A Systematic Comparative Study of Nirrudhaprakash (Phimosis): Ayurvedic Epics V/S Modern Medical Science
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
INTERNATIONAL AYURVEDIC MEDICAL JOURNAL International Ayurvedic Medical Journal (ISSN: 2320 5091) (August - September, 2017) 1(6) A SYSTEMATIC COMPARATIVE STUDY OF NIRRUDHAPRAKASH (PHIMOSIS): AYURVEDIC EPICS V/S MODERN MEDICAL SCIENCE Divya Gakhar Medical Officer, Nokha, Bikaner, Rajasthan, India Email: [email protected] Published online: September, 2017 © International Ayurvedic Medical Journal, India 2017 ABSTRACT In AyurvedicSamhitaNiruddhaPrakash (phimosis) vyadhi (disease) is described to be formed because of vi- tiated VataDosha where constricted Shishnacharma (prepuce) covers Mani (glans penis). This creates ob- structed, slow urine flow and the prepuce could not be retracted. Treatment described in Ayurvedic epics is dilatation of preputial meatus by NiruddhaprakashNadiyantra and VatadoshShamak medicated tail (oil) Pari- shek (fomentation). Surgery is advised if this measure fails. Niruddhaprakash has similar features to that of phimosis described in modern medical science. Recent researches shows that glans penis and prepuce has common epithelium and its complete separation essential for complete perpetual retraction exposing whole of glans may normally occur up to the age of 17 years. This may lead to wrong diagnosis of phimosis. Circumci- sion is considered as treatment of choice for phimosis. Keyword: NiruddhaPrakash, phimosis, Circumcision. INTRODUCTION Ayurveda is considered as great ancient medical commonly worldwide as religious, cultural, medi- treatise. Ayurvedic Samhita describes a Vyadhi cal, personal preference and several other reasons. (disease) NiruddhaPrakash having similarity to An estimated one third of males are circumcised Phimosis. On account of morbidity and mortality globally.1 Phimosis is the most frequent medical of circumcision operative procedure and anesthe- reason for male circumcision where a stricture of sia, the review study of NiruddhaPrakash and its the foreskin narrows the opening and prevents it treatment described in Ayurveda classics gains from being retracted to uncover the glans. much importance. Similarly the study of develop- ment and separation of prepuce and conservative AIM & OBJECTIVE: treatment also becomes important. Foreskin cut- 1. To describe Niruddhaprakash according to ting also called male circumcision is done most Ayurvedic Epic Divya Gakhar: A Systematic Comparative Study Of Nirrudhaprakash (Phimosis): Ayurvedic Epics V/S Modern Medical Science 2. To describe Phimosis according to Modern taghna medicated Chakrataila. After consecutive Medical Science three days larger nadi should be used in sequence. 3. To compare Niruddhaprakashvs Phimosis in Snigdhaanna should be given during this treat- detail regarding development and separation of ment. If this treatment fails then surgery can also prepuce, non-surgical treatment of phimosis be done preserving Sevani (frenulum) and it is for bypass of surgical and anesthetic complica- treated as Sadyakshata.6 Nibandhasangraha com- tions, and surgical procedure with less compli- mentary of Susrutasamhita describes Chakrataila cations compared to circumcision as Yantrapidittaila meaning oil extracted by com- pressing machine. 7Similar treatment and surgery MATERIALS AND METHODS: if needed is advised in Astangahridaya 8and As- Comparative references have been collected from tangasamgraha.9 different AyurvedicSamhita and their commenta- Nadiyantra: Different types of Nadiyantra are de- ries, modern medical text books, and published scribed in Ayurvedic Samhita. These are tube like research articles. Results and conclusions were instrument having opening at one or both the ends. made as per our study objectives. These are used to remove foreign bodies from Sro- tasa, for observation like different speculum, for DISCUSSION aspiration, director like fistula director etc. The Niruddhaprakash in Ayurveda classics: thickness and length of this instrument is as re- Sushrutacharya includes Niruddhaprakash (Phi- quired for meatus. Niruddhaprakashyantra (pre- mosis) in Kshudraroga.2 In AstangaSamgraha it is puce and urethral dilator) is described in Sushrut- 10 described as Niruddhamani and included in Gu- samhita. hyaroga (diseases of genitals).3 Vatadosha vitiated Phimosis according to Modern Medical Science: Shishnacharma (prepuce) covers Mani (glance) Phimosis is stenosis of the prepitual orifice so that and occludes Mutrasrota (route of urine flow). the foreskin cannot be pushed back to expose the 11 This creates Mandadhara (slowed down urine glans penis. The physiological adhesion between flow) without pain. Here Mani (glans) is always the foreskin and the glans penis may persist up to covered with Charma (prepuce), this painful