I Am an Omnivorous Reader 5975W
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
“I AM AN OMNIVOROUS READER” Book reviews by CATHERINE COOKE, ALISTAIR DUNCAN, GORDON DYMOWSKI, MATTHEW J ELLIOTT, MARK MOWER, SARAH OBERMULLER-BENNETT, VALERIE SCHREINER, JOHN SHEPPARD, JEAN UPTON, NICHOLAS UTECHIN and ROGER JOHNSON This August and Scholarly Body: The Society at Blaze . If it had a name it’s in the book! 70 edited by Nicholas Utechin; design and layout by For each character we are given the name, story, Heather Owen. The Sherlock Holmes Society of sex, and whether they are alive or dead in the Canon. London , 2021. 116pp. £11.00 (pbk) In addition, depending on the importance of the They say that when drowning, one’s life flashes character, are details which can range from physical before one’s eyes. Reading this book is rather like that appearance to occupation and, if relevant, what — only somewhat drier! While I do not go back to the Holmes deduced about them. Holmes himself has a Society’s foundation in 1951, I do go back over half predictably long entry, whereas, for instance, Captain the Society’s existence and have had much to do with Ferguson (“The Three Gables”) is concisely the 1951 Festival of Britain in Westminster Libraries. described: “A retired sea captain who owned the This is a fitting record, a highly enjoyable read and an house before Mrs Maberley. Holmes asked if there invaluable reference book. There are lists of the was anything about remarkable about him, and if he Presidents, Chairmen and Honorary Members and a had buried something. Mrs Maberley answered in the useful list of all the Society’s publications, so you can negative.” check for any gaps on your shelves that need filling. Illustrations by all manner of artists are included; There follows a complete list of all the Society’s it is very interesting to see how the different meetings and excursions — a very useful index to the illustrators approached their commissions. accounts in the Journal . What one would give to have Finally, there are three tables, listing the stories in attended some of the early ones! More discursive are order of occurrence (though Foy does not say which the reminiscences of the Chairmen, and the history of chronology he has used); in alphabetical order, by the Society’s genesis and of the Journal . All this is four-letter abbreviation; and in order of publication. lavishly illustrated with myriad black & white and The book is large and over 500 pages — rather colour photographs, including the infamous Dancing cumbersome, but when it is this comprehensive it’s Men — what we got up to on our excursions! (Is that hard to see how it could have been smaller. Some a file Geoffrey Stephens is holding in the photograph might be deterred by the price. To them I would say on page 80? It looks suspiciously like the record of that if you don’t already have such a book, it is very the soundtrack of the 1951 Festival Exhibition.) much worth it. If you do, and you are not a completist, The book captures the unique blend of you might decide this one is not for you. I would buy scholarship, humour and sheer fun that is the it, even though I already own similar books. Society’s hallmark. Reading the reminiscences brings AD back many happy memories — a former Chairman, dressed as a cow, pirouetting into a room because… The Mystery of the Parsee Lawyer: Arthur Conan No — you will have to buy the book! Doyle, George Edalji and the Case of the There is one erratum which we should mention. Foreigner in the English Village by Shrabani Basu. On page 83 it is stated that The Golden Jubilee Cruise Bloomsbury Publishing , 2021. 320pp. £20.00 (hbk) of the Baltic was organised by Guy Marriott. It was Ten years ago I wrote that Roger Oldfield’s not: Peter Horrocks was the mastermind behind it. Outrage; The Edalji Five and the Shadow of Sherlock CC Holmes seemed unlikely to be surpassed as a comprehensive, intelligent, balanced and intensely The Curious Book Of Sherlock Holmes readable account of this tragic affair. It’s pleasing to Characters by Mike Foy. MX Publishing , 2021. know that Mr Oldfield provided assistance to the 572pp. £34.99/€39.99/$44.95 (hbk) author of this new book, which, if it doesn’t excel his This comprehensive directory of every character own, at least equals it. George Edalji, son of an Indian in the Canon sensibly proceeds in a simple father and an English mother, was convicted of alphabetical format (by character rather than story) brutally maiming livestock in his father’s and, equally sensibly, has a comprehensive index. Staffordshire parish. Released early, he wrote to the Characters I didn’t even consider characters are creator of Sherlock Holmes, who, on meeting him, represented, such as Desborough, a horse from Silver immediately noticed that his eyesight was so poor as to render him incapable of the crimes for which he’d Hardwick’s, broadcast on the BBC Light Programme been imprisoned. Eventually cleared on appeal, Edalji in August 1962, is inaccurate). was refused compensation on the grounds that he was The Irregulars have now embarked on the guilty of writing a series of threatening letters, an facsimile publication for next year: “The Norwood offence for which he had never been tried, let alone Builder”. I am looking forward to it already. convicted. The police, under Chief Constable George NU Anson, pursued a clearly racist agenda, with apparent Home Office approval. Conan Doyle’s evidence was The Lost World: Manuscript by Arthur Conan derided or ignored. There have been other very good Doyle. SP Books , 2020. 