTEMBER 11.2008 4:00-6:00 pm REGIstRATION l o c a t i o n Columbia University 9/11 DAY OF SERVICE 6:00-7:00 pm OUR ROLE, OUR VOICE, OUR SERVICE PRESIDENTIAL FORUM& 101 Young Leaders Building a Nation of Service l o c a t i o n Columbia University Usher Raymond, IV • RECORDING ARTIST, suMMIT YOUTH CHAIR 7:00-8:00 pm PRESIDEntIAL FORUM ON SERVICE Opening Program l o c a t i o n Columbia University Bill Novelli • CEO, AARP Laysha Ward • PRESIDENT, COMMUNITY RELATIONS AND TARGET FOUNDATION Lee Bollinger • PRESIDENT, COLUMBIA UNIVERSITY Governor David A.
    [Show full text]
  • Threat to Public Education Now Centers on Massachusetts
    THREAT TO PUBLIC EDUCATION NOW CENTERS ON MASSACHUSETTS May 2016 Preface This document updates and expands on Threat from the Right, an MTA task force report issued in May 2013. During the intervening years, the threat to public education, organized labor and social justice has grown substantially. Massachusetts is now in the crosshairs, with the forces behind charter schools, privatization and other attacks on the public good coalescing on Beacon Hill and throughout the state. That is reflected in the title of the 2016 edition, Threat to Public Education Now Centers on Massachusetts. No one should doubt the danger of the challenges outlined in these pages or the intensity of the forces behind them, which are national in scope. Nevertheless, winning the many fights we face is well within the power of the MTA and our allies — parents, students and other members of communities across Massachusetts and the nation. Understanding our opponents is an important step, and this report is intended to help us move toward meaningful victories as we continue to organize, mobilize and build the power we need to realize the goals of our Strategic Action Plan. Contents Introduction Elements of the Charter Campaign The Massachusetts Alignment ......................................................................................................7 Great Schools Massachusetts.......................................................................................................9 Families for Excellent Schools ....................................................................................................11
    [Show full text]
  • Joanne Barkan Is a Writer and a Member of the Editorial Board of Dissent Magazine. Her Recent Work Has Focused on Philanthropy A
    Joanne Barkan is a writer and a member of the editorial board of Dissent magazine. Her recent work has focused on philanthropy and democracy, private foundations, and the effort to remake public education in the United States. Barkan is the author of “Visions of Emancipation: The Italian Workers Movement Since 1945” (Praeger Publishers Inc., 1984) and was a regular contributor to the Rome-based daily newspaper Il Manifesto. She has also written many books of fiction, nonfiction, and verse for young readers. Jim Blew recently became president of StudentsFirst, the political and advocacy organization founded by former District of Columbia Public Schools Chancellor Michelle Rhee. For nearly 20 years before joining StudentsFirst, he advised the Walton family and the Walton Family Foundation on their K–12 reform investments. While serving as the foundation’s K–12 reform director, he helped guide more than $1 billion toward activists and educators who were striving to create high-quality school options for low- income communities across the country. At StudentsFirst, Blew is focusing more than 100 staff on policy opportunities in 12 states, combining his long-term commitment to educational choice with the pursuit of performance-based systems for teachers, administrators, and schools. From 2000 to 2005, Blew directed various campaigns for the Alliance for School Choice and its predecessor, the American Education Reform Council. Before committing himself full time to education reform, he worked at political and communications firms in New York and California. Stacey Childress is CEO at NewSchools Venture Fund. Before joining NewSchools, Childress led the K–12 Next Generation Learning team at the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, investing in schools and technologies that support personalized learning for middle and high school students in the United States.
