Rhod e Isl and Bar Journal Rhode Island Bar Association Volume 61. Number 1. Jul y/August 2 012
Rhode Island Bar Association Officers 2012-2013 Association Annual Report and Committee Reports Annual Meeting and Awards RHODE I SLAND Bar Association 1898 33 RHODE ISLAND BAR ASSOCIATION LAWYER’S PLEDGE As a member of the Rhode Island Bar Association, I pledge to conduct myself in a manner that will reflect honor upon Article the legal profession. I will treat all participants in the legal process with civility. In every aspect of my practice, I will be 9 Remembering Attorney and Friend John Bomster honest, courteous and fair. John A. Tarantino, Esq. Editor In Chief , David N. Bazar Editor , Frederick D. Massie Assistant Editor , Kathleen M. Bridge Editorial Board Features Victoria M. Almeida, Esq. Roland E. Chase, Esq. 3 You may ask, “Who is this guy?” 20 Bar Foundation 2012 Annual Meeting Jerry Cohen, Esq. Eric D. Correira, Esq. 4 Letter to the Editor – Response to 24 Annual Meeting Highlights William J. Delaney, Esq. Commentary: St. Thomas More and 33 Our Local Hero: Bruce W. McIntyre, Maureen D. Gemma, Esq. the Cranston West Prayer Banner Life-Saver and Bar Officer Jay S. Goodman, Esq. Case Bryan W. Hudson, Esq. 35 New Bridge the Gap Mandatory CLE 5 New Rhode Island Bar Association Hon. Patricia A. Hurst for New Attorneys Debuts in April Ernest G. Mayo, Esq. President and 2012-2013 Executive Elizabeth R. Merritt, Esq. Officers 36 Lawyers on the Move John T. Mulcahy, Esq. 7 Rhode Island Bar Association 37 Bar’s Volunteer Lawyer Program and Matthew R. Plain, Esq. 2012-2013 Officers’ Profiles RWU School of Law Provide Free Kevin N. Rolando, Esq. Family Mediations 11 2012 Ralph P. Semonoff Award for Miriam Ross, Esq. Andrew C. Spacone, Esq. Professionalism 37 Live! From the Bar! It’s CLE Seminar Simulcasting! Elliot Taubman, Esq. 11 2012 Florence K. Murray Award Harris K. Weiner, Esq. 38 SOLACE – Helping Bar Members 12 2012 Victoria M. Almeida Servant in Times of Need Leader Award 40 In Memoriam Executive Director , Helen Desmond McDonald 12 2012 Award of Merit Association Officers 44 New Name, Same Excellent, and Free, 13 Rhode Island Bar Journal Lauren Confidential Assistance for Bar Michael R. McElroy President E. Jones Writing Award Association Members and Their J. Robert Weisberger, Jr., President-Elect 13 50 Years of Service – 2012 Honorary Families Bruce W. McIntyre , Treasurer Melissa E. Darigan, Secretary Members 45 Memoriam: July 2011 – June 2012 14 2012 Volunteer Lawyer & Pro Bono 46 Publish and Prosper in the Rhode Direct advertising inquiries to the Editor, Frederick D. Program For The Elderly Award Island Bar Journal Massie, Rhode Island Bar Journal, 115 Cedar Street, Recipients Providence, RI 02903, (401) 421-5740. 46 Please consider joining or renewing USPS (464-680) ISSN 1079-9230 16 Rhode Island Law Day Focused on your membership in a Bar Committee Balancing Individual Rights Rhode Island Bar Journal is published bimonthly by this year. the Rhode Island Bar Association, 115 Cedar Street, 18 Ponaganset High School Student 47 Advertiser Index Providence, RI 02903. Wins 2012 Hon. Francis J. Darigan, Jr. PERIODICALS POSTAGE PAID AT PROVIDENCE, RI Rhode Island Law Day Essay Contest Subscription: $30 per year 19 Bar President William Delaney and Postmaster NBC10 News Anchor Frank Colletta Bar Summer Hours Send Address Correction to Rhode Island Bar Discussed Bar Volunteer Education Rhode Island Bar Association Office Journal, 115 Cedar Street, Providence, RI 02903 and Pro Bono Work www.ribar.com 19 Volunteer Bar Lawyers Offer Free Monday, June 18, 2012 Front Cover Photograph Information and Advice on Rhode through View from Benefit Street, Providence, Island Bar/NBC10 Ask a Lawyer Tuesday, September 4, 2012 Partnership Programs by Brian McDonald 9:00 a.m. to 4:30 p.m.
