DOCSLIB.ORG

In Defence of Marxism : Marxist Theories of Globali

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
In Defence of Marxism : Marxist Theories of Globali ORBIT-OnlineRepository ofBirkbeckInstitutionalTheses Enabling Open Access to Birkbeck’s Research Degree output In defence of Marxism : Marxist theories of globali- sation and social injustice and the evolution of post- socialist ideology within contemporary movements for global social justice https://eprints.bbk.ac.uk/id/eprint/40184/ Version: Full Version Citation: Wood, Jared (2016) In defence of Marxism : Marxist theo- ries of globalisation and social injustice and the evolution of post- socialist ideology within contemporary movements for global social justice. [Thesis] (Unpublished) c 2020 The Author(s) All material available through ORBIT is protected by intellectual property law, including copy- right law. Any use made of the contents should comply with the relevant law. Deposit Guide Contact: email In Defence of Marxism: Marxist theories of globalisation and social injustice and the evolution of post- socialist ideology within contemporary movements for global social justice. Page 1 of 290 In Defence of Marxism: Marxist theories of globalisation and social injustice and the evolution of post-socialist ideology within contemporary movements for global social justice. Jared Wood Birkbeck, University of London Doctor of philosophy (Ph.D.) in Human Geography In Defence of Marxism: Marxist theories of globalisation and social injustice and the evolution of post- socialist ideology within contemporary movements for global social justice. Page 2 of 290 Declaration I declare that all the work contained herein this thesis is the candidates own. Signed: Jared Wood. In Defence of Marxism: Marxist theories of globalisation and social injustice and the evolution of post- socialist ideology within contemporary movements for global social justice. Page 3 of 290 Abstract The protests against the World Trade Organisation in Seattle in 1999 have been described, along with the development of World and European Social Forums (WSF/ESF), as the beginning of a new Global Movement for Social Justice (GMSJ). This movement has been argued to represent a ‘new type of politics’ with an unprecedented ideological and organisational character based on new fragmented power relationships that have undermined traditional class and national relationships and consequently have undermined the relevance of classical socialist theory. In place of nation state-based socialist strategies for delivering social justice, the GMSJ has been established on the principles of autonomy and an absence of representative structures of any kind. Often, these movements are described as (transnational) New Social Movements. This thesis challenges these concepts and argues they fall within a post-socialist orthodox approach to social science. It compares socialist concepts relating to power, class, nations and political organisation with post- socialist concepts, and in so doing, argues that post-socialist ideas have gained an orthodox status in a period when Stalinist models of (national) state planning have collapsed and social democratic parties have capitulated to the demands of globalised neo-liberal capitalism. Under such conditions, it has been possible for post-socialist theory to reflect observed failures of socialist movements and the thesis argues that underlying post-socialist theories of power, globalisation and a fragmentation of material power relations are often excessively abstract and unconvincing. These arguments are developed through the presentation of research into GMSJ activist organisations, part of the movements that affiliated to the London round of the ESF in 2004. In presenting analysis of in-depth interviews with participants and key organizational leaders, the thesis examines how the contemporary GMSJ remains sceptical that class based socialist theory can mobilise contemporary mass movements. However, it also develops a better understanding of how activists in this new global social movement reflect socialist theories relating to power, property relations and class in their conceptualisation of patterns of social injustice. Overall, the research suggests post-socialist theories have failed to provide a programme or strategy for building a mass In Defence of Marxism: Marxist theories of globalisation and social injustice and the evolution of post- socialist ideology within contemporary movements for global social justice. Page 4 of 290 movement for social justice. It argues that, contrary to often