Financialization and Sustainability in the Dubai Model

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Financialization and Sustainability in the Dubai Model SUSTAINABILITY OF THE DUBAI MODEL OF ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT A thesis submitted to The University of Manchester for the degree of PhD In the Faculty of Humanities 2014 Nada Saleh Al Shama Manchester Business School Division of People, Management and Organisations LIST OF CONTENTS LIST OF CONTENTS....................................................................................................................2 LIST OF TABLES.........................................................................................................................6 LIST OF FIGURES........................................................................................................................7 LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS..........................................................................................................8 ABSTRACT.................................................................................................................................10 DECLARATION..........................................................................................................................11 COPYRIGHT STATEMENT........................................................................................................11 DEDICATION..............................................................................................................................12 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS...........................................................................................................13 CHAPTER 1: RESEARCH OVERVIEW....................................................................................14 1.1 Introduction........................................................................................................................14 1.2 Research Problem.............................................................................................................15 1.3 Scope of the Research......................................................................................................17 1.4 Research Aim and Objectives...........................................................................................17 1.5 Research Questions..........................................................................................................18 1.6 Contributions of the Research...........................................................................................20 1.7 Thesis Structure.................................................................................................................21 CHAPTER 2: LITERATURE REVIEW AND THEORETICAL FRAMEWORK..........................23 2.1 Introduction.........................................................................................................................23 2.2 The Case of Dubai in Academic Studies............................................................................23 2.3 Cultural Economy...............................................................................................................26 2.4 Economic Geography.........................................................................................................27 2.5 Dynamics of Economic Landscapes Under Globalisation..................................................30 2.5.1 The Emergence of Global Cities.........................................................................32 2.6 Dynamics of Economic Landscapes Under Growing Competition.....................................35 2.6.1 The Emergence of Competitive Cities................................................................35 2.6.2 The Emergence of Entrepreneurial Cities..........................................................37 2.6.3 City Images, Narratives, Place Branding and Marketing....................................38 2.7 Dynamics of Economic Landscapes Under Capitalism......................................................40 2.8 Dynamics of Economic Landscapes Under Financialization..............................................42 2.9 Theoretical Framework of the Study...................................................................................45 2.10 Conclusion.........................................................................................................................49 CHAPTER 3: RESEARCH METHODOLOGY...........................................................................51 3.1 Introduction.........................................................................................................................51 3.2 Methodological Approach...................................................................................................51 2 3.3 Research Design................................................................................................................53 3.3.1 Documentary Evidence......................................................................................56 3.3.2 In-depth Elite Interviews.....................................................................................56 3.4 Data Analysis Strategy.......................................................................................................60 3.5 Research Validity and Reliability........................................................................................63 3.6 Research Ethics.................................................................................................................64 3.7 Conclusion.........................................................................................................................65 CHAPTER 4: SOCIO-CULTURAL AND POLITICAL CONTEXT OF DUBAI...........................66 4.1 Introduction.........................................................................................................................66 4.2 Overview.............................................................................................................................66 4.3 The Historical Trajectory of Dubai......................................................................................67 4.4 The Social Structure of Dubai............................................................................................70 4.5 The Cultural Features of Dubai..........................................................................................77 4.6 The Political and Institutional Structure of Dubai................................................................78 4.7 The Governance System in Dubai......................................................................................83 4.8 The Nature of Leadership in Dubai.....................................................................................85 4.9 