Monday – Friday XX%
Cert no. XXX-XXX-000 You may ask, “Who is this guy?”
Looking at this picture, you may ask, “Who is the Southeastern US , and I argued a number of this guy? Can he really understand what I need cases in the US Courts of Appeals for the fifth from the Bar Association?” and sixth circuits. Good questions, because I have not had an In 1981, with our one year-old son Brian, we opportunity to meet as many of you as some moved back home to Rhode Island to be closer of my predecessors, so I believe an introduction to our families. Chris was pregnant with our is in order. I want you to feel comfortable daughter Dianne. I hung my shingle and started approaching me, knowing that, whatever your my own practice. Since then, I have prac ticed situation, whether you are struggling or well- either with one other attorney or as a solo. established, hanging your own shingle, or prac - When I first started practicing, I took nearly ticing in a big or small office, I have been there, every client who walked in the door. After all, Michael R. McElroy, Esq. so I understand your needs, and I will do my we needed to eat! I also took almost every President best to help you meet them. Continuing Legal Education course offered by Rhode Island Bar Association I was raised in West Warwick. I have three the Bar Association. These courses and related younger sisters. We lived with my mother in a forms were, and still are, invaluable to me. tenement house in Arctic. We survived on wel - As I developed a business practice, I realized fare and the generosity of my mother’s parents. most business transactions had tax implications I found out what it was like to have to make I did not understand, so I took night courses at payroll at the end of every week when I was 12 Bryant University and earned a master’s degree years old and took over a large paper route in taxation. Eventually, my practice became pri - requiring me to hire a helper. When I turned 16, marily general commercial and litigation. Our I became a truck driver for the newspaper dis - three children are now adults. And Chris and I I hope over the tributor. In my high school years, I worked 40 have two grandchildren, with a third on the way! course of the to 50 hours per week outside of school driving I met Lauren Jones as a co-counsel in the the truck. I played bass in a rock ‘n roll band I early 1980s. Lauren became a close friend and coming year, started with my best friend. Our band was pop - an invaluable source of legal advice. He recruit - you will feel com - ular because we played music you can dance to. ed me into active Bar Association involvement. We were booked every Friday and Saturday I spent three years as Superior Court Bench/Bar fortable approach - night for years. Committee Chair. Working with then Presiding ing me with any At the University of Rhode Island, I was Justice Rodgers, we developed the first medical captain of the rowing team, and I worked every malpractice mediation program in the state, and ideas you have job I could find to pay tuition, books and living we also completed a significant revision to the about how your expenses. I had a lawn-cutting business. I ran a rules of civil procedure. jackhammer, dug ditches, drove a dump truck, I hope over the course of the coming year, Bar Association roofed houses, and did rough carpentry. I you will feel comfortable approaching me with can help you. worked in a textile mill, a commercial laundry, any ideas you have about how your Bar Associa - and on an assembly line. tion can help you. I guarantee you that, working At Boston University School of Law, I worked with our terrific executive director of over 25 as a resident assistant in the undergraduate years, Helen McDonald, her staff, and our dorms and, in the summers, as a mailman. In a Executive Committee and House of Delegates, litigation clinic at BU Law, I was assigned to the we will listen carefully to your thoughts and Dorchester District Court with a small group of concerns. We will do our best to make your Bar student public defenders including our First Cir- Association work hard for you, whether you cuit Court of Appeals Judge Rogeriee Thompson. are a solo practitioner, in a small or large firm, After dating her since she was 15 years old, or in-house. I finally married my wife Christine on June 5, That said, I would like to make one request. 1976. I graduated from law school the next day. In order to get better, your Bar Association One week later, I started as a trial attorney for needs you as an active participant in whatever the Tennessee Valley Authority (TVA) , a federal way works best for you. Working on one of our agency in Knoxville, Tennessee. I worked at 26 committees and volunteering to take a pro TVA for five years on a staff of 75 lawyers. I bono case is a great way to start. Together, let’s handled cases in US District Courts throughout make this a year to remember! O
