University of Massachusetts Amherst ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst
Masters Theses Dissertations and Theses
July 2017
METER IN FRENCH AND ITALIAN OPERA, 1809–1859
Nicholas Shea University of Massachusetts Amherst
Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarworks.umass.edu/masters_theses_2
Part of the Music Theory Commons
Recommended Citation Shea, Nicholas, "METER IN FRENCH AND ITALIAN OPERA, 1809–1859" (2017). Masters Theses. 536. https://doi.org/10.7275/10009956 https://scholarworks.umass.edu/masters_theses_2/536
This Open Access Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Dissertations and Theses at ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst. It has been accepted for inclusion in Masters Theses by an authorized administrator of ScholarWorks@UMass Amherst. For more information, please contact [email protected].
METER IN FRENCH AND ITALIAN OPERA, 1809–1859
A Thesis Presented
by
NICHOLAS J. SHEA
Submitted to the Graduate School of the University of Massachusetts Amherst in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of
MASTER OF MUSIC
MAY 2017
Music
© 2017 by Nicholas Jordan Shea All rights reserved
METER IN FRENCH AND ITALIAN OPERA, 1809–1859
A Thesis Presented
By
NICHOLAS J. SHEA
Approved as to style and content by:
______Christopher Wm. White, Chair
______Gary S. Karpinski, Member
______Brent Auerbach, Member
______Roberta M. Marvin, Department Head Department of Music
DEDICATION
To Trice and Mary Ann
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS
Christopher White must be thanked first. I would not have been able to
conceptualize the scope of this project, master its methodologies, or convey the
implications of my results to the scholarly community without his boundless patience and
enthusiasm. Much gratitude to his ever-open door. Just as crucial to the development of
this study is Brent Auerbach, for his critical eye on scholarly style, alongside an acute familiarity with historical and metrical discourse, constantly encouraged precision in my analysis. I also extend many thanks to Gary Karpinski for his consistent support of this project from its early stages; his direction refined my methodology, prose, and conference
presentations to great effect. Further gratitude goes to Jason Hooper for pointing me
toward this research area, his insightful feedback on style and analysis, and his general
guidance through the program. Equally invaluable are my peers and other professors at
UMass. I thank Allison Smith for her suggestions in our opera seminars and graduate
student presentations, and Morgan Markel for her keen edits that always pushed me to
consider other perspectives. Further thanks go to Jennifer Smith and Erinn Knyt for
exposing me to the rich world of opera in their seminars.
I conclude by expressing my gratitude to friends and family. First to Cody and
Claire, who supported my lofty goals from the start and always checked in on me. Also to
my siblings Tabitha and Brendan for always having my back. And to my partner, Abigail,
for her grace and patience. Finally, the utmost appreciation goes to my parents Trice,
John, and Jack, who gave me the all the love and encouragement I needed to embark on
this adventure.
v
ABSTRACT
METER IN FRENCH AND ITALIAN OPERA, 1809–1859 MAY 2017 NICHOLAS SHEA, B.M., UNIVERSITY OF MISSOURI-ST. LOUIS MM., UNIVERSITY OF MASSACHUSETTS AMHERST Directed by: Professor Christopher Wm. White Current and historical methods of metric analysis often assume that the first of two concurrent and equal pulses is stronger than the second. This, however, is not the case in all repertoires. For example, it has been shown that Verdi’s midcentury operas often place emphasis on even-numbered beats (Rothstein 2011). This paper shows this metric trend to be even more prevalent in a corpus of nineteenth-century operatic excerpts (1809–1859).
I present a formalized decision tree that classifies phrases according to anacrusis length and prosodic accent, showing where large-scale metric accents fall within a phrase. This model produces three metric types which align with Rothstein’s previous work. Compositional and historical features (e.g., language, premiere date, librettist, etc.) were tracked alongside type to determine whether preferences for certain metric forms were more prevalent in certain contexts. This indeed was the case. For instance, use of even-beat-emphasis meter increases over time, although odd-beat-emphasis meter remains most common. Individual composers also show a significantly distinguishable preference toward each type of meter. These results not only confirm that the highest concentration of even-beat-emphasis meter occurs in Verdi’s midcentury operas, but that
Verdi is the primary user of this type overall. Language and composer nationality do not significantly affect an excerpt's metric type; only Verdi shows the most distinction in
vi these areas. With these findings, I argue against using nationalist language to identify metric types (e.g., Franco-Italian meter and German meter) and instead propose a more nuanced understanding of nineteenth-century metric conventions.
vii
TABLE OF CONTENTS Page
ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ...... v ABSTRACT ...... vi LIST OF FIGURES ...... x CHAPTER 1. INTRODUCTION ...... 1 Biases in Accent ...... 1 Biases in Theory and Analysis ...... 3 Addressing the Bias ...... 8 Nationalisms and Meter ...... 11 2. THE CORPUS ...... 13 French- and Italian-language Operas, 1809–1859 ...... 13 3. METHODOLOGY AND ANALYSIS ...... 15 Marked Scores ...... 15 Perception of Meter and Hypermeter ...... 16 Perception of Duration and Tempo ...... 19 Decision Trees ...... 20 Sample Analysis – Franco-Italian Meter ...... 24 Sample Analysis – German Hypermeter ...... 26 4. RESULTS ...... 29 Meter Over Time ...... 29 Franco-Italian Meter over Time ...... 31 Meter and Language ...... 35 Meter by Composer...... 35 Meter by Composer Country of Origin ...... 37 Meter by Librettist ...... 38 Meter by Gender ...... 40 Other Observations ...... 40 5. DISCUSSION ...... 42 Textual Accent in French and Italian Verse ...... 42 Summary of Findings ...... 45 6. OTHER APPLICATIONS ...... 47 Meter Outside of Opera ...... 47
viii
Meter in “Venezianisches Gondellied” ...... 49 Phrase Rhythm in “Venezianisches Gondellied” ...... 53 7. CONCLUSION ...... 60 A Summary of this Study ...... 60 Considerations and Future Work ...... 61 APPENDIX METER IN FRENCH AND ITALIAN OPERA, 1809–1859 ...... 63 BIBLIOGRAPHY ...... 66
ix
LIST OF FIGURES
Figure Page
1. Isolated quarter notes ...... 2
2. Combinations of accent...... 2
3. "Me-ter" ...... 2
4. "Me-ter" with a barline ...... 2
5. Meyerbeer, ‘Je t’ai trompé, je fus coupable,’ Robert le Diable, mm. 1–4...... 5
6. Plausibility of competing metrical models ...... 5
7. Melodic grouping and displacement ...... 6
8. Verdi, "Ma tu, superbo giovane,” Oberto, mm. 98–102, conflicting phrase rhythms .... 8
9. Hugo Riemann’s weak/strong setting of a formal period ...... 10
10. Metric features of Rothstein’s nationalistic metric types ...... 11
11. Rossini, “La speranza più soave,” mm. 9–11, score as marked in the corpus ...... 16
12a. Rossini, “La speranza più soave,” mm. 9–11, Franco-Italian meter ...... 17
12b. Rossini, “La speranza più soave,” doubled duration and te