stated claims about its Marxist foundations, post-socialist ideology has not been able to outline the systemic foundations for another world. However, the research suggests that the central concepts of Marxist theory relating to power, property relations, class and political organisation nevertheless remain relevant to the GMSJ and that democratic socialist planning is the only coherent systemic alternative to capitalism that has been placed before the GMSJ. The thesis will argue that the GMSJ could help to develop an ideological alternative to global capitalism by engaging with a rich history of socialist theory. In Defence of Marxism: Marxist theories of globalisation and social injustice and the evolution of post- socialist ideology within contemporary movements for global social justice. Page 5 of 290 Table of Contents Declaration 2 Abstract 3 Contents 5 1 Introduction 10 2 In Defence of Marxism: Post-Socialist theory fails to explain Patterns Of Social Injustice or create the foundations of ‘Another World’. 23 2.1 Marxist Ideology Under Attack: Class, Identity, Power & Property Relations 24 2.1.1 Class and Identity 26 2.1.2 Power and Property 31 2.2 Nation and State 36 2.2.1 Time, Space and the Nation 38 2.2.2 The State as an Agent of Social Justice 43 2.2.3 Globalisation: The Highest form of Imperialism 48 2.3 The Role of the Political Party in Movements for Social Justice 51 2.3.1 Power and Party 54 2.3.2 Party Traditions in Radical Movements in Britain 56 2.3.3 The Party and the GMSJ 58 2.4. A Post Socialist Orthodoxy 63 2.5 Post-Socialism, Social Democracy and Marxism: Three Ideological’ Trends within the GMSJ 69 2.5.1 The limits of Post-Socialist Ideology 70 In Defence of Marxism: Marxist theories of globalisation and social injustice and the evolution of post- socialist ideology within contemporary movements for global social justice. Page 6 of 290 2.5.2 Social Democracy and the GMSJ 75 2.5.3 Latin America puts Marxism back on the Agenda 79 2.5.4 Harvey’s Defence of Marxism Wobbles 83 2.5.5 Can Marxism Appeal to the Democratic Aspirations of the GMSJ? 87 2.6 Conclusion: “Workers of the World Unite; You Have Nothing to Lose but your Chains” 90 3 In Defence of a Marxist Methodology 95 3.1 The Epistemology of Dialectical Materialism 98 3.2 Defining the Research Question 102 3.3 The Management of Subjectivity: Grounded Theory, Action Research and Dialectical Materialism 103 3.4 Data Collection 106 3.4.1 Locating the Thesis within Radical Literature 108 3.4.2 Access to Respondents and Empirical Data 111 3.4.3 Sampling 113 3.4.4 Ethics 118 3.4.5 Developing an Interview Technique through a Pilot Interview: The Topic Guide 120 3.5 Data Analysis 124 3.5.1 Coding and Thematic Analysis 125 3.5.2 Organisation and Presentation 126 3.6 Limitations 128 3.7 Methodological Conclusions 130 4 Property Relations, Power and Class 132 In Defence of Marxism: Marxist theories of globalisation and social injustice and the evolution of post- socialist ideology within contemporary movements for global social justice. Page 7 of 290 4.1 Property Relations and Production as Sources of Social Injustice 134 4.2 Power and Global Social Injustice 141 4.3 Multitude or Social Class? 146 4.4 Conclusion: The Power of the Organised Working class 154 5 Nation, State and Global Consciousness within the Global Movement for Social Justice 157 5.1 Nation States and the Global Scope of the GMSJ 160 5.1.1 Conceptualising Globalisation, Nations and Imperialism 160 5.1.2 The Social Democratic Nation State 165 5.1.3 The Global Consciousness and Scope of the GMSJ 167 5.1.4 Nation States and the GMSJ: Conclusions 172 5.2 The Internationalist Traditions of the Workers’ Movement 173 5.3 Radical Post-State Theories and Social Justice 179 5.4 Nation, State and GMSJ: Conclusion 182 6 Organising the Movement for Global Social Justice: The character of the European Social Forum (ESF) 185 6.1 ICT and new forms of organisation 186 6.2 Social Forums and the Political Party 191 6.3 The Labour Movement and the Social Forums 196 6.4 ESF: Clearing house, or parliament of the movement? 