Conclusion..........................................................................................................................89 CHAPTER 5: MACROECONOMIC CONTEXT OF DUBAI.......................................................90 5.1 Introduction.........................................................................................................................90 5.2 The Economic Background of Dubai..................................................................................90 5.3 Macroeconomic Performance of Dubai..............................................................................92 5.3.1 The Composition and Growth of the Gross Domestic Product...........................92 5.3.2 Foreign Trade.....................................................................................................93 5.3.3 Foreign Direct Investment...................................................................................95 5.4 The Strategy of Economic Diversification...........................................................................96 5.4.1 Infrastructure, Transport and Logistics Sector....................................................97 5.4.2 Tourism and Leisure Sector................................................................................99 5.4.3 Specialised Free Zones.....................................................................................101 5.4.4 Real Estate and Construction Sector................................................................103 5.5 The Outbreak of the Global Financial Crisis.....................................................................105 5.6 Effect of the Global Financial Crisis on the Economy of Dubai........................................106 5.6.1 Gross Domestic Product and Foreign Trade....................................................106 5.6.2 Financial Status................................................................................................107 5.6.3 The Real Estate Market....................................................................................111 5.6.4 The Banking Sector..........................................................................................115 5.6.5 Reputation and Economic Confidence.............................................................116 5.7 Federal and Dubai Local Government Responses to the Crisis.......................................117 5.8 Conclusion........................................................................................................................118 3 CHAPTER 6: EMPIRICAL AND ANALYTICAL RESEARCH FINDINGS ON THE INFLUENCE OF THE POLITICAL AND SOCIO-CULTURAL CONTEXT ON THE DUBAI MODEL.........................................................................................................................119 6.1 Introduction.......................................................................................................................119 6.2 The Political
Recommended publications
  • Reigniting Growth in Central and Eastern Europe Eastern and Central in Growth Dawn:A New Reigniting
    McKinsey Global Institute McKinsey Global Institute A new dawn: ReignitingA new dawn: growth in Central and Eastern Europe December 2013 A new dawn: Reigniting growth in Central and Eastern Europe The McKinsey Global Institute The McKinsey Global Institute (MGI), the business and economics research arm of McKinsey & Company, was established in 1990 to develop a deeper understanding of the evolving global economy. MGI’s mission is to provide leaders in the commercial, public, and social sectors with the facts and insights on which to base management and policy decisions. MGI research combines the disciplines of economics and management, employing the analytical tools of economics with the insights of business leaders. Its “micro-to-macro” methodology examines microeconomic industry trends to better understand the broad macroeconomic forces affecting business strategy and public policy. MGI’s in-depth reports have covered more than 20 countries and 30 industries. Current research focuses on six themes: productivity and growth; the evolution of global financial markets; the economic impact of technology and innovation; natural resources; the future of work; and urbanisation. Recent reports have assessed job creation, resource productivity, cities of the future, and the impact of the Internet. The partners of McKinsey fund MGI’s research; it is not commissioned by any business, government, or other institution. For further information about MGI and to download reports, please visit www.mckinsey.com/mgi. McKinsey in Central and Eastern Europe McKinsey & Company opened its first offices in Central and Eastern Europe in the early 1990s, soon after the momentous democratic changes in the region. McKinsey played an active role in the region’s economic rebirth, working with governments, nonprofits, and cultural institutions, as well as leading business organisations.
    [Show full text]
  • Guide to Doing Business in the United Arab Emirates
    CANADA-UAE BUSINESS COUNCIL GUIDE TO DOING BUSINESS IN THE UNITED ARAB EMIRATES 1ST EDITION This document offers an overview of each federal government’s strategies and initiatives, key organizations, main women’s events & key people. This Canada-UAE Business Council Guide to Doing Business in the United Arab Emirates is intended UAE to educate Canadians interested in conducting FACT SHEET business in the United Arab Emirates (UAE). The Guide gives an overview of the UAE—its government structure, demographics, and economy. It presents considerations for business, including reasons to do business in the UAE, business etiquette, establishing a business, labour laws, and taxation. It also incorporates a section on Canada-UAE commercial relations to provide context for the broader bilateral business relationship. This Guide is not an exhaustive resource on every FOUNDED aspect of doing business in the UAE and therefore should only be used as a starting point for Canadian businesses exploring potential opportunities in 1971 the UAE. It is not a substitute for specific business ST or legal advice. Section 12 provides a list of FOUNDER/1 PRESIDENT RELIGION organizations in both the UAE and Canada that can HIS HIGHNESS SHEIKH ZAYED OFFICIALLY ISLAM; be contacted for further information and assistance. BIN SULTAN AL NAHYAN OTHER RELIGIONS PRACTICED This Guide was inspired by the US-UAE Business POLITICAL SYSTEM Council Guide to Doing Business in the United Arab LANGUAGE Emirates CONSTITUTIONAL FEDERATION OFFICIALLY ARABIC; designed for American businesses. The (THE MONARCH OF ABU DHABI IS THE HEAD OF STATE) Canada-UAE Business Council (CUBC) developed ENGLISH IS WIDELY SPOKEN this Guide after reviewing dozens of other similar FEDERATION GDP guides published by various trade and investment SEVEN EMIRATES entities and law offices active in the UAE.