Rhode Island Bar Journal Jul y/August 2012 3 RHODE ISLAND BAR JOURNAL Editorial Statement LETTER TO THE EDITOR The Rhode Island Bar Journal is the Rhode Island Bar Association’s official magazine for Rhode Island attorneys, judges and others interested in Rhode Island Response to Commentary: law. The Bar Journal is a paid, subscription magazine published bi-monthly, six times annually and sent to, St. Thomas More and the Cranston West among others, all practicing attorneys and sitting judges, in Rhode Island. This constitutes an audience of over Prayer Banner Case 6,000 individuals. Covering issues of relevance and pro - viding updates on events, programs and meetings, the Rhode Island Bar Journal is a magazine that is read on arrival and, most often, kept for future reference. The Bar Journal publishes scholarly discourses, commen - Dear Editor, tary on the law and Bar activities, and articles on the administration of justice. While the Journal is a serious magazine, our articles are not dull or somber. We strive Your May/June 2012 issue included a commentary (pages 27-30), St. Thomas to publish a topical, thought-provoking magazine that addresses issues of interest to significant segments of More and the Cranston West Prayer Banner Case , by John T. Mulcahy, Esq., the Bar. We aim to publish a magazine that is read, about St. Thomas More and Judge Lagueux’s recent decision in Ahlquist v. City quoted and retained. The Bar Journal encourages the free expression of ideas by Rhode Island Bar members. of Cranston . Because the Rhode Island Bar Association embraces the entire The Bar Journal assumes no responsibility for opinions, Rhode Island Bar, and because St. Thomas More is the patron saint of all statements and facts in signed articles, except to the lawyers, I do not feel the commentary should be the last word on the matter. extent that, by publication, the subject matter merits attention. The opinions expressed in editorials represent I have read Mr. Mulcahy’s essay several times, and I do not think I do it any the views of at least two-thirds of the Editorial Board, substantial injustice by summing it up so: St. Thomas More was a great champi - and they are not the official view of the Rhode Island Bar Association. Letters to the Editors are welcome. on of the individual conscience, and, because, it would seem, Ms. Ahlquist was Article Selection Criteria following her own conscience in bringing her suit against Cranston West, St. • The Rhode Island Bar Journal gives primary prefer - Thomas More would approve of the suit and the decision. ence to original articles, written expressly for first publication in the Bar Journal , by members of the I will not take issue with certain questions that Mr. Mulcahy’s proposition, Rhode Island Bar Association. The Bar Journal does stated so, raised for me. In other words, I will not address the wisdom of com - not accept unsolicited articles from individuals who are not members of the Rhode Island Bar Association. paring the mind of an early modern to that of a post-modern. Nor will I take Articles previously appearing in other publications up the matter of whether the conscience of a person who did believe in God can are not accepted. properly be reckoned of the same substance as the conscience of a person who • All submitted articles are subject to the Journal’s editors’ approval, and they reserve the right to edit does not. And, I will leave aside, for the most part, the fact that Thomas More or reject any articles and article titles submitted for grew to manhood in a culture whose social and political rituals were informed, publication. • Selection for publication is based on the article’s in the main, by Catholic doctrine, and that the notion of prayer in the public relevance to our readers, determined by content and sphere