Klein Halevi: Recognize Jewish State, Freeze Settlements

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Klein Halevi: Recognize Jewish State, Freeze Settlements Klein Halevi: Recognize Jewish State, freeze settlements Yossi Klein Halevi On X-Mas morning, I heard Yossi Klein Halevi speaking at a Modern Orthodox synagogue on the Upper West Side of Manhattan (Lincoln Square). He was here for three months, teaching a course at Jewish Theological Seminary as well as hawking his new book, “Like Dreamers,” and heading back to Israel on New Year’s Eve. It was very different than his talk at a Barnes & Noble several weeks before, with him being more specific on Israeli politics for this second audience, which knows much more about Israel than many at the bookstore. I still see his enthusiasm for what he regards as the pragmatic center as flawed, but I learned more of what he means. He clearly supports the agenda of Yair Lapid’s new Yesh Atid (There is a Future) party, and extolls its post-election alliance with Naftali Bennett’s Jewish Home party, the latter being an amalgam of Religious (Modern Orthodox) Zionists and right-wing nationalists. In line with this, he regards confronting the power of the Haredim (ultra-Orthodox) as Israel’s number one challenge. But he also sees the secular-religious divide within Israel as fading, and argues (reasonably) that Lapid’s party is not anti-religious. Klein Halevi points out that Lapid belongs to a Reform synagogue and Halevi speaks optimistically of the growth of Reform and other non-Orthodox Jewish streams; similarly, he’s enthusiastic about Ruth Calderon, a pioneer in the re-embrace of traditional texts by non-Orthodox Israelis, who is also now a Yesh Atid Member of Knesset. Still, he does not see any real prospect for a peace agreement with the Palestinians at this time, and ridicules John Kerry’s warning that the current negotiations are Israel’s last chance for a negotiated two-state solution. Klein Halevi emphasizes the importance of an explicit Palestinian recognition of Israel as a Jewish state — recognizing the legitimacy of the Jews as a historically indigenous Middle Eastern people — because Israel must make concrete concessions of territory in return only for Palestinian pledges of peaceful intent. Moreover, he correctly points out that the Palestinian national movement is divided between Fatah and the rejectionist Hamas (as well as others), and he obviously does not buy our hopes that Hamas can moderate or that the Gaza Strip can be dealt with separately from the West Bank. When I questioned him from the audience on his lack of regard for Mahmoud Abbas’s moderation (e.g., his renunciation of the Second Intifada and his recent condemnation of the global BDS movement), he answered forthrightly: He felt some hope when Abbas indicated on Israeli television, a year ago, that he wasn’t claiming his right to return to his native town of Tzfat (the Israeli city rendered in English as Safed), but was disappointed when Abbas stepped back from this potentially game-changing position by later stating that his was a “private” decision, whereas the collective “right of return” is sacred. I was not permitted to follow-up with speculation I’ve heard from some Israelis that the demand for a right of return may be a bargaining chip meant to secure a measure of Palestinian sovereignty in East Jerusalem, which they claim as their capital. Yet Klein Halevi agreed partially with my point about the insidiousness of constantly expanding settlements. He declared himself in favor of a partial settlement freeze, not building beyond the three settlement blocs that most Israelis envision being ultimately annexed into Israel proper with a peace agreement. From our more dovish point of view, however, this is still problematic, as any construction within the occupied territories (including East Jerusalem) probably violates international law and continues to change facts on the ground in areas that should be negotiated over. I know where he’s coming from. During his three months here, he’s experienced many American Jews as living in a “time warp”: with liberal audiences confronting his views as if the Second Intifada had never happened, while right-wingers criticized his reference to “Palestinians” as if they were still in the 1970s denying their reality as a people. And he admitted in response to me that “centrism” could be framed to constitute an ill- advised defense of the status quo. Unfortunately, that’s exactly what his centrism amounts to as well. As if to clinch my sense of his myopia, he contrasted AIPAC positively with J Street. He praised AIPAC as representing the “center” rather than the right, and dismissed J Street as being on the “left” (he made no reference to Jewish Voice for Peace and other groups that support BDS and do not express unambiguous support for a two-state solution). Substantiating his definition of AIPAC as centrist, he made the technically correct observation that it rhetorically endorses a two-state solution and would support a settlement freeze beyond the separation barrier. Nevertheless, he credited J Street’s Jeremy Ben-Ami with a verbal formulation that may provide a compromise on the Jewish state issue, by suggesting that the Palestinians recognize Israel as the “Jewish homeland.”.
