Research Paper
GEOSPHERE Variable normal-fault rupture behavior, northern Lost River fault zone, Idaho, USA
1 2 1 1 1,3 1, 2 GEOSPHERE, v. 15, no. 6 Christopher B. DuRoss , Michael P. Bunds , Ryan D. Gold , Richard W. Briggs , Nadine G. Reitman , Stephen F. Personius *, and Nathan A. Toké 1U.S. Geological Survey, 1711 Illinois Street, Golden, Colorado 80401, USA 2Utah Valley University, 800 West University Parkway, Orem, Utah 84058, USA https://doi.org/10.1130/GES02096.1 3University of Colorado–Boulder, UCB 399, Boulder, Colorado 80309-0399, USA
13 figures; 1 table; 3 sets of supplemental files ABSTRACT Springs section, and the southern half of the Warm Springs section, north CORRESPONDENCE: [email protected] of the Willow Creek Hills structure, a prominent hanging-wall bedrock ridge The 1983 Mw 6.9 Borah Peak earthquake generated ~36 km of surface where the LRFZ splits into multiple strands with differing strikes (Crone et al., CITATION: DuRoss, C.B., Bunds, M.P., Gold, R.D., Briggs, R.W., Reitman, N.G., Personius, S.F., and rupture along the Thousand Springs and Warm Springs sections of the Lost 1987) (Fig. 1). As one of the largest intraplate normal-faulting earthquakes Toké, N.A., 2019, Variable normal-fault rupture be- River fault zone (LRFZ, Idaho, USA). Although the rupture is a well-studied recorded historically and an example of the complex rupture of a multiseg- havior, northern Lost River fault zone, Idaho, USA: example of multisegment surface faulting, ambiguity remains regarding the ment normal fault system (Haller and Crone, 2004), the Borah Peak earthquake Geosphere, v. 15, no. 6, p. 1869–1892, https://doi.org /10.1130/GES02096.1. degree to which a bedrock ridge and branch fault at the Willow Creek Hills rupture offers an important opportunity to relate spatial and temporal patterns influenced rupture progress. To explore the 1983 rupture in the context of the of surface displacement to fault-rupture processes (e.g., Wesnousky, 2008; Science Editor: David E. Fastovsky structural complexity, we reconstruct the spatial distribution of surface dis- Nissen et al., 2014; Haddon et al., 2016; Delano et al., 2017; Personius et al., Associate Editor: Jose M. Hurtado placements for the northern 16 km of the 1983 rupture and prehistoric ruptures 2017; Johnson et al., 2018). in the same reach of the LRFZ using 252 vertical-separation measurements Although the subsurface rupture geometry (Boatwright, 1985; Doser and Received 29 November 2018 made from high-resolution (5–10-cm-pixel) digital surface models. Our results Smith, 1985; Smith et al., 1985; Richins et al., 1987) and slip (e.g., Ward and Revision received 16 May 2019 Accepted 15 August 2019 suggest the 1983 Warm Springs rupture had an average vertical displacement Barrientos, 1986), far-field crustal deformation (Stein and Barrientos, 1985; of ~0.3–0.4 m and released ~6% of the seismic moment estimated for the Barrientos et al., 1987), fault-zone structure (Janecke, 1993; Susong et al., 1990; Published online 8 November 2019 Borah Peak earthquake and <12% of the moment accumulated on the Warm Bruhn et al., 1991), and surface rupture extent and displacement (Crone et al., Springs section since its last prehistoric earthquake. The 1983 Warm Springs 1987) of the Borah Peak earthquake are well documented, uncertainty remains rupture is best described as the moderate-displacement continuation of pri- regarding the role the Willow Creek Hills structure played in controlling the mary rupture from the Thousand Springs section into and through a zone of length of the rupture (Crone et al., 1985; Bruhn et al., 1991). That is, did the structural complexity. Historical and prehistoric displacements show that the structure impede the lateral propagation of the 1983 rupture, where surface Willow Creek Hills have impeded some, but not all ruptures. We speculate faulting to the north along the Warm Springs section is secondary (nonseismo- that rupture termination or penetration is controlled by the history of LRFZ genic) in nature (Crone et al., 1987)? Or is the 1983 earthquake an example of moment release, displacement, and rupture direction. Our results inform the multisegment rupture in which the Willow Creek hills modulated, but did not interpretation of paleoseismic data from near zones of normal-fault structural fully stop slip propagation? Further, to what degree has the structure impeded complexity and demonstrate that these zones may modulate rather than the propagation of previous LRFZ ruptures? These questions are important in impede rupture displacement. recognizing how conditional probabilities of rupture through structural barriers (e.g., Oskin et al., 2015) may help explain evidence of multi-modal fault behavior (e.g., single-segment and multi-segment rupture; e.g., DuRoss et al., 2016), and ■■ INTRODUCTION ultimately help improve earthquake-rupture forecasts (e.g., Field et al., 2014). Here, we use high-resolution (5–10-cm-pixel) digital surface models (DSMs) The 1983 Mw 6.9 Borah Peak earthquake ruptured ~36 km of the ~130-km-long to improve our understanding of the 1983 rupture in the context of slip propa- Lost River fault zone (LRFZ, Idaho, USA) (Crone et al., 1987), one of several gation through the Willow Creek Hills structurally complex zone (Fig. 2). DSMs normal faults that accommodate dominantly SW-NE extension in the Centen- generated from low-altitude aerial photography derived from unmanned air- nial Tectonic Belt of the northern Basin and Range Province (Scott et al., 1985; craft systems (UAS) allow us to map the geometry and extent of deformation Stickney and Bartholomew, 1987; Payne et al., 2013) (Fig. 1). Surface rupture in the 1983 rupture, estimate the vertical displacement of geomorphic surfaces occurred along two structural fault sections, including all of the Thousand faulted by the LRFZ in both the 1983 and prehistoric earthquakes (Fig. 3), and This paper is published under the terms of the quantify trends in displacement along fault strike. We focus on the northern- CC‑BY-NC license. *Emeritus most 16 km of rupture, north and south of the Willow Creek Hills, using 252
