Draft History
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Draft History - Murray Island Group, national heritage assessment Murray Island Group and the Meriam People The people of the Murray Island group are known as the Meriam people and Miriam Mir is their language. The Murray Island Group is three Torres Strait islands, Mer (also referred to as Murray Island), Dauar, and Waier (both uninhabited) on the north eastern fringe of the Torres Strait Islands. Collectively they are referred to as the eastern Torres Strait. The other seventeen inhabited islands are divided into the central and western Torres Strait, with no common genealogical and language base connecting them (MS 9518 1990:75-78). At the time of European contact, generations of Meriam people had been engaged in small scale agriculture and farming on the fertile and permanently inhabited Mer Island, while their central and western neighbours were fisher people (MS 9518 Moynihan 1990:10-15; 82). Gardening was considered incompatible with fishing and appropriate rituals and prohibitions existed to separate these (MS 9518 Moynihan 1990:11-15). A major distinction of the social organisation of the Murray Island Group was the absence of totems and the focus on enhancing individual garden productivity (MS 9518 Moynihan 1990:78). Prestige was dependent on gardening prowess with techniques passed from father to son by descent or adoption and associated with the growing of coconuts. Excess produce was available for exchange for death, marriage and adoption ceremonies and to sustain those engaged in cultural rituals. In 1871 the London Missionary Society (LMS) arrived in the Torres Strait with Samoan teachers (MS 9518, Moynihan 1992:100). This event is referred to and celebrated annually as 'The Coming of the Light' (Keon-Cohen 2000:21). In 1877 the LMS established their headquarters on leased or purchased land on Mer, building a church in 1879. They withdrew from the island in 1891 (Keon-Cohen 2000:11). The Pacific Island Protection Act 1872 set up to protect islanders and stamp out blackbirding, was amended to include the Murray Islands in 1875 (High Court of Australia 1992:3). In 1878 the Thursday Island Police Magistrate administering the islands, set up an informal law and order system to assist in keeping the peace. Meriam Islanders were asked to select a 'Mamoose' or 'chief', who was responsible for the good behaviour of his countrymen (MS 9518 Plaintiffs' Statement of Fact 1990:10). The Mamoose was supported by local constables and provided with a government boat. Most notably, the Torres Strait Islands came under Queensland's administrative control when it was annexed under the Queensland Coast Islands Act in 1879 (MS 9518 Moynihan 1990:102). The purpose of the annexation was to: command the Torres Strait and sea lane to India, control the fishing and pearling industries, protect the natives (who were now British citizens) and their property; defend the area; and extend their jurisdiction to non-British subjects (High Court of Australia 1992:5). The Murray Islands has never had any permanent immigrant population (High Court of Australia 1988:2; High Court of Australia 1992:1). In the early 1890's requests were received from the Mamoose to the Queensland authorities to remove Murray Islanders tenants (currently living on the South Sea Islands) who were in dispute with their landlords over the ownership of crops (MS 9518 Plaintiffs Statement of Facts 1982:9-10). This included 'objectionable characters' considered trespassers (High Court of Australia 1992:5). In 1891 Alfred Haddon led the first Cambridge Anthropological Expedition to study and record details of Torres Strait Island life including mapping land ownership and recording customs, genealogies and a Bomai-Malo cult ceremony (MS 9518 Moynihan 1992 162-173). J S Bruce was appointed school Headmaster, government adviser and Treasurer to the Murray Islands in 1892, when courts were established in Queensland Aboriginal communities (Keon-Cohen 2000:16). Bruce resided on Mer till 1934 and: recorded births, deaths and marriages; oversaw the 'system of self government'; maintained and updated Island Court records; and sent Annual Reports to the Director of Aboriginal Affairs Queensland. This included overseeing the Mamoose's actions, to deal with minor offences including land disputes and the spending of local fees (MS9518 Moynihan 1992:142); (MS 9518 Plaintiffs' statement of fact 1990:13; High Court of Australia 1992:6-7). From 1899 elected councillors assisted the Mamoose and in 1923 an elected Chairman replaced him. In 1912 the Torres Strait Islands including the Murray Islands became permanent Aboriginal Reserves for the use of the Aboriginal inhabitants and an Island Fund was set up to administer them. The Queensland Government purchased several portions of land in 1913 for administrative purposes including a Court House, Jail House and recreation reserve, public hall and school (MS 9518 Plaintiffs Statement of Facts 1982:18). In 1924 a public meeting discussed government interference in the payment of locals working as pearlers. In 1928 the people of Dauar moved to live