Recommended publications
  • MARCH 2017 B’NEI MITZVAH Providers
    UPCOMING EVENTS Ruth Calderon Scholar-in-Residence Weekend March 31 – April 1 Friday, March 31 6:00 pm One Shabbat Service: Rav Ishmael meets God – Modern Spiritual Meaning and Challenges Friday, March 31 7:30 – 9:00 pm Special dinner with Ruth Calderon immediately following Shabbat service $20 per person, pre-registration required. Register online. Saturday, April 1 9:15 – 10:15 am Israel Action Committee Presents: Torah Study ‘NEHORA’ - on light and beauty of Talmudic protagonists AMBASSADOR DORE GOLD Sunday, April 2 ISRAEL’S EMERGING STRATEGIC 9:30 – 11:00 am Lecture: Spiritual Legacy and Doubt, What did RELATIONSHIPS WITH SUNNI Yochanan Ben Zakai leave his students and how is it relevant for us today? ARAB AND AFRICAN NATIONS - THE QUIET ALLIANCE Sunday, April 2 Tuesday, March 7, 7:00 pm Noon - 1:30 pm The doors open at 6:00 pm for check-in THE Book Club: Brunch with Ruth Calderon For this event, Young Adult Congregant Cost: $10.00; walk-ins will not be Young Adult General Admission: $18.00 accommodated. Brunch will be provided. This event requires registration in advance. Join our Young Adult Community and THE Book Registration will close Club for a one-of-a-kind opportunity to learn with at 5:00 pm on Monday, Ruth Calderon, famous Talmudist and founder of a March 6 secular yeshiva in Tel Aviv. She served as a member of Knesset for Yesh Atid between 2013 and 2015. Join us for the unique opportunity to hear We will discuss: spiritual legacy- what did Yochanan directly from Ambassador Ben Zakai leave his students and how is it relevant for Dore Gold, president of us today? the Jerusalem Center for Public Affairs.
    [Show full text]
  • Download Full Journal (PDF)
    SAPIR A JOURNAL OF JEWISH CONVERSATIONS THE ISSUE ON POWER ELISA SPUNGEN BILDNER & ROBERT BILDNER RUTH CALDERON · MONA CHAREN MARK DUBOWITZ · DORE GOLD FELICIA HERMAN · BENNY MORRIS MICHAEL OREN · ANSHEL PFEFFER THANE ROSENBAUM · JONATHAN D. SARNA MEIR SOLOVEICHIK · BRET STEPHENS JEFF SWARTZ · RUTH R. WISSE Volume Two Summer 2021 And they saw the God of Israel: Under His feet there was the likeness of a pavement of sapphire, like the very sky for purity. — Exodus 24: 10 SAPIR Bret Stephens EDITOR-IN-CHIEF Mark Charendoff PUBLISHER Ariella Saperstein ASSO CIATE PUBLISHER Felicia Herman MANAGING EDITOR Katherine Messenger DESIGNER & ILLUSTRATOR Sapir, a Journal of Jewish Conversations. ISSN 2767-1712. 2021, Volume 2. Published by Maimonides Fund. Copyright ©2021 by Maimonides Fund. No part of this journal may be reproduced in any form or by any means without the prior written consent of Maimonides Fund. All rights reserved. Printed in the United States of America. WWW.SAPIRJOURNAL.ORG WWW.MAIMONIDESFUND.ORG CONTENTS 6 Publisher’s Note | Mark Charendoff 90 MICHAEL OREN Trial and Triage in Washington 8 BRET STEPHENS The Necessity of Jewish Power 98 MONA CHAREN Between Hostile and Crazy: Jews and the Two Parties Power in Jewish Text & History 106 MARK DUBOWITZ How to Use Antisemitism Against Antisemites 20 RUTH R. WISSE The Allure of Powerlessness Power in Culture & Philanthropy 34 RUTH CALDERON King David and the Messiness of Power 116 JEFF SWARTZ Philanthropy Is Not Enough 46 RABBI MEIR Y. SOLOVEICHIK The Power of the Mob in an Unforgiving Age 124 ELISA SPUNGEN BILDNER & ROBERT BILDNER Power and Ethics in Jewish Philanthropy 56 ANSHEL PFEFFER The Use and Abuse of Jewish Power 134 JONATHAN D.