    [Show full text]
  • Blackboard Bodhisattvas
    ! ! BLACKBOARD BODHISATTVAS: ! NARRATIVES OF NEW YORK CITY TEACHING FELLOWS ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! A DISSERTATION ! SUBMITTED TO THE GRADUATE SCHOOL OF EDUCATION ! AND THE COMMITTEE ON GRADUATE STUDIES ! OF STANFORD UNIVERSITY ! IN PARTIAL REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF ! DOCTOR OF PHILOSOPHY ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! Brian D. Edgar June, !2014 © 2014 by Brian Douglas Edgar. All Rights Reserved. Re-distributed by Stanford University under license with the author. This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution- Noncommercial 3.0 United States License. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/3.0/us/ This dissertation is online at: http://purl.stanford.edu/kw411by1694 ii I certify that I have read this dissertation and that, in my opinion, it is fully adequate in scope and quality as a dissertation for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. John Willinsky, Primary Adviser I certify that I have read this dissertation and that, in my opinion, it is fully adequate in scope and quality as a dissertation for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. David Labaree, Co-Adviser I certify that I have read this dissertation and that, in my opinion, it is fully adequate in scope and quality as a dissertation for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. Ari Kelman I certify that I have read this dissertation and that, in my opinion, it is fully adequate in scope and quality as a dissertation for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy. Raymond McDermott Approved for the Stanford University Committee on Graduate Studies. Patricia J. Gumport, Vice Provost for Graduate Education This signature page was generated electronically upon submission of this dissertation in electronic format.
    [Show full text]
  • Bipartisan, but Unfounded the Assault on Teachers’ Unions
    Bipartisan, But Unfounded The Assault on Teachers’ Unions By Richard D. Kahlenberg central impediment to educational progress in the United States. Part of the assault is unsurprising given its partisan origins. eachers’ unions are under unprecedented bipartisan Republicans have long been critical, going back to at least 1996, attack. The drumbeat is relentless, from governors in when presidential candidate Bob Dole scolded teachers’ unions: Wisconsin and Ohio to the film directors of Waiting for “If education were a war, you would be losing it. If it were a busi- “Superman” and The Lottery; from new lobbying groups ness, you would be driving it into bankruptcy. If it were a patient, Tlike Michelle Rhee’s StudentsFirst and Wall Street’s Democrats for it would be dying.” If you’re a Republican who wants to win elec- Education Reform to political columnists such as Jonathan Alter tions, going after teachers’ unions makes parochial sense. Accord- and George Will; from new books like political scientist Terry ing to Terry Moe, the National Education Association (NEA) and Moe’s Special Interest and entrepreneurial writer Steven Brill’s the American Federation of Teachers (AFT) gave 95 percent of Class Warfare to even, at times, members of the Obama adminis- their contributions to Democrats in federal elections between tration. The consistent message is that teachers’ unions are the 1989 and 2010.1 The nakedly partisan nature of Wisconsin Gover- nor Scott Walker’s attack on public sector collective bargaining Richard D. Kahlenberg, a senior fellow at the Century Foundation, is the was exposed when he exempted from his legislation two unions author or editor of several books, including Rewarding Strivers: Helping that supported him politically: one representing police officers Low-Income Students Succeed in College; Tough Liberal: Albert Shanker and the other representing firefighters.
    [Show full text]
  • Annual Report LETTER from the CHAIRMAN and the CEO & FOUNDER
    TFA priorities 2006 Annual Report LETTER FROM THE CHAIRMAN AND THE CEO & FOUNDER Dear Friends and Supporters, This is a particularly exciting time in the effort to ensure educational opportunity for all. At the end of 2006, The New York Times Magazine ran a cover story reflecting on the challenge of meeting the benchmarks of the No Child Left Behind Act and suggesting that in order to close the achievement gap that persists along socioeconomic and racial lines, we should look for lessons within the new crop of schools in low-income communities that are actually doing it. The article focused on lessons from KIPP, Achievement First, and Uncommon Schools—three charter school networks that collectively run approximately 70 schools serving low-income children of color. This article publicly acknowledges that educational inequity—the reality that where one is born in our country still largely determines one’s educational outcomes and opportunities in life—is a problem that can be solved. Its author argues that we should work to decrease socioeconomic disparities, in part because accomplishing this will make the work of schools easier. Its central point, however, is that even before we make significant progress in reducing poverty and its effects, it is possible to build within our schools and school systems the capacity to put children growing up in economic disadvantage on a level playing field with children in other areas. We at Teach For America have seen evidence of this fact for years, in the classrooms of corps members who are significantly advancing their students’ academic progress and in the schools the article featured, about 60 percent of which are run by our alumni.