    [Show full text]
  • However the Ugly Face of the So Called "Dubai Model" Which Was Based Upon Debt and Speculation, Was Hiding Somewhere in the Breakneck Boom
    What is Dubai Crisis? y The Dubai Debt Crisis 2009 has been called by economists a consequence of real estate bubble burst when on November 26, 2009 vaDubai proposed to delay repayment of its debt which includes delay in the payment of $ 59 Billion debt on Dubai World, the investment vehicle for the emirates for 6 months. Dubai's Economy: y Dubai has one of the most unique and unusual economies in the world. Dubai has numerous free zones including Jebel Ali free zone, Dubai Maritime City, Dubai Internet City, and Dubai Media City. y Contrary to the general assumption that Dubai's economy is totally driven by oil and gas,It is a fact that oil sector only comprises less than 6% of the economy of Dubai. y In fact, Dubai's portion of natural gas revenues in the United Arab Emirates is only about 2%. Dubai's oil production is estimated to be about 240,000 barrels per day. y It is true that Dubai's economy was built on the back of Oil Money but Dubai's oil reserves have diminished significantly and are expected to be exhausted in 20 years. y The other largest contributing sectors of Dubai economy are Real estate and construction (22.6%), trade (16%), (15%) and financial services (11%) (all are 2007 figures). Diversifying to Real Estate: y In 2000, Dubai Financial Market (DFM) was established. It was established as a secondary market for trading securities and bonds, both local and foreign. During that time the Government decided to diversify Dubai's economy from a trade-based, but oil-reliant, economy to one that is service and tourism-oriented has made real estate more valuable.
    [Show full text]
  • Dubai - the United Arab Emirates
    Sydney (+61 2) 8825 9300 Melbourne (+61 3) 9799 5800 Brisbane (+61 7) 3348 2500 www.ossworldwidemovers.com Dubai - The United Arab Emirates Dubai is truly a unique destination. Situated in the UAE, the world’s 31st popular tourism destination and the Arab World’s most popular, Dubai is both a dynamic business hub and a tourist’s paradise. The emirate offers more attractions, shopping, fine dining and quality hotels than virtually any other destination on the planet. In 2012, Dubai welcomed over 10 million visitors from around the world, which is an increase of 9.3% from the previous year. It also ranked 8th place globally in terms of tourist spending in the same year. From the timeless tranquillity of the desert to the lively bustle of the souks, the city presents a fantastic ensemble of attractions and activities for its visitors and residents. In a single day, one can experience everything from rugged mountains and breathtaking dunes to white sandy beaches and lush, beautifully landscaped parks, from dated villages to luxurious residential districts, and from traditional houses with wind towers to ultra-modern shopping centres. The emirate’s scoring point’s lie in its entrepreneurial abilities to create the inconceivable found in its tourist attractions, landmarks, shopping centres, nightlife and hotels. Although it strictly safeguards its traditional practices, it allows space for other religions to breathe, a rare quality amongst the conservative Arab world. Thankfully, it has been successful in shielding itself from extremism, much-needed for it to survive. Today, Dubai has emerged as a cosmopolitan metropolis that has grown steadily to become a global city and a business and cultural hub of the Middle East and the Persian Gulf region.