was likely so prevalent as to have been unremarkable. I do not pretend timeliness. Articles appealing to the widest range of interests are particularly appreciated. However, com - to have either the wit or the reading to address these matters properly. mentaries dealing with more specific areas of law are My only purpose is to set right what I see as the essay’s main defect. Thomas given equally serious consideration. • Preferred format includes: a clearly presented state - More did follow his conscience, and his conscience bade him stay silent and not ment of purpose and/or thesis in the introduction; unfold his mind to the authorities that would have him swear. And so, in prison supporting evidence or arguments in the body; and and faced with the prospect of tortures that we – post-moderns that we are – a summary conclusion. • Citations conform to the Uniform System of Citation can scarcely imagine, but which St. Thomas himself likely witnessed regularly • Maximum article size is approximately 3,500 words. from the windows of his childhood home in Milk Street, silent he remained. To However, shorter articles are preferred. • While authors may be asked to edit articles them - be sure, it was only after he was sentenced to death in one of the most shameful selves, the editors reserve the right to edit pieces for travesties in the history of our profession that he at last laid his mind open for legal size, presentation and grammar. • Articles are accepted for review on a rolling basis. the world to judge whether he was a fool or a saint. I do not think I am over - Meeting the criteria noted above does not guarantee stating things to say that More kept silent on the matter of his conscience even publication. Articles are selected and published at the discretion of the editors. to the point of death. And so, insofar as St. Thomas More is the patron saint • Submissions are preferred in a Microsoft Word for - of lawyers, and insofar as we all rely – whether we believe it or not – upon his mat emailed as an attachment or on disc. Hard copy intercession on our behalf for every good thing we do, we work an injustice by is acceptable, but not recommended. • Authors are asked to include an identification of their attributing to him any thought that was not assuredly his own. By doing such a current legal position and a photograph, (headshot) thing, we fail both to understand clearly the significance of his martyrdom and preferably in a jpg file of, at least, 350 d.p.i., with their article submission. to honor adequately the scope of his patronage. Direct inquiries and send articles and author’s photographs for publication consideration to: Very truly yours, Rhode Island Bar Journal Editor Frederick D. Massie email: fmassie @ribar.com telephone: 40 1-421-5740 Brian Clifford, Esq. Material published in the Rhode Island Bar Journal remains the property of the Journal , and the author consents to the rights of the Rhode Island Bar Journal to copyright the work.
4 Jul y/August 2012 Rhode Island Bar Journal New Rhode Island Bar Association President and 2012-2013 Executive Officers
New Rhode Island Bar Association President Past Rhode Island Bar Association President William J. Delaney [l] passed the Bar’s gavel and to new President Michael R. McElroy [r] who pledges to uphold and further the Bar Association’s core mission and goals.
Rhode Island Bar Association 2012-2013 Executive Officers The Rhode Island Bar Association Executive Officers were enthusiasti - cally and unanimously endorsed at the 2012 Annual Meeting [l to r] Melissa E. Darigan, Esq., Secretary, partner, Partridge Snow & Hahn LLP ; Bruce W. McIntyre, Esq., Treasurer, legal counsel, Rhode Island Department of Health; Michael R. McElroy, Esq., President, partner, Schacht & McElroy; and J. Robert Weisberger, Jr., Esq., President-Elect, counsel, Edwards Wildman Palmer, LLP.
Rhode Island Bar Journal Jul y/August 2012 5 10 Weybosset Street, Suite 205 • Providence, RI 02903 Tel: (401) 455-3500 Fax: (401) 455-0648
www.mignanelli.com
Wills/Trusts
Estate Tax Planning
Estate Settlements
Trusts for Disabled Persons
Personal Injury Settlement Trusts Anthony R. Mignanelli Attorney at Law All Probate Matters
The R.I. Supreme Court Licenses all lawyers in the general practice of law. The court does not license or certify any lawyer as an expert or specialist in any field of practice.