    [Show full text]
  • NCTQ Teacher Prep Review EMBARGOED COPY 12:01
    NCTQ Teacher Prep Review EMBARGOED COPY 12:01 AM Tuesday June 18th, 2013 A REVIEW OF THE NATION’S TEACHER PREPARATION PROGRAMS 2013 2013 EMBARGOED — UNTIL 12:01 AM, TUESDAY, JUNE 18, 2013 AUTHORS: Julie Greenberg, Arthur McKee and Kate Walsh OUR THANKS TO: NCTQ Teacher Preparation Studies department, with adroit oversight from Robert Rickenbrode: Graham Drake, Marisa Goldstein, Katie Moyer, Chase Nordengren, Ruth Oyeyemi, Laura Pomerance, Hannah Putman and Stephanie Zoz Expert consultants: Richard Askey, Andrew Chen, Marcia Davidson, Deborah Glaser, Mikhail Goldenberg, Roger Howe, R. James Milgram, Yoram Sagher and Anne Whitney Subject specialists: Heidi Abraham, Mary Alibrandi, Melissa Brock, Sarah Carlson, Susan Clarke, Aileen Corso, Gordon Gibb, Robert P. Marino, Nancy Nelson-Walker, Felicity Ross, Julie Shirer, Jamie Snyder, Jessica Turtura and Shirley Zongker Analysts: Katherine Abib, Andrew Abruzzese, Paul Aguilar, Cheryl Anderson, Naomi Anisman, Gail Arinzeh, Alex Au, Christian Bentley, Kate Bradley-Ferrall, Tara Canada, Erin Carson, Justin Castle, Alicia Chambers, Theodora Chang, Kimberly Charis, Bridget Choudhary, Hester Darcy, Melissa Donovan, Zachary Elkin, Amy Elledge, Michelle Crawford-Gleeson, Nikee Gof!gan, Samantha Greenwald, Whitney Groves, Catherine Guthrie, Sumner Handy, Bess Hanley, Chelsea Harrison, Stephanie Hausladen, Heather Hoffman, Sean Hutson, Anne Kaiser, Kate Kelliher, Maria Khalid, Rebekah King, Susan Klauda, Michael Krenicky, Jay Laughlin, Alicia Lee, Christine Lincke, Michelle Linett, Karen Loeschner, Leslie
    [Show full text]
  • 'Reform': Creating Opportunities to Profit from a Quiet Word: Lobbying
    ‘Reform’: Creating Opportunities to Profit from A Quiet Word: Lobbying, Crony Capitalism and Broken Politics in Britain Tamasin Cave, Andy Rowell ‘When we try to understand the world most of us have to rely on information that is profoundly unsafe.’ Dan Hind, Return of the Public1 ‘We sort of quote that there’s a wealth of evidence out there.’ Elizabeth Sidwell, schools commissioner, Department for Education 2 ‘THIS IS GREAT Britain’ shone from the enormous screen. In front stood the speaker at the government business conference held to coincide with the London Olympics . The UK’s Trade Minister, Stephen Green, introduced ‘One of the world’s leading authorities on educational reform, Michael Barber.’ 3 While the rest of us were gripped by the Olympic triumphs of Mo Farah and Team GB, and were surprised by an opening show that celebrated the youthful, creative and slightly bonkers spirit of these islands, as well as our public-spirited inventions like the NHS and the world wide web, Barber and the British government were promoting a very different set of values to their international business audience. Barber is a ‘visionary’ according to the man currently in charge of schools, the Education Secretary, Michael Gove. 4 But the vision he is promoting is far from the idiosyncratic world portrayed in Danny Boyle’s opening ceremony. Barber prescribes turning whole education systems upside-down, in part, through the introduction of market competition and the greater use of technology. The test bed for some of Barber’s experiments in schools in the UK was nearly two decades earlier in Tony Blair’s government.
