The Incorporation of an Individual Into the Liturgical Action of the Church of England
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Durham E-Theses The incorporation of an individual into the liturgical action of the church of England Dewes, Deborah How to cite: Dewes, Deborah (1996) The incorporation of an individual into the liturgical action of the church of England, Durham theses, Durham University. Available at Durham E-Theses Online: http://etheses.dur.ac.uk/5245/ Use policy The full-text may be used and/or reproduced, and given to third parties in any format or medium, without prior permission or charge, for personal research or study, educational, or not-for-prot purposes provided that: • a full bibliographic reference is made to the original source • a link is made to the metadata record in Durham E-Theses • the full-text is not changed in any way The full-text must not be sold in any format or medium without the formal permission of the copyright holders. Please consult the full Durham E-Theses policy for further details. Academic Support Oce, Durham University, University Oce, Old Elvet, Durham DH1 3HP e-mail: [email protected] Tel: +44 0191 334 6107 http://etheses.dur.ac.uk 2 The Incorporation of an Individual into the Liturgical Action of the Church of England The copyright of this thesis rests with the author. No quotation from it should be published without his prior written consent and information derived from it should be acknowledged. M.A.Thesis submitted by Rev'd Deborah Dewes University of Durham Theology Faculty 1995 2 0 JUNTO I confirm that no part of the material offered has previously been submitted by me for a degree in this or any other university Signed. Date. The Copyright of this thesis rests with the author. No quotation from it should be pubUshed without her prior written consent and information derived from it should be acknowledged Abstract The question central to this thesis is: how the 'incomer' experiences the liturgy of the Church of England. The discussion focuses mainly on the occasional offices of baptisms, weddings and funerals, and their impact upon the mission of the church. Part One examines some of the dynamics which operate within communities, and within the church community in particular. Determinative for the incomer's perception is the church's self- understanding as presented through the liturgy, whether it is an open or closed community, and what conception of God it offers. Of particular importance is the way in which ritual, symbol, language and story help to create community, as also more explicit as also more explicit concepts such as the Trinity and the body of Christ. Part Two then turns to a more detailed consideration of the impact of the occasional offices upon die incomer. Rites of passages are discussed. The chapter about weddings includes an examination of the service in the Aitemative .ServicR Rook 1980. and a discussion of co-habitation and the re-marrriage of divorcees. In the chapter about funerals there is discussion about the pastoral care of the liturgy and ritual, about cremation and the lack of appropriate imagery in present liturgy , about Ufe-centred fiinerals (saaed or secular) and about the assumed faith stams of the dead. In the chapter about baptism the tensions between baptism as a rite of passage and/or initiation are explored, catechesis as part of the baptismal rite is discussed, and changes ate suggested to reclaim baptism as the rite of initiation by a process of welcome, education and nurture. Part Three examines some of the less verbal messages in the liturgy and the missiological implications of the bridge or barrier which weekly worship constitutes to die incomer. Attention is paid to care of the individual through worship, in particular through using shalom as a model for personal and corporate wholeness. There is a discussion of die elements of worship in functional and phenomenological terras. In ch 7 elements of worship in a Sunday service and their effects on the incomer are examined through the focus of story. The use of the bible and lectionary, prayers, and the role of music in services is discussed. There is a brief examination of participation in and mingling of stories, particularly related to the catechumenate. My conclusions are as follows; 1) It is time to enrich the liturgy. 2) There is a need for greater participation and inclusion in liturgy. 3) It is time to allow for greater honesty in liturgy. 4) The church needs to take mission seriously in its liturgy. The mission of the church in worship should be consistent with die mission of the church in proclamation, social action and pastoral care. If worship is not shaped and informed by the perceptions of modem thinking as well as historical accuracy it will become irrelevant. CONTENTS Tntrndiictinn 1 Fields of Reference 2 Part One 4 Part Two 5 Part Three 5 Chapter One - A View of the Church 1.1 The Community of Faith 7 1.2 The Form of a Servant' 11 1.3 The Body of Christ 13 1.4 The Boundaries of Community 16 1.5 St Utopia and the Trinity 18 Chapter Two - The Commiinitv of Faith 2.1 Invisible Threads 22 2.2 Ritual, symbol and language 25 2.3 Story and the Formation of Community 29 2.4 Community, distance and the Mystery of God 33 Tntrndiicrinn fn Part Two Rites of Passage 37 Chapter Three - 'To have and to hold' 3.1 The Wedding Ceremony 42 3.2 From Cohabitation to Marriage 46 3.3'Till death us do part'? 49 3.4 An Honourable Estate 54 Chapter Four - 'The Snares of Death' 4.1 The Sting of death 57 4.2 'Ashes to ashes' 64 4.3 Sacred or Secular? 67 4.4 'Sure and Certain Hope...' 70 Chapter Five - Initiation 5.1 Rite of Passage? 73 5.2 The Catechumenate 83 5.3 Baptism and Thanksgiving Towards 2000 86 Introduction to Part Three 90 Chapter Six - Worship. Mission and Pastoral Care 6.1 'A Significant By-product' 91 6.2 Making Shalom 95 Chapter Seven - Sundav Worship 7.1 Story and Sacrament 101 7.2 Use of the Bible 104 7.3 Words and Music 108 7.4 Story and Identity 112 Conclusion Changing the Liturgy 117 Endnotes 122 Rihliopraphv 129 Introduction At the centre of the christian life of faith are the two great commandments, to love God with all your heart, soul, mind and strength, and love your neighbour as yourself(i). Much thought has been given throughout the ages as to what the two great commandments might mean and how they might look if they were the basis for all life. In an age when 'back to basics' is the cry of many, this thesis is an attempt to address what is basic in all christian life and embedded in the heart of the two great commandments: in this work the emphasis will be focussed on the church's worship and the church's mission. This is not to look back but to find a way forward on firm foundations for the future. It seems important that these questions should not simply be abstract but should involve some real situations which impinge on real people. With that in mind the discussion will be based on the Church of England. For most people in the pews of the Church of England most of the time, worship and mission belong in very separate compartments: worship is what 'we' do on a Sunday in our liturgy, and mission is what 'they' do when they can ('they' always means someone else, whether agencies or other churches of other traditions). This is a view which defines worship only as church services and mission only as 'more people coming to church'. This is a problem of perception which will take time, energy and the enlightenment of the Holy Spirit to solve. The 'view in the pew' is, however, somewhat different from the view from behind a dog- collar. Much of the contact the clergy have with those who are as yet not part of the worshipping community is through the 'occasional offices', baptisms, weddings and funerals. In these services people come in to church for a specific reason requiring specific celebration, thanksgiving, blessing or care. In this thesis these people who come in to church will be referred to as 'incomers'. This is intended to be a value-free term which does not judge the reasons why someone wants to come in to church, nor what their state of faith might be, but simply indicates the coming in of a person who does not regularly attend church. Central to this work is the question of how an incomer experiences and is drawn into the liturgies of the Church of England. Because of the emphasis on mission and the incomer, the liturgy of the eucharist will not be discussed in any detail. The eucharist is primarily a service intended for those who are part of the church. The whole movement of the service is 1 towards receiving bread and wine which is perceived (deliberately so) to be a privilege of the committed. The proclamation of the Lord's death 'until he comes' is undoubtedly a missiological theme which could be explored. It is, however, beyond the scope of this work. Fields of Reference Both worship and mission are complicated to define, so rather than attempt neat definitions there follow some fields of reference within which the argument of the thesis will unfold. a) Worship and Liturgy. Worship is a part of christian existence which is at the heart of loving God with heart, soul, mind and strength.