© 2019 The Authors
GEOSPHERE | Volume 15 | Number 6 DuRoss et al. | Northern Lost River fault zone rupture behavior Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/15/6/1869/4876716/1869.pdf 1869 by guest on 27 September 2021 Research Paper
displacement observations (Supplemental Fig. S11). Measurements include 114°W 113°50' W geomorphic surfaces displaced by both the 1983 rupture (n = 196) as well as Idaho Montana prehistoric ruptures (n = 56). These observations highlight the complex sur- Challis face-rupture geometry near the Willow Creek Hills and clear and continuous section rupture of the southernmost Warm Springs section, and provide evidence BFZ W
that prehistoric ruptures of the Warm Springs section had displacements and a Challis r m along-strike extents distinctly different from the 1983 rupture. MC
LFZ
S N '
p 0
RC 2 r ° in Mackay 4 g LRFZ 4 s 1983 ESRP ■■ TECTONIC SETTING Mw 6.9 s e Arco c INL t Lone io Lost River Fault Zone n 20 Pine km fault The LRFZ is one of several NW-striking normal faults that accommodate SC dominantly SW-NE extension and terminate to the south near the northern margin of the eastern Snake River plain (Baldwin, 1951; Scott et al., 1985; Payne Willow Creek Hills et al., 2008) (Fig. 1). Six sections along the LRFZ have been proposed, includ- Dickey ing (north to south) the Challis, Warm Springs, Thousand Springs, Mackay, Peak
T Pass Creek, and Arco sections (Scott et al., 1985; Crone et al., 1987). These h o sections range from 15 km (Arco and Warm Springs sections) to 26 km (Pass u s a Creek section) in length (U.S. Geological Survey, 2018) and are defined using n Hwy 93 d PS
along-strike changes in fault geometry and geomorphology, structural relief
N
of the range front (including the presence of hanging-wall bedrock salients), '
0
1 DP ° and differences in the timing of most recent fault movement (Scott et al., 1985). 4 4 S Movement on the SW-dipping LRFZ since ca. 4–7 Ma has generated the p r in prominent SW-facing Lost River range front and ~2.7 km of maximum struc- g s Borah
tural relief, accounting for basin fill and range front topography (Scott et al., Peak
s 1985). This translates to a late Neogene average slip rate of ~0.4–0.7 mm/yr. e c
t i Scott et al. (1985) calculated a latest Pleistocene to present geologic slip rate o n of ~0.3 mm/yr for the Thousand Springs section, based on 3.5–4.5 m of vertical offset (including displacement from the 1983 earthquake) measured across
a ca. 15 ka fan surface (Pierce and Scott, 1982). Using the 1983 displacement EC (~1.5–2 m) and time since the previous surface-rupturing earthquake (~8 k.y.; Quaternary faults <1.6 Ma Scott et al., 1985), Hanks and Schwartz (1987) reported a single-event closed-in- <15 ka terval slip rate of ~0.2 mm/yr. Slip rates for fault sections north and south of 1983 AD the Thousand Springs section are not well known but are possibly <0.2 mm/yr 0 5 km Mackay based on geologic mapping and trench investigations (Scott et al., 1985; Olig 10 km section et al., 1995; U.S. Geological Survey, 2018). Figure 1. Surface-rupture extent of the 1983 Mw 6.9 Borah Peak earthquake (red), which ruptured the Thousand Springs and southernmost Warm Springs sections of the Lost River fault zone 1 Supplemental Figures. Lost River fault zone mapping, (LRFZ). The Willow Creek Hills are an area of hanging-wall bedrock and complex surface faulting topographic profiles, and vertical separation data 1983 Borah Peak Rupture that form a normal-fault structural barrier between the two sections. Yellow polygons show the (Fig. S1), aftershocks of the 1983 Borah Peak earth- extent of digital surface models generated in this study using low-altitude aerial imagery derived quake (Fig. S2), vertical separation in the Goosebury from unmanned aircraft systems. Fault traces and time of most recent faulting modified from graben (Fig. S3), vertical separation along the south- The 1983 Mw 6.9 Borah Peak rupture initiated at a depth of ~16 km (Doser U.S. Geological Survey (2018). Focal mechanism from Doser and Smith (1985); approximate lo- ern Warm Springs section (Fig. S4), vertical separa- and Smith, 1985) near the structural boundary between the Thousand Springs cation is 10 km south of figure extent (Richins et al., 1987). Triangles indicate paleoseismic sites: tion along the northern Arentson Gulch fault (Fig. S5). and Mackay sections (Susong et al., 1990) and propagated unilaterally NW RC—Rattlesnake Creek; SC—Sheep Creek; PS—Poison Spring; DP—Doublespring Pass; EC—Elk- Please visit https://doi.org/10.1130/GES02096.S1 or horn Creek; MC—McGowen Creek. Inset map shows regional context. LFZ—Lemhi fault zone; access the full-text article on www.gsapubs.org to (Boatwright, 1985; Doser and Smith, 1985; Richins et al., 1987), resulting in BFZ—Beaverhead fault zone; ESRP—Eastern Snake River Plain; INL—Idaho National Laboratory. view the Supplemental Figures. 36 ± 3 km of surface rupture (Crone et al., 1987) (Fig. 1). Finite fault models Base maps are National Elevation Data set 10 m and 30 m (inset map) digital elevation models.