    [Show full text]
  • Boston University Commencement 2018
    Boston University Commencement 2018 SUNDAY THE TWENTIETH OF MAY ONE O’CLOCK NICKERSON FIELD BOSTON, MASSACHUSETTS Contents 2 About Boston University 3 Program 4 The Metcalf Cup and Prize and The Metcalf Awards for Excellence in Teaching 8 Honorary Degrees Candidates for Degrees and Certificates 15 College of Arts & Sciences 26 — Graduate School of Arts & Sciences 33 — Frederick S. Pardee School of Global Studies 35 Questrom School of Business 44 College of Communication 51 Henry M. Goldman School of Dental Medicine 56 School of Education 60 College of Engineering 67 College of Fine Arts 72 College of Health & Rehabilitation Sciences: Sargent College 76 School of Hospitality Administration 77 School of Law 80 School of Medicine 85 Metropolitan College 95 School of Public Health 99 School of Social Work 101 School of Theology 103 Arvind & Chandan Nandlal Kilachand Honors College 105 Division of Military Education 107 Academic Traditions 108 School and College Diploma Convocations 110 Prelude, Processional, and Recessional Music 111 Clarissima 113 The Corporation 114 Map of Nickerson Field 1 About Boston University Boston University’s impact extends far beyond its divisions to women, the first to award a Ph.D. to Commonwealth Avenue, Kenmore Square, and the a woman, the first coeducational medical college in Medical Campus. Our students, faculty, and alumni the world. Martin Luther King, Jr., perhaps our most go all around the world to study, research, teach, and famous alumnus, studied here in the early 1950s, during become a part of the communities in which they live. a period when nearly half of this country’s doctoral BU is the fourth-largest private residential university in degrees earned by African American students in religion the country today and is a member of the Association and philosophy were awarded by Boston University.
    [Show full text]
  • Teacher Prep Review Can Be Retrieved At
    Revised February 2015 AUTHORS: Julie Greenberg, Kate Walsh and Arthur McKee OUR THANKS TO: NCTQ staff, with adroit oversight from Robert Rickenbrode: Graham Drake, Marisa Goldstein, Katie Moyer, Ruth Oyeyemi, Laura Pomerance, Hannah Putman, Christine Statz, Stephanie Zoz, and Susan Douglas, Julia Peyton, Maegan Rees Expert consultants: Richard Askey, Andrew Chen, Marcia Davidson, Deborah Glaser, Mikhail Goldenberg, Roger Howe, R. James Milgram, Yoram Sagher and Anne Whitney Subject specialists: Heidi Abraham, Mary Alibrandi, Melissa Brock, Susan Clarke, Aileen Corso (mathematics lead), Gordon Gibb, Robert P. Marino (reading lead), Felicity Ross, Julie Shirer, Jamie Snyder and Shirley Zongker Analysts: Katherine Abib, Paul Aguilar, Ruxandra Arustei, Christian Bentley, Catherine Bockius Guthrie, Shannon Bradford, Katherine Bradley-Ferrall, Mary Bridget Choudhary, Tara Canada, Mirachelle Canada, Erin Carson, Justin Castle, Theodora Chang, Kimberly Charis, Carolyn Chen, Chelsea Clark, Rebecca Cohen, Michelle Crawford- Gleeson, Zachary Elkin, Lena Fishman, Julie Greger, Aretina Hamilton, Chelsea Harrison, Stephanie Hausladen, Maria Khalid, Rebekah King, Stuart Klanfer, Susan Klauda, Ashley Kopp, Michael Krenicky, Christine Lincke, Michelle Linett, Karen Loeschner, Shannon McCutcheon, Natasha Modeste, Rosa-Lyn Morris, Dina Mukhutdinova, Ashley Nellis, Jaclyn Nikee Goffigan, Christina Perucci, Rebecca Rapoport, Melissa Reaktenwalt, Shobana Sampath, Thisie Schisler-Do, Carolyn Semedo-Strauss, Anissa Sepulveda, Patrick Sims, Shlon Smith, Lindsey Surratt, Winnie Tsang, Laura Updyke, Patricia Vane, Mariama Vinson, Alexandra Vogt, Meg Weaver, Jeanette Weisflog, Julie Wilson Graduate Fellows and Interns: Amy MacKown, as well as Natalie Dugan, Phil Lasser, David Reid and Anna Syburg Database Design and Technical Support: EFA Solutions Graphic Design: EFA Solutions NCTQ BOARD OF DIRECTORS: John L. Winn, Chair, Stacey Boyd, Chester E.