    [Show full text]
  • Introduction
    INTRODUCTION RECOVERING A REPRESSED PAS T On February 12, 2013, Ruth Calderon was invited to the dais of the Israeli Knesset to deliver her firs t speech as a newly-elected member of parliament.1 The speech was unlike any given in the his tory of deliberations in Israel’s legislature in that it consis ted primarily of her reading and interpreting a Talmudic s tory. The Talmudic s tory that Calderon read before the Knesset, firs t in the original Aramaic and then in Hebrew translation, was, as is typical of these s tories, very brief: Rabbi Rahumi s tudied under Rava in Mehoza. He would regularly come home to his wife on the eve of Yom Kippur. One day [on the eve of Yom Kippur] the topic [he was s tudying] drew him in. His wife anticipated him, “He is coming. He is coming.” He did not come. She began to grieve. She shed a tear from her eye. He was sitting on a roof. The roof collapsed under him, and he died. (B. Ketubot 62b)2 The s tory reflects what appears to have been a common practice among rabbinic scholars in Babylonia: to absent themselves from home for long periods of time to s tudy Torah. The author of the s tory expresses his disapproval of this cus tom by portraying empathically the emotional s tress experienced by Rabbi Rahumi’s wife when he was so engaged in Torah s tudy that he forgot to return home for the sacred holiday. The excitement captured in her cry of anticipation, “He is coming.
    [Show full text]
  • Ian S. Lustick
    MIDDLE EAST POLICY, VOL. XV, NO. 3, FALL 2008 ABANDONING THE IRON WALL: ISRAEL AND “THE MIDDLE EASTERN MUCK” Ian S. Lustick Dr. Lustick is the Bess W. Heyman Chair of Political Science at the University of Pennsylvania and the author of Trapped in the War on Terror. ionists arrived in Palestine in the the question of whether Israel and Israelis 1880s, and within several de- can remain in the Middle East without cades the movement’s leadership becoming part of it. Zrealized it faced a terrible pre- At first, Zionist settlers, land buyers, dicament. To create a permanent Jewish propagandists and emissaries negotiating political presence in the Middle East, with the Great Powers sought to avoid the Zionism needed peace. But day-to-day intractable and demoralizing subject of experience and their own nationalist Arab opposition to Zionism. Publicly, ideology gave Zionist leaders no reason to movement representatives promulgated expect Muslim Middle Easterners, and false images of Arab acceptance of especially the inhabitants of Palestine, to Zionism or of Palestinian Arab opportuni- greet the building of the Jewish National ties to secure a better life thanks to the Home with anything but intransigent and creation of the Jewish National Home. violent opposition. The solution to this Privately, they recognized the unbridgeable predicament was the Iron Wall — the gulf between their image of the country’s systematic but calibrated use of force to future and the images and interests of the teach Arabs that Israel, the Jewish “state- overwhelming majority of its inhabitants.1 on-the-way,” was ineradicable, regardless With no solution of their own to the “Arab of whether it was perceived by them to be problem,” they demanded that Britain and just.