6 Jul y/August 2012 Rhode Island Bar Journal Rhode Island Bar Association 2012-2013 Officer s’ Profiles
Michael R. McElroy, Esq. J. Robert Weisberger, Jr., Esq. Bruce W. McIntyre, Esq. Melissa E. Darigan, Esq. President President-Elect Treasurer Secretary
Michael R. McElroy, Esq. is President of the and House of Delegates. He has chaired the Rhode Island Bar Association. He is a resident Bar’s Government Relations Committee and of Providence and Narragansett and is a part - the Annual Meeting Planning Committee. He ner in the Providence law firm of Schacht & has also served on several of the Bar’s standing McElroy. A graduate of the University of Rhode committees. Bob is a Rhode Island Bar Foun- Island, where he was Captain of the crew team dation Fellow and a member of the American and the first student Ombudsman at URI , he Bar Association. For many years, he served as a earned his law degree from Boston University member of the Board of Directors and Executive School of Law and his Masters Degree in Committee of McAuley House. He serves his Taxation from Bryant University. He is a former town of Smithfield as its Town Moderator. He three-term Chairman of the Superior Court and his wife Gail have two children. Bench/Bar Committee. He is a member of the House of Delegates and the Executive Commit- Bruce W. McIntyre, Esq. is Treasurer of the tee of the Bar Association. He is a Fellow of the Rhode Island Bar Association. He has been Rhode Island Bar Foundation. He is admitted legal counsel to the Rhode Island Department to practice in Rhode Island, Massachusetts, of Health, Board of Medical Licensure and and Tennessee, as well as various United States Discipline since 1991. His legal expertise is in District Courts, Courts of Appeal, and the the areas of medical regulation of physicians, United States Supreme Court. He is a member physician assistants, chiropractic physicians, of the Rhode Island Association for Justice. and acupuncture and oriental medicine. He is He is a former trial attorney with the Tennessee an immediate past Director at the Federation Valley Authority and a former Special Assistant of State Medical Boards of the US , Inc., Dallas, Attorney General. He is currently Legal Counsel Texas. Bruce also advises the Rhode Island to the Rhode Island Personnel Appeal Board. Director of Health on legal and legislative He and his wife Christine have three children issues. He has served as an administrative and two grandchildren. hearing officer for the Boards of Pharmacy, Nursing, Dentistry and Certificate of Need. J. Robert Weisberger, Jr., Esq. is President- Elect of the Rhode Island Bar Association. Melissa E. Darigan, Esq. is Secretary of the He is counsel with Edwards Wildman Palmer, Rhode Island Bar Association. She is a partner LLP serving in the firm’s litigation management in the Providence law firm of Partridge Snow department representing CVS as national litiga - & Hahn LLP and chair of the firm’s Litigation tion counsel. Bob is a member of the Rhode Practice Group, specializing in complex com - Island Bar Association’s Executive Committee mercial, business and regulatory litigation. She
Rhode Island Bar Journal Jul y/August 2012 7 is a mentor in the firm’s mentoring pro - gram and co-founded and assists the administration of the firm’s Women AdVocates for Enterprise (WAVE) initia - tive helping women in business advance professionally. She is a graduate of George Washington University, and she earned her law degree from Catholic University of America. She is co-chair of the Bar’s Superior Court Bench/Bar Committee, a member of the House of Delegates, served as Chair of the 2012 Annual Meeting Committee, and, since 2007, has served as a member of the Executive Committee. She was also a member of the Bar’s Strategic Planning Committee which developed a five-year plan to guide the Association. She is a Rhode Island Bar Foundation Fellow and a New England Bar Association Board member. She is admitted to practice in the: U.S. District Courts of Rhode Island and Massachusetts; the U.S. District Court of Appeals, 1st Circuit; and the U.S. Supreme Court. O
Immigration Lawyer IMMI GRAT ION Joan Mathieu
Call me if your legal advice may LAW affect your clients’ immigration status. Protect yourself and your client 401-4 21-0 911
We practice only US Immigration Law with 15 years experience in JAMES A. BRIDEN • IRCA. 1-9, no-match advice • Minimizing adverse immigration for US employers consequences of crimes Blais Cunningham • Foreign Investor, business • Deportation/removal & Crowe Chester, LLP and family visas • All areas of immigration law – • Visas for health care professionals referrals welcome 150 Main Street • Visas for artists and entertainers Pawtucket, RI 02860 Member and past CFL chapter president of the American Immigration Lawyers Association. BU Law and MPA Harvard Graduate. 401-723-1122 Full resume on my web site www.immigrators.com Law offices of Joan Mathieu, 248 Waterman Street, Providence, RI 02906
8 Jul y/August 2012 Rhode Island Bar Journal Remembering Attorney and Friend John Bomster John A. Tarantino, Esq. Adler Pollock & Sheehan P.C.