    [Show full text]
  • CEO Wendy Kopp
    CEO Wendy Kopp Wendy Kopp is CEO and Co-founder of Teach For All, a global network of independent organizations that are cultivating their nations’ promising future leaders to ensure their most marginalized children have the chance to fulfill their true potential. Wendy founded Teach For America in 1989 to marshal the energy of her generation against educational inequity in the United States. Today, more than 8,000 Teach For America corps members—outstanding recent college graduates and professionals of all academic disciplines—are in the midst of two-year teaching commitments in 52 urban and rural regions, and College (2007), Pace University (2004), Wendy serves on the Board of New Teach For America has proven to be Mercy College (2004), Smith College Profit and is a member of the Council an unparalleled source of long-term (2001), Princeton University (2000), on Foreign Relations. leadership for expanding opportunity Connecticut College (1995), and Drew for children. After leading Teach For University (1995). Wendy holds a bachelor’s degree America’s growth and development for from Princeton University, where she 24 years, in 2013, Wendy transitioned She is the youngest person and the participated in the undergraduate out of the role of CEO. Today, she first woman to receive Princeton program of the Woodrow Wilson remains an active member of Teach For University’s Woodrow Wilson Award School of Public and International America’s board. (1993), the highest honor the school Affairs. She resides in New York City confers on its undergraduate alumni. with her husband Richard Barth and Wendy led the development of Teach In 1994 Time Magazine recognized their four children.
    [Show full text]
  • Excellent Educators
    EXCELLENT EDUCATORS EXCELLENT Excellent Educators A Wise Giver’s Guide to Cultivating Great Teachers and Principals The strongest influence on whether a student learns (and how much) is the teacher. Never mind fancy facilities, new technology, top curricula, or more school spending—research shows that the intelligence, skill, and dedication of the instructor is two to three times as important as any other contribution to student outcomes. If we want to improve schools, we must raise the quality of teachers. Yet credentials, degrees, years on the job have little to do with classroom excellence. Fascinating investigations have recently given us clearer pictures of what a successful teacher looks like. Now leading schools are beginning to hire and mentor teachers differently, with a clear-eyed focus on their demonstrated ability to transfer knowledge to their students. New techniques for measuring and enhancing the teacher’s capacity to add value in the classroom are the VANDERKAM VANDERKAM most promising elements in school reform today. Putting them into effect, though, requires wise and brave school leaders. Without bold, sober, demanding principals, few schools will build a truly excellent set of instructors. This book is for public-spirited donors who want to foster educational excellence by elevating teachers and principals. It reviews the latest academic Excellent research and on-the-ground experience of reformers and offers practical advice on multiple fronts. It is written for philanthropists and allies active in the field who want to make a positive difference. Educators A Wise Giver’s Guide to Cultivating Great Teachers and Principals Laura Vanderkam PhilanthropyRoundtable.org (202) 822-8333 Free copies of this guidebook are available to qualified donors.
    [Show full text]