    [Show full text]
  • ANNUAL REPORT 2016-2017 Table of Contents About the Elie Wiesel Center for Jewish Studies
    ANNUAL REPORT 2016-2017 Table of Contents About the Elie Wiesel Center for Jewish Studies ........................................................................ 3 Faculty and Courses ............................................................................................................................ 4 Director’s Message .............................................................................................................................. 7 In Memory of Elie Wiesel .................................................................................................................... 8 People ....................................................................................................................................................... 8 Faculty Highlights .................................................................................................................................. 8 Jewish Studies Faculty Receive Prestigious Awards ..................................................................... 9 Prof. Leora Bilsky’s year at EWCJS ...................................................................................................... 10 Visiting Scholars Share Their Expertise .................................................................................................... 10 Alexandra Herzog on Her Experience as a Postdoctoral Fellow ........................................................... 11 Featured Faculty Publications .........................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Israel and Overseas: Israeli Election Primer 2015 (As Of, January 27, 2015) Elections • in Israel, Elections for the Knesset A
    Israel and Overseas: Israeli Election Primer 2015 (As of, January 27, 2015) Elections In Israel, elections for the Knesset are held at least every four years. As is frequently the case, the outgoing government coalition collapsed due to disagreements between the parties. As a result, the Knesset fell significantly short of seeing out its full four year term. Knesset elections in Israel will now be held on March 17, 2015, slightly over two years since the last time that this occurred. The Basics of the Israeli Electoral System All Israeli citizens above the age of 18 and currently in the country are eligible to vote. Voters simply select one political party. Votes are tallied and each party is then basically awarded the same percentage of Knesset seats as the percentage of votes that it received. So a party that wins 10% of total votes, receives 10% of the seats in the Knesset (In other words, they would win 12, out of a total of 120 seats). To discourage small parties, the law was recently amended and now the votes of any party that does not win at least 3.25% of the total (probably around 130,000 votes) are completely discarded and that party will not receive any seats. (Until recently, the “electoral threshold,” as it is known, was only 2%). For the upcoming elections, by January 29, each party must submit a numbered list of its candidates, which cannot later be altered. So a party that receives 10 seats will send to the Knesset the top 10 people listed on its pre-submitted list.
    [Show full text]
  • Zionist Thought: Classical Theories and Current Dilemmas Dr
    Zionist Thought: Classical Theories and Current Dilemmas Dr. Arnold M. Eisen, JTS ScholarStream | April 21, 2021 Source 1: Theodor Herzl, The Jewish State (1896) in Hertzberg, Arthur, ed. The Zionist Idea: A Historical Analysis and Reader. Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society, 1997, 209. Anti-Semitism is a highly complex movement, which I think I understand. I approach this movement as a Jew, yet without fear or hatred. I believe that I can see in it the elements of cruel sport, of common commercial rivalry, of inherited prejudice, of religious intolerance—but also of a supposed need for self-defense. I consider the Jewish question neither a social nor a religious one, even though it sometimes takes these and other forms. It is a national question, and to solve it we must first of all establish it as an international political problem to be discussed and settled by the civilized nations of the world in council. We are a people—one people. We have sincerely tried everywhere to merge with the national communities in which we live, seeking only to preserve the faith of our fathers. It is not permitted us. In vain are we loyal patriots, sometimes superloyal; in vain do we make the same sacrifices of life and property as our fellow citizens; in vain do we strive to enhance the fame of our native lands in the arts and sciences, or her wealth by trade and commerce. In our native lands where we have lived for centuries we are still decried as aliens, often by men whose ancestors had not yet come at a time when Jewish sighs had long been heard in the country.