    [Show full text]
  • Understanding Free Trade Zones
    Understanding Free Trade Zones CA. Sameer Kashikar ACA, MBA Table of Contents Page Topic No. Free Trade Zone - An Introduction 1 Benefits of Free Trade Zones 2 UAE And Free Trade Zones 3 Jabel Ali Free Zone – A Pioneer 4 List of Free Zones in UAE 5 UAE Free Zones & VAT 7 Free Trade Zone - An Introduction A Free trade Zones (FTZ) also known as Free Economic Zones (FEZ), Free Economic territories (FEts) or Free Zones (FZ) are one or more areas of the Country where tariffs & quotas are eliminated, and bureaucratic requirements are lowered in order to attract companies by floating the incentives for doing business there. Free trade Zones are proved to be an effective & useful tool to develop new markets and to increase earnings from foreign trade. Most of the Free trade zones are located in developing countries. They are special zones where typical trade barriers such as import or export tariffs do not apply, bureaucracy is typically minimized by outsourcing it to FTZ operators. Companies can seek sheltered area best suited to their needs The organizations set up in the Free Trade Zones may be given tax breaks as an additional incentive. Mostly these zones are set up in the underdeveloped part of the country, the rationale that the zones will attract employers and thus economic activities will take place in that area thereby increasing employment and cashflow. 1 Free trade zones in Latin America dates back to the early decade of the 20th century. The first free trade regulations were enacted in 1920 in Argentina and Uruguay.
    [Show full text]
  • Allcovered News CONTENTS Information to Help You to Manage and Grow Your Logistics Business
    AllCovered HIGHLIGHTS TO HELP YOU THIS WEEK · Are Your High Performers Ready to Quit? · Association Health Plans… Down… Not Out · Cargo Theft Up So Insurance Rates Up NEWS · Cooperate to Cut Shipping Costs COPYRIGHT 2006 Monday, 9 October 2006 --- Edition #509 All Rights Reserved AllCovered-NEWS is sent free via email to all who request it designed to display as html or plain text as your email software requires Allcovered.net – PO Box 1439 – 304 MLK Jr Dr – Fort Valley, GA 31030 USA – Voice: +1.478.825.5566 DETAILED AllCovered News CONTENTS Information to help you to manage and grow your logistics business. THIS WEEK YOU DESERVE IT – WE DELIVER IT Allcovered.net … We have logistics Allcovered SMALL BUSINESS: Allcovered News is a service of Allcovered & the Allen Insurance Group Your Sources For: Cargo – Liability – E&O – Bonds – Trucking – Life – Health - Benefits Are Your High Performers Trouble viewing this? See this & past issues online in PDF format at: Ready to Quit? http://www.allcovered.net/AC-News-PDF.htm AHPs Down But Not Out > > SMALL BUSINESS SECTION < < Do Small Firms Pay Less for Benefits? SMALL BIZ – ARE YOUR HIGH PERFORMERS READY TO QUIT? According to a study by Leadership IQ, 47% of high performers are actively looking TRUCKING: for other jobs (they’re posting and submitting resumes, and even going on interviews). Keep Your While it’s terrible that almost half of high performers are thinking about quitting, Owner – Operators what’s perhaps even worse is that low performers want to stay. Only 18% of low performing employees are actively seeking other jobs, and 25% of middle performers Drivers’ Eyes Open for US are actively looking around.