203 6.4.1 The Problem of Informal Power 209 6.5 Organising the Movement for Global Social Justice and The character’ of the European Social Forum (ESF): Conclusion 211 In Defence of Marxism: Marxist theories of globalisation and social injustice and the evolution of post- socialist ideology within contemporary movements for global social justice. Page 8 of 290 7 Another World is Possible: Systemic Alternatives to Neo-Liberal Globalization 215 7.1 Post-Socialism and Post-Ideology 216 7.1.1 Zapatismo: A Non-Ideological Model for 21st century Struggle 219 7.2 Social Democracy and the GMSJ 225 7.2.1 Classical Social Democracy 227 7.2.2 Social Democracy and the Nation State 231 7.2.3 Reforms as empirical demands 232 7.3 Revolution: Another World built on Socialist Planning 234 7.3.1 Legacy of the Soviet Monolithic State 236 7.3.2 Ideological Pick ‘n’ Mix 238 7.3.3 The Trotskyist Left 240 7.3.4 Socialism in the 21st Century – Venezuela and Bolivia 242 7.4 Conclusion: Systemic Alternatives to Neo-Liberal Capitalism 247 8 Conclusions 251 8.1 Property, Power and Class 253 8.2 Nation and State 255 8.3 The Political Party 257 8.4 The challenges facing three ideological traditions: Post Socialism, Social democracy and Marxism 258 8.4.1 Post-Socialism 259 8.4.2 Social democracy 260 8.4.3 Marxism 261 8.5 The Thesis: Achievements and Limitations 262 8.6 In Defence of Marxism 268 In Defence of Marxism: Marxist theories of globalisation and social injustice and the evolution of post- socialist ideology within contemporary movements for global social justice.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • How the SWP's Bureaucratic Factionalism Is Wrecking Respect
    How the SWP's bureaucratic factionalism is wrecking Respect https://internationalviewpoint.org/spip.php?article1330 Britain How the SWP's bureaucratic factionalism is wrecking Respect - IV Online magazine - 2007 - IV393 - October 2007 - Publication date: Wednesday 31 October 2007 Copyright © International Viewpoint - online socialist magazine - All rights reserved Copyright © International Viewpoint - online socialist magazine Page 1/4 How the SWP's bureaucratic factionalism is wrecking Respect No one who supports left unity could be anything other than deeply disheartened by the turn of events inside Respect, which has created a crisis that threatens the future of the organisation. The current crisis is unnecessary and the product of the political line and methods of organisation of the Socialist Workers Party. [https://internationalviewpoint.org/IMG/jpg/respect23-2.jpg] Happier days - Respect founding conference The real meaning of the crisis, its roots and underlying dynamics are however being obscured by the SWP's propaganda offensive, an attempt to whip its own members into line and throw up a smokescreen to fool the left in Britain and internationally. How so? The crisis was started by a letter from Respect MP George Galloway to members of the National Council on August 23, a time it should be remembered that a general election seemed a short-term possibility. In his letter Galloway drew attention to organisational weaknesses of Respect, the decline of its membership and political life in general, but also to the (not unrelated) lack of accountability of the National Officers, including the Respect national Secretary John Rees. These criticisms reflected those that had been made for several years by supporters of Socialist Resistance.
    [Show full text]
  • PDF Print Version
    AUSTRALIA $1.50 · CANADA $1.50 · F RANCE 1.00 EURO · NEW ZEALAND $1.50 · UK £.50 · U.S. $1.00 INSIDE Sankara’s revolutionary legacy discussed at NY forum — PAGE 6 A SOCIALIST NEWSWEEKLY PUBLISHED IN THE INTERESTS OF WORKING PEOPLE VOL. 83/NO. 20 MAY 20, 2019 Latest fighting Uber, Lyft drivers strike Demand US shows need for across US for pay, dignity hands off recognition of Venezuela Israel, Palestine THBY SGAE LINSKY and Cuba! A new tenuous cease-fire agreement BY TERRY EVANS between the Israeli government and “The Socialist Workers Party urg- Gaza-based Hamas and Palestinian es working people and youth to join in speaking out against Washing Islamic Jihad does nothing to elimi- - nate the unending cycle of violence by ton’s threats against Venezuela and groups in the Gaza Strip committed Cuba,” said John Studer, a member to the destruction of Israel and Israel’s of the SWP Political Committee and editor of the Militant, capitalist rulers. The repeated mili - at a special tary battles there are a deadly obstacle Militant Labor Forum here May 4. It to uniting working people, whatever was organized as a call to action to mobilize opposition to the U.S. rul their religion or nationality, to ad- - ers’ intervention. vance their interests against the capi- talist governments and ruling classes Studer urged forum participants to on both sides of the border. initiate and build protests demanding At the heart of the repeated fighting an immediate and unconditional halt to the U.S. government’s violations is the refusal of Hamas, the reaction- Militant/Edwin Fruit ary Islamist group that runs the Gaza Uber, Lyft strikers rally in Seattle May 8.
