Mountains, Cities, and Heimat in Weimar Cinema
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Environmental Fantasies: Mountains, Cities, and Heimat in Weimar Cinema The Harvard community has made this article openly available. Please share how this access benefits you. Your story matters Citation Peabody, Seth. 2015. Environmental Fantasies: Mountains, Cities, and Heimat in Weimar Cinema. Doctoral dissertation, Harvard University, Graduate School of Arts & Sciences. Citable link http://nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:17467382 Terms of Use This article was downloaded from Harvard University’s DASH repository, and is made available under the terms and conditions applicable to Other Posted Material, as set forth at http:// nrs.harvard.edu/urn-3:HUL.InstRepos:dash.current.terms-of- use#LAA Environmental,Fantasies:, Mountains,,Cities,,and,Heimat,in,Weimar,Cinema, , , , A,dissertation,presented,, , by, , Seth,Edward,LaFond,Peabody, , to, , The,Department,of,Germanic,Languages,and,Literatures, , in,partial,fulfillment,of,the,requirements, for,the,degree,of, Doctor,of,Philosophy, in,the,subject,of, Germanic,Languages,and,Literatures, , , , Harvard,University, Cambridge,,Massachusetts, , April,2015, , , , , , , , , ©,2015,Seth,Edward,LaFond,Peabody, All,rights,reserved., , , , Dissertation,Advisor:,Eric,Rentschler, , Seth,Edward,LaFond,Peabody, , Environmental,Fantasies:,Mountains,,Cities,,and,Heimat,in,Weimar,Cinema, , , Abstract, , , This,dissertation,analyzes,filmic,environments,within,Weimar,cinema,and, argues,for,a,concept,of,Heimat,in,which,the,landscapes,of,modernity,are,embedded, into,the!environments,of,home.,Mountain,films,such,as,Der!heilige!Berg!enact,a, visual,mechanization,of,the,Alpine,landscape;,industrial,films,such,as,Sprengbagger! 1010!constellate,pastoral,and,modernized,scenes,in,a,similar,fashion,to, contemporary,Heimat,club,journals;,and,urban,films,such,as,Menschen!am!Sonntag, reveal,the,ways,in,which,the,city,figures,as,Heimat,within,Weimar,film.,Further,,film, journals,display,contradictory,discourses,surrounding,Heimat!before,the, standardization,of,idyllic,rural,scenes,in,the,postwar,Heimatfilm!genre.,, These,filmic,environments,interact,with,the,realRworld,environment,in, complex,and,multiRdirectional,ways.,They,participate,in,the,development,of,new, ways,of,seeing,,marketing,,and,using,the,environment,and,function,as,nodes,within, sociopolitical,debates,regarding,human,communities,and,physical,landscapes.,These, findings,complicate,arguments,made,by,environmental,historians,who,have,claimed, that,the,German,notion,of,Heimat,,encompassing,both,natural,and,cultural,elements,, might,offer,a,useful,alternative,to,the,essentialism,of,the,American,wilderness,ideal., In,fact,,the,image,of,Heimat,as,a,rural,natureRculture,hybrid,,at,least,within,film,,only, became,dominant,in,the,Nazi,era.,Within,Weimar,cinema,,the,term,Heimat, represents,the,focal,point,of,a,much,more,diverse,and,open,discussion,of, environmental,values.,, , iii, , , Table&of&Contents& , , Introduction,, Navigating,Filmic,Environments,, 1, , , Chapter,1,,, Before,Bavaria,Conquered,the,World:,Heimat,in,Weimar,Cinema,, 22, , , Chapter,2, The,City,in,the,Country:,Mountain,Films,and,Fantasies,of,Alpine,Tourism,, 