GEOSPHERE | Volume 15 | Number 6 DuRoss et al. | Northern Lost River fault zone rupture behavior Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/15/6/1869/4876716/1869.pdf 1870 by guest on 27 September 2021 Research Paper
114°W 113°55' W Topographic profile
0 4 km Surface projection 0 Historical rupture 0.5 m Scarp face projection profile Vertical separation 1983 surface rupture 0.6 m Prehistoric fault scarps N ' 0 1m 1983 Arentson Gulch fault 2 ° W 4
RC rupture (Crone et al., 1987) 4 a r 2 km 2.0 m m Cracks/unknown origin Eroded fault scarp (prehistoric)
1983 fault scarp & VS
VE=1.5x Eroded fault free face (historical)
Goosebury graben Regression Fig 4 Goosebury Scarp colluvium (historical) 4 km Creek domain Fig S3
S Scarp colluvium (prehistoric) pr in g s
Figure 3. Vertical separation measurement for a compound normal-fault scarp
formed by both prehistoric and historical fault rupture. Regression domains 6 km s e show points along profile used to calculate a linear surface projection. No ver- c t io n tical exaggeration (VE). Subset of profile, showing vertical separation for the historical rupture of the scarp, is enlarged by 50%.
8 km
suggest 1.5–2 m of dominantly dip-slip displacement occurred on a 40°–50° Fig S4 SW-dipping sub-planar normal fault (Doser and Smith, 1985; Stein and Bar- SC rientos, 1985; Barrientos et al., 1987). Surface faulting in the 1983 earthquake 10 km includes rupture of (1) the entire 24-km-long Thousand Springs section, (2) the
0.1 m southern 8 km of the ~15-km-long Warm Springs section to the north, and Sheep Creek (3) a fault that branches WNW from the range-front trace of the LRFZ at the
0 northern end of the Thousand Springs section (herein, the Arentson Gulch 12 km Willow Creek fault after Bruhn et al., 1991) and continues into the Willow Creek Hills (Crone N Fig S5 ' Hills 5
1 et al., 1987) (Fig. 2). The Willow Creek Hills are a prominent bedrock ridge ° 4 2 km 4 on the hanging wall of the LRFZ that form an apparent long-lived structural complexity between the Thousand Springs and Warm Springs sections (Figs. 1 Arentson Gulch fault 4 km 14 km and 2). Bruhn et al. (1991) suggest that the Willow Creek Hills are structur- Fig 5 ally perched (hung-up) on a SSW-plunging subsurface bedrock ridge in the 6 km LRFZ that increases in width with depth. Only a 9° change in the strike of the Dickey Peak range-front trace of the LRFZ occurs across the Willow Creek Hills (Crone et al., 1987) (Fig. 1). Aftershocks following the 1983 earthquake were most 16 km 8 km abundant near the Willow Creek Hills, eventually migrating to near the Warm Springs and Challis sections (Boatwright, 1985; Zollweg and Richins, 1985; Thousand Springs Richins et al., 1987). More recent (2010–2018) moderate-magnitude seismicity section distributed along the Challis section (Fig. S2 [footnote 1]) is likely part of a long-lived aftershock sequence (Pang et al., 2018) and highlights the area of Figure 2. Unmanned aircraft systems photography acquisition areas (yellow polygons), showing the 1983 and prehistoric ruptures of the Lost River fault zone (LRFZ (this study). The 1983 rupture increased Coulomb stress along the Challis section following the Borah Peak includes the southern 8 km of the Warm Springs section, the northern 6 km of the Thousand earthquake (Payne et al., 2004). Springs section, and the 8-km-long Arentson Gulch fault, which branches WNW into the Willow Surface rupture in the Borah Peak earthquake produced mostly continuous, Creek Hills structural barrier. The 1983 rupture had no net displacement within the 2-km-long Goosebury graben and did not break the ~5-km-long discontinuous trace of the LRFZ at the SW-facing normal-fault scarps with a minor (~17%) left-lateral component eastern boundary of the Willow Creek Hills (Crone et al., 1987). Ticks show along-strike fault (Crone et al., 1987). Vertical displacements are typically ~0.5–2 m and reach distance extending south from the northernmost rupture of the Warm Spring section. The 1983 a maximum of 2.5–2.7 m near the center of the Thousand Springs section rupture trace and 0.1 m vertical displacement of the Arentson Gulch fault outside of our Willow Creek Hills acquisition area is from Crone et al. (1987). Base map is National Elevation Data set (near Doublespring Pass Road; Crone et al., 1987). Measurements of laterally 10 m digital elevation model. RC—Rattlesnake Creek; SC—Sheep Creek; VS—vertical separation. offset cultural features (e.g., fences and roads) indicate 0.4–1.0 m of left lateral