There are days in your life you never for - with John for the next 17 years after he get. Something happens that leaves a per - retired from AP&S and moved to New manent mark. Sometimes good, sometimes Hampshire where he served as Of Counsel bad. On October 7, 1979, I met John to our firm. Over those next 17 years, I Bomster, and I’ll never forget that day. worked with John on various matters and Nor will I ever forget him. That day made on a number of bar committees. But, most a permanent mark and a good one. significant to me, was whenever I had I was a twenty-four year old, second what seemed to be an insurmountable year law student interviewing for a job problem, I could turn to John for advice. at Adler Pollock & Sheehan. John was a John’s gift wasn’t that he provided the partner and chaired the litigation depart - answer or the solution to my problem. ment. As a young law student, I thought Rather, through his disciplined way of I knew a lot more than I actually did. I thinking and then his challenges and, was confident then, as now. (Actually, my sometimes, even his cross examinations mom still says, “I’m not always right, but (and, make no mistake, being cross exam - John F. Bomster, Esq. never in doubt”). So, I told John I wanted ined by John was like walking barefoot on to try cases. He asked me: “Well, then, broken glass), eventually, he would force where do you see yourself as a lawyer in me to think through the issues properly the next ten years?” I answered him with - and thoroughly. And, just about every you may also remember, when Atticus left out hesitation that I expected to be a great time, I’d realize that there was a solution the courtroom, supposedly in defeat, all trial lawyer in ten years. But, I didn’t stop to the problem. John did this for me many the African American men and women there. I invited him to come along for the times, and I know that he did it for many who had been seated in the balcony of the ride with me, emphasizing that I hoped he others in my firm, as well as elsewhere. court, stood together to honor him. When and I would try great cases together. I said When I learned of John’s passing, I felt Atticus’ daughter, Scout, asked why they all of this with conviction and, I hope, not what I can only describe as loss, excep - were doing this, she was told that you with arrogance, and I don’t believe John tional loss. I know many of us who knew stand when a great man is passing. took it as arrogant. Rather, I believe, he John felt that loss. I lost my mentor, my John Bomster was my Atticus Finch, took it the way I intended. Becoming a colleague and my dear friend. And, I will the epitome of professionalism and great trial lawyer was something I truly admit to you, I didn’t know quite how courage. And, I know, he was the Atticus wanted. I remember John telling me he to react to the news of his sudden death, Finch for many other lawyers as well. liked the fact that I had confidence in but, instinctively, I was compelled to stand So, John, my friend, take your rest. You myself, and he told me I would need con - silently in John’s honor. always fought the good fight. Be in peace fidence if, in fact, I would ever be a good Many of John’s colleagues and friends with God. But, John, I do have a small trial lawyer, let alone a great one. And yes, and even many of John’s legal adversaries favor to ask. If by chance, when my time he said, maybe, if I did join the firm, that spoke to me when they learned of his comes, if St. Peter should assign you the someday we would work together and try death, and each felt, in his or her own way, job of examining my qualifications to cases. a loss in John’s passing. All recognized a enter Heaven, please go easy on me with Well, I have the honor of saying that great lawyer and a great man had passed. your cross examination. O for the next 16 years, John and I did work As I had these discussions, I was together and we did try cases together and reminded of a scene from the movie To it was an amazing experience. He was a Kill a Mockingbird . A small town lawyer, wonderful mentor, a superb attorney (truly Atticus Finch, had defended a black man a lawyer’s lawyer) and, most important, he against a rape charge brought by a white was a great friend. John was a lawyer of woman in a rural southern town. Of exceptional competence and courage, and course, with an all male, white jury, a man of true faith. He was principled, Atticus lost the trial. In fact, he had lost ethical and honest. I continued to work the trial before it had even begun. But, as
Rhode Island Bar Journal Jul y/August 2012 9 $0- ;;695-@: ,=)5;)/- 65315- )7731+);165 796+-:: 6..-9: ) +65=-51-5; >)@ .69 :4)33 .194: ;6 /-; ) 796.-::165)3 31)*131;@ +6=-9)/- 8<6;- C " %
'- ,65D; ;0152 )33 ;0- -?;9) >692 9-8<19-, !& ;6 :-+<9- 796.-::165)3 31)*131;@ +6=-9)/- :06<3, 2--7 @6<