97, , , Chapter,3,, Urban,Heimat,in,Weimar,Film,, 138, , , Conclusion,, 189, , , Bibliography,, 193, , , Filmography,, 213, , , , , , iv, , Acknowledgments& , This,project,would,not,have,been,possible,without,generous,funding,from,the, Minda,de,Gunzburg,Center,for,European,Studies,at,Harvard,University,,Fulbright,, the,Jens,Aubrey,Westengard,Scholarship,Fund,,the,John,A.,and,Elizabeth,S., Armstrong,Fellowship,Fund,,and,the,Graduate,School,of,Arts,and,Sciences,at, Harvard.,The,Fulbright,IIE,grant,was,especially,pivotal,in,that,it,allowed,me,to, spend,a,crucial,year,researching,and,writing,in,Munich., , I,have,received,steady,strong,support,from,my,thesis,advisor,Eric,Rentschler;,his, expertise,,enthusiasm,,and,rigorous,feedbacK,through,numerous,drafts,have,been, tremendous,assets,to,this,project.,My,additional,committee,members,Tom,Conley, and,Oliver,Simons,have,liKewise,been,thoughtful,and,generous,with,their,feedbacK, and,flexible,in,accommodating,my,scheduling,requirements.,I,consider,myself,lucKy, to,have,received,such,valuable,mentorship,from,my,entire,committee., , Several,institutions,have,provided,crucial,resources,and,scholarly,communities;, foremost,among,them,is,Harvard’s,Department,of,Germanic,Languages,and, Literatures.,The,Rachel,Carson,Center,for,Environment,and,Society,at,the,LMU, Munich,welcomed,me,as,a,Visiting,Scholar,during,the,2013–2014,academic,year., The,Vorarlberger,LandesbibliotheK,,HFF,Munich,,and,Munich,Film,Museum,also, provided,vital,resources,for,my,research,abroad.,Particular,thanKs,within,these, organizations,go,to,Melissa,Carden,,Rachel,Shindelar,,Janine,Fartek,,Peter,Heinrich,, and,Gisela,Pichler., , , Emily,Jones,,Daniel,Le,Ray,,Jillian,DeMair,,and,Keith,Stone,have,been,extremely, generous,as,interlocutors,and,editors,,likewise,Christine,Howard,,Cot,LaFond,,and, Lydia,Peabody.,To,the,extent,that,the,prose,is,clear,,I,owe,them,many,thanKs.,For, blemishes,that,remain,,the,fault,is,my,own.,, , I,am,grateful,to,numerous,colleagues,for,questions,and,conversations,that,have, inspired,me,throughout,this,project:,a,few,noteworthy,names,include,Ben, Anderson,,Emily,BrocK,,Chris,Brown,,Andrea,DeeKer,,Rob,Emmett,,Robert,Groß,, Thomas,Herold,,Stephanie,Hood,,Elin,Kelsey,,Björn,KühnicKe,,Pascale,Lafountain,, Jon,Mathieu,,Anna,MazaniK,,Ruth,Oldenziel,,Anders,Otterness,,Jenny,Price,,Nicole, Seymour,,and,MarKus,WilczeK.,A,special,thanKs,goes,to,Christoph,Mauch,,my, Ersatzdoktorvater!in,Munich,,for,giving,me,the,opportunity,to,work,at,the,Rachel, Carson,Center,and,for,his,thoughtful,engagement,with,my,project.,,, , , Finally,,my,family,has,offered,invaluable,support,and,enthusiasm.,To,my,parents, Cot,LaFond,and,Lionel,Peabody,,my,sister,Lydia,Peabody,,and,my,brother,Daniel, Peabody,,I,send,my,love,and,my,thanKs.,Christine,Howard,has,been,my,first, audience,,trusted,editor,,and,tireless,advocate,throughout,many,projects;,our, partnership,has,sustained,me,through,the,years,that,led,up,to,this,dissertation., Finally,,our,amazing,daughter,Josephine,gave,me,the,inspiration,to,push,through, the,final,stages.,, , v, , , ! ! ! To!Christine! , , , , , , vi, , & & & & Note& , This,work,contains,numerous,quotations,that,were,originally,printed,in,German., Unless,an,