GEOSPHERE | Volume 15 | Number 6 DuRoss et al. | Northern Lost River fault zone rupture behavior Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/15/6/1869/4876716/1869.pdf 1871 by guest on 27 September 2021 Research Paper
strike-slip displacement along the Thousand Springs section (Crone et al., Stratigraphic evidence and geochronological results from an additional 1987). Along the northernmost Thousand Springs section near the Arentson trench and natural exposure suggest that the Thousand Springs paleoearthquake Gulch fault, complex faulting includes discontinuous normal and thrust faults may have occurred in the early Holocene. About 3 km northwest of Double (Crone et al., 1987) (Fig. 2). Displacement along the Arentson Gulch fault spring Pass Road, the Poison Spring (PS; Fig. 1) trench exposed faulted bedrock, decreases to the northwest: the southeastern part of the fault has 0.8–1.6 m hillslope colluvium, and scarp-derived colluvium from a prehistoric earthquake of vertical and 0.3–1.2 m of left lateral strike-slip displacement, compared to (Vincent, 1995). Charcoal from the uppermost part of the scarp-colluvial unit 0.3–0.6 m of vertical and 0.3–0.7 m of right lateral strike-slip displacement to yielded an age of 9045 ± 100 14C yr B.P. that provides a minimum constraint on the north (Crone et al., 1987). At the northern end of the Arentson Gulch fault the timing of the prehistoric rupture. A natural exposure at Elkhorn Creek (EC; (northern flank of the Willow Creek Hills), Crone et al. (1987) mapped zones Fig. 1) provides additional evidence of the prehistoric rupture of the Thousand of surface cracking and a single 0.1 m vertical displacement scarp (Fig. 2). Springs section (Vincent, 1995). At this site, a soil A horizon formed in allu- About 2–3 km west, two isolated and <0.05-m-displacement scarps correspond vial-fan sediments predates a prehistoric fault scarp; charcoal from the soil with the southern termination of the Lone Pine fault (Fig. 1), a Quaternary dated to 9710 ± 240 14C yr B.P. provides a maximum limit on the timing of the active, NE-dipping normal fault west of the LRFZ (U.S. Geological Survey, prehistoric rupture. Vincent (1995) used a similar pattern of surface displace- 2018). Crone et al. (1987) suggest a possible nontectonic (shaking-related) ment decreasing from the center (Doublespring Pass and Poison Spring) to origin for the 1983 Lone Pine scarps on account of the minor and isolated southern (Elkhorn Creek) parts of the Thousand Spring section to infer that nature of the slip. the Poison Spring and Elkhorn Creek sites record the same paleoearthquake. An important aspect of the 1983 rupture is the occurrence of prominent As a result, Vincent (1995) used the Poison Springs and Elkhorn Creek radio- gaps in surface displacement observed along the range-front-bounding LRFZ carbon ages to bracket the timing of the prehistoric Thousand Springs rupture (Crone et al., 1987). Northeast of the Arentson Gulch fault, the Willow Creek to between 9045 and 9710 14C yr B.P., or 10.2–11.1 ka, calendar calibrated here Hills abut the Lost River range front, coinciding with a 5-km-long portion of using OxCal (version 4.3; Bronk Ramsey, 2009). the range-front trace of the LRFZ that did not rupture in 1983 (kilometer marks Two trenches across the Warm Springs section (Fig. 1) provide evidence of 8–13; Fig. 2). Older, discontinuous scarps in this area (Crone et al., 1987) indi- a ~mid-Holocene earthquake. Schwartz and Crone (1988) excavated trenches cate previous ruptures of the LRFZ; however, the late Quaternary surfaces that across the section at two locations: an unnamed drainage ~2 km SE of McGowan are faulted have not been precisely dated. Northwest of the Willow Creek Hills, Creek (the Rattlesnake Canyon trench, RC; Fig. 2) and an unnamed drainage 1983 surface rupture resumes on the southeastern half of the Warm Springs within the northern part of the Willow Creek Hills near Sheep Creek (herein, the section (kilometers 0–8; Fig. 2). Displacements along this section decrease Sheep Creek trench, SC; Fig. 2). Although the RC and SC trench observations from ~0.5–1 m in the south to <0.2 m in the north, and only a few, small (<0.2 are unpublished, a summary by Schwartz and Crone (1988) indicates similar m) lateral offsets were measured (Crone et al., 1987). A nearly 2 km gap in the stratigraphic relations and ages. Charcoal derived from burn horizons within 1983 surface rupture occurs at the Goosebury graben in a zone of prominent basal scarp-derived