    [Show full text]
  • Quantifying the Economic Impact of Aviation in Dubai November 2014
    The impact of Oman Air in Oman Final Report – July 2013 Quantifying the Economic Impact of Aviation in Dubai November 2014 A report for Emirates and Dubai Airports November 2014 Quantifying the economic impact of aviation in Dubai Contents Executive summary ...................................................................................... 3 1 Introduction ..................................................................................... 5 2 The core impact of aviation on the Dubai economy...................... 7 3 ‘Catalytic’ benefits of the aviation sector .................................... 13 4 Diversification analysis ................................................................. 23 5 The potential impact of aviation in 2020 and 2030 ...................... 26 Annex 1: Calculating the core economic impacts .................................... 33 Annex 2: The basis for the 2020 and 2030 projections ............................. 35 2 Quantifying the economic impact of aviation in Dubai Executive summary This report sets out the contribution of the Emirates Group, Dubai Airports and the aviation sector as a whole to the economy of Dubai in 2013. It assesses the value of the activity undertaken by businesses forming part of the aviation sector (the ‘direct’ impact), and that of the additional work carried out by other Dubai-based entities as a result of supply chain (‘indirect’) and employee spending (‘induced’) impacts, together with the associated employment effects. The study also analyses the benefits to the Dubai economy
    [Show full text]
  • DMCC Pdtiproductioon Zone 14
    ahesh Goyal & Associates Al Ali Auditing ahesh Management Consultants (Auditors & Business Advisors) Our Company Profile _________________________________________________ 3 About UAE ______________________________________________________________ 5 UAE Profile ______________________________________________________________6 Types of CiCompanies in UAE___________________________________________ 7 Business in UAE________________________________________________________ 9 Free Zones of UAE___________________________________________________ 10 Offshore Companies_________________________________________________ 11 About Dubai__________________________________________________________ 12 Dubai Free Zone______________________________________________________ 13 Sharjah__________________________________________________________________ 19 Abu Dhabi _____________________________________________________________ 20 Ras Al Khaimah ______________________________________________________ 21 Umm‐Al‐Quwain _____________________________________________________ 22 Ajman__________________________________________________________________ 22 Fujairah _______________________________________________________________ 23 Contacts us ____________________________________________________________ 24 Disclaimer: 1) Although the team of M Al Ali Auditing has made every effort to ensure that the information in this book was correct at press time, the team does not assume and hereby disclaim any liability to any party for any loss, damage, or disruption caused
    [Show full text]
  • Who Better to Guide Visitors to Dubai Through the Layers
    Who better to guide visitors to Dubai through the layers of the city than its residents? While Dubai’s five-star hotels, shopping centres and beaches tend to dominate the pages of most guidebooks, visitors who are limited to these destinations would leave with a mere unsatisfactory glimpse of the city. If you’re looking to get a sense of what it’s like to live in Dubai, to visit the city’s distinctive corners and explore its nooks and crannies, this unconventional guidebook will serve as your perfect companion. In its pages you will find the reflections and recommendations of Emiratis and long-time residents of the city, who will introduce you to its cultural identity, its distinguishing characteristics, and its soul. There is far more to the city than record-breaking skyscrapers and malls. The metropolis, which is home to more than 200 nationalities, has a rich history, celebrated through ongoing heritage preservation programmes, and it has rapidly evolved into a global arts hub, a multicultural culinary destination, an eco-friendly landscape, and a trendsetter in fields as diverse as business, technology and fashion. Through focus groups and interviews with the people who know Dubai best, the Dubai Culture and Arts Authority asked the city’s residents to tell its story, highlight its popular facets and share their diverse memories of life within its friendly borders. What follows is a people’s introduction to Dubai, an invitation from the city’s residents to potential visitors, guiding them towards its cultural enclaves, historical districts, design boutiques, homegrown eateries, parks and much more.
    [Show full text]
  • Children with Autism Spectrum Disorders in the Arab Gulf Countries – the Others?
    EDUKACJA MIĘDZYKULTUROWA 2019, nr 1 (10) ISSN 2299-4106 DOI: 10.15804/em.2019.01.12 aGata wentz Children with autism spectrum disorders in the Arab Gulf countries – the Others? Streszczenie: Autyzm jest zaburzeniem neurorozwojowym, które manifestuje się w obszarach związanych między innymi z relacjami społecznymi, komunikacją werbalną i niewerbalną. W ciągu ostatnich dziesięciu lat liczne kampanie spo- łeczne na całym świecie, także w regionie Półwyspu Arabskiego, podniosły ogólny poziom świadomości na temat tego zaburzenia zarówno wśród rodziców, jak i eks- pertów. Jednakże tradycyjne wierzenia i przekonania pozostają nadal istotnymi czynnikami, które kształtują zachowania związane z profilaktyką prozdrowotną i nastawieniem do kwestii związanych z szeroko pojętym zdrowiem psychicznym. Niniejsze opracowanie omawia znaczenie tych czynników, a także religii, na per- cepcję zaburzeń ze spektrum autyzmu w regionie państw GCC (Rady Współpracy Zatoki). Słowa kluczowe: autyzm, niepełnosprawność, GCC, Zjednoczone Emiraty Arab- skie, islam, społeczeństwo, percepcja, edukacja międzykulturowa Introduction In the last decade, there has been increased media attention to autism both globally and across the GCC (Gulf Cooperation Council countries – Saudi Arabia, the United Arab Emirates, Oman, Qatar, Kuwait, Bahrain). This, in turn, has increased the knowledge and awareness of the condition in the Ara- bian Gulf region among both parents and professionals. The first report from the region about the prevalence of autism in the community came from the United Arab Emirates (UAE) and reported a weighted prevalence of 29 per 10,000 among 3-year-olds in the UAE national population. While the rate re- ported from the UAE is comparable to that observed in other countries, none of the UAE children diagnosed during the study have a prior diagnosis.