    [Show full text]
  • 1 a New Political Dawn: the Cuban Revolution in the 1960S
    Notes 1 A New Political Dawn: The Cuban Revolution in the 1960s 1. For an outline of the events surrounding the Padilla Affair, see chapter two. 2. Kenner and Petras limited themselves to mentioning the enormous importance of a Cuban Revolution with which a great number of the North American New Left identified. They also dedicated their book to the Cuban and Vietnamese people for “giving North Americans the possibility of making a revolution” (1972: 5). 3. For an explanation of the term gauchiste and of its relevance to the New Left, see chapter six. 4. However, this consideration has been rather critical in the case of Minogue (1970). 5. The general consensus seems to be that, as the Revolution entered a period of rapid Sovietization following the failure of the ten million ton sugar harvest of 1970, Western intellectuals, who until then had showed support, sought to distance themselves from the Revolution. The single incident that seemingly sparked this reaction, in particular from some French intellectuals, was the Padilla Affair. 6. Here a clear distinction must be made mainly between the Communist Party of the pre-Revolutionary period, the Partido Socialista Popular (Popular Socialist Party) and the 26 July Movement (MR26). The former had a legacy of Popular Frontism, collaboration with Batista in the post- War period and a general distrust of “middle class adventurers” as it referred to the leadership of MR26 until 1958 (Karol, 1971: 150). The latter, led by Castro, had a radical though incoherently articulated ideo- logical basis. The process of unification of revolutionary organizations carried out between 1961 and 1965 did not completely obliterate the individuality of these competing discourses and it was in their struggle for supremacy that the New Left’s contribution was made.
    [Show full text]
  • Nicolas Maduro Won the Presidential Election
    Newsletter of the Hands Off Venezuela campaign www.handsoffvenezuela.org May 2013 Defend Venezuela’s democracy Nicolas Maduro won the presidential election - respect the democratic will of the people n April 14, the Bo- the day after, with the presence livarian candidate of opposition technicians and no Nicolás Maduro complaint was registered won the presiden- • on election night 54% of poll- Otial elections with 7,586,251 ing booths, chosen randomly, votes (50.61%) against the op- were publicly audited with the position candidate Henrique presence of opposition and Bo- Capriles who received 7,361,512 livarian observers. The voting votes (49.12%), with a turnout of results recorded by the voting 79.69%. machines were checked against The opposition refused to rec- the paper receipts in the boxes. ognise the results of the election No complaints were registered. and has launched a campaign of • the elections were observed violence. On the night of April by over 170 international observ- 15 several CDI health clinics ers from many countries includ- were attacked across the coun- ing India, Brazil, Great Britain, try, as well as alternative and Argentina, South Korea, Spain state media outlet buildings and and France. Among the observ- journalists, offices of the United ers were two former presidents Socialist Party of Venezuela, etc. (of Guatemala and the Domini- As a result of this politically mo- can Republic), judges, lawyers tivated violence 9 people were and high-ranking officials of killed, all of them in the Bolivar- national electoral councils. All ian camp. of them stated that the elections The noisy campaign of the had been free and fair and the opposition was combined with system transparent, reliable, The working masses defend the Bolivarian revolution pic: Prensa Presidencial a national and international well-run and thoroughly au- media campaign, international dited.