colluvium at the sites yielded radiocarbon ages of 4940 prehistoric scarps (kilometers 3–5, Fig. 2). ± 200 14C yr B.P. (RC trench) and 5280 ± 240 14C yr B.P. (SC trench). Schwartz and Crone (1988) used the distance between the sites (~7.5 km) and degree of soil development to infer that the trenches record the same paleoearthquake on Paleoseismic Data the Warm Springs section, calendar calibrated here to shortly before 5.1–6.6 ka. Vertical displacement estimates are 0.75 m at the Rattlesnake Canyon trench Paleoseismic data for the northern LRFZ are from four paleoseismic trench and ~2.2 m at the Sheep Creek trench (Schwartz, written communication, 2016). sites and a natural exposure. Although constraints on event timing are sparse, we consider it most likely Trenches excavated near Doublespring Pass Road (DP; Fig. 1) exposed that earthquakes occurred at ca. 10–11 ka on the Thousand Springs section evidence of at least one paleoearthquake on the Thousand Springs section. and shortly before ca. 5–7 ka on the Warm Springs section. An initial trench excavated in 1976 by Hait and Scott (1978) found evidence for a single paleoearthquake expressed in alluvial-fan deposits postdating the most recent (Pinedale) glaciation (ca. 15 ka; see summaries by Crone, 1985; ■■ METHODS Schwartz and Crone, 1985; and Haller and Crone, 2004). A second trench, excavated immediately adjacent to the Hait and Scott (1978) trench follow- To investigate surface displacement along the LRFZ, we acquired low-altitude ing the 1983 earthquake, showed that 1983 rupture displacement at the site aerial photographs using UAS and a tethered balloon in May 2015 (Warm (1.7–2.0 m) had a similar magnitude compared to prehistoric displacement Springs section; Fig. 2) and May 2016 (Willow Creek Hills area, including the at the site (1.3–1.5 m) (Schwartz and Crone, 1985). Neither trench yielded age northern Thousand Springs section and Arentson Gulch fault; Fig. 2). Using constraints for the paleoearthquake. image-based (structure-from-motion) modeling, we generated 5–10-cm-pixel
GEOSPHERE | Volume 15 | Number 6 DuRoss et al. | Northern Lost River fault zone rupture behavior Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/15/6/1869/4876716/1869.pdf 1872 by guest on 27 September 2021 Research Paper
DSMs for the northern 16 km of the 1983 rupture (Fig. 4), georeferenced using 2015 and 2016. UAS platforms and sensors included (1) a DJI Phantom that we ground control from kinetic differential global navigation satellite system customized to carry a Sony a5100 camera and 16mm prime lens, (2) a Falcon (GNSS) measurements of survey targets. We measured the vertical separation fixed wing with a Sony a5100 camera and 20mm prime lens, and (3) a 3DR (VS; Fig. 3) of geomorphic surfaces displaced by the LRFZ using topographic Solo with GoPro Hero4 Black (~3mm fisheye) camera. A Canon SX230 compact profiles extracted from the DSMs (e.g., Fig. 5; Fig. S1 [footnote 1]). camera set at a focal length of 28 mm was mounted on the Helikite. We used the Phantom and Helikite during the 2015 survey and the Phantom, Falcon, and Solo during the 2016 survey. Digital Surface Models For geographic control, we placed ground-control targets throughout the survey area. Targets consisted of ~0.3-m-diameter bucket lids, ~0.5-m-wide We generated DSMs from photographs acquired from low altitudes (mostly mesh construction flags, and, most commonly, ~1.5-m-square black and <100 m) using UAS and a Helikite tethered balloon during field campaigns in white (iron-cross pattern) vinyl targets. For our ~11.9 km2 acquisition area, we
0 0
Vertical separation (m) - prehistoric <2 m 2-3.5 m 3.5-4.5 m 1 Warm 1 Vertical separation (m) - 1983 <0.25 m 0.25-0.5 m 0.5-1.04 m 2 2 1983 Surface rupture certain uncertain
Springs concealed 3 3 unknown Prehistoric fault scarps Figure 4. Extent and magnitude of 1983 displacement certain along (A) the southernmost Warm Springs section, uncertain (B) the northern Thousand Springs section, and Ar- concealed entson Gulch fault near the Willow Creek Hills. Ticks Fig 8 4 4 Goosebury show kilometer marks along the Lost River fault zone
graben and Arentson Gulch fault. Scarp-profiles and vertical separation measurements are also shown in Figures 5 and 6 and Figure S1 (see text footnote 1). Base Fig S3 maps are slopeshade maps derived from low-altitude 5 5 unmanned aircraft systems photography (Bunds et al., 2019); point clouds available at Open Topography (https://doi.org/10.5069/G9222RWR). (Continued on following page.)