    [Show full text]
  • Letters to My Palestinian Neighbor Ebook Free Download
    LETTERS TO MY PALESTINIAN NEIGHBOR PDF, EPUB, EBOOK Yossi Klein Halevi | 224 pages | 24 Sep 2019 | HarperCollins Publishers Inc | 9780062844927 | English | New York, United States Letters to My Palestinian Neighbor PDF Book And we were at stages that actually drafted solutions. In lyrical, evocative language, he unravels the complex strands of faith, pride, anger and anguish he feels as a Jew living in Israel, using history and personal experience as his guide. And that will hopefully trigger a different kind of conversation-- an internal Israeli conversation, which is badly needed on the Palestinian issue, because even today, on the left, there is an avoidance of a real conversation about the future of our relationship with the Palestinians. I know of no other occupation, certainly in memory, where the occupying power not only worried that in ceding territory it would be diminished, but actually worries that in ceding territory it may not be able to adequately defend itself, which is an acute worry among many Israeli Jews, a worry that I share. And we we're engaged in this for the last at least 1, years, since Islam came into the picture-- competing over identity and competing over the position of the victim. You know, in America, there used to be a saying. And so what I've tried to do is create a language for Israeli Jews like myself who don't come from the left-- I come from the center, from the political center-- and for whom the subject of peace leaves many of us tongue-tied. English and Hebrew options are available for purchase wherever you can buy books.
    [Show full text]
  • Contributor Biographies
    155 Contributor Biographies Rabbi Rachel Adler, PhD, is the Ellenson Professor of Modern Jewish Thought at Hebrew Union College-Jewish Institute of Religion in Los Angeles. She was one of the first to bring feminist perspectives to bear on Jewish texts and law. Her book Engendering Judaism (1998) is the first by a female theologian to win a National Jewish Book Award for Jewish Thought. Hadeel Azzam-Jalajel, who was raised in Nazareth, was at the time of writing this essay co-director of the Racism Crisis Center and a lawyer with a private legal practice. She is a grad- uate of the Law School of the Hebrew University in Jerusalem. She interned at the civil rights organization Hamoked: Center for the Defense of the Individual, and since passing the bar in March of 2014, she has focused on administrative and constitu- tional law. Hadeel is a social and political activist, and a member of the leadership of the Jewish-Arab movement Standing Together, which works to promote peace, equality, and social justice. She also works as a content manager in both Hebrew and Arabic for the movement. Ruth Calderon, PhD, is a former member of the Israeli Knesset, former vice-speaker of the Knesset of the opposition party Yesh Atid, a Jewish educator, and Talmud scholar. In 1989, she founded Beit Midrash ELUL and, in 1996, the secular Beit Midrash for He- brew Culture, ALMA. She served as the head of the Division for Culture and Education of the Israeli National Library and on the faculty of the Mandel Institute for Nonprofit Leadership, where she also belonged to the first cohort of students to finish the program.
    [Show full text]
  • Jewish Sages of Today Teacher's Guide
    1 " % " / 0 g u i d e jewish sages of today Profiles of Extraordinary People MULTIDISCIPLINARY CLASSROOM IDEAS, DESIGNED TO INSPIRE Innovative, flexible lesson suggestions adaptable to a wide range of classroom settings and students: suitable for day schools and congregational schools and for middle school through university and adult school students A PROJECT OF TARGUM SHLISHI A RAQUEL AND ARYEH RUBIN FOUNDATION 1 " % " / 0 g u i d e jewish sages of today Profiles of Extraordinary People t e a c h e r’ s g u i d e jewish sages of today Profiles of Extraordinary People Jewish Sages of Today BOOK EDITOR ........................................ARYEH RUBIN teacher’s guide project team DEVELOPER .............................................................................RABBI ALAN ZELENETZ, M.PHIL PROJECT DIRECTOR .................................................................JUDITH