    [Show full text]
  • Lenin and the Bourgeois Press
    REQUEST TO READERS Progress Publishers would be glad to have your opinion of this book, its translation and design and any suggestions you may have for future publications. Please send your comments to 17, Zubovsky Boulevard, Moscow, U.S,S.R. Boris Baluyev AND TBE BOURGEOIS PRESS Progress Publishers Moscow Translated from the Russian by James Riordan Designed by Yuri Davydov 6opac 6aJiyee JIEHMH IlOJIEMl1311PYET C 6YJ>)l(YA3HO'A IlPECCO'A Ha Qlj2J1UUCKOM 11301Ke © IlOJIHTH3L(aT, 1977 English translation © Progress Publishers 1983 Printed in the Union of Soviet Socialist Republics 0102020000-346 _ E 32 83 014(01)-83 Contents Introduction . 5 "Highly Interesting-from the Negative Aspect" 8 "Capitalism and the Press" . 23 "For Lack of a Clean Principled Weapon They Snatch at a Dirty One" . 53 "I Would Rather Let Myself Be Drawn and Quartered... " 71 "A Socialist Paper Must Carry on Polemics" 84 "But What Do These Facts Mean?" . 98 "All Praise to You, Writers for Rech and Duma!" 106 "Our Strength Lies in Stating the Truth!" 120 "The Despicable Kind of Trick People Who Have Been Ordered to Raise a Cheer Would Use" . 141 "The Innumerable Vassal Organs of Russian Liberalism" 161 "This Appeared Not in Novoye Vremya, but in a Paper That Calls Itself a Workers' Newspaper" . 184 ··one Chorus. One Orchestra·· 201 INTRODUCTION The polemical writings of Vladimir Ilyich Lenin continue to set an unsurpassed standard of excellence for journalists and all representatives of the progressive press. They teach ideo­ logical consistency and develop the ability to link political issues of the moment to Marxist philosophical theory.
    [Show full text]
  • The Electoral Geography of European Radical Left Parties Since 1990
    ‘Red Belts’ anywhere? The electoral geography of European radical left parties since 1990 Petar Nikolaev Bankov, BA, MSc Submitted in the fulfilment of the requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy School of Social and Political Sciences College of Social Sciences University of Glasgow January 2020 Abstract European radical left parties (RLPs) are on the rise across Europe. Since 1990 they became an integral part of the party systems across the continent and enjoy an increased level of government participation and policy clout. The main source for this improved position is their increasing electoral support in the past three decades, underpinned by a diversity of electoral geographies. Understood as the patterns of territorial distribution of electoral support across electoral units, the electoral geographies are important, as they indicate the effects of the socio-economic and political changes in Europe on these parties. This thesis studies the sources of the electoral geographies of European RLPs since 1990. The existing literature on these parties highlighted the importance of their electoral geographies for understanding their electoral and governmental experiences. Yet, to this date, it lacks systematic research on these territorial distributions of electoral support in their own right. Such research is important also for the general literature on the spatial distribution of electoral performance. In particular, these works paid limited attention to the relevance of their theories for individual political parties, as they
    [Show full text]
  • Development & Resistance
    Development & Resistance to the Empire of Capital John Saul Realizing “developmental socialism” which, as recently as the changes seem equally necessary now – for, as Colin Leys and I 1970s, seemed a prospect worth fighting for has come, to many, have much more recently noted, “the dream of a transformative capi- to seem much less so now. True, the goal still has moral force, this talism in Africa remains just that: a dream.” This is true even if, con- encompassing the judgment that people can resolve economic fronted with an ever more ascendant globalized capitalism, the goal and political tensions and potential contradictions collectively and of a developmental socialism, key to the only genuine “develop- democratically rather than having to build centrally on competi- ment” that is really possible for Africa, seems at least as difficult to tion and the entrepreneurial greed of the few as the ultimate cen- realize as it did when Arrighi and I first wrote. tral keys to the welfare of everybody else. One cannot afford to Of course, the African case may be, globally, the most ex- be naïve, of course. Quite apart from questions of divergent class treme example of capitalist failure. Nonetheless, more generally, interests, it is also true that “human nature,” however much mis- the logic of socialism (but also the extreme difficulty of realizing shaped and distorted it may be within a world of ascendant mar- it) seems clear, at least to those who care to look. For Africa, like ket norms, will, even in the best and most propitious of times, be much of the rest of the underdeveloped world, is now “invited” pulled between the claim of individuality (and family) on the one (in fact, largely forced – by the IMF, World Bank, WTO and the hand and that of humane collectivity on the other.