6 section 6
7 7
8 8
± Slope 0 2 km 0º ≥40º Fig S4
GEOSPHERE | Volume 15 | Number 6 DuRoss et al. | Northern Lost River fault zone rupture behavior Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/15/6/1869/4876716/1869.pdf 1873 by guest on 27 September 2021 Research Paper
2 2 12
3 3 Slope 13 º º 0 ≥40 4 4 A ren Vertical separation tson 5 5 (m) - prehistoric G Fig S5 ulch 0-2 m f au 2-4 m lt 14 6 4-6 m 6 Fig 9 6-8 m
Vertical separation (m) - 1983 Springs section 0-0.5 m Thousand 7 0.5-1 m 7 15 1-2 m 1983 Surface rupture certain 8 uncertain 8 concealed unknown Prehistoric fault scarps certain 0 2 km uncertain concealed
Figure 4 (continued).
placed 186 control points, including ~28 control points/km2 along the Warm were recognized in individual photographs, (3) used the OPUS-corrected dif- Springs section (~4.6 km2) and ~8 control points/km2 near the Willow Creek ferential GNSS data to provide spatial control for the markers, (4) for 2016 data, Hills (~7.6 km2). Target locations were measured in the field using kinetic dif- removed sparse cloud points with large uncertainty via Photoscan’s gradual ferential GNSS systems and local geodetic-quality base stations (Trimble 5700 selection tools, and (5) optimized cameras (least squares bundle adjustment). receiver with Zephyr Geodetic I antenna) that were postprocessed in the NAD83 We merged 12 subregions that form the surveyed portion of the Warm Springs (2011) reference frame using the National Geodetic Survey’s Online Positioning section in Photoscan, re-optimized the camera models, and built a dense point User Service (OPUS; National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, 2018). cloud using high quality and aggressive depth filtering. Six subregions of Control-point positions were transformed into NAD83 (2011) UTM zone 12 and the Willow Creek Hills area were combined and processed in the same fash- orthometric heights using GEOID12A. ion as the Warm Springs section data except the merged sparse point cloud We used Agisoft Photoscan image-based photogrammetric modeling soft- was cleaned of high uncertainty points. We did not automatically classify the ware (versions 1.2.6–1.4.3) to generate two separate point clouds and DSMs dense point cloud because in some cases steep topography and locally heavy (available at Open Topography, http://opentopo.sdsc.edu/datasets; Bunds et vegetation prevented imaging of the ground surface. The DSM of the Warm al., 2019), one for the Warm Springs section (2015 data) and one for the Willow Springs section was generated in Photoscan from a mesh built in Photoscan. Creek Hills area (2016 data). Image-based modeling uses feature recognition The DSM of the Willow Creek Hills area was generated in Photoscan using and photo alignment to generate a point cloud for a 3-D surface (Matthews, its DEM generation tool (inverse-distance weighting method). The merged 2008; Harwin and Lucieer, 2012; Bemis et al., 2014; Johnson et al., 2014; Reitman DSMs (Bunds et al., 2019) are 10-cm-pixel resolutions. We used GIS software 2 2 Supplemental Text. Agisoft Photoscan digital surface et al., 2015). Our DSM workflow (Supplemental Text S1 ) consisted of the fol- to visualize the DSMs, create slopeshade and hillshade maps, and map fault model workflow (Text S1), vertical separation data lowing steps. The surveyed areas were initially subdivided into 18 subregions. traces and surficial geology. (Text S2), tutorial for Matlab code Scarp_VS.m (Text In Photoscan, for each subregion we (1) added photographs then generated a Error in our DSMs results from a complex interplay of factors such as cam- S3). Please visit https://doi.org/10.1130/GES02096.S2 or access the full-text article on www.gsapubs.org to sparse point cloud and aligned cameras using Photoscan’s highest accuracy era exposure settings, lens specifications, camera calibrations applied, flight view the Supplemental Text. setting, (2) manually placed markers on ground-control target centers that design (e.g., flight-line geometry and altitude), photograph overlap, sensor
GEOSPHERE | Volume 15 | Number 6 DuRoss et al. | Northern Lost River fault zone rupture behavior Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/15/6/1869/4876716/1869.pdf 1874 by guest on 27 September 2021 Research Paper
2215 WS p38 regression 1.95 m antithetic: domain (1.40 m) 0.5–0.6 m 2210 Prehistoric (PH)
Elevation (m) 50 60 70 80 90 100 110 120 130 140 Distance (m) 2178 WS p26 2228 WS p40 4.10 m (2.88 m) 2177 2224 antithetic: 2176 0.26 m ~1.2 m PH 2220 2175 Elevation (m) 90 100 110 120 130 140 150 160 Elevation (m) 2174 1983 Distance (m) 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 Distance (m) WCH p56 2243
2241 1.83 m
2239 1983 Elevation (m) 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 Distance (m) 2248 WCH p58 2246 1.50 m 2244 Elevation (m) 2242 1983 40 50 60 70 80 90 Distance (m) 2238 WCH p54 2.95 m 2234
2230 PH+1983 Elevation (m) 0 20 40 60 80 100 Distance (m)
2256 WCH p61 3.49 m 2252 PH+1983