on Mer. In 1936 Torres Strait Islander fishermen objected to the control and regulation of their pearling boats and earnings by the Protector of Aboriginals and went on an extended strike. The first Triennial Council of all Torres Strait Islanders was held in 1937 (MS 9518 Plaintiffs Statement of Facts 1982:9-19). The Island Court was formalised by the Torres Strait Islander Act (Queensland) in 1939 '…in accordance with Island customs and practices and can make and execute by-laws' (MS 9518 Plaintiffs Statement of Facts 1982:20). Unresolved cases could be appealed by the eastern islands representative to the Torres Strait Islands Representative Council and to the Director of The Department of Aboriginal and Islander Advancement, on occasion. The Island Court was still operating in 1981, at the time of the commencement of the High Court case (MS 9518 Moynihan 1990:44; High Court of Australia 1992:6). Meriam People's identity and autonomy Meriam people wanted 'to sustain and reinforce their separate and distinct culture and society' within the Torres Strait (MS 9518 Moynihan 1990:112). From the 1960's, Murray Islander identity was revived with a focus on orally recording and publishing Malo foundation stories for the Murray Islands. Between 1973 and 1978 Torres Strait Islanders petitioned the Queensland government when borders were negotiated and redrawn between Australia and Papua New Guinea. From the plaintiff's perspective, the Queensland Government supported their aspirations to assert their unique cultural and political identity, and retain their rights to their islands and their Australian citizenship (MS 9518, Plaintiffs Statement of Facts, 1990:23). The 1982 Torres Strait Triennial Conference recorded ninety-nine percent of Meriam people had expressed their desire to have freehold title to their land (MS 9518, Plaintiffs Statement of Facts, 1990:25). In 1984 a Commonwealth Government survey of traditional seas and fishing rights concluded Meriam people 'own and use the fish traps, clam gardens, crayfish houses and have fishing rights on the fringing reefs and claim an area of the sea, reefs and banks around Murray Island' (MS9518 Plaintiffs Statement of Facts 1982:26). Although closely administered by Queensland, Meriam people not only considered they owned the land but they also had a degree of autonomy. From the plaintiff's perspective; the community had controlled access by allowing and removing tenants and had never allowed an immigrant population to settle; Murray Island Court decisions were binding; and Murray Islander representation evolved over time from a government appointed Mamoose to elected representation on the Murray Islands and regional Torres Strait Representative Councils. References to the incorporation or adherence to Torres Strait Islands customs was acknowledged in some of the rhetoric supporting the subsequent Queensland Acts and numerous Queensland reports. For example: the Torres Strait Islander Act (Queensland) 1939 claimed it was in accord '… with Island customs and practices and can make and execute by- laws' (MS 9518 Plaintiffs Statement of Facts 1982:20), and the 1958 Deputy Director of Native Affairs report stated: 2 'A complete system of self government, which gives to them home rule and a very definite control in their guidance of their destiny as a race within the Commonwealth of Australia. It also preserves the dignity and the traditions of the Torres Strait people and permits the incorporation in their by-laws of self government, many of the finer tribal laws and traditions' (MS 9518 Plaintiffs Statement of Fact 1992:21). In the early 1980's the Queensland Government enacted several pieces of legislation for the Torres Strait, including de-gazetting or revoking Aboriginal reserves under DOGITS (Deeds of Grant in Trust), the most influential of which for the Meriam People's case, was the Queensland Coast Islands Declaratory Act 1985. Among other things, these changes threatened to limit Murray Islander residency and replace their Council with a Trustee under the Land Act 1962 (QLD) 'with the power to lease and power to terminate traditional occupation' (High Court of Australia of Australia 1988:2; Keon-Cohen 2000:8). At the same time many families moved from the Murray Islands to the mainland in response to the lack of fresh water and limited work opportunities (Keon-Cohen 2000:15). Indigenous rights In the national and international arena, universal human and Indigenous rights were being challenged and recognised through: conventions such as Article 5 of the United Nations International Convention on the Elimination of all Forms of Racial Discrimination 1966; acts such as the Racial Discrimination Act (Commonwealth 1975); and the Yolngu people's (Gove) Native Title case in the Northern Territory High Court. Prior to 1967, under the Australian Constitution the Commonwealth could not make laws for Aboriginal people in the states. On 27 May, 1967 a National Referendum resulted in an overwhelming ‘Yes’ vote, and gave the Commonwealth power to legislate for Aboriginal people (potentially over-ruling State arrangements) as well as counting them in the census.