dis- the age of 6 years or more. This leads it to be much ease is Niruddhaprakash and is formed because of over diagnosed. The tight prepuce may cause uri- vitiated Vatadosha.4 Madhukosha description says nary obstruction. Masking of meatal atresia by this disease is also formed if scar of Avapatika tight prepuce causing urinary difficulty with resi- (prepusal tear) disease is not heeled properly.5 As- dual urine may be present. This may create back- tangaSamgraha describes Vata vitiated Charma pressure on ureters and kidney. BalanitisXeroti- (prepuce) adheres to front of Mani (glans) creating caObliterans can cause phimosis in later life. In obstruction to urine flow. Here slow urine flow is this the foreskin become thickened and will not present without pain and Mani (glans) could not be retract, leading to problem with hygiene and in- 12 uncovered, this disease is Niruddhamani (phimo- creased susceptibility to carcinoma. sis). Development and Separation of Prepuce: Treatment of Niruddhaprakash (Phimosis) as In fetus, the prepuce appears at eight weeks as a described in Ayurvedic classics: ring of thickened epidermis growing forwards AcharyaSushrut describes Louhanadi with open- from the base of glans penis. It grows more rapidly ings at both the ends is applied with Ghrit to make on upper surface than lower leaving the inferior it smooth, and then to penetrate it slowly in pre- aspect of preputial ring deficient. Pair of out- pusal?? opening. Then Mani parishek is done with growths is pushed out and meet from inferior as- Vasa, Majja of crocodile and pig as well as Va- pect of the glans. These enclose a tube and become IAMJ: AUGUST-SEPTEMBER, 2017 710 Divya Gakhar: A Systematic Comparative Study Of Nirrudhaprakash (Phimosis): Ayurvedic Epics V/S Modern Medical Science continuous with the existing urethra. The prepuce that incomplete preputial separation is common grows forwards to tip of the glans by 16 weeks. At and normal in neonates and infants, and prepitual this stage, the epidermis covering the glans is con- separation processes until school age. tinuous with the epidermis of deep surface of pre- Anatomy of Prepuce: puce and it consist of squamous epithelium. Later Mucosal epithelium: The mucosal epithelium of the squamous cells arrange themselves in whorls male prepuce is same as mucosal epithelium cov- forming epithelial cell nests. The centers of these ering glans penis. The inner prepuce and glans pe- degenerate that to form series of spaces. These nis share a common, fused mucosal epithelium at spaces increase in size and link up to form prepu- birth. Lamina propria of preputial mucosa- it tial space. The separation of prepuce by the time of has loose collagen and it is very vascular leading birth varies greatly. to common haemorrhagic complications associated Gairdners observation in a series of 100 newborn with circumcision. Dartos Muscle- The delicate revels only 4% with fully retractable prepuce, in attenuated penile dartos muscle surround the shaft 54% the glans could be uncovered enough to revel of the penis from the prepuce and is continuous the external meatus, and in remaining 42% even with scrotal dartos muscle. It is temperature de- the tip of the glans could not be uncovered.13 pendant and allows for the volume changes re- Work in Kayaba et al, they evaluated 603 Japanese quired for erection. Circumcised penis shows al- boys 0 to 15 years old and classified preputial sta- tered response to temperature changes. Dermis of tus in 5 types: 1 type I - no retraction of prepuce at prepuce- The dermis of the prepuce consists of all, type II - exposure of external urethral meatus connective tissue, blood vessels, nerve trunks, only, type III (intermediate) – exposure of glans Meissner corpuscles within the papillae, and scat- halfway to the sulcus of the corona, type IV – ex- tered sebaceous glands. Outer epithelium (Skin posure of glans to above the corona at the site of of the prepuce) - The outer epithelium of the pre- the preputial adhesion and type V -easy exposure puce consists of keratinized stratified squamous of the whole glans. They defined a tight ring as a cells. Melanocytes, Langerhans cells and Merkel stenotic ring that prevented the prepuce from being cells are also present. The Preputial Sac- It is co- retracted. They found that before age of 6 months lonized by Cornybacterium, Gram-negative anae- the incidence of types I (completely unretract able) robes (especially Bacteroidesmelamnogemcus), to V (completely retractable) prepuce was 47.1, Enterococci, Enterobacteria and coagulase-positive 21.5, 29.4, 2 and 0% respectively. None of the 111 Staphylococci.16 boys younger than 1 year with a type V prepuce, in Function of prepuce: The prepuce completely the 3 to 4 year-old boy’s types I and V prepuce covers the glans during the years when the child is were in