Elevation (m) 0 20 40 60 80 100 Distance (m) 2340 WS p74 WS p76 2339 2346 0.68 m 2338 2345 0.69 m excluded 1983 2337 1983 points 2344 Elevation (m) Elevation (m) 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 2350 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 Distance (m) Distance (m) 2350 2346 WS p77 WS p75 3.90 m 2342 3.82 m 2345 2338 Elevation (m) 2340 PH+1983 PH+1983 2334 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 0 10 20 30 40 50 Distance (m) Distance (m)
Figure 5. A subset of vertical separation (VS) measurements for scarps formed in the 1983 and prehistoric (PH) earthquakes along the Warm Springs and Thousand Springs sections to illustrate data quality and VS measurement method. For profiles U38 and U40, value in parentheses is net slip accounting for far-field antithetic faulting. Dotted boxes show regression domains, which were defined manually and used to determine linear surface projections (blue lines). Orange points represent vegetation points that we removed manually. No vertical exaggeration. Profile locations for all VS measurements shown in Figure S1 (see text footnote 1). WCH—Willow Creek Hills; WS—Warm Springs.
GEOSPHERE | Volume 15 | Number 6 DuRoss et al. | Northern Lost River fault zone rupture behavior Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/15/6/1869/4876716/1869.pdf 1875 by guest on 27 September 2021 Research Paper
dimensions and ground sample distance, ground-control target placement (Caskey, 1995) (Fig. 5). For profiles with heavy vegetation, we manually selected and GNSS measurement, and effects from vegetation and topography. We and removed profile points above the ground surface prior to defining foot- applied a large number of strategies to reduce error, most important of which wall and hanging-wall surface projections. Because footwall fault exposures were (1) a dense network of ground-control targets, (2) placement of targets (preserved free faces) along the 1983 rupture are rare, we calculate VS rather on relatively flat ground away from vegetation to minimize any vertical and/or than fault throw, which requires assumptions about near-surface fault dip (e.g., horizontal movement during use, (3) use of high-resolution cameras, fast shut- Johnson et al., 2018). Although slope steepness and fault dip can enhance the ter speeds (>1/1000 s), and camera mounts that did not maintain perfect nadir discrepancy between actual fault throw and measured VS (e.g., Mackenzie camera direction, (4) varied flight altitudes, (5) GNSS base station occupations and Elliott, 2017), our VS measurements are likely ~80%–90% or greater of exceeding 8 h, and (6) application of best practices for processing in Agisoft throw because steep (60°–90°; Crone et al., 1987) near-surface faults dip in Photoscan (Matthews, 2008; James and Robson, 2012; Bunds et al., 2015). We the same direction as moderately (<15°) sloping geomorphic surfaces (Cas- assessed DSM errors using checkpoints and methods similar to those specified key, 1995). Differences between VS and throw along strike are small relative for U.S. Geological Survey Q1 airborne lidar (Heidemann, 2018). Checkpoints to along-strike changes in the VS and throw values themselves, making our are differential GNSS location measurements taken on bare, relatively flat VS measurements valid for evaluating along-strike surface-rupture behavior. ground across the surveyed area. We measured 82 checkpoints on the DSM Our VS measurements do not account for lateral slip and the possibility of of the Warm Springs section, and 28 on the Arentson Gulch fault and northern two-dimensional profiles sampling non-correlative surfaces because of later- Thousand Springs section. The misfit in elevation of the checkpoints relative ally offset geomorphic features (e.g., Mackenzie and Elliott, 2017). However, as to the DSMs was determined using GIS software, and root-mean-square-er- a whole, we expect the influence of lateral slip on VS to be minimal because ror (RMSE) was calculated for the checkpoints. RMSE for the Warm Springs of the minor (~17%) strike-slip component, steep fault dips, and moderate and section DSM is 6.4 cm and 5.8 cm for the Arentson Gulch fault and northern laterally continuous surface slopes. Thousand Springs section. DSM precision across distances of meters to tens For complex fault rupture patterns (e.g., multiple synthetic and/or antithetic of meters (i.e., common topographic profile lengths) is likely better than the traces), we adopted two approaches to measuring VS. For narrow zones of overall RMSE for the models as the fine topography of features such as cob- faulting (less than a few tens of meters wide), we accounted for complex bles, boulders, and small plants are well resolved in the DSMs. faulting (e.g., graben formation) by selecting upper and lower far-field points outside of the fault zone(s). For complex scarps, such as those consisting of multiple synthetic scarps and/or antithetic scarps several tens of meters or Vertical Separation Measurements more from the primary scarp, we subdivided the profile into shorter segments and summed the VS results. For compound scarps consisting of both 1983 We used topographic profiles extracted from the DSMs to estimate the ver- and prehistoric rupture, we used short profiles (generally <10 m in length) to tical separation (VS) of geomorphic surfaces displaced by the Warm Springs reconstruct 