336pp. €180 /£150 (hbk in accounts of the affair, but The Mystery of the Parsee slipcase) Lawyer has a special value, as Shrabani Basu, herself To read the manuscript itself, you’d have to visit born and raised in India, helps us understand the the New York Public Library. This magnificent achievements and the tribulations of the Revd volume, limited to 1,000 hand-numbered copies, can Shapurji Edalji and his family. Her research in save you the trouble. As with the 2016 facsimile of Portsmouth’s Conan Doyle Collection, the “The Abbey Grange”, co-published by the Society, Staffordshire Record Office, the George Edalji papers the MS is superbly reproduced at full size, and as at Birmingham Central Library, and elsewhere is always Conan Doyle’s handwriting is elegant and exemplary. And, my goodness, she can write! legible. The illustrations from the original British and RJ American serialisations were reproduced in the 1996 Wessex Press Annotated Lost World ; this edition The Staunton Tragedy: A Facsimile of the features equally impressive illustrations by Géo Original Manuscript of “The Adventure of the Dupuis, from the original French publication, in Je Missing Three-Quarter” by Arthur Conan Doyle Sais Tout . In his perceptive and informative foreword, with Annotations and Commentary . Edited, with Jon Lellenberg remarks: “As one observes Conan an Introduction, by Michael F Whelan, BSI. The Doyle’s handwriting becoming ‘busier’ in the course Baker Street Irregulars , 2020. 216pp. $39.95 (hbk) of composition, it is impossible not to feel the The latest in this marvellous series of facsimile author’s excitement and impatience to reach the editions comes courtesy of the British Library, to climax.” The Lost World: Manuscript is available whom (as the British Museum) the manuscript was from the publisher at https://www.spbooks.com/. presented in May 1959. Its journey thither is told in RJ detail by Randall Stock: prestigious previous owners of this treasure were William Randolph Hearst and The Baker Street Journal Christmas Annual 2020: Vincent Starrett. Stock also provides a detailed report The 100-Year Adventure of The Unique Hamlet on the physicality of the manuscript itself, and Phillip edited by Richard Sveum. The Baker Street Bergem is as meticulous as ever in his textual Irregulars , 2020. 68pp (pbk) annotations. The reproduction of the manuscript “Holmes,” I began, “I am delighted to see, pages, scanned by the British Library, makes perusal amongst the heady onrush of often ludicrous easy. pastiches of our adventures, a scholarly study of that The editor, Mike Whelan, recently-retired which is regarded as one of the very greatest.” “Wiggins” of the Irregulars, had a nice idea: he and Holmes languidly stretched out a hand for the friends recently founded a scion society called proffered volume. “Indeed, by Vincent Starrett, an MISS3Q, whose membership is limited to those over American who holds, I believe, a special place in the the age of seventy-five — and all eight founding pantheon of those who engage in the idolatry of — members have contributed scholarly papers to this well — frankly, myself. In this famous 1920 volume. There is much concentration on the game of publication, he came up with the idea that I solved the rugby — understandable for what will be primarily a case of an apparently missing Shakespearian treasure. non-British readership. Side-line topics explored It is not, I may say, the best of these attempts to copy include the history of telegrams, whether Dr Leslie your overblown accounts, Watson, but I understand it Armstrong is really comparable to Professor has other elements in its favour.” Moriarty, and how allotment sites in Cambridgeshire “Indeed so, my dear Holmes,” I cried. “It is provide an important topographical clue. believed that only 110 copies were published and that I enjoyed Don Novorsky’s “alternative solution” an up-to-date census shows twenty-six of them as to the case (Godfrey Staunton’s young lady did not being in public institutions, twenty-three in private die from consumption); and Peter Blau’s charting of hands and five — as of last Christmas — on sale.