    [Show full text]
  • A Socialist Schism
    A Socialist Schism: British socialists' reaction to the downfall of Milošević by Andrew Michael William Cragg Submitted to Central European University Department of History In partial fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts Supervisor: Professor Marsha Siefert Second Reader: Professor Vladimir Petrović CEU eTD Collection Budapest, Hungary 2017 Copyright notice Copyright in the text of this thesis rests with the Author. Copies by any process, either in full or part, may be made only in accordance with the instructions given by the Author and lodged in the Central European Library. Details may be obtained from the librarian. This page must form a part of any such copies made. Further copies made in accordance with such instructions may not be made without the written permission of the Author. CEU eTD Collection i Abstract This work charts the contemporary history of the socialist press in Britain, investigating its coverage of world events in the aftermath of the fall of state socialism. In order to do this, two case studies are considered: firstly, the seventy-eight day NATO bombing campaign over the Federal Republic of Yugoslavia in 1999, and secondly, the overthrow of Slobodan Milošević in October of 2000. The British socialist press analysis is focused on the Morning Star, the only English-language socialist daily newspaper in the world, and the multiple publications affiliated to minor British socialist parties such as the Socialist Workers’ Party and the Communist Party of Great Britain (Provisional Central Committee). The thesis outlines a broad history of the British socialist movement and its media, before moving on to consider the case studies in detail.
    [Show full text]
  • Repression, Reaganomics, War and Revolution. the Present Situation
    $1.00 November 1981 Rcpteniion, RcaganomicJ, lllat, and Rcuolution The Present Situation and the Tasks of U.S. Marxist-Leninists Preface he essay which follows, "The Present Situation, Period of the Revolution and Marxist- Leninist Tasks," by the League of Revolutionary Struggle (Marxist-Leninist) is the first of a series of statements which are part of a debate in the U.S. communist movement to help clarify the political line for the socialist revolution. This debate in the communist movement was ini- tiated through a public call by the Communist Party (Marxist-Leninist), League of Revolution- ary Struggle (Marxist-Leninist) and Revolutionary Workers Headquarters for all Marxist- Leninists in the United States to participate. The debate is open to all Marxist-Leninist organiza- tions and individuals to participate by writing position papers and responses to those of others. The aim of the debata is to advance the struggle for Marxist-Leninist unity by helping clarify political line. The debate will feature the publication of positions on six political questions that are essen- tial in the formulation of a line and program for the U.S. revolution. The CPML, LRS and RWH have called for debate on the following six topics, beginning with the first topic in November, and the others following at six-week intervals: l. The nature of the current period of the U.S. revolutionary struggle and the tasks of communlsts 2. The national question, including positions on the Afro-American national question, Chicano national question, Asian national questions, the Puerto Rican national question 3. The question of labor and trade union work 4- The woman question 5.