DACH, PH.D. PROJECT MANAGING EDITOR .................................................ANDREA GOLLIN PROJECT CONSULTANT ...........................................................JOANNE PAPIR GRAPHIC DESIGNER ................................................................JENNIFER MINNICH, M2 DESIGN The Teacher’s Guide for Jewish Sages of Today: Profiles of Extraordinary People is a companion to the book. Jewish Sages of Today was conceived and edited by Aryeh Rubin and published in 2009 by Devora Publishing and Targum Shlishi. Art, design, photography credits: cover art and background art courtesy Tobi Kahn; cover design inspired by Jewish Sages of Today
    [Show full text]
  • Halevi Thursday, November 2 3:00 – 5:00 Pm Cross-Cultural Center – Communidad Room Yossi Klein Halevi Is a Senior Fellow at the Shalom Hartman Institute in Jerusalem
    University of California, San Diego STUDENTS are cordially invited to attend What Muslims and Jews Need From Each Other Coffee, cookies, and conversation with Yossi Klein Halevi Thursday, November 2 3:00 – 5:00 pm Cross-Cultural Center – Communidad Room Yossi Klein Halevi is a senior fellow at the Shalom Hartman Institute in Jerusalem. Together with Imam Abdullah Antepli of Duke University, he Co- direCts the Institute’s Muslim Leadership Initiative. Yossi is the author of Like Dreamers: The Story of the Israeli Paratroopers Who Reunited Jerusalem and Divided a Nation, published by HarperCollins in 2013, whiCh won the Jewish Book CounCil's Everett Family Foundation Jewish Book of the Year Award. He is also author of the 2001 book, At the Entrance to the Garden of Eden: A Jew's Search for God with Christians and Muslims in the Holy Land. The novelist Cynthia OziCk Called At the Entrance "a permanent masterwork." The former ArChbishop of Canterbury, Dr. Rowan Williams, called it “extraordinary and heartbreaking…a book full of wonders.” Yossi's first book, Memoirs of a Jewish Extremist, told the story of his teenage attraction to, and subsequent disillusionment with Jewish militanCy. The New York Times called it “a book of burning importance.” Yossi has been aCtive in Middle East reConciliation work, and serves as chairman of Open House, an Arab Israeli-Jewish Israeli Center in the town of Ramle, near Tel Aviv. Yossi was one of the founders of the now-defunct Israeli- Palestinian Media Forum, whiCh brought together Israeli and Palestinian journalists. He was a senior fellow at the Shalem Center in Jerusalem from 2003-2009.
    [Show full text]
  • The Avi Chai Prize ≠5757
    THE AVI CHAI PRIZE ≠ 5757 BOARD OF TRUSTEES Zalman C. Bernstein, Chairman Founding Chairman, Sanford C. Bernstein & Co., Inc. Chairman, The Tikvah Fund Avital Darmon Director, School for Educational Leadership Alan R. Feld Managing Director and Financial Advisor, Sanford C. Bernstein & Co., Inc. Arthur W. Fried Director General, Yad Hanadiv Lauren K. Merkin Past Managing Editor, Elsevier Science Publishing Co., Inc. Samuel J. Silberman Past President, New York Federation of Jewish Philanthropies Henry Taub Chairman, Executive Committee, Automatic Data Processing Inc. Chairman, International Board of Governors - The Technion David W. Weiss Prof. Emeritus & Founder, The Lautenberg Center for General and Tumor Immunology, Hebrew University-Hadassah Medical School Ruth R. Wisse Professor, Yiddish and Comparative Literature, Harvard University EXECUTIVE DIRECTORS: Dr. Eli Silver (ISRAEL) Yossi Prager (USA) Israel 28 Ramban St. P.O. Box 7035 91070 Jerusalem Tel. 02-563-1227 Fax: 02-566-2861 e-mail: [email protected] USA 52 Vanderbilt Avenue New York, NY 10017-3808 Tel. (212) 697-8836 Fax: (212) 697-8879 e-mail: [email protected] A Commitment to the Jewish People, Judaism, and the State of Israel AVI CHAI is a private foundation, established in 1984, which functions in Israel and the United States. Our primary goals are to encourage mutual understanding and sensitivity among Jews of different religious backgrounds and to increase understanding and appreciation of Jewish traditions, customs, and laws. Some projects in Israel currently supported by AVI CHAI are: * Tzav Pius: a broad public campaign, begun in 1996, to encourage mutual understanding and respect among all sectors of the Jewish People.
    [Show full text]