EnglishRlanguage,version,is,cited,,the,translation,is,my,own.,,, , , , vii, , , , , , , , In,Heimatfilm,we,are,allowed,to,dream.,There,the,forests,rustle,,the,heath,blooms,, the,lovers,meet,under,the,linden,tree,,the,evening,bells,ring,,and,traditional,parades, fill,the,movie,screen., , Wolfgang,Liebeneiner,,“What,is,a,Heimatfilm?”, , , , , Heimat,was,once,the,heath,,the,mountain,,the,linden,tree.,But,that,was,a,long,time, ago.,Fifty,years,ago,a,rental,apartment,could,still,become,a,Heimat.,A,family,lived, there,for,twenty,years,,and,the,children,married,into,the,next,block,around,the, corner.,One,hundred,years,ago,Heimat,was,a,force.,Today,it,is,a,bourgeois, ressentiment,,or,more,precisely:,a,requisite,for,tears,with,which,German,film,does, penance,at,the,box,office., , Hellmut,Haffner,,“The,Heimatfilm,Problem”, , , , viii, Introduction:+ Negotiating+Filmic+Environments+ ! This!study!examines!the!German!idea!of!Heimat!as!represented!in!Weimar! cinema.1!It!considers!how!mountains,!cities,!and!rural!settings!interact!on!screen,!as! well!as!how!they!interact!with!transformations!in!the!physical,!non>filmic! environment.!The!project!builds!on!a!growing!body!of!film!ecocriticism.!This! introduction!begins!by!situating!the!present!study!among!past!analyses!of!film!and! the!environment!and!then!lays!out!the!argument!to!be!developed!in!the!following! chapters.! The!words!“landscape,”!“environment,”!and!“nature”!will!recur!throughout! this!study.!Each!of!these!words!occupies!the!center!of!a!broad!field!of!discourse!and! no!single!definition!would!do!any!one!of!them!justice.!Still,!an!introduction!to!each! word!is!helpful!as!a!guide.!“Landscape”!comes!from!landscape!painting,!and!refers! etymologically!to!a!piece!of!land!that!is!seen!or!framed.!The!word!is!frequently!used! to!describe!discreet!segments!of!the!physical!world,!either!in!the!sense!of!a!specific! setting!such!as!an!urban!or!rural!landscape,!or!as!in!a!portion!of!land!that!is!literally! framed!in!a!work!of!visual!art.2!“Environment”!implies!a!perceiving!subject!within!a! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 1!I!have!chosen!not!to!italicize!“Heimat”!because!the!word!is!used!frequently!in!this! study!and!because!a!number!of!italicized!film!titles!include!the!word.!In!general,! however,!German!words!are!in!italics.!! 2!For!a!useful!overview!of!the!landscape!painting!tradition!and!its!relevance!to! cinema,!see!Tom!Gunning,!“Landscape!and!the!Fantasy!of!Moving!Pictures:!Early! Cinema’s!Phantom!Rides,”!in!Cinema'and'Landscape,!ed.!Graeme!Harper!and! Jonathan!Rayner!(Bristol,!UK:!Intellect,!2010),!30–70.! ! 1! landscape.!While!a!landscape!is!seen!from!outside,!an!environment!is!experienced! from!within.3!“Nature”!is!an!extremely!complex!word!in!both!English!and!German4! and!has!been!the!subject!of!much!debate.5!In!this!study,!“nature”!is!employed!simply! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! 3!Jakob!von!Uexküll’s!discussion!of!“Umwelt”!is!crucial!to!our!present!understanding! of!environments.!Prior!writers!had!used!the!word!“milieu”!to!refer!to!an!organism’s! material!surroundings!and!took!a!deterministic!approach:!the!milieu!largely! determined!the!course!of!an!organism’s!existence.!In!Uexküll’s!writings,!much!more!