Turning up the Volume: Page 4 Brooklyn A’S Foreclosure Prevention Unit Expands Legal Services During Housing Crisis
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Brooklyn Legal Services Corporation A Spring 2009 Inside: Equal Justice for All page 2 Former HPD Commissioner Shaun Donovan and NYC Council Speaker Christine Quinn with BROOKLYN A Project Director and Chief Counsel Marty Needelman and A Tree Grows in Brooklyn Advisory Committee Member Terri Thomson and Bed Stuy Restoration Executive page 3 Director Corwin Grannum during a Foreclosure Prevention Press Conference. Photo credit: Mel Wright Mel Photo credit: Celebrating 40 Years! Turning Up The Volume: page 4 BROOKLYN A’s Foreclosure Prevention Unit Expands Legal Services During Housing Crisis Jason Portwood Hipp assisting Ms. Jones in negotiations to modify the mortgage to an affordable and sustainable Ms. Jones* is one of the lucky ones – if you amount. can consider losing equity of more than $150,000 a stroke of luck. Ms. Jones, a moth- Mr. Ramirez* had been attempting to modify er of four adopted children facing foreclo- the terms of his home loan prior to a referral sure, was offered a deal purporting to assist to BROOKLYN A by a housing counselor at a her with saving the deed to her home. After- local community organization. Mr. Ramirez Expanding CED in NYC wards, Ms. Jones learned the deal was offered had been stuck with a “balloon payment” page 6 by one of the many foreclosure rescue scam – a mortgage loan structured to pay small artists using the mortgage crisis as a business amounts of interest in the beginning before opportunity. Thinking she was signing docu- the complete payment is owed after a limited ments for financial assistance and a modified period of time. Mr. Ramirez had unsuccess- mortgage, she was actually the victim of a fully attempted to modify the loan, but the scam that transferred the property’s deed to monthly payments he was being offered were a third party. With the help of Brooklyn Le- far in excess of his means, particularly after gal Services Corporation A (BROOKLYN A)’s losing rental income. After he filed a pro se Anti-Predatory Lending/Foreclosure Preven- legal document drafted by BROOKLYN A for tion Unit, Ms. Jones filed a complaint against his foreclosure case, the bank offered him the phony buyer and the mortgage company a loan modification three weeks later with terms he could meet. this past summer, and by the Fall the deed was returned to her. Although this was an The successes achieved by Ms. Jones and unusually swift success, BROOKLYN A is still Mr. Ramirez come as a result of BROOK- See Foreclosure, Page 7 BUILDING COMMUNITIES * Names of clients have been altered to protect privacy. ENSURING OPPORTUNITY ACHIEVING JUSTICE Brooklyn Legal Services Corporation A, Equal Justice For All, President providing high-quality neighborhood-based civil legal services to low-income individuals and groups in North and East Brooklyn Obama, & “Brooklyn Planning” since 1968. Marty Needelman in the borough, and somehow that prede- BROOKLYN A Project Director & Chief Counsel termination has been made without any Project Director & Chief Counsel ecent years have been especially prob- description or detail of that “inadequacy” Martin S. Needelman Rlematic for programs attempting to nor any explanation how the “inadequacy,” however that might be defined, substan- General Counsel provide legal representation to low in- Paul J. Acinapura come people, the communities in which tially differs from everywhere else. Some they live, and the local groups who serve voices believe that the Brooklyn Planning Director, Administration & Finance Joshua D. Hoffman them. Lack of support for “legal services process is a pretext toward a more cen- for the poor” by the Bush and Pataki Ad- trally controlled decision making system Board of Directors ministrations and by the U.S. and state in lieu of the current decentralized and Valarie A. Hing, Chair coordinated system. James H.R. Windels, Vice-Chair senates reduced funding for Brooklyn Le- Harvey Lawrence, Treasurer gal Services Corporation A (BROOKLYN A) Indeed, Brooklyn has five programs, three Robert E. Crotty, Secretary Musa Abdul-Basser and programs like ours dramatically below ROOKLYN of these (B A, South Brooklyn Jane N. Barrett the levels going back over 15 years ago. Any Legal Services and Bedford-Stuyvesant Le- Mirta M. De Jesus honest analysis, would have to conclude gal Services) with separate Boards of Di- Matthew Fishbein that the oft articulated vision of our legal Harold Green rectors that reflect the community based Joseph Lipofsky system providing “Equal Justice for All,” services of those programs, and which Frances Lucerna that Americans take so much pride in, is maintain four neighborhood based offices Moronke Oshin-Martin - at best - self deception. However, recent (the other two Brooklyn programs are Anne Pilsbury changes at both the federal and state lev- Saul B. Shapiro LS-NYC Brooklyn Office and the Brook- Thomas McC. Souther els, particularly