1983 VS, and longer profiles (tens of meters in length or more) to section (n = 133) and northern Thousand Springs section (n = 119), including extract the cumulative (prehistoric and 1983) VS. the Arentson Gulch fault (Fig. S1 [footnote 1] and Text S2 [footnote 2]). Profile To account for uncertainties in our measurements, we conducted multiple locations were manually chosen and drawn on hillshade and slopeshade maps (typically five to seven) VS-measurement iterations for each profile. Each iter- using GIS software and extracted from the DSMs using Quick Terrain Modeler. ation used a different subset of the original ground-elevation points to define The profile lengths are mostly <25 m long for recent and steep 1983 scarps and alternative upper and lower far-field surface projections, thereby standardizing <300 m long for the larger and more eroded, prehistoric compound scarps. For and facilitating multiple geomorphic interpretations, both factors that control some 1983 scarps, short (<10-m-long) profile lengths reflect the limited extent measurement error (e.g., Salisbury et al., 2015). This method is especially of correlative surfaces across the rupture (e.g., Figs. 3 and 5). We found that useful for non-bare-earth DSMs, where geomorphic surfaces adjacent to the randomly generated profiles or strictly imposed sample-distance intervals rupture can be partially obscured by vegetation. We use the VS results from resulted in poorly sited measurements and introduced unnecessarily inflated these iterations to define minimum and maximum VS as well as a subjective error estimates. With these limitations in mind, we subjectively chose profile best-fit preferred VS selected by assessing the linear fits to the geomorphic locations across correlative surfaces with the best geologic preservation and surfaces and the results of the multiple measurement iterations. We assume sparsest vegetation to ensure the highest-quality measurements. that the minimum and maximum VS bounds capture the range of possible For each profile, we measured VS using a Matlab script (Supplemental VS measurements (e.g., similar to Scharer et al., 2014 and Gold et al., 2015). Code S13 and Text S3 [footnote 2]) and the following process. For each The precision of our VS measurements is limited by DSM resolution, sur- 3 Supplemental Code. Matlab code Scarp_VS.m (Code topographic profile, linear approximations of the footwall and hanging-wall face texture, and vegetation height and density. For most of the 1983 rupture, S1). Please visit https://doi.org/10.1130/GES02096 .S3 or access the full-text article on www.gsapubs.org to geomorphic surfaces were projected to the midpoint of the scarp face; VS is the we were able to resolve displacements as small as ~0.2 m. Relatively smooth view the Supplemental Code. difference in elevation between the surfaces, measured at the scarp midpoint ground surfaces and a predominance of shortgrass vegetation allowed us to
GEOSPHERE | Volume 15 | Number 6 DuRoss et al. | Northern Lost River fault zone rupture behavior Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/geosphere/article-pdf/15/6/1869/4876716/1869.pdf 1876 by guest on 27 September 2021 Research Paper
resolve ~0.1 m displacements along the Warm Springs section (northernmost approximate the uncertainty in the moving average, rather than the full range extent of the 1983 rupture). VS values for compound scarps generally exceed of possible VS values. Mean VS values (and min-max values in parentheses) these lower limits. reported below for different ruptures or fault sections are based on the dis- placement curves, rather than the individual observations, which are unequally distributed along the fault trace. Along-Strike Displacement Curves
We constructed along-strike displacement curves using our VS data (Figs. 6 ■■ DISPLACEMENT ALONG THE 1983 BORAH PEAK RUPTURE and 7). We projected all VS data to a simplified fault trace with kilometer tick marks shown on Figure 2. For the Arentson Gulch fault, we also project VS 1983 Warm Springs Rupture measurements to an 8-km-long simplified trace, oriented WNW-ESE (Fig. 2). The mean along-strike displacement curve represents a 0.5 km moving average The Borah Peak earthquake ruptured ~8 km of the Warm Springs section applied to our preferred estimates of VS, linearly interpolated at 50 m intervals. north of the Willow Creek Hills (kilometers 0–8; Fig. 4A). We document rupture These parameters yield displacement curves that strike a balance between both north and south of the Goosebury graben (kilometers 3–5; Fig. 4A), an short-wavelength, hectometer-scale variability and longer-wavelength, kilo- ~2-km-long by ~0.1–0.3-km-wide zone of synthetic and antithetic faulting. Crone meter-scale trends. To define the uncertainty bounds in the curves, we applied et al. (1987) reported only minor 1983 rupture of the northernmost part of the the same linear interpolation and moving average methods to the minimum graben, including 0.03 m of synthetic displacement and 0.05 m of antithetic dis- and maximum VS values from each scarp profile. Thus, our uncertainty ranges placement. Mean VS for the Warm Springs rupture is 0.3 (0.2–0.4) m including the