    [Show full text]
  • Geographies and Genealogies of Global City Status Alisha Ticku A
    Dreamscapes of Dubai: Geographies and Genealogies of Global City Status Alisha Ticku A Dissertation submitted to the Faculty of Graduate Studies in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy Graduate Program in Political Science, York University, Toronto, Ontario February 2017 © Alisha Ticku, 2017 Abstract This dissertation asks how Dubai’s dream and position as a ‘global city’ impacts on and is impacted by the experiences of a migrant-majority population; and, simultaneously, how the operation of highly exclusionary citizenship regimes and everyday ideologies work to justify and rationalize social hierarchies. It explores the making of Dubai’s global, developmental trajectory through a multiplicity of dreams and temporalities as they shape urban landscapes and social hierarchies in the city. Methodologically, it operates through an understanding of the simultaneity of social scales, which allows, in part, for an examination of how the ‘everyday’ offers insight as a counterpoint to the spectacle of globality. Theoretically I argue that understanding the construction of particular subjectivities created through relational identity formation and processes of ‘Othering’ based on privilege and exclusion allows for a more complex understanding of the social, political, economic and imaginary realms through which we might challenge social hierarchies and the subsequent violence(s) they engender as somehow natural, inevitable, increasingly acceptable, and at times, necessary in the making of neoliberal globality. It is argued that migration is an integral and foundational aspect of Dubai’s development and global allure, illustrated by mapping the diverse routes that comprise geographies of migration to the city, while simultaneously ‘unmapping’ the historical genealogies that accompany migrants on their journeys to the city.
    [Show full text]
  • Bachelor Thesis
    Bachelor thesis GPM Is Dubai the city a new city should be? The Dubai International Financial Centre as an example for Free Zones within Dubai Student: Tim Will Radboud Universiteit Nijmegen Front-page figure top left: Figure (1) The logo of the Radboud University Front-page figure top right: Figure (2 )The Logo of the Dubai International Financial Centre Front-page figure middle: Figure (3) Own picture of the Gate Avenue at DIFC 2 B Bachelor thesis Radboud University Nijmegen Faculty of Management Sciences Department of Geography, Planning & Environment By Tim Will (s4658469) Supervisor P. Ache Word count: 23.901 August 11, 17 Final Version Is Dubai the city a neW city should be? The Dubai international Financial Centre as an examplefor Free Zones Within Dubai 3 4 Foreword I Foreword Augst, 2017 Dear reader, You are reading my final version for the bachelor thesis for the Radboud Universiteit Nijmegen. A thank you for taking the time reading this document of Which I’ve been Working for since February 2017. This thesis is part of finishing my bachelor Geography, Planning and Environment at the University. This thesis is part of a personal interest in Dubai Which comes from an internship done in the 2nd half of 2016. Thanks to this thesis I Was able to make a visit to Dubai to experience the city and do intervieWs to get data for this thesis. This visit really helped to understand the city and understand the concept of a Free Zone since on paper it Would could look like a fenced separated part of an industrial site or port, which in this case was not present and made it really special.
    [Show full text]