the election of President lyn Family Defense Project). Although Rev. Peter A. Mahoney, Emeritus Obama, should give all those of us who tru- Brooklyn is by far the largest borough by Arthur Bates, Emeritus ly care about the deficiencies in resources population (if independent, would be the Advisory Committee in the “legal services” world and otherwise 4th largest city in the US) and has the Honorary Co-Chairs in our system of justice, real reason for highest number of poor persons, the issue Barry H. Garfinkel hope of turning things around and moving Henry L. King transcends those logistics. Fundamentally, Robert MacCrate things in the right direction. That should the Brooklyn programs reflect a continu- Sargent Shriver be even more so, now that such big bucks ing commitment to the original, Sargent Haywood Burns 1940-1996 are being thrown around to “bail out” the Paul J. Curran 1933-2008 Shriver vision of a dynamic legal services Charles E. Inniss 1935-1997 US economy after its recent shocking col- program that both aggressively represents Hon. Harold R. Tyler, Jr. 1921-2005 lapse. We should have every hope that a families and individuals, and the commu- William A. Volckhausen 1937-2001 pittance of that (a couple of billion dollars nity organizations that serve them, all out Peter A. Cross, Co-Chair Gary S. Hattem Nelson Perez, Co-Chair Jean G. Leon or so at most) would go toward the fulfill- of neighborhood based, conveniently lo- ment of the dream and desperate need Alvin Adelman Frank J. Macchiarola cated and accessible offices. Henry P. Baer Kenneth J. Mahon for legal representation for low-income Maureen Bateman Rev. Peter A. Mahoney people. Yet, it is extremely disappointing I and many others believe that it is the Eileen Berkman Sam Marks and shocking that restoration and dra- right model, that that vision should be Carlos Cabrales William Mastro Evan A. Davis Jason Otano matically increased funding for these basic sustained, resurrected and expanded, and Brendan J. Dugan Vincent F. Pitta needs and goals of our democratic society that the recent trend to centralize and Thomas Early Mariadele Priest do not seem to be on the decision makers’ eliminate local offices and programs should Randy Estrada Patricia Ricketts Michael G. Flanigan Leslie B. Samuels current agenda! be reversed. Indeed it is our constant and Steven Flax Terri Thomson long-lasting presence in our neighbor- Caroline E. Forte Dean William Treanor Ironically, at this critical watershed mo- hoods which contributes to the strong Joseph E. Geoghan Grace Lyu Volckhausen ment in our history and for what should be Stephen L. Gordon Joseph Wayland relationship we have with the residents, the struggle for equal justice for all, leaders Michael Gugig community based organizations, social of the city wide legal services program (LS- service agencies and political representa- NYC) have decided to invest significant BROOKLYN A News tives in these communities. written and produced by BROOKLYN A staff, focus and human resources on “Brooklyn including Paul Acinapura, Josh Hoffman, Planning,” a process intended to evaluate At this crucial moment in the history of Rebecca Libed, Marty Needelman, and address the Brooklyn legal services the system of justice, it is time for both Jessica Rose, and Rick Wagner. Design by Tzvi S. Cohen delivery system. It has been concluded we and our society to put our priorities in that there is an “inadequacy of services” order! 2 BROOKLYN A News Spring 2009 BROOKLYN A Thanks Velázquez and Towns ROOKLYN A presented plaques to Congresswoman Ny- Bdia Velázquez and Assemblymember Darryl C. Towns for our deep appreciation for their extraordinary support for our program and for our clients, long term, low-income residents struggling to remain in their homes and in their neighborhoods. Both elected officials have been instrumental in our ability to provide neighborhood-based civil legal services to low-income individuals and families throughout North and East Brooklyn, and to the nonprofit organizations that serve those communi- Photo credit: Evelyn Cruz Evelyn Photo credit: ties. We thank them for their many years of support! Thomson Terri Photo credit: Award Presentation to Towns (left) and Velázquez (right) Welcome Aboard! andy Estrada has joined the BROOK- nomic Development (CED) Unit so we InMotion and SeedCo on RLYN A Advisory Committee. Randy is can continue to assist our clients develop various matters. He re- an Assistant Vice President at TD Bank and support their neighborhoods. ceived his JD from NYU and the Branch Manager of the Brook- School of Law and his BA lyn Heights Branch. He’s a veteran of the Starting in January 2009, Rafael Vasquez, from Yale. Prior to law banking industry having spent the past 15 an associate at the firm of Simpson school, he was a Jump- years at European Ameri- Thacher & Bartlett LLP joined the CED start Corps (Americorps) Rafael Vasquez can Bank, Independence Unit as a full time extern for a four month Headstart Teacher for a Community Bank, and rotation.