    [Show full text]
  • Ray O' Light Newsletter
    RAY O’ LIGHT NEWSLETTER March-April 2019 No. 113 & May-June 2019 No. 114 DOUBLE ISSUE Publication of the Revolutionary Organization of Labor, USA Commemorating the 100th Anniversary of the Founding of the Communist International March 1919 REFLECTIONS ON THE COMMUNIST INTERNATIONAL ON THE OCCASION OF THE HUNDREDTH ANNIVERSARY OF ITS FOUNDING (1919-2019) by RAY LIGHT “Departing from us, Comrade Lenin enjoined us to I. remain faithful to the principles of the Communist FROM THE FORMATION OF THE COMINTERN International. We vow to you, comrade Lenin, that we AND THE VICTORY OF THE OCTOBER shall not spare our lives to strengthen and extend the SOCIALIST REVOLUTION IN RUSSIA union of the working people of the whole world—the TO THE COMINTERN’S 7TH CONGRESS Communist International!” — Joseph Stalin, (Stalin, Works, Vol.6, p. 52) One hundred years ago the first world conference of communist parties and social-democratic organizations “... the pressure of the capitalist states on our state is was held in the still newly liberated land of Soviet enormous, ... the people handling our foreign policy do Russia, in the midst of a Civil War and the imperialist not always succeed in resisting this pressure, the danger intervention of a dozen foreign powers. It began with of complications often gives rise to the temptation to take Lenin’s opening speech on March 2, 1919. In the the path of least resistance, the path of nationalism ... course of the next four days a proposal was put forth the path of least resistance and of nationalism in foreign and implemented to transform the conference into a policy is the path of the isolation and decay of the first constitutive congress of the Communist International.
    [Show full text]
  • A Critical and Comparative Analysis of Organisational Forms of Selected Marxist Parties, in Theory and in Practice, with Special Reference to the Last Half Century
    Rahimi, M. (2009) A critical and comparative analysis of organisational forms of selected Marxist parties, in theory and in practice, with special reference to the last half century. PhD thesis. http://theses.gla.ac.uk/688/ Copyright and moral rights for this thesis are retained by the author A copy can be downloaded for personal non-commercial research or study, without prior permission or charge This thesis cannot be reproduced or quoted extensively from without first obtaining permission in writing from the Author The content must not be changed in any way or sold commercially in any format or medium without the formal permission of the Author When referring to this work, full bibliographic details including the author, title, awarding institution and date of the thesis must be given Glasgow Theses Service http://theses.gla.ac.uk/ [email protected] A critical and comparative analysis of organisational forms of selected Marxist parties, in theory and in practice, with special reference to the last half century Mohammad Rahimi, BA, MSc Submitted in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of PhD Centre for the Study of Socialist Theory and Movement Faculty of Law, Business and Social Science University of Glasgow September 2008 The diversity of the proletariat during the final two decades of the 20 th century reached a point where traditional socialist and communist parties could not represent all sections of the working class. Moreover, the development of social movements other than the working class after the 1960s further sidelined traditional parties. The anti-capitalist movements in the 1970s and 1980s were looking for new political formations.
    [Show full text]
  • A Collection of Articles by Harry Ratner
    IS THERE A FUTURE FOR SOCIALISM? A collection of articles ?by Harry Ratner INTRODUCTION ANY READERS will be familiar with Harry but have a consistent theme – the need to question Ratner’s excellent book, Reluctant what passes in Trotskyist circles for Marxist ortho- RevolutionaryM , which details the more than two doxy and face up to political reality. This is not, I decades he spent as an activist in the Trotskyist imagine, a message that will be well received in movement before breaking from it in 1960. One of some quarters. the features of the book was that, while the author Among the shibboleths Harry challenges are no longer considered himself a Trotskyist, his was the necessity for centrally planned production in a not an embittered account fuelled by personal socialist economy, the rejection of a parliamentary resentment towards the movement to which he had road to socialism, economic catastrophism, re- once committed his life. On the contrary, Harry’s ductionist views on the “class character” of the memoirs were distinguished by an admirable state, the validity of the Bolshevik revolution, both objectivity, in which he gave credit to his former in its own terms and as a model for future socialist comrades as serious and honest socialists, while struggles, and more. Even those who profoundly rejecting most of the main planks of the Trotskyist disagree with the author’s conclusions will hopefully programme. at least be provoked into re-examining their political The articles in this collection continue the assumptions. general approach of Reluctant Revolutionary, but Harry would welcome readers’ comments on in theoretical rather than autobiographical terms.
    [Show full text]